Okay so i love the world of prythian but i am nit liking how Sarah is treating the characters or the story, do i think i am better than her at writing well no but she literally has said that she doesn't use a notebook to keep track of things and yeah girl it shows ACOTAR introduces genuinely interesting concepts but often doesn't follow through on their implications.
Here is a list of things I have thought of that need to be changed or elaborated on to make the overall story more cohesive for MY FANFIC
Rework the Archeron sisters dynamic, elain plants veggies and nesta makes or mends cloths, cleans the cabin and chops the wood, nestas harshness is seen has a depressed survivor not just lashing out, feyre keeps her personality and elain has a personality nit just a plot device
I do think feyre and rhys work together but they need some work also, like why are they sleeping together right away almost like they were both just in abusive relationships
Elain needs someone i do think her and maybe tamlin but like he needs work alot but Like so does rhys
No naked painted drunk feyre that story line is so fucking useless
Feyrah that a name from an old dialect !!!,
Fix the inner circle, there needs to be more balance or there is the inner circle and then there is a like political version with other people that does eat rhys ass NO ONE SHOULD KNOW THAT AZ IS A SPY there is no political advisors, dissenting voices its just a tight knit group of besties
MOR needs to be changed. She drags Az along for so long! That whole storyline is so dumb.
She is so disrespectful to Nesta with Cassian, they are like siblings but talk about fucking like wtf
We need the truth of her power and wtf happened with Eris! Like who cares she's gay
Tamlin and Rhys are very similar lets not forget that like
Rhys is a hypocrite
Feyre doesn't lock herself away when she finds out about her mate nor paints the cabin if the timeline is more dragged out this wouldn't be such a shock i feel like
Amren dies ?
Rhys doesn't die then just come back that was so stupid
Tamlin dies ?
Rhys and Feyre don't make a dumb bargain
Anti climatic war it was over in like 4 chapters, we need more gritty campaign actual military strategy and espionage and severe lose
maybe hybern is run by Amarantha and she doesn't actually die and tamlin is her mate ?
Use naula ans cerridwen have elain train with them
I want the sisters to start training after they go into the cauldron, like they adapted to being poor and taking care of literally everything but then can't adjust to a possibly better life
DEATH has no weight in the war
HOW TF DID THE DEATH GODS DIE IN LIKE ONE MN
Would love Feyre to still have the kid but like make it normal
Rewrite acosf completely
Love the dance scene maybe thats how nesta meets eris or starts to fall for lucien
Sure the blood rite might still happen like i want the valkyries to be a thing and training still but if she starts training sooner the blood rite is more earned
Fix the night court dynamic and politics its just dumb they are so evil yet they want ppl to trust them and work them also we need more culture and politicals ans traditions
How are mates so rare yet every highlord has ome and so do the 3 sisters
The timeline needs to change or just that rhys and inner circle isn't alive 500 years ago then get with a 20 year old girl like noo
The illyrians ans rhys needs to be fixed hes like oh girl power but then illyrian woman are treated like ass
Mating ceremony
Jurain is back to normal way to quick to be an eye for how long
Feyre shouldn't be ALL POWERFUL she should be as powerful as a highlord like she has a drop if each , also this needs to be explored more
Feyre and tamlin fight like physically ?
Suriel lives ?
Beron should die in acowar and eris is crowned
Fix the spring court its like the other courts don't exist till the inner circle needs them like no
Why did rhys sister get killed off
If the sisters train after acomaf then they fight in the battle together
Acowar feyre doesn't go back or she does just to fight him like i hated that
Amren is just a cunt thats her only skill
Multi pov ?
Inner circle is just a bunch of babies
Back to the 500 year gap like feyre he literally has no gf for that long
Amarantha needs to stay (also she called her feyre darling first)
A court of song and shadow is canon but again not 500 years ago
There needs to be more time between the books or more time between wars or stuff
Explore the magic better like we need a power scale not just the ground rumbled
Explore nestas powers like how is rhys so scRed of her
How is amren just like 15,000 and shes just mean
Pacing and structure filler chapters take forever and big events are over so quick
Don't tell us ,show us
Feyre whines too much
Emeries back story changes in the same book
Maybe hybern is a pawn for koschei
Tamlin glamouring feyres mind the whole first book and nesta has no issues with deflecting a glammour
Lucien in book 1 described to look like beron
Lucien book 3 described not looking like his family
Rhys tells feyre book 2 wind is from day court but in book 3 its a spring court power
Cassian can have his guys hanging out but feyre cant give birth to a baby with wings
Tamlins soldiers
What did tamlin actually do vs what feyre says he did
House of wind stairs
Glamouring vs daemati
Veritas orb
Highlords powers
What is hybern doing during amaranths reign
Cassian's backstory
Fae aging
Is alis still alive ? what if feyre had to kill her nephews
Eris calls mor a liar and her power is truth
Starlight pool
Cassian and mor are described one way ans it changes
“No insult if she had been into females” but mor cant be gay like whats the reason
Far kids are rare but there are alot
Mama archeron
Rhys and the red star (makes a model of the worlds at some point)
How was mor is vallahan for like 2 books ans gets no where
I would've kept Rhys a little more evil, especially after we see him outside of UTM, as I much preferred the unwillingly falling for the villain trope from book 1. I'd have liked to see him gradually soften, mainly towards Feyre, while opening up to his friends. At the same time, I'd have made Feyre more morally grey, learning to stand up for herself and do morally questionable things in the name of her own justice.
I would kill maybe one or two meaningful characters. Like a sister or one of the IC
Nesta doesn't lose her powers
Sorry for the long post! I'd genuinely love to hear everyone's thoughts on this, both the good and the bad. I'm really interested in hearing different perspectives and seeing what others would have done differently, so please feel free to share your opinions. Thank you! ❤️
EDIT !!
Right, so everybody in the comments who is just hating on me I love this series. I love these characters. I am unhappy with how unjust. The characters have been treated and like I said this is all for a fanfiction that I am creating. I’m not asking Sarah to change all these not doing anything like that except for simply stating that I wanted to change these things in my fanfiction.