r/askanatheist • • Dec 24 '24

He is believed in by millions around the world, so he must be real, right?

88 Upvotes

People have believed in him for centuries all around the globe. We sing songs about him, and generation after generation teach our children about him, so Santa must be real!!

Merry Christmas, happy holidays, have a cool Yule, enjoy Festivis for the rest of us. Happy Kwanza, happy Chanukah


r/askanatheist • • May 19 '21

Atheist daughter uncomfortable with Christian themes in the house

83 Upvotes

My daughter, who is 12, recently decided/realized she is an atheist. I am a Christian. I support her decision completely. She has started taking down some of the things she made in Sunday school and Bible school, saying they make her uncomfortable. I support this, as these things were in her room. I am worried about what I can do to support her at Christmas, without suppressing my own observation of the Christian part of the holiday. If you are an atheist who had supportive Christian parents (long shot, I know), please advise! How did your parents recognize the holiday without “stuffing it down your throat”?


r/askanatheist • • Feb 19 '25

Why do half of the questions on this sub ask why we don’t believe in God?

60 Upvotes

Genuine question. I want interesting, difficult questions that challenge my beliefs and make me think and I hate that every third question on here is “why don’t you believe in God?”

Seriously, can there be a rule about this or something? If you wanna know why we don’t believe in God, then search for it and click on one of the two billion posts on here that ask that exact question. Most of us probably have very similar answers to that question anyway. Give us something fun to answer. Nobody wants to answer the same easy question 30 times a day.


r/askanatheist • • Nov 01 '22

The New and Improved r/AskAnAtheist!

59 Upvotes

Hi folks, I'm u/c0d3rman.

If you're wondering why the sub has been private for the last few weeks, it's because the previous mod of r/AskAnAtheist has left reddit. After an approval process I have adopted the sub. I hail from r/DebateAnAtheist and r/DebateReligion, where I've been modding for several years.

The sub has been revamped for its reopening with a new look, streamlined internals, and new rules.

Please take a moment to read the rules now - I promise they're short.

Welcome back!


r/askanatheist • • Jun 25 '24

Why don't apologists for religion learn to stop repeating bad arguments?

54 Upvotes

I've been discussing these topics with people for 50+ years now,

and it is extremely obvious to me that apologists for religion

[A] Only make bad arguments in defence of their religions.

[B] Repeat the same small number of bad arguments incessantly.

(And inevitably get shot down by skeptics.)

Why do apologists for religion think that repeating these arguments that have been repeatedly shown not to work will be effective?

.


r/askanatheist • • May 16 '20

Trolling

52 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

So as some of you know there was a recent spam of trolling over the last 12 hours on this sub. This sub is pretty small compared to the other atheist subs on reddit and we haven't had to deal with this kind of thing before. Mostly just some bad faith actors who post a comment here or there.

I want to thank all of you who messaged me about it. I admit I take a bit of a hands-off approach to modding, but I've decided to activate the automod to remove posts from accounts under a certain age and karma threshold. This should help this kind of thing in the short term.

Meanwhile, I invite all of you to message here with any thoughts you may have, ideas, suggestions, comments, long winded tales of adventure, or invitations for me to go fuck myself. They will all be read and seriously considered.

A few of you have graciously offered to step up and become mods in order to help with the duties, but as I've said, right now this is a small community and the first time something like this has happened. However, as we grow and if these kinds of things continue to escalate, I will bring on another mod or two.

Thank you all for making this community a fun one to moderate and keep on abiding.


r/askanatheist • • Feb 08 '26

Being Atheist in Egypt

49 Upvotes

Hi so I've been Atheist for 6 years and its very difficult in my country they treat us like monsters and alot of Atheist Egyptians have been jailed just for their thoughts including Sherif Gaber a kind brave person who had a dream who fought for us and speaked for us he made us feel we're not alone even in the dark times and the society pressure he've been there of us and now we don't know anything about him and the government doesn't want us to see him but even if he's in jail that's not fair because he doesn't deserve that he doesn't deserve to be in jail just for being different that's against human rights and that isn't okay as an Atheist and as a human being I won't let him going through this alone his story must be known and we can't do this our own thats why i need your help we have to let everyone knows about this maybe we could figure away out to help him please free sherif gaber


r/askanatheist • • Nov 10 '24

I don't know is an outstanding answer.

49 Upvotes

I see so many posts about atheists on the fence because there are things that they don't know. One of the best atheist arguments is that we are allowed to say, "I don't know." Everybody else says, "I don't know, therefore God." It's the God of the gaps. Isaac Newton invented calculus to explain the solar system, but didn't know why it didn't fall apart after a few thousand years. He said that God must help. Then comes Einstein with Special and General Relativity that explains what Newton attributed to God. The solar system works if you add Relativity to Newton's math. "I don't know" is an empowering statement. I don't know why the Big Bang happened, but that doesn't imply that God did it. We have string theorists who have possible answers. We have mainstream physicists working on it. Atheists: Don't be afraid to say that you don't know. Theists: Please remember that "I don't know" does not prove God. Feel proud to say, "I don't know."


r/askanatheist • • Jan 23 '26

If youre an atheist I'd like your perspective.

47 Upvotes

I'll start this off with im a Christian but I find myself at odds with some of Christian faith. It doesn't make sense to me that the days talked about in Genesis was a thousand years or a literal day. To me it makes more sense if the days talked about in Genesis was hundreds of millions of years. The fossils show that there have been creatures on earth for millions of years. As a Christian it doesn't conflict with my beliefs that the earth has been around for a very long time. I would luke to have a discussion with an atheist and see their point of view. Please dont treat me luke a moron for believing in God but I would like to have an understanding on why you landed on atheism. Maybe it would help me on my journey.


r/askanatheist • • Dec 11 '22

the "power of prayer"

47 Upvotes

I'm a pianist that often plays for churches. I have played a variety of Christian denominations. I'm an atheist myself, and am usually unbothered by services that I sit through. I find myself becoming increasingly irritated and confused at the concept of praying for someone. The congregation says "please pray for my father he is dying". So they do. The next month he dies and they pray for peace to the family, while also praising God for answering prayers for another family.

What is the point? How do Christians in your life "explain" this?


r/askanatheist • • Oct 24 '25

Hello there! 17M here, Tell me why?

46 Upvotes

17 M here, and I have been thinking a lot lately about this whole atheist thing. Like, why do people become atheists? Is it just because they grew up questioning stuff or did life throw them some curveballs that made them go, "Okay, where is the proof of all this god stuff?" Honestly, I keep seeing people say being atheist is "cool" or "woke" or "intellectual," but I do not fully get it. So I am here asking, what is the story behind your journey into atheism? Was it a sudden realization, a slow burn, or did you just get tired of going to church or temple and decided "nah, not for me"?

And is it actually cool? Or is it just like a phase for some people, like when you want to seem independent and unique so you pick a label that sounds deep? Because I feel like people throw around the term atheist like it is some badge of honor or rebellion sometimes. But then there is the flip side where some people say atheists are just lost souls who cannot find meaning in life. So which one is it?

Another thing I have been wondering is, if you actually are atheist, is life different? Do you wake up feeling lighter, like no more guilt about sins or whatever? Or is it kind of scary sometimes, like "Okay, so there is no higher power watching and maybe nothing really matters in the grand scheme"? Because that sounds both freeing and kind of existentially terrifying at the same time, lol. If you do not believe in a god, do you just make up your own meaning? Or is the meaning of life just whatever you choose it to be?

Also, do people ever regret becoming atheist? Like, do you ever feel like you miss the comfort or community that religion provides? Or do you think it is better to just face life head-on without any supernatural safety nets? I want to know if the grass is truly greener on the atheist side or if it is just a different kind of struggle.

From what little I have gathered, atheism is not really a belief system, it is more like the absence of belief, right? So then, what do atheists do about morals or ethics? I guess it depends person to person, but how do you personally decide what is right or wrong if there is no god telling you? That part fascinates me. Because I grew up hearing that without god, you cannot have real morals, but is that just one way of looking at things? Lots of people say being atheist means you base your values on empathy, reason, and the kind of world you want to live in.

And since I am only 17 and still figuring things out, should I even care about picking a label? Like, is being atheist something I should "aim" to be if I ever feel doubtful about religion? Or is it better to just keep an open mind, explore different beliefs, and not rush to define myself in any one way? I feel like sometimes the pressure to "choose a side" can make everything feel way more complicated than it needs to be.

Honestly, I am just really curious about the lived experience of atheists. What is it like day to day? Do you have communities or friends who get it? How do you deal with family or society if they do not understand or accept your beliefs? Because for me, stuff like that is a huge deal. Like, being true to yourself sounds amazing but also kind of scary when it means standing apart from most of the people around you.

So yeah, if you have been through the whole "why I became atheist" thing, or if you think it is "cool" (or not), or if you would recommend it or not for someone like me, please share your whole story. Do not hold back on the yaap, the good, the bad, the confusing, the enlightening. I want to hear all the vibes, rants, philosophical deep dives, whatever.

And if you want to roast me for being a naive teenager just asking questions, that is cool too 😂. I am just trying to figure this whole life and belief thing out, one step at a time. So fire away with your thoughts!


r/askanatheist • • Sep 17 '25

I keep seeing posts on Charlie Kirk news YouTube videos where atheists say they’re now going to church bc of Kirk’s death

44 Upvotes

This seems like a massive stretch for lifelong atheists. This is probably bot action, right?

I just can’t imagine any atheist turning to religion when faced with news about Kirk’s death. That seems like a Christian fundamentalist manic pixie fantasy.

EDIT: “posts” in the title should say “comments” my bad


r/askanatheist • • Apr 10 '21

Is this why poor people fall for conservatism? Because of religion?

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/askanatheist • • Jun 10 '20

How many of you identify as anti theists?

44 Upvotes

I'm an atheist and anti theist.

Basically I don't believe in God, and I think God is bad for society and the general public. Though I have seen some atheists push back on the anti theistic ideology - so I was curious how many of you we're also anti theistic? or what views you have on them?


r/askanatheist • • Dec 12 '25

It's so over for me AHHH

43 Upvotes

My mom knows I'm an ex-Muslim atheist, so she decided to like get some weird looking bearded guys to try to get me back to Islam, and tomorrow I will have to go with them and they will try to get me back into this shitty ass religion.

In this case, I could actually just debate them. But the problem here, I don't have the mental ability to debate Muslims as I still fear Islam being true and my arguments against Islam are limited, also my mental health is also really bad because of the fear and I sometimes get really bad thoughts (if yk what I mean) so I'm definitely not in a state of being able to debate anyone right now, so what to do? I really don't wanna have to face this especially when I'm nowhere near prepared to debate due to the mental health problems I'm experiencing.


r/askanatheist • • Aug 03 '25

Other than “look at the trees!” - what is the most annoying argument for God?

43 Upvotes

What common phrase should a theist never use in arguing with an atheist? What shuts down the conversation the quickest?


r/askanatheist • • Oct 25 '25

Satan makes absolutely NO SENSE

42 Upvotes

If he rebelled against god, why would he eternally torture people who are like him i.e dislike god?

Also why the hell does he even torture sinners? Shouldnt he just make hell a huge paradise better than heaven?? That would encourage humans to sin more, which is the WHOLE point of satan.

the idea of heaven is so bad because it strips you out of the ablity to sin, thus you dont even have free will anymore, i'd rather be in hell than become a mindless saint, theres just so many stupid sins in the bible you literally can't do anything in "paradise"

Satan could literally "manipulate" people onto rebelling against god to join hell, rather than make it some non sensical torture place, instead he discourages people to join hell? Is he stupid???


r/askanatheist • • Sep 12 '25

Need help as an atheist persecuted in Algeria – seeking a way out

42 Upvotes

Hello friends,

I’m a young Algerian, an atheist living in a very conservative and religious environment. Because of my lack of belief, I face discrimination and pressure from radical people around me. Life has become very difficult and I don’t see a safe future here.

About me: • I’m an engineer in chemistry and also work as a technical sales engineer. • I speak fluent French and English. • I’m motivated and willing to relocate anywhere I can live freely and safely.

I’m looking for advice or help: • How can I realistically apply for refugee/asylum status in a safe country? • Are there any organizations, networks, or communities that can provide guidance? • If someone knows of opportunities like work contracts, housing support, or sponsorship that could help me leave Algeria, I would be deeply grateful.

I don’t want to hide who I am anymore. I just want to live in peace, work hard, and contribute to society in a place where freedom of belief is respected.

Thank you for reading and for any advice you can give.


r/askanatheist • • Mar 04 '26

What premise inside an argument for theism that you find disrespectful?

40 Upvotes

For me, it's,

The universe had a beginning.

It's frustrating because the premise isn't only unjustified, but presented as if it's a solid scientific theory. Like, it doesn't take more than three seconds to think how unprovable that hypothesis is with current technology. Don't get me started with the assertion that the big bang is the beginning of the universe.


r/askanatheist • • Dec 17 '24

Evangelical Asking: are christians shooting themselves in the foot with politics?

38 Upvotes

So, a phenomenon that I’m sure everyone here is absolutely familiar with is the ever-increasing political nature of Evangelicals as a group. I would consider myself an Evangelical religiously, and even so when I think of or hear the word “Evangelical ” politics are one of the first things that comes to mind rather than any specific religious belief.

The thing that bothers me is that I’m pretty sure we’re rapidly reaching a point (In the United States, at least) where the political activities of Christians are doing more harm for Christianity as a mission than it is good, even in the extreme case of assuming that you 100% agree with every political tenet of political evangelicals. I was taught that the main mission of Christianity and the church was to lead as many people to salvation as possible and live as representatives of Christ, to put it succinctly, and it seems to me that the level of political activism— and more importantly, the vehement intensity and content of that activism— actively shoots the core purpose of the church squarely in the foot. Problem is, I’m an insider— I’m evangelical myself, and without giving details I have a relative who is very professionally engaged with politics as an evangelical christian.

So, Athiests of Reddit, my question is this: In what ways does the heavy politicalization of evangelical Christianity influence the way you view the church in a general sense? Is the heavy engagement in the current brand of politics closing doors and shutting down conversations, even for people who are not actively engaged in them?


r/askanatheist • • Oct 07 '21

Not really a question post but really appreciate you guys.

38 Upvotes

As a new atheist y'all helped me understand alot of stuff, i'll be here often i guess. Thanks again❤️🙌🏼


r/askanatheist • • Dec 20 '21

Is there a Christmas Story Version of the contradictions like you always see with the reresection story?

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/askanatheist • • Jan 17 '21

Really needing some clarification right now...

35 Upvotes

So I’m an atheist. I just got into a huge Twitter argument basically about whether it was okay to criticize Islam or not. I was arguing that Islam, the religion, needs to be held accountable for the atrocities it has committed and continues to commit due to how many people interpret the Quran’s teachings.

Pretty much everyone on Twitter came at me about how racist I was for criticizing Islam. I got called a racist piece of shit, etc. from people of whom I typically share political views with.

I couldn’t get through to any of them that what I was criticizing was the religion. The idea of it. I tried to emphasize how I don’t hate Muslim people and in fact completely support their right to believe and practice Islam peacefully as long as they don’t push it onto others. If anything I feel bad for religious people for being misguided into believing such nonsense, but I digress.

The conversation really deteriorated when an actual openly racist person stepped in and agreed with my argument, thus solidifying me in that conversation as also being a racist.

I just need to know that my logic here is correct - that Islam in and of itself is not immune to criticism just because non-whites are predominantly the believers of it. This is obviously true of every other religion, but especially the case for Islam because of its propensity for violence in modern times with the ability to cause suffering on a macro scale.

Am I racist for basically saying Islam needs to be held accountable?


r/askanatheist • • May 03 '24

Question for any LGBT atheists here

34 Upvotes

Especially if you’ve come out of the closet on both fronts to a religious family, how did the two experiences compare? I’m an atheist but I’m not LGBT. Well, I’m demi, but when I tried to tell my family that they dismissed it as me making stuff up, so that isn’t really the same type of experience. The amount of judgement, talking behind my back, just complete abandonment that’s happened from my family for being an atheist is frankly crazy and I’m just wondering if this is what it’s like coming out as LGBT, or if the two experiences are completely different. I may be an atheist, but I’m still a straight white male in the Bible Belt USA so that comes with a lot of blind spots, but understanding the similarities and differences between the two experiences could help me understand what it is like in another person’s shoes to some extent.

TIA for your responses.

Edit: everyone’s responses have been so genuine and honest. Thank you all so much.


r/askanatheist • • Oct 17 '26

Debaters, what's the most "0 IQ" comment you've heard while debating apologists?

33 Upvotes

To me it was this:

"I'm wrong, you're wrong, only the word of God is the truth."

Like bro, if you're admitting that you're wrong, how do your interpretation of God's word is right?

the math ain't mathing 😭