r/andor • • 4h ago

Meme Remember Erskin Semaj from the cartoon? LOOK, HERE HE IS IN LIVE ACTION!!

Post image
220 Upvotes

r/andor • • 8h ago

Meme This belongs to here

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Totally true and must definitely shows what our goal for SW should be


r/andor • • 9h ago

Theory & Analysis How to Write A Perfect Season of TV - Andor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
56 Upvotes

r/andor • • 11h ago

Media & Art Reign of the Empire

17 Upvotes

This Andor related book (Mon Mothma & Ghorman, with some Saw & Kreegyr backstory is currently on sale in the UK for 99p as an ebook from Kobo and Kindle - I paid full price on release, and it's worth a read!


r/andor • • 13h ago

General Discussion Tony Gilroy AMA is now live on r/movies (joint one with Eva Victor)

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/andor • • 14h ago

General Discussion 4 years to the day since Luthen took on an Arrestor Cruiser, B2EMO and Cassian mourned Maarva, and Saw said “Let’s call it… War”. What are your favourite moments of s1 ep 11?

Thumbnail
gallery
201 Upvotes

I clearly remember the sensation of going from the exhilaration of Luthen’s great escape to the sadness of Cassian calling home to say that Maarva would be proud of him, only to discover that she’s died while he was in prison. Bee’s reaction had already devastated me. So too had Mon, confessing to Vel “I’ve found a solution” and simply glancing up towards Leida.

Something of a buildup episode to the finale but still filled with incredible moments like these.


r/andor • • 16h ago

General Discussion The three types of Star Wars: Fareau, Filoni, Gilroy

330 Upvotes

Borrowed from social media; 10/10, no notes:

[e/t/a]

https://www.threads.com/share/BAvX4NQMIU


r/andor • • 16h ago

General Discussion No one else (besides this sub) seems to like Andor as much as I do

113 Upvotes

It's a masterpiece and it confuses me that it doesn't get as much hype as the other Star Wars movies/shows. What gives? Whenever I mention Andor people have either not heard of it or haven't watched it.


r/andor • • 1d ago

Media & Art Sigur Ros and Andor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

It’s cold and gray today and I thought of this song as a backdrop for some of the more physically stark and emotionally isolated moments in the show.


r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion Hello my friends! I am here again, some of you in the comments of this post asked me to share more details about this course if I could. So, I want to share my midterm questions and my answers.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
14 Upvotes

I really want to talk about what we have discussed in the class in much more detail but we are talking so many topic in every class and it is really hard for me to write everything we talked about in this 6-7 week. Maybe I can answer your questions if you have any :(
We have been talking about Andor for the last two weeks btw. We have talked about Syrill's personality, banality of evil and mass pyscology of fascism also the relationship of Dedra and Syrill, paralles of Andor with the history of our own country for example the Ghorman Massacre and the Bloody May First of 1977 in Taksim Square in Turkey. Also, we have talked about indigenous cultures, conservative rebellion of Mon's daughter against her and the Marxist alienation theory from the Arkina 5 arc, we also talked about Charlie Chaplin's Modern Times while we are talking about alienation


r/andor • • 1d ago

Question Which Star Wars crime family has the messiest internal drama?

4 Upvotes

The Hutts lock up and double cross their own relatives. Crimson Dawn runs entirely on fear and betrayal. The Pykes switch sides the second it pays better.

If you HAD to attend one of their family dinners, which one are you least likely to walk out of alive? I'm saying Hutts. Nobody's safe at a Hutt dinner.


r/andor • • 1d ago

Real World Politics Final Bix scene Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

For others who missed it (like myself) - it's an obvious reference to the 1997 cover of "Hasta Siempre" by Nathalie Cardone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTqwy6ay1HQ


r/andor • • 1d ago

Theory & Analysis First scene: Tay Kolma

Thumbnail
gallery
493 Upvotes

Tay Kolma’s first scene in 1.07 is one we’ve been anticipating even though we didn’t know his name before: this is the “someone” who Mon has found who she thinks can help her continue to fund the rebellion despite increased Imperial scrutiny of her accounts. Luthen was dismissive of the idea: “Someone to bring into the circle? No, we have enough people to worry about”.

The plot of the scene is simple enough. Once she is as sure as she can be that Tay is on her side after he says that his politics might be too strong for her taste, Mon shares her biggest secret: that she is not the Mon Mothma that her public image suggests. She’s not even the person that her husband thinks he knows. She’s instead using her public image as cover for what she’s really doing: “raising money”. She asks Tay to set up a charitable fund for her and to be the chairman of that. When he asks her for more detail of what she’s raising money for, she tells him it’s better that he doesn’t know: “Or perhaps you’d find my politics a bit strong for your taste”.

The whole scene represents a huge gamble for Mon, a real leap of faith. She’s known Tay since they were children and there’s even a hint of a possible romantic attraction at some early stage. It’s fascinating that before season 2 released a lot of viewers were actively hoping that they would have a torrid affair - I remember the meme with Mon saying “I wish he would Tay Kolma clothes off!”. How things changed in season 2!

The whole scene is much more about Mon than Tay and it’s one of Genevieve O’Reilly’s best appearances - and that’s saying something. Tay himself remains something of an enigma in this scene. He comes over as personable and open to the idea but gives little away beyond that. But I think there’s a moment in the conversation where he locks in. Credit here to the excellent ‘The Upstairs Lounge’ video analysis; his most recent post (link in comments) gives a really close look at Tay in this scene and he picks up on something in Ben Miles’s acting I never noticed before: there’s a genuine gleam of excitement in his eye once he realised he’s being let in on a very risky secret. Tay is seemingly hooked by the idea of being part of something exciting and dangerous, and in terms of the possible “are they having an affair?” vibe what’s creating that impression is, I think, the intimacy of this scene. That he’s being invited into Mon’s confidence in a way that her husband isn’t. “Perrin knows none of this. He’s not to be trusted” really fuels this idea.

Tay is implied to have a pretty pedestrian life and his anti-Empire feelings might be more to do with irritation at their interference in Chandrilan banking, or he might simply be an ‘armchair politics’ kind of guy - a privilege of someone in Chandrilan high society. It’s hard to imagine him giving that up in the way of Vel - “eating roots and sleeping on rocks for this Rebellion”. But I kind of like the idea that he is at this point pretty committed; that he at least sees himself as something of the ‘firebrand’ that Perrin apparently once was, even if in a somewhat romanticised way. Maybe that fuelled the ‘they should have an affair!’ speculation. He seemed at this time to a lot of viewers to be a better match for Mon than Perrin. But on a rewatch, all the warning signs are there.

Tony Gilroy apparently had a bit of trouble getting people to accept Tay’s change in heart in season 2, but I think that it helps to see the full thematic context. For Gilroy, season 2 is all about the “real effect of painful, pressurised time” and what that does to those taking part in a revolution: the way people get worn down, grow tired, change their minds, betray others. Losing resolve might be more common for many than strengthening it; for every Vel Sartha there might be ten Tay Kolmas, and of course even Cassian is very much wavering over the course of the first three years of season 2. Tay is not a bad man. He’s categorised by Perrin as “always weak” in a way that suggests not so much possible jealousy as genuine contempt for a man who cannot handle his drink. But of course Mon hears the deeper meaning. The stages of her realisation at the wedding are so well written and of course Tay’s final scene is where he gets into the limo with the new driver who has been called to fill in for Otto. Cinta’s presence indicates that Luthen had plans in place long before the “How nice for you” exchange. Tay is going to be, in Gilroy’s words, Fredo Corleone-d (a reference to the ill-fated brother in The Godfather).

Tay’s fate was sealed from the moment he even suggested that the rebellion was to blame for his financial losses. The trouble is, he probably wasn’t wrong about that. Committing to the Cause means making sacrifices and I don’t think Tay realised that, or maybe he thought he would be immune. Mon’s judgement that he was on her side wasn’t wrong, it’s just that time took its toll. Tay is also of course from the privileged classes - sheltered in at least the early stages of a fascistic takeover. If season 2 is as Gilroy says about Time and the answer to the question of “How much are you prepared to give up for the cause?” Tay has already reached his limit. His wife left him, he was drinking too much, and finally ready to go to help from Sculdun. All this in just one year. It’s not even clear that he’s actively blackmailing Mon. Perhaps she should have offered him a cut of the funds transferred, in the way that she offers Sculdun. Even Cassian insisted on payment for his first mission.

But none of that matters. Mon is the priority. Luthen knows it and she herself knows it. The slightest threat to her is a threat to the whole rebellion. Tay’s biggest mistake was not realising that, but the guilt will live with Mon for a long time as a deep scar on her soul. “People fail”, as Luthen says, but she feels the pain too. “How quickly you decided he was a risk” she says to Luthen two years later. But the reality is that she knows, deep down, that he’s right. As is so often the case.

TLDR: Tay Kolma is a victim of the fight but also of the pressure of time - he’s not a bad man but a weak one. His commitment was not deep or enduring enough to save him and perhaps he didn’t realise his position: as Luthen says to Lonni, “I can’t let you go”. Tay ends up being blood on Mon’s hands at the same time as she is effectively emotionally severed from her daughter forever. No wonder she is “dancing to stop the screaming” at the end of s2 ep3.

Next time: Kino Loy


r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion Gilroy / Pascal / composers panel for BEHEMOTH!

32 Upvotes

As someone who's collaborated with & admired creative artists for over 50 years, I can say that the last two minutes of this panel (Tony Gilroy, Pedro Pascal, John Gilroy, and some of the musicians and composers who brought TG's BEHEMOTH to life) is possibly the most eloquent, truthful, incisive, and loving tribute by one artist (Gilroy) to another (Pascal) that I've ever heard. Watch it all, but especially for that last two minutes from Tony.

Damn, I admire this man.

https://youtu.be/PzOBHb_om6g?si=9xqgUaUcv31vjSGq&t=1522


r/andor • • 1d ago

Meme Anyone else see this?

Post image
455 Upvotes

r/andor • • 1d ago

General Discussion Suggested follow up after Andor S2 (what could be missing??)

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/andor • • 2d ago

AMA/Q&A Announcement - Tony Gilroy - Monday 11/14 at 4 PM ET - Oscar-Nominated Filmmaker & Screenwriter - 'Michael Clayton', 'Andor', 'Rogue One', 'Behemoth!', 'Bourne' Franchise

Post image
212 Upvotes

r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion The irony of Kloris’s last words being “Who are you?” and Cassian asking Mon for his name … when Perrin kept forgetting his name in the s1 episode ‘The Axe Forgets’

Thumbnail
gallery
2.0k Upvotes

I don’t think he was about to switch sides, but we will never know. Anyway, another particularly delicious use of the “Who are you?” question.


r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion The tunnel Maarva opened under the hotel (108) is the tunnel where Cassian meets Brasso before he sneaks into the hotel to rescue Bix (110)

423 Upvotes

I’m sure a lot of you figured this out but it was on my latest rewatch I realized it was that tunnel.


r/andor • • 2d ago

General Discussion Is there a reason why Vel didn't use a fake name on Aldhani?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

I know the others didn't either, aside from Clem. But unlike them she's related to a big public figure.


r/andor • • 2d ago

Real World Politics The entirety of andor is proof that an US rebellion will never happen

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve seen multiple posts and comments on the internet talk about how people call for revolution against the current US government, some cases the entire system as a whole. But the entire show encapsulates what people are willing to do for revolution and what they believe in and how it brutally complicates moral compasses of varying people.

I’ve seen people say that “in the revolution, I’d be the poet” or “I would knit sweaters”. They don’t really know what it would take. Even I don’t. But we see it in real life AND this show what it would. In the first season, we see the rebels take a child as a hostage, and if things went south, they were going to kill him. Now they didn’t, but the question still stands. Would you kill the young for your beliefs against authoritarian rule? We’ve seen that before with real life revolutions too like the Bolshevik Revolution. Yall think Anastasia ran away? She was shot in the head and dumped in the palace cellar along with the rest of her family.

Hell, Luthen’s entire speech is how he damns any saving grace of his being and admits that he must use the tools of his enemy to defeat them. He becomes a monster to defeat monsters. He lets innocent people die and his own allies perish when it becomes a disadvantage to save them. He uses his friends go into enemy territory and when they’re founded out, he kills them to secure secrecy.

I am kind of blowing this out of the water, but in no means am I in support of imperialism and authoritarianism. I am only trying to be as critical as I am with Star Wars and in real life because, as well as anyone knows who’s a Star Wars fan, that this franchise has always mirrored real world events.

But I am open to criticism of my points. Please share what you all think


r/andor • • 3d ago

General Discussion Even though he died tragically, Nemik is still our hero and the most important character

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Without him Cassian wouldn’t be inspired by him in the first place.


r/andor • • 3d ago

Theory & Analysis Is there significance to these similar names?

0 Upvotes

I could just be thinking too much into this. But is there a reason that both Luthen and Mon have “children” with similar names to Leia? If we think of Leia as Bail(arguably one of the other most important rebel leaders), that means we have 3 children all with very similar names. Leida, Leia, and Kleya. Probably nothing, but interesting to think that the 3 children of the 3 main rebel leaders all have similar name


r/andor • • 3d ago

Media & Art Luthen Rael leitmotif

Post image
48 Upvotes

Just finished another rewatch of Andor and I still cannot get enough of the theme song for Luthen Rael.

The low rhythmic percussions in the background signifying his obsessive dedication to the cause.

The long violin notes, each one a crescendo at first, conveying his rage and incendiary methods. Then, softer in a minor key to signify his life in the shadows, his yearning for liberation and his resignation in knowing he won’t live to see it.

I was not familiar with Nicholas Britell’s game before the show but jfc what a soundtrack! I’m so grateful for how the creative team managed to pull together so many talented people to produce the miracle of Andor.