I'll try to explain the situation, because the background is important.
My sister won an expensive 3 week trip abroad and invited her best friend Chloe, our mother, and me.
I'm single. Before the trip, my sister had once mentioned that Chloe would be a good match for me, but immediately added that she didn't want anything to happen because Chloe was her best friend. I respected that, although I occasionally joked about sharing a room with Chloe during the holiday. She never found the jokes funny..
About ten days into the trip, Chloe kissed me. She told me she felt there was something between us and that she knew I wanted it too.
Shortly afterwards, she messaged me apologising, saying she might have misread the situation.
I told her yes she might have misread and I explained that my sister had made it very clear she didn't want us to get romantically involved. I told Chloe that, out of respect for my sister's wishes, I wasn't going to pursue anything. I suggested we simply enjoy the rest of the holiday.
Chloe understood, although she said she would keep some distance. Despite that, there was still a flirty atmosphere between us during the remaining days, and we continued spending time together.
Two days after the kiss, Chloe had told my sister what happened. My sister took it relatively well, but her position remained unchanged.
We returned home end of September, and Chloe and I continued messaging until mid October. We talked about travelling together, including snowboarding and other destinations we would both like to visit. We both love travelling and have a very similar travel style. She occasionally sent me reels about places we could potentially visit together.
Eventually, the conversation faded. Her last message was on October 17, which I liked but didn't reply to.
Then, last Thursday, I suddenly found out through our family group chat that my brother Ryan and Chloe were dating.
I had absolutely no idea.
My brother became defensive, explaining that Chloe was the only woman in ten years who regularly asked him how his day was going. He made it clear that he would decide for himself who he wanted to date. Apparently, he had asked her out the previous weekend, the date went well, and they're now seeing where things go. It's still very early.
Meanwhile, my sister has sent both my brother and me messages saying she's done with us and will never contact us again.
And this is where things get difficult.
I deliberately stepped aside because I wanted to avoid a family conflict. I gave up the possibility of something with Chloe because I respected my sister's wishes and wanted to keep the peace.
Now, roughly a month and a half later, that family conflict has happened anyway. My sister has cut contact with both of us, there's resentment between my brother and me, and our mother is caught in the middle.
I feel jealous, betrayed, resentful and honestly quite bitter. I sacrificed a potential relationship to protect my family, only to end up with neither the relationship nor the family peace I was trying to preserve.
I don't know whether my brother knew about the kiss or the connection Chloe and I had. I suspect he didn't. Chloe, however, certainly knew about my sister's objections and what had happened between us.
Part of me feels that I was the first person Chloe showed interest in, and that my brother only became involved afterwards. I realise I can't know for certain how she sees it.
I also genuinely believe Chloe and I might be more compatible than she and my brother. We have more in common in terms of personality, interests and lifestyle. My mother has expressed a similar opinion. Obviously, that doesn't guarantee a relationship would work, but it makes the situation harder to accept.
I'm now seriously considering reaching out to Chloe and telling her that I still have feelings for her and would like to explore whether something could happen between us.
My reasoning is that the original reason I didn't pursue her was to protect my relationship with my sister. But that relationship now appears to be broken regardless.
If I do nothing, my brother and Chloe will continue dating, and I'll have lost this opportunity twice: first by deliberately stepping aside, and now by choosing not to try again. If I reach out, she might still be interested, or she might prefer to continue dating my brother. Either way, at least I won't spend the rest of my life wondering what might have happened if I had stood up for what I wanted.
I understand that pursuing her now would be a betrayal of my brother. He has asked her out, they had a good date, and I know they're seeing each other. I'm not pretending that doesn't matter.
However, there's another side to this. My brother may initially have been unaware of what happened between Chloe and me. I can understand that. But if he learns the full story, knows that I had feelings for her and deliberately stepped aside because of my sister's ultimatum, and still chooses to pursue her, wouldn't he also be knowingly disregarding my feelings? Wouldn't that be a betrayal of me?
I also need to be honest about how far this has gone. At this point, I am certain I don't want to see my brother, indefinitely. I cannot imagine attending Christmas or family birthdays and watching him with the woman I wanted to pursue but gave up for the sake of my family.
It's even reached the point where I'd rather pay a mechanic to do something my brother would normally help me with, than rely on him for a favour while feeling this much resentment. That's how serious the rift is for me right now.
Realistically, I can see myself withdrawing from family gatherings altogether. My sister is already gone from my life, and I may end up being absent too. Our mother will be left in the middle, knowing that the woman my brother is now bringing into the family is the same woman I had feelings for and deliberately chose not to pursue.
I don't want to pretend my motivation is entirely selfless. I'm jealous, hurt and regret the decision I made. But I also feel I gave my sister's opinion far too much power over a personal decision that should ultimately have been mine.
So, WIBTA if I reached out to Chloe and told her I still have feelings for her, even though I know she has just started dating my brother?
I know it would be a betrayal of my brother. But given everything that happened, would it necessarily be wrong to do it? And if he knows the full story and still chooses to pursue her, isn't he also betraying me?
Am I wrong to finally put my own feelings and happiness first, even if it means going against my brother's new relationship, after already sacrificing a potential relationship to protect my family?
EDIT: I left out some context about why my sister cut me off. She already felt that Chloe and I had ruined her dream vacation because of the chemistry between us, even though we tried to be considerate of her feelings throughout the trip. Towards the end, she was also getting angry with me over all sorts of minor things, from driving too slowly because of traffic to stopping for fuel or the bad weather. Most of her frustration felt completely disproportionate.
When we got home, she essentially cut me off because she felt Chloe and I had ruined her holiday.