r/andor • • 12d ago Bravo Popcorn

Real World Politics A Rebellion vs Performative posting.

Thumbnail
gallery
347 Upvotes

Start by saying that everyone should vote and that every vote counts; having your say in the system is important.

A lot of people in this sub suddenly think voting makes you a rebel; you are not. Voting is Systemic Legitimacy and a privilege; by voting, you implicitly agree to the "rules of the game," validating the authority of whoever wins. If you truly believed your government oppressed you or it was fascist, then it was your duty to rebel and (Insert Luther speech here) to improve your country.

Agree or disagree with him: Luigi Mangione did; it was an act of a rebel.

Stop these performative posts that have no relation to Andor. Just because your chosen political party is now doing better, you believing that you now have more representation also means others now believe they have lost it. Should the Republicans in Texas now start Andor posting because they are now the minority?

You live in a system that allows people to speak out and change the people within your government; claiming you are rebels only dilutes the actual true rebels in history and now.


r/andor • • Jul 24 '25 Bravo

Media & Art Andor inspired me to join up. We have friends everywhere.

Thumbnail
gallery
365 Upvotes

Wanted a patch!

Credit: Keith @ Ink or Dye Studio, Centreville, MD


r/andor • • Jun 17 '25

Real World Politics America is THE Empire

94 Upvotes

America is not just AN Empire. America is THE Empire. Andor is about THE American Empire.

You can say that it has elements of the British Empire. You can say it has elements of the Roman Empire. You can even say it has elements of USSR and China. Empires have things in common — sure. But it most closely resembles THE American Empire.

America is not “more evil” than other empires. It’s just come to its peak at a very specific time in human history. Things like globalization, nuclear proliferation, and late stage capitalism have made America’s reach more influential than other Empires in the past. It’s kind of like Anakin. The Empire flourished specifically because the Sith coaxed in Darth Vader at a very specific time of the fall of the Jedi/Republic, thus making Palpatine’s reach and power that much more destructive. America came to power after WWII. It became the world’s bastion of wealth at the exact same time it created the most powerful weapon to ever exist — Nuclear weapons.

America is the most powerful empire in the world. America is the most contemporary Empire in the world. America is also the most influential Empire in the world. It impacts more lives than any Empire has been able to in the past. Rome didn’t even know the New World existed, let alone have the means to colonize it.

Andor was also made by Disney, a uniquely American company. To say Andor is not reflective of American Empire is like looking at a Fransisco Goya painting and saying it has nothing to do with the Spanish Civil War. Time matters. Context matters. Authorship matters.

Lastly, we are witnessing one of the most catastrophic events of the past 100 years in Gaza. We are watching an entire population, in an open air prison, be systematically murdered via starvation. It is hard to convey just how historically malicious this event is. It is being funded and supplied by America. While Israeli planned and carried out, it would not be able to happen if not co-signed by the world’s Empire.

People who disagree will gleefully point out other atrocities in human history. They will talk about horrific events that American antagonists have carried out like gulags and what not. But what makes Gaza particularly heinous is that it is being live-streamed for the world to see. Very few horrors have been so visible throughout human history.

To hear an American television show say the word genocide, in the midst of THIS genocide, is not a coincidence. It is an attempt by the screenwriters to call attention to something very specific. Just like how George Lucas made the Rebels resemble the Viet Cong during its fight against American Empire.

Art is often the only means that regular people have of fighting back. One man cannot fight an empire alone. But one man can write a story. One man can create a picture. It’s what makes the power of the pen so satisfying. It’s something to be proud of. It’s also in the tradition of Star Wars.

There is a very vocal part of the fan base that would rather have Andor mean nothing more than be a million dollar clashing of action figures that is symbolic of literally nothing. Void of all meaning. Making Star Wars a modern day circus clown.

There is another group hell bent on making it an analogy for antagonists of, conveniently, the American Empire it is criticizing. Making Andor nothing more than a stone they get to throw at others.

You are not responsible for Empire just because you are born into it. But you are perpetuating it by denying and diverting blame to other groups and other atrocities. It’s an excuse. You have the same energy as Krennic talking to Mon Mothma. Bringing up the violence of Rebel groups as if it exists in a vacuum. Everything is related to Empire. The world revolves around American Empire. We have forced it to.

It’s why we ended up in the jungles of Vietnam. In the deserts of Iraq and Afghanistan. It is an infection dedicated to infiltrating all aspects of life — for resources. It’s all for resources.

I am an American. I see the propaganda of Empire everywhere I look. For Andor to be made is an anamoly. Empire is not supposed to let things like this get made. But, like Nemik’s manifesto, it finds a way. Embrace it.


r/andor • • May 29 '25

General Discussion Me whenever somebody calls Syril a fascist.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/andor • • Jun 04 '26

General Discussion In my opinion The Last Jedi of the mainline movies is the closest to Andor

7 Upvotes

I dont really know if this is a hot take. But both have some similar themes. Rose, DJ (the one guy that sells weapons) and Holdo would be right at home one Andor. And the end of the film with the broom boy is something that i really can imagine Tony Gilroy doing.


r/andor • • Feb 06 '23

Discussion I feel like there are too many British accents in this show.

0 Upvotes

Star Wars has always had a bifurcated take on accents. American accents for Rebels (broadly speaking) and British accents, specifically posh received pronunciation, for Imperials (broadly speaking). Most non-Rebel or non-Imperial characters likewise tended to have American or some other accent, but usually not British.

In Andor it feels like nearly every character has a British accent with the exception of Cassian himself and a small handful of others. I'm not complaining about all the Imperial officers having British accents, that's basically established Star Wars canon at this point, but even in places where you'd expect a lot of accent diversity like when Cassian is imprisoned? Nope. All British there too.

All the rebels, as well, have suddenly been given British accents rather than the traditional General American twang most Star Wars series give them. I have no problem with British accents but it feels like I'm watching a British show, not a Star Wars show, with how little accent diversity exists in this series.

Don't get me wrong I enjoy the show I just really wish that they'd stop nearly exclusively casting British actors and allow a more mixed accent range for the characters. It's probably the only real complaint I have about this show, most everything is extremely well done.


r/andor • • Dec 04 '22

Discussion I wish this Andor team would have done the DUNE reboot.

3 Upvotes

It calls for a much more substantive and thoughtful treatment than what that product was/is.


r/andor • • Nov 12 '23

Discussion Andor is not Star Wars… and that is why it is the best Star Wars.

3 Upvotes

When you look at Andor, it obviously stands out as an outlier when compared to pretty much all previous Star Wars visual media. I have watched countless reactions to people who say, “This is what I’ve been waiting for or wanted.” I have also heard people say that it’s not Star Wars… and both are right.

Star Wars is fantasy. When you break it down, it’s an adventure story about a farm boy who gets taken in by an old wizard with a laser sword. They team up with a thief, his companion (sorry Chewie), and a couple funny sidekicks to rescue a captive princess and save the galaxy from an evil emperor and his champion knight dressed in black armor and a red laser sword.

Andor, while set in the same universe, is pure science fiction. It is a reflection of the world we live in, highlighting some of the social and political issues we face today. I think the Board of Jurors said it best when awarding Andor and Star Wars its first Peabody, “For conjuring up a terrifying world uncannily like our very own (despite taking place a long time ago in a galaxy far far away), one that stresses the need for grassroots organizing lest a fascistic state wholly subsume any spark of rebellion—and for imagining how IP-driven storytelling can flourish in today’s corporate-driven television landscape—Andor receives a Peabody.”

Andor is not a Star Wars fantasy epic and it’s the best Star Wars story ever put in visual media.

Edit: I feel the need to explain the meaning behind this post. It may be a bit confusing, I did write this late at night.

There are people out there who think Andor is not Star Wars. They rightly point out that there are no lightsabers, Jedi, Sith, and the Force. Is that what makes a show Star Wars? I would say no, except for those who believe it purely to be a fantasy epic. If that is what they see and attribute to SW, then I can see why they would say so. Star Wars is fantasy.

As someone who prefers Science Fiction over Fantasy, Andor is better than the other Star Wars visual media at mirroring current events and political and social issues through its writing than any other SW property.


r/andor • • Sep 05 '25

Theory & Analysis S2E2: Anybody else feel like Tay Kolma wanted sex from Mon Mothma as a way to pay back for his losses?

0 Upvotes

I watch that scene where Tay Kolma and Mon Mothma are talking and Tay is pretty much saying, "everybody else got what they wanted and I got screwed." But it wasn't clear exactly what he wanted. He doesn't say it outright.

I read other analysis on this scene and many say he wants money, but to me it seemed like he wanted sex based on these things:

  • They are very flirty with each other in season 1 and have had known each other for years.

  • Perrin says Tay Kolma is Mon Mothma's lover boy straight to her face

  • Mon Mothma in this scene immediately feels betrayed and disgusted and I felt that it was because she could sense that he wanted more than just money. Like a guy who pretends to be a girl's friend but then reveals that he wants sex.

  • Tay Kolma just recently separated from his wife.


r/andor • • 12d ago

Real World Politics To all the Andor fans drawing parallels between American Democrats and the Rebels

0 Upvotes

In this analogy the Democrats didn't blow up the Death Star. They helped build it.

You watched Andor but you didn't learn anything from it.

Don't put your faith in a political party. Put your faith in your family, your neighbors, your friends.


r/andor • • May 07 '25

General Discussion A lot of people are REALLY missing the point of the Ghorman arc.

4 Upvotes

I'm writing this fully aware that I'm probably going to get downvoted to hell for it, but I think it's an important statement to make.

The point of the Ghorman arc is very much not to demonize one group of people, it's to encourage people to question the media they consume, the narratives they are fed, and to think for themselves.

I knew the moment the word "Genocide" was uttered on screen that it would trigger a certain segment of the population to immediately see it as a confirmation that "Oh look, Tony Gilroy is on our side, let's go ahead and loudly advocate for the destruction of a country we don't like, question their legitimacy, and muse about how they just can't "stop senselessly resisting international norms."

There are plenty of posts and comments about that already, and it's frankly unbelievable to me that they could miss the point so badly.

The show pretty explicitly codes the Ghormans as Europeans pre WW2. The cinematography borrows heavily from "Battleship Potemkin" and the "Battle of Algiers," and the plot involves a insular group who wasn't really bothering anyone suddenly finding themselves "othered" by the state for reasons they don't even understand to further the reigning authority's nationalist goals.

You can find examples of this behavior in the US today, and several other autocratic countries, but in terms of overlaying this plotline to actual history, we're very clearly talking about the Nazis in the run up to the second World War, and the actual massacre plays out more like the Warsaw Ghetto uprising than anything happening in the modern world.

If your reaction to this episode is to immediately flock to social media to parrot slogans, downvote dissenters to your opinion, and demonize/"other" a group of people because media (social or traditional) told you so, congratulations: You're Syril's mom.

If your reaction is to go "Wait, how much of the information that I consume is propaganda designed to make me hate specific groups and advance large scale agendas I can neither see nor understand?" then congratulations, you got the point the creators of this show were making.

So far, unfortunately I've seen a lot more examples of the first kind of person than the second.


r/andor • • Jan 06 '26

General Discussion Season 1 was better than season 2.

0 Upvotes

Finished S2 yesterday, that last sequence for the tie in with rogue one was incredible, I'll be rewatching that movie later this evening, I last saw it in the theaters when it released, I wonder what will change now. S1's ep3 > S2's ep3. Aldhani, Narkina and back to Ferrix were better arcs than the wedding/stolen tie, Ghorman, and the epilogue. Everyhting Luthen was doing in S1 was also better. The numerous time jumps did not help the plot at all. Not witnessing the birth of the rebellion at Yavin was a let down. Season 2 was still pretty good, but in comparison to it's predecessor it was a step below, which is a bummer considering it was the last we'll ever see of Andor. I did like where they took Syril's character, wasn't expecting it to go down the way it did; and Kleya was also more fleshed out this season, there was always something more to her that I wanted to see in S1 and I ended up liking her a lot here.


r/andor • • Jun 01 '25 Helpful Polished Gold Turd Diamonds are Forever

Real World Politics Never have I felt more on the side of the Palestinian cause than after watching this. I understand resistance in a way I never had before

6.3k Upvotes

I’m aware the writers drew from many oppressions and genocides. But we are experiencing a genocide in real time, right before our eyes, funded by US taxpayers and carried out by the current Israeli government.

And never have I felt more on the side of the Palestinian cause than after watching this show, which was masterfully written. It showed me the side of resistance we often grapple with, the side where resistance more often than not becomes an armed resistance when the peaceful part of resistance doesn’t get you anywhere. When your land is taken forcibly, when your city is besieged, when your land, sea, and air borders are controlled by an occupying entity, and you are left with one choice, to fight back, even if the empire (Israel/US) is overwhelmingly stronger, more powerful, and better funded.

Cassian and Luthen were both part of the resistance and each, questionably, had to end the lives of people who otherwise could or should have lived (Jung 😭). While I know this story is fictional, it brings out a truth we often avoid. Resistance is rarely clean or easy, and it never comes without moral compromise. When you are fighting an empire, you do not get to choose the terms. You are forced into the shadows, pushed into impossible choices, and made to sacrifice lives so others might have a future.

The writers did not glorify rebellion. They humanized it. A constant theme throughout the Star Wars franchise, but especially so in Andor. It showed how resistance comes at a cost. It reminded me that behind every act of defiance is someone wrestling with the weight of it. Someone who has lost too much already to keep standing still. And maybe that is why it hit so hard. Because right now, in Gaza, people are making those same impossible choices. When your children are bombed to smithereens, starved to death, your hospitals destroyed, your homes flattened, and the world either watches in silence or arms your oppressor, resistance stops being about right or wrong. It becomes survival.

And no, Gaza’s oppression did not begin after Oct 7, their resistance was born out of the oppression they’ve been experiencing for decades long before it ever made it to our mainstream news. Andor is not just a story. It is a reflection. Of history. Of now. Of what it means to live under occupation and still choose to fight back, even when you are outmatched in every way. And for me, this show did not just entertain. It awakened. It reminded me that in every generation, there are those who will resist. Not because they want to, but because they have to


r/andor • • Nov 09 '22

I’m sorry, but I couldn’t care less about the Mon Mothma scenes.

0 Upvotes

I try to be interested in the secret political origins of the rebellion, but I basically have to take an adderall to sit through a single Mon Mothma scene and know what the hell those space-Brit’s (wearing kimonos) were whispering about.


r/andor • • Sep 20 '25

Theory & Analysis Andor hurts OT experience

0 Upvotes

Just finished Andor and it's one of the finest depictions of rebellion against an oppressive regime I've ever seen.

In fact, it's brutal, paranoid, random, despairing journey from discontent to plausible revolution is so well thought through that I wanted more than anything to follow this story through to regime collapse.

Except instead of that, we get Luke Skywalker and the Force (God basically) deux ex machina-ing the Death Star away. And it feels like such a cop out compared to the insane tight rope over the abyss that Andor/R1 was.

Ive always only been a mild SW fan. Now I'm rethinking everything. ESB did a decent job of showing that E4 was only the start and that the regime was still immensely powerful. But then RotJ takes out the whole thing with Ewoks and a convenient & seemingly unnecessary visit by the Emperor to the new DS.

I've heard that Andor/R1 enhances Episode 4. Maybe in some ways. But I almost think it makes E4 seem like a mockery of the theme.

You might argue that Andor was not meant to be a roadmap for Regime overthrow from A->Z, and maybe I'm wishing it was exactly that given the current environment, but I still think the enormity of the task in Andor is cheapened by E4. Give me Cassian over Luke any day.

Maybe after digestion, my thoughts will change but happy for other PoVs.


r/andor • • Mar 02 '23

Discussion I feel the Andor sub is a safe place for this: The bar has been raised and The Mandalorian premier was the worst episode of that series so far. I can only assume thar Feloni and co had access to Andor as they were making this. Hoping it gets better..

0 Upvotes

r/andor • • Jun 22 '25

General Discussion Forgive me

Post image
4 Upvotes

Was just watching The Last Jedi again. Don’t ask me why. But, is this who I think it is?!


r/andor • • Oct 04 '23

Discussion Well it looks like the only thing worth watching is Andor S2, then after that idk…

12 Upvotes

After only watching half of absoka ( stop after 5 episodes) I think I only am interested so far in Andor. I really gave it a chance but nothing really wowed me and everything else just felt bland. Shout out to Hayden and Ray but everyone else felt monotone.


r/andor • • Jul 01 '24

Discussion A silly scene I imagined between Mon Mothma and her daughter

1 Upvotes

This scene is definitely not going to happen, but I just felt like sharing it.

It's implied that Lieda, Mon's daughter, suspects that she's cheating on Perrin with Tay. So one night, Mon leaves for a secret Rebel meeting and Lieda follows her to get proof.

Mon is waiting in the meeting place as Lieda watches from a hiding place. Tay walks in. Then Luthen. Then Cassian. The Kleya. Then Vel.

Lieda: "My mom's about to have an orgy!" 🤢


r/andor • • Mar 07 '25

Discussion I wouldn't mind a more overt tie-in reference to "Rebels" in "Andor" season 2

4 Upvotes

I LOVE that season 1 included some blink-and-you'll-miss-them references and Easter eggs from other stories, while still largely standing on its own as a story within the Star Wars universe.

Since season 2 is building up directly to Rogue One, though, and since we know Mon Mothma has direct interactions with the Ghost crew, I have to confess I'd be STOKED if more Rebels events were directly mentioned in season 2.

Anyway, April 22 can't come fast enough!!


r/andor • • Jan 09 '25

Discussion Keep Office Jargon in Empire only Going Forward

0 Upvotes

I enjoyed the "corporate empire" of Andor a lot including the inclusion of contemporary office jargon into the dialogue - Syril talks about how he could be of use "going forward", The Aldhani imperials use that phrase too "they'll have that going forward". BUT, unfortunately it shows up in Luthen's dialogue as well "Going forward, there will be no rules." Let's keep the heroes/anti-heroes free of corporate jargon in the next season, please :-)


r/andor • • Jun 22 '25

General Discussion After watching Andor this scene kinda feels wrong

1 Upvotes

So after watching Andor I rewatched Rogue One. This scene hits different now. When I first watched Rogue One this scene felt like a couple who was sorry they didn’t have more time to share their feelings for each other. It was a tragic scene. Now I feel like no way Cass would be looking at a strange women with loving eyes like that after we all saw what him and Bix went through. Plus we got to know Cass more with the show and we all know he wouldn’t just develop feelings for someone so easily. This scene now feels like it doesn’t belong or it’s way out of character for Cass.

It might just be me though. I feel like the show ruined this scene. I still love the movie and the show just made it better in some regards, but this scene is not one of them.


r/andor • • Jul 29 '25

Theory & Analysis Anti-Capitalist Sci-Fi Decoded: Andor, Hunger Games, and Severance

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
2 Upvotes

r/andor • • Jun 12 '25

Media & Art My mom is struggling with Mon Mothma’s name

Post image
4 Upvotes

So she’s calling her mothman. She’s the one who introduced me to Star Wars. So I had AI create me an image which I found hilarious.