r/askphilosophy • • 1h ago

Open Thread /r/askphilosophy Open Discussion Thread | November 16, 2026

4 Upvotes

Welcome to this week's Open Discussion Thread (ODT). This thread is a place for posts/comments which are related to philosophy but wouldn't necessarily meet our subreddit rules and guidelines. For example, these threads are great places for:

  • Discussions of a philosophical issue, rather than questions

  • Questions about commenters' personal opinions regarding philosophical issues

  • Open discussion about philosophy, e.g. "who is your favorite philosopher?"

  • "Test My Theory" discussions and argument/paper editing

  • Questions about philosophy as an academic discipline or profession, e.g. majoring in philosophy, career options with philosophy degrees, pursuing graduate school in philosophy

This thread is not a completely open discussion! Any posts not relating to philosophy will be removed. Please keep comments related to philosophy, and expect low-effort comments to be removed. Please note that while the rules are relaxed in this thread, comments can still be removed for violating our subreddit rules and guidelines if necessary.

Previous Open Discussion Threads can be found here.


r/askphilosophy • • 22m ago

Is procreation morally permissible if one believes their child could suffer eternally in hell?

0 Upvotes

I'm interested in the ethics of procreation under religious beliefs involving eternal punishment, particularly in Abrahamic theology.

Consider a parent who believes that having children creates a nonzero probability that those children will eventually experience eternal suffering.

Three problems seem to arise:

  1. Moral risk: Even if the probability of damnation is small, can exposing someone to the possibility of infinite suffering be morally justified, particularly when the child cannot consent to being created?

  2. Predestination: If God already determines who will ultimately be saved or damned, how does this affect the justice of creating someone whose ultimate fate is already fixed? Does the problem shift from parental responsibility to divine justice?

  3. Divine command: Suppose procreation is understood as a religious duty. Why should fulfilling that duty override the potential moral cost imposed on one's children? Could accepting a lesser moral or religious failing (remaining childless) be preferable to exposing another person to eternal punishment?

I recognize that different theological traditions interpret hell, predestination, free will, and divine commands differently.

Are there established philosophical arguments addressing this problem, particularly in the literature on procreative ethics, the problem of evil, or religious ethics?


r/askphilosophy • • 27m ago

What can be known without proof?

3 Upvotes

Like the question is asking about something that can be known without proof, how can something be known without proof?

When someone goes against the typical norm/grain of what should be understood to be unquestionably true, what sorts of things can be fully known and understood without proof?

Anyone?


r/askphilosophy • • 49m ago

is it concerning to find this a difficult read?

1 Upvotes

Recently picked up Either/Or by Kierkegaard. The 1992 abridged version.

is it concerning to find the abridgers notes a difficult read?

I'm kinda just briefly reading the initial editors notes that occur in the first 27 pages and i found it genuinely hard to understand and decipher meaning from the abridgers (Alastair Hannay) writing.

The way he constructs sentences it feels like figuring out a math problem and to fully understand some points i have to do what feels like too much thinking, it just concerns me.

I havent gotten to Kierkegaard's actual work and I am struggling. My literacy comprehension may be completely terrible.

I just wanted to know if anyone else considers that stuffy wordy or very academic

For any reference I am relatively new to philosophy as a whole, and reading literature I haven't done much in my life until recently, so I may genuinely be an idiot when it comes to reading stuff and getting an understanding of what's being said.


r/askphilosophy • • 1h ago

How much general philosophy knowledge is a PhD student expected to know?

18 Upvotes

Hi all. I'm a fourth year PhD student, and lately I've started to get a creeping sense of impostor syndrome. My research is a relatively niche intersection of philosophy of mind, cognitive science, and disability studies. Within that area I'm relatively confident (although my knowledge is still incomplete), but outside it I often feel like a complete fraud.

I've never read most of the canon classics. I don't have opinions on the major philosophers. I don't have defensible positions on the big debates. And I don't have more than a superficial grasp on non-Western traditions. I know that philosophy is vast and it's literally impossible to be well-read in everything, but at this stage I imagined that I'd be more of a generalist than I am.

How much general knowledge is actually expected of someone at my stage of study? Is the "well-rounded philosopher who has read everything" possible, or is it just a myth? How is one supposed to balance building breadth of philosophical knowledge without neglecting my thesis and all the other time-consuming activities like teaching and marking and other life stuff that we all have to manage?

Thanks in advance for any replies and/or suggestions!


r/askphilosophy • • 3h ago

Is there any way of proving free will?

0 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

Is there any explanation or theory for why Humans are the only creatures who developed Morality??

0 Upvotes

Basically what the Text says


r/askphilosophy • • 4h ago

What is the literature on whether Kantian Ethics succeeds in forbidding false promises?

1 Upvotes

The standard example of Kantian ethics is that of seeking to acquire money by falsely promising to repay a loan, the argument going that if such a maxim were universalised, then no lender would ever believe such a promise, and so the maxim leads to a practical contradiction.

However it seems to me (and it seems Sesardić (2020) has argued this in the literature) that this argument doesn't quite work. That is, such a con artist's maxim will not be to falsely promise to just anybody: they will make this promise only when it serves their interests, i.e. when they have reason to believe the ruse will be successful, and so seek out a gullible mark. Hence, their maxim might be more accurately summarised as "when desiring money, make a false promise to a lender you justifiably believe to be a sucker".

But it seems that this maxim can be universalised, akin to how the maxim of lying to a lying murderer did in Korsgaard (1986). That is, even if it were a law of nature that everybody makes false promises to those they justifiably believe to be suckers, one's false promise to a sucker could still succeed if they (incorrectly) believe themselves not to be a sucker. And surely it is the mark of a true sucker that they believe themselves not to be!

One still seems to be using them as a mere means, but if Kantianism can only condemn their action via the 2nd Formula, that does seem to raise the worry of why they should be compelled not to act like this. My understanding of the appeal of Kantian ethics is it gives a sort of internalist motivation via deriving a contradiction, but I'm not seeing the contradiction in this "lie to suckers" maxim.

So, my question is twofold:

  • Am I missing something here? I've not read much Kant beyond Groundwork, is this sort of thing answered by his further works?

  • Is this something contemporary Kantians have written on? The Sesardić paper only seems to have one citation on Google Scholar.


r/askphilosophy • • 8h ago

Why do some believe that an argument being counterintuitive or absurd is a reason to reject it?

4 Upvotes

It seems to me that absurdity is culturally and temporally sensitive or even depends on the person. Why would such a flimsy concept be a reason to reject an argument?

As another example I’ve debated people on the cosmology argument for god and some of said people try to grandstand infinite regression being counterintuitive, but of what relevance is this to the argument exactly? They will say “there needs to be a canon that fires the cannonball“ and usually don’t elaborate further.

Similarly when I’ve debated infintism vs foundationalism vs coherentism I’m met with “justification needs a stopping point!” and little explanation as to why besides “it doesn’t make sense otherwise.”

If someone is making a vibes based judgment of an argument like this, is it somehow disingenuous or bad faith of me to also reject said argument based on vibes? Like a vibes based hitchen‘s razor?


r/askphilosophy • • 12h ago

What are the cases for and against blind adherence to society’s expectations of you?

2 Upvotes

Everyone around me (friends, teachers, parents, shit even guidance counsellor) “reaffirms” my freedom to chase my own truth, however they always try to nudge me towards the golden (skewed by our community’s interests if I may say) Catholic standard—straight, rich enough to retire early, couple of children, etc. This constant friction between their words about “being who you are” and the very rigid values that they are viewing me with has honestly strained the image I have with myself. If I try to view myself through myself I feel self-indulgent and extremely misanthropic (God forbid haha), and if I try to view myself within my own circumstances I feel extremely rash and irrational. I can’t help but think that adhering to those standards will be my path to bliss.

Truth be told some of my exhaustion also comes from being met with extreme disinterest (or worst the conversation get shrouded in taboo) whenever I talk about what I think or about something that I care deeply about.

P.S. I’ve rarely read any philosophy. I’ve only really read the Socratic plays by Plato, Very little of Marx, Kierkegaard, and the novels of Camus and Satre (I found the former’s philosophy drab and dropped it without much regard)


r/askphilosophy • • 13h ago

Is there a name for, or refutation of, the following idea?

5 Upvotes

Hello, thank you for taking the time to answer. I recently had an idea and I figured it's either accidentally plagiarized, or wrong but I can't see how. I was hoping someone could tell me the name of this idea if it's been thought up before, or please tell me if it's just no good. Here it is.

Our decisions can be modeled on the assumption that we are trying to maximize utility on a time adjusted basis. The models used are things like exponential discounting, hyperbolic discounting and some others. This is of course not my idea, this comes from behavioral economics. I don't know what that method is, but I will assume that some such decision making method exists.

Whether or not our method of decision making succeeds in bringing us happiness is out of our control. Our actions are guided by this process, but we cannot guarantee its success. We also can only choose to change this decision making method, if that decision is reached by our original method.

We might admit that it is impossible to guarantee happiness for a few reasons. Some being that we have incomplete knowledge, we might decide to go to work instead of staying home but get into a crash. We might also be unhappy because we have mental needs that we can't satisfy. But is there a name for, or refutation of the view that our happiness depends on the success or failure of a mental decision making process that we cannot control?

Thank you.


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

Why do we assume that because something's smaller, it's more real?

45 Upvotes

Am I misunderstanding the word 'real?'

I'm not quite sure how to convey this concept when talking to people, I'm often met with one of these kinds of statements:

(1) "Subjective experience isn't real, it's just chemical reactions in the brain" or (2) "everything that is real is fundamentally just atoms."

(1) - is my subjective experience not a part of reality? It exists to me, therefore in some sense it must exist. I subjectively experience, therefore I am.

(2) - is my subjective experience just atoms? Is a 3rd person model of my brain the same as the 1st person experience I'm having?

Further points:

- a cat is 'real' in that there's a real difference between a cat and a dog that's not just linguistic. Is it less real than an atom?

- the concept of a cat is real in that the word carries real meaning, can have real world effects (I'm going to draw a cat and not a dog).

- the cat I'm picturing in my mind is a part of reality, even if only from a subjective point of view. I'm really imagining it. Is subjective experience 'less real', or just less universally applicable?


r/askphilosophy • • 15h ago

what is a moral compass?

0 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 18h ago

Which political philosophers distinguish the freedom to leave an institution from the power to change its rules?

7 Upvotes

Imagine a version of The Truman Show where Truman knows he’s being filmed and can leave whenever he wants. He chooses to stay, but the director still has the final say over how the show is run. I’m interested in what changes if Truman also has a formal way to challenge decisions or help revise the rules.

Which philosophers have written about whether a meaningful right to exit is sufficient for freedom within an institution, or whether freedom also requires some power to contest its decisions? Are there introductory readings that explain the distinction?


r/askphilosophy • • 18h ago

Is there a philosophy that separates the moral teachings of Jesus from the broader Christian doctrinal and metaphysical worldview?

0 Upvotes

I'm asking this here rather than a Christian/theology subreddit because it doesn't have to be tied to Jesus (though I'd be curious either way).


r/askphilosophy • • 18h ago

What makes so many philosophers write in such dense, obscure, and hard-to-understand prose?

0 Upvotes

Also known as - If you're so smart, why do you write like crap?


r/askphilosophy • • 21h ago

Does one create or find one's Purpose in life?

5 Upvotes

r/askphilosophy • • 23h ago

Frederick Copleston vs. Anthony Kenny: How Do Their Histories of Philosophy Compare?

5 Upvotes

I am in my late forties and recently returned to studying. I am currently pursuing an undergraduate degree in philosophy online and gradually building a personal library for long-term study.

I have been considering Frederick Copleston’s A History of Philosophy (11 volumes) and Anthony Kenny’s A New History of Western Philosophy (4 volumes).

Before committing to one, I would appreciate some insights into how these two works compare in terms of depth, readability, historical coverage, and treatment of philosophical arguments.

Also, how well has Copleston’s work held up against more recent scholarship, particularly Kenny’s?

Thank you for your insights.


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Hamlet "to be or not to be" soliloquy interpretation.

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm taking my first university philosphy class this year and we have to interpret "to be or not to be" in Hamlet. My issue is that my professor has a very unconventional interpretation that we are supposed to follow, that I just don't understand.

The common interpretation of this scene is that hamlet is asking whether he should live or die because he doesn't want to battle with his mind anymore. Hamlet says "to die, to sleep" and "when we have shuffled off this mortal coil" which aligns with that interpretation.

My philosophy teacher interprets it as: because hamlet is already being, he is not asking whether to be or not to be, he is asking how to be. In order to doubt your own existence you must be. both taking arms against a sea of troubles and fighting what brings you harm are not ideal because they both lead to eventual demise for you. Like the taking arms is affirmation of life and nilhlism both require there to be life.

We are expected to follow this interpretation to not get marks off, but im just very confused why it has to be so convoluded. I wasjust wondering if anyone else knows about this philisophical interpretation and how it should be wirtten?


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Where should I start with Kant? I have been into philosophy for one year now and read various philosophers, but now I want to start reading from Kant but I have no idea with which book to start.

18 Upvotes

I have read many philosophers so I'm not exactly a beginner, but I also don't want to start Kant with CPR, so which works from him do you recommend to start with?


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

What do different philosophies/religions believe the "good life" to be, and how do they compare to the Christian one?

5 Upvotes

I have to do a presentation in my Bible class on a book of my choice that's about the "good life" and what living it looks like. My professor has encouraged us to look at different philosophies and religions and find what their "good life" is so we can compare and contrast it to the Christian one. However, I can't decide on which would be an interesting comparison, let alone what book to read, so this question may help me to do that.

Feel free to leave book suggestions!


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Which philosophical views are commonly accepted by philosophers yet strike outsiders as surprising or counterintuitive?

85 Upvotes

There seem to be lots of cases of philosophers defending highly counterintuitive positions (like Zeno denying that things really move), but from what I can tell those kinds of "odd" views stay unpopular even among philosophers (though I'm not a philosopher, so maybe I've got that wrong?).

Are there any cases of surprising or counterintuitive philosophical conclusions that philosophers broadly accept because of philosophical work, ones that would strike non-philosophers as strange or surprising?


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

Best lecturers on individual philosophers?

6 Upvotes

Hey I’m pretty new to philosophy, I’m taking an intro to philosophy course in college and I have genuinely never felt more engaged or excited by a subject. I prefer reading primary sources and that’s what I try to do for the most part, but I was wondering if there are any good lectures I can watch for overviews on specific philosophers before diving into their bodies of work.

the philosophers I’m most interesting in right now are

Camus (I really enjoyed the stranger and I’ve always loved dostoyevsky, and they both give me a similar overall feel in a weird way)

Sarte

Marx

Hegel (I’ll be real I’m not sure if I’ll be able to get through phenomenology of spirit on my own but I’m really really interested)

Descartes (I sort of dislike him so far, and that makes me want to understand it more deeply because I feel like I’m missing something, especially with regards to his proof of gods existence)

and I would also like to figure out Kierkegaard and kant, though I’m less specifically interested in them and moreso interested in how they influenced other philosophers.

I’m very new so if I sound sort of silly I apologize :)

I am an anthropology major, so any additional recommendations that intersect with the two fields would be highly appreciated as well :)


r/askphilosophy • • 1d ago

What does a law school owe applicants when it changes which seats are available?

0 Upvotes

magine a law school with two routes to the same J.D. Last year it offered 120 places in the three-year daytime program and 40 in the four-year evening program. This year it offers 140 daytime places and 20 evening places. The school still offers 160 places. Applicants who can attend only in the evening have lost half the places they could actually use.

Suppose applicants in your community were among those affected. Some could attend either program. Others could attend only in the evening. For those evening-only applicants, the 20 added daytime places gave them no additional path to law school.

Which philosophical theories should you apply to determine the best distribution?

How are you measuring harms/benefits? what is the incentive?