r/WritingWithAI • • Aug 24 '26 Bravo

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I use AI. Get over it

0 Upvotes

I want to share my views on AI for whatever it's worth.

Im AI skeptic, I work as a lawyer who defends lawyers, and were seeing our fair share of hallucinating AI cases. This stuff is dangerous, it can get you in trouble

Im also an aspiring writer, someone who's had the same story rattling around in the brain for more than fifteen years. A post apocalyptic turned fantasy works, where tech and religion have morphed into the same thing. A story that gives a satisfying resolution to a complex world and mystery. I've world builders to oblivion, started over 6 or 7 times. But this time, with AI I am actually getting somewhere. I'm 23 chapters in with a complete outline and moving into the final act. I am writing something im genuinely enjoying working on, and I did it by feeding AI alot of my raw ideas and old drafts and letting it develop with me the best of those ideas into an actual story with characters and a plot.

I use AI for a lot. Mainly a sounding board, or to remember midnight ideas and tell me later if they make any sense. I use it to draft prose, it's garbage, but it's a jumping off point and mess scary than a blank page. But, importantly I use it as an assistant that I'm responsible for. As a lawyer or professional should use it. Think of it as an amazingly advanced spell checker. At the end of the day, you are putting your name on it. Standing by it as your own. Once you do that, AI prose is no different than a ghost writer, or an editor, or having an assistant. You sign it, you are responsible for it. That should be enough for any serious artist or author.

With that in mind. Here is a Claude generated descriptor of my novel. Yes I used AI. Get over it. I'm having fun :)

Starfall Herald is a standalone science-fiction novel with post-apocalyptic bones, set a few centuries after a catastrophe that tore the sky open and ended the world people knew. The story unfolds across a ruined mega city, where the survivors have built something new out of the wreckage of something they no longer understand.

Its central idea is that advanced technology, given enough time and enough forgetting, becomes religion. The people who now rule the ruins treat the relics of the old world as holy objects and its warnings as scripture, without any memory of what the machines actually were or did. Into that world comes someone who remembers, because she was there when it broke, which makes her either a heretic or a prophet depending on who is doing the looking.

It follows three characters whose paths cross without any of them seeing the whole board: an engineer out of her depth in a world that has mythologised her own work, a smuggler trying to stay in the gap between the man he used to be and the one he is now, and a city administrator making impossible compromises to keep his people alive. It is about faith and knowledge, about what gets lost when a civilisation falls and what gets invented to fill the hole, and about the cost of the choices people make when survival is on the table.

Tonally it sits somewhere between grounded post-collapse survival and the bigger questions of who gets to define the truth. Think ruined subway tunnels and salvaged tech, priesthoods and resistance cells, and a mystery at the centre that the reader gets to assemble a piece at a time.


r/WritingWithAI • • May 27 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Who Produced This AI Slop?

0 Upvotes

Sorry for taking up space, but, after watching a ton of YouTube videos about "Don't use AI to write stories" I just had to write this...

Let's start with a calculator. You punch in 847 × 293 and get 248,171. Quick question: who did that math? You, or the calculator?

  • Now picture a typewriter. You sit down, hammer out a letter, and pull the page out of the roller. Who wrote those words? You, or the typewriter?

  • Open a Word document. You type out a report and the grammar checker quietly fixes your comma splices and flags a passive sentence. Who authored that document? You, or Microsoft?

  • Now use ChatGPT to draft a short story. You feed it your idea, your characters, your direction, and out comes a draft. Who created that story? You, or the AI?

People are so consumed with detecting whether AI touched a piece of text that they've lost the plot.

If a human initiates the work, the result belongs to that human.

Full stop.

The whole debate about AI not being able to hold a copyright is ridiculous on its face. It's always the human who should hold the copyright, because the human is the one responsible.

Imagine sending a threatening email to the President and then telling the Secret Service, "Oh, my chatbot wrote that and sent it on its own." Let me know how that defense works out for you. I'll wait.

The reason I actually care about this is that the punchline of all this hand-wringing is, "Don't use AI." That's absurd. It's the same energy as telling early writers not to use typewriters, or telling accountants not to use calculators, or telling everyone in 1995 not to spell-check their documents because it's somehow cheating.

So did I use AI to write this blog post? Of course I did. I wrote down hundreds of words first — the ideas, the examples, the argument, the attitude. Then I had AI clean up my half-finished sentences and organize the whole thing into something coherent. Then I told it to cut the fat so the piece moved fast and didn't bore anyone.

I produced this. The AI just helped me type it.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jul 23 '25

AI is for Lazy writers

0 Upvotes

I have seen so many comments and posts about calling us lazy when we are using AI to write. What's the purpose of joining this sub? ''If you use AI, you're not a real writer.'' Cool. I am not going to feel guilty for using tech to write better or faster. Using AI to write is our choice. We chose to use AI not to cheat but to create. Call us lazy, you want, but we were out here creating. It's our process, our story, our choice. Everyone creates differently and that's okay.


r/WritingWithAI • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Where is all this AI-gen hate actually coming from?

0 Upvotes

At this point, it really can't just be about slop. Traditional content is drowning in slop. It can't just be about stolen training data. Traditional art has centuries of uncompensated inspiration, reference, and outright copying Tainted into its canon.

So what is it? Commercial entrenchment guised as ethics. The harassment, the "AI user = ban" rules with zero nuance, the downvote brigades in a sub literally called WritingWithAI. That's not really evangelism on behalf of original artists. That's a tribe protecting its border.

Also There's an argument nobody properly interrogates: "AI consumed human art as training data and that's theft." Every artist alive spent years, decades, consuming other artists' work. Reading, watching, listening, absorbing. That consumption shaped their style, their voice, their instincts. At some point they started producing work that carries most if not all of that influence. How is that meaningfully different from a model trained on datasets producing work after going public? I'm not saying they're identical. I'm saying nobody wants to seriously answer the question. Because if you do, the "theft" argument gets complicated really fast.

The context argument is where it really falls apart. Say a creator builds a 300k-word knowledge base of their raw ideas, full universe rules, worldbuilding, lore, characters, technology. Every word of it theirs. They use AI to render that into a series. They edit the output. They make the final calls.

Does that context ever get considered in this debate?

No. Because "did you use AI for anything" is the only question, and the answer determines your status regardless of how, why, or how much. That's not a standard. That's a witch test. To sanction a witch hunt.

The advice to "just do it yourself — even a title, a nice font, good colors tells us a lot" sounds humble. It isn't. Audiences don't reward you for the art that expresses you. They reward you for the art that serves them — precisely, consistently, on demand. The entire production process exists to execute that. Telling a creator to strip it all back is advice from an adversary wearing humility as a mask.

Last thing. Readers want unchallenged authority about what counts as "real" art. But that authority has never been stable. Cave paintings are stick figures. Ancient Egyptian murals are flat 2D vectors. A significant portion of historical artifacts aren't technically impressive by modern standards — and we worship them. You can't say that honestly without someone splitting on you even if they privately agree. They're treated as sacred.

I respect them. I think they should be preserved — they're a record of where human creative expression started. But the reverence is the point. We decide what counts as art after it becomes culturally legible, not before. That process is happening right now with AI. The people swinging hardest are the ones who already decided — and don't want the verdict revisited.

This was never about slop. It was never about stolen data. It's about who gets to make things, and who decides.


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 05 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) The unspoken logic of the Anti-AI argument

0 Upvotes

The anti-AI position on art has a logical endpoint that is rarely discussed. When critics argue that using AI to generate images or music is "cheating," they are making a claim about legitimacy. They are saying that true art requires human execution. But if you follow that logic, you arrive at an uncomfortable conclusion.

The only difference between hiring a human artist and using an AI tool is money. Both approaches involve direction. Both involve vision. Both involve curation. The only thing that changes is the cost. When you hire a human artist, you pay for their time and skill. When you use AI, you pay for tokens and compute. The role of the director remains the same. The vision remains the same. The only difference is the price tag.

If hiring a human artist makes you a legitimate creator, but using AI does not, then legitimacy is not about vision or direction. It is about money. It is about whether you can afford to pay for traditional execution. That means creativity becomes a luxury. It becomes something available only to those who have the budget to outsource. The rest of us are told to stay in our lane.

This is not an argument about art. It is an argument about class. It is a defense of a system where creative direction belongs to those who can pay for it. And it is dressed up as a defense of craft. But craft is not the issue. The issue is access. And access is what the anti-AI crowd is really trying to protect.

They do not say this out loud. They say they are protecting artists. But the effect is the same. They are protecting a system where only the wealthy can afford to be directors. And that is not a moral position. It is a class position. And it is one that deserves to be named.


r/WritingWithAI • • Feb 24 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Unpopular Opinion: The publishing world's hostility towards AI makes no sense when you look at literally every other industry.

0 Upvotes

There’s a massive amount of hostility toward AI in the writing and publishing communities right now, but honestly, it feels like a massive double standard. We seem to be completely losing the plot on what actually matters to the end consumer.

Think about the conveniences we enjoy every single day. We embrace modern communication technology and the energy revolution, both of which are prime examples of new tools completely replacing the "old ways."

Look at the food industry. When we buy groceries or eat a meal, our primary concerns are: Is this healthy? Is it environmentally sustainable? Can more people afford to eat it at a lower price? We don’t put our dinner on trial to figure out if it was 100% handcrafted by a human artisan or produced through machine automation. If the food is safe, nutritious, and affordable, we call it progress.

So why is publishing treating books like some sacred exception?

If AI tools lower the production costs and the barrier to entry, that theoretically translates to more content, faster output, and lower prices for readers. If a novel has mind-bending worldbuilding, a great plot, and keeps me hooked, I really don't care if the author used an LLM to generate parts of it or streamline their workflow.

As a consumer, I am paying for an engaging experience at a fair price. The romantic idea of the "tortured human artist" shouldn't override the actual quality and accessibility of the final product.

Why are we judging the tools used rather than the result? If the quality is high and the cost is lower, does the "human purity" of the text really matter that much?

Would love to hear why people think text should be the exception to the rule of technological progress.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jul 04 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I just realized I'm not a writer who learned to tell stories. I'm a storyteller who finally found a way to write.

23 Upvotes

For the last few weeks I've been trying to write a memoir with AI (chatgbt).

At first I was doing what I think a lot of people do: I'd tell the AI what I wanted to say, it would rewrite it into polished prose, and then I'd edit the result.

The problem was that the more polished it became, the less it sounded like me.

Then something clicked.

I realized I don't write to discover. I discover by talking. The writing comes afterward.

That made me realize I'd actually been preparing to write this memoir for decades without knowing it.

I've told these stories hundreds of times—to friends, in therapy, at parties, to anyone who would listen. Every time I told one, it evolved a little. The setup got cleaner. The timing changed. The reveal moved. A joke landed differently. I wasn't consciously editing. I was just telling the stories over and over until they naturally became better.

So I wasn't starting from a blank page.

I was starting from decades of oral storytelling.

The biggest breakthrough came when I stopped asking AI to rewrite my stories and started using it as an interviewer instead.

Now it asks me questions like a documentary filmmaker. I answer however my mind naturally wanders. One memory leads to another. One story uncovers three more.

Instead of rewriting everything into polished prose, we do the lightest edit possible—mostly punctuation, readability, and trimming obvious repetition while preserving my voice.

Any reflection or framing happens separately in short narration paragraphs instead of inside the stories themselves.

The stories stay conversations.

The narration provides the structure.

That feels dramatically more authentic.

It also made me realize something else.

My medium isn't writing. My medium is conversation.

Writing is just the artifact that comes afterward.

For me, AI didn't invent a new way of writing. It finally gave me a way to translate the way I've already been processing my life for decades.

Has anyone else discovered that they don't think on the page—they think out loud? Have you found that AI works better when it adapts to your natural creative process instead of trying to replace it?

TL;DR: I discovered I don't write to discover—I discover by talking. AI works much better for me as an interviewer and transcript editor than as a ghostwriter. Has anyone else found that their best writing process starts with conversation instead of the blank page?


r/WritingWithAI • • Oct 04 '26

Showcase / Feedback Claude has a f*cked up sense of humor

0 Upvotes

Background: I'm writing a novel that involves a scene in which a young woman dies from a self-induced abortion using a knitting needle.

Today, overthinking things as usual, I started a fact-finding convo about how film and merch rights are negotiated.

Me: I want a piece of every lunchbox and the inevitable action figure line.

Claude: Noted. The Knitting Needle playset with realistic blood-red fabric sheets has a clear market.

Me: Bad bot! Bad bot!


r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 13 '25

Is it okay if my story is written with AI but the concept is 100% mine?

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m a creator and I’ve been working on an original story idea the characters, world, and plot are all mine. But instead of writing it line-by-line myself, I’ve been using AI to help put my thoughts into words and make the prose stronger.

The result feels like my story just written faster and sometimes better than if I had struggled alone.

Now I’m thinking about turning this into a collaborative project (maybe with artists, editors, or even other writers), but I have this question:

Is it “wrong” or less authentic if the story is AI-written but fully my concept?

Would you collaborate on a project like this if the creator was open about using AI in the process?

Do you think AI-assisted stories still count as original work?

Curious to hear what other creators think especially anyone who has done AI-human collaborations before.


r/WritingWithAI • • May 04 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Various types of slop 😂

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • Aug 28 '25

I'm a CTO who just wrote and illustrated children's book. What technical questions do you have about AI and writing and art?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I've been an engineer for my entire career, working deeply with large datasets, machine learning systems, and now modern AI. What deep technical questions do you have about using AI for writing, how it works, or the future of the technology? I'll answer here and then do a writeup where I go into more depth.


I recently wrote and illustrated a children’s book for my son, Bodhi ❤️📖🤖

This began as a week of experimentation "just to play with AI". But once engaged, the project expanded into months of focused creative expression. I rediscovered how much I enjoy writing, design, and layout, skills I haven’t exercised this deeply since my high school newspaper days.

Something unexpected happened: I found myself in a deep flow with AI as my writing and illustrating partner (vibe writing?). With LLMs and diffusion models as collaborators, the process was elevated. I had: • a partner for ideation and exploration • an assistant for the difficult and tedious steps • an illustrator that could quickly mock up new ideas • an editor that brought structure, coherence, and a deep knowledge of publishing

The tools didn’t replace me; they amplified me. I thought I'd be embarrassed I used AI, but I'm not. I loved it. I feel like we truly produced this together. The whole experience was deeply creative, fulfilling, and delightful.

The result is something tangible and personal; a book my son can hold in his hands. I’m very proud of it. I didn't expect that either. I'm stoked!

🧠💡 What I learned? This project gave me a practical perspective on how modern AI functions as a utility for creative work. Beyond the inflated expectations, I experienced its real technical capabilities and limitations from the eyes of a creator, and not just a technologist. This was an important goal for me. Language is arguably the original technology. I now see more clearly how these systems will influence media, art, and startups in the years ahead.

🚀🔮 What’s next? I plan to publish a few short reflections on: • How I used LLMs and diffusion models to write and illustrate a book. • How I believe this technology will inspire new technologies and reshape creative industries.

👉 What specific questions do you want me to explore? I’d love to incorporate them.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jun 27 '25

The Big Mistakes the AI Haters Make

Post image
0 Upvotes

I see this mistake from writers all the time, trying to prove that AI is "Slop". They'll ask it to rewrite their work and make it better or more creative, which often leads to stuff like this: 

"The scent of burnt toast, a tiny apocalypse in the kitchen, always signaled the start of another impossibly ordinary Tuesday."

They'll hem and haw about how it's too flowery or sterile. But what's funny is that as a filmmaker, I see this ALL THE TIME with writers directing their first movie. They know everything about writing, but nothing about directing or cinematography.

So when they coordinate with a DP to set up a shot for evoking fear, they won't go into any great or meaningful detail about what they mean by scary and will generally defer to the DP's expertise. BIG MISTAKE. They will make it scary, but they won't make it meaningfully scary to the story. They won't use any kind of motivating shots or symbolic lighting. They'll just set it up conventionally because they can't know what's inside your head unless you spell it out for them to execute.

It's very similar to AI. If you know what you're doing and know exactly what you want and how you want it, you can easily use AI effectively. Otherwise, it'll be trash. And I suspect most writers fail to understand this because they let their fears and concerns get in the way of understanding what is required: extreme thoughtfulness, focus, and critical thinking skills.

Huh...Sounds a lot like what a director does when working with other experts. If writing were simply about the physical act of stringing words together, everyone would be Mark Twain. But writing stories requires so, so much more than just that. You have to understand how to construct and append vast informational matrices that can express coherence in a way that meaningfully connects to your audience. And that requires a deep understanding of many different subjects and skillsets, which is why most writers fail.

So don't be like the Holy Roman Empire. Understand and learn how to use it, not how to ban it. Openness and curiosity are what move the World forward, not oppression stemming from fear. There's a lot to be fearful of, even with AI. I won't pretend otherwise. But allowing yourself to be captured by it...Well, that's what will manifest our worst nightmares.

Also, I added a cute puppy typing on a computer. Why? Because it's awesome.


r/WritingWithAI • • Nov 22 '25

Gemini has changed the "write with AI" picture forever!

0 Upvotes

 Up until last week, I was using Gemini mostly as a researcher: a factual, investigative journalist, an intelligence much like the librarian in Slow Horses (though much more willing to share information without being grumpy about it).

Then, on November 18th, Google released Gemini 3. And everything changed.

Here is how huge this is: I was planning on launching my AI Writer’s Studio “Idea to Screen™” course this week—just in time for the "Black Friday" rush.

I stopped the launch.

I am taking the next few days to rewrite the entire system because I need to place Gemini on equal footing with Claude and ChatGPT. Gemini and its studious sibling, NotebookLM, have become such an essential part of how writers can construct a Virtual Writers’ Room that I couldn't release the course without capturing this new reality.

Here are the Four Massive Updates that forced me to rewrite the playbook:

1. It Holds Your Entire Project (EVERY Change and Note) in "Memory"

In the Idea to Screen™ system, the first thing I teach is how to train LLMs to do the specific jobs we need. Previously, this was a juggling act of file limits.

But the new Gemini 3 features a 1-million+ token context window. In plain English? It can hold my "Who I Am" profile, my project document, our “Contract” for how we’ll work together, my outlines, my full script, AND the dozens of changes I’ve made along the way in its active memory simultaneously. It doesn't "forget" Scene 1 when we are working on A new draft of the end of act two. 

It successfully pulled the old F. Scott Fitzgerald trick: holding two conflicting thoughts in its head at the same time without crashing.

2. The Perfect "Left Brain / Right Brain" Split

I finally realized how these tools fit together.

  • Gemini is your Creative Producer. It is bossy. It holds the schedule. It knows who I am. It points out exactly what I need to do today to fulfill my goals.

  • NotebookLM is your Story Editor. It can read 500 pages of research in seconds, tell me exactly what is in my files, and is laser-focused on the text itself.

Combined, they can literally "take you aside" and tell you that you are not writing the movie you said you wanted to write. (I had a mind-blowing exchange about this that I’ll post later this week.)

3. It acts as a "No-Nonsense" Story Coach

My system helps students test their ideas against the "Big 4" story structures (McKee, Snyder, Campbell, and Dramatica).

I ran Gemini through the paces, and it is incredible at applying these frameworks. It didn't just offer generic advice; it acted like a seasoned story editor. Using the Dramatica framework, it pointed out that in the first 15 pages of my script, I had a missed opportunity: a passive side character named Edgar.

Gemini suggested: "What if Edgar wasn't just jealous? What if he was the active 'Voice of Authenticity' challenging your protagonist's delusion?"

In a few quick exchanges, we rethought those opening scenes and elevated a throwaway character into the moral center of the film. But here is the key: At one point, Gemini tried to write the scene for me. I had to point to our "How We Work Together" contract and say: "No. You suggest. I write."

It apologized, corrected course, and gave me options instead of prose. That is the partnership I want.

(Note: While these story structures are built into the AI's training data, I always remind students: BUY THE BOOKS. It’s the least we can do for the master teachers who gave us these frameworks.)

4. Instant Visualization with "Google Flow"

This might be the wildest update. Included in the new model is Google Flow (powered by their cinema-grade Veo model). You can take a text description of your scene and generate a high-definition video render instantly.

Now, some writers worry this gets in the way of imagination. I disagree. It is the ultimate "Pacing Check."

If you feed your scene description into Flow and the resulting video is boring? Your scene is probably boring. It allows you to direct the visual flow of your movie before you even type "FADE IN." Plus, for the final module of my class, students can now generate a "Sizzle Reel" for their pitch decks without needing a film crew.

So, What Now?

If you're not asking Gemini to learn who you are and what you're working on, if. you're not asking it to analyze your work, you're missing a GREAT partner.


r/WritingWithAI • • Nov 05 '25

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) AI doesn't erase an author's voice

0 Upvotes

So, I've done a lot of reading of authors on this sub (check out the blurb post if you haven't). I've read about shipwrecked sailors, early Victorian serial killers, sweet interactive fantasy romance, badass Amazon warriors, my first taste of werewolf fanfiction, as well as original werewolf fiction, and more.

I can say, unequivocally, that AI does not remove an author's voice. Every single one of the stories I've dived into has sounded different, had a different style, and emphasized different things. The human touch on these stories is absolutely evident. It's not even subtle.

Some authors were better at bringing out that urge to know more about a setting. That mysterious vibe that draws you in, making you need to know wtf this world is.

Other authors were strong at battle scenes, crafting intense fights that made me want to throw down and go super Saiyan myself, I was so hyped.

Others still had this beautiful, bird's-eye view of a world slowly revolving below them, and yet even at a distance tugged at my heart strings.

Did all of the above stories have the same AI-isms? Yep, and some more than others.

Did those repetitions make the human behind the tool less obvious?

No.

Keep writing.

(And share your blurb.)


r/WritingWithAI • • Jun 19 '25

It Is Our Right To Create - A Movement For AI Writers

2 Upvotes

Hello /WritingWithAI denizens,

I’m reaching out as the founder of the Right To Create movement. A manifesto and fledgling community dedicated to defending AI-assisted creativity, advocating for neurodivergent empowerment, and fighting against gatekeeping in creative fields.

Our manifesto addresses common misconceptions about AI-generated writing, music, and art. It highlights the legal and ethical foundations supporting fair use, scientific musings, and promotes inclusive creative freedom for all.

Given the alignment of our goals with the spirit of /WritingWithAI, I believe the Right To Create manifesto would provide a valuable resource and further unification of members, foster informed discussion, and strengthen the community’s united front.

Moderators, I would be grateful if you could consider reviewing and pinning our manifesto as a pinned post or sidebar resource. Artists aligned with our cause need to unite, our movement needs more leaders spreading awareness.

Thank you for your time and dedication to supporting AI artists.

Manifesto link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEkCyZR40Lo


r/WritingWithAI • • Apr 01 '25

I wrote a book using AI and getting HUGE backlash!

0 Upvotes

Edit again: Thank you all! This was the feedback I was looking for. The critique on execution, the over wording. I have something to work on before sharing it with you guys again!

Edit: my apologies, I had just got kicked out of another writers group before finding this one that supports ai. Noone in this group has been negative at all!

I admit I'm not a writer.

I got hurt working as an ER RN last October, and was compelled to shout out to the world my frustrations with the healthcare crisis. I put my soul into a fictional story, and used AI as a tool.

I'm self publishing, but man would I like someone other than my family (they all think its great) to read it.

I can't get anyone to read it, writers are very judgmental and wont even give me a chance.

With that being out of the way. I have a 28K word Novelette I'd like some input on. I'll be happy to read and review yours!

I just want to know if I should tell the story. I have attached Chapters 1-6

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cQh9Omz_LUWVck3o18qOEd3txbu3X0_9qCHtylTyIq8/edit?usp=sharing

++++Graphic Warning This story has drug abuse and addiction, sexual battery, and violence.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jul 23 '25

Claude refused to write a fanfic of my work.

Post image
1 Upvotes

I’ve been using Claude as a beta reader to read over what I’ve written, give feedback, track plot inconsistencies and character voice etc

My characters live in a crappy world and are pretty much perpetually sad or fearing for their lives, lol. So sometimes I like to ask Claude to write ‘fanfic-style’ short stories based on my characters and/or world, giving me a glimpse of what it might look like for them to have a happier existence.

They’re not part of the story, just for my own entertainment. I don’t want to write those moments myself because I feel that writing them having lighter moments would take me out of their current mindset and affect how I portray them when I’m writing.

Anyway, when I made this request yesterday, Claude refused to write a fanfic because it wouldn’t be fair to my work.

Has this ever happened to anyone else? It wasn’t a big deal (and I was able to prompt it to do so later, in a different chat), but I thought it was so strange!


r/WritingWithAI • • Mar 22 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Who's opinion matters? Consumers rule, Anti AI folks drool.

8 Upvotes

Luckily, all the anti AI folks that bitch and moan, are not the consumers that actually buy the products.

Real world consumers in general don't give a shit ‘how the sausage is made’, all they want is good tasting sausage.

Sorry Anti AI cult, but it is the consumer who will decide what is a good product. Slop is slop. Regardless of its origin. Same with quality.


r/WritingWithAI • • 26d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I have a story I've wanted to write for years. How can I use AI to finally bring it to life?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm new to this subreddit. So, I've had this story in my head for as long as I can remember. It's something I really want to write, more for catharsis than anything else. The problem is, I don't think I'm particularly talented at writing, and I also have learning disabilities (dyslexia and related difficulties). I'm thinking about using AI to finally turn this story into something real, but I honestly have no idea where to start.

What kind of workflow would you recommend? Right now, I'm using ChatGPT Plus, but I'm mainly interested in understanding how people actually structure their writing process with AI, from developing an idea to finishing a complete story.

I also want to make one thing clear from the start: in this particular case, I genuinely don't care whether people consider my work AI-generated or not. This is something I feel a deep, almost visceral need to get out of my system, and frankly, I'm not particularly concerned about what other people will think once it's finished. I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from people who've used AI to work on long-form fiction or deeply personal writing projects.


r/WritingWithAI • • Apr 10 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) "I will never read a book made by AI." That's what many people think. That's what I thought, being a skeptical writer and all. Sadly, I don't believe it anymore.

19 Upvotes

Moreover, I think that most books will be written by/with AI. In the not-so-distant future.

And we — you and me — will be reading them. And we'll enjoy it.

These books will be fine. No worse than many books we read today. Maybe even better.

This dawned on me after watching a TV series with such a stupid plot twist that I thought at some point: "AI would come up with something better!"

Then I realized that most fiction that is published is genre fiction. In the US, it makes up 90-95% of all sales.

Genre fiction is based on cliches. Lone-wolf detective. Wizard in a cloak, with a staff. Eccentric but brilliant scientist. And so on...

Replicating proven tropes is basically the job description. You need to give it a slight twist, sure, but not too much, otherwise it stops being genre fiction.

AI can do it. Replicating proven formulas is what it was built for.

Moreover, genre fiction writers rarely write from experience. Many crime fiction writers have never seen a dead body. Many fantasy writers have never been on a horse...

Processing raw human experience into art is a job for literary fiction. In genre fiction, the talent is in combining things you've read somewhere, in a clever way.

AI has all the world's existing knowledge. So it can rearrange the existing pieces much better. Maybe not today, but relatively soon. In 2 years? In 10?

A thought experiment:

we can imagine the entire writing community as a huge distributed network. In this network every node generates some fiction, almost randomly. Nobody knows what will take off. Most of it fails, but some nodes (writers) occasionally find a perfect combination of proven formulas and new ideas (like "Harry Potter" and "Project Hail Mary" ), and it becomes a hit.

All this can be taken over by AI. AI can start generating all these things too. We won't need human nodes to do that.

Human writing will be pushed into a corner, for those who explore fiction as art or at the very least try to write about new lived experiences that don't yet exist in the collective knowledge of humanity.

I'm not sure if it's a scary picture — or a fascinating one.


r/WritingWithAI • • Apr 24 '26

Showcase / Feedback Usage of AI

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I'd like to refer on this topic.

As someone who used AI. I wrote a fantasy book in 11 months. Hey, 11 months. While other people write book with AI in few days or month it took me 11 months! 190 xxx words.

Why? Because I had my own story I was creating 4 years ago where there was no AI/ChatGpt and other stuffs. I used AI or a.k.a. digital tools to help me with grammar, structuring a sentence and so on, which would be same job as I pay 3-4k for an editor. So what is the difference? I payed like 200-300 USD for AI tools instead of paying 3-4k USD for someone else.

As the technology is growing, we should adapt to it. Whether you like it or not. That same technology can help us do things we're not able to do, like writing as example. So why my idea has to die if someone doesn't like AI a.k.a digital tool?

They say using AI is plagiarism. Let me tell you what plagiarism really is since a lot of people misunderstood it.

"Plagiarism is the act of presenting someone else's work, ideas, or language as your own, with or without their consent, by failing to properly acknowledge the original source."

https://www.ox.ac.uk/students/academic/guidance/skills/plagiarism

So tell me, how can my own story, my worldbuilding, my characters my everything be plagiarism? If you're still thinking it, then congratulations, every book in the world is plagiarised. Why? Because of the same reason you're thinking - if I ask you to help me with a part of the story then they are not my sentences anymore, they're yours. So please... Same goes for editors and lecturers.

I'm a financial manager, and I want to write if I'm able to, and I'm able, with AI. I write text, tell him to fix grammar and restructure it and that's it. I don’t see a problem in that.

I got critics, good and bad ones. Everyone likes my story, my idea. It's amazing. But bad thing is I used AI. "There is no you in the story, readers want to feel you". Yeah, they're feeling me, I just used AI to structure my sentences a little more.

Funny thing , I asked someone what if I used digital tools for translating my book. Everyone hated on me. Yeah, would you pay 10k+ USD or 20 USD for translating book to English? Period.

You can hate me or downvote me, but there are a lot of amazing people who don't know how to write, but have amazing ideas. So they need to stop because of someones opinion? That not human at all. Let people be people, if you want to read it, then read it, if you don't - stop criticising.

Also, my own profesor who has PhD. uses AI, everyone on my college uses AI (and I'm referring on professors with PhD). Does their dipploma means less if they're using AI? Answer me please. Edit: just to be clear. They use it for structuring a sentences, grammar and things like that.

Edit: I love how someone talks about usage of AI and being honest and gets downvoted


r/WritingWithAI • • Mar 18 '25

I'm worried about the racism in Ai

0 Upvotes

I have had some seriously racist responses when doing my research using Chatgpt. I'll just give two main examples

  1. It refused to give me information on slavery in N America experience specifically to BW and red warned me.

  2. It told me medical experiments on black slaves was scientific but in the holocaust it was sadistic and unscientific!

Yesterday though is when I realized if the next generation becomes fully dependent on Ai in writing then were doomed. I asked both Deep and CGPT yesterday how i could use a specific quote on happiness I gave it in relation to the character in my book, a BW.

Chatgbt constantly kept using words like

Character X found happiness in struggle X found happiness in resistance X found happiness in fighting

Even when i questioned why it was describing my character using words I've never used in my book it still gave me similar responses. I was so confused until I realized it was automatically co relating the black woman with struggle and fighting and is not capable of seeing the problem with it.

I am not sure how I can promt it to check bias before rendering.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jul 30 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Why do some people get so pressed when hobby users share AI storytelling workflows?

1 Upvotes

Why do some writers get so pressed when people share their ChatGPT or any AI system workflows, custom instructions, or prompt setups for AI storytelling as a hobby?

I understand disliking AI writing. I understand having concerns about writing as a craft, publishing, originality, young writers, etc. Those are valid broader discussions. But sometimes the reaction feels so disproportionate when the post is clearly for other hobby users.

I mean why does it suddenly become a lecture about the downfall of literature, young writers ruining their craft, and publishers not accepting it?So yeah, I’m genuinely curious. Is it because AI storytelling itself feels threatening? Is it because some outputs are getting good enough that they make people uncomfortable? Or is it just Reddit being Reddit?


r/WritingWithAI • • May 26 '25

AI has made my writing worse?

4 Upvotes

I have a middlingly successful pen name in a romance niche, and the whole point of using AI was to speed through the commercial work so I could save my real creative energy for the big personal projects I actually care about. But it's taking longer to get a decent book with AI than it would to just write it myself from scratch.

The constant editing loop is destroying my writing process. Instead of drafting then editing like every writing guide tells you, I'm trapped in endless tweaking of AI-generated text that isn't even good. I'm spending so much time wrestling with this stuff, editing and re-editing and trying to make it not sound terrible, that by the time I'm done with the commercial stuff I have nothing left for my passion projects. This isn't about the ethics of AI, just the functionality.

I feel trapped. The commercial work was supposed to be the income that would buy me time and mental space for the writing that matters to me. Instead, I'm pouring all my energy into fixing bad AI prose while my literary work sits there, untouched. In the end, the commerical work does sell, but when I look at how many hours it takes to get a decent draft I feel like I would be better off drafting manually. The thing that was supposed to free up my creative bandwidth is completely draining it instead.

Does anyone know of a tool that gives you like 50-100 words when you're stuck? Not full scenes or chapters that change your voice - just enough to get unstuck and keep your momentum going. Everything I've tried either generates way too much or completely derails what I'm writing.

Is anyone else dealing with this? Where you thought AI would handle the "grunt work" but it's actually consuming more of your creative resources than doing it the old way? I'm starting to wonder if I should abandon AI entirely and go back to pure manual drafting.


r/WritingWithAI • • Jun 04 '25

Ethics and morality? More like plagiarism with style.

0 Upvotes

Ethics and morality?

These aunties are literally just hilarious. They say AI-generated content is plagiarism. They’re the same people who write fanfiction and fan art, which is plagiarism but with style, so you’re telling me that taking the author’s character and drawing them without their consent is not considered plagiarism, but when I ask ChatGPT to generate an image of Naruto, it’s plagiarism now? And you also tell me that the millions of fanfics out there are not plagiarism, but when a person uses AI to write their stories, it’s suddenly plagiarism? Dude, are you for real?

Explain to me how the fan fix and fan art are not plagiarism. You don’t support the author. You don’t give them money. You don’t ask for their consent, and now when a person uses AI to create an image or to write a story, it’s suddenly plagiarism in the end of the world?