I have been watching the Foundation TV series and have been astounded by the bad science. I made it to Episode 5 but it may be my last. I loved the books and respected them because Asimov was a scientist and tried to write science fiction rather than fantasy.
The rock debris field was ridiculous, and the Empire Ship was right in the middle of it. How is a ship suppose to take off in the middle of an asteroid belt?
The temperature in space is -275C. Those silly small space suits would be completely useless at these temperatures.
The folks walk into the Empire ship, press a button and instant atmosphere and room temperature. At some point the protective guns, located on the inside of the ship for some reason, start firing at people inside. What if one of those shots punctures the hull? Hello -275C and the vacuum of deep space. Salvor is an expert on just about everything it seems and knows how the defences work. Not very well I guess because the rag tag group coasts right in and enters the ship without even setting off an alarm. Oh – and the force field around the settlement on Terminus can be bypassed if a non settler follows right behind a settler.
Isn't it strange that a rag tag group of people were able to operate an extremely complex Empire spaceship (the one that jumps around the galaxy at random) that would likely require hundreds of people with extensive technology skills to operate.
The ship taking the settlers to build the Foundation was a so-called slow ship that would take a couple of years to arrive at this planet in another solar system. At slow speed (10% of the speed of light) it would take a spaceship 44 years to reach Alpha Centauri from Earth. This show makes it feel like the galaxy is in our solar system.
Stars whizzing by like in Star Trek? Not a chance. Stars are so far apart that when the Milky Way combines with Andromeda galaxy stars will not even be close to one another.
Those silly binoculars that can see a spaceship two days away in broad daylight. Ridiculous.
How can people live on that desolate Foundation planet almost completely void of plant life?
Explain how that sophisticated Empire ship was shot down by but a rebel cannon? The Houthis have been launching missiles at US war ships in the Red Sea and haven't connected once.
The Star Bridge. Why would a civilization make a structure, load it up with 100 million people, and allow it to be destroyed by one terrorist. I can't imagine the engineers of a society like that, with faster than light speed travel, constructing an albatross.
Rach is executed on the spot without a trial. What kid of society operates like that? Harry Sheldon's trial was ridiculous. You think that an advanced society would have the emperors sitting in on something that? Couldn't we assume that there would be a multi tiered justice system with appeals etc.
The emperor is prancing around on that planet with little to no security. This guy is in charge of a vast empire with thousands of planets and decides to show up there and risk his life? Isn't that what ambassadors or Empire representatives for? Even Medieval Kings would not operate like that.
How about this silly telekinesis stuff going on between Gail and Salvor. Isaac Asimov must be rolling around in his grave. Also, they hinted that Salvor was able to understand Seldon’s math – really.
How could Gaal Dornick become a genius scientist and understand the most complex math in the galaxy without books or teachers where the people float around on rafts? And global warming was destroying the planet - people were floating around in the ocean. This is some silly attempt to highlight global warming today. I guess it isn't very windy because one storm would wipe out the entire civilization.
Sorry but the Anacreons are a silly take off on Middle Eastern terrorists using all the stereotypes. They are dark skinned, have dark hair and the language even sounds like Arabic. What were they thinking?
What exactly are the settlers on Terminus working on? The seem to be completely useless. Aren’t they supposed to be sorting out how to save the Empire from a dark age? They should have at least given an update on their progress.
What is the point of killing off the main character – Harry Seldon? Wouldn’t he be the only one who could lay the foundation for the empire’s future? What did he become after death? An apparition? A ghost in purgatory? Ghostbusters anyone? Even the Star Trek episode Spock’s Brain was more believable. Maybe he could have downloaded his mind into a computer and lived on that way - it certainly would have been more believable.
The emperor declares the Anacreons guilty of destroying the Star bridge without an investigation or trial and then kills millions on their planet. The legal system in Medieval Europe was more advanced than this. It appears that the only evidence they had was that the bomber used an Anacreon slogan before detonating. They make it look like the Empire is ruled by backward Ancient Roman dictators like Nero.
And the Empire ship that is jumping around the galaxy out of control at random. What? A sophisticated society would not have the ability to find this rogue ship? How does a spaceship shuttle around the galaxy without a crew? In addition, how can one ship destroy worlds as they claim? Kind of a Star Wars rip off of the Death Star. How could a competent empire that controls an entire galaxy let this fall into the hands of a rag tag bunch of terrorists who can’t even operate it?
The terminus settlers are forced at gun point to operate the Empire ship and without them the whole plan is dead. Just punch in the codes and voila - destroy worlds. The Terminus settlers were brilliant and all knowing I guess. At least the 9/11 terrorists learned how to fly before crashing the planes into the twin towers. Wouldn’t it make more sense to have the Anacreons or their allies infiltrate the Empire and learn how to operate their ships before trying to steal one?
You think that they could have hired some good science fiction writes to cook up this series. David Goyer makes superhero movies and video games.