r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 30 '26 Hooray Bravo Popcorn

Immediate ban on AI Slop content

4.3k Upvotes

Effective immediately, AI-generated content and AI-generated code will be removed from the Warhammer Competitive subreddit. AI slop is unimaginative, derivative trash and has been observably seen as a negative by the community.

You want an image on your video? Make one, or pay someone to make it.

You want deep thoughts on the content of a video? Get to writing.

You want a web application? Learn how to code.

Thanks in advance for your compliance,

The Warhammer Competitive moderation team

Edit: after rumination, it's important to note that 100% generated code is what we're banning. Yes, code completion is a thing that exists and can be immensely helpful when creating abstract models that parallel each other. We've updated the text of the rule and the removal reason to be more explicit in this.

You can also stop reporting ListForge and Alpacasoft. We are not removing them, as real development work went into making these great tools.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Oct 08 '20

40k Event Results This community has a fundamental problem with the interpretation and citations of statistics and data.

1.9k Upvotes

During the no-play-for-COVID era, coinciding with the release of 9th edition, the community was given a unique set of circumstances, that we'll probably not see again. A brand new game prompting a brand new meta, but also no tournaments being played meaning no statistics or data to give any real insight into this new edition. People's opinions were flowing in discussion, opinions based on personal experiences, theories, and critical thought. People seemed a more open minded to creative ideas and fresh takes on units, and even things some might call outlandish were being given the consideration they deserve, rather than being dismissed offhand for not being represented in the month's statistics.

And that last sentence is my lead-in to the problem here. People using "the stats" to stranglehold discussion, and citing them as "objectively correct" ways to disprove opinions that are not represented in these statistics. Because now that we've had a few events and people are creeping back to the tables, this mentality is creeping back into discussion amongst the community. Take note of the fact as well that I've very carefully used the phrase "represented" here both times, rather than "disagreeing" or "agreeing" with the stats, because that's where a fundamental misunderstanding is occurring.

++~++

Just because an opinion isn't represented by the stats doesn't mean it disagrees with them.

Just because an opinion is mirrored by the statistics, doesn't make it correct.

The statistics themselves are objective. Your interpretation of them may not be.

++~++

So what does this mean? Let's break it down. The statistics are a measure of what IS, CURRENTLY, doing well. My emphasis on both words. The statistics represent the human beings who have taken their collection to an event, and performed well on the day. This is admittedly, probably a decent indicator that the armies that performed there are decent armies, and does prove one thing - they were capable of winning, well, whatever they just won. That's the fact the statistic tells us. No matter how skilled the player, that was achieved by a human playing the army, not a wizard (for the sake of stats having any meaning at all, we have to assume that neither player was cheating, which is honestly a pretty safe assumption in this relatively small, friendly insular, and communal competitive scene - we know who the cheaters are). And at the same time, it does not prove that any of the armies not positively represented by this statistic cannot also perform to a similar level. It just means they aren't currently doing so. And while this may be because they are underpowered and not capable of doing so, there's also a variety of other reasons as to why this may be completely unrelated to the power level of the army. If you have ever used an army's lack of first place finishes, or win rate, as "proof" that they are can't do well - you have fallen into this fallacy. It's an easy trap to fall into, but you have looked at what the statistics say, and extrapolated from that and interpreted them into saying something that they didn't quite prove at all.

For a recent example demonstrating this: midway through 8th, many people cited many statistics about Tau's win rate, and comparative lack of GT 1st place finishes, as proof as to why Tau just weren't a top army in 8th, or even a good one. Then Richard Siegler went and won 9 games in a row at NOVA and blew away all those "objectively proven" claims like dusting the windowsill with a leafblower. Or did he? Nope, even then we had people on this very sub dismissing his Tau placing as a fluke and getting upvoted for it, while citing the stats. We have the benefit of hindsight to know that this wasn't a fluke at all, and at the same time, a perfect example of just how counter-productive and strangling "the stats" can be towards building your understanding of the game. Tau didn't suddenly become strong at this event, they were just as strong before Siegler won with them, it just hadn't happened yet. And if Siegler didn't go to NOVA that year like he initially planned at at all and Andrew Gonyo's 2nd place Imperium got first place, while Tau didn't even crack the top 10 - guess what, Tau would have still been just as strong - but people staring at the stats would have no idea, because this wouldn't have been represented by any data. The stats don't lie - they just aren't saying what you think they are.

++~++

Some more reasons not related to a balance deficiency as to why an army might have a poor win rate or a lack of GT finishes, are almost all the human elements, something which way too many people are forgetting about or entirely ignoring when attempting to read the stats. For starters, this community is not a large one. We aren't playing millions of games a day like this is league of legends in its prime. We have a handful of tournaments weekly of varying sizes, and there is more than enough room for an individual person's presence or absence alone to skew data. This leaves obvious room for inaccuracies in trying to tie win-rate or finishes to overall power level.

Also, human understanding of an army. Everyone seems to have this idea that because there are competitive players for every army, that every army has been fully "solved". Siegler's list was a brand new approach on Tau that many people hadn't even considered doing with the army yet, and that started getting attention near the END of the season. It was always there, the human element of the players themselves hadn't really brought this style of play yet. And this is almost always possible the case for any undersuccessful army, that they aren't currently being played to their fullest. Even Siegler's NOVA list wasn't his final take on the list and he spoke afterwards on improvements he could make on it.

This last point also goes hand in hand with the statistics themselves - just because two list share a faction name, does not make them the same army. Erik Lathouras for example is one of the few people doing well with Tyranids. But of the people struggling with Tyranids, who else is actually playing his list of 200 Termagants or whatever and the same character support? All the other guys out here running monster heavy or genestealer bombs or whatever, share a data point with his list, but in reality they are completely different armies. How is the people out here banging their head against brick walls with the thoroughly outdated Stealer bomb, at all representative or relevant to the strength of a good Tyranid horde list? Answer: it isn't, yet still, it shares the data point.

The human playerbase of an army also varies - it isn't the same people playing every army! What if, hypothetically, Richard Siegler had decided as a human being, having a human thought, "anime is lame, I'm playing Khorne Berzerkers", and his contribution competitively was as a World Eaters player? Where would the general view of Tau as a faction in 8th have finished? Even with Siegler's wins and an improved understanding of the army by the end of the year, the army finished with a 48% win rate. I don't think it's unfair to say that I think many people would be saying right now that "Tau have been awful since 7th!", and citing "the stats" to anyone who disagreed. Playerbase's are made up of very different people, and have different players of different skill levels pioneering them and building our understanding of them.

This is true on a broader level than the individual as well. We recognise the positives of this sometimes ("oh, Orks as an army very commonly attract the kind of person who is boisterous and rowdy and loves a crazy melee!"), but people easily get offended when addressing the other implications of this sometimes. So I'm going preface this generalisation by mentioning that it's exactly that - a GENERALISATION, and like all generalisations is full of exceptions. An easy example is Space Marines - they are undeniably one of the most popular armies among newbies. Even players of other armies often started with Space Marines and eventually expanded / swapped into their current faction (Even me - my first army was Blood Angels!). The competitive win-rate of Space Marines is undoubtably dragged by a much higher rate of newer players, as opposed to an army like GSC or Ynnarri, subfactions of lesser popular armies to begin with, with a much smaller range, and also much harder to play. For this reason alone the Space Marine win rate will never be accurate. The same can be said for over or underrepresentation of an army. Slaanesh Daemons say could be a total sleeper, one of the best armys in the meta, but there's only so many events they can possibly win if only one good player is out there taking them to events. There's many other observations people can make about the playerbases of each community, I'll definitely say my own army, Tyranids, attracts a certain type of player as well, and this type player that I've found is most common among the vocal elements of our playerbase, is probably not the type of person best suited for the competitive mentality. And again (to both preface and postface now), this is a generalisation, and affects the overall statistic, but is not a reflection of any individual person, who may very well be a polar opposite to any of these descriptions.

I also want to address the dismissal people use "oh he's just a good player, so that win doesn't count". No, he's a good player, so that's exactly WHY it can count. This player is demonstrating what the army is capable of, it's them we should look to for where the ceiling of the army is, not you, who plays weekly with your buddies at the shop with your slowly increasing 3000 pt collection with a little bit of flex. That's not to dismiss anyone's experience as invalid of course and you may very well have great insight into your army, but it is to say that if we are going to look to someone for an indication of the the potential strength of an army being played to its fullest, we should look to the best players and the top-end outliers - not the weaker players, or mid level competitive players or whatever you consider the average comp player. It's also very dismissive, and often forgets that these results by excellents players are almost always playing against other the excellent players out there in the world, by just a few rounds into an event." I'm going to stick with my NOVA example for consistency here. Here's a couple of quotes from the reddit thread about his win, that attempted to do just that:

Siegler is an amazing player, but hes the outlier not the standard

.

One super successful person is the outlier, not the trend. Again, that's stats 101

Now we can easily see the flaw here in hindsight. Tau weren't underpowered at all, as was further demonstrated throughout the rest of the edition, Tau were very much an army of a power level capable of winning an event like NOVA, but quotes like these would happily say this wasn't the case and dismiss this placing as an "outlier" because of the "stats", when neither of these words mean what they thought, and only serve to give a blinkered view competitively. Richard Siegler is not a Jedi, he showed what his army was capable of, and if you or I can't measure up to that, it's not because the army is lacking.

And on the topic of player skill, just quickly, the difficulty of an army when combined with the human element is also going to have an impact on any overall statistic. In a hypothetical world where Space Marines and GSC are both perfectly balanced, and we requisition the exact same 1000 players take each army to an event, can you guess which one is going to have the lower win rate? Almost certainly GSC, the fact is they are just harder to play at a higher level and leave much more room for errors. This also affects army representation. I think most people agree horde Nids is probably one of the strongest ways to play Nids - but honestly who wants to go out and buy + paint up 200 termagants and exhaust themselves moving them around all day, just to help prove that Nids are a decent midtier army as opposed to a bottom one? I mean you're not even getting rewarded with a top tier army here. This sort of stuff affects the statistic - the statistic is a number which holds absolutely no nuance at all.

++~++

All of these points are important reasons why the stats are not objective measures of anything power level wise.

This isn't to say we should ignore the stats. Especially top 4's. They demonstrate a good picture of the meta. They demonstrate what is currently doing well, they often demonstrate the currently known power level of factions, and with unexpected or surprise faction placings they demonstrate what an army can achieve in the right hands or circumstances. However it's important that we recognise what the stats are saying and not get tricked into thinking they are saying more than they actually are. And to respond to a statement that boils down to "I think this even though I don't believe it to be known by others", with what is essentially a list of "well here's what we know so you're wrong" is actually just an irrelevant counter argument, to break the most common misuse I see down to it's simplest terms.

People are all over the shop, making these statistics say whatever suits their current held belief. I don't even believe it's intentional most the time. But we as a community have been victim to this mentality of "stats" and "data" being absolutely counter-productive to discussion for so long that its becoming ingrained, and causing people to be incapable of recognising facets of the game that are yet to be spelled out by these stats. I'd like to promote an increase in, or even just a return to, the use of critical thought, personal experience, and rationality, as support for our opinions and claims - and discourage the use (or should I say misuse) of stats to "counter" people's opinions, when very rarely are you doing that at all.

EDIT: Special thanks to Mr Siegler for providing my go-to example for this thread <3 There's many others I could have used, but that one was very prominent and fresh in most of our minds I'm sure, so hope he doesn't mind me making such liberal use of his name in here.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Mar 06 '25

40k Discussion Am I in the wrong for leaving a game after being Gotcha'd

1.7k Upvotes

Hey guys, I recently competed in a semi competitive tournament with about $300 worth of prizes on the line. This was towards the end of the event and I had gone 4-0 and was N4 on the ladder, with an okay win putting me at N3 minimum, I was running templars and my opponent was a well experienced player, and he had brought a World eaters army that was entirely proxies except for his angron model, the way our tournament works- you are only allowed minimal proxies unless you get the permission of your opponent, I'm fairly easy going so I told him I'm fine with his proxy list, as long as he let's me know what's what and reminds me before I make any major moves which he agreed to. Now keep in mind, this proxy army didn't look anywhere near original models and was hard to keep track of, and even multiple times through out the game he "forgot" which is which so i had to keep track of his units for him, so long story short, it's Round 3 I'm winning by about 25 points Im about to have control of the centre with helbrechts brick of sword bros and score area denial he has angron and another unit next to him, I charge angron with helbrecht, it's successful, I move in and he heroic intervenes with his other unit, which I was aware he could do that, and was fine with, because if anyone knows helbrechts brick, you know nothing is surviving its damage, but little did I know that unit was his master of executions with 5 zerkers. I told him we had agreed that he would remind me of his units before I made a critical decision, but his excuse was " I assumed you knew because I had put them next to angron to intervene, and my intentions was clear" so I'm mad as hell but it's late and I couldn't bother to argue as I had to already call a "judge" several times for him changing up his proxies. So what do you know, The best charcter killer in the game, kills both helbrecht and my castallan, leaving the sword brethren without letal hits and now wounding angron on 5s and 6s. So anyway.. i started swinging (joke) but I let him know that he played like a loser😂, and packed up. I've shared this with the tournament organisers, awaiting a reply.

(UPDATE) Hey guys, thanks for your comments, tips, and your support. After opening an investigation with the TO, my opponent was disqualified as a result of previous opponents having similar experiences to mine. Thank you all.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 11 '26 Bravo

40k Discussion 3DP armies only having 1 disposition is a feature, not an oversight.

1.4k Upvotes

Yes we all know you want to play Gladius as Purge, bring 3 RepExes, and table your op on turn 3.

Or Awakened Dynasty as Purge to punish your op for not being able kill your units that are designed to be unkillable.

The fact that you can’t do these things is the point. There have been like 5 posts this week about misaligned dispositions… but they’re not misaligned. They’re intentionally designed to force some armies away from playstyles they are capable of leaning into to the point of being unbalanced if given the opportunity.

I understand. I wanted Host of Ascension to be Recon or Disruption. Take and Hold sucks for it. But it’s also strong enough to overcome that and means I have to build a different style of list which is fine.

If we could all take our best units in our best detachments with the disposition of our choice then the whole DP system falls apart. I believe this is truly a case of restriction breeding creativity.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 13 '23

40k Discussion The amount of work put into 10th needs to be Acknowledged, above the complaints and moaning.

1.3k Upvotes

Woah boy. If I read the words "embarrassing" or "incompetent" or "pathetic" or some other word that disparages the work put into the various datasheet reveals, might just roll my eyes into the stratosphere.

I get it. Errors are annoying. Errors draw attention. Errors can cause confusion. Errors can make the game worse. But the reality is, errors happen. And when the step into 10th is the complete rebalancing, restructuring, and rewording, of every single ability, weapon, and unit, something like over 1,000 datasheets, I think a little bit of leeway should be given.

Calm down people. The world isn't over because Deathwatch have a super version of jet packs until a correction comes out. It is not pathetic because a Leader unit was not given a list of units to lead. It isn't embarrassing that a 2 should be a 5.

/rant

[HIDE]#GW please send the check to the normal place#[SECRET]


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jul 13 '20

40k Discussion Consolidated 9th Edition Points changes

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1.2k Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Nov 19 '21

PSA The Imperium is Driven by Hate. Playing this Game is Not.

Thumbnail
warhammer-community.com
1.2k Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 27 '26 This Heartwarming

PSA Hey Guys, a little help here.

1.2k Upvotes

This is literally for the guys. We need your help.

Hi, I'm Elle. I currently sit at 35th in the world in Drukhari, and am the highest ranked Drukhari woman competitively. I've been talking to a lot of other female players and a lot of us are struggling right now, so I want to have an open dialogue about the state of our game in terms of how we are welcomed and accepted into the gaming space.

In North America, there are less than 100 female competitive players out of 17,000. That's less than a tenth of a percent. Go to any female tiktok or instagram where we share gaming or painting, or our joy of the hobby and what you will find is some of the most vile, vulgar, insulting commentary you will see. This behavior isn't isolated to online.

So, from us to our male counterparts. What do we need to do to get your help with managing the toxic men in the hobby. We've stood by and watched so many in our LGS's continue to allow sexist and homophobic comments that make us not even come into the stores. We've proven that we are just as good at the game as men, and still we struggle with being accepted in the space. With that said...

What do we need to do to get better support in our local communities?
What have you seen work in your spaces?

We want to be here. We love this game, and we love being a part of the community when it is welcoming to us. That is becoming more difficult to find these days and some of us are struggling finding a way to keep playing with the way things are right now.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Sep 20 '22

40k News Votann banned in Germany

1.1k Upvotes

Votann are getting banned from most tournaments in Germany. If you are planning to attend a tournament in Germany with Votann, check with your TO's, if Votann are allowed. Most likely they are not.

The codex has been tested thoroughly the last 6 weeks and it needs a nerf. More information is avaiable on the Target Priority Discord.

Edit: Added source

Edit: removed source, since owner set video to private. Information is still avaiable on Target Priority Discord.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jul 27 '20

40k News Battlescribe is updated

1.1k Upvotes

That is all

Edit: Clarification. I am in no way associated with Battlescribe or the amazing team of people.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Mar 15 '22

40k Discussion So the whole Tyranids codex leaked…

1.1k Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jan 25 '24

40k Battle Report - Text Game got ruined

1.0k Upvotes

Different type of battle report today...

I was playing 1.5k admech vs 1.5k death guard, it was a semi serious game as our club have brackets / leagues.

Whilst I was playing, a person came over and simply started dictating rules and looking up stratagems in the moment for the death guard player, then they kept score(? For some reason) all the while telling my opponent what my plan was, as it was easy enough to spot but my opponent had their own plans but were quickly changed.

By the end if turn 3 I couldn't contest even though I tabled a few hard to kill units and had fair few numbers with some big guns on the death guard player.

I understand the community is there to help and assist players which I love doing - but I don't want to play 2v1.

At what point can you say, nicely that is to "Go away and stop helping".


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Feb 21 '22

40k Discussion Custodes are not broken, they are a club in a meta filled with seals

1.0k Upvotes

The transition from 9th edition to 9.5e created a number of drastic shifts in the meta. One of the most pronounced was the shift towards unkillable, uninteractive units. Durable bully units that can threaten the mid board and take a lot of punishment dominate many lists, regardless of faction. The back-to-back-to-back releases of Orks, the balance dataslate, and Crusher Stampede reinforced this meta trend. By the time the Custodes book released, basically unkillable models had completely taken over the the competitive zeitgeist.

And what are Custodes good at? You guessed it, overwhelming unkillable unit lists with their own killer, even more unkillable units. And what type of lists are good at countering Custodes? The same medium AP, high damage lists that have been pushed out of the meta by all the unkillable units running around. The sky is not falling. Custodes have not broken the competitive meta any more than Drukhari did.

Remain calm, take another look at your Codex, tweak your lists. Everything is fine.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Apr 30 '21

40k Discussion Drukari are not broken, they are a hammer in a meta filled with nails

1.0k Upvotes

The transition from 8th to 9th edition created a number of drastic shifts in the meta. One of the most pronounced was the shift towards elite infantry. Durable bully units that can threaten the mid board and take a lot of punishment dominate many lists, regardless of faction. The back-to-back-to-back releases of Codex Space Marines, Dark Angels, and Deathguard reinforced this meta trend. By the time the Drukari book released, elite infantry had completely taken over the the competitive zeitgeist.

And what are Drukari good at? You guessed it, overwhelming elite infantry lists. And what type of lists are good at countering Drukari? The same "wide" shooting lists that have been pushed out of the meta by all the elite infantry running around. The sky is not falling. Drukari have not broken the competitive meta any more than Mortarion did.

Remain calm, take another look at your Codex, tweak your lists. Everything is fine.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jun 03 '20

40k Discussion New players: your list will stop working. This is normal.

969 Upvotes

I've been seeing a similar sentiment across a lot of posts in the sub. "How will my list work in the new edition?" "My list needs X command points to function", stuff like that. I know a lot of people came (or returned) to the game in 8ed, so in case you haven't been through an edition change before:

Any list that is competitive in the current meta will probably not be in a few months. This is normal. You should expect that any list you currently run won't be competitive any more.

I can't think of a single edition change that didn't alter some fundamental rules of the game, and we know this one will. Most points costs will change. Command points are likely to be quite different. Some units will become much better or much worse, because the rules of the game itself will change. Just think of 9ed as a new game, just one that you can still use the same models for.

Also, the business model GW uses does not account for players who theory-craft a 2000pt list and then buy ONLY those models. GW assumes players are collectors, that a marine player has a collection of marine units they build their list from. Which is fine, because that is how most people buy models.

I'm not really criticising people here, but I can see a lot of posters setting themselves up to be really angry when 9ed comes out and the army they bought doesn't 'work' any more! But it's an edition change. Expect that this is going to happen. It's happened every other time.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Aug 05 '23

40k Discussion A message for all the casual chaps in here

960 Upvotes

Brothers,

As you read through this sub, please remember that it is focused on competitive play. That is, people playing in a competition setting.

If you are playing with the guys at your LGS you will find helpful information here, but it is not the words of God.

Does someone call a unit "unplayable"? This means it isn't viable in the competitive meta. This does NOT mean that mean that you can't play it against your friends and still have satisfying results.

Is your faction "bad"? Again, this is focused on a high level of play. It does not mean you should give up hope. At your LGS a skilled player can still get great results with a "bad" army.

I often here a new player say that he brought a unit or weapon because this sub says it is good. And that is still true, but it may be referencing a different meta. Maybe a unit is great at killing eldar, and you don't know any eldar players.

It is not enough to know facts, you need to know why the facts exist.

Play the models you like, practice, experiment, read, and most of all enjoy yourself. It's ok if you're not competitive yet.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • 20d ago

40k Analysis The Root Cause of Power Creep is the 4+ Invulnerable Save

931 Upvotes

GW's core system is really nice IMO. You have a set of paired stats that create natural counters of offense and defence. Strength is paired with Toughness. Save is paired with Armour Pen. Wound Count is paired with Damage. The defensive stats on the data sheet profile have natural counters in the offensive stats on the weapon profile.

They work together to create a nice variety of different profiles. E.g. High Toughness, Low Save, High Wounds.

You can also add in model count and number of attacks as another paired counter though a weaker one. As single shot weapons are weak against units but lots of attacks is almost always good.

This is a great system IMO. It creates clear options and allows a nicely shifting meta that ought to self balance to a degree as long as most factions have reasonably affordable access to most archetypes of defensive and offensive profiles.

If High T, High Save models are a bit under-costed people can bring their high S, high AP weapons and they have real counterplay to offset that advantage. We can achieve balance without too much intervention by the designers because for every option, there's an existing counter.

What happens if you break this system of natural counters? Like by giving a low strength unit lethal hits so it can still be effective into high toughness? The answer is... usually nothing. The profile gets a bit more efficient into that type of target and it's fine. That's the beauty of the system, it's quite resilient from a balance perspective.

There is an exception : If you have a unit with a with high T, high Save and high Wounds then the natural counter would be a weapon with high S, high AP and high Damage. Naturally, you can't have a weapon with all offensive stats high also have a high attack count (cause it'd have no counter) so it's balanced by a low shot count. The system has provided us a nice, natural counter.

UNLESS the unit in question has a 4++ Invulnerable Save. This undermines the value of AP. The natural counter to a good save is good AP but it doesn't work in this case. So our "High Quality" weapon with the low shot count is now super unreliable, it's dreadful actually. (Our beloved Casino Cannons - all or nothing!).

This breaks the system of natural counters. You should be able to counter a big tough Primarch equivalent model with your big, high quality guns, but they don't work right because they don't get the value out of their AP.

So... we've got a problem. Here we have a big-tough tank/monster and it's very efficient into anti-tank... The tool that should work doesn't. We can't have certain units running around without a counter and our designers know this...

So (in the next codex) they give a little buff to damage output. Maybe sprinkle in some lethal hits, or rerolls, to allow our higher shot count (lower quality) weapons to give the defending unit more saves. We can't give a buff to AP, because in this scenario having more than 2AP is worthless, so instead we have to attackers unit ways to deal more wounds. Maybe we get some plasma cannons with +1 to wound and reroll 1s (throw in sustained or lethal for good measure). NOW we're getting past that 4++. Just through sheer volume of saves.

These are our only options to have their be an efficient counter to the High T, High Wounds Good invul profile. We can either bypass the invul with devs or we can dish out more wounds.

But that's fine, now we can take a mid range weapon profile, add some buffs and do some reliable damage to a unit with an invul. Or we can have a smattering of Mortal Wounds. Balance has been achieved.

Except...

These buffs aren't just good into invul saves. Handing your opponent MORE saves is good against everything. And ignoring saves is also good against everything. If we take a gun that's say 2 shots, S8, AP2, damage 3 it's a really good profile into elite infantry. It's naturally balanced and efficient into that profile. If you give that profile a boost, (say, +1 to wound) it becomes efficient into other profiles and it becomes VERY efficient into elite infantry. It's now kind of just, good against everything.

So now you've got a DIFFERENT balance problem. There's a super efficient profile that's good against everything and GREAT against specific things gradually taking over the meta. So you've gotta nerf that thing (but then what kills a T11 unit with a 4++?). You know what, maybe we need to buff elite infantry? Now they get -1 to wound, or -1 damage or an extra wound?

But now those units are really hard to kill? So maybe we need to give the next army book full rerolls to hit? But that's crazy damage into nearly everything so maybe the next book needs a bunch of fire and fade? Or do we up the invuls to 3++?

And it just spirals forever until we have a big reset edition that tries to drag the power creep back to a reasonable level.

But we don't get rid of the original problem, which is that we created a profile that has no efficient counter in the game's core systems. Which means whoever writes the next codex has to respond with some kind of buff... and here we go again...

There're places where Invuls are fine because you're not removing the only counter. If we removed invuls, or just used them more judiciously , the system of natural counters would work again and we wouldn't see the design space spiraling out of control every two editions as designers struggle to create balance by endlessly adding stuff instead of removing the rule that causes the problem.

TL;DR - The crux of my argument is, the game is a system of counters. S/T, AP/Save, Dam/Wounds Attacks/Model count (sort of) but the invul breaks this system, it removes the natural tension between save and ap. It has no "Inherent" counter. So you have to add counters (mortal wounds, higher lethality), but then you have to add COUNTERS to the counters (FNP, better defensive rules, cheap hordes), and that's where power creep starts and how it gets out of hand. The same thing would happen if you had a rule that said "this unit can't be wounded on better than a 5+", you broke the natural dynamic tension between strength and toughness and now the next codex designer has to respond with SOMETHING and we're in big trouble again.

We saw this happen with mortals in 9th ed too IMO. Invuls, mortals to counter, FNP to counter that, super mortals to counter the FNP, SUPER FNP to counter the super mortals... GW gotta start removing rules that break the counter system, instead of constantly adding mongooses to eat the snakes that we released to eat the rats that we released to... etc.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Aug 13 '20

40k News All marines moving to 2 wounds!

921 Upvotes

It's officially confirmed in the community article today. Along with confirmation that all armies will be getting the new weapon profile rules with the launch of the marine codex.

Confirmed that all marines are getting 2 wounds. Also confirmed coming for Chaos and Grey Knights; also that all weapon profiles are getting updated across all armies with the Space marine codex:

  • Flamers to 12"

  • Heavy Bolters to D2

  • Melta to Dd6+2

  • Multi-Melta to 2 shots

  • +1S Powerswords

  • -1AP Astartes Chainswords

  • Plasma only overheating on a natural 1

Edit: also confirms some price changes as tacticals are moving to 18pts.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Nov 09 '21

MEGATHREAD Big FAQ and points update!

864 Upvotes

Link in text. Check it out on the community page.

2+ save guard tanks!

Baby knights get Ob Sec

Necron get more Core units

CSM get exploding 6’s to hit against everyone

Ad Mec and DE get point increase

Limit of 2 flyers in a 2k game


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Feb 22 '23

40k Discussion The Brutalis Dreadnought is the perfect example of what made most troops poor choices.

862 Upvotes

https://www.warhammer-community.com/2023/02/22/the-brutalis-dreadnought-is-even-more-terrifying-than-you-thought/

This is a Dreadnought that is billed as a melee monster. It is a variant of the ranged version and comes with massive claws to rip apart hard targets. The claws even sweep to give it some flexibility in melee. Seems interesting as an option, and the idea is fine.

Right up until you read and see the number of guns it has for no reason. I get that people want it to have a few build options. I get it having some different loadouts too. But why does it have guns on top, guns in the chest, and four guns in the hands with the fist build? The amount of shots coming out of this melee Dreadnought is just stupid.

If the design team wanted to allow the more fragile troops to play their roll other then just hiding, they shouldn't have given everything enough guns to kill an entire unit. It shrinks the design space of the game each time they add an extra gun to some random shoulder.

It seems Space Marines are the biggest abuser of this idea. It slows the game down to have to roll all the profiles. It takes away the opportunity to have a cheap, but tough melee option because they need to price in the firepower, and to me is always looks stupid.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Oct 26 '19

40k Battle Report - Video One of you said our battle reports were too long even at 30 mins. Well fine then, so how about 40k in 10 seconds! New battle report out now. Tau vs Chaos!

861 Upvotes

r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jul 13 '23

40k Analysis Who is 10th Edition for? (and observations on evolving strategies)

859 Upvotes

I am lucky to be able to play with multiple different groups when enjoying my warhammer hobby. I play mostly with a competitive group, and we enjoy trying to make the best lists possible. I also play with a much smaller, much older casual group. Finally, I have been an ambassador for the hobby for many years, helping teach and encourage new players in the hobby.

I have been able to play several dozen games at this point, and observe parts of another half a dozen games. And I have gotten to see this new edition played by the new player, the casual veteran, and the competitive player. My observations are obviously anecdotal, but I have seen each group approach the new edition in different ways. The experiences of these different groups is so different I started to wonder, who is 10th edition for?

The New Players:

I got to witness a small friend group at my FLGS recently try 40k, all in their early 20s. One gentleman got a small space marines force, he bought a sisters of battle army for his girlfriend, and his other friend thought Knights looked the coolest and picked those up. They started collecting in the end of 9th, and they played some at their home and some in the store. I got to watch several partial games when they were playing at my FLGS.

It is always fun to watch really new players try to play the game. You might think I would talk about something like towering as being a problem as one of the players chose knights, but honestly it didn't come up. Even when they played with terrain they didn't really use it, and most games had units standing out in the open shooting other units standing out in the open.

The simplified charge and combat rules worked really well for these new players. Very simple to understand and straightforward, without any nuance. The different abilities on each data sheet were a bit much for them, and from what I observed they basically played all the units without most of their special rules. Army wide rules were remembered, and that was all of what they used to modify their armies.

They were playing 1,000 point games, which now play on a larger table size, which means games weren't over in the first turn like often happened on the smaller tables in 9th. The rules were generally clear enough for them to follow. They did not, as a rule, use strategems or take battleshock tests, and the game seemed just fine without them. And they liked to recount the tales of great moments they had from games played at home.

There were, in fact, only 2 problems for these new players. The first was the overall lack of balance. The sisters player always lost. The knights player always won. The marine player won based on his matchup. The girlfriend quickly decided she just wasn't good at the game. I tried to be helpful, and I said it wasn't her, but the armies weren't balanced right now. This did not help. She was immediately mad at her boyfriend for "buying her a bad army" and "of course they make the girl army the bad one". Maybe I shouldn't have said anything.

The second and critical issue was the inflexible way you build lists in this edition. This is VERY punishing to people with small model collections. When points shift they don't have the depth of models to change things around like a veteran with a large collection can. The knights player had bought one big knight and two boxes of little knights. If memory serves he was running a crusader, 4 warglaives and an enhancement, and was running a list close to 1000 pts.

Then the points changed in the app, and his big knight went from fitting comfortably in his list to 60 points over. And even dropping his one optional enhancement couldn't help. Now in past editions close to a thousand people would appear on the internet and shout "MAGNETS!" at this poor soul in unison. Change your wargear, change your arms to a different knight, move this or that around and you can still play. But this is 10th edition. There are no options This player had his 40k "come to Jesus" moment as he faced that he now either had to run two big knights (costing him more than 100 more dollars to buy a second knight), or run 7 little knights which meant buying 2 more packs of armigers (ALSO costing him more than 100 more dollars).

Now the knights player was already getting shade from his friends about always winning with his army. And with the points change he very quickly had to face if he wanted to spend a lot of money to keep playing with his army. He considered just running with 900 points, but that didn't sit right with him. Given the social situation, he decided it was time to stop playing and not buy anything more. They decided to go back to playing DnD the next weekend. Although, I don't think the love of big robots has left this gentleman, as the group of three is now talking about trying out Battletech. Interestingly, of the three, I think the girlfriend is the most likely to stay in part of "The Hobby". She was the only one to paint any of her miniatures, and she got a lot of positive reinforcement from everyone at the game store over her paint jobs. I can see her becoming a painter with a "I tried the game and it just wasn't for me" story.

Now, while this group moved on to other games after this, I don't know that this was a bad situation for GW. Attractive box art and free rules got new players to shell out several hundred dollars each for a new army. They were mostly able to figure out how to play the game in a short period of time. Yeah, they didn't stick with the game, but a sale is a sale. If the business model expects a high level of churn, the basic selling points are there. It isn't until after you've made the plunge that you discover any of the problems. Then it will come down to each individual whether sunk cost fallacy motivates them to keep going, or whether they will move on to a different hobby. I wonder, is this behavior a bug or a feature of the edition design?

The Older, Casual Players:

I play with a small group of close friends that only play with each other, and we have all been playing together occasionally since 4th edition. Most of this group is in their late 40s through early 60s. This group is by FAR the happiest with the current game. In fact, I would go so far as to say 10th edition seems tailored made to cater just to them.

A lot of the problems of 10th are just not an issue for older, casual players who already own very large model collections. So the list building is very restrictive.... they have TONS of models they may not have taken off the shelf for years. They can pull anything they can think of off the shelf to make the points work out. If a 35 point change means they need to swap 4 or 5 units around to get to 2000, it is no big deal and even fun for them. These people own 10,000 points or more of their favorite factions.

So the game isn't balanced? Who cares? They don't play with strangers, and are very happy to house rule anything with their long time friends that might make the game more fun. I got to watch a casual game of 2000 pts of Eldar against a little over 3000 pts of guard in a siege game, and it was a pretty close game. And both players had a lot of fun. And neither player was prepping for anything competitive or cared at all about the state of the meta or balance.

Finally for this group, the rules are free means they don't need to buy anything to have fun with the new edition. They already have large model collections, add in free rules and 10th is all upside. The missions offer a lot of variety, assuming they don't just make up their own missions and win conditions. Strangely, while the people I know who are in the group are super pleased with 10th edition, this is also the group of people that does not spend money on the game anymore in general.

The Competitive Players:

The competitive group I run in is the most diverse, and also plays the most games. This group ranges from mid 20s all the way to early 50s. We play several times every week in person or on TTS.

This group is the least happy with 10th edition, although everyone I know is still playing. There are complaints about factions, points vs power level, how to handle terrain, the structure of the game as you play it more, how useless battleshock is, the lack of depth in the fight phase and the state of melee armies, etc. etc. etc.

This group actually digs into the details of the game, strictly play by all the rules, and also generally try to break mechanics by building the toughest lists possible. This group also buys the most, although rarely new. One gentleman paid a truly outrageous sum to secure 3 hexmark destroyers off of eBay, for instance, to build his 10th edition necron army. This group has several members with 3d printers if a hard to get item is needed on short notice for a tournament, although in general they buy the majority of their collection.

There are several things I would say about this group. First, there is a mood setting in that it is not the right time to invest in travel and hotel to go to a tournament when the game is so unbalanced. There are constant arguments about terrain or how the rules should change for the good of the game. This group is the one that is impacted by towering, indirect fire, skew lists, etc.

That said, the general consensus is to stick with the game and wait and see. They are treating this as a standard botched AAA video game release. There is hope that after 6 months or a year of patches the game will be great. This is very similar to, for instance, the release of Total War Warhammer III, with a rocky launch but eventually everyone was happy with it. There is praise for the app. There is some optimism that GW is committed to eventually getting the game right. And these players will generally stick around for that to happen. They just don't want to do tournaments right now until stuff is fixed.

I know that overall the competitive player base is just a small percentage of the overall customer base. I consider myself lucky to be in a group that plays the game this way. That said, I don't know that it feels like 10th edition is made for these players either. The current state of the game simply isn't competitive, and so it is hard to try to force it to be that kind of game. I'm curious how GW evolves the edition and if the negative initial experiences of this group will eventually be just a forgotten memory.

Part 2, Other Competitive Game Observations:

Now that I have played several dozen games there are other trends I am witnessing that are emerging from my competitive games.

Tactical vs. Fixed Objectives:

Tactical Objectives appear to be much stronger than Fixed Objectives. Indeed, it is rare I see a game with evenly matched armies (more on that below) be won by a player who uses Fixed Objectives. From what I observe this is due to three reasons:

First, playing Tactical Objectives can earn you more CP than someone playing fixed. Especially on turn 1 it is likely you only score 1 secondary and then bank an extra CP. When CP is so limited this can turn a key moment.

Second, playing Tactical Objectives usually scores you more points for doing the exact same thing. It seems small, an extra point here or there, but that adds up.

But it is really the third reason that is why Tactical are so powerful. There is no way to play defense. See, neither side knows what someone who is playing tactical objectives is going to have to do. If you build a flexible list that is good at playing the cards, you get to always play offense in the points scoring game.

When someone plays fixed objectives, you know every way they can score. You know how they score primaries from the mission, and you know what they have chosen as win conditions for secondaries from the outset. This means that you can plan counter play to thwart how your enemy scores. Maybe you hide characters, or kill units that are likely to deploy homers, or whatever. The point is, if you know HOW your opponent can score, a good player can then play to work against his opponent's goals.

But, outside of tabling someone quickly, there doesn't yet seem to be a lot to prevent a scoring list from playing tactical objectives. I mean, are you going to screen the whole table on your turn so they can't be in table quarters, or in your deployment zone, or in 9" of a corner, or holding your home objectives, or holding no man's land objectives, or killing your units that are on an objective, etc. etc.? The answer is no. The only counter play to tactical is to either kill outrageously quickly or to be able to score faster yourself.

Scoring vs. Killing:

The above situation regarding tactical objectives quickly leads to a strange situation. Combat can become very secondary when playing to win.

Let's take a simple situation. You have enough assets to kill one enemy unit in an area of the battlefield on your turn. On one hand, there is a large blob of hellblasters. These pose a strong combat threat. On the other hand, there is a small unit of inceptors that are now on your objective.

Now, playing to win the battle, you should kill the hellblasters. You want to degrade your opponents main killing threats as soon as possible. And if the hellblasters are dead now, they won't kill your units in future turns degrading your future options. To win the combat, they are the clear choice. However, if you don't kill the inceptors, they are going to keep scoring points.

Outside of lists with so much offense they can table the enemy very fast, more and more I am seeing that in the above scenario, killing the hellblasters is the wrong move. And this seems wrong to a lot of players on an instinctual level. Obviously you should focus down the biggest threats of your enemy so they can't kill your guys. The person who kills more wins, right?

But you can be tabled and win. I'm currently 9-0 with my competitive Tyranids, and I have been tabled or down to 1 model in 6 of those games. And my experience is not unique, other players in my competitive group are starting to get to the same place. My toughest game was against an Ork list that was also just built to score, with a final of 89-90 in my favor. And I've faced some brutal lists built to kill everything that comes their way, that just couldn't put up more than 60 or 70 points.

Now my record is anecdotal and I don't want that to be the focus. But the trend I'm seeing speaks to the very structure of how 10th is played and scored. You win if you score more points. And you can score very high consistently if you focus your assets on the scoring game rather than the killing game.

Under the Line Problems:

Right now the competitive scene is dominated by Eldar, GSC and Imperial Knights. These 3 armies are all very strong for their points, and each one is a gatekeeper of sorts that are keeping a lot of lists down. Add in Custodes to remove any other melee builds, and only a small handful of armies out of the 27 armies (+ imperial agents) are doing well.

One issue with a small set of armies being widely represented and hogging all of the wins is that it is more difficult to see some deeper problems that are also there, but being drowned out by the current big boys. If the top few super lethal armies are removed from the game, what happens next?

When not playing against the top factions, I'm starting to see a real trend in practice games of what may be the next set of problem armies. Specifically, Tyranids, Orks and Necrons all could really dominate the scene if not for the current set of top armies.

Tyranids and Orks can run builds with an almost identical philosophy and footprint. They take tons of MSU units and focus on scoring as much as possible in the first 3 turns, expecting to be tabled. When these lists are built right, the only counter appears to be EXTREME offense, to be able to table them faster than they can score, or a similar scoring focused build. And only the current top armies are capable of this archetype.

These armies are not designed to kill the opponent or really engage in the combat portion of the game more than necessary, but will comfortably score 80-100 points per game if you can't basically table them in 3 turns. Whether this is a focus on biovores, gargoyles, trygons, etc. or a focus on cheap trukks, stormboyz, gretchin, etc. these armies can be all over the board with lots of little units scoring any points they have to. If lethality is toned down overall, these lists will be able to dominate the game.

The last army that can play this game, but with a nice twist, is Necrons. They are also able to build a list mostly designed for scoring by leaning into tech pieces like hexmark destroyers, lone operative technomancers and death marks. However they are able to combo this with several very hard to kill blobs which they can also be used to sit on objectives and eat fire. Like Orks and Tyranids, this list type, as near as I can tell, is only being kept down by the 4-5 top dogs.

"Score Blitz" lists like this, when combined with good terrain and tactical mission objectives feel a little like playing on easy mode. They also directly work against the ethos of people that want the game to boil down to the side that wins the combat wins the game. If the top dogs get hammered down, will this be the next set of dominant armies?

Hopefully this all gives you something to think about. Have any of you seen the same trends in your own games? What is your experience? Let me know what you think and good luck in your future games!


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Oct 10 '23

40k Discussion Always help your opponent play their best game.

854 Upvotes

After witnessing a surprisingly heated debate in one of the faction discords about "letting your opponent make mistakes" I feel compelled to speak my mind about how I feel "competitive 40k" should be played.

The example given was if my opponent declares a charge into my unit which has the fights first ability. In my experience, the correct and sportsmanlike thing to do in this situation is to remind my opponent that I have fights first and ask them if they still want to declare the charge. Alternatively if my opponent moves into overwatch range of my great big flamer, I feel compelled to remind them of the danger and ask if they wish to proceed. If I forget to remind them and they seem surprised or upset, claiming they weren't aware or they forgot, I always offer a takeback. There is so much to keep track of with our own armies and I don't think it is fair to ask my opponent to remember every single trick that MY army can do in addition to remembering their own convoluted rules. This is especially difficult in 10th edition where the number of reactive abilities you can use on your opponents turn has increased dramatically. Stratagems like Rapid Ingress and Overwatch (and Phantasm lol) are very powerful, but require one player to interrupt their opponents turn in order to declare their use. I don't want to win because my opponent forgot that I could rapid ingress on his turn, or because he walked into a bad overwatch or because he threw away his unit because he forgot I get to fight first.

However, there are apparently a significant number of people who don't feel this way at all. They seem to feel that unless their opponent asks them if they can fight first, they aren't obligated to warn them. Its your job to remember I can overwatch you and if you forget then sucks to be you. We are competing after all, and capitalizing on your mistakes is a perfectly valid way for me to win the game.

Please don't play this way. It sucks for your opponent and it makes you a worse player because you become reliant on your opponent making a big mistake in order to win your games instead of relying on your own ingenuity and good decision making. There will always be moments of friction between you and your opponents, but if you go into every game intending to help your opponent play their best game, you will know that you won because you were at your best and not because they were at their worst.


r/WarhammerCompetitive • • Jul 29 '20

40k Battle Report - Video Our first 9th edition game. First born vs Primaris marines! We worked really hard to get this out as close to the release of 9th as possible. Hope you enjoy!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
830 Upvotes