r/ask_detransition • • Oct 22 '20

Announcement Welcome to r/ask_detransition!

60 Upvotes

After talking with the moderators over on r/detrans we discussed that there needs to be a community where those curious and allies can interact and ask questions. We realized there wasn't a space for loved ones of those detransitioning or questioning to go as detransition itself isn't a process that is only hard on the person undergoing it but loved ones as well.

That being said, let me be clear about some things here.

This space is open to anyone to post, however topics need to be relevant to detransition.
If you are considering detransition and want an environment that is solely centered on and focused on that topic, please see our sibling subreddit: r/detrans - You are encouraged to post there if you want detrans-only input, this space will have mixed input.

This is not a space meant for instigating or harassing a group of people.
The point of this space was to allow those who are not necessarily detransitioned or experienced with transition a place to comment and ask questions regarding the controversial and sensitive topic of detransition. That being said, it is expected that rule 1 & 2 are followed strongly as this is not a space to attack anyone based on what group they belong to.

Conversion therapy or asking detransitioners to convince your child/friend/sibling to detransition is a BIG NO!
Let me stress that detransitioners do not endorse or support conversion therapy. Although the views of each detransitioner varies, asking for advice directly on changing someone who is content being trans will not be tolerated. That said, this is also not a subreddit to convince people to transition either so there will naturally be some degree of bias. However it isn't against the rules to be concerned about someone making a wrong choice as long as there's suitable evidence backing this up.

Please remember this is a detransition focused space.
Although this subreddit is open to the general public unlike r/detrans, our rules are very similar and we will actually be stricter in some regards as we do not want the same issue that happened to that subreddit in the past. Topics are to be relevant and we encourage those seeking specific help to participate in r/detrans, this sub's intention as stated before is to allow a general view and discussion into detransition.

Thank you and I hope you can follow the rules!

One last thing I guess. I will be moderating by myself at first but I will be specifically seeking those detransitioned/desisted only for moderators if people are interested in the position. I have a firm belief that detransition spaces should only be ran by those who are detransitioned themselves, although re-transitioners do have experience in a sense with detransition, it is far different and they are generally transgender.


r/ask_detransition • • 6h ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE 27 ftm wondering about detrans and reasons for it? NSFW

2 Upvotes

i apologize if this is all over the place, or if anything is offensive or anything like that. throwaway cuz i dont feel like this fits on my regular or nsfw account. also nsfw for talk of kink and stuff, and TW for talk of SA

basically, i think i might want to detransition? i mean obviously, since i’m here. the thing is, i also still think i’m trans. i’ve considered myself some flavour of genderfluid/nonbinary for a long time, and a trans man for longer than that. been on T for like more than a decade, i dont remember.

i’ll be honest that this feeling started as a result of kink. i think i’ve always felt more feminine when i’m horny but its hard to say. recently (like the past 2 months) i’ve been engaging in misgendering and detrans kink, as well as feminization hypnosis content. this is why i think i might not actually be detrans, but at the same time i doubt i would be comfortable being [referred to as] a woman in any context if i were actually trans. periodically in my transition i would also sometimes fantasize about being hyperfeminine, like plastic surgery, implants, etc. but like is that just fantasy and would i actually hate it if i went through with it? idk

it doesnt help that the only experience ive had irl with “being a woman” since i started transitioning has been nonconsensual. a (very drunk) male acquaintance hit on me, saying that i was a gorgeous lady and that he would fondle and/or bang me if i didnt have a bf and he didnt have a gf. and before that, i had an abusive ex (also a trans guy) hold me at knifepoint and make me admit to being a girl. so basically, all my experience has been uh. bad. but i dont want that to colour my opinion as to whether or not i’m trans

i do prefer to be seen as male irl. i think. but ive crossed a point where i feel way too masculine now. i have body hair literally everywhere, and my hairline is receding. i know pre-transition, one of my goals was to be masc enough that people still see me as a man even if i’m dressed fem. and recently ive been wanting to present more feminine, i dont know if i care how people gender me but it feels weird to [want to] dress fem when im so goddamn hairy.

if there was no social aspect, i think i would detransition in a heartbeat. but i fought so hard to convince my christian family to call me my preferred name and pronouns. it took literal years. i have lots of trans friends and i dont want them to think im transphobic or to stop being friends with me.

and my boyfriend. i have no clue how he’d take it. we’ve been together 9 years. hes cis male bisexual, and my biggest supporter, he always corrects people if they misgender me. i started T before we got together, and he’s always seen me as a guy. but also, early on in our relationship, i had an “identity crisis” and thought i was a lesbian, and broke up with him. that lasted about a day and i missed him so bad i decided i couldnt be a lesbian if i missed a man so badly. so i went back to identifying as a gay man. so i worry that if i detransition he might think back to that and we might break up or something and thats the last thing i want. we’ve had times where it was dicey, like when i tried to bring up abdl kink, and i dont want to ruin a good thing for no reason if im not 100% sure about detransitioning

where i am right now, detransitioning is basically just stopping T. and i guess doing something about my hairline. i havent had any surgery, and i havent changed my legal name or gender marker. but the social aspect is terrifying. but also, i’m not sure i’d “desist” if i do transition, if that makes sense. like, i might just be a feminine guy. i tried stopping T for a few weeks recently but my mood has been shit, but i dont know if thats just from the change or cuz im actually trans.

i feel cute when i dress up, i like it. i always have, at least since identifying as male. as a child i didnt care one way or the other, and after figuring out i was trans, i refused to wear fem stuff. but as a guy i enjoy it. i know presentation isnt gender but it definitely plays a part in how we navigate the world as our gender.

idk where im going with this. does anyone here have experience with detrans kink and actually detransitioning because of it? or like, medically detransitioning but not socially? probably i should talk to a therapist about this but i dont want someone who is biased one way or the other. thanks for taking the time to read


r/ask_detransition • • 14h ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE Feeling lost (FTNBTM)

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m feeling very confused with my gender since taking testosterone. I’ve been at 2 pumps a day for 5 months now and something just switched in my mind a few days ago that I don’t want to transition.

I was constantly oscillating between increasing my dose, coming out to my family, what I want my body to look like, how I want to be perceived and now something has changed. I was watching Ethel Cain videos (lmao) and felt a draw to want to look like her and her version of femininity just resonated with me for some reason and I’ve just stopped my T.

I had top surgery 1 year ago and progressed to start taking T , working out because I hated my curves. But now I can’t envision myself with facial hair, broad shoulders, receded hairline when a week ago that’s all I wanted lol?

I will note that I went back on Zoloft last month from being on lexapro so maybe that has cleared some depersonalization I felt? I have no idea, I felt spiralling thoughts of what I needed or not needed to achieve my gender goal and now that’s changed suddenly to wanting to be more feminine.

I don’t feel like a woman, I absolutely do not see myself as a man. I don’t feel like anything really, never have but now I know I do not want male puberty. I want to be soft.

I’ve always hated my body. I was teased growing up. Thought I was fat. Hated my hips. And thought T would be the answer but it has just made me wider and larger and more disconnected to my appearance. I’m not sure where I fit in. This has been really confusing.

I don’t really feel connected to they/them pronouns and am unsure if it’ll be comfortable with she/her pronouns because the past 7 years those have also made me uncomfortable. All to say is .. I’m confused.


r/ask_detransition • • 2d ago

QUESTION How did you know?

2 Upvotes

I asked this question already over in another subreddit

What is transitioning like?

Im a Transgender male of 21 years old and wish to know what it was like for others. It was suggested by my mother, who somewhat supports me, to ask about both sides of the equation. I've been trans since I was 16 and have struggled since it started. I want to have the surgeries but my mother wanted me to ask others who've transitioned and detranstioned before I do it myself. So, backstory out of the way; what was transitioning like and why did you detransition?

(Note: I made some edits from the other post to make the question more clear)


r/ask_detransition • • 2d ago

QUESTION Need advice

2 Upvotes

I am 35 AMAB but questioning my gender since long time, I felt feminine and have strong urge to transition to womanhood. But I am confused, will this really for me? Will it work? I want guidance from Detrans Males, why they regretted their transition? Why and what caused them to detransition? Were there one specific aspect that made them detransiton or mixed of things? What were motivations behind detransitioning?

I think these questions will help lot of people questioning their gender. Someone who have already went through transition and then suddenly decided to Detransition, what happened, should someone who is considering transition think about this earlier even before starting the transition.

Please approve my post and please respond. Thank you.


r/ask_detransition • • 2d ago

Demande d’accompagnement dans le cadre d’une détransition (FtMtF)

3 Upvotes

Bonjour,

Je suis une personne ayant effectué une transition de genre de femme vers homme (FtM), à la fois sur le plan administratif et médical.
Au cours de cette transition, j’ai notamment modifié mes prénoms ainsi que la mention de mon sexe à l’état civil.
Aujourd’hui, je souhaite entreprendre une démarche de retour à mon identité administrative précédente, notamment en retrouvant mes prénoms de naissance.
Par ailleurs, je souhaiterais être accompagnée dans l’arrêt de mon traitement à la testostérone, ainsi que dans un éventuel projet de reconstruction mammaire afin de retrouver une poitrine féminine.
Résidant à Montpellier, je souhaiterais savoir si vous proposez un accompagnement dans ce type de démarche, tant sur le plan administratif que médical et psychologique, et si vous pourriez m'orienter vers les professionnels adaptés.

Je vous remercie sincèrement pour votre attention et pour les informations que vous pourrez m'apporter..


r/ask_detransition • • 3d ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE Desister with partner who is newly trans

9 Upvotes

Posting here because I don’t know if I’d get honest answers from other threads and/or crucified for asking. I’m a desister. My partner of 4 years recently came out as trans. We were previously a wlw relationship. I’m supportive of my partner in their endeavors but my partner has had untreated mental health disorders before suddenly coming out as trans. They VERY quickly got on HRT soon after. We were originally going to focus on their mental health issues first but ever since this came up, they’re treating it as the fix to their issues and have since then placed treatment on the back burner. They’ve completely changed as a person. It’s like walking on eggshells around them now because everything I say or do or anything someone else says or does gets taken as an attack on them for being trans. Nearly every conversation turns into being a conversation about trans topics (which I don’t mind but the frequency of it becomes exhausting). I can’t express how I feel because, again, it gets treated as an attack or I don’t have a right to feel how I’m feeling because how they feel is worse. Some of the things they’re saying now are coming off as extreme ways of thinking they didn’t use to agree with (like children being allowed to undergo gender-altering surgeries, certain people should be unalived for having an opinion they don’t agree with, etc). When they talk about their transition, it sounds like they’re doing it to be spiteful. They’re extremely lacking in empathy now. There’s just A LOT going on. With their mental health issues, I’m not even sure how they were able to start HRT so quickly but I’m also worried it’s contributing to their mental health getting worse.

I love my partner to the moon and back. I’m not sure what I’m doing in posting this. Maybe just to vent. Maybe to have some direction. I’m supportive of my partner but I also fear for their mental stability because they seem even more unhappy now vs before they started transitioning. I miss the calm and caring person they used to be, and who they are now is constantly looking for conflict and wants people to be intimidated by them. It’s been extra hard lately and I haven’t had anyone to talk to.


r/ask_detransition • • 5d ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE questioning detransition

4 Upvotes

hi, i’m 16 (17 next month) and FTM, i’ve been out since i was 11, i’ve only socially transitioned but recently for the last few weeks ive been reconsidering if im actually trans or not, ive kinda just been ignoring it tbh.. for the last 5 years ish ive been more comfortable perceived as male, i still am, but i yearn for the woman i could’ve been , i look at some women and think “i wish i was like you”. for context im catholic and i see people veiling and i wish i could do that too but only females veil. for a while now ive been comfortable with my body, i dont bind as is because i have back problems, but even if i wasn’t to detransition i wouldn’t get top/bottom surgery because i dont mind my body. i look at certain clothes and think “i wish i could wear that, but i can’t because then i wouldnt pass”

ive not experienced my teenage years as a female, i don’t know what thats like. i feel a pit in my stomach when i get called ‘she’ but idk if thats because “well i wanna pass because rn i do identify as trans” or if because i just, don’t like being perceived as a woman.

i don’t know what to do, i don’t wanna jump into detransitioning but i don’t wanna keep ignoring it necessarily. do these feelings sound similar to anyone else who’s detransitioned, or is it just a phase every trans person goes through?

im sorry if this doesn’t make any sense


r/ask_detransition • • 5d ago

Do you think gender dysphoria should be classified as a disability?

0 Upvotes
26 votes, 2d ago
6 Yes
14 No
6 Results

r/ask_detransition • • 6d ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE Any advice to socially detransmission

4 Upvotes

Hi,

So I am 18F and has socially transitioned into a man who got really close to legally and medically transitioning and I'm just looking for any advice on how to be a girl since I socially transitioned at 9 so I don't really know how to be one if that makes sense

Thanks,

LittleStar


r/ask_detransition • • 6d ago

QUESTION Do I count as a desister?

5 Upvotes

So, I was born male and I never went on hrt or had any surgeries but I did identify as a trans at ages 16-18, in fact the only reason I didn’t go on hrt is because I saw a trans woman on YouTube say that hormones can potentially reduce your erections and ability to ejaculate, my doctors didn’t inform me about that at all (which… ain’t that a crime?)

Anyway, do I count as a desister?


r/ask_detransition • • 6d ago

QUESTION Do you think gender dysphoria should be classified as a disability?

3 Upvotes

I would argue yes since it can really limit your independence (talking from experience) but I’m curious what you guys think


r/ask_detransition • • 8d ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE Questioning

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ask_detransition • • 8d ago

For those who never really passed: Would you have still detransitioned if you had paased?

3 Upvotes

If you don’t pass as the desired gender I assume that makes your life 100x harder. Did it play a role or was it maybe the deciding factor for some of you?


r/ask_detransition • • 9d ago

ASKING FOR ADVICE I think I want to detransition (ftmtf)

12 Upvotes

Haii! If you’re reading this thank you for getting to know my story<3. I transitioned as a minor. Started t at 15 years old and got too surgery 6 months later. I don’t blame my mom nor my doctors bc I’m a emotionally intelligent person and pretty stubborn so when I belived with my whole heart that I’m a man I manipulated the story to my doctors, psychologist, psychiatrist and parents that I feel and am a guy. Now I identify as a nonbinary person and I feel comfortable where I am but also when I think of the future I see myself as a mom, sister, wife. My presentation is really feminine and people usually ask for pronouns because my voice is really deep. I stopped taking testosteron because I felt depressed while being on it. After I stopped I realized I’m much happier without it and that where I started questioning my identity. I also think of getting implants sometimes but I still live with my mom and she paid for my top surgery which makes me feel guilty for spending a lot of her money on top surgery and now for implants. Nobody knows I’m having those thoughts other than me and my boyfriend. I hope someone can see this and maybe give me some sort of advice. Sorry if I said something incorrectly, English isn’t my first language.. also getting a psychologist is out of the conversation bc my mom is ignoring my requests of getting one and I don’t have the money for it at the moment. It would mean so much if someone could help me out🙏


r/ask_detransition • • 17d ago

QUESTION Discord and other social networks

6 Upvotes

A question for anyone who has detransitioned and started identifying as trans when they were teenagers. And for the others.

How important do you think the role of social networks, especially discord, and the community of trans teenagers that is present there and with which you were in contact was in the formation of your trans identity? Did you encourage each other?

Thank you


r/ask_detransition • • 22d ago

I want to detransition but my husband doesn’t want me to. I am so confused but I can’t perform the gender anymore.

7 Upvotes

I am regretting all my choices and hating parties that made me woke and made me transition. I have come to my senses.


r/ask_detransition • • 23d ago

[DETRANS REPLIES ONLY] Help me understand (questions for trans male who later detransitioned)

11 Upvotes

I'm a parent of a 14 year old daughter who wants to be male. I've had a hard time accepting this but I try to support her with the clothes and haircut she wants. She doesn't know or can't articulate the reasons why she wants to be male. The only clue I gathered was she had said she hated the clicky popular girls at school and she likes to be different. I get that. She's very smart, get good grades, but is attracted to being male and has a 'boyfriend" who is also trans male. I'm at a lost. What were your initial reasons for wanting to be male? And what ultimately made you decide that you don't want to anymore? Do you think there's a chance she'd rethink this and want to become female again?


r/ask_detransition • • 24d ago

QUESTION If you were asked to draft guidelines to help a doctor determine which patients are likely to desist and which are likely to persist, what would your advice be?

10 Upvotes

r/ask_detransition • • 29d ago

Is there anyone out there who cares? I really need someone to hear me.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ask_detransition • • Oct 12 '26

For the FTM who is now questioning whether they did the right thing by transitioning.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ask_detransition • • Oct 11 '26

QUESTION Were there any signs you’d detransition later on?

7 Upvotes

I believe i’m a ftm, i’ve had some signs of being transgender since childhood and have the desire to transition. But there’s still the question of detransitioning. Is there any way to tell when a person is probably gonna detransition? Or did you have any signs when you were transitioning that you’d end up detransitioning?