r/armchairphilosophy • • Oct 23 '12

Anything worth knowing is in a book

25 Upvotes

So, to kick things off, I figure I'd throw this nugget out there.

Late one night, I was having a pow-wow with a friend of mine over some smokes and a beer or two. She made the statement to me that "anything worth knowing is in a book".

I think the literal idea she was going after was for me to read more; but I digress.

I have a few ways to interpret this, away from the literal.

The first, and most troubling, is that there are no original ideas worth knowing. If anything worth knowing is in a book, that means someone else thought it and wrote on it. My thoughts at the present could then, at best, be largely (or minutely) influenced by these, but are wholly not original.

I suppose that's not a huge deal, but everything I will ever think being a subset or re-grouping of others thoughts... totally detracts from my idea of individualism. It really put me in a rut for a few hours one night.

The other facet (that brought me out of the rut) was that, OK... anything worth knowing is in a book... what if I write a book? Is that then qualitative of something worth knowing? It was worth me taking the effort to develop and write... surely, if not even original, it is worth knowing?

But then, where I am now, in modern technology, with abstract ideas of communication and text (blogs, twitter, facebook, .. reddit), what constitutes knowledge worth knowing? Surely books are not intrinsically higher than a blog, or a twitter feed. They're all forms of written language... so what distinguishes a profound twitter quip from a lengthy but ultimately meaningless blog post?


r/armchairphilosophy • • Jan 21 '21

I'm pretty sure I now oppose "terraforming" of extraterrestrial planets and moons.

19 Upvotes

I would have posted this in r/philosophyself but the submissions there are restricted now, for some reason. I'm changing my mind from a previous post in which my opinion supported terraforming as a valuable scientific activity. My reasoning is basically that we should prevent suffering.

Brian Tomasik compares space colonization to the fictional place called Omelas, and this analogy supports the position that we should try to prevent suffering more than we should try to increase happiness. In general I have read some about suffering-focused ethics and my ethical views have become at least somewhat more suffering-focused since I wrote this.

I suppose it's okay to conduct some forms of "space exploration" in the name of science in our solar system, but I believe we should not bring too much sentience into existence. Sentient beings include humans, many animals, and, in the future (maybe), sentient AI (sentient AI for example, includes sufficiently detailed simulations of humans). Certain types of space exploration may be immoral: terraforming would likely bring animals into existence, some applications of AI might cause suffering in space, and it's immoral to harm astronauts for no reason. On the other, I could imagine situations where it would be justified to mine from asteroids, for example.

If humans start to try to terraform a planet like Mars, humans might or might not actually stay on Mars. Humans might abandon the project for various reasons, but (if the concept of "terraforming" is doable in the first place) life would go on unregulated on Mars. The animals on Mars would likely suffer a lot, considering those animals evolved on Earth and may be ill-adapted to Mars even after the environment is modified. I'm not sure how I feel about trying to use non-sentient organisms like plants in the process of space exploration. If plants and stuff can thrive on whichever planet we try to grow them on, then it's theoretically possible that the plants (and all the bacteria and microorganisms that probably come with the plants) will evolve into something sentient--at least, such as evolution is more likely than abiogenesis occurring on the planet if we humans do not introduce life.

I think we should focus on making life better (or less bad) on Earth instead of terraforming other planets. I do realize that space exploration has led to the invention of many technologies that improve peoples lives though (I mentioned this in my previous pro-terraforming post). And by making live better on Earth, I do not necessarily mean nature conservation. I think climate change is bad and we should stop using fossil fuels, and I think that humanity is not currently capable of responsible large-scale intervention in nature, but I do not consider the ecological status quo to be intrinsically valuable. Basically I think that someday humanity will intentionally interfere in nature for the purpose of reducing animal suffering. Civilization currently depends heavily on ecological services though.

Perhaps the danger of terraforming is one of the reasons negative utilitarians should support environmentalism--I could imagine some future humans evacuating a polluted and overpopulated Earth, bringing sentient animals (and other life forms) to Mars. At least I think it's clear that utilitarians should oppose climate change.

One the arguments in favor of terraforming which I made was that I want humanity to "learn how to engineer an ecosystem". I think humanity can "learn how to engineer an ecosystem" on Earth--maybe in some sort of desert or in smaller-scale isolated experiments.

When I wrote the other post, I was distracted by the "ecocentrist" objections to terraforming. I wrote that other post soon after I wrote this, in which tried to criticize some parts of ecocentrism and deep ecology but also suggest that "all other things being equal, extinction is bad." As I said, I'm now more convinced by suffering-focused ethics, so I would probably somewhat modify this post and also change the conclusion of my post about terraforming.

One thing that could cause me to change my opinion, again, is the possibility that extraterrestrial aliens exist. What if sentient alien life exists somewhere in the universe, and what if those aliens would be better off if they interacted with humans? Is it possible that terraforming planets could allow mankind to avoid extinction, and should we expect mankind to compassionately help sentient aliens as they explore the universe? I don't think this thought experiment justifies terraforming Mars, though. David Pearce wrote "In practice, long-term responsibility for cosmic stewardship can probably be offloaded to insentient AI; biological wetware isn’t designed for interstellar travel and galactic exploration." Maybe we don't need a colony of biological human astronauts to do whatever is morally correct to aliens, so maybe we don't need to terraform.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Apr 28 '13

Alan Watt's "Music and Life", a simple/healthy existential reminder

Thumbnail
youtube.com
18 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Mar 26 '22

Dublin's National Botanical Garden has a random plaque to Wittgenstein in one of the greenhouses

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Oct 24 '12

On the subject of lies and love

14 Upvotes

Another fire starter for you guys...

To my knowledge and interpretation, lying is by a large margin, considered a bad idea.

Whether you are misrepresenting a state of your own mind, a state of your intentions, or are directly misdirecting others, its generally bad.

But what of lying to ones self?

I am going to attempt to actively ignore the motion that lying to ones self is directly akin to lying to others. I'll probably fail, but this is casual banter... so I'm allowed.

Specific example that is keeping me up tonight, minus superfluous and damning details of either party:

I am madly infatuated with a friend of mine. She knows it, and I know it. Early in our acquaintanceship, she made clear that no romance will occur. I lied to myself and to her, and on every instance of the notion from there on out. I said it was OK, I said I felt the same way, and that we should just be friends.

I feel that I lied to myself out of a coping mechanism. I've done it for years. Tell yourself the same lie enough times and you'll eventually believe it.

I feel that I lied to her to emphasize the first lie. Tell an intimate lie to someone else to sanctify your solid belief in it. If I tell her, she'll believe it, and by proxy force me to believe it. Thus making the lie truth.

The concept falls apart after a few beers, which is inherently the downfall of many a subject; but I digress....

I fully understand the masochism of spirit involved with my continued lying to myself. I fully understand the trite nature of telling her the "real truth"; at best she'd laugh at me, at worst she'd never talk to me again.

The real issue that I am looking to solve, is how does one convincingly change one's attitude over a matter of infatuation?

Considering a vague interpretation of strangely positive nihlism, it really shouldn't matter what either of us think; we're all (typically) rational individuals who can think for ourselves. I solely control that which is my reality. Why am I basing my reality on a latent desire for someone else? What is a reasonable alternative to this that is not a hackish patch over it? (e.g. more lies)

I've read every philosophy book my local dealer has had, and every relationship book my local dealer has had, and I can't solve this problem. I'm too focused on the context and can't see the abstract.

It's literally killing me.... at least my liver, anyways.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Sep 11 '13

"If only you could perceive time as I do"

13 Upvotes

This quote of Dr. Manhattan from The Watchmen is all too inspiring for me. It begs the question, how do I perceive time, and how may our perceptions differ?

As we've been told, time is relative, and is therefore experienced subjectively. But how then do we define time? I must define it fundamentally as rates of change in relative structure and position (essentially: progressive existentialism). This definition, I think, applies across all scales-- including the moving of electrons, protons, and neutrons to generate varying forms of energetic matter, as well as cosmic entities churning and colliding throughout the universe. Time is only change.

But how do we perceive time? Like any organism, our perceptions are limited to our sensory organs, however that doesn't mean we cannot appreciate entities beyond our scales of interest. A good example is that we see changes in the seasons here on Earth and have thus associated it with our cosmic positioning with respect to the sun. But without such obvious shifts in environmental condition, how do we really perceive time on a moment to moment basis?

Even when we're bored and "nothing is happening" we still experience time by way of our changing mind. We make observations and inferences at a rate that is within a range of human ability...some people may have more or fewer thoughts per moment than other people, and even the depth or level of detail of those thoughts seems to alter one's perception of time.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Feb 03 '22

If it’s in human nature to do awful things and continue to do them, what’s wrong with brainwashing everyone to be peaceful?

12 Upvotes

Ok why would anyone give this a helpful award???

So these thoughts have lived in my head rent free so I just need to get it out there. Every time I’ve heard someone suggest something like “We should make life less competitive” or “We should seek to end wars”, there will always be responses like “but it’s human nature for these things to happen.” However, this response never felt right to me and recently I found out why. If human nature perpetuates this endless cycle of suffering and cut-throat pressure, why should we abide by what “human nature” desires? Wouldn’t it be a good thing to brainwash people to remove this ugly part of human nature? Sure, it takes away freedom, but what exactly is good about freedom that leaves people to never be truly satisfied? Again, the only reason people desire freedom is human nature, and the goal of my idea is to change human nature to be more unified and peaceful. If the world ends up like Brave New World, it would definitely feel wrong to me but have no rational rebuttal so I accept that it’s my animal instincts making me feel this way. There’s no reason to desire something which only perpetuates an endless cycle full of pain, people only want to because this desire is ingrained into us. However, brainwashing solves that issue. Whenever people describe this love for freedom of thought/competition and how it overrides that of the suffering caused, it sounds like an absurd fetish. Maybe that’s just me though, I’m definitely tired of hearing the same arguments that can be refuted with “We can change human nature to remove that problem though”

Just to clarify, I’m not arguing if it’s possible, it probably isn’t, I’m arguing why it should be done if it is possible.

Forgive me if I’m redundant, it’s just that I notice that people tend to dodge the main point or argue against a straw-man when I look for answers. English isn’t my first language too.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Apr 20 '20

The Universe Owes You Nothing: Newton and The Phenomenological Everything

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Jun 29 '13

Watch "Alan Watts - existence is weird" on YouTube

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Feb 19 '13

On the logical problem of evil...

12 Upvotes

It's a shame this sub seems mostly dead, because I definitely wanted to start a high-level free-roam discussion on this topic.

If anyone out there catches this, send me a message and maybe we can work out a real-time discussion.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Feb 07 '14

Philip Seymour Hoffman didn’t know how to be happy

Thumbnail
qz.com
11 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Apr 18 '13

Depression--Disorder, or natural reaction to modern western society of the spectacle?

11 Upvotes

Recently, I can't help but feel that our society is far too obsessed with this notion that depression is entirely alien, unusual, and disordered. Somehow, normalcy is a means of never having a negative thought about the things around you. Or also, that it can be fixed by a variety of pills, like the mind is some basic organ (though, even pills for those turn out to be a huge mistake sometimes). It is my personal feeling that depression being unequal per culture implies that it is not a genetic or chemical disorder as much as one based on surroundings and development. As such, only surroundings and development may help the person rise above it. Is it possible that our depression is more a tell-tale sign of our mispurpose as a community, than something wrong with us? I can't help but feel like this attitude of being victimized and needing someone else to fix it is entirely backwards to what is actually needed. My father is on antidepressants, and I am sorry but he appears to simply be dumbed down to the things that bothered him--and I think that the things that bother him are valid existential inquiries that have been shut down by his meds. I strongly feel that if I had not gone through the existentialism course I took in college, I would probably be lost, utterly depressed, and/or suicidal...but I am not. And, as I age and depression revisits--I understand why...I am not a victim to my brain, I am a lost person in an entirely absurd society. This obsession with the majority of us being "messed up" and needing a "cure" seems ridiculous. If I cross any boundaries with this, I sincerely apologize...I simply felt very passionately that I should post this and get feedback.


r/armchairphilosophy • • May 26 '22

There are very few arenas in which Absolute truth can be found - Math, Chess, etc

10 Upvotes

I'm not a Philosophy major or anything so go easy on me.

In real life, it's very difficult to assert a statement with proof. You would need a ton of Data and there would often be data which will fit the opposite of the statement.

For example, take a statement like 'Vaccines cause Autism'. You could disprove it with a lot of Data but still some data for the contrary statement will pop up which will either be a totally new phenomenon or some other non-disregardable thing. The point is, most of the truths that we encounter in real life exists in 'Gray Area' - not black and white.

I've only managed to find few arenas where it's difficult to call 'Gray Area' on a Solution. Math is one of them. 2 plus 2 is always 4 (Winston smith may disagree). Chess is another one. It's a mate in 4, if it's a mate in 4. It's impossible to bullshit your way out of it. And my austistic ass happens to love these two arenas.

This is more of a random musing. Reply back with your thoughts or if you find similar Black and white Frameworks.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Jul 17 '19

Cannibalism, Necrophilia, and Incest: Why are they considered immoral?

10 Upvotes

This is a question I have been pondering quite a lot recently, and nobody is willing to discuss it, because of it's taboo nature. What is morally wrong with cannibalism if the meal is not murdered, but purchased or donated in some form? No one is being harmed or wrong. And nobody is having anything unjustly taken from them. Same goes for necrophilia.

As well, what is morally wrong with incest? So long as it is done through safe means and does not potentially result in a heavily diseased child, I see nothing wrong with it.

The only commonality between these three frowned upon to potentially criminalized actions is that the public views them as disgusting. Just as the public has viewed what are now considered tame fetishes, such as bdsm. And while I do see how an incestuous relationship can be born from nothing more than fetishism, and that is certainly not healthy. A incestuous relationship may potentially be born from actual love, as unlikely as that may be.

If anyone has a proper counter, I would like to hear it. Or I could just be shunned for even discussing the potential morality of something taboo as I usual am.


r/armchairphilosophy • • Sep 17 '15

I have posted a link. What is it too? That is a worthy question. Albeit one you may find an answer too.

Thumbnail
comicsthatsaysomething.quora.com
10 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Jun 06 '14

TIL Bruce Lee borrowed concepts from Krishnamurti and Alan Watts

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Apr 23 '14

A Quantum Anthropic Theory of Immortality?

10 Upvotes

This idea has been percolating in my brain for a couple of weeks now but I'm far too intimidated to expose it to any of the more hardcore philosophy or science subreddits, for fear of being downvoted into another multiverse entire. I am not a trained scientist, nor have I plumbed the depths of the philosophy of mind; I am, however, a dabbler who has read and thought a great deal about both. It is likely that this idea already exists elsewhere in more eloquent form, and it is possible that my speculations have no real merit whatsoever. Nevertheless, the idea that occurred to me a couple of weeks ago (and it presented itself to me out of the blue, unzipped itself like a .RAR file into a little folder in my brain) still strikes me as an elegant one, one that (if it holds any sort of water whatsoever) might lay the groundwork for a radically different way of thinking about reality and about our own individual existences within that reality.

I have tentatively titled this idea of mine a "quantum anthropic theory of immortality?" with an emphasis on the question mark. A title is not something I have put much thought into. All suggestions are welcome.

Three big concepts figure into my idea: quantum mechanics, multiverse theory, and the anthropic principle. I'll start with the anthropic principle because it is the only one of the three that I can profess to vaguely understand.

In brief: the anthropic principle holds that the conditions of the observable universe must needs be compatible with the conditions necessary to allow for observers. It is true that the universe seems perfectly calibrated for the proliferation of consciousness, but if it weren't just so, no conscious beings would exist and thus, nobody would be around to talk about how perfectly calibrated the universe is. There are no nonexistent entities out there, bitching on /r/nonexistent about their shoddily designed universe.

My understanding of multiverse theory and quantum indeterminacy is about as hazy as the position of an electron -- this is why I'm posting to /r/armchairphilosophy -- but according to the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, the waveform of an electron does not collapse. The universe, instead, cleaves every instant into an infinity of universes in which each and every possible electron state is entertained, such that there is a universe in which (a split second from now) I let loose an epic belch, a universe in which (a split second from now) I suffer a massive heart attack, and a universe in which (a split second from now) I merely pick my nose, slurp my coffee, and resume typing (which I did, in fact, just do).

If I've done a halfway decent job of understanding the above and if my explanations have made any sense at all, I hope that the step I'm about to take is a logical one.

Everyone who is reading this exists, and is alive. It might not be the case that you'll be alive ten years from now, or even five minutes from now, but as long as you are reading what I am writing, you are a conscious, functioning, observing part of the universe. Now, if a many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics is true, you will (starting from this very instant) be splitting imperceptibly and infinitely into any number of different universes: one in which you belch, one in which you have a heart attack, one in which you pick your nose, et cetera.

Here is where the anthropic principle kicks in. Which of those universes will you inhabit? All things being equal, there is no reason to favor one multiverse over another -- with one obvious exception. You can only perceive a multiverse in which you exist.

This is a no-brainer, but it has some rather creepy consequences. If we think of a life as beginning at point x and progressing through time, each instant-by-instant splitting of the multiverse contains a set of possibilities in which you die or cease to be, and each splitting contains another set in which you survive. You can only perceive the multiverses in which you remain alive. The multiverses in which you die are nonexistent to you. Over time, thanks to the miracle of old age (i.e., entropy), there are more and more multiverses in which you have a heart attack, suffer a stroke, come down with cancer; more and more multiverses in which you are nonexistent -- but there remain plenty of multiverses in which you are alive, and so long as those multiverses exist, you will perceive one of them.

Here's the rub: given an infinite (or essentially infinite) proliferation of multiverses, the number of multiverses in which you are alive and conscious will never hit zero. In short, this may be a kind of roundabout argument in favor of immortality; or, to look at it another way, it may be an argument against the possibility of mortality.

If it is the case that we are immortal in this way, it would be an extremely strange form of immortality. You, as I explained above, would resume perceiving multiverses in which you are alive. The rest of the people in your life, however, would be perceiving multiverses in which they are alive. In other words: your existence is not a necessary condition for their existence. Neither is anyone else's existence a necessary condition for yours. Consequently, all of the people you know will die while you remain living. Likewise, in their multiverses, you will die. Completely separately and forever out of reach from one another, everyone will remain conscious forever, or for as much of forever as the universe allows.

What form this immortality might take in the long run is not something I have given a tremendous amount of thought to -- I haven't gotten that far yet -- but feel free to speculate for me. I would expect that, as the possible multiverses in which you survive -- much fewer for a 93-year-old man than, say, for a twelve-year-old kid -- dwindles, the conditions in which you remain existent become less and less optimal and more and more precarious. As long as the number of possible conscious "you"s remains nonzero, however, quality of life doesn't matter. What matters is conscious perception, and where that exists, so shall you.

I just farted this out over the course of about ten minutes, so I'm sure there are glitches (grammatical and rational ones) strewn about all over the shop. Nevertheless, these are the thoughts that have been keeping me awake as of late, and if they've been interesting to you, I'm glad that they were -- if you're a knowledgeable person and they actually make sense to you, I'll be surprised and absolutely delighted -- and if you can poke a hole in these ideas or shoot them down completely, I would very much appreciate it, because while some form of immortality has always appealed to me (though I've never been able to believe in one), this is certainly not the sort of immortality that I would ever wish upon anyone.

Warm regards, --Carl


r/armchairphilosophy • • Jun 20 '13

What is Real

10 Upvotes

I was reading something on the 'Forms' recently, and managed to find myself on this page on wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegory_of_the_cave It says in the third paragraph from the top "possess the highest and most fundamental kind of reality". I was thinking, what actually makes something REAL, because surely for them to make this statement there must be a standard that must be adhered to if one 'reality' is better than another. Otherwise is reality just what we perceive or is there some underlying... realness that is an absolute. I am tempted to think that what is real is just what we perceive, and maybe the word is tricking us; the word is just used to describe what is perceptible, rather than define what we SHOULD perceive (possibly, i am confusing myself here (i dont really want to say here that there is no such thing as reality (sounds way too wacky))).

What do you think? i dont even know if much of the above makes sense, but thought it could start some discussion :) <-- DISCLAIMER SMILEY FACE (you cant be mad at me now) Im sure this train of thought has a technical name that someone will be learned in.


r/armchairphilosophy • • May 25 '13

Philosophy on the Morals and "Value" of idle hours being stoned and gaming

10 Upvotes

I suppose this isn't quite going anywhere scholarly but...

I can't help but wonder if people who spend time that is considered "wasted" by the status quo might be justified, or that their actions might "have their place" as an alternative to a different addiction. Is it not a sort of moment of "ignorance is bliss"? How do you all feel about how healthy it is to spend extreme amounts of time gaming or being idle and lazy...as someone who has more or less grown out of these things I can't help but feel that moderation, yet again, is key.


r/armchairphilosophy • • May 22 '13

I just like to give a shoutout to the community, thanks for taking the time to post your sincere opinions and taking me/eachother seriously, nyawhatimsayin

10 Upvotes

I appreciate it, it makes me intrested in hearing what you have to say'nshiet


r/armchairphilosophy • • May 12 '13

Why do people always talk about shallow shit and dont talk more about real shit that might actually mean something and share an experience with oneanother and shit

10 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • May 05 '21

VSauce video about "minds," environmental issues, the Fermi Paradox, rationality, confirmation bias, and sortition

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Mar 10 '21

Is hedonism the Great Filter of Fermi's paradox?

9 Upvotes

In the movie Star Trek (2009) Dr. Leonard McCoy is quoted as saying

"Space is disease and danger covered in darkness and silence"

To which James Kirk (not yet captain) responds by saying that Star Fleet works in space. Dr. McCoy may have a point. There is little in the idea of space travel that offers anything in the way of happiness and much in the way of suffering. This is not to say that space travel/colonization should not be pursued, just that there is little to no justification for doing so under a purely hedonistic metric (egoism, utilitarianism). Utilitarians in particular could argue that because the spread of humanity throughout the galaxy would require, and result in, massive suffering and hardships, and even death, space travel should be outlawed. There is also the argument from "voluntary" human extinctionists that humans and all other life should just go extinct in order to end all suffering. This brings us to the Great Filter.

According to Great Filter theory, there have been multiple instances throughout history where life on Earth risked becoming extinct (failure to achieve abiogenesis, asteroids etc.) and there are possible future filters (nuclear war, asteroids (again), VHE, etc). In the context of Fermi's paradox, this would go a long way to explain why we haven't encountered sentient beings from another star system, not even their robotic emissaries. It could also be the case that almost all advanced species reach a point where hedonism is their only concern, and space travel (even sending probes) becomes a waste of resources to them. This seems to be a rising trend on Earth as nations evaluate themselves according to how well they satisfy their citizen's/subject's wants and less on things such as human space flight.

It would seem that in order for humanity to spread across the galaxy, it would need to overcome its obsession with hedonism and take an entropic approach, seeing human thriving in terms of "spread".

Could there be any merit to this line of thinking?


r/armchairphilosophy • • Feb 10 '14

Modern Kierkegaard - What happens when philosophers are reborn as Twitter accounts?

Thumbnail
josephpascale.blogspot.com
9 Upvotes

r/armchairphilosophy • • Dec 01 '13

Famous novelists on "symbolism" in their work, hope this belongs here!

Thumbnail
mentalfloss.com
9 Upvotes