Note: Please don't PM me asking me to look up your information.
I've gotten quite a few PMs asking about the types of information leaked. Although there are a lot of articles out there with analysis already, I wanted to put up my thoughts on what you should and should not be concerned with.
Yes, the data contains all of your member profile information, including email address, preferences, signup IP address, DOB, gender, etc. This is covered elsewhere. For the most part, the most revealing bits of information included in the database dumps are your email, location and date of birth. There is also the issue of the "security question" which I will touch upon later.
Along with the leak, credit card transaction logs were provided. These logs contain, among other things, the following information: Credit Card Type, Last 4 of Card, Full Billing Address, and sometimes Email. Along with the transaction is an identifier of the associated profile. There are no full credit card numbers and there are very, very few phone numbers in the system, most of which are fake/placeholders due to manual transactions and gift card (really?!) purchases.
So the main way in which a particular email address/profile can be associated with a real person is by matching up the profile ID and/or email address with a credit card transaction. It is also possible for someone to start with a particular street address and resolve it to a member. (e.g. I did a search for my own zip code and discovered I have several dozen neighbors that are paid members.)
As I've mentioned before, my personal intent here is not to help expose cheaters or relationship issues - my only goal is to help people understand what information got leaked and how it can be used. Sadly, data leaks are common and quickly forgotten - I mean, beyond the initial week or two of excitement, when was the last time you heard about The Fappening (celebrity nude leak)? Yes, you may have a relationship issue to be worked out, and you may need to be concerned with identity theft based upon these facts:
It is possible to build a profile about you, including Full Name, Address, DOB and Email.
Some users have also included a Security Question/Answer with information that they may have used on other sites.
Therefore, it might be possible to call up financial institutions and given the information above, access your accounts. Before you freak out though - let's think about this. Of all of the information I listed above, how much of it is personal/unknown/not available through public sources? The main danger lies in that an attacker has DOB and Last Four of Credit Card, both of which may be used to verify identity. Check with your financial institution to see how far they let a caller get.
Moving past identity theft, the other concern is basically getting exposed as a cheater or former cheater. If this is your primary concern, then yes, be concerned, because there are tools out there that allow for a quick email search. There is absolutely nothing you can do about it now, so have whatever conversation(s) you need to have.
In my opinion, other than some slight embarrassment and tough conversations, there is little to no risk to most users in developed countries. Countries that have, for example, the death penalty for being gay, are another story and outside of the scope of this opinion. (Note: This is also why I am personally refusing to divulge personal information - I cannot be sure that your intentions are good.)
The real problem today is that organizations do not do enough to protect your information. Just a couple of weeks ago I had to report to my local YMCA that their web server was exposing FULL credit card details (including CVV) to the world. I'm still waiting for the letter/news article/etc that they are legally obligated to publish.
tldr: If you're in a modern country, don't be too concerned. This is going to blow over pretty quickly once the last of the data is released. If you're a cheater and that's your concern, have your conversations now and own it. If you paid via Credit Card in the past, there's a high chance that your profile can be tied to you even with fake profile data. If you never paid or paid via PayPal, the chance of tying it to you depends on the accuracy of your profile information (email, DOB, location).
The Ashley Madison $19 delete feature seems to have been implemented, but poorly executed. If you paid via CC for your profile to be deleted, your profile was likely scrubbed from the member database but records of the transaction (including name, billing address, etc) are still in the credit card logs.
I don't want to get in to a rant how Ashley Madison has acted stupidly (by badly implementing their "delete" option) and IS acting stupidly (by abusing the DMCA to get information taken down), but we really need to work on forcing companies to be significantly more responsible with their data. Morality aside, Ashley Madison made some technical mistakes that I've seen in MANY other companies, and they should be judged more in how they handle it than by the mistake itself.
Questions I received via PM that deserve a public response:
Q: I downloaded the data torrent and am trying to read the files. I don't know what to do with them.
A: If you are not familiar with using databases, your ability to work with this data is limited. The credit card log files are daily logs that you can open in Excel. The dump files are basically database backup files (SQL) that require you to import and run queries against. You should not expect to just open these files and start looking through them. It takes almost a day to import these files and make use of them - beyond the abilities of the average user. I'm sorry but I don't have time to help you with this.
Q: Can you confirm that if someone knows my username, they easily have access to my email address (and potentially other personal information)?
A: Yes, there is a table of usernames which then ties to email addresses. If your email address contains your full name (or googling for that email address exposes you), then your privacy is at risk.
Q: I paid via (some method). Is my full name and address exposed now?
A: See this answer.
Edit at 8:49PM CT - Removed my analysis of GPS data as it was flawed.