Yesterday, at about 7PM Eastern (for the first time in about a year), I reviewed the front page of the Worm board on SB.
Saw two I recognized and am following (I've even caught up on one!):
And that prompts this post, here.
I have a strict grading rubric I apply to Worm fanfictions before reading. I will read the first post in any non-snippet thread that scores at least one point.
0.5 Points - thread title is free of the following "nopes":
Cross/Fusion/X-theft involving a work I haven't read or watched
CYOA
SI
Any words that appear even remotely weeby (when in doubt, chuck it out!)
Gamer, LitRPG, or anything "number go up" (ETA, as apparently most folks don't consider this a subcategory of weebshit)
0.5 Points - author is not:
1 Point - a so-called friend has linked it because it's terrible and they want to share the suffering
1 Point - a so-called friend has linked it because they enjoyed it
Only three fics passed this filter yesterday. Not naming names but one was really shitty suffering porn, one was a GoT cross with creepy sexualized teen vibes (possible inadvertent due to ESL, but fucked if I'm gonna wait to find out), and a pleasantly mediocre TINO Dresden Files cross. The latter, I read all of, but don't anticipate following closely.
Having completed the initial filter, I open the survivors in new tabs, and begin the next screening stage.
Step 1 - Read the summary to see if the title tags failed to mention any of my "nope" criteria.
I also try to get a sense of the author's writing ability, maturity, sense of humor, and depth of understanding for the Parahumans setting. (I don't think I'm particularly discriminating in my tastes, but if there's no chance of chemistry, why swipe right?)
Step 2 - Read the first story threadmark. Here, I apply a much stricter filter, across several criteria.
Prose quality is a big one for me. I don't mean "has the author run Grammarly and accepted all the reasonable suggestions," because that should go without saying. I've started reading tradpub fiction again and it's remarkable how much better the prose in even the weakest novels is compared to most fics.
A good hook/premise appears within the first screenful of text is nice, but so long as it's somewhere in the first chapter that's fine. I'm a big fan of:
entirely (or nearly so) OC casts
fics that explore DPoMs, or otherwise fill in canon gaps
other canon-compliant worldbuilding
novel AU concepts (with or without canon casts)
queer shit
conciseness (brevity is the soul of wit, you goddamn size queens!)
Absence of nopes. TBH, in the first chapter I'm looking more for reasons not to read the fic. For a lot of reasons (mostly disability), my reading for pleasure time is limited. I want to spend it well. I can screen out a lot purely on author and title tags, and most of the rest by the time I'm done with the summary. However, some common nopes only become apparent deeper in. Those include but are not limited to:
Fanon, or other clear evidence the author hasn't read Worm (at least not carefully). Deviations from canon are fine, of course, or what would your fic even be about? But I hope your intro or title tag sets appropriate expectations, 'cause simply out: I don't trust that you know what you're doing.
The author's naked or poorly concealed fetishes, especially trauma/suffering porn.
Locker scenes.
Lung fights.
Bank robberies.
(Really, opening with a repetition of any canon or fanon scene is gonna see me CTRL+W with a quickness.)
"Cinematic" fight choreography.
OOCness (so tired of -INOs). Of course, I will accept characterization changes that make sense and are internally consistent with setting changes laid out in the premise, provided I didn't object to the premise.
Platforming any sort of bigotry, even to denounce it.
UwU (I was shocked to see this pop up even in non-weebshit fics, but it is sadly pervasive in queer online spaces lately and that has spilled into fics.)
Happy to answer any questions about the above!
To save us all time, please keep in mind that I have either read, or chosen not to read:
Every fic in the r/WormFanFic sub banner.
Every fic initially published before 2014.
Every fic nominated for Best Fic of 2018, 2019, or 2020.
Every fic in the wiki
Status of the fic (dead, hiatus, whatever) doesn't matter.
While I quite enjoy snips, oneshots, etc, I am only soliciting fic recommendations at this time.
I expect I'll have read most of what isn't precluded by the above, but here's hoping, and thanks in advance! <3