r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Oct 14 '26

40k Analysis Can we admit the (post 415point price change) Lion panic has been overblown?

0 Upvotes

Edit: People are claiming that the response to Lion at 415 was not to think he was broken. This is objectively wrong. The top replies in the thread which announced his new price:

"Still incredible at 415. Just park him in the middle to cause all kinds of problems for the opponent that they cannot ignore"

"Probably still too strong of a datasheet but it's a step in the right direction"

"And is still worth it "

"There's just legit no reason to give him a 3++."

"Good. He should be even higher."

https://www.reddit.com/r/WarhammerCompetitive/comments/1wmdkg1/lion_will_cost_415_according_to_gw_partner/

______________________________________________________________________________________________

I fully expect to get downvoted for this, and I 100% understand. The Lion is a frustrating model to interact with for many lists, and can create feels bad moments. Go ahead and downvote away if that applies to you.

However, it's pretty clear he's not OP Broken. DA managed a **45%** winrate and 0.7 overrep ast week with the new codex, and a big part of it is the Lion.

https://listhammer.info/?faction=Dark+Angels

Lion showed up in less than half of the X-1 lists. Generic SMs are at a 53% winrate, significantly better than DA's 45%.

While everyone was focusing on his wounds, toughness, and save, all non-DA players ignored the *massive* nerf that he recieved on his abilites. All of them trigger off of DARK ANGELS, not ADEPTUS ASTARTES. As there is no mechanism for genetic SM units to gain a divergent keyword, this means the Lion does nothing for the vast majority of the SM range, and also does not get Lone Op from them. If it's not in the DA supplement, they do nothing for the Lion and he does nothing for him.

Lion next to a Deathwing Terminator squad? Gives them the 5+++ (in of itself a meaningful nerf. I piloted Lion giving 4+++ to Dreadnoughts to multiple X-1 results), RR1s to hit and wound in melee, and gets Lone Op. Lion next to Assault Terminators? No dice, no benefit either way.

This is a severely underlooked aspect of the Lion. While he is an absolutely deadly option, he is a melee missile that does not give out benefits to the majority of the army in many builds, and can only realistically engage and kill one unit at a time. And he REALLY doesn't like the Terminator-equivalent meta where his effective damage is reduced significantly by 4++ and possibly -1 damage on Assault Terminators in Terminator Storm.

If the Lion was what people have wailed about, DA would not be sitting at a 45% tournament winrate after the codex. Generic SMs are 8% higher, and RG has nearly the same durability as the Lion (4++/5+++ is mathematically equal to 3++ into non-mortal damage, and even into mortal it's only a 5+++ bs 4+++), and his abilities are all keyed to ADEPTUS ASTARTES. This not only means he benefits all SM codex seclections, he even gives reroll 1s to hit and wound to DW (both shooting and assault). This is a massive improvement compared to the Lion. In fact, it's such a better phrasing that if you could legally do it, RG is objectively better for a DA list than their own Primarch.

So can we agree once again that online 40k discussion is always pure reflexive response, and that when we let things actually hit the table, they may not be what they seem? Plenty of people were arguing 2 points. 1. Lion would only be balanced at 450+ or 2. There was no point at which the Lion could be balaned. He would either be undercosted and broken or overcosted and worthless. Yet we *do* see the Lion make X-1 competitive lists. DA are just weak enough that it doesn't matter and the whole faction is back on the strugglebus, as is tradition. (The heights of Transhuman 9th and broken CoH+DFP are by far the exceptions for DA. They have spent much more time bottom 5 in 40k history than even top half).

Simply put, I would kill for the weaker, old 10th ed 265 Lion back, even tho he has 10W T9. He was cheap enough to use as a melee missile, without needing to maximize his auras (which applied to everything, and were thus wete easier to maximize). Now he is so expensive that you both need to build a list of purely DA supplement units (and generic infantry with DA characters attached) AND manage to get him into consistent combat while his army benefits from his aura. It's an incredibly thin line to walk and can be easily disrupted. Tournament results give a clear representation of where rhe faction struggles, and it's when an opponent forces them to abandon that game plan.

Edit 2: As I said in the comments, I will come back to the thread and eat crow to every single commenter if the Lion does not see a points reduction or keyword change on his abilities in the next dataslate. So if I'm wrong, you have that to look forward to.

For all rhe "only one week" responses, how long dis it take for the community to come to consensus that the Destrier was a middling model that was okay, and the Defiler was game warping? That was discussed literally after 1 week of results. Obv RG is not an OP problem akin to Defilers, but he is amazing while Lion is usable, but not seeing a lot of lists. And DA and SM comp players have had the rules and ppints for 3 weeks. The results this last week were the culmination of all the prep that they did before that. And in that prep, top tier comp players who are DA specialists or have won GTs/Majors with them moved off of eirher the Lion (see Tony Bennet's published DA list) or off the faction in general (John Lennon, who has crushed tournies with DA in the past, choosing yo go UM+RG over DA+Lion for his supermajor). Okay, last edit, but I'm just getting a lot of the same replies.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Mar 31 '26

40k News Unpopular opinion : Rolling charge distance before selecting a target is a terrible idea, and GW’s justification doesn’t really hold up.

0 Upvotes

First, it removes a huge layer of decision-making. Right now, you have to weigh risk vs reward: do you go for a safer single charge, or risk a multi-charge for a bigger payoff? That choice is a core part of the game’s strategy. If you roll first, that tension disappears and the outcome swings much more on luck than on player judgment.

Second, the argument that this change prevents units from being “left out in the open” doesn’t make sense. Players already avoid risky multi-charges unless the odds are acceptable. You don’t get stranded because you declared too many targets, you get stranded because you fail a relatively manageable charge like a 4” or 5”. Rolling before choosing doesn’t fix that at all.

In the end, this feels like a game-warping change that reduces skill expression while not actually solving the problem it claims to address.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Feb 19 '23

40k Discussion On "rules bloat" and the purpose of stratagems.

0 Upvotes

Since the start of Ninth we've had a steadily growing critisism of ninth edition codex design.

"Rules Bloat"

The complaint goes like this: "Ninth edition codexes are too large, there is too much to remember, I wish there was less to remember, therefore I wish the codexes were smaller".

Recently the World Eaters codex has hit shelves, with less stratagems to remember, less warlord traits, relics and subfaction options to choose from.

Lo and behold, having less options to choose from is not as good. Having less stratagems to use during the game is less interactive.

Why is this happening?

Because "rules bloat" was actually just codex depth. The Aeldari codex might be the deepest codex I've ever played, in 4 editions. It has dozens of good stratagems, a great set of subfaction traits, warlord traits and relics and enough of them to keep me entertained for years.

It is not bloated because it has depth and options. Because depth and options is not rules bloat. Rules bloat is Army of renowns adding an extra layer of rules to models who already have enough rules.

Actual rules bloat

Crusher stampede. Improving the balance of something by adding further passive abilities to its datasheet and by increasing the amount of publications you needed to carry around. That's rules bloat.

Stratagems

There has been a growing grumbling about stratagems for most of the edition.

"Why are there so many?" and "why isn't this just on the data sheet?"

The answer is a good one. Because stratagems are a great method of balance. Instead of your whole army Permanently Transhumaning all the time (that proved to be a massive mistake when the dark angels codex was released....), by hiding that mechanic in a stratagem, the game design team can ensure that the ability is present, useful, but not active on the entire board the entire game, being the defining factor of the game. It also has a cost! A trade-off!

So, in summary:

  1. We've seen what happens when the options players asked to be removed get removed, the codex becomes thinner and less interesting.

  2. We've seen what happens when stratagems instead get implemented on the datasheet (Deathwing permanent transhuman) and I think we can all agree that having a good mechanic both costing a small amount and also being locked to one use per phase, is a good thing.

I will not be playing world eaters, with 2 subfaction traits to choose from and a half dozen stratagems, that will quickly go stale.

I instead will play my huge, deep codexes filled with dozens and dozens of options for as long as I can.

Hopefully games workshop does not listen to the community and avoids making the same mistakes made in the world eaters and dark angels codexes.

Or, repeat the errors of 5th edition, which had no stratagems, no relics, no warlord traits and no subfactions.

The game was much, much less interesting.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Aug 26 '26

40k Discussion Let's be honest, new mfm kinda sucks.

0 Upvotes

To be clear, I am heavily dissapointed about points changes, and lack thereof, but thats not what this is about.

I was unsure how I felt during 11nth launch and the first dataslate, but this update confirms how bad the new mfm is combined with the lack of a comprehensive dataslate pdf. Previously you cliked one pdf and could look through every factions points changes to get a rough idea what happened and then dive deeper. Worked great even on mobile, now you have to open the mfm site and click through every faction. This is so tedious and a general chore to do when you just want a rough idea.

The absolute worse part of the data slates though is having to open 20+ pdfs to try and see important rules changes. My phone lets me open them in browser, my laptop I'd have to download and open all of them. If they really want to keep this they should at least offer a master rules change doc that has the entireity of the current slate and a pdf mfm in addition to the website.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 04 '26

40k Discussion Was Fights First over-nerfed?

5 Upvotes

When I first read the blurb explaining the new Fights First rule, I understood it to be a change so that a Fights First unit going into another Fights First unit would get to.... fight first.

I didn't realize until after the full rules were released that it also applies to any unit that's charging, which means that Fights First goes from being a very powerful, albeit rare tool that will swing the way the battle is fought, to something that is essentially very occasionally valuable

For those unaware, with the changes, the charging player gets to fight first with any charging unit, even into a Fights First target, which means you have to be charging at least two targets with the rule for it to make any impact, since the attacker will invariably choose to fights first unit to deny you the opportunity to fight next in the sequence.

What are your thoughts on this?

For me, of all the changes of 11th edition, this one seems like it's going against the intention of what Fights First intends, which is that this is an "anvil" unit that forces your opponent to play their melee units around it.

It's also actually a reduction in the game's level of clarity, since you'd assume a unit that has the explicit rule that it Fights First would... fight first?

I also feel like it's a rare enough rule that it was rarely problematic?

Hopefully if it stays as-is, models that lean heavily into that rule for their value (Lion, Fulgrim, Judiciar, Foul Blightspawn) will get a sizeable point cost reduction, because this mostly kills their utility.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jan 27 '22

40k Discussion Getting ahead of this before the LVO results - Custodes seem a bit overtuned

27 Upvotes

Calling it now - 9 bike spam will be more oppressive than any pre-nerf buggy lists.I've played about 2 or 3 games against new custodes and the army is exceptionally overtuned.

  1. Command phase Ka'tahs provide such extreme flexibility to each unit on the battlefield it's crazy, access to ka'tahs should be priced into the cost of each unit and it certainly doesn't feel that way.

  2. Strat to change shield hosts is absolutely broken at 1 cp and basically removes any meaningful choice during list-building because you will simply be able to switch to the host you need to when you need it. Like say I'm goff orks but I need to fall back and shoot with some buggies, oops now the buggies are blood axes for the turn. Whack boys. This should be 2 cp and a once per game usage or simply yeeted from the game.

  3. Access to a hit/wound re-roll army-wide on profiles that hit on 2s and usually wound on 3 or better, plus +1 to wound on the charge.

  4. Double obsec on all infantry (not just troops) and bikes counting as 2 models means that you can't counterplay custodes on the objective game anymore (since their units are so undercosted they bring enough to flood the board anyway now).

  5. Praeto PlatAllapus teleport very annoying. Teleporting should always be 9" away.

  6. Trajan is broken at 160 points, giving what is effectively full re-rolls to hit in wound in an aura. 2+ 4++ body, bunch of fuckin' attacks, fights twice for free or interrupts for free and a bunch of other special rules. Absolutely whacked.

  7. 4+++ against mortals should be a 5+++ fight me.

  8. The bikes themselves basically hit and wound with all melta shots with all the dang re-rolls they get, making them very reliable. With a 44" threat range because of the ability to advance and shoot the meltas means you can't hide anything you need to turn 1 because they have the movement to just get angles on anything. And then they live through whatever you throw at them. And then they yeet whatever they get in melee with. They are twice as tough as any scrapjet even with ramshackle (4++ and 4+++ wins out vs ramshackle EVERY TIME), and they are twice as deadly and cost less than pre-CA buggies lol - WHACK WHACK WHACK WHACK, PUT A 3 PER ARMY LIMIT ON THESE BAD BOYS GW DO IT.

  9. No way to turn off tanglefoot grenade. Can still use it when you tag the unit in melee. You should definitely have to burn overwatch to use it.

I have a list of many more complaints but custodes basically stomp any list without access to ubiquitous invulns, they've removed the mobility issues they had, along with any obsec issues. There is no counterplay to the army for most factions in what I can only imagine full buggy orks felt like playing against. When we talk about meaningful interactions and interactivity, sure you can't fight planes and squigbuggies, but banging your head against a brick wall trying to score or make any impact on boardstate kinda feels the same way re: interactivity.

Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox just wanted to "FIRST" the custode criticisms.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Apr 03 '26

40k Discussion AITA, How strict by the rule are people in tournament?

6 Upvotes

Am I the Asshole?

My opponent and I were preparing for our first tournament. Went to shoot a Great Unclean One when my opponent remembered me that this one (1 of 3) had a lone op ability of 18". Fine, I shoot with the models that are in range and almost get it down. I get excited and pass on another unit to try to finish the monster. Later in the shooting phase I remember the rest of my initial unit, the models that did not get to shoot.

I go to shoot them in some beast of nurgle (the only other eligible target) and my opponent tell me I can't, that it's too late since I alerdy activated another unit.

After some arguing I packed my stuff and leaved. Was it legitimate from my opponent to stop me from shooting? His point was that I didn't declared them to shoot, mine is that obviously they were gonna shoot the only availlable target and that since no information was gained in between that would affect this I should be allowed to complete my activation.

Edit: I didn't leave because I didn't get to shoot the beast of nurgle. The argument got nasty.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 21 '23

40k News German TOs house rules to first GT

74 Upvotes

Edit: Wording change for towering. Now seems to follow the same rules as all other models Edit2: Another change for Towering. Now allowing toeing into terrain.

Not my decision but after seeing what is happening in the games played I don't find this too drastic. I'm just the messenger in this case and was asked to post this here. Don't shoot me ;)

The group that decided to "ban Votann in Germany" (meaning a hand full of very handsome TOs and players) reassembled in these grim times of Warhammer 40k in order to restore the fun for their community. After careful consideration they decided the following houserules to be applicable on their tournaments. This list is by no means enough to extinguish the dumpsterfire that 10th edition looks to be by now, but it is the first step into the direction of making the game fun again.

Unless GW fixes the plentiful issues of 10th edition themselves in a timely manner, starting with the first 10th edition GT in Germany (Münsterland GT) we will use the following houserules in order to make the game enjoyable for all players:

  • [Towering] is changed to: A unit with the [Towering] keyword is considered to be wholly within a piece of terrain, even if it is only partially within it (intention is: "toeing in" for the benefit of seeing "through" ruins instead of natively seeing "through" it)

  • Wraithknights Heavy Wraithcannons lose the [Devastating Wounds] ability

  • Fatedice are limited to one dice per unit per phase

  • [Indirect] fire suffers the same penalty as in 9th edition (-1BS and +1 to save) in addition to any other applicable rules like cover, [Stealth], etc. and cannot benefit from the +1 to hit for being [Heavy] when fired without line of sight (model wise)

  • Thousand Sons “Twist of Fate” Cabal Ritual is modified to “any armour saving throws of the unit are modified by -2” instead

  • The range of the “Fire Overwatch” stratagem is reduced to 12” and only visible units can be shot

  • Mortal Wounds from a single unit are capped at 6 MW per unit per phase when targeted at a non-Monster or non-Vehicle unit, any additional wounds e.g. with Assault Canons are then handled as normal (saves can be made etc.)

  • Models can move over and stay on objectives without limitations (as per 9th)

  • Lone Operative and similar abilities are subject to investigation of how to fix them best (tbd.)

This should be seen as a first try to restore the fun of Warhammer 40k in these grim times. It might be subject to change after the first results and/or actions done by GW themselves.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 07 '24

New to Competitive 40k Are there any armies that look "normal" while also being good?

11 Upvotes

Sticking my neck out here but are there any 40k armies that have their "competitive lists" actually resembling armies? It seems every comp list is some variation of "spam 3 of these three things that are meta, sprinkle a few extras, call it a day" or "well first you take this special character, whether or not you're playing that army, and then..."

I guess maybe (big maybe) the new mission deck will change that around with some bonuses for battleline, but I can't imagine you're suddenly gonna see like space marine forces that are mostly based around intercessors with extras like they "should" be in the lore, not mostly vehicles with some extras thrown in.

It's really disheartening to me to see the current state of 40k from a visual perspective; it barely resembles a wargame anymore, it's more like a dice game with miniatures as counters, and I don't know what to do anymore other than just give it up :(

For example, I was looking at Deathwing because I love terminators. But nope, doesn't seem like they're any good, Dark Angel lists are some variation of the Firestorm or whatever the "meta" marine list is, basically "Dark Angels" in name only since they have nothing that makes them dark angels. Looked at world eaters, you "need" to have Angron, no ifs ands or buts. Looked at votann, you "need" 3 Hekaton fortresses. It's all so frustrating, I literally feel like the Principal Skinner "Am I out of touch" meme.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Apr 15 '26

40k Tech To My 40k Exclusive Brothers: A Message

0 Upvotes

Do yourself a solid: Play a game of Sigmar. Seriously. You don't have to like it, or the setting, or the fantasy aspect. You don't need to own models, just proxy some stuff, and play with a faction that still has an index so you don't have to even buy rules.

The more we see of 11th, the closer and closer it seems to look like they're raiding the AoS cookie jar for ideas, and the things they've lifted all work quite fluidly in AoS.

So do yourself a favor. Dip your toes for an afternoon, you might learn something!

And to those who already play both games? Continue to be awesome pillars of handsomeness you already are!


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jul 11 '23

40k Analysis Is it right for GW to just check out of Balance Updates until Fall?

0 Upvotes

Title.

GW did one (1) emergency patch the week after release and then dusted off their hands and said "job well done, be back in the fall." Is this acceptable? The game clearly has balance issues still and 10th edition needs some tender love and care.

On the other hand, I understand that GW needs time to acrue real tournament/other types of data before making changes. Also, I understand that people's models collections cannot change with a fast paced meta and that people need time to build, paint and support an army.

Even still, I think I would appreciate a "we are monitoring the data and will make changes if needed" stance from GW as opposed to a " lol see you in September" stance as we have gotten.

I personally have been having fun with 10th so far (as a totally casual deathguard and demons player) but I have my own grievances and would love to see another few updates before the fall. What does the community think?


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 02 '25

40k Analysis Marines have one of the higher skill floors in 10th edition; this partially explains their average win rate vs tournament wins

0 Upvotes

(Skill floor means the minimum amount of skill required to play them effectively, skill ceiling is how much effect gaining more skill has your results)

Let's look at the army rule: Oath of Moment. It's a pretty standard, if powerful, buff in terms of 10th edition rules. Rerolls, maybe +1 to wound, it's good, and technically doesn't cost you anything to use. But you only get one per round (unless you're playing with certain busted charcters). This means that every round you have to make a choice where to put it and it's an unconstrained choice, you can choose literally any unit your opponent has (except transported units).

This means you're making a decision with a large number of options (entire enemy army) and a very large impact on your chances of winning. So you need to make the right choice, every round, for 5 rounds. (The guillaman oath being dependent on the first oath frankly just makes the choice even harder).

Compare this to something like custodes, super low skill floor, because they don't have decisions like this to make. Your army rule is picking lethals or sustained for every unit in melee, which is both much harder to get wrong (are you wounding them on 5s or not?) and much less punishing if you do get it wrong (the units all have high base stats and getting the wrong katah is like, maybe a 10% damage difference, if that).

Now add on to this the most powerful of the space marine detachments: Gladius Task Force.

Every single round you have a choice of one of three army wide buffs, or no buff at all, and they're extremely powerful buffs that you can only use once, which again, gives you A) a bunch of options and B) getting it right or wrong has a huge effect on whether or not you win.

Now add on top of this the sheer range of space marine units and how many of them are basically a trap, from a competitive standpoint, and playing space marines gives you a lot of chances to make the wrong choice.

Again, compared to custodes, or knights or something, which have small model ranges, which make it harder to make mistakes, as well as army and detachment rules that don't require making choices, and you can see the minimum skill level required to play each army is wildly different, which is a bit of a problem when space marines are both the starter army and the most common one.

On the plus side, they're way more fun to play against!

(To pre-empt the knee jerk response of "wtf as a custodes I have to make super hard decisions about where to move and which unit to charge and stuff", yes, congratulations, literally every army also has to make those decisions. We're talking about things beyond that.)

(EDIT: while I do enjoy arguing about the semantics of ceilings and floors, here's what google hallucinated when I asked it:

In the context of video games, a "skill floor" refers to the minimum amount of skill required to effectively play a character or game. It represents the level at which a player can start making meaningful contributions, even if they are not yet highly skilled. A low skill floor means it's easy for a new player to start making an impact, while a high skill floor indicates a more demanding learning curve. Here's a more detailed explanation:

Low Skill Floor: . A character or game with a low skill floor is easy to pick up and start playing effectively. Even a novice player can contribute meaningfully by simply understanding basic mechanics and playing with purpose. Examples include characters who have easy-to-use abilities or mechanics that are intuitive.

High Skill Floor:

A character or game with a high skill floor requires a significant amount of investment in practice and knowledge before a player can even begin to play effectively at a basic level. This often means mastering complex combos, understanding intricate game mechanics, or having a strong grasp of strategy. Contrast with Skill Ceiling:

The skill floor is distinct from the skill ceiling, which represents the upper limit of a character's or game's potential. A high skill ceiling means there's a lot of room for improvement and mastery, while a low skill ceiling means there are limits to how much a player can improve their performance. )


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Feb 11 '26

40k List How I Prepare for Warhammer 40K Tournaments With Only 5 Hours a Week

14 Upvotes

I’m not a full-time player and I’m not a top-table celebrity.

I work full time, play 4–6 events a year, and get about 5 hours per week to prep.

Over the last season I realised something:

I wasn’t losing because I didn’t know my datasheets.

I was losing 10–20 points per game on scoring discipline.

So I built a simple 3-part prep system.

1st - Scoring Before List Tweaks

Before changing units, I now ask:

• How does this list score primary consistently?

• What are my reliable secondary options?

• What is my turn 4–5 plan?

• Where do I lose 5-point swings?

If I can’t answer those clearly, I don’t change the list yet.

2nd - Deployment Rehearsal (No Dice Required)

Instead of playing endless practice games, I:

•	Set up a WTC/UKTC style layout

•	Deploy both armies myself

•	Ask: “If I go second, what happens?”

•	Identify which unit must survive until turn 3

This takes 30–40 minutes and prevents most early-game mistakes.

3rd - The 5-Point Swing Rule

Every turn I now ask:

•	Can I deny 5?

•	Am I about to give up 5?

•	Is this trade scoring-positive?

This single habit improved my results more than any list change.

What Changed

I still lose games.

But now I lose close games — and I understand why.

And when I win, it’s because I protected scoring, not because I spiked damage.

If you’re a busy player trying to improve without living at the top table, I’d recommend starting with scoring discipline instead of chasing new tech.

Happy to answer questions or compare prep routines.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Dec 27 '24

40k Discussion Yes, you should absolutely not give your opponents points for being based if they aren't

0 Upvotes

You also shouldn't "talk out" rounds that haven't actually been played to give you or your opponent extra points.

You should do this for two reasons:

First off, it's the rules you agreed to when you signed up for the event and you should follow them because that's the whole point of having an event with rules.

Secondly, giving your opponent extra points that they didn't earn doesn't just affect your own game, but every other person in that tournament that is competing against them.

Regardless of whether they should, most events use total points scored in a game as a way of breaking ties and otherwise ranking players at the end of the event. Giving your opponent "extra points" will give them an unfair advantage over every single one of those other players.

Someone might be thinking "Well how is it fair for a player to lose a game or ranking spot just because they didn't base/paint/assemble their models?" and the short answer is: because those are the rules.

As previously mentioned, you agreed to follow the rules when you signed up for the event and if everyone else is following the rules you're giving out unfair advantages and you should stop doing that.

You can scream all you want about how awful it is to having basing/painting/assembling rules in a tournament and that's fine, but don't sign up for an event and then refuse to follow the rules. If you feel that strongly that the event's rules are bad in some way, start your own event! It's free! No one will stop you! You can have literally any rules you want when it's your own event.

(The title is clickbait, obviously, obviously what I mean is you should follow the required rules of any given event, if it requires painting for 10 points or it requires basing or even if it requires zero proxies in your army. And if you aren't sure, ASK A JUDGE. If they're going to make rules about subjective things like "properly painted", ask them to enforce it.)


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Oct 10 '22

40k Discussion Leagues of Votann: What went wrong?

1 Upvotes

NOTE: Started this more or less right after the codex dropped, bt GW have released a much needed update whilst i was about 2/3 the way through.

INTRODUCTION:

Like many people i've done a fair amount of "what were they thinking" sort of questioning in my head. However i came to some pretty rapid conclusions and wanted to share my thoughts both because i think people might find them interesting, and because i think it's important to remember them when thinking about how to balance Votann.

Disclaimer up front i'm a strictly ametur hombrewer, so whilst i feel i have a decent grasp of the concepts, apply as much salt as you feel is appropriate.

I'll also admit i did some fandex work many months back before Votann where announced on a "space dwarf" fandex and some of the parallels, (and where i did things very differently), stood out in a way that helped me understand what i believe went on during the Votann design. Don't worry i'm not going to reference my fandex much, (this might be the only reference actually, will see when i finish writing) and only in very broad general terms

THE STARTING POINT:

To understand how somthing like Votann is built you have to consider the question: "What does a perfectly even match with your new army design look like".

This might sound simple but it's anything but. Different core design philosophies' for an army will produce different overarching themes in how it plays out. Different armies resist being tabled to different degrees in any given matchup and differing speeds, engagement ranges, quality of secondaries, e.t.c. All of that and more affects the ability of an army to score primaries and secondaries at any given point in a matchup.

ARCHETYPAL ANALYSIS:

Votann have an on the surface fairly simple to analyse archetype. Namely being slow and short ranged. On paper, (i'll get to where it doesn't work later), that means an army thats going to find it almost impossible to contest or score primaries in the midboard turn 1 and struggle heavily turn 2. potentially to the extreme of giving the enemy 2 full turns unmolested scoring the majority of primaries and otherwise doing actions and moving into locations and shooting stuff up to get their secondaries. This in turn in an even game requires that the Votann score a similar number of primaries across turns 3, 4, and 5 as their opponents did on turns 1 & 2 whilst also earning enough score to offset their opponents scoring on those turns. Practically speaking that probably requires them to table a standard opponent somewhere in turn 4 and contest midfield evenly on turn 3. And thats just to get an even game. They'd have to win turn 3 or have better secondaries to actually win the game rather than draw.

And of course tabling an opponent takes a lot of bang to do, and again in theory a short ranged army is going to struggle with that due to some units on some turns just not getting to deal damage to anything. In theory turns 1 and 2 would be particularly bad.

Once again in a typical matchup that throws the focus on turn 3.

In that kind of context the Judgment tokens are on some levels an amazing solution, (don't worry i'm going to get onto where it all breaks down in a minute). Not only does it hand out a ton of free killing power, but it's also contingent, (in its basic form), on your opponent doing things that will get them VP's so if they're army archetype means they do less of that early on they'll have far less tokens for you to take advantage of on turns 3 and 4 toning down the wiping power. The effect scales with the type of opposition your facing. This is in that respect a better than the solution to the same issue i came up in my fandex writing, (it's worse in other ways though).

And if we take those nice neat slightly simplistic analyses at face value it's easy to see exactly what i think GW was going for i think. It makes sense and on the surface appears balanced. So where di it all go wrong?

WHERE IT WENT WRONG:

And this is where we come to all those issues i've been hinting at. There are quite a few.

First and foremost 24" range in the current meta simply isn't short ranged enough to really create the degree of issues in the assumptions. Tables are small enough and distances between deployment zones short enough that you absolutely can reach on turn 2 fairly well, and even on turn 1 to some degree. It's not a non-issue, but it's also not anywhere near as bad as the assumption assume. In effect 24" is short ranged by the other armies standards, but not relative to the tables actually being played on. I don't think it would quite hold up even on the old 4 feet by 6 feet tables, but it would be a lot closer to it there. Now how exactly GW got this part wrong i'm not 100% sure, maybe they originally specced them out with a 6" shorter rnage on everything, or they started basic development back when bigger tables where a thing. But whatever the reason, from my perspective they designed the armies mechanics as if it would have much more trouble getting firepower on target in the first couple of turns than it actually does.

Second, the judgment tokens have more than just the basic ways of applying them. Your not restricted to just tokens from the enemy doing things. A character and several sub factions can apply or achieve the equivalent of applying extra tokens to enemy units. Thats a big issue as it means they're not restricted to waiting till late game for the enemy to rack up the tokens needed to deliver a complete nuking, they can actually apply a lot of pain from earlier into the game. It's the same issue really as their range, the mechanic works but having these extra sources of judgment tokens undermines the whole weak early game phase the archtype requires. Thats not to say that your can't have extra sources of judgment tokens without undermining the archtype, just that the method in use here doesn't do it.

Third, the lack of opponent intractability on judgment tokens. The ability to apply tokens from the Votann side, (see previous point), gives votann the means to do so from their side, but there's no counterplay to even the basic form of tokens. One of the problems with the archtype i laid out in the first part is that it';s very formulaic, absent any deliberate design decisions there's not much either player cna do in turns 1 and 5 and turns 2 and 4 are heavily slanted towards one side. This removes agency from the player, they're forced to sit there and watch mostly pre-determined outcomes play out . They're helpless in the face of their respective armies limitations. That doesn;t make for a good player feeling. Giving them some way to interact back against the steamroller mechanic to make it better or worse helps keep both players in the game affecting the outcome even on turns where they'd normally have little influence. It lets their respective decision making play out over a greater portion of the game. But by it's nature it has to be built into army unique rules for the votann. Basically a designer has to not only create balanced rules, but rules that are fun to play with and against, and the current state of judgment tokens thanks to their combination of their power level and lack of intractability fails that test pretty badly.

Fourth, the method they chose for the judgment tokens to take effect, (auto-wounds, and especially with the added rider of 6's), has some really degenerate interactions, both with the Votann's own special rules, but also with the rules and themes and principles of other armies. Armies that rely on high toughness especially feels the effects more than armies that don't, which means it punishes small elite opponent's much more on average than glass cannons, which in general is the opposite of what you want. You want a strong but relatively even effect regardless of opponent type, not a complete curbstomp into some and a strong but not insane effect into others.

WHY IT WENT WRONG?

This section is going to be a touch more speculative. Between the fandex and other non-40k homebrew and just a lot of years of watching actual professionals screw up and then talk about it afterwards in various community articles for various games stuff i've got a lot of knowledge of many of the things that can go wrong. But what precisely happened is allways going to be difficult to pin down without more information than we have. But let's discuss some of the possibilities.

The first and simplest possibility is that the devs have struggled with and possibly never been able to successfully execute this style of army before, (Death guard are the other major one i can think of with similarities in core concepts). And as a result they just went too overboard trying to make V otann good. they could have also started with using past similar armies as a touchstone to check they where on base and over time drifted so far away without appreciating the differences that they got themselves in a bind balance wise.

I don;t think either of these is especially likely as a primary cause, there are just too many rookie mistakes involved in doing this aspect wrong this badly. but i wouldn't be surprised if worries perhaps started by past projects like DG made them overdo things a bit, but i doubt it remotely explains all of the issues.

The Second possibility is one Goonhammer alluded to with them noting it felt like Votann had been given just a few too many answers to some of their biggest weaknesses. It's entirely possibble that in attempting to give them enough ability to occasionally do something a bit off base they overdid it and gave them too many strong outs. It's also quite possible that they weren't trying to stick exactly to the archetype i outlined initially but chose instead at some point in development to try to turn them into a hybrid somwhere between that and a more normal army. Hybrids like that are a notoriously difficult entity to balance and it's entirely possible to give them too much from both elements your combining.

This is in my opinion the most likely culprit for the bulk of the issues. Both problems are common design mistakes even amongst pro's and are notoriously difficult to avoid and easy to mess up. I don;t think they explain everything, there's never one neat explanation for the mistakes, but they probably represent the majority of the blame.

The Third possibility is a bit unusual, the more oddball your design concept the more your going to run into strange edge case rules interactions, this can have unintended consequences in how things actually play out compared to what you had in mind when you wrote the stats and other details out on paper. Anyone who's come back to a game system after a long absence knows this feeling, so much is the same but so much has changed and there';s so many interactions you just don't appreciate for quite a while after coming back.

I doubt very much the devs would get tripped up that badly, (though when writing my fandex it tripped me up hard personally speaking), but at the same time murphy's law exists for a reason. They also screwed up in exactly this fashion with custodes jetbikes this edition so i'm not gonna tottally So i'm not willing to completely discount it having an effect, but a lot of the issues with the Votann Codex feel like intentional design decisions, not unintended mistakes.

The fourth possibility is actually surprisingly hard to think of, but obvious once you realise it. They only had a handful of datasheets to work with and the limit wasn't necessarily set by the designers, (in fact i'd all but guarantee it wasn't). With how many differing design goals, necessary minimum capabilities, fluffy quirks, and so on and so forth they had to build into the army and so few datasheets it's an easy way for even experienced designers to overload the datasheets with too much stuff leading to capability creep that starts to breakdown the proper strengths vs weaknesses aspects. I suspect this was a factor but not the sole cause. with so few datasheets there had to be some degree of crunch that got in the way but it doesn't explain everything IMO.

EDIT: Missed this last point in my rush to finish this before the Dataslate hit and uppends things again

Fifth, as as been admitted by GW there's also the fact that Votann development in ernest was happening at a time when the other codex's in development where severely overtuned. It's actually an interesting admission for me because it suggests to me that GW mostly playtests codex's in development against the other in development and/or those just released, not against their entire list of out there codex's. That said whilst this clearly was part of the problem, it doesn't explain why they did some things the way they did, it explains how some things might have gotten overtuned, but not necessarily why they chose a particular thing in the first place or why any other issues come up.

Like i said this section is a bit speculative, but my guess would be varying degrees of all of them and probably some stuff i haven't thought of. I'm particularly inclined to think they either underappreciated how little their shorter than average range materred and/or decided to go hybrid and didn;t properly tone down some elements. But i have no proof ofc.

CONCLUSION:

At its's core however this is an army that has some obvious elements you'd expect in the design of a faction of a specific archetype, (slow and short ranged), but is lacking in some of the key weaknesses and has some of the necessary strengths implemented in a way that's not the best design for the game as a whole even if it works fine in isolation.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Sep 19 '26

40k Analysis Reasons to reserve judgment on new Space Marine points

0 Upvotes

Many are very confident online that the marine points did not go up enough. As a marine player I’m not so sure.

Vanilla Marines were garbage without oath, and only very good with super oath. Any marine player will tell you the same.

Now you’ve upped the data sheets, but also removed oath and knocked them down by 1-2 units on average. It’s just a different army.

Maybe it’s not enough, maybe it is, fair critiques of the Lion aside I would probably reserve judgment to see how they play!


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Apr 27 '24

40k Analysis A point cost comparison between 9th and 10th edition

0 Upvotes

A few months ago I made a post where I took 10 competative tournament lists which were mentioned in an article and compared the point cost the armys would have between what they had in 10th edition, and what they would have had in 9th

i found that 8 of the 10 lists would have been around 2200pts in 9th, one (an eldar list) would have been around 1950) and one (a tau list) would have been a staggering 3100

i came to the conclusion that 10th edition has across the board lowered points costs, resulting in more models on the board, a higher price of entry into the game (not even counting the increase in price of individual kits) and a homogenisation of all armies as they all trend more towards being hordes

several people pointed out this comparison wasnt great, as it didnt take into account that "tournament lists" would be using units that are "too cheap" because that means they are stronger

personally i dont agree with that logic, i believe tournament units are probably MORE expensive as if they are the good units they will have had points increases (looking at you eldar support weapons and admech breachers, the only admech unit to NOT see multiple points drops)

but with the recent dataslate i decided to put my view to another test

i took 11 random armies (i would have done more but i got bored) and tallied up the cost of EVERY unit in that army, and compared them to what they were in 9th

the armies i compared are in no particular order

sisters, custodes, admech, knights, chaos knights, guard, DG, drukhari, GSC, GK, Ksons

(i deliberatly avoided tau and votan as i KNOW those 2 armies are MASSIVLY lower point cost in 10th then 9th and felt they would horrendously throw off the curve)

the rules i followed are

one of every unit that appears in both books, if a unit is only in 10th or only in 9th, its not counted, and no repeating units, epic hero characters are given the same weighting as battleline (this is an issue with the comparison, but not a huge one)

no upgrades UNLESS they are compulsory, so no daemon hammers on the GKs, but counting the 2 cheapest weapons on their dreadknight (because you have to take at least 2)

no repeat units UNLESS, its a winged version as in 10th those function as different units, so winged daemon prince and foot prince are both counted, but the 17 flavours of leman russ are not only the "battle tank" was taken from 10th (which is one of the more expensive russ varients, so slightly favours 10th)

I totaled the points costs in each case, then divided the 10th ed total by the 9th ed total, which gave me an average for how much percentage cheaper the 10th ed units are compared to 9th

the results are (above 1=10th ed has a higher avg points, below 1=9th ed has higher points)

sister: 0.86

custodes: 0.99

admech: 0.98

knights: 0.95

chaos knights: 0.99

guard: 1.00

DG: 0.89

drukhari: 0.95

GSC: 1.02

GK: 0.99

Ksons: 1.04

with this i found several things i wasnt really expecting

i believed that 10th was MUCH cheaper then 9th, and that armies would be more in the region of 10-15% cheaper, however almost every army is enar identical to what they were in 9th

the outliers are, DG and sisters who both went down by the expected 10-15% ish, while GSC and Ksons both went up very slightly (2% and 4% respectivly)

at first glance this seems like 10th edition points are around the same as their 9th ed counterparts

admech were a real shock to me, who are almost the exact same average points as they were in 9th, however this is because with the small roster size the rediculous overcosting of certain units (disintigrator is the main one, breachers being the 2nd big points increase over 9th) massivly carries the factiosn points, and almost all the other units have gone down, the end of 9th was also when admech were getting a LOT of points decreases because of their awfull winrate so perhaps it shouldnt be that shocking

HOWEVER

i did notice several things which held true

the first

i didnt take into account points upgrades, this comparison only holds true if the 9th ed army took NO upgrades at all, while the 10th ed one can take as many as they want

for armies like guard upgrades are huge, raising the cost of their tanks by as much as 30 or 40 points

meaning for a "real" army which took multiple upgrades on different units (even ones as simple as just rubrics having flamers not bolters) the 9th ed army becomes a LOT more expensive points wise then the 10th, even for the armies which "in theory" are more expensive in 10th, if GSC or Ksons take even a small number of optional upgrades their 10th ed lists become cheaper

which leads me to believe that when GW was "writing" (if you can call their attempt that) the indexs they didnt take into account wargear AT ALL for pricing the units, and just took their base prices ignoring how much stronger or weaker wargear made them (or just removing it entirely, sorry GK no hammers for you)

this is shockingly true for knights, sisters and guard, all of whom are cheaper in 10th DESPITE having HUGE amounts of expensive upgrades just built in for free now (if you count wargear, knights and guard points costs are down easily 20% or more) while it barely affects custodes (though vexila were characters before and now are just part of a unit for no cost, so there is something there)

the other thing that stood out was pretty expected

characters tend to be more expensive in 9th, this is understandable as with aura buffs they are stronger, in 9th you took 1 manipulus and he buffed all your skittles, in 10th you take 3 because they only buff their own unit, however actually going through the armies really cemented it, a VAST number of characters are now in the 30-50 point region, out of the 9 non knight armies i compared almost every character went down by 10 or so points, with some extreme outliers in morven and celestine going down by 130 and 70 points respectivly

the other trend i noticed was how indirect is universally more expensive showing just how much more impactfull the 9th ed indirect rules were compared to the 10th (and no not just guard indirect, the other armies indirect is also significantly more expensive, the average artillary tank in 9th was around 130-150pts while in 10th they are all in the 180-190 region)

TLDR

i compared 11 armies between 9th and 10th expecting to see a huge points decrease

when wargear is not taken into account 10th ed armies are on average VERY slightly cheaper then their 9th ed counterparts, however when wargear is taken into account, even just small amounts, 9th ed armies become significantly higher point cost and so 10th ed has become (as i had felt, but now have numbers to prove) significantly more hordey

with the side notes being

indirect is MUCH stronger in 10th then it was in 9th and so has inflated points, while characters are weaker and so have deflated points

this has been a largely ussless endevour, basically just confirming what everyone sort of already knows, that 10th ed is more hordey, and so more expensive, then 9th, but i feel it does highlight how that difference is 90% down to the removal of wargear costs, if wargear costs were still in the game, or if they were free in 9th, 10th would be on average 3% lower point cost then 9th, a negligible amount

i basically come to a similar conclusion i came to several months ago

10th ed needs a 10-15% point increase across the board, points costs are too low, i dont want every army to be a horde

my reasoning for this is slightly different then it was then though, its not that the units are too cheap now, its that GW made NO attempt to account for wargear costs when pricing 10th ed, and so this universal increase is needed almost purely to counteract the removal of wargear cost


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jan 07 '26

40k Discussion GW nailed it with the new detachments

14 Upvotes

As a necron+marine player i gotta say, every single one of these new detachments looks like tons of fun to play. We’ll have to wait to see how well they perform competitively but i honestly haven’t had this level of ‘inspiration’ for building/experimenting with new lists since the start of the edition.

It’s really nice how they’ve all got some unique flair and identity to them. There are some similarities (eg. WotR’ish rule for UM) but they’re not just mixups of existing things like a lot of the ‘24 grotmas drops. There’s PLENTY of interesting rules in the mix for entirely new combos- hopefully bringing more list variation to the competitive scene.

Kudos to GW for such a fresh set of detachments, hoping every faction picks up a couple this year.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Mar 06 '25

40k Discussion How many people play as per the written rules?

0 Upvotes

I'm not sure if it's just what I'm seeing, but the vat majority of posts on here that come through my feed are about issues with proxy models, fudged movements, local organizers making idiotic changes to tournament structures and worse. It gives me the impression that if I play in a tournament and expect my opponents to know and play by the rules, I'll be the weird one.

My question is how many people here actually play by the rules, as written, without complaint, because those are the parameters that make fair competition possible, and how many people are more interested in winning than playing?

Edit: I'm not talking about blatant cheating. I'm talking about conventions like playing by intent and non-GW rulings that are to be only for convenience

Edit 2: Since this won't get any more response since it was downvoted, thanks for the impressions, does seem to be a mostly complainer issue


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 14 '23

40k Discussion Oaths of Moment has to change right?

0 Upvotes

Now that we have seen a number of faction army rules It’s safe to say this is just bonkers right?

Army wide Full hit and wound rerolls on a unit every turn with no drawbacks or counter play is bad enough, but the potential buff stacking and combos this potentially will set up on over 100 data sheets is just maddening.

It’s not just that it’s so strong it’s that it will make balancing the faction that has the most data sheets infinitely harder.

Why not tie it to marine officers or something? For example the guard rule voice of command has short range and gets less useful for every officer killed and does nothing if no officers are killed.

Just make it so a captain or lieutenant, leader etc, has to “target” a unit for oaths of moment and that target must be within 12-24” of an officer model, if you lose all your leaders no oath. I’d honestly rather see them not having such an ultra Killy option in a supposed lower lethality edition, but at least make it have a higher risk/reward and give opponents a chance to counter it


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Aug 22 '24

40k Analysis What is the most Underrated Faction in Pariah Nexus?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Apr 08 '24

40k Discussion These Codex's ARE NOT RUINED

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Aug 28 '21

40k Battle Report - Text Battle Report: A Deed Worthy of Legend: 5-0 performance at IWTS Open

Thumbnail
goonhammer.com
14 Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 15 '25

40k Analysis "Let's talk it out"

0 Upvotes

I went to my second RTT yesterday. Got through my first two games with very few issues, other than slower players. I, myself, have been trying to speed up my turns by memorizing stats of my units and making sure I'm rolling when it makes sense and planning moves ahead of time. All stuff I've been told to do by friends/other players to get better with time.

That said, I came up on the 3rd game and aside from getting my teeth kicked in, (54-12 end of 3rd turn) I saw we had roughly 5 minutes left in the round. I reached out my hand and said, "Well I'm down to 3 units, there's nothing I can do for my secondaries, you have all the primaries anyway. Good game!" The opponent shook my hand and said, "So let's go ahead and talk it out."

I stared at him, not understanding what he was saying. I asked for an explanation and he said that in that location, players normally talk it out through the remaining turns to see what secondaries they would get and add potential additional victory points to their scores and have that number as the final score.

I explained that he would get to top of battle round 4, kill my 3 units and agreed that he would get secondaries and primaries again, but what was the point? We had 5 minutes left in the game. He wouldn't have time, particularly if I finished my turn of BR 3.

He kept reiterating that we should talk it out anyway, because he would like to see if he could get his VP up. I repeated that I didn't see the point, but okay. He drew secondaries for the BR 4, then proceeded to do so again, this time for a BR 5. I asked why, he repeated the above. I said there was no way we would get to a BR 5. No time remaining to get there, and besides he would table me in 4.

More of the same repeated statements from the above. I was tired, and simply wanted to start putting up my stuff and help breakdown the tables/terrain and go home. So I said, "Okay, I don't understand why this is a thing, but you just tell me what you want your score to be." He gave me VP totals (now in the 90's). I shook his hand, and submitted the score.

This seems crazy to me. My history is in old school Warhammer Fantasy and I played 40k back in 5th-6th edition. At this RTT, someone else mentioned doing the same thing at a different table. Is this normal, now? This seems to encourage and WAAC(win at all costs) or Get More mentality.

If this is normal, I'll admit its just me and adapt, but if this is singular, any advice on how to proceed in that community?

Edit Wow, not sure what about this made everyone down vote, but I appreciate the responses.

Definitely don't think I am asking this in bad faith.

I will adjust my perspective to be more open to the talking through unfinished rounds.

Thanks for the responses!