A manuscript passed a journalās technical screening and went through three rounds of peer review by three different reviewers.
Yet nearly 80 percent of its references were fabricated or did not exist.
That is the disturbing case described by He Liu in a recent correspondence published in the Journal of Dental Sciences.
The manuscript also contained major methodological problems, but what surprised the author most was that neither the editorial staff nor the reviewers had detected the false citations.
This is a serious warning for everyone involved in academic publishing.
Large language models can produce references that look entirely credible. They may include plausible author names, article titles, journal names, volume numbers, and publication dates. Unless someone checks the original source, a fabricated citation can easily pass as genuine.
Liu refers to research covering six independent investigations and 732 AI generated citations. Approximately 51 percent were fabricated.
The lesson for researchers is simple: never cite a reference merely because an AI tool supplied it.
Editors and reviewers also need to reconsider their procedures. A manuscript can look polished, follow the expected structure, and contain a long reference list while still being built on sources that do not exist.
Reference:
Liu, H. (2026). Fabricated citations in the age of AI: A wake-up call for editors, reviewers, and authors. Journal of Dental Sciences, 21, 679ā680.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jds.2025.10.024
#AcademicWriting #ResearchIntegrity #ArtificialIntelligence #AIinResearch #ScholarlyPublishing