r/abiogenesis • u/ADragonFromTheAbyss • Aug 08 '26
News/Press Release A New Study Points to Two Origins of Life on Earth by Tracing Early Chemical Reactions in Single-Celled Organisms
r/abiogenesis • u/ADragonFromTheAbyss • Aug 08 '26
r/abiogenesis • u/jnpha • May 07 '26
Press release: https://astrobiology.com/2026/05/how-the-rise-of-continents-may-have-set-the-stage-for-life-on-earth.html
From the press release:
[Boron] operates within a narrow window: too much, and it becomes toxic to biological systems; too little, and it may never have contributed to life getting started.
The key was a boron-containing mineral called tourmaline, popularly known as a semi-precious stone that’s also abundant in continental rock. Tourmaline forms readily within granite-rich crust, locking boron away over geological time. As Earth’s crust grew and weathered, boron was slowly and steadily released into surface waters, eventually stabilizing at concentrations close to those found in modern seawater.
r/abiogenesis • u/Choice-Break8047 • Dec 13 '25
A Proposed Model for Aqueous-Phase Fischer-Tropsch Lipid Synthesis in the Hadean Eon
Abstract
One of the most persistent paradoxes in origin-of-life research is the "Water Problem" in lipid synthesis. While standard Fischer-Tropsch Type (FTT) reactions can generate hydrocarbon chains from simple gases, industrial iron/cobalt catalysts oxidize and deactivate in aqueous environments. This paper proposes a geochemical solution: the introduction of Ruthenium (Ru) nanoparticles via siderophile-rich meteorite impacts during the Late Heavy Bombardment. We posit that Ru-catalyzed Aqueous-Phase Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis (AFTS), occurring within high-pressure hydrothermal crater lakes, creates a precise pathway for synthesizing mixed amphiphiles (fatty acids and alcohols) of C10–C18 chain lengths. This model resolves the catalyst-solvent incompatibility and provides a geological mechanism for the spontaneous assembly of stable membranous vesicles.
Introduction: The Lipid Synthesis Gap
The "Lipid World" hypothesis suggests that compartmentalization was a prerequisite for chemical evolution. However, the abiotic synthesis of stable lipid membranes faces a significant chemical hurdle.
Standard industrial FTT synthesis (nCO + (2n+1)H_2 \rightarrow C_nH_{2n+2} + nH_2O) typically operates at temperatures exceeding 250°C and requires dry conditions to prevent catalyst oxidation. Iron (Fe), the most abundant transition metal, rapidly converts to oxides/hydroxides in water, rendering it catalytically inert for chain growth.
This paper proposes that Ruthenium, a Platinum Group Metal (PGM) resistant to aqueous oxidation, served as the primary catalyst for prebiotic lipid production in specific hydrothermal environments.
2. Geological Context: The Impact Delivery System
During the Hadean Eon (approx. 4.0 Ga), the Earth experienced the Late Heavy Bombardment. This period provided the necessary material influx to seed the crust with exogenous catalysts.
* Siderophile Enrichment: Ruthenium is a siderophile (iron-loving) element. While depleted in Earth’s crust (sequestered in the core), it is abundant in iron meteorites and enstatite chondrites (~5–10 ppm).
* Crater Lake Formation: Large impacts created closed-system crater lakes characterized by:
* Hydrothermal Activity: Residual impact heat and crustal fracturing leading to venting.
* High Pressure: Depth-generated pressure of 30–50 bar.
* Feedstock Gases: Volcanic and impact-generated release of Syngas (CO and H_2).
3. Catalyst Formation Mechanism: Vapor Phase Fractionation
We propose a novel mechanism for the natural synthesis of high-surface-area catalytic particles immediately following impact.
* Vaporization: Impact kinetic energy vaporizes the bolide, creating a plasma plume containing Fe, Si, and Ru atoms.
* Refractory Nucleation: Due to its high boiling point (~4,150°C), Ruthenium condenses first, forming solid nucleation seeds.
* Encapsulation: As the plume cools, abundant Iron (~2,862°C) and Silica condense around the Ru cores, effectively burying the catalyst.
* Aqueous Etching (Activation): Upon deposition into the hot, acidic/hydrothermal crater lake, the outer iron/silicate shell is chemically leached (oxidized/dissolved).
* Result: This natural "de-alloying" process exposes the non-reactive Ruthenium core, leaving a skeletal, porous nanostructure analogous to industrial Raney metals. This dramatically increases the active surface area available for catalysis.
4. Chemical Mechanism: Aqueous-Phase Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis (AFTS)
Unlike Iron, Ruthenium remains metallic and active in liquid water at elevated temperatures. The reaction proceeds as follows:
Conditions:
* Temperature: 150°C (Optimal window for Ru activity in water).
* Pressure: 30–50 Bar (Maintains liquid phase and increases gas solubility).
* Solvent: Liquid Water.
The Reaction Pathway:
Ruthenium catalyzes the insertion of methylene (CH_2) groups to grow hydrocarbon chains. Crucially, the presence of water affects the termination step, leading to two distinct amphiphilic products:
* Hydrolysis Termination: Yields Alkanoic Acids (Fatty Acids).
* Hydrogenation Termination: Yields Alkanols (Fatty Alcohols).
5. Product Selectivity and Vesicle Stability
The uniqueness of the Ruthenium-catalyzed AFTS model lies in its product selectivity, which aligns perfectly with biological requirements.
* Chain Length Control: At 150°C, chain propagation probability favors lengths between C10 and C18. Chains shorter than C10 are too soluble to form membranes; chains longer than C18 crystallize. The Ru-catalyst naturally targets the "Goldilocks" zone for bilayer formation.
* The Mixed-Amphiphile Advantage: Research indicates that pure fatty acid membranes are unstable in wide pH ranges and sensitive to magnesium ions. However, membranes composed of a mixture of Fatty Acids and Fatty Alcohols are significantly more robust, permeable, and thermostable.
* Conclusion: The Ruthenium mechanism does not require two separate sources for these molecules. It intrinsically synthesizes the exact chemical mixture required for stable protocell assembly.
6. Conclusion
The Meteoric PGM-Catalyzed Crater Lake Hypothesis offers a parsimonious solution to the problem of prebiotic lipid synthesis. By accounting for the unique electrochemical properties of Ruthenium—specifically its resistance to aqueous oxidation and its selectivity for C10–C18 chains—we can demonstrate a direct geochemical pathway from asteroid impact to stable vesicle formation.
This model negates the need for complex evaporation cycles or unlikely dry-land scenarios, placing the origin of the first cell membranes in the robust, nutrient-rich environment of a hydrothermal crater lake.
r/abiogenesis • u/jnpha • Feb 13 '26
This just in:
Not open-access: A small polymerase ribozyme that can synthesize itself and its complementary strand | Science
The press release: Scientists’ chemical breakthrough sheds light on origins of life – UKRI
The abstract, which I've split:
Background
The emergence of a chemical system capable of self-replication and evolution is a critical event in the origin of life. RNA polymerase ribozymes can replicate RNA, but their large size and structural complexity impede self-replication and preclude their spontaneous emergence.
Methods and Results
Here we describe QT45: a 45-nucleotide polymerase ribozyme, discovered from random sequence pools, that catalyzes general RNA-templated RNA synthesis using trinucleotide triphosphate (triplet) substrates in mildly alkaline eutectic ice. QT45 can synthesize both its complementary strand using a random triplet pool at 94.1% per-nucleotide fidelity, and a copy of itself using defined substrates, both with yields of ~0.2% in 72 days.
Significance
The discovery of polymerase activity in a small RNA motif suggests that polymerase ribozymes are more abundant in RNA sequence space than previously thought.
r/abiogenesis • u/Sakouli • Apr 15 '26
People often describe abiogenesis as extremely improbable, almost like a statistical miracle. But I’m not sure that framing is the right one.
Instead of asking about the probability of life across the entire universe, it seems more meaningful to ask about the conditional probability under specific, non-equilibrium planetary conditions — e.g. a system with continuous energy flux (like solar radiation), liquid water, and rich chemistry.
In such environments, we don’t just have “permission” from the second law. Systems are actively driven far from equilibrium, and some processes can dissipate energy more efficiently than others. Living systems are a clear example of this: they convert low-entropy energy into higher-entropy heat very efficiently, increasing the total entropy of their surroundings.
So the question I’m struggling with is this:
If certain chemical pathways enhance energy dissipation under these conditions, is there a strong reason to believe that life-generating processes occupy a negligibly small region of the accessible state space?
I understand that kinetics and specific pathways matter a lot here — but is the perceived improbability of abiogenesis really a thermodynamic issue, or is it primarily about whether the relevant chemical routes are dynamically accessible?
In other words, once we condition on realistic planetary environments, should we still expect abiogenesis to be extremely rare — or is that assumption doing more work than we realize?
Edit: Added a short video in the comments that helped me better understand how entropy relates to probability and why structured systems can still emerge under non-equilibrium conditions.
r/abiogenesis
•
u/Russell1A
•
Sep 14 '26
Abstract
This paper presents a unified abiogenesis model in which life emerges not from a single molecular breakthrough but from the gradual stabilization of a mineral‑organic ecological system. The model integrates (1) clay mineral templating, (2) hydrothermal vent geochemistry, (3) extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) matrices, and (4) peptide–RNA symbiosis. It proposes that early life began as EPS‑bound polymer (proto- biofilm) ecologies on clay surfaces in the “Goldilocks belt” surrounding hydrothermal vents. Fragmentation of EPS matrices under turbulence acted as the first mechanism of lineage propagation.
Modern biofilms show that life can organize without membranes. The EPS creates diffusion gradients, protection and collective metabolism**.** Also mixed chemistries (proteins, polysaccharides, nucleic acids, lipids) can coexist in a single matrix. Thus, an EPS‑like matrix could have emerged before lipid membranes stabilized.
RNA later emerged as an external replicator, eventually internalized by protocells. This paper summarizes existing experimental evidence supporting components of the model and proposes new laboratory tests capable of validating or falsifying the framework.
1. Introduction
Traditional abiogenesis theories often isolate single causal pathways: RNA‑first, metabolism‑first, lipid‑first, or clay‑first. These models struggle to explain how information, metabolism, and compartmentalization co‑emerge.
This paper reframes abiogenesis as an ecological emergence shaped by Environmental Pressure (EP) rather than classical Natural Selection. EP acts on configurations, not individuals, making early symbiosis the default state. The model proposes that life originated as a mineral‑anchored, EPS‑stabilized polymer ecology in the proximity of hydrothermal vent environments.
2. Geological Setting: The Goldilocks Belt
Life is proposed to originate in a narrow zone around hydrothermal vents1, 2, 3 ,4 where above clay mineral deposits (including montmorillonite, saponite, nontronite) form and persist. Clay minerals (especially montmorillonite) help to catalyse polymerization of nucleotides and amino acids as well as providing template structural patterns through surface charge and lattice geometry. Also, these deposits concentrate reactants by adsorption. However, clay alone is too static and too dry for sustained metabolism. This is resolved if the clay deposits are in the vicinity of hydrothermal vents, thus benefit from a chemically rich, fluctuating environment.
This model uses vents not as the site of life’s origin, but as the energy and feedstock source for clay‑based proto‑systems. In this model it is the flow of rich chemicals emanating from the vent and carried by water to the clay template which is important. This includes the main carbon source, metals and potential energy sources including sulphur compounds including hydrogen sulphide. The catalytic metals including FeS and NiS are important in fixing carbon. However, vents on their own would not store information or stabilise polymers.
The siting of the proto-biofilms cannot be too close to the hydrothermal vents as the temperature there can exceed 300°C, which is far too hot for clay minerals to form or persist. Too far way the temperature drops to less than 10°C and the chemical flow from the vent becomes too dilute for successful proto-biofilms to form. However, in the middle regions, where the temperature is between 40–120°C, clay minerals can form and persist. The chemical rich streams, including organics and metals, from the vents are not too dilute, so these regions are conducive for the formation of the proto-biofilms.
Initially the turbidity of the water with minerals provides the UV5, 6 shielding but as the EPS matrix forms within the proto-biofilm further protection from UV is provided by this matrix. In the murky water iron-sulphur-particles, colloidal clays and silica precipitates contribute to the light scattering of UV radiation5. Similar extracellular polymeric substances in the matrix also scatters UV radiation. Research indicates that a layer of mineral-rich gel only a millimetre thick can block most of the UV-C radiation—the most damaging form of light on early Earth 6. Between the clay templates and the outer matrix of the proto-biofilm strong gradients (thermal, chemical, redox) drive continuous chemistry, which supports surface‑bound polymerization, matrix formation and compartmentalization.
3. EPS as the First Compartment and First “Genome”
EPS matrices consisting of gels composed of peptides, sugars, nucleic acids and minerals are proposed to be the earliest organizational structure.7, 8 These matrixes retain macromolecules including RNA, peptides and aggregates, trapping clay particles and catalytic metals (such as iron-sulphur particles) but allow diffusion of monomers and ions.
Due to the support of the polymerisation and the trapping of these polymers the matrix is self-thickening and creates a thermal buffer.9 Inside these proto-biofilms a feedback loop forms which results in more polymers; more trapped minerals; more opacity; more protection, then more polymers as the loop repeats. This allows the formation of stable self-reinforcing gels within the matrix. Thus, chemical patterns are stored across the proto-biofilm rather than inside cells.
The clay templates are conducive to polymerization as they concentrate monomers, provide catalytic sites then stabilise the fragile monomers. But as the polymers accumulate, some rise above the surface and start to form the extracellular matrix which form local regions of chemistry. Eventually gel-like regions appear where polymers interact more with each other than with the clay. This creates micro-gradients of pH, ions, and redox potential. The result is the loosening of dependence on the mineral substrate. Gels also allow for nanoscale confinement in pores, which can significantly reduce water activity and allow polymerization to proceed even in water-rich hydrothermal environments.
RNA in the EPS doesn’t need to be inside a protocell to matter. It can replicate on clay surfaces, as well as binding peptides, whilst acting as a catalytic scaffold. The RNA can store patterns that peptides translate through binding, which persist across cycles of turbulence and recolonisation. Hence the EPS acts as a distributed genome, not an intracellular one.
4. Peptide‑First Stability and RNA–Peptide Symbiosis
4.1 Peptide-first world
Clay minerals catalyse peptide formation. Short peptides can fold into catalytic structures as well as form prion-like self‑templating networks. This reinforces EPS matrices. Mutation is rare and mostly deleterious due to folding sensitivity.10, 11
4.2 RNA enters as a symbiotic partner
RNA, which is a by product of vent chemistry appears later as a scaffold as it stabilisers peptide folds as well as being capable of limited catalysis12. The advantage of RNA as being a pattern preserving polymer is then utilised by the proto-biofilm. Peptide networks that utilise RNA become more stable and RNA that bind useful peptides get amplified. Thus, RNA and peptides form a mutualistic ecology, not a competitive one. Over time, RNA becomes the memory system, peptides remain the functional system and the two co‑evolve.
Hence self‑propagating peptides or prion‑like structures could have been early information carriers, with RNA taking over later.
Once RNA becomes the primary replicator, copying errors introduce structured, selectable variation. Environmental pressure begins shaping RNA quasi-species clouds. The introduction of these transcription errors is the start of useful mutations; although most of the errors are harmful and are eliminated. This is the beginning of true Darwinian evolution as quasi-species-like RNA populations emerge. EP begins shaping distributions of variants.
5. Stereochemical Origins of Coding
Certain RNA motifs have intrinsic affinities for specific amino acids. These stereochemical biases arise naturally in EPS microdomains due to shape complementarity, charge distribution, hydrogen bonding patterns and stacking interactions.13, 14 These biases then stabilise peptide – RNA complexes which become reinforced by EP because complexes that exploit these affinities fold and function more reliably. The formalization of pre-existing chemical relationships is the cornerstone of Michael Yarus's "stereochemical theory". His research has demonstrated specific RNA-amino acid affinities, suggesting that cognate coding triplets originated as conserved functional elements in ancient RNA binding sites. This supports the idea that the code developed in stages through the fusion of partial ancestral codes.
These eventually become formalized into proto‑translation systems. The proto-tRNA / proto-ribosomes templates evolve as efficiency upgrades, not origin points**.** These templates develop to speed up the protein synthesis but also incorporate the steric factors.
Certain triplet RNA sequences (codons) have intrinsic chemical/steric affinities for specific amino acids (or for short peptides that include them).
RNA and peptides are co‑localized in a sticky, mineral‑rich matrix so this increases the chance that those latent steric preferences get repeatedly exploited. Environmental Pressure then stabilizes those pairings simply because they “fit” better and recur more reliably.
Then larger RNA–peptide complexes emerge that hold amino acids in specific positions, as well as catalyse peptide bond formation. The proto – ribosome templates using the same stereochemical biases as previous but make translation faster. The proto-ribosomes are carried forward in EPS fragments before being incorporated in proto-cells.
6. Fragmentation, Dispersal, and Lineage Continuity
In early abiogenesis, “reproduction,” “dispersal,” and “information transmission” are not separate processes but they are different facets of EPS fragmentation under environmental pressure.
As the proto-biofilm grows, inner regions of the biofilm become nutrient‑limited as outer layers intercept vent‑derived organics and ions. Fatty acids and similar molecules accumulate in parts of the EPS, making those regions more cohesive and semi‑bounded.15
As the outer layers rise above the surface, they become more loosely attached to the clay template and more prone to be sheared off. Also, local build up of inhibitory by products could cause the proto-biofilm slow down as a ‘chemical factory’ and might eventually shut down. Clay surfaces and optimal mineral patches are finite so for continuation relocation is necessary. Detaching and settling further downstream gives access to fresher resources as well as using cleaner surfaces. Any fragment that can detach and colonize new clay gains an advantage.
The mechanism for dispersion and ‘reproduction’ is turbulence. The amount of turbulence around hydrothermal vents varies and as the proto- biofilm grows the amount of energy needed to shear EPS fragments from the top of the proto-biofilm decreases. These fragments retain RNA, peptides, minerals, and amphiphiles as well as drift into new microenvironments. This results in reseeding new EPS matrices on fresh clay surfaces. This is the earliest form of reproduction, information transmission and ecological expansion. Protocells later emerge as the most cohesive EPS fragments.
Once primitive lipid membranes or amphiphile‑rich patches exist within the EPS–clay matrix, increased turbulence (from vent pulsation, seismic activity, tides, density currents) becomes a mechanical sorting process. Within the proto‑biofilm membrane‑poor regions just get torn apart and diluted but membrane‑rich, more cohesive microdomains resist shear, pinch into blobs, and are more likely to detach as vesicle‑like units. Turbulence, in this model, is not just damaging; it selects for more mechanically coherent compartments and physically releases them into the surrounding water as protocell candidates. Turbulence provides the dispersal mechanism; lipid membranes/EPS coherence provide the capacity to survive dispersal.
The EPS fragment then drifts or is advected into a new region. If it lands in a suitable spot (initially: clay mineral deposit with the right gradients), then trapped peptides re‑adsorb onto the new surface then trapped RNA binds clay and starts whatever replication/catalysis it is capable of doing. Thus, the fragment secretes or reorganizes into a fresh EPS coating. With monomers and small molecules diffusing in, the local chemistry is rebuilt around that seed, a new proto‑biofilm with similar chemistry to the original starts to form. 16
This is effectively reproduction by fragmentation, which resembles modern biofilms, fungal mats, and some colonial organisms.17, 18 Clonal reproduction by fragmentation occurs before any cells have emerged. The EPS thus creates a lineage from a patterned chemistry, not from a fully formed genetic code. There is continuity as EPS fragments carry forward specific chemistries. New matrices formed from fragments resemble the “mother” in composition and dynamics and in this sense, there is heritability. As different regions of the original matrix may fragment with slightly different compositions, variation occurs. As some fragment‑types colonize new sites and persist better than others, there is differential persistence**.** Everything emerges from fragmentation + drift + recolonization of a symbiotic polymer matrix.
7. Transition to Protocells
As amphiphile‑rich patches form within EPS, some internalize clay particles, RNA and peptides. Some fragments become more cohesive whilst trapping more RNA, more peptides and more minerals. Vesicle‑like compartments emerge as lipid membranes begin to form. Compartments that accidentally internalize RNA + peptides + minerals survive better than EPS fragments that do not. This marks the shift from external genome to internal genome.
When turbulence hits, the more cohesive patches, resist shear but if these patches form closed vesicles with membranes, they are easily removed by the turbulence, then drift into new clay patches and re‑establish EPS matrices.
Protocells are just the most robust EPS fragments as they are the most stable, self‑contained fragments of the EPS system. Once protocells detach new pressures appear as they must maintain internal chemistry without clay as well as being able to capture energy and nutrients from the environment. Besides this they must stabilize their boundaries. This leads to Internalization of catalytic minerals from which more robust amphiphile synthesis develop along with proton‑gradient‑like mechanisms. Primitive replication cycles emerge. As protocells internalize more of this chemistry those pre‑existing RNA–amino acid biases become the seed of an internal translation system. Ribozyme‑like templates emerge inside protocells as reorganizations of chemistry that already worked outside in the EPS. At this point, the system is no longer a clay‑anchored biofilm. It is a population of semi‑autonomous protocells as the genome has shifted from being external in EPS to being internal in the protocells.
8. Why the HCB Model Uses Environmental Pressure Rather Than Natural Selection
When Darwin first wrote the origin of the species he was mainly dealing with specialists in the same way animal breeders use breeding to improve specific traits as in pigeon or dog breeding. Thus, humans are selecting for specialists. In the same way Natural Selection (NS) favours specialists for a specific environment. NS is the outcome of the filter for specialisation. EP looks at this slightly differently in that as the environment becomes more extreme the niche narrows so the selective filter becomes strong, so that only organisms with the right adaptions survive. EP is the selective filter. So, in these cases NS and EP are effectively identical. An example of a specialist is Zygosaccharomyces rouxii in a high sugar syrup as the environment is harsh and the pressure is one-directional, so the organism copes or dies. There is no reciprocal sharing nor a niche construction nor a feedback loop. Z. rouxii thrives in these conditions where other microbes cannot cope.
Generalists do not just fit an environment but they modify it. They build biofilms; alter pH; trap moisture; neutralise oxidants; create micro-gradients; recruit other species and can generate new ecological structure. This is reciprocal causation and not one-way filtering. NS in its classical form assumes the environment is fixed and organisms adapt to it. Hence the environment does not change in response. So, NS alone cannot explain niche construction; cooperative consortia; environmental engineering; feedback loops; emergent complexity and dynamic micro-niches. These are exactly the conditions that the HCB model proposes for abiogenesis. An example of a generalist is Aspergillus niger which can thrive and start to form biofilms in numerous environments.
However, EP is inherently two-way so can explain that the environment shapes the organism (or EPS fragment then proto-cell) which in turn shape the environment and the cycle then continues. This framework explains; specialists (one-way pressure); generalists (two-way feedback); biofilms; niche construction; cooperative evolution; microbial resilience and emergent complexity. EP is simply more general than NS.
9. Summary of Existing Experimental Evidence
9.1 Clay formation near vents
A recent study found 3.5‑billion‑year‑old hydrothermal vent sediments containing iron‑rich clay minerals (greenalite) and phosphate minerals (apatite), showing that clay formation in vent environments is geologically real. This supports the HCB model in that clay minerals exist in the “Goldilocks zone” around vents.
9.2 Mineral-driven prebiotic chemistry
NASA’s Origins and Habitability Laboratory actively studies show that proto-metabolic networks are mineral driven as well as redox chemistry is relevant to early life. Hydrothermal vent analogue systems experiments show that minerals and metals can drive prebiotic organic reactions under vent‑like conditions. These analogue experiments also show minerals catalyse organic reactions as well as FeS/NiS surfaces support proto-metabolic cycles. This supports the “vent chemistry as energy engine” part of the HCB model.19
9.3 RNA and peptides on clay
A 2024 study examined magnesium silicate chimneys at the Strytan Hydrothermal Field in Iceland as analogues for early Earth alkaline vents4. The findings included that porous structures by vents concentrate organics including nucleic acids and peptides. These mineral surfaces are capable of catalysis of amino acids to form peptides and nucleic acids to form RNA as they provide natural pH and redox gradients. Also, RNA -peptide complexes mutually stabilise each other**.** This supports the idea that vent structures can act as reactive scaffolds for early biochemistry.20, 21, 22
9.4 Vesicle formation in prebiotic conditions
Biofilm EPS behaviour under flow, shear and gradients has been well studied in microbiology and EPS is known to retain macromolecules and allow monomer diffusion as required by the HCB model.7, 8 However prebiotic EPS analogues (abiotic gels, mixed polymers, peptide‑polysaccharide matrices) have not been systematically tested in vent‑like conditions and no experiment has been carried out to create a prebiotic EPS matrix from scratch. Also, there are research opportunities to determine whether fatty acid vesicles form under thermal cycling and whether vesicles can encapsulate RNA and minerals.
9. 5 RNA + peptides co‑localizing on minerals
Experiments have shown that RNA binds strongly to clay minerals (montmorillonite). Also, clay can catalyse RNA polymerization (Ferris et al., classic work) and short peptides can form on mineral surfaces. Although it is known that RNA–peptide complexes can mutually stabilize each other (various ribozyme studies) but RNA + peptides + EPS + clay together has not been tested.21
9.6 Fragmentation + reseeding as a lineage mechanism
Biofilm research shows that EPS fragments can detach under shear then fragments can colonize new surfaces.17 It has also been shown that fragments carry macromolecules and structural memory. But no one has yet tested abiotic EPS fragments carrying RNA + peptides reseeding new clay surfaces. However, this is a testable prediction of the HCB model.
9 .7 Protocell emergence inside EPS
Experiments have shown that fatty acid vesicles form more easily in the presence of minerals and vesicles can encapsulate RNA as well as vesicles can survive thermal cycling. Also, vesicles can grow and divide under certain conditions.16 But no one has yet tested vesicle formation inside an EPS‑like matrix or as cohesive EPS fragments.
10. Proposed Experiments to Validate or Falsify the Model
10.1 EPS Fragment Lineage Experiment
Goal: Show that EPS fragments carrying RNA + peptides can reseed new mineral surfaces and regenerate similar chemistry.
This could be achieved by growing an EPS‑coated, clay‑attached matrix in a flow cell with RNA + peptides present. Then applying controlled shear (flow increase, agitation, or mechanical perturbation) to fragment it. Fresh clay surfaces are then provided downstream. These are monitored to see whether fragments attach and they rebuild the EPS. If an EPS is rebuilt the RNA/peptide composition downstream can be examined to see if it resembles the upstream matrix.
The HCB model is validated if the downstream EPS matches the upstream composition and falsified if the fragments fail to attach or regenerate coherent matrices.
10.2 RNA–Peptide Symbiosis in EPS
Goal: Show that RNA + peptides can co‑localize in EPS on clay and mutually stabilize each other.
A possible setup for this is by coating clay with EPS‑like material in a flow chamber then introducing microscopically labelled short RNA strands (or ribozyme candidates) and short peptides (including prion‑like or amyloid‑forming sequences). Degradation rates of RNA can be compared in the presence and absence of peptides and other EPS molecules. Also, evidence of enhanced catalytic activity could be searched for when RNA and peptides are both present, compared to the absence of each other.
If co-localisation is found to increase stability or catalytic activity this would add to support to the HCB model as far as EPS being a plausible external ‘genome’ context for RNA–peptide symbiosis.
If RNA and peptides degrade or disperse independently; this finding would weaken the HCB model as far as RNA-peptide symbiosis.
10.3 Protocell Emergence from EPS
Goal: Observe vesicle formation within EPS and test whether vesicles internalize RNA/peptides/minerals.
A possible setup could include introducing simple amphiphiles (fatty acids, monoacylglycerols) into a system where clay, EPS, RNA and peptides are already present. Then allow thermal and chemical cycling to derive vesicle formation and fusion. The system is then checked to see if there has been vesicle formation in the presence or absence of EPS and clay and whether these vesicles contain RNA, peptides and minerals.
The formation of vesicles, containing RNA, peptides, inside an EPS proto biofilm would strongly support the HCB model whilst if vesicles form only in bulk solution and fail to internalise polymers.
10.4 Stereochemical Codon–Amino Acid Biases
Goal: Test whether specific RNA motifs bind specific amino acids in EPS-like conditions.
Specific codons could be introduced into a constructed proto-biofilm along with various amino acids.
If consistent binding preferences emerge the HCB model is strengthened but if no reproducible affinities are observed the model is weakened in regard to stereochemical linkage between RNA motifs and specific amino acids.
10.5 Clay Independence Transition
Goal**:** Determine whether protocells can maintain internal chemistry without clay.
The possible setup could be the same as 10.3 above. If vesicles or protocells are formed these can be detached from the proto-biofilm and placed on other mineral surfaces, which were likely to be present in a young earth, before the emergence of life, then observe if these vesicles are capable of forming a new proto-biofilm, if provided with the relevant flow of chemicals, which are in the vicinity of a hydrothermal vent.
If protocells survive and replicate chemistry in clay-free environments, the HCB model is strengthened but if protocells collapse in the absence of clay surfaces the HCB model is weakened.
11. Conclusion
This HCB model reframes abiogenesis as the emergence of a stable ecological attractor in a mineral‑rich, gradient‑driven environment. It integrates clay templating, EPS matrices, peptide–RNA symbiosis, and protocell emergence into a coherent evolutionary sequence. Many components are experimentally supported, but the EPS‑mediated lineage mechanism and symbiotic RNA–peptide ecology remain untested — and represent promising new research directions.
References
1. Russell, M. J., & Hall, A. J. (1997). The emergence of life from iron monosulphide bubbles at a submarine hydrothermal redox and pH front. Journal of the Geological Society, 154, 377–402.
2. Russell, M. J., Daniel, R. M., & Hall, A. J. (1993). On the emergence of life via catalytic iron-sulphide membranes. Terra Nova, 5, 343–347.
3. Barge, L. M., et al. (2019). Redox and pH gradients drive amino acid synthesis in iron oxyhydroxide systems. PNAS, 116(11), 4828–4833.
4. Gutiérrez-Ariza, C., et al. (2023). Magnesium silicate chimneys at the Strytan hydrothermal field as analogues for prebiotic chemistry. Progress in Earth and Planetary Science.
5. Cockell, C. S. (2000). Ultraviolet radiation and the photobiology of Earth’s early oceans. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere, 30, 467–499.
6. Ranjan, S., & Sasselov, D. D. (2017). Constraints on the early terrestrial surface UV environment relevant to prebiotic chemistry. Astrobiology, 17(3), 169–204.
7. Flemming, H.-C., & Wingender, J. (2010). The biofilm matrix. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 8, 623–633.
8. Flemming, H.-C., Wingender, J., Szewzyk, U., et al. (2016). Biofilms: an emergent form of bacterial life. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 14, 563–575.
9. Damer, B., & Deamer, D. (2020). The hot spring hypothesis for an origin of life. Astrobiology, 20(4), 429–452.
10. Carter, C. W., & Wills, P. R. (2018). Interdependence, reflexivity, fidelity, and impedance matching in the origin of genetic coding. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 35(2), 269–286.
11. Frenkel-Pinter, M., et al. (2020). Prebiotic peptides and the origin of life. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 142(3), 1134–1147.
12. Hud, N. V., Cafferty, B. J., Krishnamurthy, R., & Williams, L. D. (2013). The origin of RNA and “my grandfather’s axe”. Chemistry & Biology, 20(4), 466–474.
13. Yarus, M., Widmann, J. J., & Knight, R. (2009). RNA–amino acid binding: a stereochemical era for the genetic code. Journal of Molecular Evolution, 69, 406–429.
14. Yarus, M. (2017). The genetic code and RNA–amino acid affinities. Life, 7(1), 13.
15. Hanczyc, M. M., Fujikawa, S. M., & Szostak, J. W. (2003). Experimental models of primitive cellular compartments: encapsulation, growth, and division. Science, 302, 618–622.
16. Maurer, S. E., et al. (2018). Vesicle self-assembly on mineral surfaces. Langmuir, 34(23), 6710–6720.
17. Kaplan, J. B. (2010). Biofilm dispersal: mechanisms, clinical implications, and potential therapeutic uses. Journal of Dental Research, 89(3), 205–218.
18. McDougald, D., et al. (2012). Should we stay or should we go: mechanisms and ecological consequences for biofilm dispersal. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 10, 39–50.
19. Ferris, J. P., Hill, A. R., Liu, R., & Orgel, L. E. (1996). Synthesis of long prebiotic oligomers on mineral surfaces. Nature, 381, 59–61.
20. Ferris, J. P. (2006). Montmorillonite-catalysed formation of RNA oligomers: the possible role of catalysis in the origins of life. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 361, 1777–1786.
21. Ertem, G. (2004). Montmorillonite, oligonucleotides, RNA and origin of life. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere, 34, 549–570.
22. Lambert, J. F. (2008). Adsorption and polymerization of amino acids on mineral surfaces: a review. Origins of Life and Evolution of Biospheres, 38, 211–242.
r/abiogenesis • u/Choice-Break8047 • Dec 31 '25
Hi everyone,
I wanted to run this community to see if it holds water or if I’m missing a major geochemical constraint.
For context, I am currently a clinical laboratory technologist, but prior to this, I worked in an industrial chemistry lab that used PGM (Platinum Group Metal) catalysts. Because of this background, I keep running into a "chemist’s paradox" when I read standard abiogenesis theories. And before anyone asks, I used AI to write this for clarity, but not create the idea itself.
The Paradox:
Most theories (like Alkaline Vents) assume life started with Iron, Nickel, and Cobalt because they were abundant on early Earth. But from an industrial catalysis perspective, first-row transition metals are often terrible to work with in aqueous conditions. Iron passivates to oxides; Nickel is prone to oxidation. They are abundant, but they offer low selectivity and poor stability in the water-rich environments needed for life.
In contrast, the heavier noble metals (Ruthenium, Platinum, Tungsten) are the "high-performance" engines. Ruthenium, specifically, is one of the rare metals that can drive Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (to make lipid chains) in liquid water without deactivating.
The Hypothesis: "Performance First, Abundance Later"
I’ve been toying with the idea that life didn't start with the abundant stuff, but rather with the high-performance stuff delivered by the Late Heavy Bombardment (LHB).
The logic goes like this:
Delivery: The LHB impacts delivered rare siderophile metals (Ru, Pt, W). Due to condensation physics, they likely arrived encased in iron shells ("Trojan Horses"), protecting them during atmospheric entry.
The Reactor: In a hydrothermal crater lake, the iron shell weathers away, acting as a buffer and exposing the active noble metal core.
The Chemistry: Ruthenium—modulated by the presence of Sulfur—is excellent at synthesizing specific C10-C18 fatty acids (fluid lipids) rather than the solid waxes or random tars you often get with Iron.
The Evolution: Life establishes itself using this "Ferrari" engine. As the bombardment ended and these rare metals became scarce, biology was forced to "value engineer" its machinery to use the abundant "Ford" metals (Iron/Nickel).
Is this consistent with the biochemistry?
It seems like the most ancient, primitive enzymes still rely on these "exotic" impact-delivered metals, acting almost like biochemical fossils:
• Tungsten (W) is used by ancient hyperthermophiles (like P. furiosus) in place of Molybdenum.
• Molybdenum (Mo) is still required for Nitrogenase (we never figured out how to fix Nitrogen with just Iron).
• Nickel/Cobalt are central to ancient pathways (Hydrogenases, B12).
My Questions for the Community:
Is there a fatal flaw in proposing that the Iron-Sulfur World was a secondary adaptation to scarcity, rather than the origin?
Does the Tungsten-182 isotope evidence (which implies the mantle didn't fully mix with late impactors) actually support this by suggesting these metals would have stayed concentrated in the crust/crater lakes rather than being lost to the core? The reason for this question is the carbonaceous material in Isua has this isotopes signature.
I’d appreciate any feedback or links to papers that discuss PGM catalysis in a prebiotic context.
r/abiogenesis • u/baba_yaga_babe • Jan 23 '26
I’m wondering about why cellular organisms that we call “life“ came to be? Why life? And I‘m not asking from a philosophical pov (what’s the meaning of life? what are we all doing here?) - I’m asking from the bio/physics pov. Why were atoms and molecules compelled to…create mitochondria (etc.)? What is the law of physics that made life happen, and continue happening?
I saw an article that said something about multi cellular organisms diffusing energy more efficiently or something? Entropy? But I’m no physicist and it didn’t make sense to me. Hoping someone here has a satisfying answer or at least can tell me where to look for one.
edit: clarified language of question
r/abiogenesis • u/VaHi_Inst_Tech • Sep 10 '26
Georgia Tech is hosting an origins of life meeting, September 22,23, 2026. On September 24-25, directly following the OOL meeting, is a sister meeting on Diversification of Life.
These meetings will be broadcast online, without charge, but require registration. These are technical/academic meetings but could be of interest to an informed lay audience.
The OOL meeting in particular is a departure from standard format. The organizers are encouraging speakers to engage each other (in their talks and in panel discussions), to acknowledge/question assumptions and to discuss model weaknesses.
r/abiogenesis • u/Dr_GS_Hurd • Feb 04 '26
I like finding open access articles that do a good job of explaining difficult topics. This one does.
“How RNA reveals clues to life’s origins on Earth” By Clare Sansom 2 February 2026 Chemistry World, British Royal Society of Chemistry
A main point is the enzyme action of short RNA segments.
A related open source article from Nature magazine is Singh, J., Thoma, B., Whitaker, D. et al. Thioester-mediated RNA aminoacylation and peptidyl-RNA synthesis in water. Nature 644, 933–944 (2025).
I hope you all enjoy them as well.
r/abiogenesis • u/BradyStewart777 • Feb 16 '25
Or how life could form from nothing? Or if it happened? Did it happen in deep oceans? Or could it have begun in clay? If you’re curious about these questions, you’re in the right place. This subreddit is all about the science of how life might have originated from simple molecules. Whether you’re new or have been following the topic for a while, feel free to jump in. Share questions, theories, or research! 🔬 For beginners, this article from Britannia serves as a great learning resource. Simply click on the colored text to access the article!
I am currently working on a resource guide that will bring together much of the research and ideas on abiogenesis in one place. I had to start over due to an issue with the original post, so it’s no longer saved after deletion. But once it’s ready, it will be a great place to explore the amazing science behind life's origins.
r/abiogenesis • u/ADragonFromTheAbyss • 18d ago
The theory that comets delivered the molecular building blocks for life on Earth is a long-standing one, since comets are known to carry many of these molecules. However, a new study challenges this idea.
The researchers, led by the University of Cambridge, found the cometary delivery of these building blocks would be—at best—a 'one-off fluke,' and not the steady rain of prebiotic molecules that had been theorized.
Using computer modeling, the researchers determined that comets travel too fast and at too sharp an angle to Earth's atmosphere for the fragile organic molecules to survive: they would almost certainly vaporize on impact with the surface.
However, the researchers also found that another planet in our system—Mars—could be a slightly more promising candidate for cometary delivery of prebiotic molecules, although this is still highly unlikely. The results are published in the journal Scientific Reports.
"Historically, scientists thought that comets were important for the origin of life on Earth, because they carried carbon- and nitrogen-bearing molecules, so these giant space snowballs were almost like a 'get out of jail free card' that brought all the molecules a planet would need to seed life," said lead author Dr. Richard
Anslow from Cambridge's Institute of Astronomy. "It's kind of a romantic idea, but our results suggest it's highly unlikely."
The researchers used recent advances in comet impact simulations, comet-atmosphere interactions and dynamic modeling of the origin and evolution of comets to conduct their study. Taken together, the researchers found that while the successful delivery of prebiotic molecules cannot be ruled out completely, it would be extremely unlikely.
r/abiogenesis • u/Aggravating-Pear4222 • May 31 '26
Title: Amplification of Chirality through Self-Replication of Micellar Aggregates in Water
[Link]
Not Open Access but is accessible through pathways some consider to be... unnatural. (Scihub... it's Scihub.)

Abstract: We describe a system in which the self-replication of micellar aggregates results in a spontaneous amplification of chirality in the reaction products. In this system, amphiphiles are synthesized from two “clickable” fragments: a water-soluble “head” and a hydrophobic “tail”. Under biphasic conditions, the reaction is autocatalytic, as aggregates facilitate the transfer of hydrophobic molecules to the aqueous phase. When chiral, partially enantioenriched surfactant heads are used, a strong nonlinear induction of chirality in the reaction products is observed. Preseeding the reaction mixture with an amphiphile of one chirality results in the amplification of this product and therefore information transfer between generations of self-replicating aggregates. Because our amphiphiles are capable of catalysis, information transfer, and self-assembly into bounded structures, they present a plausible model for prenucleic acid “lipid world” entities.
"Here, we describe an example of strongly self-selective, autopoietic aggregates that grow via a bond-making copper-catalyzed azide–alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) reaction. (17, 18) Our aggregates are capable of discrimination between the two enantiomers of the starting material."
"Our amphiphiles assemble into structures capable of both function (phase-transfer catalysis) and information transfer (as chirality) between generations. This provides support for the idea that lipidlike, catalytically competent molecules could have played a dominant role in the prebiotic era, before the emergence of more specialized information-bearing structures such as RNA."
Personal Thoughts: The amphiphiles used are not prebiotically relevant but offer a proof-of-principle for how chiral amphiphiles may form "chiral micelles" capable of enantiodiscrimination between the R vs S polar heads. The hydrophobic "tail" is a simple linear hydrocarbon with an azide at the end capable of undergoing a "click reaction" (names after the manner in which the azide "clicks" onto an alkyne using a Cu catalyst. Such chemistry is common today as it is bioorthogonal, capable of being in in aqueous conditions and is non-toxic but has not, to my knowledge, been proposed as being prebiotically relevant nor are the amphiphiles.
Chiral micelles [link 1, link 2] and lipid bilayers [link] are not just capable of enantiodiscrimination in permeability and amphiphile integration but also catalysis [link 1, link 2]. If the catalyst is also chiral, that catalyst may also bias enantioselectivity if the initial enantiodiscriminative permeation into the micelle is imperfect.
In this case, CuSO4 is used but many other rare-earth and catalytically active metals are common in hydrothermal systems and the prebiotic oceans [link 1 (for this paper, note that the thermal range for the vent was closely linked to the tides, offering a key mechanism by which thermal cycling may have affected thermally-linked variables. I will keep this in mind.), link 2]. Amino acids or, as recently posted [link], RNRs (ribonucleotide reductases) are capable of chelating metals to act as ligands, stabilizing or modifying the metal's properties, and chirally defining the envrionment around this catalytic center. Their chirality also informs selective chirality and solubility-dependent partitioning into micelles/bilayers or the hydrophobic cores with lower water activity (~fewer waters which may "distract" other organic intermolecular H-bonding). Such environments allow for the isolation of hydrogen bonds, creating better defined intermolecular complexes which may promote a given reaction.
For these reasons and many others, the properties of chiral amphiphile-composed micelles and lipid bilayers of vesicles are currently of great interest to me. Namely, the properties of chiral micelles and chiral lipid raft domains currently informs my own ideas/models on how prebiotic systems may achieve enantioenrichment without appeals to high concentrations nor necessarily (but not limited to) covalent bond-forming reactions.
r/abiogenesis • u/Aggravating-Pear4222 • Apr 20 '26
r/abiogenesis has recently reached 1000 members!
Abiogenesis and origins of life research seeks to answer the uniquely fundamental and even existential question of life's first developmental steps and existence on Earth. Answering HOW life formed fundamentally questions the underlying laws of biogenesis and what Life exactly is and its relation to energy, entropy, and the inorganic world. As such, the field seeks the initial spark that started the bootstrapping mechanism that lead to us paying taxes.
Thank you to every one for being a part of this community. Despite how niche this topic can be, it receives a disproportionate amount of attention and much of that attention is negative.
Despite this, communities such as r/abiogenesis seeks to provide a balanced view into this topic based on evidence/data and presented in a way that's digestible to the layperson. Shoutout to u/BradyStewart777 who was a relatively recent addition to the mod team and came in like a tornado in a junk yard, setting up housekeeping bots and a lot of the decorations/look and feel of the subreddit.
Many here have consistently made resourceful posts that have helped me and others widen our view and challenge previously held assumptions about the prebiotic earth and its chemistry. As such, I'd like to take some time to highlight just a few of the members who consistently bring their A-game regarding thoroughness and quality of the work they put share on this topic. This list is NOT complete and even if you lurk here we are happy you are here. Each comment and question from anyone is appreciated.
u/gitgud_x has made a number of contributions by assembling papers on a number of topics like homochirality [Link], the relationship to the early genetic code and amino acid-nucleobase relationship [Link], and sharing 100 papers of interest [Link]. They consistently provide a thorough exposure to the literature on these topics and often broaden my horizons.
u/jnpha shows an interest in Ribozymes [Link] and RNA-DNA coevolution [Link] sharing papers on how selectivity can occur on RNA sequence space exploration for shorter sequences, supporting the idea that the RNA world wasn't only at play for more advanced protocellular systems and provides hints on how the DNA-RNA relationship may have first come about. Check out his previous post on how amino acids help catalyze formation of RNA linkages [Link].
u/VaHi_Inst_Tech has been posting an ongoing series covering the fundamental concepts in abiogenesis such as chirality, biopolymers, water, and the RNA world. Check out his "Lastest part 8" and his previous posts. u/VaHi_Inst_Tech is a key part of this community by highlighting these underlying principles and concepts that are assumed as known.
u/wellipets consistently challenges consensus via their rather distinct short-hand styled texts rapidly listing off advanced topics. The field tends to want to reach well-defined states and biopolymers with the same monomers as seen in modern biology. wellipets argues that a more open-minded approach would provide more insights into the systems possible. Comments like their inspired my recent post on membraneless coacervates. Prior to this, my "first step" for abiogenesis was vesicle formation.
u/Dr_GS_Hurd's comments often include a number of references to support their insights they share on posts, a very valuable and made an interesting post on phosphate availability [Link here] and catalytic activity of short RNA oligomers on thioester formation [Link].
u/Choice-Break8047 embraces the messiness of the prebiotic world even as this is commonly framed as a critique/barrier for the researchers in the field or the principles of the process [Link]. Furthermore, Choice-Break8047 put forward a thorough synthesis of their hypothesis on how life first formed via a vesicle-first model [Link], focusing on the role that more precious metals like ruthenium could have played by retaining FTT chemistry catalytic activity under aqueous conditions to form lipids.
So, again, thank you to every one who contributes and this community. Keep up the quality work!
r/abiogenesis • u/jnpha • Apr 13 '26
"The phylogeny of hammerhead ribozymes exhibits a star-like topology consistent with rapid post-bottleneck expansion, and its small size, ability to tolerate diverse chemical conditions, and broad substrate specificity suggest it was a resilient generalist feeder fitting as a disaster taxon. [...] This hypothesis proposes a reframing of the origin of the genetic code in part as an ecological legacy rather than a purely chemical inevitability."
—Bachelet, Ido. "A ribozyme mass extinction at the RNA-cellular boundary and its potential imprint on the genetic code." bioRxiv (2026): 2026-03. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.03.05.709948
r/abiogenesis • u/dem0n0cracy • Feb 13 '26
Abstract
The emergence of a chemical system capable of self-replication and evolution is a critical event in the origin of life. RNA polymerase ribozymes can replicate RNA, but their large size and structural complexity impede self-replication and preclude their spontaneous emergence. Here we describe QT45: a 45-nucleotide polymerase ribozyme, discovered from random sequence pools, that catalyzes general RNA-templated RNA synthesis using trinucleotide triphosphate (triplet) substrates in mildly alkaline eutectic ice. QT45 can synthesize both its complementary strand using a random triplet pool at 94.1% per-nucleotide fidelity, and a copy of itself using defined substrates, both with yields of ~0.2% in 72 days. The discovery of polymerase activity in a small RNA motif suggests that polymerase ribozymes are more abundant in RNA sequence space than previously thought.
r/abiogenesis • u/VaHi_Inst_Tech • Jan 09 '26
Spring semester I am teaching an origins of life class. I am putting together a series of short narratives intended to prompt discussion. Maybe during the semester I will try posting some of them here.
How did life begin? We do not know. This deceptively simple question demands scientific reasoning at the limits of evidence. It resists conventional disciplinary boundaries and requires the integration of concepts from chemistry, biology, physics, and geology. This course teaches students to think critically and analytically about origins-of-life research and about scientific reasoning more broadly. We will examine competing models—including the RNA World, Clay World, Vent World, metabolism-first, and chemical evolution models — and the logical frameworks that support them. Students will learn to evaluate claims rigorously, identify hidden assumptions and logical fallacies. We will study both the power and the danger of scientific models and explore how scientists commit to them through training and expertise, professional networks, publication history, and the intertwined forces of funding and reputation. We will examine how models can illuminate understanding or constrain it. Students will learn useful formalisms and common logical errors that shape scientific reasoning. This class is designed for chemists, biochemists, biologists, geologists, physicists, and engineers willing to engage with some of science’s hardest and most consequential questions.
r/abiogenesis • u/jnpha • Jun 06 '25
r/abiogenesis • u/manatorn • Feb 02 '13
r/abiogenesis • u/Aggravating-Pear4222 • Jul 07 '26
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GkuAzdS-VwA
Timestamps from the description:
0:00 Hydrothermal vent discovery
1:55 Origin of life: soup or what?
2:50 Hydrothermal vents as perfect location for life
4:25 Previous propositions but it was just a hypothesis
5:45 New study finds evidence - chemiosmotic gradient
7:20 Proof
9:30 Why this is important not just for biologists
Alkaline vents provide many benefits towards the production of life. Anton Petrov describes evidence for some of the evidence alkaline vents provide towards their being central to the origin of life.
r/abiogenesis • u/wellwisher-1 • May 10 '26
If you look at the early development and evolution of life, from before abiogenesis, forward, to the present, the majority component of life, water, has not changed. At all stages of life development and evolution, water has stayed the same.
tf follows that with water unchanging, water has applied the same set of potentials to the organic matter, du jour, at each step of change. Water is like an eternal bookend with the samepush/pull. The organics are the variable bookend of life, where change and diversity rule. But water stays the same and true like a north star for life and evolution.
Most other solvents speculated for life on other planets, such as organic solvents like alcohols, would not remain eternal, since they contain energy value for metabolism. Water, on the other hand is already a terminal product of combustion, and has little value as food for metabolism, allowing water to stay the same, forever, under the chemical stresses of life.
From a chemical POV, the fluid nature of life is based on secondary bonding forces. These weaker secondary bonds can form and break, using low energy, with no harm to the stronger primary bounds. What water brings to the table of secondary bonding, is water is able to form up to four hydrogen bonds per tiny water molecule and can also self ionize; pH effect. This unique situation makes water the king of secondary bonding within life; the eternal bookend of life is also the king of secondary bonding in life. Water's stability sets the tone. Water is also the most anomalous substance in all of nature with over 70 anomalous behaviors where it bucks the trends.
If we mix water and oil and agitate this will create an emulsion, which is a mixture of water and oil bubbles. This will add surface tension to the water, thereby adding potential to the water. Water, to relieve the tension and lower the potential in its hydrogen bonds, will combine with other water bubbles until the king is once again maximized.
The organics of life are a loosely analogous to oil in that they create some smaller level of surface tension in the water. In the case of protein, the water will pack and fold protein to lower surface tension. Hydrophobic moieties get buried in the core to help the water and the surface is made friendly to the water; hydrophilic. The king of secondary bonding, does not change, organizing protein to the water.
r/abiogenesis • u/gitgud_x • May 06 '26
Acetylene (C2H2) is often considered a useful building block for prebiotic chemistry, and one route to making acetylene is:
CaCO3 (calcium carbonate) -> CaO (lime) + CO2 @ T > 900 C
CaO + 3 C -> CaC2 (calcium carbide) + CO @ T > 1600 C, p(CO) = 1 bar
CaC2 + 2 H2O -> C2H2 (acetylene) + Ca(OH)2 @ STP
This reaction is notably elegant as it bridges the inorganic and the organic (common vitalism L 😉), and the first two steps are the way we manufacture CaC2 industrially today, using an electric arc furnace.
In Scheidler et al., 2016, the authors cite the above reaction as being a prebiotically plausible source of acetylene, with the first two processes occurring inside the mantle of the Hadean earth.
I'm wondering about the legitimacy of this, since:
Today, we don't find carbides present in volcanic xenocrysts.
Elemental carbon in reaction (2) seems unlikely - a highly reducing environment would be required, but we know that the mantle's oxygen fugacity is constrained by mineral buffers, with the mantle redox potential lying near that of the fayalite-magnetite-quartz (FMQ) buffer, where carbon is oxidised.
Do we think this process is feasible or not on an early earth? Thanks for any pointers!
Worth mentioning, if this process turns out to not be feasible, we still know that acetylene can (and is) produced from hydrothermal vents and volcanic springs, and it's also known from Miller-Urey chemistry, so it's only this specific pathway that I'm doubting.
r/abiogenesis • u/Aggravating-Pear4222 • Apr 04 '26

Paper (Open Access): https://www.nature.com/articles/s42004-026-01969-w
From the abstract: This review explores evidences that reconcile the dominant theories, including that: (i) the Hadean atmosphere was weakly oxidizing, but transiently reducing, (ii) hydrothermal systems provided energy for organic synthesis supporting both heterotrophs and chemoautotrophs, (iii) organic compounds were transported between different environments, and (iv) life emerged in multiple local environments.
For the layperson: This review seeks to consolidate recent advancements in our understanding of the early earths lithosphere and atmosphere and seeks to weigh the evidence for what chemicals are produced, their sources, and their sinks. These considerations inform properties of the prebiotic oceans as well. The authors also review how these impact different models/environments in which we believe life first arose (hydrothermal vents, shallow lakes, ponds, and hot springs).
Papers like these are foundational to any chemical investigations for origins of life chemistry. Any molecule assumed to be present in a chemical experiment must have support for arising through natural processes from these precursors.
Key words: Geochemistry, simple molecules.
r/abiogenesis • u/jnpha • Mar 07 '26
From: Tagami, Shunsuke, and Peiying Li. "The origin of life: RNA and protein co‐evolution on the ancient earth." Development, Growth & Differentiation 65.3 (2023): 167-174.
It's amazing that every numbered step now has (often many) plausible (tested) pathways, and that's just one model.
r/abiogenesis • u/VaHi_Inst_Tech • Jan 16 '26
Honey-Pot Parsimony [690 words]
Parsimony refers to the principle of seeking the simplest or most economical explanation for a phenomenon and is closely related to Occam’s razor, which favors models that minimize assumptions. However, simplicity can be misleading when explanation is collapsed by pre-selected endpoints.
We define honeypot parsimony as illusory simplicity purchased by omission. A honeypot model appears simple because it excludes hard parts of the problem. They are easy to understand and therefore seductive but lack broad predictive and explanatory power. An illusion of simplicity is dependent on narrowly drawn boundaries with exclusion of challenging data. A model is truly parsimonious when it explains more with less. Genuinely parsimonious models minimize requirements and account for complexity.
Snowmageddon, 2014. In a contrived example, one might argue that 2-3 inches of snow paralyzed traffic, stranded commuters and students, and caused widespread gridlock across metro Atlanta during Snowmageddon (February, 2014). Snowmageddon actually required specific timing of weather and commutes, a sprawling urban layout, irrational and inexpert driver behavior, poor infrastructure, lack of preparation, failures of political and administrative leadership and other factors. Snowfall is a honeypot that absorbs explanation and creates the illusion of simplicity and predictive power, while the underlying causal network is ignored. In this case, honeypot parsimony predicts that in the future 2-3 inches of snow will paralyze not only Atlanta, but Buffalo, New York and Winnipeg, Manitoba. It will not.
Honeypot models are not unique to origins-of-life research. The amyloid cascade, the selfish gene and the central dogma are honey pot models. The RNA World is used here to illustrate honeypot parsimony in the context of the origins of life. In the RNA World, catalysis, replication and heredity are attributed to a system of RNA enzymology and information. With a single biopolymer (simple), the model appears parsimonious. The RNA World is a tidy narrative. However, the RNA World does not:
a) Predict the centrality of water as biochemical medium, substrate, reaction intermediate, reaction product, or mechanistic cofactor, nor does it predict the biosynthesis of polynucleotides, polypeptides and glycans and most metabolites by condensation-dehydration.
b) Predict that polynucleotides, polypeptides and glycans are chemically (thermodynamically) unstable in water and persist via kinetic traps. Nor does the RNA World predict the role of assembly in controlling hydrolytic lifetimes of biopolymers (rRNA hydrolyses slowly, mRNA hydrolyzes quickly).
c) Acknowledge the disadvantages of solitary actors or concede the advantages of cooperative systems in which robustness, resilience, and evolvability emerge from diverse interactors.
d) Acknowledge that the proverbial chicken/egg dilemma (which came first, RNA or protein?) is inappropriate for co-evolutionary systems, where changes are linked and emerge simultaneously in disparate systems.
e) Anticipate deep molecular entanglement of biology, including the reciprocal dependencies among RNA, proteins, and small molecules (e.g., RNA synthesizes protein in the ribosome; protein synthesizes RNA in polymerases; amino acids are substrates in nucleotide biosynthesis).
f) Predict the central role of an energy currency in linking informational and metabolic systems in biological systems.
g) Account for the chemically demanding steps required for prebiotic RNA formation—ribose and nucleobase synthesis and purification and linkage, phosphorylation chemistry, polymerization, and strand separation.
h) Explain why the genetic code and universal biopolymer backbones appear highly evolved and hyperfunctional, rather than rudimentary structures expected at life’s origin. The RNA world does not anticipate the extraordinary functional competencies of polynucleotide and polypeptide backbones, which serve not only catalytic roles but also structural, mechanical, transport, adhesive and compartment-forming functions.
i) Explain the exit from the RNA World. 3.8 Billion years of known Darwinian evolution demonstrates that Darwinian evolution cannot invent central dogma biopolymers. How did an RNA world invent the ribosome in the absence of foresight?
j) Predict homochirality, despite its essential role in the structure and function of biological polymers and pathways.
k) Predict the observed divergence between prebiotic and biochemical routes of monomer and polymer synthesis, which differ fundamentally in mechanism, energetics, and environmental requirements.
In this class we will explore the possibility of genuinely parsimonious models for the origins of life. However, we need to expect that the models will be conceptually demanding, because that’s how science works.