r/asimov • • Nov 17 '23

I found this vinyl audio book at a thrift store today.

Post image
844 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Jun 23 '20

Want to read the Foundation books? Don't know what books to read? Don't know what order to read them? Confused? Don't be! Read this.

514 Upvotes

In this subreddit's wiki, we have five guides to reading Isaac Asimov's Robots / Empire / Foundation books:

  • In publication order.

  • In Asimov's suggested order.

  • In chronological order.

  • In a developmental order.

  • In a "machete" order.

You can find all you need in this wiki page: https://www.reddit.com/r/Asimov/wiki/seriesguide

Enjoy!


r/asimov • • Jan 22 '25

John Ridley Developing ‘Caves Of Steel’ Film Based On Isaac Asimov Sci-Fi Novel For 20th Century Studios

Thumbnail
deadline.com
500 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Dec 23 '23

Decided to read Foundation books 1-7 to prepare for the Foundation TV show, I regret it heavily

405 Upvotes

*Update: To anyone coming to this post in the future (Hari predicted it), I regret it because I wish I watched the show first, then read the books. As so, you wouldn't be disappointed by how far the show strayed from the books, and get to appreciate the better source material (the books) after.

I understood that the TV Show is fundamentally very different from the books, yet I heard people enjoying it so I decided to try it too. I could not get past even 2 episodes, Gaal Dornick is just so hard to watch as a main character. I understand now that it's almost nothing like the books, and I don't want to use the W-word but it really feels like it here. Not as much as Rings of Power, but gone are the wits of politics and mental planning.

Am I wrong here and should I give the show another chance?


r/asimov • • Oct 10 '21

Say what you want, but the TV series is not Foundation

359 Upvotes

You can like the series. If this kind of sci-fi is what you're into, and you genuinely enjoy it, then great! By all means, keep watching, whatever.

But the show called Foundation is not Foundation. I'm not talking about my opinions on the characters or the CGI or even the gender swaps. I'm making the objectively true claim that the series does not follow the storyline of the Foundation books. It doesn't come close to following the storyline of the Foundation books. It's a completely different story with similar names for some of the characters and plot devices.

And that's fine. But it's not Foundation. I don't care if you like it too, or if you somehow like it more. I'm just asking that you have a little bit of respect for the books that Asimov wrote and the generations of readers who enjoyed them, and admit that what's on the television is not the Foundation.


r/asimov • • Dec 16 '23

Is Asimov a hero to any of the other people here?

350 Upvotes

The man was very intelligent, educated, worked hard, answered questions for curious people, read and wrote a lot, and from what I can tell was pretty humorous. He did have something of an ego, to put it mildly, but at least he was open and honest about it, which is more than a lot of people can say.

I read I. Asimov in high school, thoroughly enjoyed it, and since then the Good Doctor has been someone I greatly admire, along with Carl Sagan and Stephen Jay Gould .

As an aside, I once made a post here asking about Asimov's stance on overpopulation, in which thread some people thought I was implying he was a fascist. The misunderstanding is completely understandable, but it hurt me a little to have people think that I was speaking ill of and slandering Dr. A.

Personally I feel that hero worship and parasocial relationships are a little weird, but Asimov is just one of those people that I greatly admire.


r/asimov • • Jan 05 '24

Google wrote a “Robot Constitution” based on Asimov's 3 Laws of Robotics

346 Upvotes

Google is using the 3 Laws of Robotics to write a Robot Constitution... This would have made the likes of Dr. Susan Calvin very proud!

Also thought this was rather well timed to be close to Asimov's birthday.

Google’s DeepMind ‘Robot Constitution’ will make sure its AI droids won’t kill you - The Verge


r/asimov • • Sep 13 '19

The neverending story

Post image
334 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Aug 24 '23

The foundation show doesn't understand the point of the books

279 Upvotes

I've read a lot of books, and seen a lot of shows and movies based on books. Many of these are not loyal adaptations, with the adaptation making many changes, some good and some bad. However, I don't think I've seen a single one where it so completely feels like the show was written by someone who didn't understand the point of the books and doesn't know why anyone would like them. From this point on, spoilers for all currently released episodes and the main foundation trilogy.

Psychohistory is not just an element of the books, it and its implications are the central point of the trilogy. It is presented consistently as a set of mathematics about how large populations will act. In the show, psychohistory is a magic box that tells the characters exactly what to do to advance the plot. The prime radiant is treated more like a magic item would be in a fantasy show, something with mysterious properties that would be impossible to replicate even by Hari. It will tell them something like "go to Ignis", even without the characters understanding why this is or what it will do. It also constantly predicts the actions of individuals, even though Hari keeps saying its not possible for it to do this (for example, in season 1, Hari thought the foundation would be in trouble because the wrong person was mayor).

Another major example is the mule. The mule is an interesting part of the story not because of his mentallic abilities but because of what he represents: something unforeseen by the plan. No matter what his abilities had been, he would have fulfilled the same role in the story as long as they made him powerful enough to threaten the foundation as an individual, so he could disrupt the plan. The moment when we learn he wasn't predicted a hugely impactful moment, where you suddenly realize that after a book and a half of the foundation surviving every crises exactly as Hari predicted, they suddenly could lose, the plan would no longer protect them. The foreshadows the mule a season early through a psychic vision, and now has the characters preparing for him a season early. He's not presented as any bigger of a threat than the anacreons last season.

The way the foundation's religion is treated in the current season is also strange. In the books, it wasn't believed by the foundation and was treated as a tool to control other planets and expand the foundation's influence. It seems to be a point about how religion can be used as a tool for control over populations, similar to something like the missionara protectiva in dune. In the show, the religion is being used for a similar purpose, but the foundation characters seem to be true believers (I think, they're attitude seems to change from episode to episode at random), which seems to fully negate the point. Now, they just seem like average missionaries: simply spreading their religion.

My main problem isn't that the show isn't loyal to the books, or that much of the acting and writing are bad, it's that the elements it does include from the book are mostly just there stripped of their context or purpose in the book. It feels like they weren't trying to write a foundation adaptation, they were trying to simply make their own show with a quota of 2 elements borrowed from foundation per episode. This is how you get things like "spacers", which simply borrows an unrelated term from the Asimov universe, rather than invent a term, or the famous quote "violence is the last refuge of the incompetent", which in the books is a great summary of the foundation's ideals but in the show is something that Salvor just dismisses as stupid, and the show seems to agree with her.


r/asimov • • Apr 15 '22

Illustrations of the Foundation Trilogy (From the illustrated Spanish edition recently published).

Thumbnail
artstation.com
261 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Jan 11 '20

Found the complete Chris Foss cover art for the Foundation Trilogy 2nd Hand

Post image
257 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Oct 02 '21

Salvor Hardin in Name Only

252 Upvotes

I'm baffled by the changes made to the character of Salvor Hardin. Remember that famous Hardin quote? "Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent." In the show, Hardin seems ready to go in, guns blazing ready to fight the Anacreons. Where is the brilliant diplomat Salvor Hardin?

I really think it has almost nothing to do with the show runners making Hardin a woman (though it is a bit of a jarring change that took me out of the story). And I don't recall Hardin's race being explicitly stated either. But they totally missed who the character is.

My impression of Hardin is that he was a natural born leader, charismatic, able to hone in on other characters's motives and predict their actions. He was cunning, always a couple moves ahead. An expert politician. He saw the opportunity and seized the reigns of Foundation to steer it in the direction he knew it needed to go.

In the show, Hardin is an outsider, a loner who feels she doesn't fit in. And there are undertones of her being the "chosen one," which feels antithetical to the essence of psychohistory since psychohistory does not make predictions about individuals.

I'm sorry. I'm ranting. I just had to get this off my chest as it has been bothering me since watching Episode 3 last night.

Some of the changes and additions to the show are great—namely the cloned dynasty of emperors. It's just crazy that they missed the fundamentals and the character we arguably spend the most time with in the original book.


r/asimov • • Jun 01 '19

They are still relevant

Post image
243 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Oct 23 '21

Apple version of Foundation is shit !

241 Upvotes

I just watched the 2 first episodes of the Apple version of Foundation and I'm amazed about how shitty it is. Did the producers actually read the novels or did they just stopped at the title. If this adaptation of Foundation would have been made based on Lord of The Rings, the ring would have been a neckless because why not, the elves would have been goblins because it's scarier, and Bilbo would have been a girl because they never read the book "Bilbo the Hobbit". Seriously, where did "violence is the last refuge of the incompetent" went !!


r/asimov • • Dec 27 '19

my The Last Question tattoo

Post image
232 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Oct 25 '21

Reasons why the Apple TV Foundation show sucks so bad

223 Upvotes

I think the primary reason why the show sucks so much is perhaps not the bad writing per se, of which there is plenty, but maybe the unfortunate choice of Goyer and his crew as show runner and writers in the first place, After all, his thing is Batman and Blade movies! Not the best choice of sensibilities and genre styles for bringing Foundation, a masterpiece of speculative fiction, to the screen (little or big).


r/asimov • • Mar 18 '23

Made this R. Daneel Olivaw fanart yesterday

215 Upvotes

I read The Robots of Dawn ages ago and loved it, but only recently started to read the rest of the robots series, and then when I was done I watched the Apple TV Foundation series, and of course had to start reading the Foundation series as books. I'm waiting for Foundation to arrive at my local library (but I read Prelude and Forward) to continue reading so I thought I'd draw R. Daneel Olivaw in a godly fashion.


r/asimov • • Apr 06 '22

Isaac Asimov died on this day, 30 years ago: 6th April 1992

208 Upvotes

Isaac Asimov died on this day, 30 years ago: 6th April 1992.

Obituaries of the time such as these ones in the New York Times and the Washington Post listed the cause of his death as heart and kidney failure, because that’s what they were told by his family. A decade after Isaac’s death, his wife Janet revealed that he died of AIDS as a result of an HIV infection received during a blood transfusion a decade prior. The secrecy about Asimov’s cause of death was recommended by his doctors who were driven by a fear of scandal; at the time, AIDS was seen as a gay men’s disease.

Asimov left behind an astounding collection of works: hundreds of books written by him, and hundreds more books edited by him. One catologuer has calculated that, considering only those books for which Asimov was mostly or entirely responsible, excluding anthologies and collaborations, and including only books in which he produced more than half the text, Asimov wrote 316 books. (PDF link) Using the most unrestrictive selection criteria, including any book that Asimov wrote any part of (such as introductions and forewords), the number expands to 583 books. Whichever set of criteria we use, the output is prodigious for a single author.


r/asimov • • Sep 11 '19

Another Foundation Meme

Post image
208 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Jun 16 '26

The Feeling of Power" (1958) hits differently in 2026. Asimov predicted our relationship with AI more accurately than almost anyone

204 Upvotes

I've been reading Asimov since the 1980s, grew up in Italy and still have some of my first Italian edition paperbacks.

Recently re-read "The Feeling of Power" and it genuinely stopped me cold.

For those who haven't read it: the premise is a future where humanity has become so dependent on computers for calculation that nobody remembers how to do arithmetic manually. A technician named Myron Aub rediscovers basic mathematics and it's treated as a revolutionary, almost mystical discovery. The military immediately sees its potential as a weapon... :(

In 1958, Asimov was writing about cognitives outsourcing, the idea that delegating mental tasks to machines would eventually mean we lose the ability to perform those tasks ourselves. He was describing exactly what we're living through now with AI writing, AI coding, AI thinking.

The most chilling line for me is when a general explains that human computers are superior to machines for warfare because "humans are expendable." The efficiency of automation applied to human lives.

I'm 60 years old. I watched computing go from room-sized machines to pocket devices. But nothing prepared me for re-reading this story in 2026 and realising Asimov wasn't writing science fiction... he was writing a warning, for us, today.

Which Asimov story do you think has aged most uncomfortably well?


r/asimov • • Sep 27 '21

Disappointed with all the racism.

195 Upvotes

There is just no way to get around the fact that parts of this sub are fixated on the race "changes" in the Foundation show in a way that can only be explained through racism. The characters in the books are not described as having particular races and the mere assumption that all of these characters are white is outright racist. Even if every character was explicitly written as white it would add nothing to the story and "changing" the character's race, while it does nothing on it's own, is also not offensive in any way or disruptive to the story being told.

The same is true for the gender swaps. Most characters in the Foundation trilogy are essentially walking cameras or exposition transcripts. Gender as a concept is basically absent from the story and to its detriment, and the addition of more women, different bodies (robots, gravity-affected, maybe more) and romance and sex are welcome inclusions to the story that add dimensions to Asimov's ideas.

If you want to say you don't like the writing or the acting or the as of yet minor changes to the plot that the show has taken on so far then we can talk. I think you're wrong, and that the show is actually a good, verging on great adaptation so far but we can at least talk. The racism is idiotic and makes me think that Asimov fans somehow missed most of the history and science fiction that has happened since the 1950s or disturbingly want to go back. As for the dogwhistlers going on about "inserting politics" into the story about A COLLAPSING EMPIRE maybe go find some coloring books to keep yourselves occupied.


r/asimov • • Oct 15 '21

Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent.

194 Upvotes

Just watched episode 5, and yes I am saying the writing team and show runners are incompetent.


r/asimov • • Jan 03 '20

My Asimov hardcovers. Happy Centennial, Isaac!

Post image
192 Upvotes

r/asimov • • Oct 09 '21

Dear angry Asimov fans, if you didn't want Gaal Dornick to be a lady,

182 Upvotes

he should have been called Guy Dornick.

Checkmate, sexists.