r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

What do academic philosophers think of Palantir co-founder Alex Karp's doctoral dissertation?

72 Upvotes

The pdf is here - https://d-nb.info/966060652/34

I was reading Karp's wiki page and found that he did his PhD under Jurgen Habermas in the University of Goethe in Germany. Seemed quite surprising, considering Palantir's work in mass surveillance, the military industrial complex and genocide, and Jurgen Habermas's work in deliberative democracy.

Any ideas?


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

How much general philosophy knowledge is a PhD student expected to know?

70 Upvotes

Hi all. I'm a fourth year PhD student, and lately I've started to get a creeping sense of impostor syndrome. My research is a relatively niche intersection of philosophy of mind, cognitive science, and disability studies. Within that area I'm relatively confident (although my knowledge is still incomplete), but outside it I often feel like a complete fraud.

I've never read most of the canon classics. I don't have opinions on the major philosophers. I don't have defensible positions on the big debates. And I don't have more than a superficial grasp on non-Western traditions. I know that philosophy is vast and it's literally impossible to be well-read in everything, but at this stage I imagined that I'd be more of a generalist than I am.

How much general knowledge is actually expected of someone at my stage of study? Is the "well-rounded philosopher who has read everything" possible, or is it just a myth? How is one supposed to balance building breadth of philosophical knowledge without neglecting my thesis and all the other time-consuming activities like teaching and marking and other life stuff that we all have to manage?

Thanks in advance for any replies and/or suggestions!


r/askphilosophy • • 12h ago

How can I explain to people that have little knowledge of philosophy that it isn’t just one big debate where everyone’s opinion holds the same value?

38 Upvotes

Hi, I have been studying philosophy for a bit more than 5 years now, and am currently specializing in philosophy of logic. My friends have started taking interest in philosophy and enjoying talking about it with me.
Those talks often run into problems and misunderstandings though. Basically, their vision of philosophy is some kind of big debate where everyone can say what they think and where each one’s opinion would have the same weight.
The two main problems that come out this are the following:
- lack of conceptual definition, they often speak about slightly different things
- a lot of logical flaws
I have tried to point those out and explain how important it is for a good conversation and to reach a common understanding or agreement, but apparently end up coming off as pretentious or nitpicky to them.
Also sometimes as I try taking examples to show a logical flaw, they will get stuck on the example instead of looking at the structure, which makes them even more confused.
I believe my way of explaining is not the best, hence this post.
How would you do it if you were in my position?


r/askphilosophy • • 11h ago

Why was Kurt Gödel a theist?

32 Upvotes

https://firstthings.com/the-god-of-the-mathematicians/

According to the attached article, Kurt Gödel - the famed 20th century logician - believed in God. While he presumably had a number of reasons for this, the article mentions one that interests me: “At twenty-five he ruined the positivist hope of making mathematics into a self-contained formal system with his incompleteness theorems, implying, as he noted, that machines never will be able to think, and computer algorithms never will replace intuition. To Gödel this implies that we cannot give a credible account of reality without God.” Why do you think Gödel’s understanding of the human intellect led him to believe in God?

Thanks


r/askphilosophy • • 58m ago

Are we losing touch with reality by means of analogy?

4 Upvotes

I don't mean to sound conspiratorial with the title, this process is something that for one reason or another I've been thinking about for the past few weeks. I think it may be anticipated by Baudrillard in Simulcra and Simulation and perhaps elsewhere, but I don't have the time to read at the moment.

To be precise, I'm talking about how in everyday talk we often refer to a) images rather than concrete events, b) we use abstract instead of instantiable verbs, c) we use terms that have become outdated to the point that they actually don't make sense to be used contemporarily.

In the first case I have in mind how certain professionals, or TV shows, or students, will liken their work (say, a financial merger or a court case), or studies, or subject matter, to things like battles. I think of this especially whenever I see business gurus suggesting people read up on Napoleon or Sun-Tzu's The Art of War.

In the second case, again the first thing that comes to mind is the financial world, when I think of how the managerial class especially (I think consulting is the most egregious and obvious case) uses very abstract, opaque wording to describe what they do, words and phrases like problem-solving, oversee, and coordinate. I understand that different communities will form different ways of speaking, but there seems to be a consistent pattern of vagueness among corporate lingo, and problably elsewhere, too.

The third case is I think related to this phenomenon but is more common. I'm talking here mostly about idioms, and am mostly following on from Orwell's Politics and the English Language. He notes how phrases like "the hammer and the anvil" are commonly used but without very much understanding, pointing out specifically how many people think it would be better to be the hammer than the anvil, but then noting that it's the hammer that eventually breaks.

I also think of certain titles which at one point (take the Lord Chamberlain in the United Kingdom) had a definite, concrete meaning, which have since retained the title but the original image which is described has since been lost to time, and now requires explicit study (say, in history) to encounter the original meaning. Again, understanding the linguistics of it, that certain words will hitchhike along time without their referents/meanings staying attached, I'm nevertheless curious whether this position of being in a world full of words and phrases with unreasonably attached (as in the first case) images/analogies, or otherwise in a world where we have those words and phrases but no longer understand the things which they initially denoted, has any effect on how we understand our world.


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

How can you study philosophy without treating every claim as fact?

13 Upvotes

I'm totally new to philosophy and I've always heard about Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle being these brilliant, legendary thinkers. After hearing all that and then actually reading their stuff, my brain just defaults to accepting whatever they say and nodding along, since they're supposedly so amazing at it. I get the feeling I'm losing out on a lot by reading this way and it feels off, but I can't stop myself. For instance, I read that Socrates believed democracy doesn't function well unless the voters are educated and wise. Then he laid out his reasoning and I immediately agreed without hesitating, because it just seemed so logical. Is this what the power of rhetoric is?


r/askphilosophy • • 2h ago

Help me with a lesson plan

4 Upvotes

Ive started a philosophy club and would love help with plans for what to talk about, or for activities/discussions. I don't know that much about philosophy and this club is definitely less trying to teach philosophy and more of all of us working together to learn more about philosophy. I'm trying to do some basic introduction so members feel confident to be able to do some leading. So far I have abridged a crash course video into our timeframe and have introduced what philosophy is and what the branches of philosophy are. What should I go into next?


r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

Are there good arguments for reincarnation?

8 Upvotes

I find myself deeply desiring reincarnation to be a thing despite being undecided on the existence of the supernatural.

I prefer secular aegiments but it is fine if the arguments come from a religious tradition as long as they can be applied outside of it (to be clear, its also fine if it depends on the religions metaphysics as long as it doesn't require you to be a total believer of it for it to make sense)

Edit: "aegiments" Aegis ments? Lmao


r/askphilosophy • • 2h ago

How to research the logical standing of the normative ethical frameworks?

3 Upvotes

I can't seem to figure out how to look into how logically sound the normative ethical frameworks are, I don't know if this is something that may have an IEP or SEP page that I'm missing, open ed resources, or if I actually have to dive into this at the college or grad level.

I'm in undergrad right now and I would normally just ask my ethics professor, but was kind enough to answer a ton of questions over email that I've had after finishing the course last semester, so I want to give him a cooldown before I ask anything more, if anything.


r/askphilosophy • • 6h ago

Feminist perspectives were important in biology, but what about physics?

5 Upvotes

In her 1994 paper "Gender and the Biological Sciences", Kathleen Okruhlik argues that diversity is important in the biological sciences because it improves the variety of extant hypotheses that can be tested in the first place.

Have any feminists argued something similar for other sciences like physics and chemistry?


r/askphilosophy • • 5h ago

I’m lookin for a decent copy of Marcus Aurelius’s Meditations if anyone could point me in the right direction. All the ones on Amazon seem bunk.

3 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 13h ago

Is procreation morally permissible if one believes their child could suffer eternally in hell?

11 Upvotes

I'm interested in the ethics of procreation under religious beliefs involving eternal punishment, particularly in Abrahamic theology.

Consider a parent who believes that having children creates a nonzero probability that those children will eventually experience eternal suffering.

Three problems seem to arise:

  1. Moral risk: Even if the probability of damnation is small, can exposing someone to the possibility of infinite suffering be morally justified, particularly when the child cannot consent to being created?

  2. Predestination: If God already determines who will ultimately be saved or damned, how does this affect the justice of creating someone whose ultimate fate is already fixed? Does the problem shift from parental responsibility to divine justice?

  3. Divine command: Suppose procreation is understood as a religious duty. Why should fulfilling that duty override the potential moral cost imposed on one's children? Could accepting a lesser moral or religious failing (remaining childless) be preferable to exposing another person to eternal punishment?

I recognize that different theological traditions interpret hell, predestination, free will, and divine commands differently.

Are there established philosophical arguments addressing this problem, particularly in the literature on procreative ethics, the problem of evil, or religious ethics?


r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

A dream feels real until you wake up. An old Indian idea asks what makes you so sure this world is different from the dream

2 Upvotes

A week ago I dreamed I was attached by a bear while camping and it felt completely real. Then I woke up and wondered why I am so sure this life is not the same kind of dream.

I do not mean that in a mystical way. I mean the feeling. In the dream I was panicking, trying to fight and then run, convinced i would die. Then I woke up, and in about three seconds it was gone. None of it had ever happened, but while I was in it, I would have sworn it was real.

Coincidently, I watched a short reel on this last night and it has stayed with me since. It starts with that simple thing we all know. In a dream, everything feels solid. The people, the fear, the joy. Then you wake up and none of it was what you thought it was.

The reel takes that feeling and turns it around on waking life. It quotes Shankaracharya, an ancient Indian philosopher, saying The absolute consciousness(Brahman) is real and the world is appearance, and the Buddha saying to look upon the world as a bubble, as a mirage. The word it uses for that appearance is mithya, and the point it makes is that mithya does not mean false. It means its reality is borrowed from something else.

The image that landed for me was the pot and the clay, and the ring and the gold. You see the pot, the wave, the ring. But you miss what they are made of. The forms change. The names change. The reality beneath them was never separate.

The basic point was simple. We keep chasing the shapes of things, the job, the relationship, the money, the version of ourselves we want to be, and we miss what they are made of. The shapes keep changing. But our awareness, the thing underneath them does not.

I am not sure I agree with all of it, but I keep coming back to the question it leaves you with. If a dream can feel this real while it lasts, how do you know this one is different?

The IG reel that got me thinking about it is here:
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfxOtj1vuWk/

Has anything ever felt completely solid and permanent to you, and then just changed, and you realised you were holding on to the shape and not the thing itself?


r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

What are the philosophical implications of artificial intelligence for intellectual autonomy, meaningful work, and human flourishing? (Schoolwork)

2 Upvotes

In my philosophy class, we are writing a paper on AI usage and how it can help/hinder the search for the meaning of life.

  1. Artificial intelligence can reduce cognitive effort by helping people organize information, solve problems, and complete routine intellectual tasks. However, at what point might delegating these tasks undermine intellectual autonomy? Are there established philosophical arguments that distinguish between using external tools to enhance human reasoning and becoming intellectually dependent on them?

Connecting to: Epistemology, intellectual autonomy, critical thinking, and philosophy of technology.

2. Several philosophical traditions associate meaningful activity, purposeful work, and personal fulfillment with living a good life. However, if technological advancements substantially reduced the necessity of human labor, would this necessarily diminish human flourishing? How have philosophers distinguished between the intrinsic value of work and the meaning individuals create through activities outside their occupations?

Connecting to: Aristotle's concepts of eudaimonia, Marx's philosophy of labor, existentialism, and ethics and human flourishing.

3. Technological advancements are frequently evaluated through their efficiency, convenience, and economic benefits. However, these measurements do not necessarily establish whether technology improves human well-being in a broader philosophical sense. What ethical frameworks or philosophical principles can be used to evaluate whether artificial intelligence contributes to human flourishing while preserving individual autonomy, intellectual development, and meaningful human relationships?

Connecting to: Virtue ethics, consequentialism, and human flourishing.


r/askphilosophy • • 9h ago

Does Tenoni's ITT imply someone born deaf, numb and blind is less conscious?

4 Upvotes

If ITT is about 'integrating information', and you have no information to integrate, does that give you a lower Phi?

If you were born with no senses would you not be conscious?

Or are sharks extra conscious because they can sense electromagnetism?

I'm sure the answers are no and no respectively but be interesting to know why.


r/askphilosophy • • 7h ago

how free is the human being?

2 Upvotes

its been difficult for me to find an answer


r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

How to continue existing in the world of 'distraction' after ego starts to dissolve

1 Upvotes

"ego is dissolving" is the closest approximation I can get to describing in words this feeling/experience and it was definitely pushed along by reading The Wisdom of Insecurity by Alan Watts. Anyone who's read this book or experienced this process of forgetting the "I": how did you continue to participate/be in the world without feeling total dissonance with distractions ( including this device/platform/hive mind we call tech)? Or even just the typical milestone distractions of living (career, materialism, relationships, cycles, etc)? Did you somehow skate or meditate along in parallel with the daily-doings, the ones that threaten to completely engulf our existence and squish us into mental isolation of the ego? How to interact with others without categorizing every experience, without slipping into the next pleasure-seeking and pain-avoiding behavior? My takeaway from philosophers like Watts and Eckhart Tolle was to surrender to the Now without trying to swim against it, but it's extremely tempting to go back into plan/think/label experiences mode (like I am currently). Or tempting to abscond to the wilderness and do away with all of it, a la Supertramp.This might be ranging into a spiritual question, and the closest I think Watts got to describing actionable 'being' or functioning in the world is to love. How did you 'come down', rejoin the others, so to speak, after reading a book like this?


r/askphilosophy • • 9h ago

Badiou, Deleuze, And Currents

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

I have been interested in Deleuze and Badiou lately, and have recently read D&R as well as B&E. I found both books fascinating and highly relevant to our current situation philosophically and scientifically.

But, a couple interesting things I've noticed when I put down the book and looked left and right:

We are all saturated by talk of AI, and at this point AI writing has already "infiltrated" academia. But it is also a useful tool for people who were not able to get past the prose of continental philosophy texts to understand the main ideas of the works.

What is the currents like right now in academic philosophy? Are we already past Deleuze and Badiou as far as groundbreaking work? (Already blasé with the speculative realist fad?) Or is it still highly relevant? Or is the hyper-spwcialization of academia made it so that these questions are not really explored in much detail and AI just helps with expanding on subproblems?

I am genuinely wondering since I am not part of academic circles but I understand the works but have not found anything of a similar profoundness since these works in let's say the "canon" or have there been new works recently accepted as equally profound?

This is also interesting to me because, I may have a bias associated with my age, but it seems that not just in philosophy but in other areas of the sciences there have been differing amounts of "stagnation" due to hyperspecialization (I'm obviously excluding some fields it is not a uniform phenomenon) and am wondering if this is the more likely explanation as to why I have not heard of new great works.

I was suggested speculative realist work in the past like Graham Harmon and Quentin Meillasoux but I found their ideas not all that inspiring although Harmon's concepts of process philosophy was at least an interesting type of thought experiment but meillasoux's argument about retrojection made logical sense to me but addressing this concern of the Kantian variety seemed unnecessary as both Deleuze and Badiou sufficiently addressed the role of the transcendental subject in their works.

Any thoughts are appreciated, thank you.


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

Open Thread /r/askphilosophy Open Discussion Thread | November 16, 2026

6 Upvotes

Welcome to this week's Open Discussion Thread (ODT). This thread is a place for posts/comments which are related to philosophy but wouldn't necessarily meet our subreddit rules and guidelines. For example, these threads are great places for:

  • Discussions of a philosophical issue, rather than questions

  • Questions about commenters' personal opinions regarding philosophical issues

  • Open discussion about philosophy, e.g. "who is your favorite philosopher?"

  • "Test My Theory" discussions and argument/paper editing

  • Questions about philosophy as an academic discipline or profession, e.g. majoring in philosophy, career options with philosophy degrees, pursuing graduate school in philosophy

This thread is not a completely open discussion! Any posts not relating to philosophy will be removed. Please keep comments related to philosophy, and expect low-effort comments to be removed. Please note that while the rules are relaxed in this thread, comments can still be removed for violating our subreddit rules and guidelines if necessary.

Previous Open Discussion Threads can be found here.


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Why do we assume that because something's smaller, it's more real?

51 Upvotes

Am I misunderstanding the word 'real?'

I'm not quite sure how to convey this concept when talking to people, I'm often met with one of these kinds of statements:

(1) "Subjective experience isn't real, it's just chemical reactions in the brain" or (2) "everything that is real is fundamentally just atoms."

(1) - is my subjective experience not a part of reality? It exists to me, therefore in some sense it must exist. I subjectively experience, therefore I am.

(2) - is my subjective experience just atoms? Is a 3rd person model of my brain the same as the 1st person experience I'm having?

Further points:

- a cat is 'real' in that there's a real difference between a cat and a dog that's not just linguistic. Is it less real than an atom?

- the concept of a cat is real in that the word carries real meaning, can have real world effects (I'm going to draw a cat and not a dog).

- the cat I'm picturing in my mind is a part of reality, even if only from a subjective point of view. I'm really imagining it. Is subjective experience 'less real', or just less universally applicable?


r/askphilosophy • • 13h ago

What can be known without proof?

2 Upvotes

Like the question is asking about something that can be known without proof, how can something be known without proof?

When someone goes against the typical norm/grain of what should be understood to be unquestionably true, what sorts of things can be fully known and understood without proof?

Anyone?


r/askphilosophy • • 10h ago

Can you truly love someone without needing them?

0 Upvotes

I’ve always wondered about this. How can you genuinely love someone but not need them in any way?
Think about it. If you love someone but don’t need them, doesn’t that imply that they don’t really bring anything meaningful to your life? Almost as if they’re replaceable, disposable, or simply there for their looks.
Let me give you an example. Let’s say your partner is struggling with something, and you try to be there for them. You provide emotional support, comfort, companionship, affection, and do everything you can to make their life a little easier. But despite all that, they still don’t need you. They don’t need your support, your presence, or anything you have to offer.
So what exactly makes them want to be with you? If they don’t need you for anything, then what’s keeping them there? Is it just your physical appearance or the temporary pleasure you provide?
I’m not saying someone should be completely dependent on their partner or incapable of living without them. Obviously, you should be able to function independently. But if you genuinely love someone, shouldn’t you need them in some capacity? Whether that’s their emotional support, companionship, presence, affection, or simply having them in your life?
Otherwise, what’s the difference between loving someone and just enjoying what they look like or what they bring to the table?
I want to hear different perspectives. Can you genuinely love someone without needing them? And if so, how can someone be irreplaceable to you if you don’t actually need them?


r/askphilosophy • • 11h ago

Where to find Helene Stöcker works

1 Upvotes

Maybe a shot in the dark, but does anyone know where/how to access any of Helene Stöcker's work?

I'd like to read her novel Love and her essay collection Love and Women. I've found Love and Women in its original German*,* but it's been exceedingly difficult to find an English translation. I ran it through Google Translate, but it didn't actually...translate anything. I guess because it was a PDF of the actual book instead of recognizable text, not sure.

If anyone has any resources or suggestions, please let me know!


r/askphilosophy • • 17h ago

What is the literature on whether Kantian Ethics succeeds in forbidding false promises?

3 Upvotes

The standard example of Kantian ethics is that of seeking to acquire money by falsely promising to repay a loan, the argument going that if such a maxim were universalised, then no lender would ever believe such a promise, and so the maxim leads to a practical contradiction.

However it seems to me (and it seems Sesardić (2020) has argued this in the literature) that this argument doesn't quite work. That is, such a con artist's maxim will not be to falsely promise to just anybody: they will make this promise only when it serves their interests, i.e. when they have reason to believe the ruse will be successful, and so seek out a gullible mark. Hence, their maxim might be more accurately summarised as "when desiring money, make a false promise to a lender you justifiably believe to be a sucker".

But it seems that this maxim can be universalised, akin to how the maxim of lying to a lying murderer did in Korsgaard (1986). That is, even if it were a law of nature that everybody makes false promises to those they justifiably believe to be suckers, one's false promise to a sucker could still succeed if they (incorrectly) believe themselves not to be a sucker. And surely it is the mark of a true sucker that they believe themselves not to be!

One still seems to be using them as a mere means, but if Kantianism can only condemn their action via the 2nd Formula, that does seem to raise the worry of why they should be compelled not to act like this. My understanding of the appeal of Kantian ethics is it gives a sort of internalist motivation via deriving a contradiction, but I'm not seeing the contradiction in this "lie to suckers" maxim.

So, my question is twofold:

  • Am I missing something here? I've not read much Kant beyond Groundwork, is this sort of thing answered by his further works?

  • Is this something contemporary Kantians have written on? The Sesardić paper only seems to have one citation on Google Scholar.