Edit in an hour, and not even for a good reason. If you wanted to discuss, this was your opportunity. But we seem to have too mnay users who want to be nasty for the sake of it. So comments are locked. This is why we can't have nice things.
Hello, we need to talk about why using the term "girl inches" is inappropriate, incorrect, and detrimental thus not allowed. This is long because I am being thorough in my reasoning.
The TL;DR is don't say girl inches, it's wrong with multiple factors, and you will be banned if you do.
A few years ago, a man who got upset about a ban went and made a post about this sub filled with lies that lead to harassment of the mod team and users here. It was so bad admins stepped in and some of us dealt with threats of doxxing and years long harassment. Recently, another user was upset and made a post, where he gave a very one side veiw as an attempt to bash modding because he did not understand, nor did he want to understand, what the issue is. I am hoping this post clears up the issue and gets ahead of any possible harassment or misunderstanding of what happened. We will continue to do this in reaction towards users who do make dishonest posts about us. And for the record, modmails cannot be deleted. We have reciepts because even we can't delete them.
It was brought to my attention that I am wrong for my reasoning and that I need to find a dictionary (valid to a certain extent, I am dyslexic and my spelling is rough at times). So, in the spirit of that, these results were determined using the dictionary and various psychology/medical studies. My paraphrasing will be similar to AI overviews from google because sometimes it does a decent job. And since the legitimacy of google was also questioned, I'm going to add that google is a search tool, not an encyclopedia. That's a pretty common way to find information these days and pretty much the only way my students get any of their papers done. Genuinely can't believe I have to say that but like I said, someone didn't seem to get that I used it. I do go the extra mile to look at the sources it uses as well, as AI is frequently wrong, pulls from invalid sources, and I'm a double checker.
I went to school for psychology. Reading studies and understanding abstracts was something that was taught in literally every single class. Because misunderstanding results can have nasty consequences, and ethical responsibility matters greatly. Please, if you can find anything valid/legitimate that contradicts me, I'll happily incorporate that or even change the ruling. I won't cite everything I find to back me up because one, there is a lot/not enough, two some of it seems too duh and I don't want to be condescending and three, I'm not gonna cite something that asks you guys for money. Also Reddit doesn't allow all links for some reason.
For starters, girls are children. It's the literally definition of the word Girl. They are female children under the age of 18. It's also sexist, to apply the term to women, heavily frowned upon and as bad as an offense that gets your fired in professional settings, thus a form of bigotry. I find it repulsive that women are infantilized and demeaned through that term, and this sub will not contribute to the problem we have with sexualizing children, especially the female ones, in our society. I have fostered children who were trafficked by their own parents. I have witnessed the real life consequences of what some of you have had the privilege not to even realize exists and know why being rigid about this matters. There are so many sources to cite here but I'm not bothering to do that, because seriously, the E Files have brought many of these resources to light and the information is readily available. Go look it up. We are not helping to normalize that children can determine dick size. If you attempt to normalize the sexualization of children on this sub, the ban will be without warning, permanent, heavily documented, and we will report you to the admins of reddit.
The user who is upset that I questioned his definition of girl said girl is an acceptable colloquialism for women in some contexts, which some dictionaries do say and I will acknowledge that it used that way. I use it myself, but I also use the term boys with grown men in similar situations. Please note, this sub and subject is not one of those contexts. There are plenty of contexts that I can think of when the N word is acceptable. Hell, I call my women friends my B words sometimes as a form of affection. Once had a Scotsman call me the C word and it had me blushing and giggling I was so flattered. We still aren't allowing those words here.
Also, we are talking about someone's ability to determine dick size, and he wants to defend using the term for a child as appropriate for the context. Is no one else disturbed by that? Because disturbing is the only word I will use. While I am sure that will ruffle some feathers, I'll add this. Every women I have spoken to about this said they would feel put off to repulsed by men who use this terminology and/or defend this. Many of you want to know how to interact with women when you come into in my DMs. Probably a good idea to avoid a term/concept that gives them the creeps. And I consider it dense to assume that it's okay here because it *can* be elsewhere. It's not a reasonable justification or I would never have gotten in trouble for bringing a goat to my high school in my backpack.
There are no studies that prove "girl inches" are real, at all. In fact, one study that comes through this sub proves the opposite. You know it, the study where women guess cylinder size and then say which size feels best. Women are just as capable, possibly even better at it. One issue is there aren't actually enough studies done on women on most subjects, and many studies are riddled with so much bias that they can't be taken seriously (bias is a huge problem for men too by the way, including when the bias seems to favor them). Even the study I mentioned, it shows women can guess accurately, but it's a bad study for determining sexually pleasure of dick size, as multiple participants admitted to having no sexual experience or only one partner ever. It's quite foolish to me to draw results from experiences that have literally never been had just because they know how big a cylinder is. It's like coming to the conclusion that because I prefer using a fork to eat I would rather have a salad than sushi, after I admit I have never eaten a vegetable. But back to the point, studies that do compare the abilities of men and women to guess size in a variety of contexts find that gender is typically irrelevant, only jobs where that knowledge is helpful really make a difference, but some studies say that women show more accuracy in real world scenarios, while men were favored in the abstract.
Anecdotally, I knit and crochet as a form of income, it's one thing I teach as well. Knowing how big something is matters, especially in pattern writing. Me and others in this business stay in this business because of skills we develop to further our expertise. Looking at something, I can guess all dimensions with accuracy and it streamlines my ability to write patterns for any body size or shape. Understanding geometry is a big help in the fiber arts world. My father is easily as good as me, because he does carpentry/construction, a kind of job were again, being able to determine dimensions becomes second nature. My mother, who bakes, is stupid good at guessing weights of various ingredients, literally never measures anything and always gets the amounts right, it's genuine magic to me. But my point is, people's ability to judge size isn't innately attached to their gender and anyone can learn the skill should they want or need to.
I have had opportunities to guess a size after guys have asked me. I have never once had a guy guess his own size more accurately that me. I've even called out the liars. This provide an example that even dick owners aren't always the most accurate and that personal experience cannot be applied to all. Also, gonna say it, a lot of men I talk to during my dating years didn't know or care what size they are. Especially as they got older or the less invested they were in the concept of masculinity funny enough. Many of them admit they didn't guess their own size right till they measured. Now be honest, how accurately did you guess your own size when you first questioned it?
It helps many men feel better by placing the blame on someone else. But when that happens, it builds fear and hate towards ehat has been labeled. This is one of the most documented phenomena. It's why bacon sales decreased when swine flu broke out (for those who remember that, back in 2009), even though there was no evidence to support you'd get it from a pig. Everyone I know who got it worked in schools. The amount of men who come into my DMs terrified a women is gonna instantly go after them for being small or average, hell even those with big dicks DM similar things, it's too many. There is a male loneliness epidemic, men are depressed and suicidal, and too take out their anger with violence against women for what is a man created problem, and I do not think it's responsible to create more reasons for a divide, especially when it's having real life detrimental effects on people. So many of you are so young and there is no physical reason for you to think your dick is not enough. Truly, I hate that you guys experience that. I may not have a dick but I have sons. I don't ever want them to experience what so many of you have. And so many of you want a woman who cares yet when I say I do I'm called a liar or told I'm virtue signaling. It's so bad that you can't believe me. And I care. A lot. Why is it so impossible to think I can care? This may seem unbelievable but confronting why placing blame on women is a problem is gonna help men too. Remember when I said bias that seems to favor men may not help them? This is what I mean. It's all the women's fault when we label it as a gender issue, but its the guys who deal with the consequences of it and it's not going to be stopped by placing blame on women and laughing about it like they're dumber when no they are not. Do you think they'll want to be with anyone who does that to them either? You'd be amazed how changing one word can change the attitude towards how to handle something.
The other thing I'm gonna say that may not be popular, some women lie. Sometimes it's knowingly, sometimes not, and sometimes it's to be malicious intentionally. Here are some reasons they respond as they do.
A, women don't care so they say a number. Remember when I said it isn't attached to gender and people being bad at it comes down to them not bothering to learn the skill? That's what is happening. They don't learn because they don't care. Seriously, how many of you have heard "I don't know, 6 if you make me answer." Because I have seen something like that written, a lot. They give an answer to shut you up because you badgered them. I've talked about the "girl inches" concept with women. Several went "seriously? They have nothing better to do than determine how women see their dick size?" The phrases "that's really weird/men are weird" comes up a lot. The majority of women agreed though, men who think this are probably lying about their size to others, or need therapy. Several of them have said they are gonna ask their male partners if they think this because they want to know if they're that foolish/think so little of women. It's also mentioned a lot that men who focus this much on their dick are probably bad at sex. That's not a secret, you can find that mindset in many spaces women occupy. I don't know if I would apply it to everyone but in my experience, I don't think it's untrue and I would love to see a proper study done on it. But to my point, I truly don't think you guys get how off putting thinking things like this is.
B, we have learned that if we say the wrong number that men could become angry or upset, to the point of physical aggression (this has happened to me personally and other women have told me the same). Lying can literally be the only way to stay safe. Not all men, blah blah blah, but the fact is the majority of women have dealt with one or more men like this. Be honest, if your choices were Honesty or Saftey, which one would you pick? Hell women are encouraged to lie to maintain safety, and you be amazed how much that becomes second nature even when men don't think it should apply. Especially if they person asking is someone who is bigger and stronger.
C, it is viewed as an opportunity to dirty talk. I had an ex who was super into worship during sex. He wanted me to tell him he had the greatest dick ever and no man has ever satisfy me as well. That he ruined me for all men. He did not have a big dick and he knew it. He also liked doing it back, and told me I was the greatest sex, best [whatever body part he was focused on] and such things. No women would ever be able to make him cum like that. He still broke things off when he wanted to find a GF and I didn't want anything serious. Sure, it made the sex hotter but I didn't attach myself to it quite so seriously because it was hot play. I don't think I'm gonna be everyones best sex for so many reasons. A lot of women say "just say it's huge, he'll love it, doesn't matter if it's real or not." Because they have had experiences with those guys who responded enthusiastically to that kind of talk. You're literally shaming them for attempting to be sexy with you. You think if they knew that, they would want to do it again?
And lastly, they say what they think the guy wants to hear because isn't that really what it's about? Plus when a women does say a number too small, men can look demoralized. Y'all read posts here, you know this is irrefutably true. So guessing high is better for their ego. I guarantee they would not do that if they knew you were docking their intelligence with the kind of judgment some of you come at this with. They don't care either way, so just say what makes the guy happy. Anytime a guy asks me if that's the case, I say yes, it's a very real thing to consider because women absolutely do that, even some of the ones who say that don't. And I have heard many men admit to doing this themselves with their women partners on other subjects. I don't like it at all but it's normal to lie for someone elses benefit.
We also need to talk bias when coming to these conclusions. Confirmation bias is a massive problem with people and researchers. Research ethics and scrutinizing verbage and materials used are taken so seriously because of how easy it is to manipulate responses out of people. The study I mentioned where women guess size based on the cylinders, that study noted that the cylinders were made to be smooth and blue, because they knew color and texture would be influenced by bias and have too great an effect on outcome. Fun fact, blue is used a lot because it's a color that creates the least emotional response and cannot be attached to racism. Though that information may have changed since I learned it.
Also, the bias of the researchers when determining results. This is one reason double-blind studies are more accurate, and also why self reporting surveys can be the most inaccurate. So when guys are like "my experience says it real." Question that. I know that my experience doesn't match everyone elses, can you acknowledge the same? Because many people believe things that are blatantly not true. For example, in a recent study, people reported that women talk way more than men. Yet when it was recorded for words used and duration of speaking time, and put into statistics, it was found men out talk women. By a lot. Context could change outcomes a little, but in general, in mixed company, the majority of people believed it was women but the unbias collection of information turned out to prove them wrong.
In this case with confirmation bias, y'all are only asking women about your dicks. Seriously, how often have any of you asked a man that question? Like seriously, no fucking shit you have experience women get it wrong all the time compared to men, YOU'RE ONLY ENGAGING WITH WOMEN. I asked guys this all the time in DMs. Do you ever ask men how big something is? Remember my carpenter dad? He used to tease co workers about how bad they were with guessing size. I remember hearing him ask men "did you measure with your dick or the tape? Because that's not as big as you think." I have even brought this up before because I spent years working with him cackling about that. It's why I've always called them dick inches. He said most guys learned to get good at estimation in a few months. I just gave you guys a few good reasons why women would guess the way they do, but many of you just came to the conclusion on your own prior to it that women are stupid or bad at it. You can't defend that kind of bias as good faith or well natured, and I see very few men acknowledge it exists.
It's also important to note who is being studied, because bias is there as well. Why would a women who does not give a shit about dick size participate in a study about dick size? They don't, and it's one of the biggest issues when studying it. Only women who do care will, and that skews results. And even then most won't go out of their way to do it. I'll admit, most studies I participated in I only did because I couldn't graduate with my psych degree without participating in a set amount, and I only picked the ones that I thought were interesting, were available for enrollment, were available at a time I could manage, and didn't require a lot of my time. Paying people to participate helps get better results, but funding is an issue and even more so when it's about women. There is mountains of proof of how little women are studied in comparison to men, which is why it can be hard to determine facts and mis/disinformation on sexism or women, which is also why people go with "they say" facts that are just biased and frequently blatantly wrong. Yet you want to apply what we learn from them to women who have literally never had that thought cross their minds? This is also something that is warned about in studies. Do NOT apply what is learned in studies to everyone, especially when most studies have incredibly small sample sizes, and are not even repeated. Do you know how many studies are shown to be wrong once they are repeated? Also, where in the globe were they done? What age? What experience? How much education do they have on the subject? Culture, age, experience and education have a massive effect on bias and outcomes. Bias is in everything. If you can't question your own, and regularly, you cannot expect to be expected to be taken seriously by someone who is informed enough to. And to the user who said he wanted an opinion based discussion on this and my removing it was unfair to him, sorry, your opinion are not equal when they can be proven wrong by facts. And that's a healthy way to be. That's how misinformation is dealt with. This is how we educate and improve ourselves.
And finally, we have to acknowledge men lie. You wanna compare girl inches to boy inches? The majority of men have not told me the accurate size they have. I have said many times on this sub and others that when I was on tinder, most men claimed to be 8 inches, not one could prove it, and I insisted they did. And the ones who guessed weren't much better. The only men who have are honest are the ones who come into my DMs and have questions about themselves. They aren't there to seduce me, just get reassurance they aren't freaks. And many of them admitted to being afraid to measure themselves because they didn't "want to know." To be clear, they knew they couldn't tell just by looking at what was literally attached to them the whole time.
I would even put forward the hypothesis that men lie way more than women guess wrong. Sometimes they assume size wrong, sometimes it's blatant. In self reporting subs, on reddit, the average dick size went down by over an inch when moderators required proof. Funny how few men seemed to catch how many men were lying, or am I the only one who seems to have noticed that? Self reporting studies almost always show a larger size than others, though I don't dismiss the fact that some of that has to do with it being hard to get hard in front of researchers (this is me giving a good example of checking bias to try to arrive at a more accurately result).
Why should you care if the blame needs to come off just being a women thing? Men set a standard of what response they want to hear based off information present. Example, they show someone their dick, say it's 7 inches when it's only 5. Women believe them and go with it. Continue to not only be misinformed, but apply that to others. Other men who are probably the same size will hear that she was with a 7 incher and enjoyed it, and now will feel insecure they won't be as good even though they are probably the same size. Or they will also lie, and contribute to further misinformation. Frankly, it doesn't make sense to me that men get more upset that women lack a skill they don't care to have then men lying. They even make excuses why men lying is okay, or use the mental gymnastics to say they have to lie because women are dumb. Don't tell me this doesn't happen, I have lost track of how much I have seen this. Been modding here for a long time and gotten thousands of DMs.
Labeling it "girl inches" is a problem because it places blame on women but will not address the role men have played in this. This hurts you guys way more even if it makes you feel better temporarily to blame women. Very few women, an amount I'm not even sure is worth mentioning, have any real stakes in this concept, so why would they care if they're right? Women can always find a guy who doesn't care if they don't want to deal with it. And why do you expect them to fix what men most likely started anyway? You seriously expect women to argue with all the men who lie about this when they don't even care to begin with? And as I have stated, most of us don't want to deal with the emotional response from a man anyway.
How many of you go around telling men they are wrong about women's anatomy? Do you call out women for being wrong about their own bodies too? And how many of you would defend why you wouldn't, but the women are gonna call out men for this for you now? Also, as someone who does call out men for being wrong about their own anatomy at times, rarely does it work. Literally almost never. Hell I can guess a guys size more accurately than him and he still won't believe it or admit I'm right. Because I don't have a dick, I am considered less of an authority on them, despite my education and experience. Which I find funny because women attracted to men see and feel more dicks in person than straight guys yet that experience gets dismissed a lot because anatomy. Hell I'm told all the time that I don't belong here because I don't have a dick, even though I moderate content regarding female anatomy and women. It doesn't matter if I know what I'm talking about, it won't be well received.
I would like to thank the user for the opportunity for me to create this post. I hope others found it educational and engaging. And I want to go on the record and say that I and the other mods of this sub are NOT okay with anyone seeking out the user and bothering him. He had his reasons for his reaction, whatever they are, and while he may not have considered what he did to be a problem for us and this sub, there is no need to interact with him in a way that makes his life harder or shows anything less than being decent and respectful. If I find out you have harassed him, you will be permanently banned and reported to the admins. DO NOT HARASS ANYONE, capiche?
Sorry for the novel, but I like to be thorough. I know a lot of my DMs also want me to explain further as well. Some things cannot be simplified to be explained well. And now you can't say you weren't warned that it's problem.