r/agnostic • u/scoopsicle • Aug 30 '12
r/agnostic • u/Macboogie • Jun 18 '22
Agnostic is just atheism with commitment issues, change my mind.
Believing the burden of proof hasn’t been met is at the core of both. Saying “we can’t know” or “idk” seems like a cop out or philosophical rhetoric trying to make it seem deeper than it is. Saying you don’t know is in itself disbelief because it’s not belief and this topic is binary I don’t feel you can kinda believe either you do or don’t. what’s happening is both don’t believe. Why they don’t believe is because both feel the burden of proof hasn’t been met.
I didn’t come here to insult or argue this is just the position I’ve held for many years. So I came to ask you what do you feel provides a true valuable distinction between the two?
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Sep 08 '21
Original idea God is the only way humans can understand our existence.
What other alternatives do humans offer? Science? Science is simply a model of the conscious experience that we call life. What lies beyond perception, and how can humans hope to know this? Where does the assumption that life is meaningless come from, certainly not our perceptions? There is undoubtable unity and beauty in the creation of the universe, in science and mathematics, the symmetry present in nature from the stars to the oceans. Clearly, this was not the result of chance. What is chance anyway, but another word for missing variables? It's quite egotistical of humans to assume that reality can be comprehended completely by our feeble brains, or that there is no higher reality. Our realities while alive and human are limited to our perceptions, but what if there are ways to experience higher/spiritual conscious experiences? What if life was not random, and death was not nothingness, but perhaps life itself is the illusion and existence is the underlying reality? How then could we decipher what's real and what isn't without invoking a higher consciousness than the one present in the illusion of perception?
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Dec 16 '21
Testimony This life is fucking difficult to live without a god. I am going back to christianism before it's too late
I'm going through some shit and, like, I feel hopeless. There is no hope for a better future. I put a lot of faith in myself, that I'll be able to overcome the difficulties and arise victorious, but I'm just a human! I am frail and I can fail. Having someone to believe in is fucking useful, as I don't have to go through hardships alone.
I have decided to go back to christianism after 3 years of agnosticism. I can't stand being sad and hopeless anymore. Hugs to y'all and I hope you succeed in your journey, wherever it may take you
r/agnostic • u/zerooskul • Jul 01 '23
Rant I was an atheist but then realized that my arguments against god were equally arguments against atheism, it is a belief asserted as truth about an idea about god, which is unknowable, exactly like religion.
Your idea of god exists in your head.
Evetybody's idea of god exists in their head.
You exist in your head, and therefore--as: I think therefore I am--you exist.
The idea of god exists as much as your own sense of being as yourself.
Does it exist any more than that?
I don't know, but it definitely exists in the mind of every person who has an idea about it.
Since everybody's idea about it is different, religion makes no sense, because the idea of god in any mind and the words that describe it and what they mean to the person who so describes it is different, just as every mind is different.
Apparently, most atheists are actually irreligious and when asked about god they will point at religion and their opinion of religion, not god.
Irreligious means hostile to religion.
Areligious means not influenced by religion.
Atheist means one who knows there is no god.
These terms are not interchangeable, yet "atheists" seem to believe or insist that since religious rule is often terrible, that means there is no god.
That's not even correlation.
These people are irreligious and preaching about god to each other.
So I am irreligious, and I see atheism, especially organized groups of atheists, with as much evidence as the most pious zealot has about god, discussing their ideas about the true nature of god, as being a religion.
I wish I could be areligious but I doubt people are ever going to shut up about their ideas about what god is and isn't which is all speculation based on no evidence.
I was raised areligious till I was 4, then I d2aw a movie called "Oh, God!" Starring George Burns, and that was my personal introduction to it and that is who I still picture.
My mother got religion when I was 5 or 6 and decided to keep attending services up to the end of her life.
When I was about 14, it dawned on me that these people really believed it. And I saw this as a mass hysteria guiding lives for generations and I quit.
Nobody knows. Don't worry about it, right now. Try to be nice and try to be happy and try to avoid extreme conflict.
Be civil.
Live till you die, and you'll either find out then or there's nothing to ever find out, so you won't, and that's it.
Who knows?
Maybe it's George Burns singing "Old Bones" over and over for eternity. Not very likely, but who knows?
Nobody.
r/agnostic • u/raindogmx • Jun 20 '24
Opinion: Agnostic-atheism is just a meme
I can't find any definitions for agnostic-atheism or any of the gnostic/agnostic-theist/atheist axes combinations outside of r/atheism, 4chan, and other internet boards. Even the Wikipedia page for Agnostic Atheism seems to be very weakly supported with only a couple of citations.
Do you believe in the two axes? Do you know any sources for it other than posts? Or do you agree it's not much more than an internet meme?
r/agnostic • u/fastpenguin91 • Jun 03 '16
Comparing "God" to the Flying Spaghetti Monster is dumb
A Flying Spaghetti Monster is fabricated purely for ridiculing religion. Of course the Flying Spaghetti Monster does not exist. You made it up in your mind to make a statement.
Religious beliefs, however, are probably fabricated, but there's a lot more room for truth, error, and interpretation of "God".
First, you immediately compare God to the flying spaghetti monster, but you haven't defined God.
God could be the God of the bible, God of the Quran, some higher being that intentionally confused us all because it wants us to not know, God could be "a guy in a cubicle" controlling the computer program we live in, or God could be all of us, and every atom/singularity in existence is part of one collective consciousness, [insert thousands of other definitions of God here...]
Also, Christianity, or Islam, or whatever, could very possibly be true as well. I have my doubts about the books that men have wrote, AKA the Bible/Quran/insert_other_books. But the deity behind them could very possibly existed, and man just ruined the books by mis-interpreting (Notice how confused the disciples were by Jesus's teachings.) So sure, the Bible may be horribly butchered by man, but the "Creator of the universe" they were referring to could likely exist, and even satisfy many scientific theories/facts like Evolution, etc...
Maybe God really told the author of Genesis to write "In the beginning there was a Big bang... and over millions of years..." or to not write anything at all, perhaps?
It's entirely possible (practically guaranteed) that man screwed up the religious texts, so we don't even have a good foundation to work with in the first place.
It's also hard to discredit something that was written thousands of years ago about a man that lived way back then. I'm uncomfortable saying Jesus didn't rise from the dead because those events took place so long ago that it's even difficult to get historical texts that talk about it.
So comparing God to the Flying Spaghetti Monster is ridiculous. some form of a God is a very reasonable theory. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is a shitty analogy Atheists use to ridicule others.
TLDR:
Man wrote Bible/Quran. Man is stupid/greedy/malicious and probably mis-interpreted God from Genesis to Revalation, just because books are probably wrong doesn't mean the deity they refer to doesn't exist. God could be a million different things. Religious texts are thousands of years old, and date back to beginning of humanity.
The existence of some form of God is MUCH more likely than the existence of a Flying Spaghetti Monster, and comparing God to a flying spaghetti monster, the Tooth fairy, or anything like it makes you a hardcore douchebag.
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Nov 14 '22
Original idea my theory on after life
What if people that tries to be good all go to hell, and the people who truly set themselves free to live by their deepest desires, the ones that we as a society consider to be the sickest ones.. they all go to heaven, because they are being true. what if evil is our true self? everyone when no one is watching or judging, they reveal their inner secrets, deep web is the perfect example... any thoughts?
r/agnostic • u/No_Practice688 • May 11 '25
Advice Converting to a Islam for a guy?
Hi I am seeking some guidance about a dilemma I am facing at the moment.
For some context, I (20/F) am an Agnostic Indian, and I met this Muslim guy (20/M) as he became my mentor in an organization we are both in. Despite the circumstances, we both caught feelings for each other, and he confessed his feelings. However, recently we were talking and he told me, "I don't want to freak you out because it's so early on, but I need to know whether you are willing to convert to Islam because that is the only way this would be able to work out down the line". He reasoned that he doesn't want to enter into a relationship if there is an expiration date because the only way his family would accept something long-term is if I were (at least on paper) a Muslim.
Islam and the community/values that come with it are very important to him and his family. Even though he doesn't feel the need to impress the same amount of commitment for it onto me, it is important to him that I am also "Muslim".
Culturally, I have no issue embracing his practices and traditions. I have a lot of Muslim friends and can see the good that the religion brings (I can even see it as something that I am able to eventually love and practice if I come to it on my own terms).
Where I do take issue is that I don't know if I would be able to honestly call myself a Muslim just because a guy needs me to be. Something I deeply value in myself is my strong-willed nature and my autonomy, and if my only reasoning for conversion were to appease a guy, it makes me feel like a fraud. Additionally, I don't know if conversion would even make me suddenly accepted... will I always be an outsider?
I fear that if I tell him 'yes' now and then change my mind when things get more serious because I realize that I don't want to convert, then I am setting us both up for heartbreak. But at the same time, if I say 'no' now, I might regret losing this really great guy over something that I might not even really mind doing (aka converting). Even though he said I can always change my mind in the future, and he won't hold it against me, I can't in good conscience do that to him (and selfishly, I don't want to set myself up for a potential painful experience).
I don't know I'm just so confused. I wouldn't be in this dilemma if I didn't feel like this is a human that I saw a really great and fulfilling future with but it is... I also don't even know why I am going to Reddit for guidance but maybe you guys would be able to offer some fresh perspectives for me.
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • May 22 '22
Rant To everyone downvoting my post the other day: are you sure you’re on the right sub?
I posted this the other day: https://www.reddit.com/r/agnostic/comments/uuf6aa/what_if_every_death_results_into_its_own_big_bang/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
Since you want to take it so literally, this is the definition of agnostic:
a person who believes that nothing is known or can be known of the existence or nature of God or of anything beyond material phenomena; a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God.
So that begs the question, if you are agnostic, and nothing can truly be known about the immaterial, why are you correcting me, talking about “a lot of what if’s don’t make that” and etc. if ANY what if is questionable? Does it have to make sense for you in a assuring way, perhaps I should’ve included an argument by design?
Are you sure you’re on the right sub? If you just thought the idea was crap and downvoted it, fine, but it doesn’t make logical sense for any of you to want to downvote it because of the absence of EVIDENCE that it is correct 🥴
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Jan 31 '26
Rant Being an atheist is a choice — and not making fun of theists at the same time is one too.
Atheists are sick of being disrespected for their beliefs, so why must we not resepct theists beliefs? I know they haven't treated up very right, but not treating them right either or calling them dumb etc makes us the part of the problem too. No, not many atheists are like this, but at the same time, many are. Many make fun and say rude things to and about people who believe in god.
r/agnostic • u/David_Smith04707 • Apr 07 '24
The rapture in Christianity is starting to seem a bit off
I'm not sure if I even have to explain but if you know you know. Does anyone just think this seems a bit weird what's been going on lately and that it's starting to really look like how the bible is explaining it? By the way I'm an agnostic pantheist so just keep that in mind.
r/agnostic • u/Curious_Suchit • Jun 02 '24
What are some effective parenting strategies to raise a 3-year-old child as an atheist, and to nurture logical, rational, and critical thinking skills? Looking for advice and tips.
Looking for advice on effective parenting strategies to nurture these qualities.
r/agnostic • u/NewRedSpyder • Sep 13 '22
Some atheists are just as bad, if not even worse, than some religious people in terms of forcing their beliefs and I dislike being lumped in with them.
Certain atheists swear that they’re so intelligent and that all religious people are stupid, immoral, or mentally ill. They throw the same rhetoric that some religious people do, yet bitch about it when when they receive it back? While they’re right in the sense that there is no evidence of a God, there’s also no definitive proof that there isn’t one either so claiming that there isn’t a diety of any sorts isn’t the revolutionary genius “gotcha” claim that they think it is. Obviously not all or even most atheists think like this, but it’s enough for them to be heard (especially on Reddit).
r/agnostic • u/tcmaster5000 • Sep 24 '19
Why bother with the term “agnostic”?
Atheism is the state of not being convinced by theistic claims. If agnosticism is the state of not knowing whether or not these claims are true, then you are, by definition, unconvinced that these claims ARE true. If you aren’t convinced that they are true, then you can’t believe that they are. If you don’t believe that they’re true, then you’re an atheist. Now, you might argue that one may not definitively know whether or not a claim is true, but believe that it is, but the point is that no one can KNOW with absolute certainty whether or not a god exists which still leaves the term “agnostic” useless because everyone is an agnostic (whether they claim they are or not). Just call yourself either an atheist or theist based on what you believe to be true.
Edit: changed some words and phrases for brevity and clarity.
Edit: My point is NOT that all agnostics are atheists. My point IS that people are agnostic whether they are theist or atheist (if you aren’t convinced that religious claims are true, you’re an atheist) because absolute knowledge about the existence of god cannot be obtained. If everyone’s an agnostic, what’s the point of the label?
r/agnostic • u/Ill_Honey3693 • 14d ago
Can someone be a genuinely good person without religion?
I grew up in South Africa during apartheid.
My father was an ordinary man who believed in treating people with dignity.
During those difficult years, he sometimes allowed Black workers to shelter in his garage when they were at risk of being stopped for being out after curfew.
When asked why he helped them, his answer was simple:
"They are people just like us."
Those words stayed with me throughout my life.
Today, as I reflect on faith, love, conscience and the meaning of being human, I find myself asking:
Does religion teach us to be compassionate, or is compassion already part of who we are?
I believe faith can bring meaning and comfort. But I also believe kindness belongs to all humanity, regardless of religious belief.
What do you think? Can goodness exist independently of religion?
I would love to hear your experiences, whether you are religious, nonreligious or still searching.
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Mar 18 '24
Did atheists changed their beliefs/arguments over time ?
I’ve been reading about atheism and different religions for a long time but mainly reading Islamic books. But if I remember correctly atheists would make the argument that the big bang theory is where life started and it expanded and still continuing and that’s how life came from nothing. I remember reading in especially Islamic books trying to either disprove atheism that life doesn’t come from nothing or how the Quran already knew about the Big Bang 1400 years ago before scientists did.
Here’s an example at 0:07:04 https://youtu.be/HONF5YsqdUs?si=sz01EZvWoXliIXgT
But now that I’m watching atheist content on YouTube recently a lot seem to act like they never said the big bang is where life started or that we came from nothing. I know atheism doesn’t have an obligation to defend or prove anything and science can change but it just sounds more like denying and back peddling in most of the videos I watched. Anyone else notice or am I misinterpreting?
Also please no need to downvote this post it won’t get interactions that way. I’m just asking questions and want to clear up my confusion here. I thought this sub won’t be as triggered as the atheist sub so you can just state that you disagree or put thumbs down emoji in the comments we will be fine :)
EDIT: So everyone here says they have never heard of any atheists (or theists) say what I said above well that is so weird because how did I get this confused. I must be retarded then sorry
r/agnostic • u/FrogMantra • Oct 23 '16
We will always fall short in our attempts to understand God with our intelligence.
Modern science is finding the same about the universe too, which, the Vedic literatures state, is a product of God’s super intelligence. Centuries of cosmological research has increased scientific information, but not scientific understanding, because of “two” unexpected trends:
--The more scientists know, the more they realize how little they know – Science “conquered” space – and realized how little it knew about space. To the uninformed, space missions proved human greatness. To the well informed, they showed human smallness. Space research reveals that there are more stars in the universe than all the grains of sand on all the beaches of earth, and our sun is just one of these cosmic grains. No wonder former President of the American Association for the Advancement of Science Kenneth R Boulding admitted, “Cosmology… is likely to be very insecure because it studies a very large universe with a small and biased sample.”
--The more scientists know, the more they realize what they previously “knew” was wrong – Newton’ laws were considered bedrock truths of physics till they were found inapplicable in the microscopic and the macroscopic realms. Quantum physics was developed to explain the atomic world, and relativistic physics for the cosmic. But then both of them turned out to be violently contradictory. As both have to coexist at the origin of the universe – when both the microscopic and the macroscopic were one, science had the formidable challenge of devising with a Theory of Everything (ToE) to unify these irreconcilable pillars of science. Let’s review the history of the development of the ToE: Initial vain roar: Physicist Leon Lederman, former president of the American Physical Society, “we hope to explain the entire universe in a single, simple formula that you can wear on your T-shirt.” Subsequent exasperated grunt: Astrophysicist Steven Weinberg, a Nobel laureate in physics, “As we make progress understanding the expanding universe, the problem itself expands, so that the solution always seems to recede from us,” Final concealed whimper: Theoretical physicist John Wheeler of Princeton University, “Never run after a bus or woman or cosmological theory, because there’ll always be another one in a few minutes.” Going back to the pastime, the rope Mother Yashoda was trying to tie around Krishna was only two fingers short. But the rope of ToE that science has been trying to tie around the universe is not only short, but also broken, as Stephen Hawking confessed, “The theories (in physics) we have so far are both inconsistent and incomplete.” Mother Yashoda did eventually succeed in tying Krishna – but only after when Krishna, by His own grace, let Himself be bound. Similarly science can understand the universe, especially our place and purpose within it – but only when it harmonizes with super intelligence by researching and applying the verifiable spiritual science delineated in BG, thus paving the way for spiritual revelation. That’s not as unscientific as it may sound. A scientist no lesser than founder of quantum physics Nobel Laureate Max Planck stated, ” For religion, God is at the beginning; for science, God is at the end.” And science has started reaching that end by its discovery of “fine tuning” of the universe – micro-precise adjustment of the values and inter-relationships of at least 80 parameters essential for life. Obviously fine-tuning needs a fine tuner. Of course, diehard devotees of atheism have proposed chance and multiple universe theories, but these are all intrinsically unproven and unprovable. They fit better the realm of science-fiction than science. When scientists accept the verdict of their own evidence, they will remove the obstacle in a long-overdue spiritual leap of science. Lest they hesitate or falter in this bold step, renowned physicist Micheal Faraday’s reminder can urge them on, “We ought to value the privilege of knowing God’s truth far beyond anything we can have in this world.”
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Jul 27 '17
I'm agnostic and I hate atheists
What the title says, and I mean the 'militant' atheists who whine and complain about Christians all day and make sarcastic comments on their shit subs and internet sites. I'd call myself an atheist but I want nothing to do with that crowd of buffoons. I like normal people - religious or not. edit obviously not all atheists people, you know the type I'm talking about. They're basically a hate group - I can't stand when people spend their energies hating others and that's what the shitty 'militant' atheists do.. worse still is that they try to put agnostics into their category - 'atheists and agnostics have had it with your fairy tales and your imaginary sky daddy you delusional religitards!' - Shitty attitudes like that deserved to be slapped down in itself, trying to include me into that shit makes you 10 times worse, fuck the atheists (the shitty ones like you find on r/atheism, not the regular ones who can act like an adult)
r/agnostic • u/JJK_415 • May 09 '22
Why couldnt theist and atheist be at peace?
Do you have this feeling were you are confuse on what to believe in, whether it is science or religion. After watching a lot of videos on youtube about religious debates, I wonder why couldnt this people just respect each other's belief. I believe that both sides are just close minded and dont want to learn from each other.
r/agnostic • u/SamuelColeridgeValet • Feb 22 '16
Carl Sagan's demonstration of 4-dimensional reality is helping people with extistential crises at r/anxiety
Edit - Actually, I would prefer if you DON'T comment here.
Edit - Well, I did get a lot of comments, but they've all been deleted.
In spite of all the conversation, this post still hasn't gone above zero. In contrast, the post about near-brainwashing Catholicism by teen subredditor Gummybugger is doing great. This has got me thinking. Why not a separate sub just for teenagers? I'm thinking somebody like Gummybugger could do this or Mr.Sleepy Head, the kid who just deleted all his comments.
An anxious subredditor has just said,
I feel like this existence is pointless and makes no sense I don't know what to do I fear death so much cause it's insane to me and it's ruining my life I can't think of anything else.
any advice for this?
to which I said,
People have told me this is encouraging.
Maybe I should start with some philosophy. In his book Republic, Plato related the story of a soldier named Er who was thought dead but revived days after he was wounded. The story of Er is what we would call a near-death experience story. Because he was a philosopher, Plato tried to figure this kind of thing out. With his Cave Analogy, he presented the idea of human bodies being like "shadows," because we exist in a reality beyond three dimensions. So, he said, when the 3-D body no longer exists, the person still exists, just as something would still exist if its shadow on a cave wall went away.
If that sounds like a screwy idea, here's Carl Sagan talking about a 3-D object as the shadow of a 4-D object.
(It's kind of long. You can take my word for it.)
(3 points so far.)
PLEASE, DON'T TELL THIS GUY ABOUT SAGAN'S DEBUNKED CHILDBIRTH EXPLANATION OF NDE!
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • May 18 '20
Why are atheists afraid to debate agnostics and deists?
I used to be an agnostic and all they ever did was call me a liar and then fling the stupid arguments at me that are specifically about Christianity, as if they're relevant. Same now as a deist.
r/agnostic • u/sgavary • Nov 21 '22
Rant I feel like this sub is turning into a sub for just hating religion.
Most of the posts I’ve been seeing here are just rants about why religion is bad this and that, when I first joined this sub I thought there were true agnostics that didn’t lean towards one side too much (Which would allow discussions that would get us somewhere), but now it feels like r/atheism lite.
r/agnostic • u/Fit-Adhesiveness9127 • Jun 13 '25
At 27 years old I'm beginning to believe in "god"
Helloooo. I'm currently in the midst of what I would consider a spiritual crisis. My whole life I have leaned on the side of atheism, as I got older I came to the conclusion that there is just no way to get answers for thr questions I have, and I kind of just pushed spirituality to the very back of my brain and was always fairly certain that God did not exist in any form or fashion.
I've always been the very open minded free thinker type, and as a kid my mother always let me make decisions for myself in terms of religion and sports and what not. She never forced anything on me, although she is Lutheran. When I was a little kid I decided I wanted to start going to church, so she took me. Within 2 visits I had determined that everyone in that building was a lunatic, and it always seemed extremely silly to me that people can be convinced of the things written in religious texts. Basically I thought I was smarter than everyone, so I never went back.
I have an EXTREMELY dark, grotesque past. As a recovering drug addict of 14 years, I've seen a thing or two. And unfortunately every negative experience I've ever had was used as ammo in my little personal war against spirituality. "If God existed, he couldn't possibly allow this to happen" right? Horrible thinking.
I'm 27 now. Been sober for 2 and a half years. Things aren't great right now but they aren't bad. I recently got engaged to a woman who I believe is the most incredible human on this planet. And I believe that her entrance in to my life is what started this little snowball effect of religious conflict in my head.
Since I've met her, over time I've slowly started to feel something more. Something I've never felt. I can't explain what the feeling is, and to be honest with you, I'm completely terrified. I'm starting to feel like everything I've spent my whole life believing in, is just crumbling apart and I have to find a way to embrace this new feeling and these new beliefs in to my life... I Don't know if any of this makes sense, or if anybody is even gonna make it thos far in my post, but if you did, I would like to thank you for taking the time to read about my nonsense.