r/agnostic • u/abillonfire • Oct 02 '12
r/agnostic • u/bill-pilgrim • Mar 02 '20
This Carl Sagan quote is the best explanation of why I do not concern myself with religion or atheism.
“I would love to believe that when I die I will live again, that some thinking, feeling, remembering part of me will continue. But much as I want to believe that, and despite the ancient and worldwide cultural traditions that assert an afterlife, I know of nothing to suggest that it is more than wishful thinking.
The world is so exquisite with so much love and moral depth, that there is no reason to deceive ourselves with pretty stories for which there’s little good evidence. Far better it seems to me, in our vulnerability, is to look death in the eye and to be grateful every day for the brief but magnificent opportunity that life provides.”
— Carl Sagan
r/agnostic • u/ajmadrid123 • Jul 14 '21
Rant Let‘s not become a sub for shittalking religion. This mindset doesn‘t lay a foundation for any meaningful or productive discussion.
People don‘t get the point of religion. That‘s the problem. I get that for a lot of people in here the resentment towards religion is personal. It was for me as well. I grew up in a very religious family and became the only one to question it. But I’ve also grown to understand why they thought the way they did. My family comes from very poor circustances. The whole point of religion is to unite people into smaller groups and communities to work towards a common goal. If the world and the whole economic system and infrastructure was to fall apart tomorrow and the few survivors left had to rebuild, I would found a religion to make people work together. The belief of a higher power watching over them makes people feel safer than they normally would be, or more comfortable than they would be otherwise. It gives hope to the hopeless. If you face true despair and have nothing left to turn to, it can save you. Even if it may be based on a lie or story. This is why religion is usually more prevalent in poorer or more unstable regions. It gives people with nothing comfort. Yes I am aware that it can be easily be corrupted or abused. But this is not unique to religion. Nor is war or discrimination. It‘s just human nature. Facebook was created to connect people. Now it got corrupted and is a giant mess. Reddit as well. Or any government. Let‘s also not pretend that science and technology aren‘t responsible for the creation of nucleor bombs, or other weapons. Everything made by men for any reason, even for good, eventually get corrupted. That shouldn‘t stop us from trying to connect and rebuild and be better. Don’t blame people for turning to a „higher power“ in times of struggle. If you truly want to take down religion, you should start with fixing the social and economical imbalances that force people to turn to religion and raise their children to be the same. I say this not to defend religion but as a true agnostic. Fixing what is wrong with the world starts with empathy and understanding, not hate.
r/agnostic • u/UndeadMarine55 • May 09 '19
A stoic’s take on Agnosticism, courtesy of Marcus Aurelious
r/agnostic • u/idkdjvdibdub • Jan 02 '20
What that turned me into an agnostic:
“If all religious books were destroyed, in a 1000 years time, it wouldn’t come back just as it was. Whereas, if we take a science book, it would all be proven again.”
Bruh I’m shooketh
r/agnostic • u/sgavary • Sep 06 '20
Rant If your religion does not punish those who don't hear about it then for everyone's own good please do not spread it.
Some Religions like certain branches of Christianity, or Islam state that those who do not hear the message will not be held accountable for upholding the rules, meaning by telling others about the religion you are giving them a liability to follow the rules, meaning you just made their lives harder. Like let's say we have a Russian Pig Farmer who learns about Islam, this mean the Russian guy would now have to sell his pig farm, and follow numerous rules that make his already difficult life even more difficult, had he not been told he would have not have that liability. So it would be in everyone's best interest if religions like this did not try to evangelize others.
r/agnostic • u/wordsiwouldntsay • May 21 '20
Most people are born into a religion and don't consider other religions to be an option
Most people are born into a religion believing it is the true word of God and they don't bat an eye to any other religion, dismissing them to be "wrong". In science, we would discuss all variables before coming up to a conclusion. In religion, that is hardly the case - you almost never hear of an instance where someone tries out many religions as a test run before settling into one they believe to be the truth.
In fact, I've heard of instances where the opposite happens - they try out different religions before deciding none of it is real. That's what happened to me after taking a religion course and going to various churches.
Note: Although I believe religion was created as a series of coincidences and way to construct morality/society, I don't think it has no place in this world, nor do I fully dismiss it. Religion is a powerful way to bring people together and give you a sense of hope and purpose in this meaningless universe. But we can't prove God exists or prove God doesn't exist, and often times religion creates unhealthy echo chambers that results in toxic behavior. Certainly doesn't help if someone is born into a religion and never challenges it.
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Feb 08 '13
"I don't know" is a legitimate answer (x/post from r/atheism)
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Apr 30 '20
Advice As a young agnostic and an admirer of Stoicism, I adored this quote from the last great Roman Emperor.
“Live a good life. If there are gods and they are just, then they will not care how devout you have been, but will welcome you based on the virtues you have lived by. If there are gods, but unjust, then you should not want to worship them. If there are no gods, then you will be gone, but will have lived a noble life that will live on in the memories of your loved ones.”
Marcus Aurelius
r/agnostic • u/Noe_Wunn • Mar 16 '21
How could you enjoy Heaven if your loved one was suffering in Hell?
I wasn't there to see it, but my former pastor did. Years ago, there was a guy who volunteered to speak to the church one Sunday. He spoke of how he himself was a born again Christian, but his father was not. This man had spent much time trying to lead his father to Christ, but his father repeatedly rejected the idea. One day, the father passed away without ever accepting Jesus. The son, who was now beside himself with grief, believed his father was in Hell. As the man who was telling the story got to this part, my former pastor said he could hear people in the audience start to sniffle and cry over this gut wrenching story.
For a long time after I heard this story, I often wondered if what Christianity teaches about the afterlife is true, then how could a person who made it to Heaven be in bliss, while a loved one (spouse, parent, child, friend) was in eternal torment in Hell? How could you enjoy Heaven with that knowledge? Not only would I ask how could you, but would you even want to? If God saw you crying over your loved one who was in Hell, would you even want him to snap his fingers and somehow just magically take away your grief over it? Because my answer (as I'm sure many other people's answer is) would be "no". What I would want is for my loved one to be rescued. Or what I might even tell God is that he can just go ahead and condemn me with them, because I couldn't just abandon that person even if God had.
I've even heard Christians try to explain this concern away, and use the line about how "God will wipe away every tear from their eye". But again, would you even want him to do that? If the person in this world who you love most died and went to Hell, are you telling me that when you get to Heaven and you find out he/she didn't make it, you are going to just shrug you shoulders and say "Sucks to be them"?
r/agnostic • u/[deleted] • Nov 29 '20
I find comfort in the idea that life is meaningless and there is nothing after death
If there is no god, than there is no god. If there is a god or gods, I like to think that they have no concern for us whatsoever, that we are just a product of the infinite university that they've created. That there is nothing after death. I like that.
It gives me a sense of freedom and control over my own life. I don't have to worry about following someone else's teachings or morals in fear of a hell. I am free to live my best life on my own terms and morals. To do what I believe is right and to improve the world around me the best that I can before I die. That u can do whatever u want without worrying about something being "forbidden". I don't want life to have a meaning that I have to follow. I want to create my own meaning.
r/agnostic • u/Deeperthanajeep • Jan 08 '21
Argument I don't want to exist in a universe where there's even a possibility of the Christian god being real
I know it's unlikely that Christianity is the true religion but there could still be a 0.0001 chance that the god of the universe chose to go only to Jerusalem to do miracles and If you don't believe that then he will torture you for eternity, honestly I don't even want to exist in a universe where that's even a possibility of being the truth and I don't even know why christians and conservatives are so desperate to defend their faith, their faith literally involves a deity who will torture them for eternity if theyre gay or have sex before marriage, I wish my parents or anyone's parents had half a brain and thought maybe we shouldn't bring a child into a universe where there's a possibility our all loving god might end up torturing it forever...sigh...end rant...
r/agnostic • u/RandomAnt_01 • Jul 17 '22
Why aren't Americans leaving Christianity in droves?!?
We have now seen what happens when you let religious nuts gain power, and then lose it by popular mandate, so why are so many (including our youth) sucked in by fairy tales from a bygone, barbaric age?
r/agnostic • u/No_Trouble_No_Fuss • Jan 08 '22
Why can't people just accept/admit we have no idea where we came from, why we are here or where we go when it ends?
I guess it's fear and indoctrination? I rarely meet other agnostic people in real life.... Curious on the opinions of others who consider themselves agnostic.
r/agnostic • u/Sciencemusk • Sep 07 '20
We can't disprove that god or an omnipotent being exists, but we can agree most religions have it wrong, right?
I do appreciate the positive side of religion and am not against people believing whatever the hell they want.
But seeing things from a logical point of view, even if a omnipotent being exists, responsible for all creation, it's highly unlikely any human religion has gotten it right.
I do believe that someone or something could have created the universe willingly and I believe there is no way to disprove that, and I guess there's where my agnosticism comes from.
r/agnostic • u/Ohcaptainmycaptain18 • Jun 11 '22
Rant I’m tired of hearing that agnosticism is not a legitimate position to take in regards to God/afterlife
It seems like whenever agnostics tell people they are agnostic, they are often met with the “Ahh, no you’re not,” and then presented with the epistemology (gnostic/agnostic) vs belief (theist/atheist) scale as if it’s supposed to be some kind of “gotcha” moment. And I’m just tired of that because in my experience, agnostics are usually people who have thought long and hard about their position and are well aware of this model. I myself am aware, but I resent the fact that “I don’t know” in regards to these questions is oftentimes not considered legitimate. I am neither in the “I believe in God” or “I don’t believe in God” camps. I don’t believe I have any way to access that kind of knowledge or prove/disprove the idea of a God being out there somewhere. It’s not because I’m actually an atheist and just clinging onto some semblance of belief, and it’s not because I haven’t made up my mind yet. It’s because I DO believe that it is completely beyond my human limitations to know or comprehend the origins of the universe or what exists or doesn’t exist in the fabric of all of reality.
r/agnostic • u/ccmcdonald0611 • Aug 15 '22
If God wants to forgive everyone's sins, then why doesn't he just do it?
Who is God trying to impress? Presumably, himself since he is simultaneously the judge, jury, executioner as well as the perpetual victim.
r/agnostic • u/ConfidentRow • Oct 14 '20
Argument You only know about God because someone told you about it.
Random thought- Let's say three years after you were born, your parents took you to a remote Island and left you there all alone. It's pretty remote and nobody will ever hear or rescue you. Let's also say that somehow you figured out how to survive on that remote island and learned various survival skills all by yourself. Soon, after a few years, you grow up to be a young person with no access to any books, technology, or other people whatsoever.
Essentially, you'll have no idea about what/who God is.
Obviously the above is a hypothetical situation that is unlikely to happen in real life. But, my question is, Is the idea of god just social conditioning from books, relatives,friends, parents etc?
r/agnostic • u/HskrRooster • May 05 '21
Rant The fact that there are “other” religions is the reason I can not believe in one.
Hey all, new to this sub. I’ve had an up and down journey with religion since I was raised in a pretty strict catholic environment. I always had that looming fear that god was watching everything and I better not mess up “or else”. So I never felt comfortable questioning things for fear of punishment.
Now that I’ve been able to separate myself and open my eyes I can say I’m firmly agnostic. For me it was a simple realization that the fact that there are hundreds of religions completely discredits the possibility of ONE being the right one. Religions also steal things from others or just morph other things into their own ideology like the stars and space in general. Most religions always have some sort of basis in the stars.
For example with Christianity the story of Jesus’ resurrection is just correlated to the sun and the winter solstice. The sun gets to its lowest point in the sky for 3 days and then starts to “rise” again. I see things like this and it just exposes religion to me. It all seems like a giant brainwashing system to keep people domesticated and give them a false reason to be “good” people.