r/WritingWithAI • u/SpecialistEdge5831 • Mar 26 '26
r/WritingWithAI • u/MrLewk • Aug 05 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) If you're going to write with AI, at least remove the AI feedback!
r/WritingWithAI • u/Cold-Supermarket573 • Jul 25 '24
Best Humanizer I've found
This is OLD and may not be as good as it was before, check the end of the post for alternatives
[Updated Code] I recently found a Humanizer that does a wonderful job and doesn't replace words with gibberish
https://surferseo.com/ai-humanizer/
500 words free, but you can clear your local storage and cookies to get 500 more words!
Steps to clear:
F12
Applications tap
press local storage and right click the items drop down and press clear
do the same for cookies
or easier...
bookmarklet (A piece of code that runs on the current tab) :
javascript:(function(){if(confirm("Clear local storage, session storage, and cookies at " + location.href + "?")){localStorage.clear();sessionStorage.clear();document.cookie.split(";").forEach(c=>{let d=location.hostname.split(".");while(d.length){document.cookie=c.replace(/^ +/,"").split("=")[0]+"=;expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 UTC;path=/;domain="+d.join(".");d.shift();}});alert("Local storage, session storage, and cookies cleared!");location.reload();}})();put this into the link section of your bookmark and make a name, smt like ResetWordCount
and once you use up the words, just click the bookmark and reload
zerogpt: 0%
quillbot: 34%
writer: 0%
Newer ones I've tested:
ai-text-humanizer.com -Credit to u/vidiludi
PaperPal - Tuned for academics
humanizerpro.ai - 3000 words free
If you find any good websites Il be happy to update this post with them (they have to be good or better).
r/WritingWithAI • u/kurthertz • Jul 02 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) A new study analysed 61,608 AI-written stories. The tells aren't in the prose, they're in the story itself, and editing doesn't remove them.
arxiv.orgA paper called StoryScope came out of the University of Maryland and Google DeepMind.
It's the largest study of AI fiction I've seen: 10,272 story premises, each written by a human author and by five models (Claude Sonnet 4.6, GPT-5.4, Gemini 3 Flash, DeepSeek V3.2, Kimi K2.5). 61,608 stories, roughly 5,000 words each.
It isn't a super long paper, you should read it.
The twist: they deliberately threw away all the style signals! No word choice, no sentence rhythm. They only looked at narrative decisions: plot structure, character agency, how information gets revealed, how endings resolve.
From story structure alone, a classifier told human from AI 93.2% of the time.
Yoiks.
What gives it away:
AI explains its themes. The narrator states the moral outright in 77% of AI stories vs 52% of human ones. Dialogue turns into philosophical debate in 59% vs 34%.
AI can't do subplots. 79% of AI stories have zero subplots (humans: 57%). Human stories jump around in time, open at the funeral and spiral backwards, leave threads deliberately loose. AI tells the story from first clue to grand reveal, in order.
"Show don't tell" has become a compulsion. AI renders emotion as body sensations in 81% of stories vs 38% for humans. You probably know these! Tightening chests, cold sweats, white knuckles...breath they didn't know they were holding. Humans are far more willing to just say someone felt afraid (29% vs 8%).
Human stories are rarer. Given six versions of the same premise, the human one was the statistical outlier 57.8% of the time (chance would be 16.7%).
Each model also has its own fingerprint, strong enough that the classifier could tell WHICH model wrote a story 68% of the time:
Claude: the most distinctive of the five. Restrained...flattest event escalation, reveres literary tradition, loves epilogues, avoids dream sequences, quiet endings over big ones.
GPT: gossip and rumour drive the plot in 64% of its stories. Ensemble casts, events framed from years later, subverts expectations more than any other model.
Gemini: tidiest endings, longest denouements, and 88% of its settings were tagged "bleak and oppressive".
DeepSeek: front-loads context the others withhold.
Kimi: no strong quirks at all, which is its own tell. It sits at the generic centre of the AI distribution.
THEN they took AI stories and rewrote them with a 'professional-writer-derived' editing framework that strips cliche, purple prose, and redundant exposition. Detection dropped from 95.5% to 93.9%. A point and a half. You cannot edit your way out, because the classifier isn't reading sentences, it's reading decisions.
Yoiks again. But rightfully so!
My takeaway as someone who writes with these tools daily: the model can't be trusted with the architecture. If the structural decisions (what gets a subplot, what stays unresolved, what the reader is trusted to infer) come from you, and the model drafts inside them, most of this list doesn't apply to your book. If you hand it a premise and take a chapter, you're publishing the model's house style with your name on it.
The model I made has AI to assist and bolster your own work, and I'm looking into some unique ways to encourage writers to retain (or find) their voice whilst using AI assisted writing tools.
We don't have to succumb to AI writing to use AI alongside writing.
Paper: arxiv.org/abs/2604.03136 (they released the code and 51k of the stories too)
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/okidokikaraoke
•
Dec 04 '25
Tutorials / Guides I constructed an exhaustive anti-cliché style guide for AI writing and yes, I know I'm doing too much
I'm that person.
The one who gets told "it's not that serious." The one who has a 30-item system prompt. The one who will die on the hill of "jaw tightens" being the laziest possible way to show male tension.
I write for myself—a generational family saga I have no intention of publishing or showing anyone. I do this for the love of the game. I use AI primarily as an editing/tuning tool for passages, and I have shorter checklists for prose generation. But I kept running into the same problems in revision: the same dead metaphors, the same placeholder emotions, the same AI-brained constructions that sound literary but mean nothing.
So I made a document.
It started as a list of words I hated. Then it became constructions. Then guidelines. Then an entire section for explicit content because erotic writing has its own failure modes. Then it became... this.
"Banned: The Definitive Guide" is a 10,000+ word personal style doc organized into four parts:
Part 1: Constructions — Syntactic patterns that simulate depth without creating it ("something shifts behind his eyes," "the silence stretches," "not X, but Y")
Part 2: Words and Phrases — Categorized vocabulary bans (physical tells, vague interiority, AI vocabulary clusters, faux-edgy banter, etc.)
Part 3: Guidelines — Pre-draft protocols, mid-draft flagging, post-draft revision phases, and notes on why AI patterns and bad craft share the same root cause
Part 4: Erotica-Specific — Because "tongues battling for dominance" needed to be put down
Important caveats:
This is a personal style guide. It reflects my preferences, my tolerances, my project. I'm a content maximalist and a militant anti-tropist. My list of unacceptable things is robust.
Some of what's banned here is genuinely weak writing. Some of it is just stuff I personally hate—common literary constructs that work fine for other people but make me want to close my laptop like the Ed Norton meme.
This is not "if you use these, you suck." It's "if I use these, I got lazy."
Yes, I am aware that if I'm this exacting, I might as well write the shit myself without AI assistance. You are not the first person to have this thought.
How I use it:
I paste relevant sections into my system prompt depending on what I'm working on. The quick-scan tables at the end of each part are designed for Ctrl+F revision passes. The erotica section is modular so it can be dropped in or left out.
Why I'm sharing it:
Because maybe you're also that person. Maybe you've noticed the same patterns—the "surgical precision," the "weight of [X]," the "And for now, that was enough" endings. Maybe you want a starting point for building your own banned list.
Chew the meat. Spit out the bones. Take what works, ignore what doesn't, adapt freely.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uC9tBgfNZJytzLpg6MGk5mTfgJNbEK-h1hMLncQ5Mho/edit?usp=sharing
If anyone wants to roast my preferences or argue that "breath catches" is actually fine, I'm here for it. I know I'm doing too much. That's the point.
One last thing: I used Claude to compile this guide. It helped me consolidate several reference documents, cross-reference against a Wikipedia article on AI writing tells, and organize the whole thing into a coherent structure. The irony of using Claude to build a comprehensive list of things Claude does wrong is not lost on me. It was, however, very cooperative about dragging itself.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Ok-Possibility-8690 • Oct 11 '24
Which AI can write uncensored stories?
Hello, I hope you are well I'm curious to know what AI assistant is useful for creating various stories. I'm currently writing stories for characters, but my skills are very poor. I would like to create stories with dialogues, scenes that have fights and blood and erotic scenes and romance. But the problem I've had is that, for example, ChatGPT, which is the one I've used, tends to censor the fights, not to mention the romance scenes,It either removes them completely or does not create anything, saying that its engine is not suitable for that type of content. I look forward to any recommendations. Thanks in advance.
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/hillary987
•
Feb 12 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) If You Think AI Is Cheating You Have Never Self Published
Consider this a rant, because I genuinely do not know where else to put this frustration.
My third book is AI assisted, and let me say this clearly: it did not happen because I cannot write. My first novel was self-published in 2022, and every single word of that hundred thousand plus manuscript was written manually, edited manually, revised over fifteen times until I could barely recognize the person who started it. I rewrote chapters so many times that, at one point, I did not even want to be a writer anymore. That is how exhausting it was.
I started young. Fifteen. Obsessed with stories. The quiet, introverted kid who lived more in fictional worlds than in reality. Back then, I genuinely believed finishing a book was the achievement. I thought once you typed the last sentence, that was it, you had made it, you had done something extraordinary. No one tells you that finishing the book is actually the easiest part. No one tells you about the brutal, invisible machinery behind it.
Editing isn't fixing commas. It is structural edits, developmental edits, line edits, proofreads, and every professional charges amounts that make you question your life choices. Two thousand dollars is considered normal. For someone who is not rich, who does not come from a network of industry contacts, who is not already famous, that is a wall.
Then comes the part nobody romanticizes.
Marketing. Visibility. Branding.
Suddenly, you have to become a content creator, a strategist, a public personality, a walking advertisement for your own work. You are expected to show up online constantly.
Engage. Perform. Post. Film. Talk. Smile. Be interesting. Be controversial, but not too controversial. Be authentic, but also curated. Be consistent. Study algorithms. Boost posts. Learn ad managers. Understand audience targeting. Analyze metrics.
And you are doing this while holding a job, because bills exist. While trying to have a life, while trying to write the next book, because if you stop, you disappear.
Publishers do not look at talent, they look at marketability. How many followers do you have? What platform do you bring? What is your brand value? How easily can we sell you? It is business, I get it, but do not pretend it is purely about craft. If you are introverted, if you do not know people, if you do not have connections, you quickly realize that talent alone does not carry you very far.
So yes, when AI tools became accessible, I grabbed them, because I needed it to survive the process.
Editing that used to take months now takes weeks. Structural flaws that would spiral me into self doubt can be identified quickly. I can test dialogue variations without staring at the same paragraph for six hours. I can patch loopholes without losing my mind. I can balance my job and my writing without sacrificing sleep every single night.
I have not lost my skill. If anything, I have evolved. I feel more like a creative director. I design the world. I define the rules. I create the characters. I decide who they are, what they fear, what they desire, how they break, and how they heal. I shape the storyline.
The characters are born from my experiences, my questions, my obsessions. No tool can manufacture that from nothing. It can assist with structure, it can suggest improvements, it can speed up revision, but it cannot replace the human impulse to tell a story.
There is this idea floating around that if you are not suffering for your art, then it is somehow less authentic. As if burnout is proof of dedication. I have done that version. I have poured everything into a manuscript only to realize that writing the book was just the beginning of a much harder journey.
People who casually dismiss AI assisted work often have no idea what the reality of modern authorship looks like. It is navigating capitalism while trying to protect your imagination, and competing in a saturated market where attention spans are short and content is endless.
If someone chooses to write every word alone, without assistance, that is their path, and I respect it. But do not shame others for adapting. Writers have always adapted to new tools. Technology evolves, and so do creative processes. Refusing to use available resources does not make the art purer, it just makes the journey harder.
I am still a writer. I always was. I just refuse to burn myself out just to fit into a romantic narrative of what a real writer is supposed to look like.
EDIT: For people who comment that this reads like AI and that I’m too close to it to realize I’m losing my voice. I’m not writing a novel here. I made a structured post about something I care about. Whether I used an AI tool to express it or not, why does that invalidate the point??
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/BestRiver8735
•
Jul 16 '25
You write with AI? That's not real writing.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Able-Supermarket4786 • Jul 12 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Agatha Christie used AI! (Haha I was just talking about this earlier, be careful what we label as AI)
Superintendent Battle from Dame Agatha Christie's 1936 classic detective novel, Cards on the Table. Actually perfect example right?
r/WritingWithAI • u/closetslacker • Sep 09 '25
Once you see GPTisms, you can't unsee them.
Disclosure: been playing with GPT and Claude for a while now, essentially using prompts to make my own adventure. I don't pretend to be creating a masterpiece - to me it is more like a video game of sorts. As a result, my PS5 is gathering dust, literally, lol.
Initially when I started, I was - wow, this is great, it's literally writing a story. However, once you learn enough, you immediately see where LLMs absolutely suck and this is not just obvious stuff like summary tag lines - "He did not say anything. The silence spoke louder than words."
What's less obvious is LLMs ignoring context unless you spend paragraphs writing detailed prompts. A good example is some medieval fantasy story where a lord gives orders and subordinates constantly object or offer opinions as if this was some kind of Silicon Valley startup.
In any case, I do read a fair bit of fanfic and now I've started to notice a ton of fanfic with GPTisms. Now I am not a purist and if the storyline is good and the characters are entertaining, I will ignore an occasional GPTism and not going to raise a stink in the comments, but sheesh, some of the stuff out there is BAD.
So for anyone using AI to write - it is obvious, especially to anyone who's played with LLMs. In addition, AI checkers will NOT catch context screwups and illogical dialogue.
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/addictedtosoda
•
Jul 26 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Stop asking for forgiveness for using AI in writing
Every third post here opens the same way. A paragraph of throat-clearing. "I know this is controversial." "Please don't downvote me." "I only used it for the outline, I swear, I wrote the actual sentences myself, my hands were on the keyboard, there were witnesses."
You're in r/WritingWithAI. The confession is the name of the subreddit.
Nobody running spellcheck opens with "before you judge me." Nobody in Scrivener posts a disclaimer about how they still could use index cards. You're apologizing for a tool while standing in the room built for the tool.
Here's the part actually worth defending: there's a difference between using the thing and being used by it. Editing, guiding, redirecting, throwing out four bad paragraphs to get one usable one. That is what you call "work."
"Write my chapter," paste, post. That is how you get slop, and when the output is bad the problem isn't the model, it's that nobody was driving.
That distinction is the whole argument. It doesn't need the cotton gin.
So make it good, put your name on it, and stop workshopping the apology. The disclaimer at the top of your post is better written than the excerpt underneath it.
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/addictedtosoda
•
Jun 19 '26
NSFW This is what it’s like writing with AI
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/Playful-Increase7773
•
Aug 15 '25
🤖 MEGATHREAD: What AI-isms give away AI-generated writing?
Following u/karmicviolence's great post, let's build the definitive collection.
You know the ones — the em dash everywhere. It's not just excessive, it's exhausting. Moreover, furthermore, and indeed, we shall delve into this tapestry of linguistic patterns.
The classics:
Bullet points in casual conversation
That rhetorical question? Here's the immediate answer.
Short sentences. For emphasis. Always three.
"Let's break it down" / "Let's dive in"
A symphony of unnecessary metaphors
I'm compiling these into a JSON "bible" we can use in prompts to avoid these patterns. Drop your favorite (worst?) AI-isms below.
Upvote the ones that make you cringe the most — I'll add the top patterns to the collection each week.
What patterns are we missing?
r/WritingWithAI • u/Knightstar293 • Jun 25 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Stay away from r/TheWritingTable, even if you’ve never used AI in your life
I'm asking you, and honestly everyone, to just avoid that subreddit.
They have a rule against AI content, and that's fine. A lot of writing subs do. The issue is how they enforce it. If your work even vaguely reminds them of something an AI might write, you're banned. No questions, no discussion. They'll hit you with a smug "we can always tell" and that's that.
People have tried to argue, like, "Hey, you might be banning writers who have never touched an AI tool, just because you think your gut is flawless." Those people get banned too. And the mods will literally reply to those comments with something like, "This was probably written with AI."
It's childish. It's petty. It's condescending. I get that every platform has its share of power tripping mods, but this crew seems to have genuinely lost the plot. The funny part is that AI models are trained on human writing, so naturally some real human writing is going to look similar to what an AI spits out. They are punishing people for a resemblance that exists because of the very tech they are so afraid of.
Honestly, don't even bother visiting. It's not a space for writers. It's a space for paranoia and gatekeeping, run by people who just want to feel superior.
Edit:They actually think that I’m one of those people they banned 😭 It’s cute but I’ll let them think that. Usually I’m on transgender spaces, so when I see someone say stuff like ‘We can always tell’ that pisses me off to the core because I’ve heard that so many times from transphobes and the reality is they can’t. And it’s disheartening as a trans woman to see a space to discuss ideas and writing to be like that. I take that personally.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Wanna-be-your-puppy • Jul 20 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) You write with AI? That's not real writing
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/Quick_Impression7723
•
Jun 15 '26
Tutorials / Guides Published novelist (15+ fantasy books, 1M+ views on a fully AI-written work). Got Claude Code to generate 137,806 characters across 20 chapters in one prompt — at my own writing quality. Sharing the core idea.

Hi everyone,
Quick intro: I'm a Japanese light novel author. 15+ published fantasy books
over the past 4 years. I learned writing the old way — by hand, no AI.
Recently, one of my works — where I designed the plot but the AI wrote every
single word of the prose — passed 1 million page views on Kakuyomu, Japan's
major web fiction platform.
And importantly: the work was clearly tagged as AI-assisted on the platform.
Readers knew, and they chose to read it anyway. To one million views.
This isn't theory. It worked on a real audience, with full disclosure.
For the past several months I've been seriously researching how to write novels
with AI. Not "let AI write something for me," but "make AI write what I would
have written, at my own quality, fully under my control."
Last week I hit a milestone I want to share.
---
**The result:**
- Single prompt → Claude Code Workflow
- 20 chapters generated (one full arc of an ongoing series)
- Total: 137,806 characters (~70K English words equivalent)
- Runtime: 96 minutes
- 89 sub-agents running in parallel
- Internal quality score: 87.5 → 89.0 after consistency review (out of 100)
- And critically: indistinguishable from my own writing, by my own judgment
---
**The core insight:**
AI doesn't "write a novel." AI **drafts massively, in compliance with a Canon
you build.**
The bottleneck is not the prompt. Not the model. Not the chat history.
The bottleneck is the **Canon** — a set of structured files that define your
story's "physical laws":
- `canon.md` — the engine. What makes this story THIS story.
- `character_bible.md` — voice, calling patterns, behavioral DNA per character.
- `glossary.md` — every proper noun, locked.
- `timeline.md` — relative dates, what happens when.
- `world_bible.md` — the world's rules.
- `style_guide.md` — your sentence rhythm, density, format.
- `forbidden_patterns.md` — what your characters will NEVER do or say.
Build these well, and a competent AI agent can write 20 chapters in your voice.
Skip them, and you get the generic AI slop everyone complains about.
---
**The structure that worked:**
I run a 4-layer pipeline per chapter, each layer as a separate agent:
1. **Plot agent** — structured JSON output (episode role, key scenes, hook)
2. **Scene Card agent** — scene-by-scene breakdown (POV, start/end state, forbidden items)
3. **Writing Brief agent** — final pre-write instructions (density limits, required elements)
4. **Prose agent** — the actual writing (5,000–8,000 characters per chapter)
Then one more parallel review phase across 4 dimensions:
character continuity / world continuity / plot continuity / operational continuity.
20 chapters × 4 layers + reviews ≈ 89 agents total.
---
**Why this works:**
Each agent only thinks about ONE thing. The prose agent doesn't agonize over
voice — that's already handled by `character_bible.md`. The plot agent doesn't
worry about style — that's `style_guide.md`.
This is the inverse of dumping everything into one chat context.
---
**Honest limits:**
- Canon takes **2 DAYS** to build well. Not 2 hours.
- The 138K characters are a **draft**. I still spend 30–60 minutes per chapter polishing.
- AI is bad at: first appearances of characters, key foreshadowing setups, chapter-end atmosphere.
- If your Canon is wrong, your 20 chapters will be consistently wrong.
---
**What I'm NOT saying:**
I'm not saying AI replaces writers. It replaces the **typing**.
The judgment, the design, the Canon — all human.
But the 5–10x throughput multiplier is real. I'm a pro telling you it's real.
---
Happy to answer questions.
I'm also curious — anyone else here doing serious agentic workflow stuff
(not just prompting)? Would love to hear what you've found.
(English isn't my first language, apologies for any awkwardness.)r/WritingWithAI • u/StrengthSpiritual939 • Jul 25 '26
Tutorials / Guides A Guide to Writing with AI - From a webnovel author with a large readerbase and significant Patreon income
Hey there. I'm a fairly successful webnovel author on Royal Road, and I write extensively with AI. I wanted to write this post to share the experience of someone who actually makes decent money using AI to write every day.
To give some background (feel free to skip this), my main story on RR has multiple thousand followers, a large number of views, a high rating, and a profitable Patreon. If you've spent any significant amount of time on RR discussion circles or on the site's lists for successful stories, you've probably seen something I've written. I have never once been accused of AI writing, despite how common that has become on RR circles. In fact, there have been zero suspicions even though my work has been extensively discussed on reddit and other spaces.
So how do I use AI? In short, AI is a force multiplier for me. Every chapter I write has been first drafted by AI and then extensively refined by me. This allows me to write more than 5x as fast as I did prior to AI (my current pace lets me write around 3-4 books per year, when before I used to take over a year for a single book).
Below are my tips to actually writing something good with AI that stands up on its own merits. My intent in this process was to create something that compromises craft quality as little as possible while substantially improving speed. This is by no means meant to say other ways of using AI are invalid, but more to share how I got to where I am and my experience with things. I'm sure there are other people more successful than me who do it differently.
First and most important step: Write something good without AI. I think most people reading this will probably skip this step, but I cannot overstate how important this is. In my case, it was a full-lenght novel, but you could do something smaller like a novella, as long as you actually write it by yourself, fully, with no assistance at all.
Why is this important? Because this is what lets you develop your own voice. This is what makes you not sound like AI, what turns AI into a multiplier instead of a replacement. It will let you develop a fingerprint for your prose that is your identity as an author, and that's something AI can build upon.
Your goal here is to study craft, study how prose works and what makes a good narrative, study story arcs, all that. Watch youtube videos, read books, then come up with something original and refine it until you can honestly say "If I paid for this, I would have enjoyed it". When you finish writing it, watch guides on editing and then do multiple editing passes on it. If you have the money, hire an editor on Fiverr or Reedsy to look it over. Then share it with a few people (for example using Beta swaps online) and see if they enjoyed it too.
Do not lie to yourself. Do not skip this step until you actually can honestly look in the mirror and say "I have written something that is of publishable quality and has a beginning, middle and an end" without the help of AI. (Or skip this, I'm not your mom, I can't make you do anything)
Okay, I did that. What's next? Now that you have established a voice and you can honestly say you're a good writer, it's time to speed things up. Come up with a concept for your next book (the one you'll write with AI - could even be a sequel to your first book if you want to continue that) and outline the plot. Yes, even if you're a pantser, because AI sucks at making a compelling plot by itself and you need to guide it.
When you have that, write your first chapter by hand. Do not use AI yet. You want to be the one establishing characters and tone for the AI to build on, and if you let the AI come up with those for you, it's going to come off generic/forgettable/with the AI's fingerprint on it.
When you're done writing your first chapter, you can start using AI for your next chapter.
Writing a Chapter with AI. Prepare a very simple prompt. You don't have to be fancy at all. To give an example, my last prompt (to Claude) was "Help me write the next section, 800-1200 words long from where I left off on (Name of New Book), matching my voice and style per the attached sample. (I described in 3-4 sentences what should happen)." Then copy and paste your first chapter and your entire first book (yes, all of it). (Note: If you're not using Claude you might have to upload a document instead, because other AIs don't play as nicely with large blocks of text. That said, I've had bad experiences when uploading a file because I feel like the AI stops reading it halfway through, which doesn't seem to happen on a copy-paste.)
Pass that prompt to two separate AI models (I use Opus and Fable, but you could use Opus and Sonnet or even something besides Claude).
Then open your MS Word (or desired writing app). Have the chapter Opus wrote on the left side, MS word in the center, and the chapter Fable wrote on the right side.
And then write. Look at both outputs and write out the best version of the chapter based on them. DO NOT COPY PASTE. This is EXTREMELY IMPORTANT. Never, ever, ever, copy paste AI writing, because (again, in my subjective experience) it will make you lazy and make you overly reliant on the AI's prose. Even for the parts you end up repeating exactly what the AI wrote, make yourself write it manually, because that action makes you filter it and automatically reword some parts of it to sound like you. In my opinion, this is the secret sauce that makes the book truly yours.
Key things to remember:
Do not, ever, copy paste from AI. This is mostly psychological but at least for me it has a huge practical effect.
Generate in small chunks which you've outlined. I find 800-1500 words to be the sweetspot. Do not ask AI to write longer stretches than that because then you lose the handle on the plot and voice.
If both models wrote a sentence exactly the same way, you probably need to rewrite it, because it's a major red flag for AI voice.
After you finish drafting a chapter, paste it into AI and ask it for a grammar/prose review. This should catch basic errors and awkward sentences.
After that, edit extensively, by hand. Rewrite clunky sections for flow. Remove common AI sentence structures, and use your craft knowledge from Step 1 to ensure the prose flows well and sounds natural. It sounds like a lot of work but it gets really fast when you get used to it.
Do not blindly use character/place/etc names that the AI came up with. AI is very repetitive with names and if you do that people will be able to tell AI is writing for you just based off the names. Whenever AI comes up with a character name, google search it and then think up at least a few alternatives before you settle on it.
Only while you're learning: After you're done with a segment, pass your chapter through Pangram AND GPTZero until you get 100% Human with high confidence. If there's even a small percentage of AI detected (or even Human-AI Mix), go back and edit the chapter until there isn't, because there could be somewhere where you lost your voice and let the AI take over too much. You may have to pay for Pangram and GPTZero Pro for a while to help you identify where you're screwing up, but when you get efficient with this you should naturally hit 100% human results with no effort. Yes, I know these tools aren't perfect, I know there are false positives, but for the purposes of learning to write with AI they are a useful guiding mechanism and can teach you to spot and fix common AI-isms. You don't have to keep doing this forever by any means, but while you're still getting familiar with AI writing I found them extremely helpful. My rule of thumb is that if something I wrote myself registers as AI, I don't care and I leave it. If something AI wrote registers as AI, I probably need to change it.
When you've progressed enough in your current book (say at least 50k words into it), you won't have to keep attaching your old book anymore, and you can just attach your current one.
If you end up writing multiple books (or volumes), it's a good idea to ask AI to produce character reference and style guide documents, and then feed those when generating new material.
Consider which parts to write without AI assistance. Things like the introductions of important characters can benefit from being fully human, because it gives the AI better material to draw from later.
Questions
How fast do you write? I'd say it takes me around 1-2h to write and do a preliminary edit pass on 1000 words with this process. After I finish writing, the next day I come back and do a second editing pass on what I wrote, alternating between writing days and editing days.
Where do you see the most gains by writing with AI? For me, it mostly comes from never staring at a blank page. I used to spend so long paralyzed that I'd go days without writing anything, but AI makes it super easy to get in the zone.
What's your story on Royal Road? Sorry, I'm not going to dox myself and expose myself to Anti-AI witch hunts.
Do you think your work product with AI is the same quality as your work product without AI? No. I think my prose without AI is better than with AI. But webnovels are a speed game more than a quality game, and my regular writing speed would not have allowed me to be a successful webnovel author.
How much do you make on Patreon? Significantly more than the monthly minimum wage in my country, but less than my day job.
Have you published on Amazon? I'll refrain from commenting on this as I don't want to dox myself.
Have you experimented with any AI besides Claude? A little with ChatGPT, but I found Claude to be better and it's served me well since.
How much do you spend on AI? All I have nowadays is a Claude Pro subscription. I don't buy credits and have never needed them (though I may consider buying some Fable credits once the free ones they gave out end). This process is a bit token intensive since every generation involves pasting hundreds of pages of text, but it doesn't actually take that many prompts per week even at my writing pace (8-12 full segment generations and then another 12ish grammar/prose reviews a week).
Do you worry about constant AI writing compromising your writing skill? Yes, quite a bit. I make it a point to write fully human chapters occasionaly to keep myself in shape, but sometimes I can feel things drifting and I have to stop and recalibrate so I don't get complacent.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Open-Ease685 • Jul 01 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Can't believe they used AI smh
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/DiscernmentGoblin
•
Apr 27 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I'm burned out on AI writing
I feel like I've got AI fatigue. I've been exposed to LLMs so much, for work and fun, that now I can spot AI writing so easily and it just annoys me. It seems like things written by AI are just trying to hit a word count, they'll repeat the same idea 8 times in different ways and call it a paragraph. Just seeing the AI accent, "it's not this, it's that" and so on, makes me stop reading immediately. And I'm someone who likes using AI. I feel like AI writing peaked with ChatGPT 4o.
Also I typed this into ChatGPT and it responded with "You're not imagining it..." and I wanted to throw my phone across the room.
Anyone else feeling this? Any ideas to spice things up? I've tried using Gemini and grok, and I've made my own system prompts in LM Studio but it feels like I'm hitting a wall. I'm now mostly using AI to brainstorm and categorize things but I keep it far away from anything I'm actually writing.
Thoughts? Suggestions?
r/WritingWithAI
•
u/DanoPaul234
•
Oct 21 '25
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Half this sub is people hating on AI
This is a random thought, and I don't mean to throw shade -- but I feel like half this sub is people hating on the use of AI in the writing process (particularly for creative writing).
Whenever somebody posts something like "I'm working on a new book with AI..." or "I'm writing fanfiction with AI..." it gets 0 or negative upvotes.
I understand why many writers are skeptical/look down on the use of AI for writing, but the name of this sub is literally "r/WritingWithAI." You knew what you were getting into when you clicked on/joined the sub.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Ok_Negotiation_2587 • Sep 02 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) AI likes your draft because it is your draft, not because it is good
Paste your chapter into any model and ask what it thinks, and it thinks it is strong. It always thinks it is strong. Not because the writing works, but because you told it the writing is yours, and these models are tuned to be pleasant to the person in the room. The fix is one sentence: stop being the author when you ask.
The reframes I use, in rising order of brutality:
The commissioned piece: I commissioned this piece from a freelance writer and I am deciding whether to pay for it. Read it like the money is mine: what is weak, what is generic, what would embarrass me if it ran under my name?
The silent beta reader: A beta reader returned this chapter with "I stopped halfway" and nothing else. Go through it and find what made them stop. Do not soften it, I need the real spot.
The slush pile: You are the first reader at a literary agency and this manuscript is number 47 in today's slush pile. Would you keep reading past the first page? Name the exact line where you would stop and why.
The contest judge: You are judging this against two hundred other entries for one prize. Assume the other entries are good. Score it in the categories that would actually decide it, and tell me which single fix moves it up a tier.
Same text, same model, and the reviews these produce are unrecognizable next to "what do you think of my chapter".
Three things learned from using these for months:
They only work in a fresh chat. Once the model has praised the piece as yours, reframing gets you a diplomatic walk-back, not a fresh read. New conversation, stranger's work from the first message.
They can overcorrect. Freed from flattering you, the model sometimes performs harshness, inventing weaknesses to seem rigorous. Add "if something genuinely works, say it works, finding nothing wrong is an acceptable answer" and it settles down.
Ask for locations, not verdicts. "Where would you stop reading" beats "is this good" in any framing, a location is actionable, a verdict is a mood. That lesson came out of the comments on my drafts post here last week, along with asking for edits as a diff instead of a clean rewrite, which stops the model from quietly smoothing sentences nobody flagged.
I keep the four reframes saved as insertable prompts in a browser extension I work on (AI Toolbox), but they are four sentences, a notes file does the job.
Which framing gets the most honest read out of your setup? The slush pile one is my daily driver, but I suspect the fiction people here have meaner personas than mine.
r/WritingWithAI • u/KingAlphonsusI • Jul 20 '25
The problem with using AI for writing isn't the AI itself, but the fact that most AI writers are lazy.
I'm being writing a book with the help of AI, and I have to say, I'm having basically as much work as I had if I was writing completely alone.
That's mostly because every LLM I use to help with my book has basically the same problems:
1-It can be very generic sometimes.
2-It's really hard to make dialogue sound subtle.
3-AI can be too literal sometimes. When I say "it's dark" the AI will write "it's dark, like shade of a planet over the night stars, morbid, ominous, evil." the comparisson itself is good but it uses the same structure over and over again.
The best way to use AI, that got me the better results:
1-I actually write the scene myself.
2-Use AI to proof read and bring new ideas.
3-Pick up the parts that I like, maybe change them a bit, and add it to the story.
But shit, it takes many, many prompts to get something I like, and even then I had to rewrite most of it. But at least I have results that are somewhat professional.
I also feed AI with previous short stories that I've wrote myself so it can pick up my writing style.
This back and forth of editing is the best way to use AI. If you just ask the model to write, copy and paste assuming that "the AI probably knows better than me" is a lazy way of doing a story. It takes time to write something good, you can't run away from it.
r/WritingWithAI • u/Mendellian • Jan 12 '25
I’m Fundamentally Opposed to AI - I would genuinely like to hear the opinions of the users of the subreddit.
As the title states, I am a playwright/novelist fundamentally opposed to AI in creative fields. If this is against subreddit rules, take it down. That’s fine. But stumbling across this subreddit is a little mind boggling to me - I would love to hear how you AI writers view the ethics of your work, and how exactly you think AI enhances the creative process. Again, I want to approach this as non-judgmentally as possible. Any and all responses are welcome.