r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 6h ago

WIBTA if I asked my husband to stop telling people how much I make?

82 Upvotes

I got promoted recently and told some friends over dinner what my new salary would be. I was excited and probably overshared a bit.

But now my husband keeps bringing it up. We’ll meet someone and somehow my job comes up, followed by exactly how much I make. He’s proud of me, I get that. But then I’m stuck answering questions about why we still live in a small apartment or why I haven’t bought my mom a car. That last one actually happened.

I told him those questions were getting awkward. He said he figured I didn’t mind people knowing since I’d told our friends myself. He seemed a little hurt because he thought he was saying something nice about me. I want to ask him to check with me before sharing the number again.

WIBTA? I know I brought it up first, but I didn’t think I was signing up for this every time we meet someone.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 6h ago

WIBTA if I didn’t buy Christmas gift’s for my sister’s kids this year?

71 Upvotes

I (31F) have an older sister (32F) who has children. I do not. Before her eldest was born and for most of our lives we were pretty close especially due to how close in age we are. After becoming a mom she started spending much more time with my brother-in-law’s side of the family (I always assumed because they have small children on their side too and we do not in addition to her having pretty complicated feelings about our parents) but in the last few years I have seen them less and less frequently despite my best efforts. I attempt to reach out for birthdays, holidays, offer to come by on any day she might be free with dinner for them or something, offer free babysitting because I know she is overwhelmed. I rarely even get a response.

I realized recently when the discussion of holiday plans came up that I don’t think I’ve even seen her children since last Christmas. She has actually been consistently flaking on even our individual plans for months. Her kids have a huge extended family and some might even say receive too many gifts and toys as it is all year round that end up donated or trashed. I’m pretty sure only one of the kids would even be able to identify which auntie got them gifts.

Would I be a huge asshole to THEM if I didn’t get them anything at all this year?

I don’t intend to participate in the planned family Christmas gathering if that makes a difference. I will hopefully be out of state.* But I guess there’s maybe a small chance they have some sort of expectations of what Christmas looks like at my mom’s house? They celebrate at several households over Christmas and Christmas Eve.

Edit: typo*


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 12h ago

WIBTA for ordering my own turkey on Thanksgiving?

128 Upvotes

We decided last minute to visit my in laws for Thanksgiving.

Growing up, my family would always get honeybaked ham smoked turkey, and it’s the thing I look forward to the most. I love making little sandwiches out of it alongside sharp cheddar cheese and Hawaiian rolls; that’s pretty much all I eat on Thanksgiving.

I was about to place an order to have the HBH turkey shipped to my in-laws house, and my husband excitedly told me his mom bought a whole turkey for Thanksgiving. I was immediately disappointed. Not only do I look forward to the honeybaked ham turkey every year, but also, my MIL is very bad at cooking meats; they are always extremely dry. Like, choking on the food dry.

Would I be the asshole for still ordering my favorite turkey even though she’s going to make a whole turkey?

I will probably put a slice of her turkey on my plate to be polite, but I’m not interested in eating it, and I don’t eat ham.

Edit to add: we will be staying at my in-laws house Nov 21-Dec 3.

Edit 2: My in-laws are not American and do not have any solid Thanksgiving traditions. They just see it more as a family meet up, so it’s not the same vibe as an American Thanksgiving tradition. I assume they got the turkey for me since I am American, and although I appreciate their heart being in the right place, I really don’t want that turkey and feel sad about missing out on my family’s tradition. I’ve spent Thanksgiving with them in the past, and it was very disappointing and underwhelming. No traditions, no holiday magic, and unfortunately, no good food. It’s not a holiday that’s celebrated in their country, so there’s no pride in putting it all together, and oftentimes the foods served aren’t even Thanksgiving foods. That Thanksgiving actually made me very sad, and I was starving with nothing decent to eat that night.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 2h ago

WIBTA For Keeping the Treasure in My Gym Equipment?

7 Upvotes

I purchased a weight bench of Marketplace a little bit ago. The guy had me get it from his wife. She was such a sweetheart and although I haven’t looked this over fully I was initially missing parts to the bench. She gave me some pieces she found. Right before leaving she found another.

Anyway, while bringing the bench into the house I’d turned it to the side and change fell out. Got it to my gym area and heard more jangling. In all, after 10-15 minutes I shook out some pumpkin carve tools, a pen, a 5mm socket, a silver, Indian Head ring and about $35 in change.

I plan to message the guy about the ring but part of me wants to keep the change.

Money has been tight, I’ve been on med leave for 6 months with no true return date in sight. The bench was a cheap Walmart one I’d gotten on impulse for $10. I’d reasonable it’ll help with some of my PT. Now I have this cash and technically profited but feel bad keeping it. Should I offer to give it back too?

Update: So, I’d already typed the message about the ring and sent it at the time of posting this. Multi tasking I guess?

He said yes to the ring. My husband looked up the ring history and turns out it’s an American Indian 1940’s biker gang signet ring. The guy said it belonged to his grandpa which makes me feel better about dropping it off.

That said, I’m not gonna bolster myself by saying I was OF COURSE gonna return the change. I was tempted to keep it. After reading these messages though, I’m gonna let him know and ask if he wants it back too. My conscience probably wouldn’t let me keep it if I didn’t.

Update 2: Sorry if I’m formatting this incorrectly; I did move it all to the bottom for easier reading. I’d dropped off the ring while debating the change since it was along the way for dog park(I have 2 puppy Great Pyrenees-> 10 months and 1.5 yr. 85-95lb each for anyone curious)

For those saying it’s dumb I’m cash strapped but willing to spend $10 on a weight bench you’re right. It was an impulse buy. I’d rationalized getting it would make my PT easier. Before the bench I’d set 2 dining chairs together. So I obviously made do but hopefully the now improved ROM/comfort will help me heal faster so I can go back to work. Anyhow, the guy told me I can keep it and thanked me for the honesty. I appreciate you all for keeping me honest, a guilty conscience isn’t worth $30ish bucks.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 13h ago

WIBTA for not spending Christmas with my partner?

24 Upvotes

I 30f and my partner 33m have been dating for 2.5yrs and will be our 3rd Christmas together. However, I don't want to spend it with him, due to his behaviour over the last year and recently.

We don't live together, he rents a room and I own a flat with my cat. He does have a key, but I've asked him to message when hes coming over, so I can be ready or let him know if I'm not home and shouldn't come over. Plus, when he has let himself in without letting me know, it's awkward as sometimes I'm getting out of the shower and there he is, which makes me jump. A few times I've messaged him night before asking him not to come over due to feeling a migraine coming on and to get rid, I need sleep and quiet, but the next morning he's over and in the kitchen making a tone of noise! Plus, I've never seen inside where he lives, I've only ever picked or dropped him off.

What happened a few months ago has changed my view on the relationship completely and nearly ended right then and there. I had a bank issue causing my mortgage payment to bounce back and I didn't realise until receiving a letter, but phoned to pay straight away. I put the letter back in the envelope and on the side thinking nothing more, as its sorted.

A few days later we called to catch up and say goodnight. I asked what he'll like for Christmas but then he said this "Don't worry about getting me anything as I saw the letter about the mortgage payment and if you lose your flat, that's basically us over" I was stunned and hung up on him. He messaged saying thats not what he meant and of course he'll still date me if I didn't have my flat.

Since then, I'm slowly getting more annoyed, reflected on our whole relationship and realised he's said a lot of hurtful things.

This year, I want to spend Christmas morning at home alone and then head over to my parents to spend the night with them and come home boxing day evening.

I have mentioned spending Christmas with my family and he said "I thought I was coming to over to cook again, so what am I suppose to do now?" I did feel bad, but he pays nothing towards my flat and cooking here last year was stressful and not in the good way. He then followed up with "I could come over to check in on baby (cat)" but shot that down as I don't want him over without me there after knowing hes read my post and probably going to use my PS4 to game while over. So I did kindly say no and that if he does come over without my permission or knowledge, I'm taking the key back or changing the locks.

My family did invite him over for our first Christmas, but over the years, they don't want to be around him as they don't like him at all!

So would I be the a**hole for not wanting to spend Christmas with my partner?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 2h ago

WIBTA For Keeping the Treasure in My Gym Equipment?

1 Upvotes

I purchased a weight bench of Marketplace a little bit ago. The guy had me get it from his wife. She was such a sweetheart and although I haven’t looked this over fully I was initially missing parts to the bench. She gave me some pieces she found. Right before leaving she found another.

Anyway, while bringing the bench into the house I’d turned it to the side and change fell out. Got it to my gym area and heard more jangling. In all, after 10-15 minutes I shook out some pumpkin carve tools, a pen, a 5mm socket, a silver, Indian Head ring and about $35 in change.

I plan to message the guy about the ring but part of me wants to keep the change.

Money has been tight, I’ve been on med leave for 6 months with no true return date in sight. The bench was a cheap Walmart one I’d gotten on impulse for $10. I’d reasonable it’ll help with some of my PT. Now I have this cash and technically profited but feel bad keeping it. Should I offer to give it back too?

Update: So, I’d already typed the message about the ring and sent it at the time of posting this. Multi tasking I guess?

He said yes to the ring. My husband looked up the ring history and turns out it’s an American Indian 1940’s biker gang signet ring. The guy said it belonged to his grandpa which makes me feel better about dropping it off.

That said, I’m not gonna bolster myself by saying I was OF COURSE gonna return the change. I was tempted to keep it. After reading these messages though, I’m gonna let him know and ask if he wants it back too. My conscience probably wouldn’t let me keep it if I didn’t.

Update 2: Sorry if I’m formatting this incorrectly; I did move it all to the bottom for easier reading. I’d dropped off the ring while debating the change since it was along the way for dog park(I have 2 puppy Great Pyrenees-> 10 months and 1.5 yr. 85-95lb each for anyone curious)

For those saying it’s dumb I’m cash strapped but willing to spend $10 on a weight bench you’re right. It was an impulse buy. I’d rationalized getting it would make my PT easier. Before the bench I’d set 2 dining chairs together. So I obviously made do but hopefully the now improved ROM/comfort will help me heal faster so I can go back to work. Anyhow, the guy told me I can keep it and thanked me for the honesty. I appreciate you all for keeping me honest, a guilty conscience isn’t worth $30ish bucks.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 4h ago

Am i the asshole for being on love with a taken men .

0 Upvotes

To get some context, I started college again this year ( F,24). At first I wasn’t so sure I would make friends at all . Thats where I met him, in cinema class, this cute guy (m,23). We bonded and quickly realized we had so much in common and that we were at a similar time in our lives . Very earlier on he talked to me about his boyfriend and his kid talking about very deep and very personal things , like the fact that he is trans , his relationship with his parents . I also talked to him about the people close to me that passed away and sadly but gladly too, he was there through the grief of my father . Also the fact that I really wanted to be a mom but that I am infertile . Very early on , we got so close he even mentionned wanting to carry a baby maybe one day for me if i could not find any other way and that since he felt close to me and that we started to be close friends . We did alot of school work together up and downs and being there for eachother . But honestly I’ve had feelings for him since day one . There was some days where it was up and down . Seeing him with his boyfriend and kid , i understand how i needed to let go and that I was glad he was happy with his family and i for a little bit tought that this feeling was leaving me . Until we got even closer recently . I really think me and my crush really trauma bonded , because we got closer because of a comment that a random boy at school made directly at my crush/best friend appearance, it really brought up some ptsd , trauma and alot of gender disphoria. He admitted to me many Times his relationship struggles before that but proceded to say that he did not feel like « a first choice » and he always felt like he was the last option for his boyfriend and for mostly everyone , in every context . He was very sad and so I look at him and admited to him my feelings telling him that for me i really had a crush on him the first Time I saw him he took it in a very sweet and friendly way . He proceded to say that he was very flattered and that I was very cute took , he also says that if he wasn’t dating anyone at the moment he would consider . We were both very shy and tried to deal with it in the most mature way but it felt good to let it out .
I putted my feelings aside ,the least I wanted was to be a homewrecker or to make it harder for him.
Since to remind you there is a kid in the picture .
But recently things have been worst and worst , My bestie missed school which he never does , his mental health went downhill , he told me alot of things were affecting him and one morning he cried in my arms telling me that his boyfriend has admitted to wanting to see elsewhere , try something else in their relationship, his boyfriend said to want to try things with women and struggling in a sexual way . Let’s just say my friend was heartbroken . In the heat of the moment my friend looked at me and asked me if i would be down to join their relationship because he said that his boyfriend has mentionned maybe wanting being poly or a trouple. My friend said he’s not open into having this happen expectally if it’s a stranger in his words he told me he feels like « ur the only person i know that I feel like it would work with i mean since maybe there’s a mutual attraction there ) but after mature thinking we were both not into it because we felt like either way maybe at some point someone would maybe feel left out or not comftable and we were not into going any further with that , i had no feed-back whatsoever to see if they talked about it .
Time passed and on friday my friend is texting me very mad saying his boyfriend got upset and his driving him back home .my friend explains that he asked his boyfriend if he wanted to go eat together with me the three of us for lunch and just chill . My friend has mentionned going on dates first to try and he was ver into trying being poly so i wonder if that’s something they talked about and the boyfriend did not take it well . My friend ended up having a horrible day and missing class . The next day I wasn’t having any news at all I was being kind of worried . I started having voice messages and texts and apparently there was alot of stuff happening and my friend really was in a mental break-down because of all the most recent events + school .
His boyfriend was more mad and was in pain apparently we think he had a broken rib that he didn’t take care off and it got worst and did not want to go to the hospital , my friend tried to get him to go and it caused a fight and my friend to get ptsd and anxiety attack . So I asked another one of my friend ,a guy I know because neither does my crush or me have a car btw my crush mostly relies on his boyfriend for transportation. My crush ended up coming to my house with his baby to spend the night . I helped him and we had a cozy night to help my crush’s mental health and to help him with his kid and also to get some time for the boyfriend to calm down and go to the hospital . I spended the whole night resting with my crush and his baby and we talked for a long time , we are used to it by now we talk about everything but I feel like the only subject he does fully open up to me about its his boyfriend or maybe his feelings for me prehaps .? I just came back from work because I was working and my crush was at my appartement and he left but he decided to clean me my appartement and buy me some food as a gift and he is the sweetest person ever . Whatever happens between us I’m trying to be as respectful to everyone as possible. We are still such close friends and even tough we know we have maybe a bit of a mutual crush we both hope to be as close as possible forever . If yall have any tips of what to do ? I’m trying to wait and he there for him during this hard time . Apparently he wouldnt want to rly break up with his bf but it’s definitely not the best moment for both of them . Also my friend is not ready to have his baby 50% of the time and totally refuses . And he has no car and barely any money to hold on by himself if they break up. He has told me this himself that this scares him and he is litterally in a rush to get his lisense i feel like this stresses him out alot and I’m worried he might feel stuck in some way . There’s alot of positive i feel like in their relationship. But I just cant help but feel butterflies when I’m close to him and just want to kiss him so badly in some moments . I also just feel so special when we give eachother hugs I just want to be very affectionate to him and bring him on a date make him feel like the amazing boy he is. It’s not fair to his boyfriend to do that obviously . You can be very direct with me tell me tips if you’ve been through something similar .


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 4h ago

AITA for not caring that my childhood best friend is pregnant after she ignored me for almost a year?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

AITA for not caring that my childhood best friend is pregnant after she ignored me for almost a year?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 11h ago

WIBTA If I Ask For My Money Back On An Art Commission?

3 Upvotes

A few weeks ago I had commissioned a crochet plush from someone online. The person had a business and I even found a convention posting that she was selling her items there, so I had no reason to think it was a scam.

I sent her a portion of the money and she was active and sent me updates. Then one day she stopped responding to me so I left her alone for a week or two.

Until she texted me back a couple of days ago. I would not like to disclose what she told me, but essentially she said she had to escape a personal situation.

She said she would send me my money back and that she will still finish my commission when she gets the chance.

I sort of panicked and felt really bad so I told her not to worry about it and to take as much time as she needed without really thinking about it. (For context, I have a really difficult time when heavy situations happen suddenly)

I didn't really think anything else of it until I told my family about it today. They told me that I wouldn't get sent my plush and that I essentially got scammed.

I would hate to ask for my money back and take away from someone in a bad situation, but I also understand my family's side I really do not know what the truth is.

WIBTA if I asked for a refund?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 5h ago

WIBTA for telling o my friend with her mom? "

0 Upvotes

I don't even know if she should be considered my friend atp..

She literally has done me dirty many times and I forgive her. She does lots of things she shouldn't be doing and started sleeping around a few months ago. She doesn't care whether she'll catch an std or something. She said she likes it and tells me like if will support that. I mean, if it's her boyfriend then sure. The problem is she will just sleep with the first guy she sees and it's very upsetting. She's been also smoking green stuff, abusing alcohol, and getting bad grades in school.

There's more things she's done but still, I let them slide. Not this time. She told her mom I haven't texted her in a few weeks. I already told my friend I don't support this sudden behavior and should probably slow down. Instead she got worse. I don't find it cool because her mom just told me like "hey why aren't you talking to my daughter? She said she misses you. " what should I say?

My friend know why I took some distance and still chose to tell on me. I even told her a few days before I stopped talking to her that I would if she didn't slow down. I'm really worried for her because she's high-texted me, she's drunk texted and called me. I don't like this. It's not fun to have a friend like this who won't listen..


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 7h ago

AITAH for not forgiving my friends roommate for SA me

1 Upvotes

This past halloweekend me and my friends had been planning for months. We all had a group costume and planned out exactly where we wanted to go and what all we wanted to do! It started off really fun when we were out on thursday and friday and then actual halloween day came around. Early halloween day my friend i’ll call Van decided he didn’t really want our other friend Liz to spend the night at his because “he was tired of her bringing all her shit over and being a messy drunk that he had to take care of”. What Van said really rubbed me the wrong way because Liz was his #1 best friend next to his roommate but I didn’t want to start halloween off with drama or hurting Liz’s feelings so I just agreed to let her crash on me and my gfs couch! Well evening rolls around and it’s time to get ready to go out so Liz came over and got ready with me! While we were getting ready I heard her talking on the phone with Van, he was saying something along the lines of “just let me know when you guys are on your way (to the club)” and immediately I was kinda like wait what? cause we’d had these plans for months and the plan had always been for everyone to come to me and my gfs so we could get good pictures with our group costumes, pregame, and then all share an uber together! I asked Liz if I could speak to Van and asked him what he was doing. He told me that he was just going to meet us there because he wanted to go with his roommate and their friend that came to town for the weekend. I immediately realized he only dumped Liz on me because he didn’t want to wait for her to get off work or hang out with us and he waited until we were getting ready to go to say it. I also knew this couldn’t have been a last minute plan of his cause his friend had driven like 5hrs to be here so there was no way this wasn’t a premeditated decision. Normally this would just be kinda annoying or inconvenient but it also really made me upset because he intentionally kept it from me until last minute cause he knew i didn’t really care for his roommate and really didn’t like their friend that came to town. I told him it wouldn’t have upset me if he was honest about it when i asked. About a week before halloween he said something about his “friend coming to town” and i asked if he was referring to the girl i didn’t care for (I’ll call her Bianca) and he said “no” and i told him right then and there that it was fine if that’s who he was talking about I just wanted to know if she was coming. But he told me it wasn’t her and quickly changed the subject so I just let it go. 

Anyways back to halloween. Me and Liz talked about how what Van did was really shitty but quickly moved on to drinking and hanging out when everyone else started to arrive. We made our way to the clubs and started off the evening without Van Bianca and his roommate but eventually Van begged my gf to bring us to the club they were at so we finally caved and went to meet them. After standing in line for about an hour to get in we finally met up with them and headed to the bar. 

One thing I should note before I continue is that me and Vans roommate, Emmy do not really get along. Or I guess rather I didn’t really care for her. I was always pleasant and respectful to her and really tried my best to start conversations with her especially the first few times I met her but it quickly became clear to me that we had absolutely nothing in common. Van got her to move from their hometown (about 5hrs away) to our town. So obviously I knew her first few months would be Van including her extra hard to make her feel welcome which was fine at first. It started off as a once in a while she’d come with us to go somewhere or something but then it became she would just tag along to anything Van was invited to do even if I asked Van if it could just be an us thing. Basically what i’m trying to say is she was really good at self inviting and inserting herself. I think the thing that finally really pmo was one day I asked Van to get coffee just us two to talk to him about how I felt really pressured to include this girl I don’t really know in everything our group does, and then Emmy just pulled up driving her car with Van and I was like oh! I didn’t know you’d be joining us! Well on the way back Van was like “I have work in an hour but you two should hang out” and immediately I was like “oh I can’t i’m sorry I already made plans with my two friends” which wasn’t a lie and that was that until I get a call from those two friends telling me Emmy asked if she could come. I asked if they had invited her and they said no she just called and asked. So she invited herself and then on top of that ruined the night by complaining the entire time about what we were doing and that we were smoking a lot. (mind you we told her if she didn’t want to be in the hotbox we understood and she could wait the less than 5 mins we were smoking in our other friends car) but she declined and continued to take up a lot of the back seat (she was also the smallest person out of our mostly grown men group) and was mad the entire time about how smelly and cramped it was. So yeah safe to say she wasn’t my favorite and I eventually talked to Van basically saying I didn’t mind if she was included in group things but that I’d appreciate if he let us do the inviting since most hang outs are at me and my gfs place and to just give us a heads up if she’s coming. But he took this as I hate her and never wanna see her. Which was kinda true but I was trying to be understanding that she was in a new area and even made the effort to invite her to my birthday dinner and party. But that went kinda shit because she drove Van to both and then left both things early due to Emmy having to work in the morning.

(Back to halloween) We walked up to the bar and I immediately noticed how fucked up Van was. He was yelling about how one of the bartenders had cut him off and started to try and convince this other bartender to give him more drinks. While he was begging my gf stood with him trying to get herself a drink and Liz started talking to Bianca and my other two friends went to the bathroom cause one of them wasn’t feeling well. So that left just me and Emmy. I was really annoyed at this point in the evening cause I didn’t even wanna be with Vans drunk ass but before I could walk away Emmy started talking to me about how she was super annoyed cause Van got them both cut off even though “she wasn’t feeling it at all anymore” (the alc). While she was saying this she kept getting really close and at first I just assumed it was due to the loud music but it wasn’t that loud by the bar so I backed up trying to give myself space since I could still hear her but she kept re-closing the gap between us. She started to put her hands on my chest and that’s when I was like ok this is really making me uncomfortable and I really don’t care what she has to say so mid convo I just stepped in front of her to try and get to my gf to tell her I was uncomfortable and wanted to leave. And that’s when I felt a hand slide up my shorts underneath my underwear and then finally a tight squeeze on my butt. I froze in shock for a second trying to decide what I should do. I wanted to freak out but all my body allowed me to do was turn around. And what I saw was Emmy removing her hand from my pants. I was immediately really shocked and upset and gave up trying to get to my gf at the crowded bar so I ran to the bathroom to find my other two friends. When I found them my other friend wasn’t feeling well so I walked us outside and immediately started trying to come to terms with what had just happened to me. I’ve been SA before so this was not only a really uncomfy situation but also kinda traumatic. After I got my friend that wasn’t feeling well a water I told them what had happened. They immediately said they were so sorry and understood my wanting to leave. I texted my gf to come find us and after about 10 minutes she found us and unfortunately was followed by the rest of the group. I pulled my gf aside and told her “Emmy grabbed my butt and I just want to go home” she told me that Emmy had also been really handsy with her too and that she had to ask Emmy to remove her hands from her butt. I told her that tonight wasn’t the night to talk about it or tell Van since he was drunk and she agreed. We gathered up our group and left after my gf said goodbye to Van. When we got back everyone had gone home except Liz since she was sleeping on our couch. Liz sat there next to us eating her taco bell while I was shaking and sobbing on the couch explaining to my gf exactly what happened. When Liz heard she grabbed my butt her first response was “oh my god me too! she was being so touchy”. So I was like wow shes obviously done this before and felt really gross about it wishing I had called her out right when it happened. I told both my gf and Liz that I wanted time before I told Van because I knew he would make the situation about me not really getting along with Bianca and Emmy. I cried for days and even had a couple nightmares about similar situations. It was such a violation but I knew speaking up would mean “drama”.

Well the day after Liz apparently told Van about what had happened but just not at all the full story or even truth. I was so hurt that she told him when I specifically asked her to give me time to talk to him about it. Immediately my fears came true. It was no longer about me being grabbed. It was boiled down to drama. I woke up to a notification saying Van had left our friendgroup chat and life 360 circle. I knew Liz had said something at this point so I texted her saying I wish she would’ve let me tell Van since it happened to me and she wasn’t even aware when it happened and she apologized and I forgave her. That was it for a few days. Until my gf and Van started texting about the situation. Van was saying things like “well this is so out of character for Emmy” “Maybe it wasn’t her and she just thought it was Emmy” or “Do i need to call the club and ask for the footage?” all making it really clear to me he didn’t believe what happened. He didn’t believe me. Him and my gf fought for what felt like hours and it really wasn’t pretty. They were really close so it made me sad especially knowing it has something to do with me. For the next few days I just didn’t wanna think about it. I’ve already been having a really hard year so I was really struggling mentally. About a week after halloween I was trying to relax in the bath when I felt my phone buzz. It was two notifications. A text from Liz to our group chat followed by a *Liz has left the group* notification. Obviously I was confused so I clicked on the text to see a 5 page essay message about how we have been bad friends. Her message was full of a bunch of things we’ve all done wrong as a group (going all the way back to like 3 years ago) that deeply bothered her and Van (just not enough to voice those issues to us for years). And ended it by talking about the Emmy situation saying “while i will never be one to not believe the victim, as that is what should be happening in these situations, i do also believe that every side should be looked at. what i mean by this, before y’all get this twisted, is that someone else could have done what Emmy was said to do. based on every interaction i’ve had with Emmy, both sober and drunk, i do not think she would do something like this. I think there is a conversation to be had about that night. relatedly, maybe *the club* has cameras that could show what happened that night to help ease the tension, or find out if another person did this. however, i do not think jumping ship on one of our friends should be occurring, without a proper conversation.” then she left the gc and blocked everyone. Mind you she has known Emmy for approximately 5 months and we have been friends almost 5 years. And she literally claimed Emmy grabbed her butt that night too. I also have told them about how my brother was accused of assault in high school and proven innocent so I fully understand how big of an accusation it is and I would NEVER throw around such a serious thing or lie especially as someone who’s been a victim of SA before. So yeah. Liz if ur reading this I hope you know how much that message hurt me and I also hope you enjoy having no couch to sleep on.

And finally I talked to Van. He came over and we talked in my car instead of my apartment (he was hiding from my gf cause she lwk tore his ass UP over text) (shoutout my gf i love u ur a real one) anyways he got into my car and I told him that he needed to hear exactly what happened before we continued since he’d heard the story from everyone but me. And he agreed so I did. After I finished explaining it felt like I was arguing with Emmys lawyer and not my friend. He just kept going through every possibility as to how it could’ve NOT been her while also backtracking and then saying he believed me. He even said that “Emmy knew she was wrong and that she messed up” which I thought was really interesting cause days before she was saying she was blackout and didn’t remember a thing. Anyways the whole conversation felt so weird and then finally after like an hour of pointless circles he said “I just find it funny that you replaced one SA with another” and obviously I was like what the fuck are you talking about? He started going on and on about how one of our mutual friends we were with the thursday before halloween SA him and stuck her fingers down his throat. I didn’t see it happen but my gf did and she said he laughed it off and said it was fine after she said sorry and they moved on and kept hanging out. So I was obviously like I don’t know what this has to do with Emmy grabbing me but ok? And also there was no “replacing” because me and Emmy were never close. So yeah that really pmo so I looked at him and said “I know you aren’t genuinely comparing what happened to me to that right now”. To which he replied “How is that not SA that’s literally just as bad” and i responded “Well I don’t necessarily think that’s SA, maybe assault and it is weird, but I didn’t see it. Maybe if you had footage i’d believe you.” He looked shocked so I said “yeah it sucks when one of your best friends doesn’t believe you doesn’t it.” The one time in that whole conversation he shut the fuck up. So yeah then I told him to get out of my car and he said he was sorry and I said “good. now get the fuck out of my car”. Now he’s transferring jobs cause my gf was “bullying” him aka told our friends that work there what happened and why they weren’t friends.

I guess the reason i’m posting this is cause a part of me still feels crazy over the situation and also really mad that I didn’t call Emmy out right when it happened. In a way I kinda just want some sort of justice since I know i’m never getting an apology. Sorry it was long.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 3h ago

AITA for encouraging my 2 best friends to break up because I like one of them??

0 Upvotes

So I, female am in band and this new kid I'm going to name him Charles recently joined band and he is trans gender. He identifys as a boy but he looks like a girl and anyone who wasn't really close with him would not know. Especially since he has a female name but mostly gos by the male version of that name. So Charles has a girlfriend that is also one of my best friends. They have been dating for some time now recently they had a little argument and things have been awkward since then between them. BTW we are going to call his girlfriend jade. So as I was saying Charles and Jade have been going through a little argument and have been really distant with each other. So as I said before, Charles recently joined band and since he signed up to play the same instrument as I do, he asked me to mentor him. We go to the old room every Thursday so I can teach him one on one. So back to jade, she knows that I am close with Charles. So me and Jade were walking going to class and Charles was walking with some of his friends and Jade had yelled him name and waved at him but he didn't wave back so me being that good friend that I am in said "maybe he just didn't hear you" to jade then I yelled his name and he waved back this time so we kept walking and Jade was telling me how she didn't think that I'm Charles liked he anymore because they stoped texting they didn't talk at school and he was basically avoiding her as much as he could. Like this one one time I was walking with Charles and we had saw jade and I had waved to her but when Charles saw jade he quietly looked away and covered his face then when we were far enough from jade Charles had told me that he could not looked at herr anymore because the tension between was unbearable. Anyways we were switching classes and Charles had come up to me taking about something so random and then jade came up to us told us that she had been holding in her wazz for three hours and then she ran to the bathroom, so I looked at Charles and told her to go In there and talk to her and keep In mind Charles is trans gender and most people think that he's a girl he doesn't really tell anyone he's not close to so he just goes in the girls bathroom. Anyways we went in and got some odd reason there was a girl in the bathroom with their top off but they were still wearing a small T-SHIRT and I had looked over to Charles and he looked uncomfortable so we went out to wash our hands then we were talking about the situation between them and Jade comes out of the bathroom to wash her hands and because me and Charles were talking about her in a way not gossiping, we had went silent, then Charles just froze up and looked straight not even glancing at jade so he left before me and Jade did and she had asked me why when she came out we stop talking so I told her that we just weren't expecting her to come out so quickly or something like that. Of course I couldn't tell her about how we were talking about their relationship. Anyways fast forward to lunch that day jade and I were eating and she had told me that she wanted to break up Charles because she felt like Charles didn't like her anymore after the fight. So later I told Charles that jade was planning on breaking up with him and he said that he was also thinking about breaking up with her too because she had been catching feelings for someone else. And fast forward to Thursday we were in the old band room and I was helping him with something and I noticed something that was wrong so I fixed it and me and Charles looked eyes and then kissed.... We both pulled away quickly and we were freaking because he just cheated on his girlfriend and and I was basically a homewrecker!! But we both did enjoy and we promised that we would never tell anyone about what happened. So I went home that day and I realized something I was the one how he was catching feelings for it's all made sense. He had got into an argument with jade and while they weren't talking he had started catching feelings for me and he felt guilty and that's why he couldn't look or even talk to jade.so fast forward over the weekend made and Charles had texted all weekend and hung out a few times without jade knowing so it's Thursday and we were back in the old band room and before we started practicing Charles had said that he was going to break up with jade soon. He had said that he didn't have any feelings for her at all and wanted to be with me but still keep our relationship a secret. I was of course very shocked by this because I was the reason that my 2 best friends were breaking up. Honestly I do want to be with him too but I also don't wanna hurt my friend but on the other hand jade had said that she wanted to break up with Charles too so in hoping it will go smoothly. Hes doing it tomorrow. What should I do???

Am I wrong for em my 2 best friend to break up because I like one of them?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 7h ago

would i be the asshole if i cut off my friend?

0 Upvotes

I've been friends with this girl for about 3 years, and we recently got into a big argument because I didn't apologise. I said it's because I'm sick of having to say sorry, and now she's stopped talking to me. We've had a history of quick arguments and then going back to normal, but I really don't want to deal with her. Sarah (not real name) doesn't have the best home life, and I feel like I'm constantly walking on eggshells to make sure I'm not upsetting her, and it's just really tiring. She has also made me cut off a few of my old friends bc she doesn't like them. If I were to cut her off, we would still see each other because we have a few classes together; I just don't have very many other people I'm close enough with. If this matters, I'm also queer, and she's one of the only people I've come out to, and I don't know if she'll tell people if I stop being her friend. She's unpredictable, and im not sure if shell tell my parents or people in my community i dont want knowing.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 7h ago

Tipping

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 14h ago

AIO: My best friend invited me on her anniversary trip

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 17h ago

WIBTA to insist someone stops referring to me by an outdated nickname?

3 Upvotes

I used to sing a comedy song on karaoke. This earned me a nickname based on the cartoon character whose voice I sang it in. However, I haven't sang it for years now, and people refer to me by my real name - except one person who still keeps referring to me by that name in group chats and to my face, and I overhear him calling me that name to other people when he thinks I'm not within earshot, while he's talking about organising nights out.

One day, we were watching some stand-up comedians and a comedian asked this guy to introduce him to everyone on the table - and he referred to me by that name, and I had to explain it to a comedian who asked me to sing that song! I didn't mind, but we go regularly and there are different comedians there. It'll all get samey for the regulars. I asked him not to do it again to his face.

I've replied to messages in groups where he's called me that name, and I've replied with one word - my real name. Today, he did it again and I had to delete a message asking him not to because I thought it was harsh and I'm seeing him tonight and I don't want an atmosphere.

I don't think he means any harm by this.

WIBTA to explain to him, either to his face (which I've already done and he looked a bit shocked) and in a multi-paragraph message just saying that this nickname represents a person I've moved on from being, and that I wish to move on from the past?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 12h ago

Will I be the asshole to bring this up to my friends

0 Upvotes

So I’m an 18 yr old college student staying at hostel and I have a lip balm and it’s pretty good actually and it’s also lil expensive not very just reasonable price for its quality and its not those stick types it’s those box types were you have to scoop the lip balm out to use it and my friends happened to really really love it and they used to use mine like once a day or maybe twice and I really didn’t mind it cuz what else are there for as a friend…… but during recent days the usage has gone way higher than it usually used to be by my three friends who stay at the same hostel as me they don’t even use the right amount they scoop up way more than needed and waste the rest and I just bought a new one it’s like half done… and it kind of bugs me because like they use it more than me tbh I use it twice a day with the right amount and they use it six times with very high amount … imagine three ppl using it so yea I’m kind of confused if I should tell something about it or leave it as it is….. I feel like an ass hole just thinking about this but please do let me know what I should do in this situation 🥹🥹


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 5h ago

WIBTA if I pursued a woman my brother has just started dating, after I deliberately stepped aside for the sake of my family?

0 Upvotes

I'll try to explain the situation, because the background is important.

My sister won an expensive 3 week trip abroad and invited her best friend Chloe, our mother, and me.

I'm single. Before the trip, my sister had once mentioned that Chloe would be a good match for me, but immediately added that she didn't want anything to happen because Chloe was her best friend. I respected that, although I occasionally joked about sharing a room with Chloe during the holiday. She never found the jokes funny..

About ten days into the trip, Chloe kissed me. She told me she felt there was something between us and that she knew I wanted it too.

Shortly afterwards, she messaged me apologising, saying she might have misread the situation.

I told her yes she might have misread and I explained that my sister had made it very clear she didn't want us to get romantically involved. I told Chloe that, out of respect for my sister's wishes, I wasn't going to pursue anything. I suggested we simply enjoy the rest of the holiday.

Chloe understood, although she said she would keep some distance. Despite that, there was still a flirty atmosphere between us during the remaining days, and we continued spending time together.

Two days after the kiss, Chloe had told my sister what happened. My sister took it relatively well, but her position remained unchanged.

We returned home end of September, and Chloe and I continued messaging until mid October. We talked about travelling together, including snowboarding and other destinations we would both like to visit. We both love travelling and have a very similar travel style. She occasionally sent me reels about places we could potentially visit together.

Eventually, the conversation faded. Her last message was on October 17, which I liked but didn't reply to.

Then, last Thursday, I suddenly found out through our family group chat that my brother Ryan and Chloe were dating.

I had absolutely no idea.

My brother became defensive, explaining that Chloe was the only woman in ten years who regularly asked him how his day was going. He made it clear that he would decide for himself who he wanted to date. Apparently, he had asked her out the previous weekend, the date went well, and they're now seeing where things go. It's still very early.

Meanwhile, my sister has sent both my brother and me messages saying she's done with us and will never contact us again.

And this is where things get difficult.

I deliberately stepped aside because I wanted to avoid a family conflict. I gave up the possibility of something with Chloe because I respected my sister's wishes and wanted to keep the peace.

Now, roughly a month and a half later, that family conflict has happened anyway. My sister has cut contact with both of us, there's resentment between my brother and me, and our mother is caught in the middle.

I feel jealous, betrayed, resentful and honestly quite bitter. I sacrificed a potential relationship to protect my family, only to end up with neither the relationship nor the family peace I was trying to preserve.

I don't know whether my brother knew about the kiss or the connection Chloe and I had. I suspect he didn't. Chloe, however, certainly knew about my sister's objections and what had happened between us.

Part of me feels that I was the first person Chloe showed interest in, and that my brother only became involved afterwards. I realise I can't know for certain how she sees it.

I also genuinely believe Chloe and I might be more compatible than she and my brother. We have more in common in terms of personality, interests and lifestyle. My mother has expressed a similar opinion. Obviously, that doesn't guarantee a relationship would work, but it makes the situation harder to accept.

I'm now seriously considering reaching out to Chloe and telling her that I still have feelings for her and would like to explore whether something could happen between us.

My reasoning is that the original reason I didn't pursue her was to protect my relationship with my sister. But that relationship now appears to be broken regardless.

If I do nothing, my brother and Chloe will continue dating, and I'll have lost this opportunity twice: first by deliberately stepping aside, and now by choosing not to try again. If I reach out, she might still be interested, or she might prefer to continue dating my brother. Either way, at least I won't spend the rest of my life wondering what might have happened if I had stood up for what I wanted.

I understand that pursuing her now would be a betrayal of my brother. He has asked her out, they had a good date, and I know they're seeing each other. I'm not pretending that doesn't matter.

However, there's another side to this. My brother may initially have been unaware of what happened between Chloe and me. I can understand that. But if he learns the full story, knows that I had feelings for her and deliberately stepped aside because of my sister's ultimatum, and still chooses to pursue her, wouldn't he also be knowingly disregarding my feelings? Wouldn't that be a betrayal of me?

I also need to be honest about how far this has gone. At this point, I am certain I don't want to see my brother, indefinitely. I cannot imagine attending Christmas or family birthdays and watching him with the woman I wanted to pursue but gave up for the sake of my family.

It's even reached the point where I'd rather pay a mechanic to do something my brother would normally help me with, than rely on him for a favour while feeling this much resentment. That's how serious the rift is for me right now.

Realistically, I can see myself withdrawing from family gatherings altogether. My sister is already gone from my life, and I may end up being absent too. Our mother will be left in the middle, knowing that the woman my brother is now bringing into the family is the same woman I had feelings for and deliberately chose not to pursue.

I don't want to pretend my motivation is entirely selfless. I'm jealous, hurt and regret the decision I made. But I also feel I gave my sister's opinion far too much power over a personal decision that should ultimately have been mine.

So, WIBTA if I reached out to Chloe and told her I still have feelings for her, even though I know she has just started dating my brother?

I know it would be a betrayal of my brother. But given everything that happened, would it necessarily be wrong to do it? And if he knows the full story and still chooses to pursue her, isn't he also betraying me?

Am I wrong to finally put my own feelings and happiness first, even if it means going against my brother's new relationship, after already sacrificing a potential relationship to protect my family?

EDIT: I left out some context about why my sister cut me off. She already felt that Chloe and I had ruined her dream vacation because of the chemistry between us, even though we tried to be considerate of her feelings throughout the trip. Towards the end, she was also getting angry with me over all sorts of minor things, from driving too slowly because of traffic to stopping for fuel or the bad weather. Most of her frustration felt completely disproportionate.

When we got home, she essentially cut me off because she felt Chloe and I had ruined her holiday.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 1d ago

AITA for telling my dad and grandma that I want my friends money for my birthday party even though my dads inviting 70 friends of his?

80 Upvotes

hi! I’m 15 f, im turning 16 in january, my family is celebrating my 16 birthday and invited many people. I know, a bunch of expenses per person yes and table and I’m grateful.. but my parents told me to invite my friends which I was gonna do anyways, so I invited them.. I said my dad on the way to school that I’m Getting my gifts and the money from my friends. And he said no. Because he’s spending everything for my birthday and I got mad. I told him they are my friends and that I should deserve my friends gifts. And my grandma said the same. they are doing my hair, bought my dress and the venue and the food for the birthday cake and everything.. aita for saying I won’t give them my money that my friends will be giving me?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 16h ago

Reporting tattoo artist to IRS

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 16h ago

AITAH for moving my roommates veggie brush?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 18h ago

Is nepotism really unfair, or is it just how the world works?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes