r/acotar_rant • • May 01 '26

Rant The Nesta-bias and IC-hate is really getting on my nerves Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I just read all the books and I am sooo annoyed about people ranting about Feyre/the IC/Cassian after ACOSF. You have some weird Nesta-bias and project alot of your own experiences unto her situation and the book overall. Nesta was a bitch, hateful and sooo destructive and needed someone to step in.

I would be sad if I was in her situation and everyone I know just let me be. It worked didn't it? Living in the House, training and working in the library, the hike and having Cassian there every step of the way.

I loved Nestas journey in the book and her development. I also loved Nessian and thought it realistic of someone wanting to help the one the care about, but making mistakes along the way.

What I really wanted to say is Nesta-fans are very biased and pisses me off so much it is unreal. I hate that all ACOTAR-subs are basically IC rants and Nesta praise. GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!!!

Thank you for coming to my TED-talk


r/acotar_rant • • Sep 28 '26

Rant SJM is playing in people’s face with ACOTAR 6 & 7

0 Upvotes

I can truly already guess what they’ll consist of: terrible/no plots, bad pacing, no character arcs, and random sex scenes. Just from reading the overview of both books, I just know SJM is finna waste people’s time. They only highlighted Koschei as being the villain, drama between the IC, and vague mentions of “enemies.” Lol. Where is the mention of a plot? That’s not a plot; that’s just highlighting things that’ll happen in the book. I can bet yall real money that the real “plot” won’t come in until part 4, which has no publish date as of yet.

For starters, I made up my mind to not read them before they were announced. But after I read the synopses of both books, the final nail was in the coffin for me. What made me mad THE MOST was sjm’s refusal to declare a female main character as the protagonist of the books. It genuinely made me mad because we’ve been waiting for 6 years just for her to give us a vague Nesta/Valkyrie/IC book. You mean to tell me after waiting THAT long she doesn’t even give us a main female character? And forgive my bias, but i really wanted it to be Elain. But as it turns out, this isn’t an Elain or Gwyn book, it’s just an “everyone” kind of book, which feels like a weird cop out on her behalf.

It’s actually very crazy that people have been waiting for her to announce the fmc just for her to not even do it. Like girl…what are you doing? Literally no one even wanted a Nesta/Valkyrie/IC book. People wanted a FMC to be announced! And I don’t know about yall, but if I have to read another Valkyrie or IC book, I will lose my mind. We already got both of those kinds of books. One in ACOSF and the other in ACOWAR/ACOMAF. There’s really no point in doing that when you can just go on and give someone else their story. And what happened to the main characters getting their story? It’s like SJM has completely abandoned Lucien, Elain, Azriel, Mor, and Amren. I want their stories in their own point of views, not an “everyone” book.

I fear SJM is really finna fumble this one!


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 05 '26

Rant Nesta rant

0 Upvotes

Ok so my problem isn’t really with Nesta, as towards the end of SF I started liking her. My problem is the people who stand 10 toes behind her and thinks she can do and has done no wrong. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not a diehard Rhys stan but people always point out the way he treats her especially during her intervention and like can you actually blame him?? She was pretty hateful books 3-5, yes she had her reasons and I do see a lot of Nesta in myself but people act like the IC should have been completely ok with her treating everyone like absolute shit while simultaneously demanding her rent paid and drink bill paid for. This isn’t an attack on her character as like I said I can relate to her in many ways and I’ve grown to like her, more so on the people are just ignore how cunty she actually was lol


r/acotar_rant • • Apr 12 '26

Rant This fandom (at least on reddit) is so toxic.

0 Upvotes

title says a lot, and I'm WELL aware I'm going to get an absurd amount of hate on this post and I honestly don't care. I'm gonna rant about it anyway.

The fact that pretty much the only place people in this fandom can go to speak positively about the MAIN COUPLE in this series is a dedicated subreddit for the ship is ABSOLUTELY INSANE. God forbid you come onto this sub or the main reddit page for ACOTAR and say a single negative thing about Tamlin or Nesta, your absolutely ripped to shreds. There was a post in the MAIN REDDIT PAGE of a new reader saying they didnt like tamiln (which is valid we can all have our own opinions) and it wasnt even up for 24 hours, I can only assume this is because of the amount of tamiln defenders jumping down their throat.

my biggest issue is these conversations arent being had respectfully. I can understand not everyone is going to like the same things for the same reasons but a large portion of the tamlin/nesta defenders take a stance of "if you like Rhys your a shitty human or "don't know how to read" and thats 1. objectively wrong and 2. being an asshole. And im used to toxic fan bases, I grew up on tumbler but yall this is BAD. Its laughably reddiculous, and at this point I check these threads mostly for the drama cuz thats all it is tbh.

yes im aware theres reasons to dislike Rhys, and reasons to like both Tamlin and Nesta, and im not trying to say anyone is not valid for having said opinions. But these groups are pushing away readers and I have beef with bullies, and a lot of the Tamlin/Nesta defenders (not all) really act like bullies.

Anyway thats my rant, feel free to downvote me into oblivion i know its coming xD


r/acotar_rant • • 29d ago

Rant The Valkyrie

0 Upvotes

Im so so sorry! But am I the only one who doesn’t care that much for Gwyn and emerie 🙃
I loved the girl power and healing on acosf but I’m okay with not just having them as sides characters


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 31 '26

Rant Can we talk about SJM's cultural appropriation?

23 Upvotes

I feel so annoyed by some of her appropriation of Irish culture and language as a descendant of the Irish who were forced to leave Ireland due to colonisation by the English. Her Celtic aesthetic is purely vibes, and her blatant cultural appropriation of Irish words like anam cara into caranam pisses me off.

But also, I'm a writer. I research the crap out of my own fantasy world that I'm writing in, and it's just pure fucking laziness that her books borrow Celtic feels without the deep understanding of the culture she's borrowing.


r/acotar_rant • • Oct 15 '26

Rant SJM being a “vibes” writer doesn’t mean nothing is planned

3 Upvotes

Just a small rant because I feel like this comment by her has been taken SO out of context by the fandom that because SJM is a “vibes” writer that means she doesn’t plan or foreshadow anything and that is not true.

SJM is a “pantser” short for “writing by the seat of her pants”. This means she doesn’t sit down and outline every chapter of her book / series before writing. She lets the story come to her as she writes. It DOESN’T mean that she doesn’t have any idea or plans of what could happen in the future. She doesn’t go into every book completely blind with no plans, she just doesn’t hold herself to a solid outline. She enjoys the journey of writing and discovering the characters and plot as she writes. But she is still able to plan out things and foreshadow while she does.

It does mean there may be more discrepancies throughout if she mentions something in passing that wasn’t meant to go anywhere or be a big deal but then comes back around later on and she forgets about it. This style of writing should come with more effort to create consistency throughout, and I 100% agree with criticism that she often doesn’t do that. I just disagree with people who say that she can’t plan anything because she writes this way.


r/acotar_rant • • Mar 07 '26 This

Rant The fandom is the reason we cannot be taken seriously

0 Upvotes

The entitlement over that interview is ridiculous.

Yes, the interview was not the best. Yes, the questions were random, boring, repetitive, and had been asked times and times again before. Sarah, evaded a lot of answers when it came to her book etc...

But jesus christ, she does not owe you her writing style. She does not owe you a fucking writing schedule nor plan. Sure, there are plot holes, but 'cmon, they are not even that relevant, and honestly im sure they are pointed out merely out of the fact that we have gone five years without a book.

Tamlin here, tamlin there. Suck it up.

She doesn't like him. Hell, I almost didn't finish ACOTAR cause I found him unbearable - imagine my surprise when some of y'all thought he was some perfect love interest.

She does not owe you a redemption arch. Favouritism?? Is her own damn book. She can do whatever she likes.

How dare she talks so badly about Tamlin??? Cause she does not like him. Why are you guys forcing her to write a redempion arch?! Write your own fanfic if you want to see it.

That's the whole point of fanfiction.

Oh she excuses Rhysand. So what. Okay sure, what he did was wrong. But we are talking about a fictional character. You can form your own opinion about it regardless of what Sarah thinks. You do not need her to hand hold you and validate your own feelings and tell you that yes, Rhys was bad. Blah Blah Blah.

Honestly, this fandom is one of the most toxic thing I have ever been part of.

Get a grip. Get a life. Stay critical. Write fanfic. Don't get all pissy when an author takes creative liberty with their own book.


r/acotar_rant • • Mar 05 '26

Fandom I'm so SICK of people saying that people aren't empathetic/never experienced trauma because they dislike Nesta

4 Upvotes

She's not real. FFS. I have never been in a fandom with so many people that make such ignorant claims over someone not liking a character.


r/acotar_rant • • Jun 11 '26

Hottake All the Elain hate is just giving mean girl toxic energy and I'm tired of it tbh

1 Upvotes

I genuinely don't understand why so many people hate Elain. There's something incredibly sweet, feminine, and understated about her that I really love. She's delicate, cautious, graceful, and eloquent. She gets scared. She feels anxious. She isn't fearless or loud, and that's okay.

What confuses me is that people seem willing to extend empathy to Nesta because they see parts of themselves in her. Nesta was objectively much harsher to the people around her for a long time, yet she's been embraced because readers connect with her anger, trauma, and complexity. Elain, on the other hand, gets dismissed as "boring" simply because she's softer.

And the way people talk about her online sometimes feels like a bunch of mean girls. Why is tending a garden considered a personality flaw? Why is being gentle treated as if it's somehow less valuable than being fierce? Not every female character has to wield a sword, deliver cutting one-liners, or dominate every room she walks into.

I also don't understand the resistance to Elain and Azriel. Why do so many people want to see him with Gwyn instead? Gwyn is lovely, but she was JUST introduced. Is it because she is Nesta's friend or that she had a crush on him during training. Idk, but people are awfully overprotective and dare I say slightly "motherly" when it comes to Azriels partner. Which is kinda toxic NGL. I don't have issues with Gwyn, I just don't get the Elain hate.

Personally, I think an Elain and Azriel romance could be beautiful precisely because it would be different. We've already had the intense, passionate, all-consuming romances with Feyre and Rhysand, and Nesta and Cassian. Elain and Azriel could be something quieter. Gentler. More patient. Two people who take their time with each other. Azriel has spent his entire life feeling unwanted and unseen; I think he deserves someone who would be gentle with his heart.

And honestly, "boring" Elain deserves happiness too.

You don't have to love her character, but the level of disdain she receives has always felt strange to me.

Sometimes it feels less like criticism and more like people punishing a woman for being soft.


r/acotar_rant • • Mar 08 '26

Fandom SJM is not a doctor

0 Upvotes

We cannot attempt to self insert when reading fiction that we did not write and is not about us. It's for entertainment and SJM should not be trying to relate heavily into anything that would require a professional in mental health. It's not fair to the art of writing.

Some people cant stand tamlin because he reminds them of their abusive ex.

Some people cant stand Nesta because it reminds them of someone who used some kind of abuse tactic on them (I forgot what readers were saying it was, sorry).

Some people cant stand Rhysand because they've been sexually abused and manipulated.

Some people struggle with Feyre because they know what it's like to try everything to save a mentally ill loved one and not be able to.

When we attempt to make the story about us whether on purpose or by accident, we disregard everyone else's life experiences (in this case, abuse) and ruin the books for ourselves. There has to be conflict in a story. We should not be allowing a work of fiction, so outside the realm of reality, to impact our real lives. Just let the characters be and let SJM write them how she knows them. We can always DNF.

Edited for clarity.


r/acotar_rant • • 16d ago

SJM Rewrite ACOTAR series

0 Upvotes

Okay so i love the world of prythian but i am nit liking how Sarah is treating the characters or the story, do i think i am better than her at writing well no but she literally has said that she doesn't use a notebook to keep track of things and yeah girl it shows ACOTAR introduces genuinely interesting concepts but often doesn't follow through on their implications.

Here is a list of things I have thought of that need to be changed or elaborated on to make the overall story more cohesive for MY FANFIC

Rework the Archeron sisters dynamic, elain plants veggies and nesta makes or mends cloths, cleans the cabin and chops the wood, nestas harshness is seen has a depressed survivor not just lashing out, feyre keeps her personality and elain has a personality nit just a plot device 

I do think feyre and rhys work together but they need some work also, like why are they sleeping together right away almost like they were both just in abusive relationships 

Elain needs someone i do think her and maybe tamlin but like he needs work alot but Like so does rhys 

No naked painted drunk feyre that story line is so fucking useless 

Feyrah that a name from an old dialect !!!,

Fix the inner circle, there needs to be more balance or there is the inner circle and then there is a like political version with other people that does eat rhys ass NO ONE SHOULD KNOW THAT AZ IS A SPY there is no political advisors, dissenting voices its just a tight knit group of besties 

MOR needs to be changed. She drags Az along for so long! That whole storyline is so dumb.

She is so disrespectful to Nesta with Cassian, they are like siblings but talk about fucking like wtf 

We need the truth of her power and wtf happened with Eris! Like who cares she's gay 

Tamlin and Rhys are very similar lets not forget that like 

Rhys is a hypocrite 
 
Feyre doesn't lock herself away when she finds out about her mate nor paints the cabin if the timeline is more dragged out this wouldn't be such a shock i feel like 

Amren dies ? 

Rhys doesn't die then just come back that was so stupid 

Tamlin dies ? 

Rhys and Feyre don't make a dumb bargain 

Anti climatic war it was over in like 4 chapters, we need more gritty campaign actual military strategy and espionage and severe lose 

maybe hybern is run by Amarantha and she doesn't actually die and tamlin is her mate ?

Use naula ans cerridwen have elain train with them 

I want the sisters to start training after they go into the cauldron, like they adapted to being poor and taking care of literally everything but then can't adjust to a possibly better life 

DEATH  has no weight in the war

HOW TF DID THE DEATH GODS DIE IN LIKE ONE MN

Would love Feyre to still have the kid but like make it normal 

Rewrite acosf completely 

Love the dance scene maybe thats how nesta meets eris or starts to fall for lucien 

Sure the blood rite might still happen like i want the valkyries to be a thing and training still but if she starts training sooner the blood rite is more earned 

Fix the night court dynamic and politics its just dumb they are so evil yet they want ppl to trust them and work them also we need more culture and politicals ans traditions 

How are mates so rare yet every highlord has ome and so do the 3 sisters 

The timeline needs to change or just that rhys and inner circle isn't alive 500 years ago then get with a 20 year old girl like noo 

The illyrians ans rhys needs to be fixed hes like oh girl power but then illyrian woman are treated like ass

Mating ceremony 

Jurain is back to normal way to quick to be an eye for how long 

Feyre shouldn't be ALL POWERFUL she should be as powerful as a highlord like she has a drop if each , also this needs to be explored more 

Feyre and tamlin fight like physically ?

Suriel lives ?

Beron should die in acowar  and eris is crowned 

Fix the spring court its like the other courts don't exist till the inner circle needs them like no 

Why did rhys sister get killed off 

If the sisters train after acomaf then they fight in the battle together 
Acowar feyre doesn't go back or she does just to fight him like i hated that 

Amren is just a cunt thats her only skill 

Multi pov ? 

Inner circle is just a bunch of babies 

Back to the 500 year gap like feyre he literally has no gf for that long 

Amarantha needs to stay (also she called her feyre darling first) 

A court of song and shadow is canon but again not 500 years ago 

There needs to be more time between the books or more time between wars or stuff 

Explore the magic better like we need a power scale not just the ground rumbled 

Explore nestas powers like how is rhys so scRed of her 

How is amren just like 15,000 and shes just mean 

Pacing and structure filler chapters take forever and big events are over so quick 

Don't tell us ,show us 

Feyre whines too much 

Emeries back story changes in the same book 

Maybe hybern is a pawn for koschei 

Tamlin glamouring feyres mind the whole first book and nesta has no issues with deflecting a glammour

Lucien in book 1 described to look like beron 
Lucien book 3 described not looking like his family 

Rhys tells feyre book 2 wind is from day court but in book 3 its a spring court power

Cassian can have his guys hanging out but feyre cant give birth to a baby with wings 

Tamlins soldiers 

What did tamlin actually do vs what feyre says he did 

House of wind stairs

Glamouring vs daemati 

Veritas orb 

Highlords powers 

What is hybern doing during amaranths reign 

Cassian's backstory 

Fae aging 

Is alis still alive ? what if feyre had to kill her nephews 

Eris calls mor a liar and her power is truth 

Starlight pool 
  
Cassian and mor are described one way ans it changes 

“No insult if she had been into females” but mor cant be gay like whats the reason 

Far kids are rare but there are alot 

Mama archeron 

Rhys and the red star (makes a model of the worlds at some point) 

How was mor is vallahan for like 2 books ans gets no where 

I would've kept Rhys a little more evil, especially after we see him outside of UTM, as I much preferred the unwillingly falling for the villain trope from book 1. I'd have liked to see him gradually soften, mainly towards Feyre, while opening up to his friends. At the same time, I'd have made Feyre more morally grey, learning to stand up for herself and do morally questionable things in the name of her own justice.

I would kill maybe one or two meaningful characters. Like a sister or one of the IC

Nesta doesn't lose her powers 

Sorry for the long post! I'd genuinely love to hear everyone's thoughts on this, both the good and the bad. I'm really interested in hearing different perspectives and seeing what others would have done differently, so please feel free to share your opinions. Thank you! ❤️

EDIT !!
Right, so everybody in the comments who is just hating on me I love this series. I love these characters. I am unhappy with how unjust. The characters have been treated and like I said this is all for a fanfiction that I am creating. I’m not asking Sarah to change all these not doing anything like that except for simply stating that I wanted to change these things in my fanfiction.


r/acotar_rant • • 29d ago

Fandom Even People Who Leak Are Human

0 Upvotes

I really think this is just a hottake more than fandom but this is about the fandom so I marked it here.

Listen, I get that "leaks" are inconvenient but to say that its "disrespectful" well, I disagree. When something is disrespectful, it means something done with a lack of esteem, regard or offensive words and actions.

I publish scientific papers and do you know how exciting it would be for people to post leaks about my work because they love it SO much that they just want to find out what happens and share with their buddies? That would be awesome but unrealistic because science doesn't reach a large audience that genuinely cares.

To leak is to regard them highly because they love their writing so much. The only time it becomes disrespectful if they then take those leaks and write nasty things about the author. That is bullying and disrespectful.

Now, I am all for people defending SJM and going against people that leak information that is ok! And its ok to show your support to SJM! But, to write things about the leakers in a negative way is disregarding the fact that people that did the leaks are still human. Do we have to like the choice they made? Absolutely not. We can even be angry about it. But, just remember these are still people. They made a bad choice, they are not bad people.

Thats it!


r/acotar_rant • • Oct 09 '26

Rant To people who hate Feyre

0 Upvotes

I have a genuine question about people who hate Feyre (I just saw a comment about someone who said they hated her POV and wanted her to shut up the whole time), what made you read 3 whole books (+ ACOFAS) if you didn’t like the FMC that bad?
Why wouldn’t you stop the series all together since it starts with Feyre POV anyway? If you don’t like the main character, why continue reading about her?


r/acotar_rant • • Jan 15 '26

Hottake WHY IS IT A CRIME TO LIKE THE MCs OF THIS SERIES, ACCOMPANIED BY A VERY LONG, POSSIBLE NONSENSICAL SIDE RANT

34 Upvotes

Edit: guys try to read the whole post before forming an opinion about the post by reading one sentence (PLS) 💗

GETTING STRIAGHHT INTO IT: I’m so annoyed with how this fandom downvotes any positive mention of our main characters. It feels like I’m not allowed to like Feyre or Rhysand, and I’m expected to treat Tamlin and Nesta like saints who do no wrong (their wrong doings have redemption and reason... but Feyre and Rhysand are evil overlords??).

Yes, Feyre and Rhysand have flaws, but why is it treated like a crime to enjoy the protagonists of the series? And say what you want, but Sarah J Maas wrote our MCs to be likeable, she WANTED US TO LIKE THEM. I mean it's a common joke in this fandom how Sarah J Maas is obssessed with Rhysand. I feel like half the time people are just hating on Rhysand... to hate.

PLS FOR THE LOVE OF GOD JUST LET ME ENJOY THE MCs WITHOUT GETTING -258 DOWNVOTES 😭

Every time I try to defend either of them in the ACOTAR sub, I get downvoted and told I have “no media literacy.” I can like the MC and acknoweldge he's done wrong things!! Also... I fear this might be the worst part... it really isn't that deep. I'm pretty sure when SJM wrote out Rhysnad's charcter she didn't expected half teh fandom to see his scraifice to Amarantha UTM to be him telling everyone else to go die. And I can assure you, she did not wat Feyre to be seen as some annoying pick me, who act's like a child at a HIghLord Meeting... like can we please give feyre some grace from that ONE SCENE... out of her whole chacrter arc. I admit I crinegd but PLS she's still a CHILD IN A ROOM SURROUNDE DBY PEOPEL THAT ARE LIEK HUNDREDS OF YEARS OLD and not to mention she literally just became Fae and is thrusted into thsi random war older than her fmaily tree--- LIKE DID YOU EXPECT A GIRL WHO COUDL BARELY READ TO BE SOME EXCELLENT WAR DIPLOMAT 😃 (so my rant kinda lost track of it's initial point... oops) AND YES I ADMIT Feyre is kinda naiive and has done many stupid adn even morally wrong things (SHE NEEDS TO HEAL FROM TAMLIN... and wth was that thing of her detsoyring his entire court... girl)... OMG and one more thing hate me all you want, but Rhys was valid for being weary and spiteful of Nesta. Cause that girl was nothing but rude and bitchy to him in EVERY PRIOR MEETING. And yes, (allow me to continue going off on some tangent) No hate to my girl Nesta but DAMN I would hate her too at the beginning of the book. Because yes, I will forgive her and notice that she's imporve by teh end of ACOSF but I'm not going to magically forget all her wrongdoings and say oh yeah! you haev a complete pass at tretaing veryone like sh*t cause you were going trhough some bad stuff. Like no, most of the chacters in the book go through tough shit... I'm not going to immediately forgive someon who's been nothing but rude to me for half my life (Feyre). BUT WHAT I CAN DO is provide compassion and kindness knowing she's going through something difficult. I LITERALLY CANNOT UDERSTADN PEOPLE WHO SAY NESTA WAS NOTHING BUT KIND FOR THE WHOLE SERIES... DID WE READ THE SAME BOOKS?? She treated everyone like shit, till they gave her help (BY FORCE... which idk how to feel about that, cause Nesta did need help but then again is it right to force someone into getting helped the way they did??). AND ALLOW ME TO SAY BY ME criticizing Nesta's behavior, I am not excusing how the otehrs treated her... (although as someone who has to deal everyday with someone similar to Nesta, guys sometimes it's really hard to control your anger when your being treated rudely day after day... and sometimes you kinda just explode and snap at them, even if you care for them.)

Anyway, (lowkey lost the plot) but i guess this rnat post was supposed to be the devil's advocate, and a swamr of unpopular opinions which consist of: liking the MC of the series and reproaching someone for their wrongdoings (Nesta)

AND IN ADVANCE: TRY NOT TO PUT ME IN DOWNVOTE DEFICIT (although that would make this post beautifully ironic... and maybe this might've just tempted you to hit the downvote button... idek)

RESPECT TO ANYONE WHO READ MY ENTIRE POST <3

Bonus question: Do you treat these charcaters of this book as fictional human beings, with therefore fictional reasoning and outcomes, or do you treat these characters and interpret them with the same standrads you'd have for people irl?


r/acotar_rant • • Aug 28 '26

Hottake I actually love Feyre as a High Lady

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen so many posts and TikToks debating whether Feyre is even considered a High Lady, let alone whether she’s a good one. Personally, I love Feyre as a High Lady, especially in ACOFAS, because I feel like her character gets SO much unnecessary hate.

I’m not really interested in debating whether the land itself considers her a legitimate ruler, because I think that’s a whole separate discussion. I’m more interested in talking about what we actually see her doing with the position she has.

1. FEYRE IS DOING HIGH LADY WORK

It’s been a while since I read ACOFAS, so correct me if I’m remembering anything wrong, but as much as I remember, Rhys was busy rebuilding relationships after the war, negotiating with their allies, working on trade, and repairing those political connections in-person. Meanwhile, Feyre was also dealing with similar political side of things but through paperwork, such as reading and managing correspondence from other courts, priestesses, and different people trying to establish relationships with the Night Court.

I’ve seen people use this as an argument, saying that Feyre has basically been reduced to just managing paperwork as a HIGH LADY, while Rhys is out there doing the “actual” work, and that this shows Rhys doesn’t treat her fairly.

I DISAGREE.

Feyre is pretty young and had only recently become a ruler. Of course she needs time to learn and gain experience. SO HER BEING "REDUCED" TO PAPERWORK while Rhys is doing "ACTUAL" work is necessary because that's how she will learn about the way their court functions, communicating with other courts and allies, manages their political relationships. This way she is getting the feel for the responsibilities that come with being a High Lady.

2. THE ART STUDIO WAS A GOOD USE OF HER RESOURCES

Part of rebuilding a court after a huge and traumatic war is helping the people who actually live there and giving them resources to recover. Feyre LOVES painting, and after everything she went through, painting was something that helped her process her own emotions and gave her an outlet. So when she has the resources to create a space where other people can do the same thing, especially people who have experienced trauma, why is that automatically considered a waste of money and resources?

The war left people dealing with loss, displacement, violence, losing family members and homes, and having to live with things they witnessed and experienced. Children especially would have been affected by all of this.

Feyre was creating a space where people could express things they might not know how to put into words. Art can be a way of processing emotions and experiences, and I think it makes SO much sense for HER to want to provide that because she personally knows what it feels like to use painting as an outlet.

And honestly, I LIKE that this is what she chose to do.

Of course, things like healers, mental health support, and other forms of assistance are important when rebuilding after a war, but that doesn’t mean an art studio is pointless or unnecessary. It’s an additional resource that Feyre chose to create because she understood firsthand how much something like this could mean to someone.

And I actually think this says a lot about the kind of ruler Feyre wants to be.

She could have focused only on the big, obvious things, but instead she noticed a different kind of need. She used her position, money, and resources to create a place where people could express themselves, create, and potentially work through some of what they had experienced.

Maybe this is just me, but kindness is something I genuinely want to see in a ruler. I don’t only want someone who is powerful, strategic, or good at politics. I want someone who actually FEELS FOR the people they’re ruling over.

And that’s what I see in Feyre here.

I absolutely refuse to see it as her being stupid or wasting resources on this painting studio. To me, it showed empathy and a willingness to use her position to do something genuinely KIND for her people.


r/acotar_rant • • Apr 21 '26

Roast I need to shit talk about Tamlin

0 Upvotes

I just don’t buy that he loves Feyre, and why is he so weak 😭😭

Some dark high lord steals your girl and you don’t even try to go get her? I can’t with him.

Edited:

I feel like I need to add more context. I just started book 2. I’m about 150 pages in. Feyre just got to velaris for the first time.


r/acotar_rant • • May 27 '25

Rant Wing clipping isn’t allowed and doesn’t happen

0 Upvotes

That’s really it.

It’s banned and we have no evidence of it occurring illegally outside of Emerie, who had it done to her under Amarantha’s rule when Rhys was unable to enforce his laws.

In the couple months between ACOTAR and the start of the war it makes sense that her dad would hide this, and it would make sense how this flew under the radar until ACOSF.

There’s no evidence that it happens at this point in the story otherwise, the fact that people claim that Rhys condones it is simply false.


r/acotar_rant • • 19d ago

Hottake Do people think she is writing a “guide to be a perfect person”

16 Upvotes

I feel like the whole fandom has twisted to a really weird place. I see people becoming HORRIFIED if these characters do something that can be interpreted as “unhealthy in a relationship”..

I mean are people forgetting what we are reading? It’s a fiction fantasy full of people who kill, torture, trick each other, curse each other.. it’s well established that fae are mean motherfuckers and the humans of this world pretty much the same. the first book had the audience falling for a guy, just to turn it on its head and make him the bad guy.. we are on a RIDE, not an ethics lecture. it’s supposed to be entertaining, not ‘Sarah J Maas opinion on how to navigate romance and family’.


r/acotar_rant • • Feb 23 '26

Hottake Help me understand the hype

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just cannot get behind this series? I need to understand the hype because I found it so so tedious and cliched!! Can people enlighten me as to what they loved about it ??


r/acotar_rant • • Feb 10 '26

Hottake I hate how mean Reddit is lol

11 Upvotes

Maybe I’m a wimp but the hate people have for some of the characters, (I saw someone asking about fanfic where cassian and freysand are dead) was just like goddamn. That hate and vitriol is so severe that coming to Reddit to chat with other readers feels unsafe lol.


r/acotar_rant • • Mar 27 '26

Theory Nesta's parentage Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I have a theory. What if Nesta is a descendant of The Bone Carver? I'm 3/4th way through ACOSF and many phrases indicate that Nesta is most likely a high fae or maybe even something else entirely. It actually explains quite a lot since she also a death god. I feel that her story hasn't ended and something jaw dropping might be revealed in ACOTAR 6,7 or 8.


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 21 '26

Rant NESSIAN DEFENSE

0 Upvotes

I usually am very far away from such discussions bcs of so many Nessian and Cassian antis and their toxicity, but I just felt the need to state a few things here:

  1. Ppl stating acowar nessian is better- ppl forget Nessian's relation which was hardly anything present there to begin with properly in acowar cannot be compared to a point when Nesta became her worst and she and Cass literally became strangers - everything btw them was broken even after it somewhat developed quite a lot in Acowar.Thats why Cass is also partially cold at times to Nesta bcs he , as he himself states, "could barely walk away with a semblance of pride" and that he thought she deciding to die with him was her also choosing him as he professed everything to her in a way he never did to anyone. So I dont have so much prb with him being cold and a little distant at the beginning.

  2. The infamous "defend her to Rhys and the IC"- honestly I have never found any chance where he doesn't or doesn't "do enough" as ppl like to portray. I have no prb with him shutting Nesta down when she speaks ill of his brother- he only snarls at her once in the entire book relating to Rhys i think when she says she wont train and also he defends him as any good family member will- like are u telling me my partner bcs she doesnt want to do something and is hell bent on biting my fingers off when I try to help her, somehow uses insults, not at all related to the context, but just out of nowhere, for my family members and I am supposed to coddle her ? Hell no !! He is not a doormat neither should he ever be. And it wasnt even as if Nesta was insulting Rhys as a reaction to something which Rhys did then , it was just to push Cassian away by hitting at one his softest spots and yet when he is sad, hopeless and has to fly away to calm himself, he doesnt care abt Nesta insulting Rhys- its the fact that she is not starting is what is making him mad with worry.I dont see ppl stating Feyre a bad mate to Rhys bcs of how many times she snaps viciously at him in regards to Nesta??

Also he defends her at every turn- what do ppl want ? Cassian to go all in and tell the IC "I will leave the Night Court if u dont coddle her at every turn?" Its funny how ppl say he doesnt do enough when the canon text states how many times he is fighting tooth and nail for her and gets shut down by chain of command from Rhys or Amren- and yet it doesnt stop him.He snaps at Rhys and makes him apologize when Rhys gives a mental warning to Nesta, he explodes at amren a fair few times, calls her a fool, refuses to let her be used as bait by dangling Elain (he cant control the fact that Elain herself agrees to look for the Trove), snaps and warns Az, explodes at Feysand for even requesting Nesta to be seducing Eris (he was ready to rip in rhys but Nesta agreed, if he didnt let Nesta follow her decision, would that not be abusive?) and was angry enough with Feysand till the dance and broke into Eris and Nesta dancing inspite of Rhys and Feyre shouting at him for destroying their plan and more...

3. He doesnt protect her - WHAT??? This is just poor reading comprehension skills at this point ! He is ready to rip apart the world and end every threat to his mate when she is captured by the cauldron and he runs down in own his shorts to her room with a knife, so much so taht he would have ripped into Rhys had Az not grabbed him and refused to let go. He was ready to break apart all sacred Illyrian laws and tear into teh Blood Rite and thus, Rhys had to use his dominance on him to calm him down and make him see sense! He overcame the power of a Dead Trove, made from the very vessel which gives the Universe life (Cauldron) only bcs of his love for Nesta, he almost died at the mere thought of Nesta dieing in the Bog Of Oorid, he didnt lie to Nesta abt her weapons bcs he couldnot and even when he got overpowered, he and Az refused to lie and made Amren and Rhys wait for Feyre bcs he trusted Feyre would be on her sister's side which she was.

4. The HIKE- now u can have problems with certain parts of it, I dont though- but to say he took her on it bcs he was angry on her is just again, poor reading skills . He clearly mentions the hike was only bcs he remembered Mor talking abt the Healing Mountains and he knew going back to Velaris wouldnot save Nesta , so he took her on that hike and he WAS RIGHT !! It was that hike which saved Nesta- it was that physical exertion of carrying that backpack and moving which made her body and mind collapse and she could finally reach the rock bottom and break down and let it all out. This thing is also scientifically proven. Also he had every right to be angry on Nesta- it was a combination of the factors that she hurt her own sister while she was in such a sensitive condition, she regressed from all the growth she was slowly achieving. And yes he didnt fight Rhys when he threatened to kill Nesta.

Now let me ask what u guys think of that fact that Nesta literally threatened to rip out Feyre's throat in Acowar or Amren stating Feyre was behaving like Tamlin and Rhys didnt say a word or maybe even, Rhys just shielding Feyre when he and Amren got into the discussion of how she escaped from the Prison and Amren was getting out of control. So he's a shitty mate right? Also, its clearly said that Feyre was extremely distraught and crying and broken at that news thrown at her, and his primal instincts flared bcs he perceived Nesta a threat. And its said that Cassian was ultimately protecting her by taking her away from Rhys bcs thats what a wise mate would do then- not fight an atom bomb like Rhys was at that mmt but just remove his mate from the area of conflict especially when Nesta herself was so broken and not capable of protecting herself.

5. He doesnt find her as beautiful as Mor or Feyre and wants Nesta was like them and he just sexualizes her- EXCUSE ME?? In acomaf bonus chapter (Wings and Embers), he mentions twice how absurdly and unnaturally perfect he finds Nesta, even as a human in their second meeting which throws him off his game. In acowar , Feyre notices how Cassian looks like he's gotten punched in his gut by her beauty and he cant even stay in the same room as her. In Acosf and f&s, he mentions twice, how beautiful she is inspite of her lsoing weight and becoming a ghost of what she was (he sees her beauty even at her lowest!) and throughout Acosf he is in awe of her hair, her smile, there are pages when he sees her in Con in that Black Dress and he is raving abt her- he doesnt even bother abt Mor or anyone else then and mentions how she is the "most beautiful thing ever" twice!!

He describes Mor's beauty but honestly i found nothing attractive or sexual in it bcs he himself clearly states they are nothing more than family and he he long changed those young lustful attractions.

He doesnt sexualize her- bcs she equally comments on his dick and muscles and body too!! He is always waiting for her to initiate any sexual encounters- he refuses once, twice after the kelpie accident and only when Nesta is almost crawling to him, he gives in to her demands. As SJM said in CHD podcast, sex was Nessian's way of showing their emotions, so reducing it to smut or him sexualizing her is proof of how much ppl disregard their jounrey !

**And for that bonus chapter in HOFAS, people dont grasp that its not for Nessian as a couple, its to show Nesta motherly affection bcs she never got from her parents which was her greatest pain.And I also believe this meeting with Ember will be crucial for Nesta to embark on her motherhood journey and this bonus chapter was a stepping stone, i believe for Nesta to becoming a General or Commander of the Valkyries in the Prison Island (the conflict btw her and Rhys is just like two leaders going head to head) and also SJM shows how good of a mate Cassian is through Bryce's lens (who is unbiased) by mentioning it twice! And for that part where Nesta says he's the one most angry on her, I believe we cannot draw a conclusion from it without having the Prythian POV.

NOW THATS ALL I HAVE TO SAY REGARDING NESSIAN!! I AM SO ANGRY ON THE HATE THEY RECEIVE WHEN CLEARLY, SJM HERSELF SAYS THEY ARE "PERFECT, TRUE MATES" AND ARE OBSSESSED WITH THEM AND ALSO WHEN NESSIAN'S STORY IS THE LARGER CHUNK OF HER AND JOSH'S STORY.


r/acotar_rant • • Apr 11 '26

Theory Am I the only one who thinks SJM will kill off Tamlin (in a last ditch redemption) and tamlin will somehow leave the spring court to Lucien and then Elain will be high lady of the spring court??

1 Upvotes