r/askanatheist • • Dec 10 '25

Why atheist and not agnostic

0 Upvotes

First off I’m not sure I know what I’m talking about here so not here to try and convince anyone of anything just want to learn. Anyway from my understanding atheists believe there is no god and agnostics believe there we simply don’t know. Am I misunderstanding that and if I’m not what makes you believe there for sure isn’t a god?


r/askanatheist • • Jun 19 '25

Atheists: What is stopping you from believing in a God?

0 Upvotes

I am personally religious, Christian, and I converted a few years ago and wondered if what held me back from believing in a God still holds weight today. Or just what the general consensus is.

No disrespect to your beliefs, I'm just curious :)


r/askanatheist • • Mar 25 '25

Do you think life/your life has a purpose? Why or why not? If so, what do you think it is?

0 Upvotes

As many of you probably already understand, in my religion we believe God created us with a purpose, a reason to be here. To glorify God, love Him and others, and do good works, reflecting God's grace and love in the world. That's why we're created. So I'm curious, as atheists (and related religions), what some of you believe the point of life and your existence is; if there's one at all, and where you got this idea from. I imagine you've heard this before, so sorry if it's repetitive and annoying.


r/askanatheist • • Mar 19 '26

What is the atheistic worldview on life?

0 Upvotes

To clarify, I am an Evangelical Protestant Christian and have been raised in such a circle. Recently, I have found myself curious about the worldview or perspective atheists have on the world, specifically the topics of morality, God (Specifically the God of the Bible), or anything else. I would appreciate a civil conversation on these matters, or about any questions you may have concerning my own faith if you have any. Thank you and God bless!


r/askanatheist • • Jan 23 '22

I challenge any gnostic atheist to come up with a sound syllogism that ends in "therefore no gods exist".

0 Upvotes

Please keep in mind that this would have to address deistic gods.

The question is, do you use inference to conclude that no gods exist, same as what most theists use which we all find unconvincing?

Or do you have a deductive argument, such as what we expect from theists?

If you have a deductive argument, you should be able to form a sound syllogism.

Please keep in mind that we're not talking about a specific god and we do not have a specific definition.

Feel free too explain why you call yourself a gnostic atheist if you cannot make this syllogism.

EDIT: you all need to stop down voting. I'm being respectful and polite. Even a comment where I basically said thanks for your perspective, is being down voted. We should be better at this than theists who down vote for tribal reasons. We should be looking at evidence and good arguments, not just taking sides.

EDIT 2: when I first wrote this, it hadn't even occurred to me that many of you mean something different by the label gnostic, than what I had thought.

I was under the impression that you all asserted a claim that no gods exist. Some of you it appears do not mean this, so please forgive me for assuming it. If you don't mean to assert the claim that no gods exist, or you aren't doing it with formal logic intent, then my challenge isn't relevant to you. But I'd still be interested to know what you do mean by the label gnostic atheist as opposed to agnostic atheist.

EDIT 3: I've discovered several reasons why some atheists assert that there are no gods.

  1. They don't mean it deductively, they mean it inductively.

  2. They aren't making an ontological claim that no gods exist, they're just saying that's what they believe.

  3. They aren't making the claim towards all gods or god concepts, they're talking about specific gods that they can defend the claim that these gods don't exist.

  4. Some don't understand the difference between claiming something doesn't exist, and just not believing it does exist.

  5. Some don't understand what an unfalsifiable claim is.

  6. Some don't understand the contrast between colloquial speech and formal logic.

  7. Some people are committing a black swan fallacy. Believing something doesn't exist because there's no good evidence that it does exist.

I'll update this list as I discover more. If anyone has one that they think belongs on this list, let me know and I'll consider adding it.


r/askanatheist • • Jun 12 '24

I just have a couple of questions

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'd just like to know the basics of an atheist's beliefs. Where did the world come from? after we die? Where did right and wrong come from? How did all the details that the earth and humans require to function come to be? (For example we have teeth and a jaw made for chewing food, and a throat that leads to a stomach that has stomach acid for grinding up the food but the acid doesn't hurt us) If anybody could take a minute to answer this tysm!! Edit: Okay a lot of y'all were pointing out that I said WHO on my first question so I changed it-thanks for pointing that out


r/askanatheist • • Jul 20 '26

Best arguement against theism?

0 Upvotes

Hey there, I'm an eastern orthodox inquiring catholism but in the meantime I'm also very intrested into looking at arguments from the atheist perspective. I do know alot of arguments but I was wondering whats ur guy's favorite arguement against theism? Please elaborate on ur response, don't just respond "problem of evil". Thanks for taking the time to read my question.

Edit: thanks for taking the time to reply, il look at the majority of the replies within these days, if ur reading this and u haven't responded yet, please dont , I got more responses then I need, unless the response is original then feel free to tell me!


r/askanatheist • • May 20 '26

Why high iq individuals still believe?

0 Upvotes

I live in 98% muslim country there is no domaine that don't use some type of magic(religion) even in hospitals, during critical operation or laboratory .i know those type of people are smarter than me and i also grow up in a relegious family and the evidence is there ,the fossils are there, even without evidence just the fact that it depends where were you born you become suspicious my question is why high iq still believe? edit : not high iq i meant smart


r/askanatheist • • Apr 16 '21

Atheists who reject the existence of a benevolent God due to the problem of evil: How do you justify having children?

0 Upvotes

Obviously this question is directed to atheists who have or desire to have children, not antinatalists.


The logic: Human existence is filled with so much unnecessary suffering that, if God were to exist, it is morally wrong that God caused humanity to exist. Thus, if God exists, he is evil.


Following this logic, how can having children be justified? If you think that God bringing us into this existence would be evil, how is a person bringing another person into the very same existence not evil?


——edit due to my title confusing people:

Hopefully this rephrasing will clear things up. Let’s now act as if my post was titled:

Atheists who believe that, if God were to exist, his creation of us would be evil due to the unnecessary suffering present in our existence: ...


r/askanatheist • • Oct 03 '21

How Do You Counter the Top Three Arguments of God's Existence?

0 Upvotes

Until today, despite hundreds of discussions between Christian Apologetics and Atheists, the top three arguments for the existence of God is still being debated. Here's a very extremely simplified version of each argument:

  1. Cosmological Argument

- Everything that has a beginning has a cause. The universe had a beginning, which logically mean that the universe had a cause.

2) Design/Teleological Argument

- The universe and life is designed and not through random chance.

3) Moral Argument

- There is a standard beyond us humans that we derived our morals from.

Conclusion: All three arguments lead to the attributes of a Theistic god without opening up any religious document. You end up with a "Spaceless, timeless, immaterial, powerful, personal, intelligent, moral creator."

What are your responses to each argument as well as the conclusion?


r/askanatheist • • Sep 02 '25

How do you feel about the Stanford Encyclopedia definition of the word Atheism?

1 Upvotes

Although the Stanford Encyclopedia does list other definitions for the word, it attempts to argue that the best/correct definition that should be used in (philosophy) is the one making a positive claim. The claim that there is definitively no god, rather than for someone who's simply lacking a belief that a god exist, (agnostic atheist). It's a little obnoxious because there's been a Christian rage baiting Youtuber named BigJonSteel, who has been trying to pigeon hole all atheists as being positive atheists and using this particular definition as his excuse. But it doesn't even seem like agnostic atheists would even fit in this definition, because agnostic atheists aren't making a true or false proposition. And ironically, the only reason some philosophers want to pigeon hole all atheists as making a positive claim is just for convenience. Simply to be a direct opposite to the word theist. But it sure looks like any attempt to put agnostic atheists into the philosophical category would actually be a category error. Anyways, what do you guys think. This is the link to the website. The paper should only take about 10 minutes to read or listen to if you'd like to know more about this.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/


r/askanatheist • • Aug 19 '26

Other atheists: how do you respond to atheists who are highly prejudiced against religious people?

1 Upvotes

I’m an atheist, but it’s not something I think about much and doesn’t really affect my views of other people I meet day to day who are religious, although I do confess I am very against a specific type of white American Christian mega-church going kind of religiosity. But I do admire and am friends with a lot of people who are Jewish or Muslim, and a few Christians as well. I do think religion is irrational but all humans are irrational in some way and anyone who believes that everything they do, think, and believe is perfectly rationally is suspect.

My dad, however, while he’s always been an atheist, has fallen really deep into the atheist-media content rabbit hole in retirement. While this is much much preferred to the folks whose parents get into Q anon and right wing nut job conspiracies, he’s become extremely biased against anyone who’s religious at all. He doesn’t want a doctor whose religious, and has said things like religious doctors can’t treat patients as well, he’ll make snide comments about anyone I’m friends with whose religious, he spends a lot of time listening to old Christopher Hitchens debates or reading Dawkins. Once he learns someone is religious, he’ll completely dismiss anything else they have to say as worthless because they believe in something irrational.

Does anyone else have experience with this? What did you do?

I know part of this might be religious trauma on his part from a catholic upbringing, but the fact that anyone, no matter Jewish, Muslim, or Christian is suddenly completely discounted wholesale in his book is disconcerting to me.


r/askanatheist • • Oct 14 '23

how come you see this universe and don't see creation?

3 Upvotes

I'm not trying to attack anyone here, i really only wanna understand your point of view about this.
Some background about me: I've been religious most of my life, when i had doubts about religion and existence of god, the simplest proofs would be pretty convincing, for example being asked to look at the world around me and realizing that this universe must've been created by a very capable creator, for example, if you're walking somewhere and see a tree that has its leaves cut in a way to make the whole tree look like a person or something, you would immediately think that the guy who cut it this way is an artist, how come you look at this great universe and not see an artist of a creator ?
I have to admit that i'm not well educated on philosophy, i know that what i just described if a mix of the fine-tunning argument with the principal of sufficient reason, and i know that are counter arguments in the books of philosophy and what not, but all those seem invaluable as you can simply look around you and just naturally conclude that we've been created.
All of my life i've been looking at athiests as if they are just playing with words and not accepting simple facts that we are in fact created, but i would to challenge that hypothesis of mine and see if there are poeple that truly believe there is no god.
I already asked this in /r/athiest/ but it got removed, i got a few responses which i would like to address here so they don't get repeated.
Response 1: there is literally no evidence of creation. or There's no scientific evidence for a creator.
my whole post is about realizing that the universe itself is evidence of creation, just like if you saw a statue you would come to realize that it was made a person, why wouldn't you acknowledge that you yourself were made by a creator as well ?

why isn't this whole universe considered "scientific evidcnce"?
Response 2: if you believe in a god, Thus you believe in Vishnu, or Zeus? No? How about Odin or Isis?
we don't have to give God a specific name for now, i am only talking about realizing that there is a god from the fact that the universe exists and its complicated, therefore we must see that it was created this way, whether that creators is cruel or not, or gave us a valid religion to follow or not, i'm talking about the fact that we should deduce a god exists from looking around us in the universe, even if everythring is not fine tuned to the maximum, and even if we science tells us that there are "misconfigurations" in our body. Hope my point is clear
Hope i didn't offend anyone.


r/askanatheist • • May 27 '24

Question from a Christian. What do you think happens after death?

0 Upvotes

Like do you just see black forever? And if Christianity IS real, you’d probably be in a major pickle because people who didn’t accept Jesus would be subjected to hell.

Don’t take it as provocative, just curious.


r/askanatheist • • Nov 23 '22

Why use the term "atheist" when you know it doesn't mean the same thing to believers that it does to you?

0 Upvotes

Watch the first 700 hours of The Atheist Experience for the proof of my implied fact: MOST Christians define "atheism" as "CLAIMS God is not real"

Over and over on that show, I saw Christians calling in and when it dawns on the hosts that the callers are using their definition of "atheism" and debating THAT in stead of THEIR position, the hosts WASTE TIME "correcting" them about this side topic.

We're battling brainwashing, here, folks. They're not fans of debate - otherwise they might not have fallen for the brainwashing. De-programming these people requires a more delicate touch, and "holding onto OUR definition of atheist" works at cross purposes to that goal.

We're the bigger men in this situation - we're supposed to be the smart ones, the humble ones, humbly "going with their definition" for the sake of argument.

In stead, there's this gigantic movement among skeptics to push this boulder up Sisyphus' hill and try to redefine "atheism" ON TOP OF educating believers about what we skeptics actually think.

Why?

EDIT: Sorry I wasn't clear. I was really stupid and did not clarify I was speaking about casual day-to-day discourse with believers you meet in real life one-on-one. I asked this question online, in a reddit post, which implies that (the itnernet) is the setting for discussion, and (again) that wasn't my intent.


r/askanatheist • • Sep 05 '22

Is Teaching Kids Sanskrit Mantras Religious Indoctrination In Your Mind?

0 Upvotes

I don't have any children. But if I were to teach my hypothetical children Sanskrit mantras in order to help the understand tradition and culture, would this be considered religious indoctrination by atheists? I want to get your understanding of childhood religious indoctrination is.


r/askanatheist • • Jun 04 '23

Why Do Many Atheists Believe Religion/Faith Is About Death Anxiety?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I have atheist family and friends, but many of them don't like discussing religion, so I thought I would ask atheists online my question.

Why do so many atheists, especially online think that religion and faith is all about death anxiety? I can't speak for every theist, but all the theists I have spoken to have said it's not about death anxiety at all.

Take me for example. I'm Hindu and a yogi.

For me, being Hindu is about improving my life, calming the mind and being closer to God/Brahman. Its promotes physical and mental well being as well as a sense of inner peace. It helps me create a deeper understanding of myself and the world.

While I believe in reincarnation, it isn't the main reason why I believe and practice. Same for all my other theist friends. None of my theist friends said they are theist because of death anxiety.

Converting actually is one of many things (including psychiatric, secular help) that helped me stop glorifying my potential death via suicide. It didn't ease my death anxiety at all. I never had any death anxiety, just death longing.

So, can any anyone explain why lots of atheists have that perception?

Thanks.


r/askanatheist • • Jul 27 '24

Question for those who encourage deconversions

1 Upvotes

If you're an atheist who strives to deconvert others or encourages deconversions, what is your reason for doing so absent someone religious trying to convert you?


r/askanatheist • • Dec 25 '21

What's the problem with people thanking God about the James Webb telescope?

0 Upvotes

So noticed a tons of posts on r/atheism where for some reason people seem pissed that some guy in charge of the project thanked God and quoted the Bible during a speech about the launching of the telescope.

Why be annoyed at it though? Like I can't see any reason to get angry at him doing that, it's his religion. So what that he did it? Why are people angry about it enough to declare it an 'embarrasment'?


r/askanatheist • • 16d ago

What do atheists turn to when life gets really difficult?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this from a philosophical perspective, and I’m genuinely curious to hear different viewpoints. I’m not religious in the sense of blindly accepting everything, but I do believe in God as a supernatural power that I can turn to, especially during the most difficult phases of life. Being in a STEM field myself, I deeply appreciate science. But I also recognise that science doesn’t have answers to every question about existence, consciousness, or the universe. There are things we still don’t understand.
I also feel that relying on other human beings has its limitations. People can be judgmental, misunderstand you, or sometimes fail to provide the emotional support you need. For me, believing in God provides a different kind of comfort. It’s the feeling that there’s someone I can turn to without fear of being judged, someone I can talk to when I feel completely vulnerable. There’s a certain peace and joy I get from that belief which is difficult to explain. So I’m genuinely curious:
**For those who identify as atheists, what do you turn to during the darkest or most difficult phases of your life?**
When science has no answers, people disappoint you, and you feel completely helpless, what gives you comfort? What makes you feel that you’re not alone?
I’m not trying to challenge anyone’s beliefs or suggest that one approach is better than another. I genuinely want to understand your perspective🙏🏻


r/askanatheist • • May 25 '25

If God is unjust by punishing people and by not punishing people, how is he supossed to win?

0 Upvotes

Ok, might not be the right sub but I've encountered several atheists on talking about Christianity, is people parroting "damned if he does, damned if he doesn't" I struggle with this crap too, but how could the bible possibly be written, with people doing terrible actions, that would be satisfying to you? not "would you believe," simply just what you'd find moral. Thank you. :)


r/askanatheist • • Feb 08 '25

Do You Think It's Strange That I Had To "Come To Terms" With Being Theist?

0 Upvotes

I come from an atheist background. My parents are atheists, and I was raised with a strong secular mindset. I had always been taught to view religion with skepticism, but over time, I found myself drawn to the idea of a higher power. My journey led me to Hinduism, a faith that deeply resonated with me, and I’ve been embracing its teachings and practices.

What I find interesting is that, while I now embrace theism, I had to come to terms with it. For a long time, I struggled with the idea of believing in God, especially since my upbringing and environment were so secular. It almost felt like a shift that took effort, and at times, I even questioned whether I was betraying my upbringing.

So, I’m curious, do you think it’s strange or unusual for someone to have to come to terms with being a theist? Is it common for people raised in an atheist or secular environment to experience this kind of internal conflict when exploring belief? I’d love to hear your thoughts or experiences!


r/askanatheist • • 10d ago

What do you think means "Neighbor" in the bible?

0 Upvotes

When the Bible uses the word "neighbor" in phrases or passages like "love thy neighbor," what do you think they mean by it?

The word neighbor in the most literal sense is a middle ground between a familiar/friend and a total stranger. They live next door, you see them all the time, you probably know their name and they are most likely from a similar background as yours, but they are still outside of your personal life (assuming you are not friends with them) they don't know really how you are or what you like or how you live and viceversa.

But in the more figurative sense used in the Bible, do you think that neighborhood is closer to the literal word that it stands for a person from your "tribe" who basically is like you on a broad socio-political level but unlike you on an individual level or is ment to refer to people who are very different from you like someone from a different country, or social background, language, etc?


r/askanatheist • • Apr 13 '25

Hello Atheists of Reddit! Why do you believe in atheism?

0 Upvotes

Hello again, I’m a Christian who honestly and genuinely wants to know why people believe in atheism. I’m not looking to convert anyone but I’d rather gain a better understanding of the atheist viewpoint.

I used to be agnostic but that was cause I didn’t think heavily on anything spiritual. Now that I’m Christian, I find myself often wondering how atheists believe in atheism and when I look for answers on this, it’s tends to be mostly out of spite for religion. This, however, doesn’t satisfy my curiosity.

And since I don’t a lot of atheists personally, I wanted to ask Reddit, or more specifically people who actively identify as atheists, what their thoughts are on atheism and such. So in order to give some direction for this discussion, I’ll give some questions that have been burning in my mind on the matter.

  1. What evidence convinces you to believe there are no gods?

  2. If no divine purpose exists, what is the ultimate goal you live for? What drives you to live your life?

  3. If religion never existed, do you believe life would be better? (I do disagree with the question but I think it’s crucial to ask)

I appreciate you reading my annoying curiosities and want to thank you for your time.


r/askanatheist • • May 14 '25

What Would Convince You That God Exists

3 Upvotes

Hello fellow atheists ( I hate when dishonest theists, trying to pose as atheists, start their post with that line 😂).

See below for TLDNR

All jokes asides, I’m an atheist and I’ve been listening to all sorts of atheist debate / reaction YouTube channels for the past 3 years. I’ve noticed that most arguments for the existence of god fall in these categories: 1) Something about “the origin of the universe”, therefore god - 2) life needs purpose, therefore god - 3) Moral law giver, therefore god - 4) a watch needs a watchmaker, therefore god - 5) I’m scared about what happens after death, therefore god - 6) (biased) Near Death Experiences, therefore god - 7) I’m a clown with 0 imagination and have to presuppose god, therefore god. There are a few more such as the supposed resurrection and eyewitness accounts and prophecies for christianity blah blah but this is not the point of my post.

I listed those above because they are a few of the REALLY bad arguments that I’ve heard and can spot within 2 sentences of a theist talking about why god exists. And I mean it, to me, they are all very, very, very bad. What I’ve come to realize is that the vaaaast majority of theists (Abrahamic theists specifically) were just indoctrinated in their religion and just believe in faith or had supposed supernatural experiences and some combination of those is mainly the reason why they believe in god.

This brings me to the point of my post, the only thing that would convince me of a god is repeatable novel predictions / experiences. Let’s use the most common definition of god (all powerful, all knowing etc) I’m still working out what would convince me be but think of this: Some entity appears to me and claims to be god. I would say for example, solve world hunger and fly me around the world to see that no kids are hungry and living in poverty anymore + show me what I did earlier today - play it in front of me, like some sort of hologram, now make me look like I’m 7 ft tall in said visual that’s playing in front of me + show me what I did all of yesterday, 5 years ago, so on and so forth + predict specific things that will happen in the next 3 hours around the world. Grant me the ability to fly, let’s fly through space and grab a rock from Mars - let’s go to a scientist and have them examine it, to make sure it’s from Mars. I know the previous portion in Bold seems like the rambling thoughts of a madman but that is exactly the point. Said entity would need to be able to show me experiences and grant requests that are fully absurd and fully repeatable with other humans involved to confirm. OF COURSE for all I know it could be an alien with extremely advanced tech messing with my head but at least that’s a start. Anyways, don’t comment on what would convince me, this is about you lol I know mine is pretty weak.

TLDNR: What would convince you that god exists? I’m talking about the classic god with omni attributes. If your answer is “If there is a god then they would know exactly what would convince me” then this post is not for you. A god knowing exactly what would convince you is a correct answer but, I’m more curious to see what some of you have thought of besides that. This is supposed to be fun 😅