r/acotar_rant • • Jun 28 '26 Bravo Popcorn

Fanart There, I fixed it

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

As many of us feel as though this series wasn’t accurately marketed to us, I thought I would adjust the title of each book to be a bit more fitting to what actually happens lol. Perhaps Sarah J Maas and her marketing team can take a page out of our book, pun intended.


r/acotar_rant • • 6d ago Sipping Tea WOW

Hottake SJM is the Taylor Swift of Writers

1.2k Upvotes

Hear me out. Remember the “Call Her Daddy” interview?

Maas explained that she’d been really popular in middle school, but a loner in high school who sought refuge in her writing. That’s totally fine, and as someone who had a similar experience, I can empathize.

HOWEVER, when one locks oneself away during those formative years, there are experiences you miss out on, like friendships and heartbreak. It reminds me of Swift, who spent her teenage years pursuing stardom instead of living her life.

In the decades since, Swift has re-released the same albums over and over again and cultivated a fan base that would die for her.

Similarly, Maas—and her diehard fans—insisted that we HAD to read and re-read all of her other books before the release of her latest albums (ahem, books 😉). The Easter Eggs! The crossovers! How will we ever comprehend the stories otherwise?!

Ok, back to the interview. She told host Alex Cooper that she was turning 40 and had planned a weeklong celebration titled “Sarah’s Eras” in honor of her many eras in life, which sounds a wee bit conceited to me. Fame, I fear, has finally gone to her head.

The result? Poor writing from Maas. Mediocre music from Taylor. In my opinion, both of these artists have lost the plot. I think they see themselves as too big to fail, and they’re surrounded by “yes men” who are afraid to challenge them or offer helpful critique.

Could this be the inevitable journey of a famous artist? Maybe. But there are other artists who know when to quit, when to step aside and accept the legacy they’ve left on the world.

Either way, I used to enjoy and respect the work of both Maas and Swift. Now, I just want them to retire and allow other creators to take the stage and elevate the craft.


r/acotar_rant • • 16d ago

Rant Nyx should have been a girl, not a boy.

1.2k Upvotes

And its not only because Nyx is the primordial goddess of Night in Greek Mythology (and Eris the goddess of Discord).

Because let's ask ourselves - in canon, what will Feysand actually do when Nyx comes of age? Will they send him to the Illyrian war camps, as "tradition" demands? I mean, sure, no biggie, Nyx will become the best warrior ever, right?

And what if Nyx were actually born a girl?! Well, Feysand, would you send your daughter off to the illyrian steps, to have her wings clipped along with the other illyrians, according to the "tradition"? Or will you keep her in Velaris? There is also the possibility that the Illyrians won't do anything to Female Nyx because she is simply the High Lord's daughter, but then you would still have these double standards.

Because all those other illyrian women and girls don't have a powerful daddy who can blood-mist anyone in sight.

Female Nyx could have really made Feysand think about the illyrian wing-clipping for girls and sought quicker ways to abolish it, for the sake of their illyrian daughter. And, when Female Nyx actually inherits the Night Court from her parents, the illyrians would have no choice but to accept her. The first ACTUAL High Lady in prythian history (Feyre doesn't count because the title was given to her by Rhys, not chosen by the Land itself)

SJM really made it easy on herself to make Nyx a boy instead of a girl, because then she would have no choice but to adress the whole illyrian wing-clipping to the fans and it would have made Feysand look even worse.


r/acotar_rant • • 15d ago

Rant Not wanting to read about constant breastfeeding isn't misogynistic Spoiler

1.1k Upvotes

This topic has already been milked dry (Pun intended) so I'll try to keep it short-ish.

I just wanted to say that being annoyed by the obnoxious amount of times that Feyre's overfilled, milky boobs are mentioned isn't sexist and/or inherently misogynistic.

If you found empowerment in seeing motherhood represented in this book, I'm happy for you; truly. But let's not act like it's insane for people to not necessarily enjoy the excessive amount of times it was mentioned. It truly wasn't needed, us-- the readers were informed that Feyre was breastfeeding the first time. I'm sure that the majority of us learned to infer in school and could conclude that whenever Feyre was with Nyx, she was also breastfeeding him during that time.

I feel like the word misogyny is losing its weight and true meaning. Personally I think it's nasty to stick random strangers with these horrible qualities and names based on their opinions of a FANTASY book. Talk to people, get to know their reasoning.

We're too old to be acting like this.

(I'm not referring to people who have said that motherhood has made Feyre weak and useless, I can agree that those takes are a little off. I'm talking about people who genuinely just didn't find it interesting or preferred it to be kept to a minimum.)


r/acotar_rant • • May 02 '26

ACOTAR 🐺🏹 Feyre - girl - you literally asked for the paints 😭

Post image
891 Upvotes

r/acotar_rant • • 12d ago Bravo

Hottake "To The Stars Who Listen..." Is a Meaningless Slogan And I Hate It

868 Upvotes

There are SO MANY cool quotes in ACOTAR that could be the rallying cry of this fandom. There's "you do not yield" or "don't let the hard days win" or "I am a wolf" or "I am the rock against which the surf breaks" or even "stay with the High Lord" (RIP Surry) so WHY do we have the most MILQUETOAST NOTHING of a saying as our calling card???

To the stars who listen? What stars? What are they listening to? Is there a star up there who takes out its celestial earbud to hear the needs of a horny winged eternal teenager and his instagram-faced beaux?

And the dreams that are answered? Who, except for the lactation consultants of Velaris, has actually had a dream answered? And why are we talking about answered dreams when we have a whole underclass (literally, they are under a mountain in the Court of Nightmares) who just seem to exist to suffer?

It just. It feels like the cute social media nothing burger that it is. It means nothing. It stands for nothing. It's not even at the emotional climax of a book. It doesn't say anything about the suffering of any member of the inner circle. It doesn't contain any deep thoughts about the struggles they've each had to go through in order to get where they are. It's just cute.

Rant over, I really enjoy the books, I just wish we had better taste in pull quotes and Nesta had better taste in men.


r/acotar_rant • • 4d ago

Rant Nyx should have been a girl

858 Upvotes

We all know something is gonna happen to Nyx and it's going to be that stupid plot device where a baby is in trouble and suddenly all the high lords come together like some family to save one kid.

I hate that Nyx is a boy. It would have been 10000% better if he was a girl (plus Nyx literally being a goddesses name) so that we'd actually get some plot of Rhys and Feyre finally giving a shit about the rest of their court realizing what future their leaving for their daughter so they decide to finally stop the brutalizing of Illyrian women. Maybe even Nyx if he was a boy would. It's just so generic because Nyx is just gonna continue the cycle his father and those before him allowed.

It would have been amazing to read, in future books, of Nyx breaking the cycle her forefathers allowed and finally being the change the court needed. A high lady ACTUALLY chosen by the land and not just a title to stop them whining (looking at you Feyre).

SJM is just not a good writer when she doesn’t plan shit out like she did with TOG.


r/acotar_rant • • 17d ago

Rant Idc what anyone says she was too young. Spoiler

851 Upvotes

warning, spoilers for all the books ig

I HATEEEE how young Feyre became a mother. I understand that SJM is a millennial and her along with most of that age group are becoming/already mothers at this point and she wants everyone to feel seen and heard but if you’re going to do that you need to age up Feyre. Here’s this recently human girl who’s still navigating becoming a whole new species, now leading a territory, and then she becomes a mother too? With her 500 year old mate who’s had the time to grow and live and learn. There should’ve been a time jump and it irritates me that there wasn’t.


r/acotar_rant • • 15d ago Bravo

Rant Tamlin was right about Feyre Spoiler

801 Upvotes

"Look to the male sitting beside her. Ask what he stands to gain—what they stand to gain from this war, or lack of it. Would we fight Hybern, only to find ourselves with a Queen and King of Prythian? She’s proved her ambition—and you saw how he was more than happy to serve Amarantha to remain unscathed.”

Tamlin knew. He clocked Feyre immediately, he was right. He saw how power-hungry she was and look where we are now! With Feyre now aiming to be a tyrannical ruler. Each new book, Feyre worsens as a person. Rhys enables her worst traits, giving her the High Lady title was a mistake and I wonder if he regrets it. Her being all "you should be High King and then everyone will bow down to you!" whoa girl, slow down. She got power-hungry so fast and let it all go to her head.

Feyre is so high on her self-esteem, so haughty, self-centered as well as so quick to wish violence on those she doesn't like. But Tamlin is the violent one with a short-temper? Her thoughts about others are always about how she could violently rip their lives apart. I've seen people compare ACOSH Feyre to Amarantha and are they wrong? Her whole spiel about manipulating the Prythian courts was insane. If she actually went through with it, I wouldn't be surprised. She has entered the path of villainy and is nowhere near leaving anytime soon and I question why SJM is writing this into the story if it isn't to condemn it. But at the same time, the story is still talking about the Hewn City as this horrible place so my expectations are low.


r/acotar_rant • • Aug 20 '26

Rant I completely exhausted by SJM MCU-ification of ACOTAR and the forced 10 book homework

773 Upvotes

Okay, I need to rant because if I say this anywhere else on BookTok or Instagram, ill literally be burned at the stake.

With the recent news about A Court of Splintered Harmony and A Court of Forgotten Melody I feel like we need to have an honest conversation about where this series is heading. Seriously, Is anyone else getting extremely opportunistic vibes from SJM and her publishers? ACOTAR was originally built as a neat, tight trilogy centered on Feyre. Then it expanded, which was fine, but now it's spiraling into an 18-book mandatory reading list just to understand the ending of a single series. Why am I being forced to read two other brick-sized series just to get closure on ACOTAR? The moment someone expresses excitement for new ACOTAR books but hesitates about the multiverse, a section of the fandom instantly comes at them saying "If you only excited for ACOTAR characters, you're not an SJM fan, you're just an ACOTAR fan"

EXACTLY? THAT MAKES PERFECT SENSE?! Since when is it a crime to just love ONE series without having to commit to an entire author's 10 book catalog like it's a homework assignment? Why are people being gatekept for just wanting to follow the story they actually signed up for? It genuinely feels like the publisher realized ACOTAR is a cash cow that can be milked indefinitely by smashing every series together and relying on hype tropes. And honestly, the new cover art giving heavy Stryga/Stygian Spider vibes basically confirms the ToG crossover is happening.

My biggest fear with this ToG merging is character assassination across the board. Aelin is SJM's ultimate favorite child. If she shows up I just know SJM is going to nerf everyone else power and IQ just to make Aelin look like an unstoppable genius. Honestly , if a character like Nesta (who literally stood her ground against the entire Night Court) gets completely sidelined or humbled just to prop up Aelins ego, I will lose my mind. I can already envision the inevitable Avengers: Endgame-style final battle where Rhys is on his knees and telepathically hears "Let’s rattle the stars" or something before portals open up. (Also, can we talk about "What was broken will be remade"? Are we seriously just using Lord of the Rings slogans again?)

It's just frustrating. Merging three huge series isn't clever storytelling it feels like forced consumption to boost backlist sales.

EDIT: Thanks to everyone who weighed in! I couldn'treply to every single comment, but im genuinely glad to see Im not the only one feeling exhausted by the direction the series is taking. it's refreshing to see that critical discussion is still alive and well here, and that we can actually talk about these marketing choices without pretending every single decision is perfect.


r/acotar_rant • • 16d ago

Rant Rhys is…not hot anymore (ACOSH) Spoiler

745 Upvotes

I loved Rhys. He has always been one of my all time favorite MMCs. But in ACOSH…I feel like he lost everything that made him such a fantastic, sexy character. In the previous books I loved his scheming, his smooth personality, the way he flexes his power and sensuality. But in ACOSH, all he does is cry over his beautiful baby, yell at other members of the IC, fail to advance anything plot-wise, and in general seem to be just trying to keep his head above water. He never comes across as hot or powerful, we have to have Feyre narrate his exceptionalism until she’s blue in the face (or has full boobs again). The only spark of the old Rhys was in his interactions with Nesta.

Am I alone in this? I was so sad to read him in this new book. Rhys used to be ✨Daddy✨ and now he’s just…dad.


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 03 '26

Hottake Amarantha canonically wanted Tamlin over Rhys. Feyre fell in love with Tamlin despite the mating bond with Rhys. Safe to say Tamlin's hotter than Rhysand.

733 Upvotes

This is purely a joke opinion but also what I truly believe. Like, Feyre thinks Rhysand's the hottest because of the mating bond (I'll admit, he's probably attractive like literally every Fae in this book, but still), but literally all the evidence points to Tamlin being hotter. I'm turning off reply notifications since I'm uninterested in arguing, but just wanted to get this out there, lmao.


r/acotar_rant • • May 12 '26

Meme I love the fact that we know nothing about him but he's still most hyped character and we know nothing about elain too but she's the most hated

Post image
719 Upvotes

r/acotar_rant • • 20d ago Bravo

ACOSF 🎭 I do not care to read about motherhood, especially in first person

714 Upvotes

I've had enough of Sarah J Maas self insert pregnancy and motherhood fanfiction. It ruined ACOSF for me. It's already ruining the new book.

A few pages into ACOSH and I was already skimming. There's a reason I do not read books centered around motherhood and pregnancy, one I do not need to elaborate here.

Sure, we expected a baby Nyx and doting (sleep deprived) Feyre and Rhys. But the lactation jump scare in first person POV in chapter 2 is so unnecessary. It adds absolutely nothing to the plot at hand. But it just keeps going and going. Why are other characters narrating how Feyre breastfeeds? It's implied that Rhys has a thing for her leaking breasts. which, fine. Everyone gets to like whatever they like. But is this really the representation of motherhood readers want?

These characters I've loved for the past 10 years have done a 180. From the "your choice, always" supposed king of communication Rysand, to Mrs "I've just found my freedom. I want to live my life without the rigid roles my ex tried to force into me" Feyre.

Yes, I get that Sarah J Maas modled Rys after her Husband (literally just looks up a picture of her hubby or any interview of hers). Sure, their son is a wonderful, huge topic in her life. I get wanting to write about all the new feelings she experience. Unfortunately, it didn't read true to character to me, at all. Especially not the way it was executed in ACOSF.

The inclusion of her moma bear rage in this book seems ridiculous. The focus on breast feeding more fetishizing than necessary.

So yeah, my once upon a time favourite character has been reduced to a bad caricature of motherhood. I'm dreading every chapter of hers. And I'm severely disappointed because I started Sarah J Maas' books for the empowered female characters who dare to go against norms and learn to be fine by themselves, who somehow manage to enter relationships without losing themselves (or learning from such mistakes). With that in mind, this current book turned out to be disappointing. Motherhood and breasts are just very present examples of cracks in the storyline, for me.

Anyone having similarly visceral reactions to these themes?


r/acotar_rant • • 5d ago

Rant Mates sure are common for being "rare"

638 Upvotes

SJMs world building is such a joke.

One of the many things so inconsistent is mates. Mates are described as rare, but they sure do happen a lot.

Rhys and Feyre

Cass and Nesta

Lucien and Elain

Tamlins parents

Rhysands parents

Kalias and Viviane

Drakon and Miryam

Alis's sister and brother in law

Then we have Azriel over here just waiting for his own mate like it's a guarantee, which I don't blame him at this point.

I wouldn't be surprised if Helion and the Lady of Autumn (give my girl a name I beg thee) are mates.

The mothers out here like Oprah, giving out mates like new cars.


r/acotar_rant • • Sep 07 '26 Heartwarming

ACOTAR 🐺🏹 Nesta already redeemed herself in Book 1: why does nobody acknowledge the things she did for Feyre?!

634 Upvotes

“Your beast’s little trick didn’t work on me,” she said with quiet steel. “Apparently, an iron will is all it takes to keep a glamour from digging in. So I had to watch as Father and Elain went from sobbing hysterics into nothing. I had to listen to them talk about how lucky it was for you to be taken to some made-up aunt’s house, how some winter wind had shattered our door. And I thought I’d gone mad—but every time I did, I would look at that painted part of the table, then at the claw marks farther down, and know it wasn’t in my head.” 

I’d never heard of a glamour not working. But Nesta’s mind was so entirely her own; she had put up such strong walls—of steel and iron and ash wood—that even a High Lord’s magic couldn’t pierce them. 

“Elain said—said you went to visit me, though. That you tried.”

Nesta snorted, her face grave and full of that long-simmering anger that she could never master.
“He stole you away into the night, claiming some nonsense about the Treaty. And then everything went on as if it had never happened. It wasn’t right. None of it was right.” 
My hands slackened at my sides. 

“You went after me,” I said. “You went after me—to Prythian.”
 “I got to the wall. I couldn’t find a way through.”

I raised a shaking hand to my throat. “You trekked two days there and two days back—through the winter woods?” 

She shrugged, looking at the sliver she’d pried from the table.

“I hired that mercenary from town to bring me a week after you were taken. With the money from your pelt. She was the only one who seemed like she would believe me.”

“You did that—for me?” 

Nesta’s eyes—my eyes, our mother’s eyes—met mine. 

“It wasn’t right,” she said again.

Tamlin had been wrong when we’d discussed whether my father would have ever come after me—he didn’t possess the courage, the anger. If anything, he would have hired someone to do it for him. But Nesta had gone with that mercenary. My hateful, cold sister had been willing to brave Prythian to rescue me. 

“What happened to Tomas Mandray?” 

I asked, the words strangled. 
“I realized he wouldn’t have gone with me to save you from Prythian.” 

And for her, with that raging, unrelenting heart, it would have been a line in the sand. I looked at my sister, really looked at her, at this woman who couldn’t stomach the sycophants who now surrounded her, who had never spent a day in the forest but had gone into wolf territory … Who had shrouded the loss of our mother, then our downfall, in icy rage and bitterness, because the anger had been a lifeline, the cruelty a release. But she had cared—beneath it, she had cared, and perhaps loved more fiercely than I could comprehend, more deeply and loyally. 

“Tomas never deserved you anyway,” I said softly. 

My sister didn’t smile, but a light shone in her blue-gray eyes.

 “Tell me everything that happened,” she said—an order, not a request. So I did.

And when I finished my story, Nesta merely stared at me for a long while before asking me to teach her how to paint.

This doesn’t look like someone who doesn’t care for her sister. Also, why doesn’t Feyre mention all of this to her IC friends? Or even the fandom when we discuss her actions?!


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 10 '26

Rant Rhysands iconic quote is just plagiarism from Howls Moving Castle

629 Upvotes

It drives me crazy when people gush over SJMs "incredible" writing skills and use quotes like "There you are. I've been looking for you.". She didn't come up with that. That's just a watered down version of what Howl says to Sophie. She even takes the assualt attempt from that scene.

In Acotar, Feyre is being dragged away by 3 Fae who are amused by her fear and plan to assualt her. She trips and is caught by Rhys, who comes up from behind her and wraps his arm around her shoulder.

"There you are. I've been looking for you. Thank you for finding her for me."

In Howls Moving Castle, Sophie is cornered by two soldiers who attempt to assault her. One comments "she's even cuter when she's scared". Howl comes up behind her and wraps his arm around her shoulder saying "There you are sweetheart. Sorry I'm late. I was looking everywhere for you." He then uses his magic to control the two guards' bodies and force them to march away.

Sure people will say that authors are often "inspired" by other work, but give credit where it's due.

SJM sure does seem to be inspired by a whole lot of other work, but just produces watered down versions.

(ALSO it's later "revealed" Rhys had been having flashes of feyre in dreams (when she was a minor) and so he was literally looking for her and that's supposed to be romantic. In Howls Moving Castle, Sophie told a younger version of Howl she knows how to help him and to find her in the future. So he's literally been looking for her his whole life. Which is romantic af and paints the whole movie in a new light)

Edit: if you come in with a "so you hate pancakes" comment, I'm not going to argue against something I didn't say. I said what I said and I meant exactly that. No more. No less.


r/acotar_rant • • Oct 11 '26

Rant What’s a small detail that was added that makes you wonder why SJM would even include that

628 Upvotes

I’m doing a reread and I just started frost and starlight. In the very beginning Feyre mentions that she’s donating a portion of her salary to help rebuild the Rainbow. My initial question reading that was…who’s paying the rest of it? Surely it’s not on the citizens to pay? And if the night court is footing the bill then why donate her salary?
Then very shortly after that, when she’s still wondering around the city, she’s shopping with Mor in a jewelry shop and Mor says something along the lines of “you know we have enough money to buy a bathtub full of those” to a huge sapphire. Then Feyre continues on thinking about how vast their wealth is.

So then why the f*ck is the night court not fulling funding the rebuilding outright?? The detail about Feyre donating some of her salary actually makes the whole court look bad instead of what I think SJMs intention of making Feyre look selfless.


r/acotar_rant • • 26d ago

ACOSF 🎭 Pregnancy storyline just doesn’t make sense Spoiler

565 Upvotes

In my second reading of SF, the pregnancy arc is pissing me off even more. It just genuinely does not make sense. There’s so reason they shouldn’t be able to perform a C-section. You mean to tell me Cassian could be sliced and injured so bad in battle that his intestines are outside his body and be healed perfectly fine but they couldn’t at least attempt to cut the baby out???? You mean to tell me in hundreds, thousands of years, no female has ever needed a C-section??


r/acotar_rant • • Mar 10 '26

Hottake Velaris is a flop city and I’m sick of people praising it and making merch for it.

552 Upvotes

Yes, I said it, Velaris is a flop city. I don’t understand why people praise it so much when there are so many other cool places in Prythian to talk about.

The Summer Court has Adriata, which is cool as hell. A castle made of seashells!? That’s super cool! The Spring Court has Tamlin’s manor, which I’ve always envisioned as a mini Versailles is awesome!

The Autumn Court has The Forest House, which is literally *a castle underground*. GUYS, why aren’t we talking about these places more??

Velaris gives me “rich white people, poors need not come here” vibes. Just because it’s some secret special place with some townhouses and an arts district, people suddenly love to blow smoke up its ass and I’m tired of it.

It’s giving segregated Salt Lake City, Utah. It’s giving white Christian girl vibes.

SJM needs to stop glazing Velaris, I stg.


r/acotar_rant • • Sep 22 '26

Rant Rant: The destruction of the Spring Court wasn’t a girlboss moment for Feyre. It was the death and displacement of thousands of people

551 Upvotes

Man, the amount of people who are just okay with Feyre allowing thousands of fey to just die and suffer under Hybern for a girlboss moment with the Spring Court is disturbing.

Like her promising to destroy the livelihood of an entire population in the name of petty revenge and a refusal to acknowledge the greater politics at play is a good thing.

"Look at how boss she is!" Thousand are dead, enslaved, or assaulted because she couldn't bother to communicate or even care for anyone other than herself and Rhys. So boss. So chic.

Bear in mind she could have used her Daemati powers to peek into Tamlin’s mind and possibly see his ruse.

And before people come at me saying that she was just tipping the SC off its axis cuz it was already failing ala Tamlin, two points:

  1. It was a sanctuary court in TAR, a place people actively left other courts to go too.

  2. Even if it was, my point still stands because Feyre actively made it worse. She showed no care for other people, including the sentry’s whose whippings she basically arranged.

Just keep in mind, what happened to Gwyn and the priests at Sangravah, most likely happened to thousands of fey because of what Feyre did.


r/acotar_rant • • Jul 23 '26

Rant i just realized one of Feyre's most iconic lines to Tamlin was straight-up copied from the movie Troy and I'm losing my mind 😭

525 Upvotes

Okay, so I was literally scrolling today and came across a scene from the movie Troy (2004) the famous confrontation where Menelaus is talking about Helen? he literally says "The sun was shining when your wife left you." My jaw physically DROPPED because wait a minute...ACOWAR?! Feyre saying to Tamlin: "The sun was shining when I left you."

??!!

i used to think that line was so badass and cold-hearted, one of the few moments I actually enjoyed! And then the algorithm decided to mock me today by showing me where it actually came from. First it was "To whatever end" taken directly from Théoden in The Lord of the Rings, then the Damar/Black Jewels "inspirations" and now literally word-for-word lines from 2000s blockbuster movies?!

Guys I'm about to lose my mind, why is EVERY SINGLE IDEA or line that I actually love in SJM books taken from somewhere else????


r/acotar_rant • • 14d ago Heartwarming

Rant ACOSH is proof Feyre was an unreliable narrator

516 Upvotes

Feyre finally is being exposed as an unreliable narrator. I've seen people say that the characters are so different but remember...The first 3 books are in her perspective:

-Rhys is perfect and their love is passionate and beautiful. But this book shows how controlling (to everyone) he can be and quick tempered. His temper got him some flack in ACOSF but remember that was in NESTAS pov. It also shows how unhealthily self-absorbed they are as a couple. The Idiotic Death Pack is just one example. Feyre is still naive as a High Lady and Rhys reveling in his perceived perfection of her refuses to correct her. Can Feyre honestly not understand why the Prythian Courts are hesitant to go to war after just ending one? Especially for people they have no connection to? Is it the right thing to do? Yes...but at the cost of their people?

-Azriel: I did a post a pre-ACOSH release on this subreddit saying Az would make a terribly toxic boyfriend...I didn't expect to be THIS correct. I even said that Azriel's "type" is "UNAVAILABLE" and Mor throws that EXACT term and sentiment in his face. I was very proud of myself for clocking that haha 😂

-Elain: I am soooo glad her behavior has come to light. Feyre and Nesta portrays her as. sweet, innocent, and kind. Despite this, I always didn't buy it. Yes, everyone coddled her, but she allowed it to happen and thrived off of it. Nesta always got the bad rep (arguably deserved), but Elain could be kind and innocent BECAUSE she let Nesta do her dirty work. BOTH sisters let a 14 y.o. Feyre go into the woods and relied on her. Elain wallowed in her trauma while everyone (including Nesta who also went into the Cauldron) took care of her. Yes, she lost A LOT but everyone went thru trauma as well. Then.... As soon as Nesta spiraled.... There was Elain latching on to Feyre. And THE NAIL IN THE COFFIN FOR ME.... WHY didn't she outright reject Lucien??? If it was to punish him, then it's proof of her vindictiveness and cruelty. I can't tell you how hard I cheered when Rhys called her out on it in the kitchen.

Those are just some examples. I'm sure a lot of this will become evident on a reread now if you haven't clocked it already. Any notes?


r/acotar_rant • • Jun 29 '26

Rant SJM ruined cassian for me

510 Upvotes

When I first read the first three book of acotar i genuinely liked them and the characters. There seemed to be depth in The characters. and I was extremely excited for Nesta and Cassian’s book because cassian was my fav out of the three batboys after acowar and he had such GOOD chemistry with nesta I could feel the tension when they interacted. However, in silver flames SJM completely assassinated his character and his ENTIRE being was revolved around s3x and being a simp for rhysand and choosing him OVER his mate. I also hate how there were no details about his background and childhood except for one hurried chapter. Like a character like cassian had so much potential but SJM just nerfed him 😭😭

Also tell me why Eris and nesta had more tension and chemistry in one scene when they danced than cassian and nesta in the entire book