r/againstharassment • • Oct 10 '17

How Reddit harasses Asian women into silence: A tell-all from an /r/asianamerican mod

363 Upvotes

A disclaimer: These are my thoughts only and do not represent those of my co-moderators, or fellow Asian women, or anyone else with whom I am vaguely affiliated. What I am about to describe using terms such as Asian Women and Asian Men should only be taken in the context of Reddit (and really only the corner that concerns Asian American subreddits) and are not meant to be read in the general sense. I will not answer any questions about moderation as we make decisions as a group and not individually. Please message /r/asianamerican for that.

TLDR: This is the story of how an Asian american feminist woman began moderating /r/asianamerican in 2013 and became bullied and harassed into no longer participating in the subreddit in any meaningful way beyond basic moderation duties.

In the Beginning

I considered /r/asianamerican a breath of fresh air compared to larger Reddit which I found extremely misogynistic and racist. I had thought I found my version of /r/blackladies. By invitation from /u/quadshock in 2013, I applied to become a moderator of /r/asianamerican and to my surprise, I'm invited to become one. Earlier in my time as mod, I was more open about my personal life and more willing to engage in conversations about my current and past relationships. However I begin to notice the unfortunate trend that the sub is unfriendly to any posts that called out misogyny. Posters would frequently downvote articles, report posts, and claim that feminist posts were unrelated to Asian American topics. As a self-identified feminist and Asian American, I try writing about the way feminism informs my understanding of racial justice and am always downvoted.

About three years ago, I start receiving harassment in regards to my relationship status as an Asian woman dating a white man. These are coupled with multiple messages to Quadshock that he was letting me run the show, alongside messages demeaning tripostrophe about their gender identity. Postings to the subreddit that are just naked obvious hating on Asian women not dating their race start happening with disturbing frequency. My fellow mods try to convince me that these are just a handful of trolls or one singular troll, and not indicative of a disturbing misogynistic trend. At this time I contemplate leaving the mod team, but on their advice and the promise that we would add more female mods, I stay.

Around the same time /r/asianmasculinity pops up and /r/hapas shortly after. Both these subreddits were disgustingly red-pill, misogynistic and homophobic. They nakedly demeaned women and gay Asian men and spoke of them derogatory ways and showed no signs of slowing down. We decided as a mod team to disassociate ourselves with them. Meanwhile they egged on their users into harassing us, breaking site rules like circumventing bans, and talking shit about us 1 2 3 4. Here's an album of posts from their users taken in early 2015 that show a slight taste of what subreddits like these discussed and condoned. They invented new terms to denigrate in their minds traitor Asian women--Mentally Colonized Geishas, pigchasers, Anna Lu. Any woman perceived to even somewhat struggled with internalized racism, either in the past or in the current gets painted with this same brush. The ironic thing is the representation of "Anna Lu" is a real woman whose likeness was stolen to fuel this hatred by a white dude, and all the trolls looking for a woman on the internet to hate fell for it. Even more deeply troubling, they openly discuss methods of passing their bigotry off as social justice and using less obviously slurs to gain more widespread mainstream acceptance. Despite the hostility, we the mod team had ambivalent feelings about the direction these subs might go in. We thought, perhaps naively, that /r/asianamerican will become calmer while all the bigots can have an outlet and be contained in the more "edgy" subreddits. Over time, we've learned these are not just a few bad apples and that their behavior only would breed more like them over time.

Fighting a losing battle of 2 years

Fast forward another year. We bring on new mods to stem the tide as our subreddit grows popular. More new subreddits such as /r/aznidentity pop up, their rhetoric mirroring and even going further than that of /r/asianmasculinity. We hold strong in our policy to give these trolls no attention. /r/Aznidentity, despite our best efforts to ignore them, try desperately to recruit from us. They buy ads targeting our subreddit, using the "sponsored" posts to circumvent our rules. (We engage with the Reddit Admins and they eventually take it down after several rounds of prodding.) The /r/aznidentity mods actively tell their members to pm individuals in our subreddit inviting them to join their sub. They hint at reddit rule-breaking behavior to circumvent Reddit’s rules against creating alt accounts to circumvent bans. Just like in the masculinity subreddit, the more "moderate" users encourage couching their woman-bashing in less misogynistic language to keep their hatred under the radar, but have no problem letting it fester in their communities.

As a mod team we try to keep rule-breaking posts like the ones highlighted in other subs to a bare minimum but there's always an undercurrent of misogyny even among our regular users. Even though she initially reached out to us, we struggled to get Jenn Fang of Reappropriate to do an AMA because of hostile reactions to her articles in /r/asianamerican. They overlook her years of dedication to Asian American blog activism due to her perceived bias against Asian men riding on a single post of hers about Elliot Rodger. We had a podcast about Yellow Fever featured once in our subreddit, and [one commentator stalked the social media of one of the producers because her dating history seemed suspect. She deleted her comments defending her relationships out of disgust] (https://np.reddit.com/r/asianamerican/comments/3937wj/reply_all_podcast_the_fever_episode/cs0mk4w/). In response to her comments asking for men not to stalk women online and blame Asian women for yellow fever, we had responses like this. Meanwhile, severe downvoting of anything from a woman's perspective or calling out rape culture is on par the regular course.. Here is an example of a thread featuring Anna Akana speaking about the hypersexualization of Asian women, with the deleted comments from a Asian man making generalizations about Asian women, while the downvotes are reserved for voices trying to persuade Asian men from dominating the discourse about Asian women. Meanwhile a lot of the comments we remove are variations of disparaging and generalizing Asian women, celebrities or not, for having a white partner or referring to them as whores and sluts. Of course, I'm not exempt. In the meantime, I've had multiple women message me or state publicly (exhibit 1, 2, 3 ) they will no longer participate in /r/AsianAmerican because of the way they condone generalizing Asian women and not taking criticism of rape culture seriously. Bonus: a user of ours getting harassed via PM by a /r/hapas regular.

Most of our mods just spend their days removing rule-breaking comments, chasing down trolls, petitioning admins to stop the ones who are using alts to get around their bans, get messaged hatefully, and are burning out. A lot of the messages are misogynistic in nature, targeting Asian women dating white men , and assuming the other moderators are also or at least "emasculated" men who are being led astray by me. You can see a lot of these accounts, if they weren't already deleted or suspended, are from regulars at AznIdentity and Hapas. Here's an album. The subreddits we avoid continue to get featured on SubredditDrama and other drama subreddits, and anytime this toxic discourse is brought up it brings even more drama.

At around this time, /r/AsianFeminism is formed as a response to the lack of moderation in /r/asiantwox. I'm encouraged by the strong mod team they formed, but the toxic atmosphere that has developed in Asian reddit begins to rear its head. Even when I try participating as a neutral party, users attempt to circumvent the rules there to personally attack me. While there has been some encouraging discussion around the toxicity of the more lax Asian subreddits, /r/AF still suffers from being brigaded and its users disparaged just for sharing their views.

Close to Present Day

For the most part I'm pretty hands-off in day to day moderation in /r/asianamerican. The most active mods there are Asian men and they do the majority of removing rule-breaking comments and posts. While I do have a voice in shaping policy there, my fellow moderators can back me up when I say that I tend to advocate on the side of giving leniency to users, even those who may have a history of posting in /r/hapas or /r/aznidentity. Hence, this next instance of harassment end up being surprising:

Meanwhile, our mod team is still pretty beleaguered. Exhibit 1, 2 of the type of content we remove, and an album of our most current modmail. We all deal with abuse, but some of these are definitely more personal in nature and for some inexplicable reason targetting me. Aside from the modmail and the things we have to deal with in our subreddit, we're still gossiped about regularly in other subs.

Where do we go from here?

There is a real problem with misogynist Asian men on Reddit and the Admins have allowed it to fester. While Reddit as a whole has been put on alert of spaces like /r/TheRedPill, they're given a platform to recruit others and that holds true in /r/asianmasculinity, /r/hapas and /r/aznidentity. These Reddit spaces dominated by Asian and half-Asian men are the ones shouting out everyone else in spaces like /r/asiantwox, and why /r/asianfeminism still struggles with activity. My 3 years of being a mod only cemented this reality further. These are also not just a few bad apples or dedicated white trolls. There are lots of them who share the opinion that any Asian woman in a relationship with a white man is a traitor to her race, and they are seeking to normalize this idea by appropriating the language of social justice to bully their way into the mainstream. Most of the comments and messages I've linked from the past year, and whose users we subsequently banned and now complain incessantly about our censorship in those subreddits, are those like these. (For context, this article was submitted about a bullied girl who commit suicide, and this poster chose this moment to focus on her "preferences" for dyed hair instead, an obvious dig at Asian women with "preferences" for white men.) This is not to say that every single poster from those communities are hateful. In fact, some of them do end up realizing how hateful they become and how unfounded most of their accusations against Asian women are. But by and large, those subreddits condone this behavior. If these spaces cannot and will not police their own members from harassing others, this problem will simply continue to grow.

I am tired of dealing with this. I have come close many times to quitting, but at the beginning of this year I started reading more posts from Asian women and felt inspired to document my experience. I don't think staying silent helps anymore. So here's my call to action:

  • Join your efforts with people of all genders like /u/Cheeserole, /u/Blub, and /u/xin05 who have talked back against the vitriol directed at Asian women in the Asian American subreddits. I'm so thankful for people like /u/amyandgano, /u/desolee, and /u/notanotherloudasian for becoming fellow female moderators and trying to salvage the spaces we have left for Asian women, or just spaces that are safe for Asian women as participants in general. If you're an Asian American man and you see men speaking over women in women-focused spaces, ask them to consider dialing it back. Don't just lurk or assume that the mods will take care of it, because we're tired too.

  • Use this subreddit as a starting point for shining a light on the incessant harassment that people receive for being on Reddit and daring to voice their opinion as a woman. /r/asianamerican will remain focused on building community and will not be polluted by meta-reddit and subreddit "drama" posts like this, but there needs to be an outlet for people to discuss and vent. Let's keep joining our efforts in calling harassment out, while keeping our existing spaces more open to positive content and fostering community.

  • If you find you can't help but be a participant in toxic subreddits, do your best to convince other participants that doxxing, threatening violence, harassment, and forms of misogyny and extremism are not the way to unite and strengthen the Asian American community. Find ways to build bridges, not to burn them. Consider asking subreddits you participate in to make a stand against hate speech and follow it up with actions.

I have always been and remain dedicated to providing a safe online community for Asian Americans everywhere to have a place to speak their thoughts without being attacked personally or fearing for their safety, regardless of how unpopular this makes me. My experience has made me way more sympathetic to those being harshly attacked on account of perceived self-hating behavior. More than ever I think if we as a community truly believe in destroying white supremacy at its core, we need to start by taking care of and not eating our own. We need like-minded people to help speak out against this form of "social justice" that is nothing more than bullying. I call upon our community leaders, especially mainstream activists, to reject spaces that condone this harmful behavior. I want to give a hefty warning to anyone searching for community to be careful.

We can do better. Reddit can do better.

Edit to add responses to this that further prove my point:

Part 2


r/againstharassment • • Oct 27 '17

How Reddit harasses Asian women into silence: A tell-all from an /r/asianamerican mod

43 Upvotes

Part 1 here.

Overall, the responses have been overwhelmingly positive. Of course I did not expect any of my harassers to come forward to apologize, but their retaliation efforts have further proved the point of my original post. They also fall disappointingly into a common pattern of abusive tactics meant to make sure I remain silent:

The saddest part of this fiasco is that I confided in a private subreddit for Asian ladies about writing about this months ago. A mod of /r/aznidentity posted leaked this onto his subreddit. In some twisted way of trying to defend themselves, they violated the sanctity of the one place left on Reddit that was exclusively safe for Asian women.

Some have suggested that I'm airing dirty laundry to the wider Reddit community as a way of suggesting that I contribute to the marginalization of Asian issues specific to men. Margaret Cho faced the same criticism from her community when she spoke up about her rape. Black feminists faced the same arguments from black men. On the contrary, we should be able to openly discuss misogyny within the Asian diaspora. That isn't to say that Asians, who come from a myriad of backgrounds with vastly different experiences, have a monopoly on this problem. Sexism is a global phenomenon which impacts the Asian community doubly because of gendered racism--yes, Asian men are uniquely affected by sexism too. Our community has the strength to have these conversations with nuance and compassion. We can only be weakened by those who would deny and perpetrate misogyny in the first place. Zero tolerance for misogyny in this movement is not siding with white supremacists. I thank /u/TangerineX for gathering the receipts so I didn't have to spend my time debunking the biases of people who never gave me or many Asian women on Reddit the benefit of the doubt.

To those of you who have stood by me and followed this saga so far: Thank you. You know who you are. I find strength in knowing we might not be as vocal, but our voices are being heard. Just yesterday Admins have announced that they’re beginning to ban subreddits that harbor and glorify violent content. (/r/aznidentity has already begun trying to scrub their image while just two months ago they were celebrating the opioid epidemic in America as being “karma”. Archive). They may try to smear us by calling us “PAA” (Progressive Asian Activists) but there’s nothing wrong with supporting important causes such as anti-black racism, solidarity among people of color, economic justice, and ending gender-based discrimination. We refuse to be bullied into silence by self-proclaimed “social justice leaders” who present the false dichotomy of siding with them or with white supremacists. We may disagree over policy and tactics, but we’ll continue to fight for a space on Reddit for the Asian American community without making room for dangerous radicalism and harassment.

Some positive news in all this:

Signing off. Happy Friday!


r/againstharassment • • Oct 11 '17

A whole subreddit of awfulness demeaning “race-mixing” and LGBT minorities

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 10 '17

How harassers get around the spam filter to promote their hate subs

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 10 '17

/r/Hapas attempts to deflect in response to being called out

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
17 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Dec 29 '17

On any given day you can check u/OpiumDesVolkes84's profile and see him whinging about me or a2x

16 Upvotes

https://www.np.reddit.com/user/OpiumDesVolkes84/comments

Women, watch out for this one. He claims to be a half-Asian half-Latino hapa. He has been harassing me for months, from RagingFuckalot to this account.

He posts in the_donald, mgtow, the redpill, incels, inceltears, cringeanarchy, MensRights, watchpeopledie, subreddit cancer and a whole host of other alt-right, conservative hate subs.

Despite r.hapas and r.aznidentity claiming to be against men that post in alt-reich subs, this guy is welcomed by them.

On any given day you can go to his profile and be guaranteed to see his chapped comments about me, a2x or feminism in general. He HATES feminism.

He has himself stated to having a fetish for white women, Latinas and redheads and that all other women are worthless. This race fetishist is embraced by r.hapas.

Not only does he hate women, feminism, have racial fetishes and slut shame women, he is in cahoots with the alt-reich white supremacists of r.drama. He is chummy with the white supremacist that originally got me suspended (for exposing another white male rapist).

He made a post on r.hapas congratulating the white supremacist that got me banned and called me a "chink" 16 times in one r.drama post. On this post in r.hapas, other Asian men and hapa men joined in to condone his use of the slur "chink".

He stalks me around reddit, showing up to harass me in subs and conversations that have nothing to do with him. You'll never see me talking about him but he is forever obsessing over me. He once hijacked a post I made in r.OCD to tell me theredpill has taught him to only fuck women who like their dad. So fucking creepy!!!

This is the type of person r.hapas and r.aznidentity embrace and endorse. But of course, we are somehow the white supremacists.

I will add in archives later when I'm on my computer.


r/againstharassment • • Oct 18 '17

Totally not sexist user needs to tell me how he really feels about my presence on Reddit

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 11 '17

[Meta] If you want to become an approved submitter please read this

15 Upvotes

If you have been harassed and want to take action, please follow these steps immediately:

  1. Take a screenshoot or Archive.is as evidence. Trolls often delete their comments or user accounts just to make new ones and harass you again.

  2. Message the Admins with your evidence. It may fall under Reddit's side-wide policy against bullying. Most of the time this won't accomplish anything.

  3. Do not engage with your harassers unless it's to gather more evidence. They will use tactics such as gaslighting, appeasement, and threats to make their "side" look more credible. There are no two sides to harassment unless you become a harasser yourself, even in defense.

Once you've done that and still decide you wish to document your harassment publicly here, feel free to send me a PM or message the mods directly. I will add you to the approved submitter's list.


r/againstharassment • • Nov 03 '17

White dude tries to smear RagingFuckaLot on TrollX

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Nov 02 '17

D888 is back to call me and every Asian woman in a relationship with a white ma a bed wench, sellout and whore.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 11 '17

TranceFan of r/hapas harasses me because I'm an Asian woman -- And if you think he's some angry virgin or whatever, he's actually 6'1, ripped, objectively good-looking and have played sport at national level - trust him, he has NO problem with women.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 11 '17

/u/trancefan95 on his 12th alt attempts to gaslight me

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 10 '17

/u/HopelessRomantica follows my post around Reddit to prove my point

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 10 '17

In response to my post, another PM.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Jan 01 '18

Guy admits to raping Asian women on r/hapas

Thumbnail
archive.is
12 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Dec 28 '17

Onerealhapa needs to let me know he hates my acting in a Prego commercial

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 24 '17

TIL I have a husband and I love PMing things to myself (from /r/hapas)

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 30 '17

Anyone else just get this?

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 24 '17

[Meta] Post your harassment archives

11 Upvotes

Did you save some particularly odious PMs or username mentions but they’re no longer recent? Post to share them here!


r/againstharassment • • Oct 20 '17

Brave /r/hapas poster deletes their account after harassing

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 12 '17

Received this an hour ago from /u/HmongHmong

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Feb 26 '18

/u/billiebarkingbastard- My latest stalker, who turns up everywhere I comment to claim I'm lying

10 Upvotes

The other day I commented on this post in r/gifs

https://www.np.reddit.com/r/gifs/comments/7znp5w/dont_touch_my_food/dupe9rf/

There was lots of racism in the comments. I replied to one racist comment made by this guy, not realising he would become fixated on me and proceed to stalk me from then onwards. I have literally never encountered him before and that comment was my first exchange with him.

After that, as I said, he became fixated on me and decided to follow me around reddit.

First he decided to harass me via pm.

This is the first batch of messages where I clearly ask him not to pm me. https://imgur.com/a/ZAzk3

This is the second set of pms he sends me. His comments were either removed or he was shadowbanned in the r/gifs thread as his harassment was obviously noted by the mods. https://imgur.com/a/LrjzJ

This is the third time he pms me despite having been told not to https://imgur.com/a/PdcJr

He then goes through my post history and finds this r/drama post made by someone who frequently abuses and harasses me on reddit. He joins in the abuse and leaves a comment on the thread https://www.np.reddit.com/r/Drama/comments/7zzu1p/ragingfuckalot_aka_crispysaucybackchat_returns/dusr93r/?context=3

He continues to watch my post history and attacks me on this thread in r/relationships, falsely accusing me of having claimed to be a gay black man or some such nonsense. https://www.ceddit.com/r/relationships/comments/80ayns/i_23m_am_infatuated_with_a_woman_23f_even_after_i/duuhg3h/?context=3

Finally, a few hours ago, he went through my post history again and found a comment I made on a gif about hair and, of all things, claims I'm lying about the length of my hair?? https://www.np. reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/80649q/rainbow_hair/duuiu1z/?context=3

I doubt that will be the last of it and I will edit in any new harassment from him.

I recommend all other women who post in the subs that I do to watch out for him- I doubt he's the sort of person who will be satisfied with harassing just one person.


r/againstharassment • • Oct 25 '17

Update on site-wide rules regarding violent content • r/modnews

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Oct 17 '17

All the defenders of harassment are absolutely baffled why they'd be banned from /r/againstharassment

Thumbnail
imgur.com
10 Upvotes

r/againstharassment • • Dec 28 '17

After being reported, Onerealhapa continues his obsession with Asian women’s dating histories

Post image
9 Upvotes