r/academicpublishing • • Jun 27 '26

Looking for feedback on an open-source literature review tool focused on reproducibility

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

As I've been recently working on a survey paper and needed a PRISMA figure to document the research process for reproducibility, I noticed that not many open-source tools support this natively. So I decided to build my own tool, and as time went on it ended up becoming my everyday lit review tool.

To the best of my knowledge, there are many great open-source tools for systematic reviews (AsReview, litstudy, paperscraper or ProfOlaf) and I clearly don't pretend to replace them. Surveyer (that's the name) simply focuses on a slightly different problem: reproducibility and proper exports for a survey papers and making it an another option for lit reviews.

It does everything from fetching (currently supports 5 sources), deduplication, concept and keyword filtering, snowballing (citation chasing) and complete exports (xlsx, PRISMA and BibTeX). It also has a nice TUI so feel free to play with it.

GitHub: https://github.com/IsmailHatim/Surveyer

I'd really appreciate any feedback from you, if you think that something is missing, have ideas for improvements or would like to contribute I'd be very happy to hear.

Important Note: LLM relevance filter feature is optional, as I know it can be non-reproducible and people are sceptical about this and reasonably so. But many recent survey paper use it in their systematic review and methodology as it can save you time with the manual review. Anyway this filtering is *soft* and auditable so papers are not excluded before the manual review.


r/academicpublishing • • Mar 26 '15

What steps can journals take to improve peer review and time to manuscript decision?

0 Upvotes

As an academic journal editor, what steps are you taking to refine your journal's peer review process? Do you track metrics about your journal, and which do you find most useful?

A new free eBook from Scholastica, "Academic Journal Management Best Practices: Tales from the Trenches" offers journal management insights and innovations from editors across disciplines. I'd love to hear other editors' thoughts on the topic!

eBook link: http://www.scholasticahq.com/academic-journal-management-tales-from-the-trenches


r/academicpublishing • • Aug 30 '25

Looking for Scopus Q3/Q4 journals with relatively fast acceptance (1 week)

4 Upvotes

I’m under some time pressure due to my graduation/submission requirements and need to publish in a Scopus or web of science -indexed journal (Q3 or Q4 is fine). I know that proper peer review takes time, but I’ve seen some journals and services claim extremely fast acceptance (even less than a week), which makes me worried about quality and predatory practices.

What I’m looking for is:

  • Legitimate Scopus-indexed journals (Q3/Q4 is okay)

  • Average time to first decision ideally 1**–2 weeks** (not fake “instant” acceptance)

  • Open access with transparent fees is fine, I can budget for APCs

  • Field: management, computer science,quality


r/academicpublishing • • Nov 25 '18

I found a (probably unintentional) plagiarism mistake in a peer-reviewed journal, what do I do?

0 Upvotes

1st-year college student looking for journals to support my argument for a class assignment using ebscohost. I found a quote in a paper where "Author A" quotes "Author B". Followed it to "Author B's" paper where she uses the phrase in question and credits it to "Author C". "Author C" is never mentioned in the in-text citation nor the bibliography of "Author A's" paper. Do I contact someone about this to make sure "Author C" is properly credited? If I contact the journal will "Author A" be reprimanded? I don't want to get anyone in trouble but also want to see this though.


r/academicpublishing • • 3d ago

I’ve indexed about 200 academic books. I built a tool so authors can index their own.

0 Upvotes

I’m a professional book indexer. Over the last 12 years I’ve indexed about 200 academic monographs and edited collections for presses including Duke, Oxford, Cambridge, Northwestern, and Texas.

Many of the authors I’ve worked with are surprised by what a professional index costs, and some end up paying for it themselves. So I built SeeAlso, a book indexing tool that lets authors index their own books for a fraction of what a professional indexer would charge.

You work directly from the PDF of your page proofs. You select terms on the page, and the tool tracks the page numbers, builds the index, and exports it in the format your press needs. It’s completely human-controlled. You decide what goes in the index and how it’s structured. The software handles the tedious parts.

It launched this week at seealso.io. There’s a free trial where you can upload your book and start indexing before you buy.

If you email me at [email protected], I’ll send you a discount code. I’m also glad to answer questions about indexing in general, here or by email.


r/academicpublishing • • Jul 07 '26

Are editors are responsible for personally checking every reference?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Apr 23 '26

I tested ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini on academic citations. Even with web search on, 35% had metadata problems.

0 Upvotes

Small pilot on how reliable the consumer AI websites are when a student asks them for academic sources.

Not an API benchmark. I used the latest web-based user interface products in a browser (with $20-ish subscriptions like ChatGPT 5.4, Claude opus 4.7 and Gemini 3.1 pro). If the product searched the web, showed citation cards, or ran its own source checks, I left it on. I wanted the default student experience, not a "model memory only" setup.

Setup

Three topics:

  • Medicine: GLP-1 receptor agonists in type 2 diabetes

  • CS: long-context Transformer attention

  • Psychology: replication crisis in social priming

That's 9 runs and 90 requested citations. One Claude run (CS topic) refused the format — it pushed back that conference papers and arXiv don't fit journal-style fields. I counted that as a real product outcome rather than a collection failure, so the verifier ended up with 80 citation-like entries.

Main result

28 of 80 parsed citations had a meaningful metadata problem: 35.0%.

ProductCheckedProblematicRate
ChatGPT30620.0%
Gemini30930.0%
Claude201365.0%

Claude's sample is smaller because of the refusal noted above.

Field mattered more than I expected

FieldCheckedProblematicRate
CS20525.0%
Medicine301756.7%
Psychology30620.0%

The models often had the right reference names and general topic, but the surrounding citation fields were wrong.

Typical failures:

  • DOI resolves, but the title or journal doesn't match the claimed paper.

  • DOI is real, but attached to different metadata than the citation implies.

  • Plausible venue or page range that doesn't match the DOI record.

  • Paper exists, but the full citation is malformed enough to be unreliable.

I didn't try to classify deeper "the paper exists but doesn't support the claim" errors. That needs expert review.

Web search didn't make it go away

In 8 of 9 runs, the UI showed some form of search, browsing, citation cards, or self-verification. Claude even displayed "verifying citations systematically to prevent fabrication" during one run. The checked set still hit 35%.

Can you repeat the outcome?

Likely not. They're language models, and their outputs are random. But you could definitely get something similar.

I've been trying to put together a tool to solve this problem quickly and accurately, and it's harder than it looks. If anyone's curious, the work-in-progress lives here

The pipeline I fine-tuned can cross-check citations against databases like Crossref and have the AI summarize what's off. But paywalls are the real wall. It's tough to catch the deeper class of errors mentioned above.


r/academicpublishing • • Dec 19 '14

Here is my academic article. I would like you guys to check it and tell me your opinion.

0 Upvotes

Hello. Here it goes: https://www.scribd.com/doc/250522771/Academic-Article

It is an academic article, presented at Positivo University, Curitiba, Brazil; in Brazilian means. I would like you to give your opinion about it. The article was written and presented in 2013, and translated by me a month ago.

I appreciate your concern in order to evaluate our work (mine and my colleague's). PS: you can also point grammatical errors or strange sentences that I might have used.


r/academicpublishing • • Sep 26 '18

[Academic] Parents Purchasing Laptops (parents of teens)

0 Upvotes

Hi people, I'm a student at Breda University of Applied sciences and I'm currently researching about laptop preferences, brand knowledge and children's involvement in the buying process. The answers to this survey will remain anonymous. Please help me out by filling out my survey.

https://nhtv.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_1zWj89LdtvAi5Fz

Thanks!


r/academicpublishing • • May 18 '17

Does anyone know this type of font in Microsoft word?

Thumbnail
i.reddituploads.com
0 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Mar 09 '14

Use of reporting guidelines in medical publication

0 Upvotes

Reporting guidelines are something that have grown in popularity over the past decade. These are effectively checklists of the things that you should report when reporting specific types of studies. For example CONSORT (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials - http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2860339/ ) is one of the most successful and was where the highly successful flow diagram originated. Similarly, the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses - http://www.prisma-statement.org/) statement has revolutionised the way in which systematic reviews and meta-analyses are reported.

Irrespective of the type of research you’re writing up, it’s worth knowing about reporting guidelines because they can really help you in ensuring your work contains all the required detail. Anytime you’re writing up any kind of experimental design, it’s worth heading over to the EQUATOR network library (http://www.equator-network.org/) and just having a quick look at if the kind of study you’re writing up has a reporting guideline. Reporting guidelines cover a huge number of designs, and you maybe surprised to find that your niche has it’s own reporting standard! There are also guidelines for specific intervention types within these study designs (for example randomised trial reporting for alternative medicine interventions etc.)

The real benefit of reporting guidelines is that they act as a checklist to ensure that you have included features considered critical by experts, following a review of the literature. Many journals now require that you complete a checklist for the specific study design of your manuscript upon submission - so doing this early can really save a headache when it comes to submission. People often misuse the checklists, you should put a page number next to each item so that journal editors can quickly determine if your article meets the required criteria. Even if the journal you plan on submitting to doesn’t require completion, it’s a very useful way of ensuring you manuscript addresses key points and adds another level of methodological quality to your work.

If you have any questions about reporting guidelines, I’d be happy to answer them.

[A little plug for my service that some of you maybe interested in, also a new blog coming!]

proof-read.it speciliase in academic proofreading and language editing. (www.proof-read-it.co.uk)


r/academicpublishing • • Aug 28 '19

Current Updates in Dermatological Problems

0 Upvotes

Current Updates in Dermatological Problems (CUDP) is an international, peer-reviewed, open access electronic journal that emphasizes on the latest clinical and experimental research in all aspects of skin disease and cosmetic interventions from molecular studies to clinical investigations.


r/academicpublishing • • Sep 09 '25

Fed up with academic publication valuation?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to get a gauge for what proportion of academics are tired of the status quo with issues of emphasis on journal impact factor, citation counts that can be gamed, and journal prestige over quality and actual impact. If I get some traction here, I'll set up a poll. Thanks everyone!


r/academicpublishing • • Aug 12 '26

What do you actually do at the point where you think “has someone already done this?”

0 Upvotes

Disclosure up front: I build tooling in this area, so I have an interest.
I’m asking because I genuinely don’t know what people’s real workflows look like, and every answer I’ve assumed has turned out to be wrong. Not asking what you’d recommend. Asking what you actually do, including the unglamorous version.
Specifically: When the thought first arrives, what’s the first thing you open? Google Scholar, Scopus, a specific database, Zotero, an LLM, or do you message someone?
If the first pass comes back with nothing, what’s the second move? Do you change vocabulary, chase citations backwards, ask a librarian, or decide it’s fine and get on with it? Has anything actually changed for you in the last two years? Everyone talks about Elicit, Consensus, SciSpace, Perplexity, Connected Papers, Litmaps and the rest, but I can’t tell who’s genuinely using them for this versus who tried one once. And the bit I’m most curious about: how do you know when to stop? Is there a point where you decide you’ve looked properly, or do you just run out of time and submit? Field and career stage would help if you don’t mind saying, since I suspect a first-year PhD and a 20-year PI are doing completely different things here.


r/academicpublishing • • Mar 06 '14

Four more reasons to be skeptical of open-access publishing — Anurag Agrawal, Trends in Plant Science (pdf)

Thumbnail eeb.cornell.edu
2 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Aug 11 '15

Journal Search and Selection Tool - Answer 11 questions, and the tool will find the top 5 publications best suited to your research.

Thumbnail
findmyjournal.com
2 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Apr 16 '15

In the beginning was the Word

Thumbnail
martineve.com
0 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 17 '16

Has anyone ever asked JSTOR to take down your articles? If so, what happened?

1 Upvotes

Four of the academic articles I wrote before leaving academia are still on JSTOR. I'd like them removed--is this possible? I don't think I signed away copyright ownership to the journals, so can I use a DMCA takedown notice? Can they republish and save my articles without my permission/approval? If so, what laws allow this?


r/academicpublishing • • Aug 25 '26

Deterministic way to define what is common knowledge in scientific article: Tool to check for citations need in article.

0 Upvotes

I was recently looking for a tool which needed to analyze a text, that can be an article in scientific format and that one would need to tell which term in specific is missing citation because its not common knowledge or any other reason. Or if some expression in your text has unnecessary citation reference.

Of course that involves a lot of steps. I know there are some tools which can lemmatize a text, eg. Sketch engine, it discovers what is a term, so that you can take the next steps.

I saw Some which can look for sources from the sentence itself of your text, eg. Citely, GPTzero. But again, that is not exactly what i want, looks like isolated feature, something incomplete, not the general concept.

I have also recently discovered the Purdue OWL citation law, which defines a term as common knowledge if there are 5 other articles which mentions that term without a citation.

The first thing that came into my mind about how such tool would work is it would keep a database of words and its relevance, based on a set of heuristics, probably only amount of citations over the internet articles about it for now.

This database could be public and you could have some step to populate it also, it could read articles on the internet (API, web scrapping, articles repositories, periodicals) and setting its credibility like that automatically.

***Edit: Later I noticied and also some people have mentioned that words score is poor measure. And that claims as a whole are better way to analyze something. So database would not be realistic, because the possibilities of arrengements of words are infinite***

Then there could be some threshold of what score is common knowledge, what is not. Eg. 20 articles about/mentioning such term would consider this term common knowledge. Or using the Purdue OWL law like i mentioned before. This is the general protocol.

Then the implementations of such protocol could be done in several ways, in your editor as an LSP (nvim plugin/VsCode extension, web extension, website, desktop app, AI assistant) by checking your text and comparing with those scores from the database, showing errors/warnings etc.


r/academicpublishing • • 8d ago

Why do journals get paid yet reviewers don’t

8 Upvotes

Why do journals get paid yet reviewers don’t. People should stop reviewing articles for free


r/academicpublishing • • Aug 10 '12

How Google Scholar Can Make You a More Efficient Researcher

Thumbnail
journalprep.com
4 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Jan 17 '19

Academics are slaves to where they publish

Thumbnail
medium.com
5 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • May 27 '26

I want to start writing review papers to enhance my CV and research profile.My major is Zoology, Im currently an undergraduate student in my 2nd year. But my college is not very supportive not even profs, its basically a tier3 college. Can you helpme.

0 Upvotes

how do I start writing it without any affilation?


r/academicpublishing • • Sep 15 '17

Plagiarism? Is it plagiarism if i copy the structure and some words but completely not the idea. Ex: Original: The dog was a pain the ass like how brother was. My translation: my high school was a pain the ass like my teachers were

0 Upvotes

r/academicpublishing • • Mar 02 '15

A place for opinions on journal articles

0 Upvotes

I created a website where users can post opinions and ratings on journal papers, here is an example pubrev.io

I'm looking for feedback on the idea, any comments/suggestions/criticisms are welcome!