r/ayearofproust • u/nathan-xu • Jun 23 '22
Another reading plan of ISOLT
Let me be straight, I am indiffenrent to homosexuality and I feel really disappointed when I found almost all males in the novel turn out to be gays from volume 5. To me the narrator's love of Albertine is unnatural and not inspiring or interesting.
As per Proust's original plan before WWI, ISOLT will have 3 volumes. All of additions are due to his characteristic interest on homosexuality (I share the disappointment with many of his critic comtemparies as well).
I always ruminate on the possibility of reading the original novel deprived of those additions. Needless to say, ISOLT would be much slimmer (still bigger than War and Peace, but not too much) and I can dig deeper with more savor, if not only because I can read much less.
So for such "simplified reading plan", we can skip both volume 5 and 6. The last volume would be a little bit difficult to understand but not too much (we can skip the male brothel section as well). For one thing, Albertine was seldom mentioned at all for Time Regained was finished before WWI and Proust only made some nessary changes to align with new additions.
I know, there are so many gems here and there in the skipped two volumes, but everything boils down to some tradeoff. Actually I am following this plan during my second reading now.