r/blackpowder • • 25d ago

Everyone talks about Winchester, but the Remington Rolling Block was the rifle that actually conquered the world. Here’s the mechanical reality.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Hollywood has convinced most people that the lever-action Winchester was the undisputed king of the late 19th century. While it certainly won the civilian frontier, the global military reality was entirely different. The true conqueror of the era was the Remington Rolling Block.

When you look at the engineering, it makes perfect sense why over 40 national armies (and countless buffalo hunters) adopted it instead of early repeaters.

The Genius of Simplicity: The action essentially consists of just two massive moving parts—the breechblock and the hammer. There’s no delicate linkage or complex elevator systems to jam in mud, sand, or freezing conditions.

Pressure Handling: While early lever actions were restricted to relatively short, pistol-length cartridges like the .44-40 (due to elevator length and action strength limitations), the rolling block action was practically indestructible. The hammer physically locks the breechblock in place upon firing. This allowed it to easily handle massive military and buffalo cartridges like the .45-70 Govt, 11mm Mauser, and later even early smokeless high-pressure rounds like the 7x57mm.

Global Dominance: By the time Winchester was marketing the 1873, Remington had already armed the military forces of Sweden, Spain, Egypt, Argentina, and Denmark.

I just put together a deep-dive mini-documentary analyzing the history, the mechanical genius of the Geiger-Rider action, and why it became the most widely exported rifle of its time.

If you appreciate the pure mechanics and history of single-shot mastery, check out the full breakdown here:


r/blackpowder • • Nov 16 '23

Please don't get mad at this. I was originally gonna post this on r/Samurai, but I feel like I need to ask here. This is a Nigiri-Teppo, and it gave me this idea of Jetstream Sam's sword from MGR, I need to know if this could work. Could a Nigiri use a piston system?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Jul 03 '23

Bible paper as cartridge paper?

2 Upvotes

Would this work? I don't have any pistols to try it out yet but it seems like a cheap way to have a bunch of paper. Maby the cci magnums would set it off.


r/blackpowder • • Oct 19 '26

Some people think you can't use a flintlock in the rain. skill issue or research?

0 Upvotes

I don't know why it's so hard for people to do research on any given platform like, how hard is it to put bore butter around the hammer and seal it from the elements and keep it under your armpit


r/blackpowder • • Feb 15 '25

Can you Use Smokeless Powder In A Cap And Ball Revolver? Actually tested

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Apr 07 '25

This may be the wrong thread to ask. But does anyone know about gun-cotton? And if it can possibly work in metallic cartridges?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Nov 28 '22

Elon's one of us apparently

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Sep 17 '26

The most important gun of the early frontier wasn't a Winchester or a Colt. It was a cheap smoothbore with a brass dragon on it.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

When we picture the firearms that "won the West," we immediately think of the Colt Peacemaker or the Winchester lever-action. But decades before those existed, during the fur trade era of the 1800s, the real undisputed king of the frontier was the Northwest Trade Gun (often called the Trade Musket).

It wasn't fancy, it wasn't rifled, and it was incredibly cheap to make. But it was exactly what the frontier demanded.

Why did Native American tribes and frontiersmen prefer this crude smoothbore over accurate rifles?

Ultimate Versatility: Survival on the frontier meant hunting whatever was available. Because it was a smoothbore (usually around .58 to .62 caliber), you could load it with a single heavy round ball to take down a buffalo or an elk, or load it with birdshot to hunt ducks and small game. A rifled barrel couldn't do that.

The "Currency" of the West: Companies like the Hudson's Bay Company traded these by the thousands. The legendary pricing standard was often based on a stack of beaver pelts equal to the height of the gun.

The Dragon Sideplate: The most iconic feature of the Trade Gun was the brass serpent/dragon sideplate. It became such a recognized brand of quality and authenticity that many Native American tribes would outright refuse to trade for a musket if it didn't have the dragon on the side.

I run a channel dedicated entirely to 19th-century firearms and Western history, and I just put together a documentary breaking down the history, mechanics, and impact of the Northwest Trade Gun.

(Transparency note: I am a solo creator from Spain doing all the historical research, editing, and fact-checking myself. I use an AI voice tool to translate my original Spanish scripts into English so I can share this history with you guys. No AI-generated historical fluff, just real history and a translated voice).


r/blackpowder • • Apr 04 '26

Am I crazy?

1 Upvotes

I just saw the 1858 New Model Army and I live in an old church. This place has 40ft ceilings and is about 70 feet long. I have wanted a black powder revolver since I was 10 and looking through the yearly Cabelas hardcover. I have seen the cowboy fast draw competitions and it got me thinking. Is it possible to use less powder and shoot this thing inside if I set up a range? I have 8 windows I can open for ventilation and I can weld a backstop up, angled of course. Any thoughts on how to do this would be apporeciated as I know nothing about it. I guess my tax returns are burning a hole in my pocket.


r/blackpowder • • May 10 '24

Does this look good?

Post image
4 Upvotes

45-70 case filled with goex 2ffg

Powder weighed 70 grains in weight on my scale and about 80 grains in my volume measure


r/blackpowder • • Nov 10 '24

"Drone" shot loads for bp pistols?

4 Upvotes

Been playing with the idea of anti-drone loads for my bp navy revolver.

It's basically double the amount of pellets than a snake shot load.

I've got a jar of lead bird shot, and a bottle of copper BBs to try out. Thinking the BBs might be too rough on the barrel though?

Anyone with experience?

EDIT: This is only for theoretical SHTF, civil war, govt collapse type of situation


r/blackpowder • • Apr 17 '23

I just bought a 1861 rifle and sling and bayonet with scabord for 118$ I can't believe it. Brand new. Wow. I'm super excited

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Nov 13 '25

Quick question

0 Upvotes

Can you substitute smokeless powder for FF black powder, if so what would 3-4 grains of FF convert to in smokeless. If it doesn't, that's OK, just checking


r/blackpowder • • Jan 26 '23

Big US Black Powder Cartridges

3 Upvotes

I get that the buffalo were all dead by the time smokeless powder became mainstream in the US. I also understand aside from bears we really have no "heavy" dangerous game.

But why do we not load the old 3-1/4" black powder rounds up with smokeless powder and fast twist barrels so they can stabilize heavy bullets at higher velocities? Wouldn't that be sweet!? The 38, 40, 45, and 50 calibres all came in long case versions!

I'm a true Nitro Express devotee and what's amazing about these rounds is 120 years later a .458 diameter 480 grain solid @ 2150 FPS will still kill anything that walks the planet. Despite the wailing and gnashing of teeth you hear from the 45-70 crowd .458 diameter 500 grain lead @ 1400 FPS will NOT kill "everything" that walks, though it will kill much, and that is not to say that it's not a useful load. Still just find it sad the Brits got to have all the fun hotrodding their giant cartridges.


r/blackpowder • • Feb 23 '16

Can I buy Black Powder? (California)

1 Upvotes

Hello, I live in California, I have no criminal record whatsoever, I am 22 yrs old and I would like to buy a Black Powdered weapon for self defence. I was wondering what the limitations if any are, can I legally own a Black Powder weapon?


r/blackpowder • • Oct 12 '22

Samsung 12 VS 1858 Remington New Model Army Ballistics Test

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Jan 25 '21

Are sub 40 caliber rifles perceived as less than manly?

0 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Dec 04 '24

Is it necessary to pour powder into the pan with every shot?

0 Upvotes

I belived for long time flintlock advantage to cap lock is that you can shot few times vs add new cap every shot, but every shot gave more chance on failure, now I don't know anymore if it worked that way.


r/blackpowder • • Jun 20 '21

20 Gauge smoothbore pistol recommendations for 1750s and earlier

1 Upvotes

As per title, I am looking for some recommendations, mainly for French and Indian War but for the American Revolution as well


r/blackpowder • • Feb 16 '23

How could someone tap this and thread a breech plug?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Apr 06 '21

Does anyone have experience with getting black powder from Estes rocket motors?

1 Upvotes

Could I cut some of them open (probably the D class large size ones) and crush up the solid black part which is made of black powder and use that powder in a shotgun shell? All of my local stores are out of bp and I don’t have a ball mill.


r/blackpowder • • Jan 31 '23

I designed this so a colt open top can have a top strap. Its inspiration is from the merwin Hulbert. It's pretty rough, but I like to hear your thoughts on it. (Would this work?)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Nov 02 '20

Got this kydex style holster at walmart for 9.97- they're clearing out all gun stuff for cheap in Dallas Area. Fits like a glove in case anybody needs or is looking.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/blackpowder • • Jul 09 '26

Has anyone here made a candy cannon?

0 Upvotes

I got permission to do a candy cannon at a local even in a couple weeks. Now I just need one. I'm looking for any tips or advice on how to make one and what materials I could use. Would an empty oxygen tank be safe? (The slimmer kind for medical O²) Where else could I find good barrel material? I friend of mine does have a metal lathe and mill we can use.


r/blackpowder • • Jan 29 '26

As a cap and ball revolver noob, I think I may have discovered the main reason why .44 caliber smoke wagons are more popular than the .36 caliber variety

0 Upvotes

Three words: cartridge conversion kits

.45 Colt barrel diameters and .44 cap and ball revolver barrel diameters are almost identical, making cartridge conversions of .44 cap and ball revolvers a relatively simple, easy and worthwhile exercise.

On the other hand, doing a cartridge conversion on a .36 caliber cap and ball revolver while retaining good accuracy and velocity can be a more involved an expensive process. You can either sleeve the barrel, use hollow based bullets kind of like how undersized minie bullets expand to catch rifling or using a conversion cylinder that uses heel based bullets.

The comments of the r/blackpowder post below outlines what I just discussed here, so I can give credit where credit is due.

https://www.reddit.com/r/blackpowder/comments/1hwuej1/conversion_pistol/

Also, here's a poll from this very sub 3 years ago where 48 people said they prefer .36 caliber cap and ball guns while 147 people in the same poll prefer .44 caliber cap and ball guns.

https://www.reddit.com/r/blackpowder/comments/14le395/which_do_you_prefer_a_36_or_44_caliber_revolver/