r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 17m ago

Will I be the asshole to bring this up to my friends

0 Upvotes

So I’m an 18 yr old college student staying at hostel and I have a lip balm and it’s pretty good actually and it’s also lil expensive not very just reasonable price for its quality and its not those stick types it’s those box types were you have to scoop the lip balm out to use it and my friends happened to really really love it and they used to use mine like once a day or maybe twice and I really didn’t mind it cuz what else are there for as a friend…… but during recent days the usage has gone way higher than it usually used to be by my three friends who stay at the same hostel as me they don’t even use the right amount they scoop up way more than needed and waste the rest and I just bought a new one it’s like half done… and it kind of bugs me because like they use it more than me tbh I use it twice a day with the right amount and they use it six times with very high amount … imagine three ppl using it so yea I’m kind of confused if I should tell something about it or leave it as it is….. I feel like an ass hole just thinking about this but please do let me know what I should do in this situation 🥹🥹


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 1h ago

WIBTA for ordering my own turkey on Thanksgiving?

43 Upvotes

We decided last minute to visit my in laws for Thanksgiving.

Growing up, my family would always get honeybaked ham smoked turkey, and it’s the thing I look forward to the most. I love making little sandwiches out of it alongside sharp cheddar cheese and Hawaiian rolls; that’s pretty much all I eat on Thanksgiving.

I was about to place an order to have the HBH turkey shipped to my in-laws house, and my husband excitedly told me his mom bought a whole turkey for Thanksgiving. I was immediately disappointed. Not only do I look forward to the honeybaked ham turkey every year, but also, my MIL is very bad at cooking meats; they are always extremely dry. Like, choking on the food dry.

Would I be the asshole for still ordering my favorite turkey even though she’s going to make a whole turkey?

I will probably put a slice of her turkey on my plate to be polite, but I’m not interested in eating it, and I don’t eat ham.

Edit to add: we will be staying at my in-laws house Nov 21-Dec 3.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 1h ago

WIBTA for not spending Christmas with my partner?

4 Upvotes

I 30f and my partner 33m have been dating for 2.5yrs and will be our 3rd Christmas together. However, I don't want to spend it with him, due to his behaviour over the last year and recently.

We don't live together, he rents a room and I own a flat with my cat. He does have a key, but I've asked him to message when hes coming over, so I can be ready or let him know if I'm not home and shouldn't come over. Plus, when he has let himself in without letting me know, it's awkward as sometimes I'm getting out of the shower and there he is, which makes me jump. A few times I've messaged him night before asking him not to come over due to feeling a migraine coming on and to get rid, I need sleep and quiet, but the next morning he's over and in the kitchen making a tone of noise! Plus, I've never seen inside where he lives, I've only ever picked or dropped him off.

What happened a few months ago has changed my view on the relationship completely and nearly ended right then and there. I had a bank issue causing my mortgage payment to bounce back and I didn't realise until receiving a letter, but phoned to pay straight away. I put the letter back in the envelope and on the side thinking nothing more, as its sorted.

A few days later we called to catch up and say goodnight. I asked what he'll like for Christmas but then he said this "Don't worry about getting me anything as I saw the letter about the mortgage payment and if you lose your flat, that's basically us over" I was stunned and hung up on him. He messaged saying thats not what he meant and of course he'll still date me if I didn't have my flat.

Since then, I'm slowly getting more annoyed, reflected on our whole relationship and realised he's said a lot of hurtful things.

This year, I want to spend Christmas morning at home alone and then head over to my parents to spend the night with them and come home boxing day evening.

I have mentioned spending Christmas with my family and he said "I thought I was coming to over to cook again, so what am I suppose to do now?" I did feel bad, but he pays nothing towards my flat and cooking here last year was stressful and not in the good way. He then followed up with "I could come over to check in on baby (cat)" but shot that down as I don't want him over without me there after knowing hes read my post and probably going to use my PS4 to game while over. So I did kindly say no and that if he does come over without my permission or knowledge, I'm taking the key back or changing the locks.

My family did invite him over for our first Christmas, but over the years, they don't want to be around him as they don't like him at all!

So would I be the a**hole for not wanting to spend Christmas with my partner?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 2h ago

AIO: My best friend invited me on her anniversary trip

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 4h ago

Reporting tattoo artist to IRS

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 5h ago

AITAH for moving my roommates veggie brush?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 5h ago

WIBTA to insist someone stops referring to me by an outdated nickname?

3 Upvotes

I used to sing a comedy song on karaoke. This earned me a nickname based on the cartoon character whose voice I sang it in. However, I haven't sang it for years now, and people refer to me by my real name - except one person who still keeps referring to me by that name in group chats and to my face, and I overhear him calling me that name to other people when he thinks I'm not within earshot, while he's talking about organising nights out.

One day, we were watching some stand-up comedians and a comedian asked this guy to introduce him to everyone on the table - and he referred to me by that name, and I had to explain it to a comedian who asked me to sing that song! I didn't mind, but we go regularly and there are different comedians there. It'll all get samey for the regulars. I asked him not to do it again to his face.

I've replied to messages in groups where he's called me that name, and I've replied with one word - my real name. Today, he did it again and I had to delete a message asking him not to because I thought it was harsh and I'm seeing him tonight and I don't want an atmosphere.

I don't think he means any harm by this.

WIBTA to explain to him, either to his face (which I've already done and he looked a bit shocked) and in a multi-paragraph message just saying that this nickname represents a person I've moved on from being, and that I wish to move on from the past?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 6h ago

Is nepotism really unfair, or is it just how the world works?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 12h ago

WIBTAH for not reaching out to my mom?

0 Upvotes

I got into an argument with my mom about my dad and the things he has done to me over the years. Ex. Abandon me at airports, train stations etc.

I had a baby a few months ago and they are suppose to come up to meet him for the first time on thanksgiving. The second day that he was born they wanted to come up to see him and I found out they were sick and said no. I told my mom that because of this I’m nervous for them to come up. She got mad and said she was hurt and that maybe it was better if they didn’t come up after all.

This shocked me but I guess it shouldn’t have given her history. She has a long history of threatening to back out of trips right before they happen. Normally I play along and try to talk her back into things. However this time it feels different. She’s not just bailing on me, she’s bailing on my son.

I don’t want to allow this behavior so I sent her a text that said that I want her to come and have a relationship with her grand child but she can’t do things like this. This might be where I went wrong. I asked her to apologize for trying to bail if she still wanted to come. Idk maybe that’s too far.

She hasn’t responded and it’s been over a day. Now it seems to me like she cares more about being right than meeting her grandchild.

I’m not trying to teach her a lesson or anything but I feel like if I don’t set this boundary here and now she is going to keep doing this forever. I don’t want to have a disappointed child in the future whose grandma bailed on him because she got into an argument with me or someone else. I think that if I cave now and reach out again I will be creating/perpetuating a bad cycle that will affect my son. WIBTA for not reaching out a second time?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 14h ago

WIBTA for standing up to my mom?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 15h ago

AITA if I don’t go to Thanksgiving

48 Upvotes

Backstory I moved my family across the country to be closer to my sister and her kids. Every time we make plans she changes them. Case in point we had planned a nice quiet family thanksgiving (my family and hers) and then today she texts to let me know she invited her neighbors who I do not enjoy being around (and her own college age daughter specifically requested she not invite them). Plus a couple more families we’ve never met.

She’d asked me to bring several dishes originally and now I’d not only be cooking for our 2 families but all these other families I never agreed to, two of which I don’t even know.

My husband said he doesn’t want to go, and my kids are heartbroken because they were looking forward to enjoying time with their cousins.

Personally I feel disrespected and disappointed she did this AGAIN. She’s done this almost every holiday since we moved here 4 years ago. I’m just over it!

It’s one thing to plan a big party from the get go, that’s fine. It’s the changing of plans after we’d already made arrangements.

Do I tell her the real reason we are not attending or make an excuse? I feel like telling her would be honest but not sure it would improve the relationship.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 17h ago

AITAH

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

AITAH? A short story.

I apologize in advance as this is long but I feel it’s important to give context. A couple years have passed since this all occurred but I am still so bothered by it and would appreciate some feedback.

My now two ex best friends of roughly 15 years and I are no longer on speaking terms. For the purpose of this story, I’ll call them Dani and Tori. Dani, Tori and I met freshman year of high school and were immediately inseparable. Constant sleepovers, texting/ talking on the phone, involved in sports together, vacations, pretty much sisters. Our parents even became friendly because of how often we would hangout.

When it was time for college, Tori decided to go out of state. Though, we all stayed extremely close and visited each other on several occasions throughout the four years. Once we graduated, we all ended up back in the same state and once again, would hangout as often as possible (couple times a week if not more).

Naturally, as girlfriends do, we would talk about our future weddings throughout the years and how we were obviously all going to be in each other’s wedding parties when the day came. Dani, throughout all the years, was always very focused on a timeline. She had to get married and have kids by a certain age for no apparent reason. Well, fast forward and at the time this occurred, we were all in our late 20’s and Dani was engaged. She pushed for it, but that is a different story. Anyway, by this point, we all once again lived in separate places (all within a couple hours of each other). We would still try and see each other at least twice a year with all three of us and talk on the phone/ text somewhat frequently in the group chat. However, within the last year or two of our friendship, I started to notice that Dani and Tori would either not respond to my messages, or if they did, the conversation was noticeably cut short. I chalked it up to everyone being busy in our lives and having different schedules. Plus, when we did get together, whether it was all together or hanging out one- on- one, everything appeared normal and we would pick up right where we left off.

Although, one of the last times we all saw each other in person, a comment was made. Something along the lines of how Dani and Tori talk a lot more often (which I was not aware of) because they have the same job and I “just wouldn’t understand”. At the time, I just brushed it off and didn’t make it a big deal but safe to say my feelings were definitely hurt. Not only did I find out two of my best friends talk all the time and not include me but on top of it, they’re insulting me. It wasn’t like they’re both rocket scientists, have highly classified jobs or have difficult jobs to explain, they just simply did not want to bother. Not to mention, a lot of my other friends have the same job as Dani and Tori and we talk about our jobs together all the time.

Anyway, it’s the year Dani is engaged. Due to her timeline, it is a shorter engagement (married within less than a year ) so safe to say all of the typical wedding festivities are somewhat last minute. I already had a couple vacations booked for the year. If I knew ahead of time that she would be engaged and married as quickly as she was, being one of her best friends, I would have held off on planning trips. Honestly, although she was pushing for an engagement, I did not realize it was coming as soon as it did.

Dani messaged Tori and I that she was looking to schedule a date for her wedding a specific month in the summer of that year. I jokingly said that I had a trip already booked for certain dates so if she could possibly avoid those dates that would be awesome. (Yes, it was a joke. I know it is her wedding and she can get married whenever she so chose). Well, turns out Dani did in fact pick a date when I would be away. I was devastated that I might actually miss my best friend’s wedding. However, when I told her that I might not be able to make it since I was scheduled to be away, she did not appear to care. This specific trip was a cruise to the Mediterranean, so I did not think I would be able to reschedule it without losing a ton of money, if not all of it. But! I could not miss my best friend’s wedding. I mean, I was supposed to be a bridesmaid right? This was her special day that she has been talking about forever and I wanted to be there for her. Sure enough, a couple calls were made and I was able to reschedule the cruise for different dates and different destinations. Although, I had previously been to most of those destinations before, it was worth it to me being that I could now go to Dani’s wedding. The airline ended up losing my luggage for this trip but again, that is a different story.

The months leading up to the wedding I did not hear much about plans/ festivities. I would even check in to make sure everything was okay and if any assistance was needed. I thought this was odd that I wasn’t hearing anything since prior to this, Dani would not stop talking about being married and all to come with it. Dani’s older sister “Nat” was her maid of honor. Nat and I had met several times throughout the years but she was older, did not live at home and wasn’t around much. Honestly, because of the age gap the two really weren’t very close at all so it was surprising in itself that she was the MOH.

A bridal shower was planned but unfortunately, it was while I was due to be away again. This specific trip was to visit another best friend of mine so I couldn’t bail. Dani said she understood and that it was no big deal. I mentioned celebrating at the bachelorette party and she said she wasn’t certain she even wanted one. I figured Nat would reach out at some point if there would be one.

A few months leading up to the wedding I kept trying to make plans with Dani for our typical in person check ins. She bailed once or twice but then we finally got together. I was asking all about the wedding planning, how she was feeling about everything, etc. She was very quiet the whole time which was very unlike her. I was basically pulling information from her. She mentioned that she still wasn’t sure if she wanted a bachelorette party. I hinted at a bridal party and if I was still going to be apart of it and she said that she actually was not going to have a typical bridal party. Alright, if that’s what you want I get it. Then she casually throws in that Tori and “Kathy” (another friend of hers) would be standing next to her. Taken back and at a loss for words I just sat there in silence. She came up with some lame excuse as to why that was and I could not come up with words. I was so hurt that I was being left out. I didn’t understand what was going on. I’m supposed to be your best friend too why did you not want me apart of this with you?

About two weeks after this meet up, I see all over social media that Dani is at her bachelorette party. WTF!? I messaged Dani and Tori. Dani did not get back to me until days after the fact. Tori messaged back that “Nat” wanted to keep the bachelorette small. How did I not make the list but another girl who Dani told me she drifted apart from, made the list of invites? Dani lied straight to my face. She knew all about her bachelorette trip (it was a destination) she just didn’t have the heart or respect to tell me I wasn’t included.

A week or two go by, surely Tori or Dani are going to reach out. They both know how upset and angry I am. More time passes, I still don’t hear from them. Finally, I can’t take it anymore and reach out to Tori. She was always great at breaking things down and making sense of them. Nope, she just avoids the conversation “talk to Dani”. I just didn’t have it in me yet. A couple days pass and I finally reach out to Dani. “ I knew about my bachelorette when I saw you but didn’t want to make things awkward. You were invited to the bridal shower though”. The bridal shower you knew I couldn’t make?

I expressed to her that I felt extremely hurt, unwelcomed/unwanted and wasn’t sure why I was being pushed away. Nothing happened? She could not give me an answer. At that point, I told her I wasn’t sure if I should go to the wedding as it seemed like no one cared if I showed. It just felt like a pity invite at that point. She did not ask me to come. She simply responded with “if you don’t come to my wedding our friendship is over and that I would be the reason”. I never responded. She deleted me from everything the following day and I never heard from her again.

That same month was Tori’s birthday. I messaged her Happy Birthday. About a month after, she messaged asking for a favor (which I did not do). That was the last I heard from Tori.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 17h ago

My sister calls me selfish for suggesting we drive separately on the six-hour Thanksgiving trip. Since her cars aren’t reliable, she’ll borrow Mom’s new car but blames me for the mileage. She says I’m ungenerous and won’t exchange favors again. My husband and I are already exhausted before the trip

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 17h ago

AITA Parent or is my son?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 18h ago

WIBTA for refusing a gift?

0 Upvotes

So, I hate suprises. I get annoying about wanting to know what im getting for christmas, my birthday, etc. I dont hate randomized gifts though, so Ive never discouraged friends or family from giving them. Today, through friend 1, I found out friend 2 is planning on giving me a shirt for christmas, one with an AI meme on it, which she is very aware that I hate. I not only find the meme unfunny, but the AI itself goes against my beliefs. Overall, the shirt is boring humour and tacky.

At our friends christmas party next month, would I be the asshole if I flat out refused to take the gift home? Or should I speak privately with friend 2, and tell her to cancel the order or re-gift it? Either way, I feel like ungrateful and maybe too woke for not even wanting to own something AI, or re-gift it myself.

This isnt the most serious/dire situation, but ive never had someone (seemingly) give a gift they know i'll hate.

UPDATE: Good-ish news, I talked to friend 2 because I could definitely see how I might be entitled (however, I still dont think asking for a kind/well thought gift is wrong of me, as some of you have said) I asked her, just flat out: Why get me a gift of something you KNOW I hate and wont ever wear? Her answer was kind of suprising. She said she wasnt the one thinking about getting it for me. Friend 1 was. So, I'm assuming it was a test of my reaction for friend 1? Crisis SOMEWHAT averted.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 18h ago

AITA For Bringing My Dog To The Grocery Store?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 19h ago

AITAH? Had a big falling out with a couple I was close friends with

2 Upvotes

For a bit of context, when I was 18 I moved to Australia from the uk on my own. A bit less than a year afterward I met this guy we will call him D. D comes from generational wealth and has had a very privileged upbringing. Only a few months into being friends he proclaimed I was his best friend and all this and that.

Shortly after he met me, he started seeing this girl who I will call K. K also comes from generational wealth and has had a very privileged upbringing. To be honest I really did not like her at first but I gave her the benefit of the doubt and they both ended up moving into the house I was renting. For a while things were great me and D would do everything together. But cracks started to show, there was a lack of respect for any basic boundaries I put in place he would always go into my room and take my stuff without asking me first, would always take my socks out the wash room, would never do any work around the house and over time it really started to get on my nerves.

This went on for a while and all this frustration had pent up in me. One day I had to leave for work and couldn’t find my keys so I asked them to leave the door unlocked for me, they had locked me out in the past so I made sure to make it very clear that they needed to leave the door unlocked. Fast forward I get home from work and they’ve both gone out drinking and locked me out and to be honest that was the final straw for me I just went off at them. Before I got home I had called D and said “hey man you guys left the door unlocked yeah?” And he was like “yeah bro I’m pretty sure we did” so I said “if I get there and it’s locked you know you’ve got to come straight here and let me in” and D was happy to do that. So I get home, doors locked, call him. No answer.

I called him maybe like 50 times and when he did pick up I had a bit of a go but I didn’t say what I was truly thinking because I didn’t want to upset him. It took almost 2 hours for him to get home and let me in and when he got there I did not speak to him. A little while after he comes in my room borderline crying and talking about “respect” which I thought was ironic but I also felt bad for him so we made up.

Things were very downhill from there everything me and D used to do together, he stopped doing with me and started doing it with K which obviously hurt me. This went on for a while and when our lease came to an end I decided to find my own place. Before they had moved into the house, one of my feet had gone through a floorboard so there was a hole in the floor I took full responsibility for that and was happy to pay it, I even messaged my landlord multiple times asking them to send someone over but it never happened.

Then one day when we were all living there we had this random guy come over for afters and he basically stood in the hole and put a hole in the ceiling downstairs. We never got this fixed while living there and when it came to moving out it was just gonna come out of our bond. Again, I was happy to pay for the floorboard as it was directly my fault but the ceiling no, keep in mind I had been living paycheck to paycheck at the time and both of them coincidentally had inherited triple figures at the same time. So I struck up a deal for how this would be paid for, the bill was $600 I offered to pay 400 and they paid 100 each which in my head was more than fair and actually worked in their favor, they outright refused this and said I had to pay for all of it which was like all of my savings at the time.

However I was the one getting the bond back so I was sort of like fuck you and just deducted the $200 from their part of the bond. For them this was the last straw, they completely cut me off after that.

I’ve just recently heard that they have been going around talking shit about me, and also I spoke to one of our mutual friends and the story they’ve told is basically just not what went down and twisted to make me look like a bad person. I could go on and on about this stuff and that is only the tip of the iceberg with these two. When I heard he was talking shit about me to my EX as well who is the one who told me it really made me angry so I sent him some messages basically saying fuck you keep my name out of your mouth. This only happened this morning though which is also what compelled me to make this post as I’d like to hear some unbiased outsider opinions on this whole situation. Thanks for taking the time to read this.


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 19h ago

AITAH for not killing 5 people for my best friend ? (Trolley problem)

Post image
1 Upvotes

Recently, I was asked a hypothetical by a friend(not the best friend) “A trolley is heading towards your best friend. You can pull the lever to divert it to the other track, killing 5 strangers instead. What do you do?” And I said that I would NOT pull the lever. Then my best friend overheard , now my best friend is mad at me.

(The person who asked me was not the best friend who is mad)


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 19h ago

AITA for arguing over what was initially a coffee?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 21h ago

WIBTA for making myself “sick” to get out of going to Thanksgiving

12 Upvotes

So I (19F) have a history of constipation which has led me to be aware of a specific drink called magnesium citrate. If you look it up on social media, you will know why it is very good for people who struggle with constipation.

(I also would totally suggest it if you do have trouble with constipation)

Well, for the past few years, I have been looking for reasons to get out going to my paternal grandparents for Thanksgiving. My grandmother on that side of the family loves to stir up drama between the members of the family and trying to get them to gang up on each other. I have always hated going to their place for Thanksgiving.

They also have a huge cockroach problem there.

There is no way I can convince either of my parents to let me stay home for the holiday, and last year I tried to buy a plant that was known to make people throw up. Unfortunately, that had no affects on me.

I really don’t wanna deal with any petty drama or shallow interactions as I am currently busy with a huge project I’ve been running.

I really just don’t wanna deal with manipulative people

Well, since I know the effects of magnesium citrate and I happen to have a bottle on hand, I am planning to use it to get off Thanksgiving.

Would I be the asshole?

Update

We’re not going to their place this year
🙌🙌


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 22h ago

WIBTAH for cutting my friend off?

2 Upvotes

I met my best friend a few years ago. We're going to call her G. We met when we were early teenagers, around 6 years ago. I had a crush on her when we first met. That didn't last long, I then met my girlfriend (she's my sister's friend lol) I just had a big crush on her for a very long time, but finally started dating her this year. Ok, this is not about me. Let's continue.

With G, we've been through a lot together. She's heard me out, viceversa, etc and she's also done some very stuff to me. I surprisingly forgave her many times. Some of the things she did were not ok. She ruined my rep at the church like 3 years ago, but she always apologized and I'd buy it.

This year, she went off to college. Her parents were concerned because her cousin studies there. That cousin is a mess. Abuses alcohol, smokes the green stuff, sleeps around, and a lot of things a kid her age shouldn't be doing.

My friend started doing the same things as her cousin.

\- She's drunk texted me a few times.

\- She drunk called me when I was about to have dinner with my girlfriend. I put on speaker and she said "ahhh I'm drunk. Look I'm with my friend Stacy. Hey Stacy, look, this is Rude Philosopher (ofc that's not my name) I really like him". My gf was pissed and we had our first fight that night.

\- She cheated on her boyfriend of 2 years for a redneck.

\- She then got a new guy and started smoking green stuff.

\- She might be pregnant. Apparently she got a stomach bug.

Look, I don't think I'm the one to judge. I love G, but there's no point in always trying to make her behave and take care of herself. I'm not even mad. I'm upset and I'm not willing to fight for something that won't even go somewhere.

One of the reasons I haven't sent her off is because her mom is part of the worship group at church and we have our weekly practice on Wednesdays. We're really good friends.

Would I be the asshole?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 23h ago

AITA for telling my cousin what her best friend said about her, even though it caused my entire friend group to turn against me?

1 Upvotes

I’m 19M, and everyone involved is around my age. Here’s a quick breakdown:
OP (me): 19M
Ryan: 20M (one of my closest friends)
Ethan: 19M (good friend and former coworker)
Natalie: 19F (my cousin)
Brooke: 19F (my cousin’s best friend)
Chloe: 19F
Vanessa: 19F
I’m going to try to explain this as clearly as possible because there’s a lot of context. I’m genuinely looking for outside opinions because I don’t know if I handled this situation correctly.
How everything started
Before I left for Portugal, my cousin Natalie tried setting me up with her best friend Brooke. However, I never really entertained the idea because I was involved with someone else at the time. That relationship eventually ended, and I went to Portugal for a soccer opportunity.
After returning to California, I eventually started spending more time with Brooke.
Around the time before I left for Japan for my birthday vacation, Brooke and I started hanging out. We went out twice, once for ice cream and another time for food and a movie. Honestly, I had a really good time with her.
I never kissed her or did anything physical. During our second date, I briefly put my hand on her leg, but I took it off because I wasn’t sure if she was comfortable with it. I didn’t want to make her feel pressured or uncomfortable.
After that date, we texted for a little while, but eventually she stopped responding. I asked her if everything was okay, and she sent me this:
“Honestly what we ‘have’ is kinda scaring me and you treat me very well and i am scared for it to go south. I am not healed from my past relationships yet and i dont want to ruin what we could potentially have. I really do love the person you are and i js dont want to hurt you. I promise this isnt a typical girl excuse of saying ‘oh i just dont want a relationship rn’ i genuinely mean it.”
She also mentioned that she wanted to hang out when I returned from Japan.
I eventually left for Japan for my birthday, and when I came back to California, we made plans to hang out again.
Halloween Horror Nights
We all decided to go to Halloween Horror Nights. It was me, Natalie, Ethan, and Brooke.
At this point, I was getting mixed signals. I didn’t really know where I stood with Brooke, so I figured I’d flirt a little and see how things went. If she wasn’t interested, I would back off.
The night was going well until we got onto the tram ride. Ethan started joking around and said something along the lines of, “Yo, count how many shoulders you have,” clearly trying to get me to put my arm around Brooke.
Before I even attempted to touch her, Brooke leaned onto Natalie and loudly said, “Don’t touch me, don’t fucking touch me.”
I hadn’t even reached for her.
I responded with something like, “You’re good, I wasn’t even going to try.”
I’m not going to lie, that embarrassed me. It happened in front of everyone, and I felt genuinely humiliated. I wasn’t trying to make anyone uncomfortable, and I had no intention of touching her without her wanting me to.
The confusing part is that toward the end of the night, during the last two mazes, Brooke held my hand and held onto my arm because she was scared. I put my arm around her, and we held hands. After each maze, I let go and didn’t continue touching her.
When we got back to Brooke’s house, which was our meeting point, she went inside without even giving me a hug or anything. I just said goodnight, and she said goodnight back.
Throughout the night, I had also been turning to Ethan and quietly asking him things like, “What’s going on?” and “Isn’t this whole night supposed to be a lob?” He agreed that the situation was confusing.
After that night, I told Ryan everything. We both thought the whole situation was strange, and we started joking about the “don’t touch me” incident.
I told Ryan I didn’t really want to text Brooke anymore because the situation left a bad taste in my mouth. I stopped initiating conversations. The most I did was continue our Snapchat streak.
Things started getting confusing again
Then, out of nowhere, Brooke texted me while I was in class, saying something along the lines of, “Hi, I was thinking about you.”
I wasn’t particularly interested in pursuing anything anymore, so I responded politely. We talked a little, but nothing really came of it.
She also reached out while I was at a Lakers game another time, and we had another conversation.
I wasn’t really making an effort to pursue her anymore, but she would occasionally reach out.
Then came the Halloween party.
The Halloween party
This is where everything started going downhill.
I had an absolutely terrible day. I worked a 10-hour shift, had been arguing with my parents, and was mentally exhausted. Ryan asked if I wanted to go to a party, and honestly, I said yes because I just wanted to have a good time.
Throughout the night, Brooke and I were texting whenever I had the chance. Eventually, she mentioned that she thought we were going to the same party. I told her I wasn’t 100% sure I was going, but she said she really wanted me there.
I ended up going.
Natalie was extremely drunk that night. She was honestly acting completely different from how I usually see her.
Throughout the party, Ryan and Ethan were making jokes about the Horror Nights incident. Brooke initially gave us a side-eye, but eventually she started using the same joke herself.
I want to mention this because it becomes relevant later.
Toward the end of the night, Natalie was extremely drunk and was sitting in Ethan’s car. It was me, Ryan, and Brooke still at the party when Ethan came to pick Brooke up because he was her ride.
We decided to leave because Ryan and I also had to pick up two other friends.
While we were walking back, Brooke said something along the lines of not wanting to deal with Natalie right now and not wanting to stay over if Natalie was going to act like that.
I don’t remember her exact wording, but I remember the conversation.
I turned to Ryan and whispered something like, “That’s fucked up, right?”
He responded that he honestly thought it was fake as fuck.
I want to clarify that Ryan was completely sober and heard the same conversation I did. He wasn’t just agreeing with me afterward. He was there.
The following day
The next day, Ryan and I were at the gym with another friend, and we brought up what happened. We both felt that Natalie deserved to know what had been said about her.
Ryan ended up texting Natalie first and explaining what happened. Natalie then asked me about it, and I told her the exact same thing.
However, Natalie took Brooke’s side.
She brought up the fact that I had lied to her in the past and said she couldn’t trust me. I acknowledged that I had lied to her before, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But I genuinely believed what I was telling her this time, and Ryan was an independent witness who heard the same thing.
Halloween and the aftermath
Then Halloween came around.
Everyone ended up going to a frat party except me. I wasn’t invited, and I couldn’t really get into the party anyway because of the fraternity situation, so I stayed home.
The next morning, I woke up to find that Brooke had unfollowed me, Chloe had blocked me, and Vanessa had unfollowed me.
Apparently, Natalie and Brooke had been telling the others everything.
One of the things being discussed was the “don’t touch me” joke from Horror Nights. They were saying that the joke was making fun of Brooke’s consent and that it made her uncomfortable.
Here’s something important: Brooke never once directly told me that the jokes made her uncomfortable. I only found that out afterward, when everyone started distancing themselves from me.
Another thing that came out was that Natalie told Chloe I had a huge crush on her.
For context, I had a pretty big crush on Chloe at one point, but this was way before everything with Brooke happened.
Chloe and I had hung out a couple of times, just the two of us, but I never made those hangouts into dates. Everything was strictly platonic. I never confessed my feelings to her, never told her I liked her, and never tried to make her feel like I was pursuing something more.
I kept those feelings to myself because I genuinely valued our friendship and didn’t want to risk ruining it or creating unnecessary drama.
Some of my closest friends knew about the crush, including Natalie. I would tell Natalie how much I liked Chloe and how I would love for her to be my girlfriend someday. Natalie would actually root for me and encourage me.
Looking back, I might have made it seem to Natalie like something between Chloe and me could eventually happen, even though I never actually pursued it. I think I became so attached to the idea of us being together that Natalie ran with it.
Regardless, I never intended for Chloe to find out because I didn’t want to put her in an uncomfortable position or change our friendship.
Finding out that Natalie shared something I had trusted her with was another thing that hurt.
Where things stand now
Out of everyone involved, Ryan is the only person who has really stood by me. Natalie still wants to be friends with me, but she has made it clear that she wants to distance herself from me heavily.
The other people involved seem to believe that I made up the entire story about what Brooke said because I was upset that I couldn’t “crack” her.
For those who don’t know, apparently they think I was upset that Brooke and I never ended up together, so I fabricated the conversation about her saying those things about Natalie out of spite.
I genuinely find that accusation absurd.
First of all, I wasn’t the only person who heard that conversation. Ryan was there, completely sober, and heard the exact same thing I did. He independently agreed that what was said was messed up before we even discussed telling Natalie.
Second, I genuinely liked Brooke. I wasn’t just trying to hook up with her or prove that I could get her to like me. I actually wanted to pursue a relationship with her. We had gone on dates, I enjoyed spending time with her, and I was interested in seeing where things could go.
Things didn’t work out, and I accepted that. I stopped pursuing her after the Horror Nights situation because I felt embarrassed and confused. That doesn’t mean I suddenly had some reason to invent a story about her.
I also understand that people might question my credibility because Natalie brought up times I had lied to her in the past. I acknowledged that history, but I genuinely believe what I’m saying happened this time.
What hurts the most is that it feels like people have already decided I’m lying without actually hearing me out. I feel like I’ve lost friendships, damaged my relationship with my cousin, and had something personal about me shared with someone I never intended to tell.
I’m not claiming to be perfect. I can acknowledge that making jokes about the Horror Nights incident might have been insensitive, and I can understand why Brooke might have felt uncomfortable even if she never communicated that to me.
But I also don’t think it’s fair to accuse me of fabricating an entire conversation when another sober person was there and heard it too.

So yall, AITA for making jokes about the Horror Nights situation and telling my cousin what her best friend said about her? Was I wrong for getting involved, or am I being unfairly painted as the villain in this situation?


r/WouldIBeTheAhole • • 1d ago

AITA for not wanting to be friends after feeling left out and being cussed out??

0 Upvotes

so for context, ive beenin this friend group for about 5 years, we're all girls, went to an ALL girls' school and have grown close in the past 5 years. We recently went our separate ways to college, all studying different courses. out of the 5 of them, 1 of them lets call them amy, goes to my college. we had all planned to meet up every friday's and debrief our week and lives, but this si where it goes wrong. weve all been in college for about 2 months, so ive made new friends but not like a whole NEW friend group. the last time all 5 of us met is where everything changed. i had previously told amy that id felt left out before and when i talk about myself or my personal life, they seem to brush it off completely and ive felt like this for some time. and when all of us met up, they did the same EXACT THING. they actively talked over me and when i stopped speaking, they all stopped speaking. and when one of themwere talking about anything, they were all of a sudde interest?? so for context i was talking to a guy seriously and it didnt end well, and i had told them how i felt and the same week me and him ending things, i had exams and my birthday. so obviously mentally i wasnt doing well. but after the day we met up, i sent some silly tik tok in a group hat of 4 of us because one of them cant get tik tok, besides the point, once again, they ignored me. so i took it upon myself to text amy and ask what was going on. this is where it gets bad. amy sents a whole paragraph in our shared group chat with all 5 of us basically saying how its not our fault you feel left out and were sorry you felt like that. at first we were trying to sort it out, i had said how ive felt like this for quite some time and i dont feel appricaited like they treat each other. but then, they started cussing me out and calling me names such as a "hoe" and "immature". mind you i didnt start it, i was trying to communicate about how i felt left out and ignored, but for them to cuss me out and ALL go against me is insane to me. so in retaliation i defended myself, telling them to not call me those names and its disrespectful and i didnt expect it from them. in return, they just carried out and even hanged out without me and sent me a picture of it, they even reposted about having a "group of 4" or "losing useless people in my life". i asked if we were even still friends after this and they said it was up to me. now they just send messages on the same groupchat where they cussed me out on and act like nothing happened. so am i the asshole for still wanting to be friends with them or should i not forgive and forget. any advice helps!!!