This was co-written by Jonathan Ichikawa and myself. Most of it him. Some of it me. But I'm a coward, so this is a throwaway and I'm not giving my name. None the less...
Here is a sadly familiar story: a teenage girl sneaks out of her parentsâ house, goes to a party, and gets drunk. A man rapes her. Here is another sadly familiar story: a black man in the wrong neighbourhood shouts angrily at a police officer, who kills him. While this isnât yet settled ground in the culture at large, I suspect that most reading here will agree that victim-blaming in cases like these is both morally repugnant and practically dangerous. It is morally repugnant because it undermines those who need empathy and protection, literally adding insult to injury; it is practically dangerous because it turns attention away from the perpetrators and the systems that give rise to them.
Victim-blaming comes in stronger and weaker formsâthe stronger straightforwardly asserts that the victim is responsible for the harm undergone; we also recognize a weaker form of âvictim-blamingâ where one focuses inappropriately on the victimâs actual or perceived wrongdoings: she shouldnât have drunk so much; he should have been more deferential to the police officer. Whether or not these criticisms are true, they are highly inappropriate under the circumstances. Yes, it plausibly was wrong of the teenage girl to sneak out of her parentsâ house and get drunk, but to focus on this fact under these circumstances is a significant moral mistake. Such criticisms suggest, even if they donât assert, that it is the victimâs pragmatic or moral error, rather than harmful acts by another, that led him or her to sufferâand that is why this too is a kind of victim-blaming.
The less one empathizes with the victim and his or her situation, the easier it is to victim-blame. Misogynists are more likely than others to emphasize a rape victimâs clothing choices; racists are more likely than others to emphasize a murdered black manâs criminal history. In the same way, I think, a deep-seated sexual puritanism has contributed to a problematic tendency to emphasize immoral behaviour of the victims of the Ashley Madison hack.
In case it needs sayingâI hope it doesnâtâin the vast majority of cases, I do not think that the harm the Ashley Madison victims are suffering is equivalent to rape or murder; nor are Ashley Madison users systematically oppressed in the way women and black people are. But victim-blaming is problematic, even for lesser and more episodic harms. (Prudish scolding of the victims of last yearâs photo hackââdonât send nude photos if you donât want them publishedââwas also victim-blaming.) And the harm done to many of the current victims is by no means trivial. Families are being broken up. People will lose jobs. Itâs not at all hard to imagine that lives will be lost. For many, it is all too easy to trivialize these harms and blame the victims: âI have no sympathy for cheaters,â or âthe real victims are the spouses.â
While there are individual cases deserving of little sympathyâone name in particular comes conspicuously to mindâI think itâs a mistake to have this reaction in general, for many reasons. One is that many of the 33 million users whose privacy has been violated werenât cheaters: they signed up, had a look around, and left and forgot about it; or they were just there for the thrill of thinking about the possibilities, with no intentions of any physical connection. Some were in ethical open relationships; some were closeted LGBTQ people who needed discretion. And even when weâre talking about the actual adulterers, itâs a serious lack of empathy broadly to vilify them or consider them unworthy of privacy protections. People cheat for many reasons, some of them very understandable.
Ever wonder why someone might cheat? Ever think maybe they're gathering strength in any way they can, in order to work up to leaving their abusive spouse? In all too many cases, the abuser controls finances, transportation, and face-to-face interactions with family and friends. Meeting someone who shows affection, positive encouragement, sexual freedom and the like, even in the form of an affair, can sometimes be the only way to help a person find themselves and prove to themselves that they have value and can live a life independent of their abuser. It also begins the states of emotional disconnect as well as giving the courage to ask for a divorce. Surviving intimate relationship abuse is hard, to say the absolute least; how anyone could add insult to often literal injury by adding judgment of how a survivor made it away from their abuser... I cannot even fathom the heartlessness.
Maybe you don't agree.
Even in cases of unequivocal wrongdoing by Ashley Madison customers, violating their privacy is another harm, and not one to be celebrated. Celebrating harming people?? We shouldnât let a reflexive moral disapproval overly influence our perception of what has occurred. Use of the passive voice is a clue: one focuses on the victimâs actions in saying that a woman drank too much and was raped; the more important âmore sympathetic and more accurate â description is that a predator raped her. In the same way, do not forget that there is a harmful actor in this case: itâs not that 33 million people joined a website for cheaters and were doxxed; a group called Impact Team hacked into a dating site and published the private information of 33 million people. No one has "deserved" to lose their job. No one has "deserved" to lose their life. No one has "deserved" to have their privacy violated. Those 33 million people are the victims of a harmful criminal violation, and focusing on their "wrongdoing" in this story is victim-blaming.
Let the downvotes begin.