r/asimov • • Jun 24 '24

How is Foundation so highly regarded? It’s the most boring book ever written

0 Upvotes

I’ve wanted to read this for a long time, considering its reputation. I just finished it, and I’m actually quite pissed off at how much I had to force myself through it. It is nothing but conversations from cover to cover, most of which are seemingly irrelevant. I cannot understand how anyone could read this and actually enjoy it.


r/asimov • • Dec 13 '21

I thought the first season of the Foundation TV series was pretty good.

13 Upvotes

I think that we can all agree that the books aren't written in a way that lends itself to a conventional kind of screen adaptation. And while some may have their own opinions about how it can be done in a way that's true to the source material, I think it's at best risky in terms of potential for commercial success. A summary of the books reads far more like a history textbook than a more typical story. And while that may be what many fans like about it, it puts a true screen adaptation at risk of looking like a documentary, and that would almost certainly be doomed to failure.

So with that said, I find the heavy-handed use of artistic license warranted. They seem to have taken the premise of Foundation and a sketch of the plot, and used it as an environment to tell their own story. Through that lens, I think they're doing a nice job.

One thing I'll say that may be controversial is that I like where the Gaal-Salvor arc seems to be headed. It's been like a decade since I read the books, but I feel like there was copious hand-waving around the evolution of the people in the second foundation. The concept of mutants with psychic powers isn't foreign to this universe, and I don't recall the introduction to the concept being particularly graceful. If the idea is that these two go on to start foundation 2, I think it will be a more elegant development than how Asimov did it.


r/asimov • • Sep 09 '25

Why isn't Asimov books just made into world classics? It's just so much better than those classic books..

23 Upvotes

I wish I knew Asimov back in high school, his books are just so good. Especially the Elijah Baley's stories, what s the name of the book, Steel Caves? That series is so much better than anything I have read. There is love, there is sci-fi, robots, AI, futurism, adventures and crime. Wow, that's such a talent man. None else can do this. I've never seen so much thing combined but still not distorted. I find Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky rather boring. Only Victor Hugo Les Miserables was fine.


r/asimov • • Nov 14 '21

To those who enjoy the Apple adaptation of Foundation

5 Upvotes

I have an idea I want to pitch to you: how about a series adaptation of Homer’s beloved classic „iliad“ but here’s the twist: the main character „achilles“ is a gender-non-conforming BIPOC that teaches SCIENCE at a bronze age university and are trying to find a solution for Fermi‘s paradox or whatever. Now the main conflict in the story consists in them fighting Incels online who insist in telling them that said paradox won’t even be formulated for another couple of thousand years.

How would you like them apples?


r/asimov • • Oct 20 '21

Who said Gaal was white

2 Upvotes

I just want to point out: some people have said that Gaal was a “white” male in the book. But I’m pretty sure the book doesn’t explicitly state this.


r/asimov • • Sep 24 '21

WARNING! DO NOT WATCH

4 Upvotes

You have been warned.


r/asimov • • Nov 13 '21

Plot holes in the Apple Foundation

0 Upvotes

r/asimov • • May 02 '24

Foundation of hypocrisy

0 Upvotes

Considering only the original trilogy, the victory of the second foundation over the first wasn't something to celebrate or feel grateful for. Starting from the fact that there are no good guys or bad guys, the 2nd foundation is responsible for millions of deaths, human sacrifices, manipulation of millions of humans, including infants (newborns), wars, among many other things.

All this of course for a good reason since for them the end justifies the means and since they have the greatest and most benevolent goal any means is more than justified.

The hypocrisy comes from the fact that they seek to govern humanity through the mind in the future because they say it will be the most prosperous, safe and reliable government ever conceived (No ruler of the past has ever said that), in short they want to help humanity. But at the same time they rob them of the ability to decide for themselves like a parent telling their child: You shouldn't and can't do this because you're stupid. And they are right, but they rob humanity of the opportunity to grow and improve on their own and if before they could improve on their own, now someone else will do it for them.

So no one is the owner of their own life, from a girl who was molded for a single purpose from the moment she was born to a historian who was forced to kill against her will.

They are no better than any government that has existed or will exist even if they think otherwise, not while they steal the will and the magic.


r/asimov • • Jan 23 '24

Bad Science

5 Upvotes

I have been watching the Foundation TV series and have been astounded by the bad science. I made it to Episode 5 but it may be my last. I loved the books and respected them because Asimov was a scientist and tried to write science fiction rather than fantasy.

The rock debris field was ridiculous, and the Empire Ship was right in the middle of it. How is a ship suppose to take off in the middle of an asteroid belt?

The temperature in space is -275C. Those silly small space suits would be completely useless at these temperatures.

The folks walk into the Empire ship, press a button and instant atmosphere and room temperature. At some point the protective guns, located on the inside of the ship for some reason, start firing at people inside. What if one of those shots punctures the hull? Hello -275C and the vacuum of deep space. Salvor is an expert on just about everything it seems and knows how the defences work. Not very well I guess because the rag tag group coasts right in and enters the ship without even setting off an alarm. Oh – and the force field around the settlement on Terminus can be bypassed if a non settler follows right behind a settler.

Isn't it strange that a rag tag group of people were able to operate an extremely complex Empire spaceship (the one that jumps around the galaxy at random) that would likely require hundreds of people with extensive technology skills to operate.

The ship taking the settlers to build the Foundation was a so-called slow ship that would take a couple of years to arrive at this planet in another solar system. At slow speed (10% of the speed of light) it would take a spaceship 44 years to reach Alpha Centauri from Earth. This show makes it feel like the galaxy is in our solar system.

Stars whizzing by like in Star Trek? Not a chance. Stars are so far apart that when the Milky Way combines with Andromeda galaxy stars will not even be close to one another.

Those silly binoculars that can see a spaceship two days away in broad daylight. Ridiculous.

How can people live on that desolate Foundation planet almost completely void of plant life?

Explain how that sophisticated Empire ship was shot down by but a rebel cannon? The Houthis have been launching missiles at US war ships in the Red Sea and haven't connected once.

The Star Bridge. Why would a civilization make a structure, load it up with 100 million people, and allow it to be destroyed by one terrorist. I can't imagine the engineers of a society like that, with faster than light speed travel, constructing an albatross.

Rach is executed on the spot without a trial. What kid of society operates like that? Harry Sheldon's trial was ridiculous. You think that an advanced society would have the emperors sitting in on something that? Couldn't we assume that there would be a multi tiered justice system with appeals etc.

The emperor is prancing around on that planet with little to no security. This guy is in charge of a vast empire with thousands of planets and decides to show up there and risk his life? Isn't that what ambassadors or Empire representatives for? Even Medieval Kings would not operate like that.

How about this silly telekinesis stuff going on between Gail and Salvor. Isaac Asimov must be rolling around in his grave. Also, they hinted that Salvor was able to understand Seldon’s math – really.

How could Gaal Dornick become a genius scientist and understand the most complex math in the galaxy without books or teachers where the people float around on rafts? And global warming was destroying the planet - people were floating around in the ocean. This is some silly attempt to highlight global warming today. I guess it isn't very windy because one storm would wipe out the entire civilization.

Sorry but the Anacreons are a silly take off on Middle Eastern terrorists using all the stereotypes. They are dark skinned, have dark hair and the language even sounds like Arabic. What were they thinking?

What exactly are the settlers on Terminus working on? The seem to be completely useless. Aren’t they supposed to be sorting out how to save the Empire from a dark age? They should have at least given an update on their progress.

What is the point of killing off the main character – Harry Seldon? Wouldn’t he be the only one who could lay the foundation for the empire’s future? What did he become after death? An apparition? A ghost in purgatory? Ghostbusters anyone? Even the Star Trek episode Spock’s Brain was more believable. Maybe he could have downloaded his mind into a computer and lived on that way - it certainly would have been more believable.

The emperor declares the Anacreons guilty of destroying the Star bridge without an investigation or trial and then kills millions on their planet. The legal system in Medieval Europe was more advanced than this. It appears that the only evidence they had was that the bomber used an Anacreon slogan before detonating. They make it look like the Empire is ruled by backward Ancient Roman dictators like Nero.

And the Empire ship that is jumping around the galaxy out of control at random. What? A sophisticated society would not have the ability to find this rogue ship? How does a spaceship shuttle around the galaxy without a crew? In addition, how can one ship destroy worlds as they claim? Kind of a Star Wars rip off of the Death Star. How could a competent empire that controls an entire galaxy let this fall into the hands of a rag tag bunch of terrorists who can’t even operate it?

The terminus settlers are forced at gun point to operate the Empire ship and without them the whole plan is dead. Just punch in the codes and voila - destroy worlds. The Terminus settlers were brilliant and all knowing I guess. At least the 9/11 terrorists learned how to fly before crashing the planes into the twin towers. Wouldn’t it make more sense to have the Anacreons or their allies infiltrate the Empire and learn how to operate their ships before trying to steal one?

You think that they could have hired some good science fiction writes to cook up this series. David Goyer makes superhero movies and video games.


r/asimov • • Aug 21 '26

Happy 75th birthday to David Asimov

6 Upvotes

David was born this day in 1951 @ 7:45 pm in Boston, Massachusetts, the first child of Isaac and his first wife Gertrude née Blugerman. He weighed 5 pounds, 4 ounces. Isaac was 31 while Gertrude was 33.

Since neither David nor his sister Robyn have children, Isaac never became a grandfather, but through his sister Marcia and brother Stanley, Isaac has myriad grand nephews and nieces


r/asimov • • Jun 19 '22

What's wrong with Foundation?

4 Upvotes

I like Asimov's short stories, the robot detective series and The End of Eternity, but I when I started reading Foundation I was really disappointed. I found it boring and frustrating. It felt like as soon as I started to get interested in the characters and what was going on, the story switched to other characters and another setting. But maybe I missed something. Should I keep reading, or is the whole series like this?


r/asimov • • Sep 24 '21

Show is junk

14 Upvotes

As i knew it would be. Why call this Foundation at all? Just make up some ‘edgy’ name and be done with it. These morons should have taken good look at new Dune, before doing anything. Nothing will be as good as books , but Villeneuve did awesome job bringing it to life. Why do these Hollywood imbeciles feel need to ‘improve’ on the work of geniuses…..

I wish Jobs was still alive. He might have not been nicest human being , but he knew his stuff. He would have never allowed this turd to see light of the day under Apple banner…


r/asimov • • Oct 16 '21

Salvor Hardin *is* the Chosen One!

0 Upvotes

Realized some days ago that Hardin is actually the only "Chosen One" character in the books, because he is the one chosen by Bor Alurin, the only psychologist on Terminus, to receive some minimal training in psychology.

It's subtler than in the show, and I think that if one really wanted to set some plot in circa 30 F.E., this training would have been an appropriate choice.


r/asimov • • Mar 04 '22

TV show rant Nº4278: I do mind the gender swap

19 Upvotes

I thought this was the best sub for it, partly because it's the most active and the op is mainly about the book characters.

Between all the decisions Apple made, the gender swap is the least criticized. Many people (myself included) start their opinion with "I didn't mind the gender swap, but the rest...". Well, I don't mind it too much between all the shitshow of cuestionable decisions that the TV series is, but I do mind it. It's a crucial part of the character and how they interact with other characters and their world.

An example would be the final scene of Foundation and Empire (spoiler ahead, I know spoilers are allowed, but still) when the Mule implies he would have had descendency with Bayta if he wasn't sterile. Change the gender of one or both characters, and you have to change a whole part of the narrative to suit that moment.

And if it is about creating memorable female characters, I would not want by any means Bayta to be a man. I know early Foundation novels were primarly dudes smoking and talking, but even that is a nice contrast to later Asimov literature, when he introduced more female characters therefore he created a more recognoscible fiction for modern day standards.

And even those scenes, heck, the whole Foundation saga can serve to any political message you want because it's so diverse. Man vulnerabilities? Enciclopedists stagnation and Traders depotism. Female heroism? Arkady. Female superior intellectualism and will? Bayta. Loyalty and sense of duty? Dors. Absolute good will? Bliss. It even has hermaphrodite characters.


r/asimov • • Oct 21 '24

Are there any Asimov stories that aren’t optimistic? His stories are amazing, but even today, we seem to be living in a more dystopian reality compared to the worlds Asimov envisioned. I expect the future to get even darker. I think his only flaw is that optimism

0 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Nov 04 '21

The TV show at its strongest is better than the Foundation books at their weakest.

13 Upvotes

The Terminus plotline is a genericized mediocrity. Their only adaptation of the original Foundation stories is by far the weakest one. We’ve all seen this before.

But the story of Cleon and the gardener in this show is far better than the story in Forward the Foundation IMO. And Gaal and Hari’s revelation of her mentalic powers is better than the reveal of Wanda Seldon’s, with the whole “lemonade death” episode. To be fair though, that story does feature the only time in the Asimov canon that a robot directly and physically kills a human being in violation of the First Law of Robotics.

Forward the Foundation is not the strongest Foundation novel IMO, and although the show’s adaptation of “The Mayors”, which features no Mayors, is one of the worst adaptations I’ve ever seen, the other parts actually improve on Forward the Foundation in some respects. I’m happy they exist for that!


r/asimov • • Apr 04 '25

That moment when you mention Asimov, and someone says, Oh, like iRobot?

7 Upvotes

Look, I get it. You watched Will Smith fight some robots once, and now you think you’re in the club. But while you’re picturing shiny CGI androids, I’m out here juggling psychohistory, the Three Laws, and debating whether Hari Seldon would’ve owned a cat. Read a book, Steve. Preferably 27 of them.


r/asimov • • Apr 06 '24

ChatGPT seems to think Hober Mallow was introduced in the Trader’s arc, it did it repeatedly….

0 Upvotes

I know that it’s not 100% accurate but am I missing something. When I asked further, it says it’s answered are based off the “original” Foundation novel, is that even a thing?


r/asimov • • Jun 22 '19

Foundation version 1.0 is about to beta test.

1 Upvotes

Greetings, I am not Hari Seldon, but I am a self taught game theorist akin to John Nash Jnr as portrayed in A Beautiful Mind. Hete my first post is to simply advise @space_cross is first test of a psychistorian hypothesis. I hypothesis : Social engineering without the destruction of extant cultures is possible. Your thoughts and critical assessment requested. Sincerity Mark P Gilmour.


r/asimov • • Mar 13 '25

The Fun They Had, not a good first impression of Asimov.

0 Upvotes

It was the first chapter of my English book. The teachers were speaking very highly of him even noting down fun facts about him, its the first time I've ever seen a teacher praise an author this much. So I read the story and it sucked. Really bad.

In the first sentence of the story, Margie writes in her diary that Tommy found a real book. This is already a problem because the only types of books the children read are 'telebooks' which are books on the television screen (who reads books on the TV in the first place?) and how could she write on the television?

Next, Tommy says that when people are done with a book they throw it away. No? We store them or share them and even re-read them. Nobody throws a book away once they are done with it.

The year is 2157, yet the curriculum is still 300 years old? (History, geography, maths)
And we get a sneak-peek of how the mechanical teacher (which they repeat so many times like it's a robot human) teaches. Spoiler- its just a video.

The writing is also really awkward at times and bland. I hope some of his other works are better.


r/asimov • • Jun 08 '26

Happy pride month! (The Gods Themselves)

8 Upvotes

Was Asimov an ally? Did he create the aliens with LGBTQ+ support in mind? He created a tri-sexual (polyamous?) group. The maternal Right was described as "he", the rationalist Left, also described as a "he" and the emotional Middle as a "she".

Or was it just a byproduct of the alien race he created?


r/asimov • • Oct 26 '21

I don't understand all the criticism of Salvor in the TV show

12 Upvotes

OK, so today I happened to finally start re-reading the first Foundation book. I had intended to do it all the way back before the series premiered, but, well, life.

Anyway, I'm only about 40% through the book, but several things jumped out at me.

  1. During the first meeting with the the board, Salvor explicitly advocates for using guns and not just words to defend Terminus.

  2. Skip ahead to 'The Mayors', and Salvors friend reminds him when the 'last refuge' quote is brought up, that Salvor used to be quite violent when he was younger.

  3. Goyer in the AMA specifically said that this Salvor we see on screen is about 20 years prior to the first instance of Salvor we see in the books.

Given all that, I'm finding it really hard to understand the repeated complaints, and I'd say Salvor is one of the most repeated complaints about the adaptation.

Time skips with the Salvor character are in the book, specifically one skip of about 30 years, so that's entirely precedented. So starting Salvor's story 20 years prior to when we first meet him in the books shouldn't matter.

Salvor specifically advocated using guns to defend Terminus, and was known to be violent when he was younger, so again, this seems perfectly in line with the books.

I'm not talking about the changes to Terminus, the plot, how it looks, the changes to Anacreon, none of that.

I'm talking purely about Salvor as a character being adapted and using guns, and that honestly seems absolutely fine to me and in line with the books.


r/asimov • • Sep 26 '21

Where do we go from here ?

0 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Nov 13 '21

The one time TV critics got it right.

Thumbnail
appleinsider.com
0 Upvotes