r/academicpublishing • • Aug 04 '25

Someone has published my PhD

339 Upvotes

Hi all. I've just noticed that somebody has published my PhD as a book and it's available for sale on several websites around the world. They've spelt a couple of things wrong but it's evidently my PhD with the full title and my name as author.

I was just wondering if anybody has any experience of this, and what I can do to go about getting the book permanently removed. I've contacted individual sites but it has an ISBN and will continue to exist (and potentially reappear), and I was wondering if anybody knows how to stop that from happening.

Thanks!


r/academicpublishing • • 6d ago Bravo

"It is with great pleasure that I inform you..."

Post image
124 Upvotes

...that my first research paper has officially been published in a Springer Nature journal - Q2 scopus!!!

Wrote it when I was 19, and now I'm 20!!! I know I'm still just a kid trying to pursue academia and have SO much left to learn, but I genuinely cannot stop smiling today 😭

Just wanted to share this little moment of happiness with you all!!


r/academicpublishing • • 11d ago

Does anybody need an illustrator for their research?

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

I'm a full time Wildlife Illustrator and Concept Artist specializing in species illustration and wildlife representation, and am looking to have work in published literature. I am looking for somebody researching wildlife and/or conservation who is in need of diagrams/illustrations made for their work. Attached are some explamles of my work. I am willing to volunteer my skills to the right work depending on the scope of work and timeline. Cheers!


r/academicpublishing • • Sep 15 '26

Fabricated citations in the age of AI

Post image
56 Upvotes

A manuscript passed a journal’s technical screening and went through three rounds of peer review by three different reviewers.

Yet nearly 80 percent of its references were fabricated or did not exist.

That is the disturbing case described by He Liu in a recent correspondence published in the Journal of Dental Sciences.

The manuscript also contained major methodological problems, but what surprised the author most was that neither the editorial staff nor the reviewers had detected the false citations.

This is a serious warning for everyone involved in academic publishing.

Large language models can produce references that look entirely credible. They may include plausible author names, article titles, journal names, volume numbers, and publication dates. Unless someone checks the original source, a fabricated citation can easily pass as genuine.

Liu refers to research covering six independent investigations and 732 AI generated citations. Approximately 51 percent were fabricated.

The lesson for researchers is simple: never cite a reference merely because an AI tool supplied it.

Editors and reviewers also need to reconsider their procedures. A manuscript can look polished, follow the expected structure, and contain a long reference list while still being built on sources that do not exist.

Reference:

Liu, H. (2026). Fabricated citations in the age of AI: A wake-up call for editors, reviewers, and authors. Journal of Dental Sciences, 21, 679–680.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jds.2025.10.024

#AcademicWriting #ResearchIntegrity #ArtificialIntelligence #AIinResearch #ScholarlyPublishing


r/academicpublishing • • Jun 14 '11

I'm a scientific journal editor. AMA.

53 Upvotes

My name is Dave Flanagan, and I'm the Editor-in-Chief of Advanced Functional Materials (http://www.afm-journal.de), a leading materials science journal based in Germany. I've been with the journal full-time since 2004.

I'm responsible for the acquisition and peer review of papers we publish in the journal, and am also involved with their editing and publication online and in print. My PhD is in polymer science from the University of Massachusetts Amherst, but I handle papers on all aspects of materials science: energy, nanotechnology, biomaterials, organic electronics, ...

People have posted a lot of interesting questions to the /academicpublishing subreddit, so I thought I could help out with what science editors look for in a submitted manuscript, how peer review works, and how to get your results published in your first-choice journal.

So, go ahead and ask me anything.


r/academicpublishing • • Jul 22 '25

Revealed: Harvard publisher cancels entire journal issue on Palestine shortly before publication | Harvard University

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
52 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Oct 16 '26

What kind of questions do creative people ask

Post image
50 Upvotes

What if we paid as much attention to the questions students ask as to the answers they give?

In this study, Acar, Berthiaume, and Johnson examined questions generated by 165 undergraduate students during two divergent-thinking tasks.

Participants with higher originality and fluency scores were more likely to ask open-ended questions.

Questions exploring possibilities and thinking across time were also associated with creativity indicators, although those relationships varied across tasks.

For me, this offers a useful way to think about classroom questioning. Do our activities give students room to explore what might happen, consider alternatives, and pursue questions with several possible answers?

We could invite students to generate questions about a text, image, or problem before answering anything.

Then ask them to choose one that could open an interesting line of inquiry and explain why.

The study does not show that asking open-ended questions causes greater creativity. But it reminds us that students’ questions can reveal possibilities their answers alone may leave unseen.

Reference

Acar, S., Berthiaume, K., & Johnson, R. (2023). What kind of questions do creative people ask? Journal of Creativity, 33, Article 100062.


r/academicpublishing • • Nov 01 '11

8 years of research, 30 peer review articles, 20 PhD-students and all data faked -- academic fraud shocks The Netherlands

Thumbnail translate.google.nl
48 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 21 '25

TIL journal editors have to invite 20+ reviewers to get just 2 peer reviews for a single manuscript. The struggle is real.

46 Upvotes

I was discussing with a colleague who serves as an associate editor at a STEM journal. Honestly my mind is blown. Is this how it works at all journals? Why is it so difficult to get reviewers? How do we solve this problem?

The peer review process should be improved. But no one seems to know a better way. As I see it some people don’t even realize the problems with the system.


r/academicpublishing • • Jul 22 '11

The JSTOR papers hit bittorrent with- "the money paid for access today serves little significant purpose except to perpetuate dead business models. The "publish or perish" pressure in academia gives the authors an impossibly weak negotiating position, and the existing system has enormous inertia."

Thumbnail
thepiratebay.org
45 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Dec 06 '13

Elsevier, in final desperation mode, is going after authors sharing their own papers online

Thumbnail
svpow.com
39 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Sep 28 '11

Princeton bans academics from handing all copyright to journal publishers

Thumbnail
theconversation.edu.au
38 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 08 '19

I work for a scholarly publisher and like to make memes for our twitter account.

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 18 '25

We're Back! Reviving r/academicpublishing

Post image
36 Upvotes

Hello academic publishing community! This subreddit is under new moderation and we're excited to breathe new life into this space.

r/academicpublishing aims to be a resource for researchers, editors, publishers, and anyone involved in scholarly communication. Whether you're looking to discuss publishing trends, share experiences, or seek advice, you're welcome here.

What to expect:

  • Discussions about academic publishing processes

  • Updates on industry developments

  • Publishing advice and resources

  • Community support for publishing challenges

We're rebuilding this community together, and your input is valuable.

What topics would you like to see discussed? What resources would be helpful?

Join us in making this a useful space for the academic publishing community!

Note: Check out our subreddit rules.


r/academicpublishing • • May 04 '12

German university math department to cancel all Elsevier subscriptions

Thumbnail ma.tum.de
33 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 11 '12

The Research Works Act will kill Open-Access Journals

Thumbnail
thesocietypages.org
32 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 14 '26

The Age of Academic Slop is Upon Us

Thumbnail
hegemon.substack.com
31 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 03 '26

Your ā€œFailedā€ Results Deserve Publication — I’m a Journal Editor.AMA

31 Upvotes

I’m a postdoctoral researcher in Ireland and a Managing Editor of a peer-reviewed open access journal that focuses on publishing null and negative results.

In academia, many solid studies never see the light of day because the results aren’t ā€œpositiveā€ or ā€œexciting.ā€ Our journal exists to counter publication bias and improve research transparency.

Happy to answer questions about:

  1. Publishing null/negative results

  2. How editorial and peer-review decisions are made

  3. Common reasons papers get rejected

  4. Advice for PhD students and early-career researchers

  5. Academic publishing from an editor’s perspective

PS. This AMA is mod approved


r/academicpublishing • • Sep 20 '19

Academic Porn? (SFW)

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Apr 28 '12

Harvard University is now urging its faculty to publish in open journals to break the pay-model hold on research

Thumbnail
m.guardian.co.uk
31 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 15 '12

5,700 Researchers Boycott Elsevier

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
31 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 23 '12

100 academics at the University of Sydney, Australia, have been told this week that they will lose their jobs for not publishing frequently enough.

Thumbnail
blogs.nature.com
30 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Feb 29 '12

Elsevier's Research Works Act is dead!

Thumbnail
slate.com
29 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 17 '12

Ouch!

Thumbnail
smbc-comics.com
29 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Apr 28 '16

Who's downloading pirated papers? "Everyone"

Thumbnail
sciencemag.org
28 Upvotes