r/ask_detransition • u/Mammoth_Disk_8095 • May 24 '23
r/ask_detransition • u/Shoddy_Magician7927 • Apr 13 '24
Why is the trans community so hostile to evidence based care?
The Cass report was published in the UK, which is a landmark review analysing the data on medical care for young people. It's an independent review with no agenda, and very supportive of trans people. Infact the entire painstaking review, which has taken years, is for the benefit of children who identify as trans and struggle with gender identity issues. The outcomes if implemented will improve care for trans people whilst safeguarding children.
Despite this, almost every single trans person and trans group online is against the report, despite most having not read it. There is a huge effort to slander the report and claim it's flawed, yet not of their objections have any scientific merit. It's almost like a religious movement or a cult. Could any detransitioners help me understand this mindset?
r/ask_detransition • u/everything_is_grace • Dec 05 '24
ASKING FOR ADVICE So Much Hate
You know when I started living as a woman back when I was 17, I got love bombed by “allies.” They said no matter what I did I was valid. That love is love, and I could be whoever I FELT I was.
Then when I turned 20 I couldn’t do it anymore. I still have dysphoria daily, but it was so exhausting. I had a break down and had to accept I’d never be a “real girl.” No matter how much hormone or makeup or silicone, I’d always be a biological man masquerading as a woman.
It was a really hard decision to transition back to being a man. Two years later I still hate my body. But I thought I’d found a little peace with it all.
But lately, I’m getting such hateful comments from the people who years ago “supported me unconditionally.” They talk about how I’m shameful. That I was never really trans. If I am really trans then “it’ll hit me harder than ever” later on. How I’ll regret detransitioning. How they wish I was dead.
I get so much hate. Does anyone else experience this? Where the people who championed your right to transition now hate you for “going back”? How do you handle it?
If I wasn’t depressed enough living as a man when I wish I was a woman, don’t they realise it makes it so much harder to find some peace?
r/ask_detransition • u/DisappearingAct-20 • Apr 30 '23
QUESTION Male privilege as adult MTF
I hesitate to identify as a TERF but I’m sure some trans women would feel differently about me. My take on it is that if you have truly soul searched, understood all the medical issues you may face in the future, and just absolutely need your body to appear a certain way for your own happiness, go for it. I’ll support you, take care of you, share clothes and makeup tips, and heckle you about fashion disasters like you were born my sister.
But if you’re not medically transitioned, I’d prefer you use private spaces for things like using the toilet and changing clothes. In particular, please don’t use communal Showers and change rooms with male genitals on display.
And please don’t claim to deeply understand the experience of being a woman. You’ll catch on to some of it as you continue through life, but you didn’t grow into it and there is so much subtlety you just will never experience. I recently had an older trans woman tell me that going on cross-sex hormones was exactly like female puberty. NO. I’m sure it was an interesting time but in no way is it the full brain and body change a girl experiences.
In analyzing that conversation I realized that the main reason the whole interaction irritated me was that I felt mansplained and dismissed, as if my own “lived experience” meant nothing. It’s a familiar feeling from dealing with groups of men in corporate settings. They think the “girl” (50-year-old woman!) couldn’t possibly know more. I also felt appropriated, very similarly to when men at work take credit for my ideas and results.
So my question is, for adult Mtf’s, are you aware of using your residual male privilege with the women in your lives? Are you even aware you have it? Do you consciously work to suppress it? If you do, how far do you take it? Do you try to socialize yourself to be “nice” and a “caregiver” and a peacemaker like many little girls are? And then do you try to assert yourself in groups of men? Thanks for understanding this isn’t coming from hate but curiosity.
r/ask_detransition • u/karmictaragem • May 13 '22
NEWS ‘I questioned why children were being encouraged to transition – and it cost me my dream career’
https://www.yahoo.com/news/questioned-why-children-were-being-135549946.html
"James Esses turned 30 this week and has been doing a lot of reflecting. Last year, he was ejected from his psychotherapist training course – three years in – for openly discussing his fears that young children expressing discomfort in their bodies were being actively encouraged to transition; weeks later, Childline removed him from his volunteer role as a counsellor on the same grounds. After racking up more than 1,000 hours at the charity over the course of five years, attending one night a week after his work as a criminal barrister, he had been alarmed by such calls becoming more frequent; the callers younger. Of his subsequent battle against both institutions, he says 'the pain and hurt is as raw as ever'."
[...]
r/ask_detransition • u/[deleted] • Apr 11 '21
Narcissism
Hello, I don't think this is a question, I have just got some thoughts because this is constantly in the news and I don't really have anyone to discuss it with.
I am what people who believe gender is a thing may call "gender non conforming" - I'm female but all that means to me is I was born with a female body. I dress neutrally, don't wear make up, short hair, no children etc. It's hard to be like this as a woman because society expects women to be a certain way. I always thought there was something wrong with me because my female friends seemed different - when we became teenagers it was all make up, low cut tops, wanting babies, putting up boy band posters etc. I didn't get any of it. But would I have felt like this if there wasn't an idea in society of what a woman is? Why can't I be a woman and not do the things a typical woman does?
I think transgenderism, non binary, they/them etc only reinforces gender stereotypes. Someone who says they feel like the opposite sex, neither or both, is giving a de facto definition of what it means to be that gender.
I really feel that this is more an obsession with labels and is frankly just pretty narcissistic. Shouldn't we really just accept that biological sex is a thing, and there are no rules for how to be a woman or a man? I think that would be far more freeing and allow for greater self expression than trying to conform to an idea of what a woman or a man is.
I don't mean to be offensive, I just think these are important points that can't ever be brought up on other social media because you cannot question gender identity without being accused of transphobia.
r/ask_detransition • u/Swimming_Ad7115 • May 04 '22
ASKING FOR ADVICE how to support my kid without going full speed ahead
my kid has come out to me as transgender. 14, afab, say they've felt this way for a couple of years. no signs of gender discomfort until middle school/puberty. spends a lot of time in trans spaces online. has a very high percentage of trans friends both online and at school. they use both he and they.
i have been supportive, and i have not questioned if it's real to them- i use their preferred name and pronouns.
is there anything i could say or do to help them in a way that isn't just- affirming? they really don't seem to struggle with self-image; i don't see signs of dysphoria. for those of you who have desisted or de-transitioned, is there anything you wish your parents said or did for you when you thought you were trans? when i developed i hated being a girl, and that will earn you the ire of the community but it's not an exaggeration on my part to say if trying on a boy's identity was an option to me right after puberty like it is now i 100% would have done it.
i am terrified of messing this up one way or the other. i don't want my kid to be trans because i'm worried about so many things but i don't want to push them away from me if it's truly our journey. i think though, that it's very much a possibility that one day they feel differently. i have joined some support groups for parents of trans kids but if you suggest anything other than immediate hrt and top surgery asap you are treated like you are actively killing your child. i think my job is to guide them in some way, or at least not sign off on life-altering medical procedures until they're older. i'm lost, and scared, and so so alone.
tl;dr if you're de-trans is there anything that you wish someone would have said or done when you started your transgender journey to help you accept yourself as you were
r/ask_detransition • u/Mr_walrus11 • Apr 10 '23
I hate how anyone who speaks up about gender ideology tends to be right wing.
This shouldn't be a political issue. I don't like how gender critical people also seem to tend to be anti-vax etc. Are the majority of people here like that or no? I feel like this should be something that all people with different walks of life should be questioning not just right wingers.
r/ask_detransition • u/Silly_Pain_2368 • May 22 '25
ASKING FOR ADVICE Worried mom of 20 year old Autistic kid who wants to start HRT.
Posted this in detrans group but it was deletedl, sorry for any repetition. The moderate suggested I try this group. Hi, I am new here and feeling desperately worried about my (adult) autistic kid. I have raised him on my own and consider us to be VERY close. This year while away at University he became friends with some trans kids including his roommate. As far as I know at a Halloween party they suggested he dress as a girl. Seemingly overnight he decided he wanted to be a woman. This is completely out of the blue, not one of his friends at home or any of our family saw this coming. He fits the classic description of an ROGD boy (I know that term is not well tolerated here so please don't come at me) I am just figuring this out day by day. He is fixated on all things trans, in a way that due to his autism he has fixated on other things in the past. I am trying to be supportive and surround him with love and not push him away but I am struggling. He is home from University now - after having failed ALL of his classes - probably because all time was spent on trans research and smoking pot - neither of which crossed his mind prior to meeting these kids at college. He has started seeing a therapist (his original Autism diagnostician), and she is affirming him without really doing any psychotherapy. She gave him some basics tests (which he would know how to answer to get what he wants) and says he has gender dysphoria and should start feminizing hormones. I am completely freaking out, I am so sure this is just a phase and I am terrified of the consequences of HRT. Why the rush to affirm without unpacking all that he has been through in life. His life is already hard enough - not easy to make friends etc. I feel these new “friends” really took advantage of him in many ways, financially, emotionally. He is not good at saying no to anyone. They even suggested that he sell nude photos of himself via GRINDR. They are not good friends – but he cannot see that. I am furious with this therapist that I trusted. The therapist and my son would like me to come to an appointment and I would like to come prepared with real scientific evidence of why rushing into this could be a mistake. Risks of HRT, real de-trans rates and the complications that go along with all of this , both medical and social. Can anyone help with without throwing hate at me?My son thinks any questioning from me means I am anti-trans. I am not. I'm a mom who has spent 20 years making sure this kid is safe and healthy. If I had thought this was his path I would have been behind him from day one, I would have helped him on this journey but I am 100% convinced this is a result of wrong place wrong time for a vulnerable kid. If this ends up being the right decision for him then I will support him but this all seems so fast. He has met and befriended many trans kids throughout his high school days and summer camps, but these new friends have more of an activist vibe. Like they are coaching him. Sorry this is so all over the place and apologies if this offends anyone . I really want to help my vulnerable kid - and am almost certain that rushing into HRT will not help him. We are in Canada where access to HRT is very easy.
r/ask_detransition • u/DetransIS • Oct 22 '20
Announcement Welcome to r/ask_detransition!
After talking with the moderators over on r/detrans we discussed that there needs to be a community where those curious and allies can interact and ask questions. We realized there wasn't a space for loved ones of those detransitioning or questioning to go as detransition itself isn't a process that is only hard on the person undergoing it but loved ones as well.
That being said, let me be clear about some things here.
This space is open to anyone to post, however topics need to be relevant to detransition.
If you are considering detransition and want an environment that is solely centered on and focused on that topic, please see our sibling subreddit: r/detrans - You are encouraged to post there if you want detrans-only input, this space will have mixed input.
This is not a space meant for instigating or harassing a group of people.
The point of this space was to allow those who are not necessarily detransitioned or experienced with transition a place to comment and ask questions regarding the controversial and sensitive topic of detransition. That being said, it is expected that rule 1 & 2 are followed strongly as this is not a space to attack anyone based on what group they belong to.
Conversion therapy or asking detransitioners to convince your child/friend/sibling to detransition is a BIG NO!
Let me stress that detransitioners do not endorse or support conversion therapy. Although the views of each detransitioner varies, asking for advice directly on changing someone who is content being trans will not be tolerated. That said, this is also not a subreddit to convince people to transition either so there will naturally be some degree of bias. However it isn't against the rules to be concerned about someone making a wrong choice as long as there's suitable evidence backing this up.
Please remember this is a detransition focused space.
Although this subreddit is open to the general public unlike r/detrans, our rules are very similar and we will actually be stricter in some regards as we do not want the same issue that happened to that subreddit in the past. Topics are to be relevant and we encourage those seeking specific help to participate in r/detrans, this sub's intention as stated before is to allow a general view and discussion into detransition.
Thank you and I hope you can follow the rules!
One last thing I guess. I will be moderating by myself at first but I will be specifically seeking those detransitioned/desisted only for moderators if people are interested in the position. I have a firm belief that detransition spaces should only be ran by those who are detransitioned themselves, although re-transitioners do have experience in a sense with detransition, it is far different and they are generally transgender.
r/ask_detransition • u/Longjumping_Yak4315 • Jun 01 '22
ASKING FOR ADVICE Am I too late?
My son is 23 years and has very high functioning non-documented Aspergers. He has never shown any signs of wanting to be a girl his entire life. No signs of crossdressing or girls interests toys games anything feminine. We always felt he was asexual he never had an interest of having a boyfriend or girlfriend but did tell us he liked girls and guys. In brief he is a musician and loves death metal music has long hair a goatee likes to wear concert t-shirts jeans etc.
Graduated college during the pandemic and hasn’t found a job yet which I know he has been depressed about. We encouraging him things will get better and he will land that job soon.
He is a big time online gamer always has been loves coding he has a software degree.
He doesn’t have any friends outside his virtual world. He’s an adult so we never questioned what sites he was on they were gaming coding sites and have heard him laughing on chat sites.
He meet a girl online and told me he loved her wanted to visit her. Of course we were skeptical and was worried about him being catfished. He also said she pursued him. After much arguing he gave us her name and we decided it would be good for him to start experiencing life he’s 23. We did find out through internet search and believe she was trans. Ok no problem we don’t care who our son loves as long as he’s happy. He gets back and says they will always be good friends.
Last week he asks me to drive him somewhere I said sure it’s to a pharmacy. He gets into the car with prescriptions. I say what’s this and he trows HRT into my lap. I said what’s going on? He said he wants to be a female. I am shocked and confused so I ask him questions when and how did you get this. He said he went online to planed parenthood and got a script. No counseling no physical nothing just sign some papers.
I said what makes you believe you are trans he said my friends online say that I am. I believe he has been coerced into this for social acceptance and I am concerned. I said people online are not doctors we need to talk about this.
We had a great conversation after some screaming on his part telling us we are transphobic and we hate trans people which is not the case at all. He said he didn’t want to tell us because a lot of his friends have been disowned by their families. I said we love you no matter who you are. He is dependent on us for everything as he doesn’t have a job or drive.
He has been on this medication since about January and doesn’t know what the side effects are or the potential permanent damage he could be doing to his body.
We asked him if he would stop using the HRT until he sought counseling and had a complete physical. He refused! He has agreed to seek professional help via psychiatry psychologist counseling and to get a physical.
I asked what don’t you like about being a man he said he hates his penis and likes how the medication gives him softer skin.
He does not dress like a women or has done anything to make himself feminine. Still wears the same clothes he doesn’t have any feminine traits or mannerisms at all. We have told him we love him unconditionally and always will and that we are concerned for his mental health and physical. I just don’t know where to start I know he needs to speak with a psychologist but how do you find one that won’t just affirm someone. I have read so many stories and I am terrified as he hasn’t had proper counseling from medical professionals. I believe he is making a huge mistake and is confused about his sexuality.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
r/ask_detransition • u/karmictaragem • Aug 11 '22
NEWS Tavistock gender clinic ‘to be sued by 1,000 families’
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/4e7fc538-18dc-11ed-b1f4-627a202c7457
The Tavistock gender clinic is facing mass legal action from youngsters who claim they were rushed into taking life-altering puberty blockers.
Lawyers expect about 1,000 families to join a medical negligence lawsuit alleging vulnerable children have been misdiagnosed and placed on a damaging medical pathway.
They are accusing the gender identity development service [GIDS] at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust of multiple failures in its duty of care.
This includes allegations it recklessly prescribed puberty blockers with harmful side effects and adopted an “unquestioning, affirmative approach” to children identifying as transgender.
Last month NHS England announced it was shutting the Tavistock clinic over safety concerns following a damning external review. Care will be handed to regional children’s hospitals.
The law firm Pogust Goodhead has since announced it is pursuing a group litigation order against the trust, which has treated 19,000 children with gender dysphoria (the feeling that one’s emotional and psychological identity differs from one’s birth sex) since 1989.
Former patients given puberty blockers are joining the “class action” lawsuit and papers are due to be lodged at the High Court within six months.
Tom Goodhead, chief executive of Pogust Goodhead, told The Times: “Children and young adolescents were rushed into treatment without the appropriate therapy and involvement of the right clinicians, meaning that they were misdiagnosed and started on a treatment pathway that was not right for them.
“These children have suffered life-changing and, in some cases, irreversible effects of the treatment they received . . . We anticipate that at least 1,000 clients will join this action.”
[...]
r/ask_detransition • u/medievalistbooknerd • Jun 08 '23
QUESTION What Does Gender Identity Even Mean?
Every Pride month, I always end up asking this question, and I never actually get an answer that makes sense.
What IS a gender identity? How does one know what one's gender identity is? How do you "discover" that you're non-binary or genderfluid or agender or these other things? How is that any different than simply being an androgynous man/woman?
Unless someone has actual gender dysphoria, like classic transsexuals, how does being trans or non-binary or whatever differ from just being a tomboy or femboy or something?
I can't help but feel like this is all super arbitrary and non-falsifiable. I don't know why so many people have accepted this as dogma that they will literally ostracize people who don't believe it and try to ruin their lives. It just doesn't make any sense to me at all.
r/ask_detransition • u/ekim171 • Dec 11 '24
How bad is gender ideology?
I'm a left-leaning person who watched shows like The Atheist Experience and The Line*,* assuming their critical thinking extended to gender ideology. For a while, I bought into it despite not fully understanding it, especially non-binary concepts.
After deeper research, I realized many see it as an ideology. Helen Joyce was eye-opening for me, though I now wonder if I take her views too seriously or if she's overly anti-trans. Discovering stories from detransitioners on channels like Andrew Gold's Heretics and this sub shocked me, affirming doctors often skip addressing the root causes of gender dysphoria. Yet, gender affirmers claim this isn't typical and denounce such practices, making me question my stance again.
For those who’ve detransitioned, did gender ideology convince you that you had dysphoria, or was it genuine?
r/ask_detransition • u/karmictaragem • Jul 29 '22
NEWS Tavistock gender clinic forced to shut over safety fears
A huge victory to counter trans ideology!
The NHS is shutting down its gender identity clinic for children after a damning review found that it failed vulnerable under-18s.
The gender identity service at Tavistock & Portman NHS Foundation Trust has been ordered to close by spring 2023.
It will be replaced by regional centres at existing children’s hospitals offering more “holistic care” with “strong links to mental health services”.
Tavistock’s Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) clinic has been accused of rushing children into life-altering treatment on puberty blockers.
The paediatrician Dr Hilary Cass, who is leading a review of the service, has today issued a series of recommendations for a radical overhaul of how the NHS treats young people who are questioning their gender identity.
She found that the Tavistock clinic was “not a safe or viable long-term option” and that other mental health issues were “overshadowed” when gender was raised by children referred to the clinic.
Cass, former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, said the current model of a sole provider for gender services should be scrapped as it failed to meet the holistic needs of distressed and vulnerable teenagers.
She said Tavistock should be replaced by regional centres with an “appropriate multi-professional workforce to enable them to provide an integrated model of care that manages the holistic needs of this population”.
Amid concerns that the clinic fails to take into account wider health problems before putting children on puberty blockers, Cass added: “Staff should maintain a broad clinical perspective in order to embed the care of children and young people with gender uncertainty within a broader child and adolescent health context.”
[...]
r/ask_detransition • u/EnvironmentalArmy813 • Mar 11 '25
ASKING FOR ADVICE Daughter is declaring herself a gay man
I know it’s ridiculous to even get your head around it, but what do you say to a natal female that is declaring that she is a gay man? She is definitely interested in boys. She’s not even a gay female (maybe bi, but that is for future her to figure out)
r/ask_detransition • u/TheTaoOfThings • Feb 23 '25
How can I talk my daughter down from a double mastectomy?
She's scheduled it for March (spring break). I can't stop worrying and crying about her future if she goes through with this. She's fine with her female anatomy (vagina), just not her breasts. I don't understand the logic behind being trans man and being ok with a vagina, but not breasts. How can I approach her to talk her down from this. Can I succeed? Is there any logic I can present her that will make any impact?
Thank you in advance for any replies (unless you're trolling).
r/ask_detransition • u/Terrifiedmama999 • Jan 05 '23
ASKING FOR ADVICE Please help a scared mom
My 15 year old kiddo has been out as nonbinary for a year, and their dad and I have been supportive of the haircut and pronoun changes and are willing to consider a binder as they have large breasts and they are really uncomfortable with that. They wore a suit to their middle school graduation.
However, this week they told me that they think they're a boy. I don't think they are, but let me explain:
They have never, before this, shown any sign of wanting to be a boy. They have always been a feminist, talking about girl power, etc.
First they came out as bi, then nonbinary, then lesbian... it feels like the goalposts are constantly moving, and things keep getting more extreme.
They've been struggling with anxiety & depression (and have been medicated for a year, as well as seeing a psychologist), with self-harm and a relatively superficial suicide attempt a month ago.
We are in the process of pursuing assessments for ADHD and ASD.
When they told me they think they're a boy, almost the next thing out of their mouth was "its ok of you need to grieve having a daughter. There are lots of supports for parents". Given the recent suicidal ideation, it feels like a way to see what my response would be to losing them.
Their mental health feels like trying to nail jello to a tree - over the past couple of years, we respond to one thing, then another pops up. For example, we've dealt with cutting, starting to restrict food, sensory issues...
Because they have developed physically faster than mentally (in terms of puberty and sex), they've felt very uncomfortable with male attention on their body and jerks who make comments when they walk by.
The spaces they frequent on the internet are all very queer-centric. We have raised our children to be allies since they were young and I'm wondering if I somehow elevated the LGBTQ+ community to have "special status" in the process - thereby making it more attractive to be part of, especially for a teenager who feels uncomfortable and wants to belong somewhere?
I'm terrified that by pursuing a social transition (they haven't requested medical - yet), that it will make their mental health worse, and we will end up with a request for HRT sooner than later.
Is there anything your parents could have done to help you before you transitioned? I'm thinking about things like: cutting off internet access, getting them to join a physical activity like kickboxing or yoga with me, more connection as a family, maybe a gender counselor? I also want to wait to see what happens with the ASD & ADHD assessment.
And I'm also terrified that I will drive them away, that we as parents will be labeled as transphobic (they throw that word around a lot as it is when making "jokes") and ultimately, that they will be successful in a suicide attempt and I won't have my precious kiddo at all any more. I desperately want them to be happy and healthy, and I fear one misstep will ruin everything. They're such an empathetic, bright and funny kid - why can't they see that?
I'm sorry if this is jumbled and I apologislze for any formatting or typing errors or if i have left anything out - it's the middle of the night and I can't sleep, and am doing this on mobile.
Edited to add: recently, the majority of the times they say they have felt gender euphoric are when they have put on makeup or lots of accessories.
r/ask_detransition • u/Pure_Yard_4206 • Jun 14 '22
ASKING FOR ADVICE How can I help my Pediatric patients?
I’m a Pediatrician, and I care for children and adolescents through the age of 21. I have had more and more of them asking for referrals or support to medically transition. I am troubled because in each case I have strongly suspected other underlying emotional issues resulting from sexual abuse, emotional abuse/trauma or unrecognized neurodiversity. I would love to have a network of gifted psychologists that I can refer them to, and that is something I will always be working on. Currently the only medical resources I can find to help patients with gender dysphoria are “gender-affirming” practices, which “counsel on expectations” and then proceed with hormone therapy. It’s almost as if, overnight, medicine has abandoned “First do no harm.” What advice do you have that can help me help my patients? What do you wish your family physician or Pediatrician had said or done to help you? I truly want to help my patients, and if I believed that medical transition would truly help my patients live a fulfilled life, I would support this. Unfortunately, that is not what my instincts tell me is needed. Adolescence is a turbulently emotional time, and medical and surgical transition both clearly have serious risks, that a typical adolescent is not developmentally prepared to anticipate. I am here to learn from you. I have already read some very helpful things. I’ve read that it’s helpful to say “it is NORMAL to feel uncomfortable/unhappy/awkward in your body as an adolescent.” What else you you wish you could have heard (or not heard) from a physician who really cared for you? What questions might help me to identify underlying wounds/disorders/traumas that could present as gender dysphoria? What questions might be helpful in identifying teens who might truly benefit from gender transition? Thank you all for using your own suffering to contribute to the healing of others.
r/ask_detransition • u/Tough_Worker621 • Dec 19 '24
ASKING FOR ADVICE Accepted??
Okay. So since I was 13 I identified as trans and genuinely believed that I was a boy and everything. At school no one even knew I was afab. At work a few people did. But only because I told them. I went to trans pride and everything and truly felt that must be the answer to my disconnection with my body. I'm 24 now and for the past month I've been living as a woman again. And I'm happy. Well not happy but you know. I've been on testosterone since I was 17 and I have a top surgery conciliation scheduled for Easter next year but I canecllled it since I realised. I don't want this. But I posted like "oh I'm thinking about detransitioning" on like the normal Ftm subreddit I used to go on a lot when I was transitioning still. But they told me I was a troll and to get out the group. I'm just feeling really conflicted about this. I am in no way transphobic. I literally was trans and I'm just feeling really confused about this matter. I have a few trans friends too. Real life people I've been friends with for years. But when I told them I was detransitioning or even thinking about the idea they said I was a traitor and that no I'm still transgender and not a woman. They were very close friends to me. People who told me id be their best man at their wedding and now I'm just blocked and removed from their lives just like that. I'm just feeling very seperate from the community that once accepted me greatly. Has anyone else experienced this?
r/ask_detransition • u/Jackie_boii • Oct 19 '23
I’m starting to detransition and I need some honest opinions about where to start
Hi, little recap on how I ended up here. I am 18, biologically female, I became trans FTM in the summer of 2021, I started testosterone on march 2022 and I did my top surgery august 27th of this year. Right after my top surgery, I felt the sensation of becoming a women again right away, and I just talked about it to people I trust this weekend.
I want to become a girl again, but I sincerely don’t know where to start to look like a girl… my family is biased for if I look feminine enough to just start wearing makeup and feminine clothing right away, or if I should wait for my testosterone to stop so my feminine features start to show more blatantly to then start looking feminine again.
Reddit people, I want to hear your honest opinions on the matter and if you can guide me in this hard route, I would be grateful!
Here’s a photo of me, no photoshop, no filter, no makeup, just a bad camera
r/ask_detransition • u/Shoddy_Magician7927 • Jan 13 '24
Why is body acceptance and gender non conformity not promoted more in the trans Reddit community?
The message seems to be "'if you're a boy who feels feminine then you might be a girl and need to take cross sex hormones to change your body to appear as a girl to be happy".
The progressive message should be "there is no right or wrong way to be a girl or boy, accept your sex and express yourself however you want".
r/ask_detransition • u/ttomttom123 • Sep 26 '23
QUESTION Why is it necessary for transgender individuals to undergo medical procedures to align with their gender identity, if gender is separate from biology?
If a child is born with a certain biological sex but later identifies with a different gender, why is it necessary to alter their biology to match their gender identity? If a trans man is inherently a man, independent of his biology, then is altering his body truly necessary for him to be recognised as a man and feel comfortable as a man? And vice versa with women? To me, this all feels like an issue with society and what it assumes a ''man'' or ''woman'' should be.
Why should breasts, vaginas, or higher-pitched voices, invalidate someone's identity as a man? Surely medical transition points more towards conforming to a particular societal expectation? My question is how necessary do you believe this truly is?
In a more accepting world, without these expectations and ''norms'', could being a trans man or trans women be any different?
I'm just wondering if you have any thoughts on this type of discussion?
r/ask_detransition • u/EnvironmentalArmy813 • Jan 24 '25
What made you change your mind about gender?
I’m a mum to a FTM identified teenager, aunt to an FTM in her early 20’s who is on testosterone, and aunt to a non-binary or whatever she chooses to be that week. All 3 kids are Autistic and ADHD, with some added diagnosis’, some official, and some self diagnosed. I’ve been doing a lot of reading and listening to podcasts. I’ve heard a lot of detransitioners and desisters say that the reason they stopped was because they thought differently about gender, but I’m not sure what this means. Can anyone please explain what this meant for you? Did you rethink the rhetoric around gender stereotypes? How did you come to that conclusion? Is there something I can do to help them get to this realisation? We’re 3-5 years into this, and we want to help them before they do any permanent damage that may damage their mental and physical health for the rest of their lives.
r/ask_detransition • u/NoLightningStruckTre • Mar 24 '24
QUESTION Thoughts on "What Is A Woman" Documentary?
Hi all! I'm a cis woman who has never experienced gender dysphoria, but I really want to understand the experience of people who have. First of all, I'm really glad that you all have this community, and the detrans thread. I've read from your posts that the outside attitude toward those who have detransitioned can be very hostile. I admire your integrity, and I thank you for your vulnerability. It's helping me understand a little more.
I'm wondering what your thoughts are on the documentary "What is a Woman?" It got a lot of flack from the trans community, and a lot of praise in other circles. What I haven't really heard, are the perspectives of people who have detransitioned. What do you think the doc gets right? Are there deficiencies? Ways it could be more sympathetic? Or did it hit the nail on the head? Were you at all able to resonate with the detransitioners featured?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts. I'm very open to dialogue! Like I said, I just want to understand