Am I a lawyer? No, but neither are you. Am I your lawyer? I'm as close as you're going to get: a law student on a looooot of stimulants.
For my first trick, I turned The Locker into a torts issue spotter and dragged an innocent professor into it. The conclusion reached was that Wildbow was right all along in portraying The Locker as something that would end in a small civil settlement.
Now, in order to study for an upcoming final, I have applied the principles of statutory interpretation to a question that has dogged this fandom since 2011: was The Locker bioterrorism?
Note that this is not a criminal law analysis. It is an examination of the statutory language and surrounding history to determine whether Congress could have meant "used tampon" when they said "biological weapon." In this scenario, I'm taking on the role of a lawyer in the Department of Justice to decide whether it's possible to charge the trio with use of a bioweapon using these tools. Many people have said yes, but - on the pain of failing - the answer is No.
Sorry.
Fact Pattern
After a year and a half of relentless bullying, one high school student shoves another from behind into a locker and locks her in. The locker is full of trash, most of it used menstrual products, that has been left there to rot for two weeks.
Assumptions
We will assume that S. aureus is present and alive in the locker. We will also assume that the victim herself did not bring it with her (though there is a 1 in 3 chance she did), and that it got there solely via the used hygiene products.
The Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act of 1989 was amended following 9/11, which did not happen in our hypothetical. We will assume that there was no need to update the act in 2001/2002 and therefore use the original text enacted in 1990.
All five instances I can find of people being charged under this law took place after 9/11. We will therefore assume that the US government in our hypothetical has never charged anyone under this statute and that there is no precedent to consult.
Statutory Text
§ 175: Prohibitions With Respect to Biological Weapons: "Whoever knowingly develops, produces, stockpiles, transfers, acquires, retains, or possesses any biological agent, toxin, or delivery system for use as a weapon, or knowingly assists a foreign state or any organization to do so, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned for life or any term of years, or both."
§ 178: Definitions: "As used in this chapter . . . (3) the term 'delivery system' means—(A) any apparatus, equipment, device, or means of delivery specifically designed to deliver or disseminate a biological agent, toxin, or vector; or (B) any vector; and (4) the term 'vector' means a living organism capable of carrying a biological agent or toxin to a host."
Question
Does a pile of used menstrual products, accumulated over the course of multiple weeks and used in a battery, qualify as a "delivery system" for the purposes of prosecution under the Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act of 1989?
Answer
No.
Analysis
Textual Tools
The plain meaning of the text is not open to the interpretation that a pad or tampon can be a "delivery system" for a biological weapon. The statute clearly states that a delivery system must be either itself a "living organism" or "specifically designed" as a delivery or dispersal mechanism for a toxin, biological agent, or vector. Feminine hygiene products are not "living organisms," and they are "specifically designed" to collect menses instead of delivering or dispersing biological agents, toxins, or vectors.
Examination of the whole act confirms this reading of the text. The short title of the act is the "Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act of 1989," and in ordinary meaning "biological weapon" does not apply to just any means by which someone could get sick, but rather as "a harmful biological agent . . . used as a weapon to cause death or disease usually on a large scale" (per Merriam-Webster). [Note: Pretend I grabbed examples from pop culture or a bunch of articles from the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal to further demonstrate this, since it's what a lawyer would actually do, but ain't nobody got time for that.]
The purpose of the act is twofold. It was enacted to "implement the Biological Weapons Convention" and to "protect the United States against the threat of biological terrorism." The text of the BWC, ratified by the Senate, speaks of delivery mechanisms in terms of "weapons" and "equipment" before concluding with a general term about other means of delivery. The principle of ejusdem generis suggests that everyday objects would be excluded from such a list. Finally, none of the references to menstrual products in federal law suggest that Congress believed that they should be regarded or regulated as weapons.
Legislative History
Nothing in the legislative history suggests Congressional intent to classify ordinary byproducts of menstruation as biological weapons. S. Rep 101-210 states that the act is an extension of President Nixon's campaign to curb the proliferation of WMD and that it will close the "dangerous loophole" caused by the fact that "no comprehensive law prohibit[ed] the manufacture or possession of biological weapons." Since the passage of this law, no case has been brought against manufacturers of menstrual products under this act, or of the half of the population in "possession" of such products; it would be an absurd result.
As for what might constitute a delivery system, the report notes that "[c]ombining these weapons of mass destruction with advanced long-range missile technology provide fearful opportunities to cause death and destruction." A tampon is not an ICBM.
Substantive Canons
The rule of lenity is the only substantive canon that could apply here. If we choose to interpret "delivery system" as ambiguous because the hygiene products were in fact the source of the staph (which could, under the strictest textualist interpretation imaginable, count as a "biological agent" because the definition includes "any micro-organism . . . capable of causing . . . death [or] disease"), we would have to resolve that ambiguity in favor of the defendant. If Congress wanted to define pads as biological weapons, it would have said so.
Conclusion
No, a pile of used menstrual products does not qualify as a "delivery system" under the Biological Weapons Anti-Terrorism Act of 1989.