r/abiogenesis • • Feb 09 '20

I have a proposition on the potential origins of life.

0 Upvotes

Now, I'm not a biologist/chemist, but i am an aspiring one, and i know a decent amount of scientific information, so i have a proposal (if it hasn't already been made yet). Around 4.45 billion years ago (earliest proposed time for rains that formed oceans to happen), the several million year long rain would have begun, after say 300,000 years, the ocean could have had a approximate concentration of amino acids of around 1 part per 100 million (or around several hundred billion tons of starter materials). Some of these amino acids could have formed into enzymes, including some that would have acted similarly to RNA Polymerase, but could form RNA from scratch materials. Now if such a molecule happened to encounter nucleic acids (which can also form in early earth conditions), it could have started the production of RNA, which by itself wouldn't do much, but with the help of enzymes similar to ribosomes (proto-ribosomes), it would be able to make more of itself. Now in order for the formation of proto-life to happen, you would also need to have phospholipids, which could have been formed by other enzymes at the time.


r/abiogenesis • • Jun 30 '26

Atmospheric Chemistry Has anyone ever considered approaching Abiogenesis earlier than current assumptions?

1 Upvotes

If all the water in the oceans was in the atmosphere, the atmospheric pressure would be about 270 times higher than today. Water as a gas is a good greenhouse gas. In this early earth scenario, the surface would be molten, causing the water to remain boiled as steam, with the steam gas holding in the heat; hot vapor phase reactor.

This scenario would also have acids in the atmosphere, but not much in the way of bases. Many acids stem from gases like hydrochloric, nitric, sulfuric, etc. While simple bases like sodium, potassium, calcium and magnesium hydroxide stem come from minerals and would stay molten, until liquid water appears. for the base reactions. When liquid water appears the pH begins to increase as more bases dissolve and interact with the acids.

If you look at the protonation states of phosphate, H3PO4 is favorable in strong acid conditions, while PO4-3 is favorable in strong base conditions. The middle state used by life would appear in a transitional zone; hot stormy atmosphere and boiling brine.

There is also a thing called steam distillation where steam can be used to vaporize oils way below the normal boiling point. Steam becomes a good solvent for oil. The Miller Urey experiments produced resinous solids which turned out to be polymers of HCN, which at high enough heat, break down into ammonia and oil; atmospheric oil/emulsion.


r/abiogenesis • • Nov 12 '24

Logic and Abiogenesis

2 Upvotes

My name is Stephen Mann. I have posted little on Reddit but the intelligence level of its participants seems perhaps a little greater than on Quora and Facebook where I have posted, although I've done well on those two, so I don't complain except that both do have "irritants"- people who think they know all and yet melt like snowballs in July.

I have worked hard upon my understandings of science, in Solar System formation and matter's composition. Now abiogenesis is one of my challenges as I try to make up a general philosophy of existence. It seems required to explain how our universe works. For example, logic requires that quarks be made of quarklets because otherwise they are separate rather than a part of the atomic realm of energy (photons and gravitons) and mass-energy (leptons) because those are made of quarklets (IMO). Saying all are made of these is like saying cells make up tissues, organs, organ-systems, and then organisms. Thus, quarklets would be at the bottom of the atomic hierarchy.

Likewise, then, abiogenesis is basically the theory that viruses are a portal inbetween matter and life because they crystalize, like the former, but reproduce as cell-masters once in possession of them. This said, then Earth must have had a time-frame, an interval, within which abiogenesis could happen- only once! This is similar to our Solar System's planet-formation because inspite of our asteroids and Kuiper-Oort snowballs, new larger bodies don't haven't formed in 4.56 BYs. Why? Because planets can't accrete but rather form through "disking".

Our Sun rotated at first coalescently, at about at least 2.46 times its current size at 75,000 MPH then, to contract, it ejected a disk of at least 447 Earth masses which then split into Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus-Neptune. Then Jupiter, rotating at 33,000 MPH, ejected the Terrian planets and Jovian moons (including Luna) in a disk. Mercury was the third disk and this ejected the smaller moons and planetlets of our SS such as Triton and Pluto-Charon.

Thus, life followed this single-event approach, as well because new life forms don't "abiogenerate". Evidentally, Earth was at first covered with a medium which included proteins similar to prions which encased viruses outside of membranes, fatty acids for cellular protoplasm, and the RNA-DNA of the then new viruses. This is hardly original but what is new and promising is the resemblance between stromatolites and the trovants which are also layered concretions which grow and move slowly as they absorb minerals from rain. Thus, the interactions between inert calciums, phosphoruses, irons, and other trace minerals and the "ert" carbons, nitrogens, and oxygens always central to life make fundamental dialectic which actualized their potentials somewhat as protons are buffered by neutrons in nucleuses.

The biochemistry of the lighter first-period atoms needs the chemistry of heavier second-period atoms as buffers to keep their molecules whole because in them acids balance alkalies. Because stromatolites are living concretions- spheres formed in and near oceans- life must have evolved within these because having a protected environment associated with salt water.

The recent discovery of Dark Oxygen emanating from cobalt and manganese nodules hydrolizing water into its hydrogen and oxygen atoms because generating an electric current suggests that "stromatoforms" were evolution's "life stars" which allowed for lipid-based cells to form amid bubbling from these nodules perhaps the seeds of abiogenic concretions similar to trovants. While these are made of silicon, carbon's atomic analog, certainly silicon could have been carbon's ladder.

Of course, that abiogenesis doesn't happen now implies a condition existed then which doesn't anymore. I can only guess that our ocean must have had a "biooil" afloat upon its surface which allowed for bubbles within which viruses, proteins, enzymes and minerals could interact and which were the first cells but that this sympathetic ooze is now absent...


r/abiogenesis • • May 10 '26

Discussion Is water more fundamental to life than the DNA?

10 Upvotes

If you look at the early development and evolution of life, from before abiogenesis, forward, to the present, the majority component of life, water, has not changed. At all stages of life development and evolution, water has stayed the same.

tf follows that with water unchanging, water has applied the same set of potentials to the organic matter, du jour, at each step of change. Water is like an eternal bookend with the samepush/pull. The organics are the variable bookend of life, where change and diversity rule. But water stays the same and true like a north star for life and evolution.

Most other solvents speculated for life on other planets, such as organic solvents like alcohols, would not remain eternal, since they contain energy value for metabolism. Water, on the other hand is already a terminal product of combustion, and has little value as food for metabolism, allowing water to stay the same, forever, under the chemical stresses of life.

From a chemical POV, the fluid nature of life is based on secondary bonding forces. These weaker secondary bonds can form and break, using low energy, with no harm to the stronger primary bounds. What water brings to the table of secondary bonding, is water is able to form up to four hydrogen bonds per tiny water molecule and can also self ionize; pH effect. This unique situation makes water the king of secondary bonding within life; the eternal bookend of life is also the king of secondary bonding in life. Water's stability sets the tone. Water is also the most anomalous substance in all of nature with over 70 anomalous behaviors where it bucks the trends.

If we mix water and oil and agitate this will create an emulsion, which is a mixture of water and oil bubbles. This will add surface tension to the water, thereby adding potential to the water. Water, to relieve the tension and lower the potential in its hydrogen bonds, will combine with other water bubbles until the king is once again maximized.

The organics of life are a loosely analogous to oil in that they create some smaller level of surface tension in the water. In the case of protein, the water will pack and fold protein to lower surface tension. Hydrophobic moieties get buried in the core to help the water and the surface is made friendly to the water; hydrophilic. The king of secondary bonding, does not change, organizing protein to the water.


r/abiogenesis • • Aug 13 '15

My own take on the idea of an RNA World

0 Upvotes

Being a former engineering student, I am naturally curious about the inner-workings of complex systems, how they are developed and how they evolve over time. I recently came across the idea of an "RNA Word", which as I understand it more or less states that self-replicating ribonucleic acids eventually evolved to give rise to DNA as well as all other life on Earth. I came up with some of my own thoughts and questions about this whole process and decided to write them up, share, and welcome any and all feedback. I'm just learning about this field and am interested in gaining lots of perspective. Feel free to stop reading at any point if it seems too long or boring.

https://drive.google.com/open?id=1qMhWQw5rw2a5d1SmkiEAEAeYj22s-UZClCewm-daKw4

I tried to address other theories of creationism, but just for sake of argument considered a system similar to the RNA world. It's all just theoretical and meant to inspire thought and not just argument.


r/abiogenesis • • May 19 '26

Video - lectures, animations How did life emerge and evolve from complex minerals at a submarine vent? Webinar by Michael Russell

6 Upvotes

r/abiogenesis • • Jun 01 '26

Chirality, Enantioenrichment, Diastereoselectivity, etc. Chirality and Entropic potential.

0 Upvotes

Chirality is the geometric property of an object or molecule that cannot be superimposed onto its mirror image. In chemistry this is associated with left and right handed stereo isomers. Life uses mono-chirality, limiting itself to either left or right handedness, but not both together. B-DNA double helix is right handed.

Chirality is like having 50/50 LH and RH steering in cars, at the same time, on a busy highway. This would add complexity to driving, since the line of sight is different for each. Reducing this double handedness down to one, lowers this complexity.

This lowering of complexity implies a reduction in entropy; exothermic, thereby adding free energy to the system, as well as the need to increase entropy in another way 2nd law. However, this cannot to happen with doubling the handedness, since reduction to one, makes that path irreversible. Now we have a built in potential for change, based on the 2nd law, and some extra free energy to do it.

The DNA double helix can be both right handed b-DNA and left handed z-DNA. The difference between the two is the amount of hydrated water, with b-DNA having the most water of hydration. B-DNA has a double helix of water in the major and minor grooves. Water uses more than twice as many hydrogen bonding sites on the base pairs, as the base pairs use.

Water plays a key role in assigning single handedness and thereby lowering structural entropy to give DNA an added entropic potential, expressed by an active template, to add the needed complexity, to satisfy the 2nd law in a dynamic cyclic fashion.


r/abiogenesis • • Jan 19 '26

Miller Urey Progress

1 Upvotes

Are you aware that modern Miller Urey experiments have produced ATP?

Root-Bernstein R, Baker AG, Rhinesmith T, Turke M, Huber J, Brown AW. "Sea Water" Supplemented with Calcium Phosphate and Magnesium Sulfate in a Long-Term Miller-Type Experiment Yields Sugars, Nucleic Acids Bases, Nucleosides, Lipids, Amino Acids, and Oligopeptides. Life (Basel). 2023 Jan 18;13(2):265. doi: 10.3390/life13020265. PMID: 36836628; PMCID: PMC9959757.

My question is, why not go this path? why not build the analog of particle accelerator for origin of life by building a contraption to observe what happens to the Miller Urey experiment over say 4-5 years and many copies of it at different kinds of environments? I think observing what happens is better than trying to make life from pure molecules.


r/abiogenesis • • Jan 18 '26

I completed an independent research project—how can I get serious feedback or credit without an academic mentor?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/abiogenesis • • Jan 23 '26

WHY life? r/physics sent me here

14 Upvotes

I’m wondering about why cellular organisms that we call “life“ came to be? Why life? And I‘m not asking from a philosophical pov (what’s the meaning of life? what are we all doing here?) - I’m asking from the bio/physics pov. Why were atoms and molecules compelled to…create mitochondria (etc.)? What is the law of physics that made life happen, and continue happening?

I saw an article that said something about multi cellular organisms diffusing energy more efficiently or something? Entropy? But I’m no physicist and it didn’t make sense to me. Hoping someone here has a satisfying answer or at least can tell me where to look for one.

edit: clarified language of question


r/abiogenesis • • Aug 09 '25

Abiogenesis: Easier than it used to be.

8 Upvotes

 If you are familiar with the theory of abiogenesis, (single celled life arising from non-living molecules) you may also be familiar with some of the problems with the theory.

The most noteworthy would be:

The specific sequence of nucleotides (DNA) needed as a code for useful proteins cannot be generated by chance. This is true because there are far more useless, random sequences of amino acids that could never perform a needed function in a cell than there are useful sequences. Coming up with an exact sequence of amino acids in a very short protein by chance results in one chance in a number so large, it defies logic that it could ever happen in a real-world scenario. To keep the math simple, in the case of a protein containing 100 amino acids, the probability of a protein containing the correct sequence of the 20 amino acids in the correct order results in one chance in a very large number followed by 100 zeros. If you can come up with one needed protein, you will then need many more to complete the hypothetical living one celled organism that came about by chance and natural processes. (If you hold to the theory that the first cell contained no genetic material, the above still applies).

Help is on the way: The issue is not finding a complete set of proteins to form living cell, each of which has a specific sequence of amino acids.  The issue is obtaining a complete set of functional proteins from a huge pool of functional proteins.  If this does not make sense, read this first:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4476321/

To illustrate the issue the article deals with, there are multiple proteins that perform the function of breaking down other proteins (proteases). The first hypothetical living cell may need just one protease enzyme from the very large pool of proteases enzymes that do exist and may exist by chance. To help with the math associated with coming up proteins that could form a living cell in this scenario, here is the conclusion from the above article:

“In conclusion, we suggest that functional proteins are sufficiently common in protein sequence space (roughly 1 in 1011) that they may be discovered by entirely stochastic means, such as presumably operated when proteins were first used by living organisms. However, this frequency is still low enough to emphasize the magnitude of the problem faced by those attempting de novo protein design.”

So, the probability of a useful sequence of just one protein occurring by chance is just one in 1011 (1 in a trillion). Much better odds in comparison to coming up with an exact sequence of amino acids. There you have it. It really is much easier for life to arise by natural processes and chance. But wait… For a living cell to arise from non-living molecules, A set of working proteins, and other component parts, will need to be present at roughly the same time and place for life to begin to exist.  This should be taken into account when doing the math. For all the proteins contained in the first living cell, would that be one chance in:

 1011  + 1011  + 1011 …?    or      1011  x 1011  x 1011 …?

Next:

We will need to clarify by what means these proteins were actually generated for the first cell to exist. Some proto-cell models suggests that proto-cells contain proteins in the form of coacervates.  These proteins would have formed without the aid of DNA and RNA.  First, we will need a source of amino acids which to make proteins.  The Miller experiment simulated the conditions thought to be present in the atmosphere of the early prebiotic Earth. “It is seen as one of the first successful experiments demonstrating the synthesis of organic compounds from inorganic constituents in an origin of life scenario”.

Link:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller%E2%80%93Urey_experiment

The original experiments were done in 1952.  The results showed that under plausible early earth conditions, amino acids could be formed by natural processes.

Problems:

About half of the 20 amino acids that form proteins in living organism were generated.

Left-handed and right-handed versions of these amino acids were generated (see “Left Hand/Right Hand” issue below).

How ever it was that amino acids and proteins were formed before there were living cells, there is the issue of the destructive forces of ultraviolet light. The intensity of UV radiation would be much stronger in the atmosphere and the surface of the earth then than it is today due to a lack of free oxygen in the atmosphere and therefore a protective ozone layer. Perhaps the source of amino acids was not lightning strikes in the primordial atmosphere after all (Miller experiment). Perhaps amino acids formed in ocean floor thermal vents.

See this article:

“Concentrations and distributions of amino acids in black and white smoker fluids at temperatures over 200 °C”

Link: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0146638013002520

From the article:

“The hydrothermal environment is postulated to have been the cradle of life on the primitive Earth (e.g., Miller and Bada, 1988, Holm, 1992). Previous studies revealed that the amino acids necessary to form life can be synthesized in laboratory-replicated hydrothermal conditions: large amounts of glycine, alanine and serine were produced when a solution containing aldehyde and ammonia was heated to 100–325 °C (Kamaluddin et al., 1979, Marshall, 1994, Aubrey et al., 2009).”

The above mentioned lab experiments yielded 3 amino acids (not nearly as good as the Miller Experiment). The results obtained from sample collected from multiple vents were 15 amino acids (from all samples).  Individual samples from different vents contained far less. Typically only 8. One with 4 and another with 3. These are however protected from UV radiation.

FYI: Most of the amino acids were not generated abiotically.

From the article:

“The high concentration of Gly would suggest that amino acids are created abiotically in those hydrothermal systems. However, Horiuchi et al. (2004) concluded that most of the amino acids in hydrothermal fluids collected from the Suiyo Seamount were formed biologically because the D/L ratios of Ala, Glu and Asp were very low, whereas those of abiotically formed amino acids is close to 1. In addition, the concentration of DFAAs was low in the all samples, indicating that most of the amino acids existed in polymer forms in the studied hydrothermal fluids. It is usually presumed that amino acid polymers are derived from organisms and bio-debris (Cowie and Hedges, 1992, Kawahata and Ishizuka, 1993, Sigleo and Shultz, 1993). Thus, most of the amino acids would be biologically derived in natural hydrothermal environments.”

Here's a thought in regard to hydrothermal vents being the cradle of life. One wonders if any abiotic lipids, DNA, or RNA were detected and they would fare at 200 degrees centigrade in the lab experiments.

Left Hand / Right Hand: Amino acids that could form by natural processes before life began would be generated in two forms: Left-handed and right-handed in roughly equal amounts.  In living organism, the vast majority of amino acids are left-handed. A right-handed amino acid in a location in a protein where a left-handed amino acid should be, typically results in a non-functioning protein since, in the case of enzymes, they will be the incorrect shape to have a “lock and key” fit with the intended substrate.

Some researchers are looking at meteorites for clues:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6027462/

From the abstract:

“Direct evidence of prebiotic chiral selection on Earth has not yet been found. It is likely that any such records on Earth have been overwritten by billions of years of geological or biological processing. However, prebiotic chemistry studies in the lab have revealed the facile nature of amino acid synthesis under a broad range of plausibly prebiotic conditions. These studies include the spark discharge experiments pioneered by Miller and Urey, reductive aminations, aqueous Strecker-type chemistry, and Fischer-Tropsch type syntheses, etc. Chiral amino acids formed by these processes, however, are formed in equal (racemic) mixtures of l- and d-enantiomers. Hence, although these reactions could have provided a steady supply of amino acids for the origins of life, they do not appear to be capable of generating chiral excesses of any magnitude, let alone homochirality. Key outstanding questions in the origins of life, then, include what led to the transition from racemic, abiotic chemistry to the homochirality observed in biology, and whether this transition was a biological invention or was initiated by abiotic processes.”

In other words, none of the above mentioned scientific studies reveal how left-handed amino acids became the rule in nature. So, for now, this is a significant issue. But they are working on it.

Where did DNA and RNA come from? While there's no direct "genetic counterpart" to the Miller experiment, research is ongoing to understand how genetic information (DNA) and RNA could have arisen on the primordial earth.

Read this -> The Genetics Society Podcast. Where did DNA come from?

https://geneticsunzipped.com/transcripts/2021/8/26/where-did-dna-come-from

If anyone should know, a geneticist should. I would highly recommend reading the article. Several theories are put forward.  There is no consensus. All the theories have problems. There is also no consensus in regard to the question, which came first, RNA or DNA?

Here is what Steve Benner B.S./M.S., Ph.D. has to say in regard RNA forming on the primordial earth.

Link:  https://www.huffpost.com/entry/steve-benner-origins-souf_b_4374373

“We have failed in any continuous way to provide a recipe that gets from the simple molecules that we know were present on early Earth to RNA. There is a discontinuous model which has many pieces, many of which have experimental support, but we're up against these three or four paradoxes, which you and I have talked about in the past. The first paradox is the tendency of organic matter to devolve and to give tar. If you can avoid that, you can start to try to assemble things that are not tarry, but then you encounter the water problem, which is related to the fact that every interesting bond that you want to make is unstable, thermodynamically, with respect to water. If you can solve that problem, you have the problem of entropy, that any of the building blocks are going to be present in a low concentration; therefore, to assemble a large number of those building blocks, you get a gene-like RNA -- 100 nucleotides long -- that fights entropy. And the fourth problem is that even if you can solve the entropy problem, you have a paradox that RNA enzymes, which are maybe catalytically active, are more likely to be active in the sense that destroys RNA rather than creates RNA.”

How about that RNA World Theory?

The theory proposes that life may have existed in a form that did not need proteins.  RNA does it all, even doing the job of some catalysts typically done by proteins.  

I believe the above quote speaks to some of the problems associate with the theory. There is no physical evidence that the RNA world ever existed. We currently do not have a theory that explains how that world could exist (“We have failed in any continuous way to provide a recipe that gets from the simple molecules that we know were present on early Earth to RNA”). We can’t come up with the component parts in the lab under plausible prebiotic earth conditions. So, I would summarize the theory like this:

Researchers are trying to prove that a life form could have existed for which there is no evidence of its existence. So far, they have failed. 

For more information on the theory, read this:

A stepwise emergence of evolution in the RNA world

Link:

A stepwise emergence of evolution in the RNA world - Nghe - FEBS Letters - Wiley Online Library

“The proposed scenario poses challenges that are experimental, theoretical, and computational. “

 

Closing remarks:

The current state of experiments and observations related to Hydrothermal and RNA world theories as well as theories that include the Miller experiment, tend to suggest that life forming by abiogenesis is still at the level of hopeful speculation.

Even if compelling evidence in regard to the RNA World theory is discovered, the issue of a DNA molecule that codes for a viable cell based on proteins remains. The RNA World theory does not solve this problem. It just puts it off to a later time in the past.

After abiogenesis, this: Natural selection and survival of the fittest:

Depending on who’s stats you use, there are currently about 9 million species on planet Earth. So, it looks like nature naturally selected 9 million species/winners.  On the flip side, it would appear that survival of the fittest pared down the winners to about 9 million. These are the ones that reproduce in larger numbers than the losers?

Moving on. The human body contains about 70,000 proteins (depending on who’s stats you use).  As near as anyone can tell, they all serve a useful purpose. One wonders why we don’t have any detectable amount of useless or counterproductive proteins.  Did natural selection/survival of the fittest weed out every single organism leading up to humans that had one or two faulty genes that coded for useless proteins because the organism was 0.000028 percent less fit than us? This with a backdrop of 9 million winners.  Where is the miscellaneous junk?

Copy errors and mutations in DNA are the prime movers in the theory of evolution. Things going wrong cause the movement towards improvements. This paper (link below, again) puts useable proteins vs the useless or harmful proteins at one in a trillion, yet no detectable evidence of any of the useless or harmful ones remain.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4476321/

PDF of "Abiogenesis: Easier than it used to be" here: https://content.instructables.com/F2R/0PBK/MC2HPEWJ/F2R0PBKMC2HPEWJ.pdf

AETIUTB Abiogenesis: Easier than it used to be. https://www.reddit.com/r/abiogenesis/comments/1mlqckf/abiogenesis_easier_than_it_used_to_be/


r/abiogenesis • • Jan 18 '26

OOL Class Discussion Topic #2. Teleology

2 Upvotes

Foresight and Teleology.

Our goal is to use teleology as filter for evaluating OOL models to focus our attention on non-teleological models. Teleology attributes direction or purpose to natural processes, implying that present properties exist in anticipation of future function or that past properties existed in anticipation of present function (1). Teleology is explanation by purpose or end-goal. It answers "why" by pointing to what something is for. Teleology is the reversal of causality. Outcomes are treated as causes.

A teleological explanation for an economic crash might be that the crash happened so that the economy could ultimately become stronger. The non-teleological explanation of the crash is that interacting financial mechanisms crossed stability limits; recovery followed selection among surviving institutions.

Teleological reasoning is common in models of the origins of life and in evolution. Anytime we observe a system performing a function and say it arose/emerged/evolved to perform that function, we're likely committing a teleological error. When treated as an explanatory model for the origin of life, a model is teleological if it projects biological function onto prebiotic chemistry, which in fact it could not have been guided or selected by that function. X-first framing (where X= Metabolism, Genetics, Membranes, Information, Replication, or RNA) is commonly teleological.

Metabolism-first models, for example, tend to define early chemical processes by reference to metabolic requirements of modern life. “Contemporary biochemistry depends on complex interactive and regulated metabolic networks and autocatalytic cycles. Therefore, the origins of life involved chemical networks and autocatalytic cycles.” Or “Proton gradients are critical in extant biochemistry and therefore proton gradients were important in the origins of life.” The existence a metabolic pathway or other phenomena in extant biology is treated not as a contingent outcome of prolonged chemical and biological evolution, but as an explanatory cause that defines processes at the beginning. Metabolism-first models project present-day biological reactions backward onto prebiotic chemistry, assuming that early chemical systems were organized to achieve the metabolic organization observed today. Such reconstructions substitute necessity for selection and contingency, and mistake surviving structure for original design.

A non-teleological account must instead treat metabolism as arising from many chemical reactions that emerged, morphed, competed, cooperated, and were selected and reselected (the basis of selection was dynamic) in real time (foresight not allowed) from within a vast prebiotic chemical landscape. Extant metabolism reflects prolonged, creative selection via mechanisms we need to try to understand (but do not), not historical inevitability.

However, when stripped of teleology, many OOL models dissolve into improbability. Without the assumption of purpose, many of these models degrade into lottery-winning - a long succession of unlikely events that just happen to converge on a metabolic or polymeric system. In this form, models become “Nature got lucky” or ‘just so” stories. Many steps in a long chain occur without real time selection, in just the right order to produce biology.

Here are some examples of teleology in origins of life models. Phosphates link to ribose to allow formation of RNA. Complex organic chemical reactions combined to produce RNA, which emerges to enable Darwinian evolution. DNA arises from RNA to provide a more persistent and superior genetic material. Proteins arise in an RNA World because their catalytic proficiencies are greater than those of ribozymes. The ribosome arose as a machinery for production of coded protein. Chemical cycles arose for formation of the Krebs cycle. In each case, the defining biological function is implied as the cause of emergence. In fact, chemical systems cannot causally optimize in anticipation of future function. These explanations require foresight—chemistry aiming at biology that does not yet exist. Shapiro likened such models to a golf ball making its way unaided through a golf course (2).

  1. Ayala FJ (1970) Teleological explanations in evolutionary biology. Philosophy of science 37: 1-15.

  2. Shapiro R (2007) A simpler origin for life. Sci Am 296: 46-53.


r/abiogenesis • • Mar 11 '26

OOL Class Discussion 8. Entanglement.

2 Upvotes

Entanglement

Entanglement is reciprocal constitutive dependency. In this dependency, components lack a complete or accurate description independent of one another. Entanglement is more extreme than interdependence. It dictates that components possess little or no function in isolation. Because components of an entangled system lack a complete description independent of the collective, the resulting behavior is emergent.

Entanglement in Everyday Life

Examples of entanglement exist outside of biology. Money is entangled with legal frameworks, collective trust, and scarcity. Words are entangled within language. Entanglement is the norm in biology and is an inextricable product of evolution. The bones of a skeletal system are entangled (1) Organs are entangled. The wasp and the fig are entangled (2). Entanglement is the platform by which evolutionary advances ripple through and between molecules, systems, organisms, and ecosystems.

Entanglement on a Cellular Level

The mitochondrion is entangled with the nucleus. The mitochondrial genome is incomplete. It lacks genes necessary for independent replication, transcription, translation, or metabolism. These missing functions derive from nuclear-encoded genes. Conversely, the nucleus lacks structures and genes for oxidative phosphorylation. This reciprocal constitutive dependency defines the eukaryotic state.

Entanglement on a Molecular Level

Molecular entanglement dominates biochemical systems (3-5). This entanglement manifests in part as reciprocal synthesis. In the ribosome, RNA synthesizes protein. in polymerases, protein synthesizes RNA. This reciprocity extends to precursors (6-8). Amino acids are consumed to synthesize nucleotides, such as aspartate and glycine in purine and pyrimidine biosynthesis. Simultaneously, nucleotides are consumed to synthesize amino acids, such as ATP in histidine biosynthesis. 

Universal metabolic intermediates are molecular chimeras. These chimeras contain components from multiple biopolymer systems. NAD+ contains nicotinamide derived from tryptophan and adenosine dinucleotide. FAD contains riboflavin and ADP. SAM combines methionine and ATP. Similarly, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases couple amino acids to tRNA to create the interface between genetic information and protein synthesis. Ribonucleotide reductase converts RNA precursors into DNA precursors. This enzyme is encoded by DNA. Such a circular dependency requires each biopolymer for the synthesis of the others.

Entanglement and the Origins of Life

Entanglement is a product and characteristic of evolution. In a chemical evolutionary model, diverse ancestral populations of molecular species with complementary proficiencies exchanged reciprocal benefits from the beginning. Changes in proto-building blocks or proto-biopolymer backbones caused changes in other molecules and in primitive metabolism. In this model, all biopolymers emerged and evolved in concert. The structure of polynucleotides is a result of the capacity for DNA and RNA to interact synergistically with polypeptides.

 Entanglement is not a post hoc adaptation. Evolution builds molecular entanglement from the ground up.  If biological molecules co-evolved, then they must be entangled. If biological molecules are entangled, then they must have co-evolved. In entangled systems there are no metaphorical chickens or eggs. The RNA World is therefore not consistent with entanglement. In an RNA World, RNA arose independently of protein and should not be entangled with it.

References.

1.              Botelho JF, Smith-Paredes D, Soto-Acuna S, O'connor J, Palma V, & Vargas AO (2016) Molecular development of fibular reduction in birds and its evolution from dinosaurs. Evolution 70: 543-554.

2.              Machado CA, Robbins N, Gilbert MTP, & Herre EA (2005) Critical review of host specificity and its coevolutionary implications in the fig/fig-wasp mutualism. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102: 6558-6565.

3.              Ruiz-Mirazo K & Moreno A (2024) On the evolutionary development of biological organization from complex prebiotic chemistry. Organization in Biology 187.

4.              Douglas A (2015) The study of mutualism. Mutualism Oxford Press, Oxford 20-34.

5.              Schwartz MW & Hoeksema JD (1998) Specialization and resource trade: Biological markets as a model of mutualisms. Ecology 79: 1029-1038.

6.              Nelson DL, Lehninger AL, & Cox MM (2021) Principles of Biochemistry (Macmillan).

7.              Yadav M, Kumar R, & Krishnamurthy R (2020) Chemistry of abiotic nucleotide synthesis. Chem Rev 120: 4766-4805.

8.              Lanier KA, Petrov AS, & Williams LD (2017) The central symbiosis of molecular biology: Molecules in mutualism. J Mol Evol 85: 8-13.

 


r/abiogenesis • • May 23 '26

Publication (Opinion/Perspective) Open hypothesis/framework: “The Abiogenic Operating Envelope” — a systems approach to the transition from chemistry to life-like organisation

2 Upvotes

I’ve been working on an open systems-level hypothesis/framework exploring the transition between non-living chemistry and life-like organisation.

I’d genuinely appreciate critical feedback rather than agreement — I’m trying to stress-test the framework, not defend it.

The core idea is that abiogenesis may not be a “single magic molecule” problem, but instead a coupled chemical-environmental operating regime involving:

non-equilibrium thermodynamics;

autocatalytic reinforcement;

compartmentalisation;

persistence;

environmental cycling;

transferable structure;

and differential survival.

Rather than trying to define fully developed biological life, the framework focuses on the lower threshold where chemistry may begin exhibiting life-like behaviour.

The paper does NOT claim to have solved abiogenesis.

Instead, it proposes:

an operational framework;

falsifiable criteria;

possible computer-modelling approaches;

and experimental directions.

I’m posting this specifically for criticism, peer review, weaknesses, missing literature, modelling suggestions, thermodynamics objections, systems chemistry feedback, or general scientific challenge.

Particularly interested in feedback from:

systems chemists;

origin-of-life researchers;

complex systems people;

thermodynamics/modelling people;

protocell researchers;

and computational modellers.

OSF link: https://osf.io/d7uy2/overview


r/abiogenesis • • Jun 03 '26

Discussion Entropy of Mixing, Osmosis and the Entropic Force

2 Upvotes

My approach to abiogenesis is to look for seams common in all stages of life, that could exist early in the story of life, are still used and that can be used to leverage the early steps. I am not so much about the specific changes, but developing basic tools to help promote continuous change even before templates.

One such seam that life uses is what is called entropy of mixing, which is the basis for osmosis. Besides osmosis, this form of entropy has many other uses. It is a unique form of entropy, mostly found in the liquid and gas states. Life in water is in the liquid state and therefore life can leverage entropy of mixing and entropy of mixing can be used to leverage pre-life.

Entropy of mixing has the goal of maximizing space. It is not about inefficiency. But it still involves a 2nd law endothermic process. As an example, you can do at home without any equipment; take a bottle of perfume and open it in the center of a close room. Your nose will be the only tool you will need.

The perfume will evaporate, which will make more space between the liquid molecules. Then, these close together gas molecules will expand in the air space, to fill in the room with fragrance. At uniform room concentration the most space between the perfume particle will exist; steady state. This is driven by the 2nd law and has the same goal each time.

If we made the room incrementally larger, in steps, each size has the same end goal; weakening uniform solution. This form of entropy increase, has a logical and predictable conclusion, it is goal orientated. If we open the window, it will keep expanding. The perfume would never spontaneously go backwards, into the bottle, since that would lower the space between.

Entropy of mixing is the basis for osmosis. In this case, a semi-permeable membrane is used to prevent the solute from mixing and spread out to balance the concentration on both side; uniform solution. But since the water can move freely, it does the entropy of mixing for the solute. The water will diffuse in the direction of higher solute concentration to make more space, where space is needed most.

The osmotic pressure is a measure of the entropic potential to mix and how hard the water will push to make more space between solute particles, even going upward against gravity. This is a significant pressure.

Osmotic pressure is force/area. If we multiple by area we get the osmotic force. But since this is based on entropy of mixing, I call it the entropic force. There is a fifth force of nature driven by entropy of mixing. It is common to life and needs semi-permeable membranes. It has been called the life force. The value of this entropic force is it has a force vector that can be used to steer, as well as a goal; expand.

Like all forms of entropy increase, entropy of mixing is also endothermic, picking up macro energy along the way and moving that energy into the quantum state, as it spreads out. Reverse osmosis reverses the entropy of mixing, allowing life to extract energy from the quantum state.

This most common way life uses to reverse entropy of mixing is ion pumping. Ion pumps segregate and concentrate ions; put the perfume back in two bottles. Ions in water is life's main way is harnesses entropy of mixing. Trees can use it to pump water against gravity; entropic force can oppose the gravitational force. Osmosis is also used in cell cycles. It is used by the brain to steer trillions of axon and dendrites to specific synapses, and also to move the bulk currents of the brain; expansion throughout the brain, before being reversed by the ion pumps for an another work cycle.

An argument can even be made that even the expansion of the universe; all matter expanding, in spite of gravity, in the near vacuum of space, is based on entropy of mixing. The red shift would reflect the endothermic nature of this cosmic expression of the 2nd law. Dark energy may be connected to entropy of mixing. Gravity can reverse this and retrieve quantum energy, while trees can oppose gravity, like the expansion.


r/abiogenesis • • Apr 15 '26

Discussion Is abiogenesis unlikely, or are we asking the wrong (unconstrained) question?

18 Upvotes

People often describe abiogenesis as extremely improbable, almost like a statistical miracle. But I’m not sure that framing is the right one.

Instead of asking about the probability of life across the entire universe, it seems more meaningful to ask about the conditional probability under specific, non-equilibrium planetary conditions — e.g. a system with continuous energy flux (like solar radiation), liquid water, and rich chemistry.

In such environments, we don’t just have “permission” from the second law. Systems are actively driven far from equilibrium, and some processes can dissipate energy more efficiently than others. Living systems are a clear example of this: they convert low-entropy energy into higher-entropy heat very efficiently, increasing the total entropy of their surroundings.

So the question I’m struggling with is this:

If certain chemical pathways enhance energy dissipation under these conditions, is there a strong reason to believe that life-generating processes occupy a negligibly small region of the accessible state space?

I understand that kinetics and specific pathways matter a lot here — but is the perceived improbability of abiogenesis really a thermodynamic issue, or is it primarily about whether the relevant chemical routes are dynamically accessible?

In other words, once we condition on realistic planetary environments, should we still expect abiogenesis to be extremely rare — or is that assumption doing more work than we realize?

Edit: Added a short video in the comments that helped me better understand how entropy relates to probability and why structured systems can still emerge under non-equilibrium conditions.


r/abiogenesis • • Mar 29 '21

Photosynthesis could be as old as life itself

Thumbnail
imperial.ac.uk
3 Upvotes

r/abiogenesis • • Apr 17 '25

Geochemistry How thick was the oil slick?? Relevant papers.

3 Upvotes

Tagged as "geochemistry" but I should make an "atmospheric chemistry" tag as that's more applicable.
[TLDR at bottom of post]

"Self-Shielding Enhanced Organics Synthesis in an Early Reduced Earth’s Atmosphere" - [https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/ast.2024.0048]

This paper discusses the rates at which organics may have deposited over the prebiotic oceans/land as a result of atmospheric and aqueous/geochemistry. The main thrust is that an organic haze composed of C2H2 and C3H4 absorbs UV radiation that would otherwise break down H2O to form HO radicals. According to their results, UV absorptions by gaseous hydrocarbons such as C2H2 and C3H4 significantly suppress the H2O photolysis and following CH4 oxidation. As a result, ~1/2 of initial CH4 could be converted to heavier organics along with deposition of prebiotically essential molecules such as HCN and H2CO on the surface of a primordial ocean leading to an accumulation of prebiotically important molecules in the proto-ocean."

It's not clear to me on how to think about the numbers in their math and what this "looks" like on the primordial oceans. The total mass deposited over the "10-100 million years" wouldn't necessarily stay on top, of course. Their numbers/calculations are something I'm not familiar with and so I don't have a quantitative understanding. Any insight would be appreciated.

The authors claim the primordial earth could have had an organic slick "hundreds of meters thick" and cited this 1971 paper [https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.174.4004.53] which, in the abstract, claims "An oil slick 1 to 10 meters thick"... I think this was a misreading rather than a typo since they typed out "hundreds". Even a few inches thick would be impressive, tbh.

IIRC, estimates of the degree to which the atmosphere was reducing has decreased. However, Fe-Ni meteors (I don't have the source now but can find it if you'd like) were capable of temporarily increasing the H2, H2S, and CH4 (and more) content for hundreds of thousands of years leading to bursts of atmospheric organic chemistry. Like, massive meteors. Tens of kilometers in diameter. As such, I think these are over estimates. I posted this because I've been looking for some sort of estimate.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1016577923630 is another cited paper "Possible Impact of a Primordial Oil Slick on Atmospheric and Chemical Evolution" which explores how an oil slick on the primordial ocean's surface could have had a number of compounding effects. One of which is that it could have acted as an organic solvent for otherwise difficult bulk-aqueous chemistry. Another alternative consideration is chemistry which occurs at the water-organic interface.

I've found examples where (L, L) cyclic dipeptides with a hydrophobic tail embedded in an organic layer at the water-organic interface can carry out an enantioselective epoxidation (33% yield, 70%ee) with H2O2. [REF] Another example of biphasic chemistry is the rate enhancing effects of running Diels-Alder reactions using hydrophobic substrates and minor organic solvent in water. [REF] Intermolecular Diels-Alder reactions are entropically disfavored but when run in an aqueous solvent, the hydrophobic effect minimizes interface surface area, maximizing the rotational freedom (increasing entropy) of the water molecules, and increasing the reaction rate by up to 10k compared to heated and pressurized conditions with an organic solvent. [REF] This isn't to say that these exact reactions occurred on the primordial earth but to point out examples of biphasic chemistry with simple components carrying out enantioselective or accelerated reactions, increasing the diversity of available reactions.

To reiterate, both of these reactions can be considered entropically disfavored but the environment in which they occur (taking into account the entropy of the greater system), maximizes its entropy, creating order (phase separation) which favors otherwise disfavored reactions.

TLDR: Two papers are presented in which detailed models of the early Earth's atmospheric chemistry not only produce chemicals that play key roles in abiogenesis but also contribute to a feedback loop that further promotes formation of these molecules while suppressing non-productive pathways. As a result, the authors found that a very significant amount of organic material would be deposited on the planet's surface to created a large oil slick meters thick. This organic/aqueous layer creates a "biphasic" environment.

I then presented two examples of classic organic reactions which, when run in biphasic conditions, enabling simple chiral molecules to catalyze enantioselective reaction or have their reaction rate greatly increased due to the nature of the reaction conditions.

------

As an aside/question, the journal for the first paper is Astrobiology from Mary Ann Liebert Pub. It seems legit but I don't really know much about the reliability of a given journal unless it's very obvious that they have a bias. Wiki page doesn't say anything like it being a predatory journal. The data seems reasonable but I'm not too familiar with atmospheric chemistry/experimental set-up. They've published other papers which seemed reasonable and well-thought out.

https://www.scimagojr.com/journalsearch.php?q=13090&tip=sid&clean=0 shows it seems reliable but it's not popular or well-known.


r/abiogenesis • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion Points on Argument from Incredulity for my fall OOL class (opinions?)

4 Upvotes

5 Argument from incredulity.

An argument from incredulity (1) treats an inability to imagine or fully explain a mechanism as proof that it is impossible. This fallacy substitutes limitations of imagination and knowledge for empirical refutation. Historically, the argument from incredulity led geologists to reject evidence for plate tectonics; they could not imagine a mechanism for the movement of continents (2).

Dawkins famously dismantles anti-evolutionary incredulity by showing that complex traits such as flight or vision emerge across continuous, incremental landscapes rather than through all-or-nothing leaps (3). Ironically, Dawkins argues from incredulity about life's origin, treating a replicator like RNA as a mandatory starting point for evolution and rejecting a continuous transition between chemistry and biology. Immersed in biology, Dawkins cannot imagine evolution without biological heredity. In both biological and chemical evolution, an inability to visualize continuous, non-directed trajectories imposes artificial leaps, mistaking the boundaries of human imagination for the boundaries of natural possibility.

 

1.              Walton D (2010) Arguments from ignorance (Penn State Press).

2.              Newman RP (1995) American intransigence: The rejection of continental drift in the great debates of the 1920's. Earth Sciences History 14: 62-83.

3.              Dawkins R (1996) The blind watchmaker: Why the evidence of evolution reveals a universe without design.  (WW Norton & Company, New York).

 


r/abiogenesis • • Jul 10 '26

Video - lectures, animations Powering the complexity of life with Michael Levin and Nick Lane | Reason with Science | Biology

4 Upvotes

Link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GBxVvLVzF68&ra=m

From video description: This episode is with Michael Levin (‪@drmichaellevin‬) and Nick Lane. Mike is a Professor in the Biology department at Tufts University. He studies the role of bioelectric signals in regulating development and regeneration in animals. Nick is a professor of Evolutionary Biochemistry at University College London. His work is focused on the fundamental processes that underlie the origin and evolution of life. In this conversation, we talk about major transitions and key innovations in biology, information in biological systems, bioelectricity, emergence of eukaryotes and importance of bioelectric signals to create artificial life.


r/abiogenesis • • Feb 22 '13

Molecules assemble in water, hint at origins of life

Thumbnail
esciencenews.com
4 Upvotes

r/abiogenesis • • May 03 '26

News/Press Release Showing The Math For Earth’s First — And Sudden — Spark Of Life

Thumbnail
astrobiology.com
4 Upvotes

The paper:

  • Varanasi, Varun, and Jun Korenaga. "Emergence of autocatalysis in prebiotic reaction networks." Physical Review E 113.4 (2026): 044304.
    https://doi.org/10.1103/nmt5-qsym


r/abiogenesis • • Apr 06 '26

Discussion The (Nearly) Complete Story of Abiogenesis - Phy The Neutrophil

4 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OsXGgrXwllc

A well-balanced description of what we know so far. Of course, 70 minutes isn't enough time but he does a great job.


r/abiogenesis • • Nov 04 '19

Intelligent Design Exists. I am an Industrial Design Engineer. I Exist. Concerning Abiogenesis: The Only Issue Is That Of Scope.

5 Upvotes

This is an information post. On the subreddit r/debatecreation I am discussing the issue in the title above.

This post is informational only. I expect there may be some in this group who may find this material interesting. I will not respond to replies here. This post is merely to inform those who might be interested about the discussion in the above subreddit. Of course, you are free to comment as you like here, but if you are interested in my responses to your comments, you will need to go to the above subreddit.

To simplify your decision whether this is something you want to dialogue about, I have copied the post below. I believe it represents new science and ideas that are worth discussion. Importantly, if you believe there are any misrepresentations in the material below, I invite you to join the discussion in r/debatecreation .

*****************************

Materialists like to mock the notion of intelligent design. Yet, intelligent design does exist. I have two decades of experience as an electronics hardware design engineer and two as a mechanical engineer/physicist working in desalination. I design and I exist. Hence, intelligent design does exist in the universe. The only issue is the scope of its action.

I believe scientific observation combined with the principles of engineering practice lead a person clearly to the understanding that living cells are the product of the creative work of a living God. The following is the basis for this assertion:

Experiments in abiogenesis have yet to demonstrate a prebiotic process in a laboratory with its controlled conditions that could generate amino acids in a form pure enough and in the proper ratios to be used in a subsequent step. The Miller-Urey experiment and all of its variations using different energy sources and starting chemicals and environmental conditions are consistently characterized by so much contamination and by unsuitable ratios of the amino acids produced that they are unusable. Abiogenesis cannot get out of the starting blocks--it remains stuck at the first step. It is irrational to assert that such processes could produce a large body of complex information as well as the associated hardware to read and use it in a single step. It is irrational to assert that complex cellular feedback control loops could appear in a single step. It is irrational that the dynamic self-organization characteristic of living cells could appear in a single step. However, Virchow's aphorism, "all cells from cells," requires fully functioning single-step first appearance. Anything less than a fully functioning cell including replication capability is not capable of sustained existence as cellular life. A self-replicating molecule does not even begin to meet the needs of cellular life. The gap between it and a fully-functioning living cell does not appear bridgeable by random processes in accordance with these and the following observations.

The dynamic self-organization characteristic of cellular structures requires a continuous input of energy. The bonds used in self-organization are "metastable." They are analogous to electromagnets. When the energy supply is cut-off, the bonds dissipate and the structures formed by the bonds quickly degrade beyond recovery. This is why a person choking dies within a few minutes without oxygen. By contrast, a pair of pliers stored in an moisture-proof tool box can remain available for immediate use thousands of years later, limited only by when corrosion eventually renders them useless.

The combined requirements of fully-functioning first appearance of a complete cell, per Virchow's aphorism, along with a maximum time-frame of minutes at the most for cellular components to achieve sufficient complexity to sustain life and replicate it, appears beyond the capabilities of natural, unguided prebiotic processes. This is particularly obvious when one remembers that they can't even supply amino acids in a form usable by a subsequent step. How could such incompetent processes ever be able to meet the standards actually required? Nothing even close to this has ever been demonstrated in a laboratory.

Engineers commonly provide for information-driven systems, feedback control loops, and molecular self-organization (nanotechnology). However, an engineer cannot design things he does not understand. The intelligence required to design a living cell is staggering compared to the most complex structure man has ever designed. An engineer capable of foreseeing how to combine hydrogen, oxygen, carbon and nitrogen into amino acids and nucleotides--all without a working model to guide him--and then to turn these into various enzymes and information-containing nucleic acids as required for cellular life, would have an intelligence worthy of being considered a god. Furthermore, a designer needs to exercise his will in making various design decisions, as any design engineer will readily acknowledge.

Moreover, physical processes are inherently incapable in themselves of implementing design specifications. There is no means for the laws of physics and chemistry to implement an abstract design. There needs to be a means to convert the design specification into actual arrangement of individual atoms as molecules and in their proper dynamic relationships as required. Since a designer needs to develop a design based on available resources, he needs to limit his specification to requirements he can actually implement. This flows into the requirement that the designer be able to work outside of the laws of physics and chemistry in order to place individual atoms and molecules into place according to the design specification.

The requirement that the designer have an incomprehensibly deep intelligence, a will, and the ability to work outside of natural law, moving individual atoms and molecules into place as desired to implement his will meets the definition of a personal God. An unbiased analysis of scientific observation interpreted in the light of engineering design principles leads directly to living cells being the handiwork of a living, personal God. There is no other rational explanation which can be observed both by experiment (science) and practice (engineering). This evaluation was not based on assuming God and then attempting to force Him onto the evidence. It is not a "God of the gaps" argument where anything we can't explain is attributed to God without any corroborative evidence. It is simply going where the evidence leads.

By contrast, the materialist position of the abiogenist appears to contradict scientific evidence and engineering practice wherever one looks.

I have worked through these issues in far greater detail than space allow to present here. The analysis is in an article posted online at www.trbap.org/god-created-life.pdf . Those interested in a more elaborate discussion of these issues than can be posted here may find it worth looking at the article.


r/abiogenesis • • Jul 02 '23

Video explaining how life is favored by entropy

5 Upvotes