r/TrueWalkingDead • • Feb 14 '13

TV Show Is Daryl becoming too popular?

66 Upvotes

I love Daryl like the rest of you, but I'm concerned about something. You see there's a problem when a character on a show becomes the breakout character. This happened with Cartman on South Park, Steve Urkel on Family Matters ect...what happens is that the character eventually takes over the show. Steve Urkel became so popular that Family Matters felt like it was The Steve Urkel show. People forget that Family Matters use to be more about Carl and his family.

When a supporting character becomes too popular, they eventually end up becoming caricatures of their former selves. They feel less real, and the writing feels less natural. I don't want this to turn into a show where Daryl is constantly given these "Daryl" moments, just to appease his fans. This is already happening actually. Daryl is starting to feel like more of a fan fiction-esque character. Luckily his Merle story is keeping me emotionally invested in him. He's not a full caricture yet, but these "Daryl moments" might become more and more frequent, until Daryl eventually becomes a "Chuck Norris" type character, where it's apparent the writers are writing in a way to appease the Daryl fans, and not writing what should be happening. I don't want every Daryl line to be some badass remark. I don't want everything Daryl does to be some badass move that can be turned into a gif. I want Daryl to be a real character, with flaws, character development. He's that right now, but that could change.

If Daryl Dies, I won't riot. I will be sad. Extremely sad, but I will applaud the show for showing that no one is safe in The Walking Dead world.

I don't want Dary to die, but he should be able to die. I don't want Dary becoming a Steve Urkel type breakout character. And that's the last time I'll ever compare Daryl to Steve Urkel.

A show that has done a really good job of dealing with a breakout character is Boardwalk Empire. Richard Harrow is essentially the Daryl Dixon of that show, but the difference is that the writers of Boardwalk Empire do not circlejerk Richard constantly. They always focus on developing him as a character. He has badass moments, but it happens at the perfect time, and it happens after a lot of emotionally interesting stuff has happened to him. He feels real. He doesn't feel like an internet meme action hero. I hope the writers of The Walking Dead give Daryl this treatment. They've done well so far.

tl,dr: Darly becoming too popular could be bad for the show.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Feb 28 '13

Comic Street View comparisons of Walking Dead locations around Washington, DC.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
63 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Dec 06 '12

Comic Why the Governor keeps heads in tanks - You haven't read this as it wasn't in the comic, rather part of a special preview via CBLDF.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
63 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 16 '13

Comic The Walking Dead #111 Cover

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 24 '13

TV Show S3E15 "This Sorrowful Life" Official Discussion

40 Upvotes

Episode Details

Written by: Scott M. Gimple

Directed by: Greg Nicotero

Rick and the group are faced with a serious problem. If they want a truce with the Governor, they will have to make a huge sacrifice.


Promos and Sneak Peeks

Promo

Sneak Peek #1: Giving Merle a Break

Sneak Peek #2: Officer Friendly

Sneak Peek #3: Sides (Incoming)


Rules are found here and the sidebar

If you want to discuss spoilers before the episode airs, discuss them in the Season 3 Spoiler Discussion


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Jan 19 '13

Comic Spoilers! #109 Cover

Thumbnail
cdn.bleedingcool.net
40 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Apr 01 '13

TV Show RK interview on the finale

Thumbnail
tv.yahoo.com
38 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 03 '13

TV Show S3E12 "Clear" Official Discussion

37 Upvotes

Episode Details

Written by: Scott M. Gimple (Save the Last One, Pretty Much Dead Already, 18 Miles Out, Hounded, The Sorrowful Life)

Directed by: Tricia Brock

Realizing they are heavily outgunned against the Governor's forces, Rick leads an expedition to get more weapons.


Promos and Sneak Peeks

Promo

Sneak Peek #1: Begging

Sneak Peek #2: Stuck


Sorry for getting this up late folks.

A few things to note:

Remember to separate prediction and reaction discussions for ease of reading and participation.

The entire Clear episode summary is up in the spoiler discussion. That content, and any other related content posted there, is to ONLY be discussed within that submission until after the episode airs. Don't attempt to disguise spoilers by presenting them as a "theory".

Side note: The official discussion for issue #108 of the comic series will be posted March 12, with the issue releasing on March 13.

Edit: Wow, I think this has been one of our largest discussions, with a lot of good input. Remember that you'll soon be able to conveniently revisit all of our episode discussions in a hub in the sidebar.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Feb 10 '13

TV Show S3E09 "The Suicide King" Official Discussion

35 Upvotes

Written by: Evan Reilly

Directed by: Lesli Linka Glatter

Rick tries to rescue a member of his group. Woodbury is in disarray after a recent attack. New guests raise concerns at the prison.

Promo #1

Promo #2

Promo #3 "Eye for an Eye"

Promo #4 "Lead Me Home"

Promo #5 "We have a lot to talk about"

Taiwan Promo ft. Norman Reedus in shades

Sneak peek #1: Andrea takes a stand

Sneak peek #2: Allen Plots

Sneak peek #3: Team Carl and Team Tyreese

Sneak peek #4: Woodbury Loses It


Welcome back everyone to the return of The Walking Dead on AMC! Hopefully the lull in episodes means everyone is ready to jump right into discussion with tonight's episode. Since then though, we have had a few new members join us (who hopefully will take part!). Therefore, I want to set up a few reminders.

1. Posts should be geared towards discussion. Reaction posts are ok, but try to post something that will encourage folks to reply alongside it. Save the memes for /r/thewalkingdead.

2. Until the episode airs, any spoilers to the episode the discussion pertains to and/or future episodes should be hidden using the appropriate spoiler tags. Given that this is a discussion on the television show, all comic content should use spoiler tags.

3. Sub-wide rules and redditquete still apply. Familiarize yourself with them on the sidebar. If you think something may be inappropriate, it probably is. You can always message the mods if need be.

Special thanks to /u/dizzle22 for creating our countdown and /u/roastedbagel for setting it up. If you've enjoyed it, be sure to mention it.


Update: Here we go!


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Apr 02 '13

Comic Spoilers! Issue #109 Preview

Thumbnail
firstcomicsnews.com
34 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 08 '13

TV Show Under the radar parallels from s01e1 and s03e12 by /u/whatchanged

34 Upvotes

This is all from /u/whatchanged, none of this is from my brain. I just think this is fantastic analysis that I haven't seen anyone else mention

You know there were many post about "I'm sorry this happened to you". or Rick being stabbed in the same spot he got shot. Or Carl taking Morgan out like Duane did with Rick.

I liked another part way more:

At the end there was the scene, where Rick has a moment of realization. I knew this was supposed to mean more than indicated, but I couldn't put my finger on it until I rewatched the pilot.

Because of the pilot the last scene with Morgan has more impact than it already had.

In episode 1 Duane askes if he can have a gun too, while they are looting the police station. Rick, being all good guy Sherrif, says something along the lines of: "Yes, but you have to learn to be responsible about it. Before you pull the trigger, you have to be sure you want it. Never forget that." Duane:" Yes sir!"

3 seasons later we learn that Duane died because he didn't pull the trigger. This is significant enough already.

In the final scene Carl apologizes to Morgan for shooting at him. Morgan gets intense and tells him the already very popular: "Neva be sorry kid. You never forget that!"

This is the last of many verbal punches in Rick's face by Morgan. Rick realizes what he is referring to and that, if he realized back then, that the world has changed, he could have taught Duane a better lesson. Maybe one, that could have saved his life.

Edit: Season 1 Rick did what a responsible guy would teach a boy he cares about on how to handle a trigger: Being responsible about it and not killing people if not neccesary. That was wrong in this new world. Season 3 Morgan did what someone would teach a boy in their present world: Shoot first before there is a reason to be sorry. Rick knows Morgan tells him that with the exact same intentions he had when he was teaching Duane: Because he cares for the other's son. Rick's morals -> CLEAR

Sorry if you guys already caught that one, but I felt like sharing.

So while watching the latest episode, one had a feeling this was the episode to show Rick what was going wrong. Confronting old him with new him through Morgan and all that. I thought the whole orange backpack guy thing was also there to show how he adjusted to this new world etc., but that after this episode he would readjust again. I kind of expected the final scene of this episode to be, how Rick tracks down orange backpack guy and takes him with him to the prison. This whole episode would've then said: "The Sherrif is back."

Many still expect it to be kinda this way. Many expect him coming back from crazytown after he saw Morgan, but I don't think so. Well maybe crazytown, but not I'll-kill-you-if-you-push-me-town.

Because of the last scene with Morgan and the backpack guy's demise this episode makes a statement about the world and Rick. "The world has changed. The Sherrif is not needed anymore."

Edit: Also there is another point to Rick's character development. It's all clear now to him. He's gone crazy because he couldn't maintain everything good from before the apocalypse. He couldn't let go and therefore he lost it, when he couldn't save Lori. He lost grip of the Govna situation because he couldn't let it go. I think he will be able to do so now. He now knows, he doesn't have to feel pushed everytime something happens and then react. He has to pull the trigger, speaking he has to do stuff and thangs himself for survival.

Old Rick (Old Rick, not "good" Rick) -> CLEAR

Final Episode comment: It's been quite a while we have seen an episode in which I personally really didn't find it too far-fetched to find something significant about the story and character development, actually telling something meaningful elegantly. I am very delighted by this episode and I caught from this subreddit that the writer of this episode will be the writer for Season 4? Seems to be good news to me.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Dec 10 '12

CONTEST! ****Walking Dead Original Art Holiday Contest/Giveaway for charity!

34 Upvotes

Hello fellow Walkers!

user /u/roastedBagel and I are going to be running a Contest/Giveaway for charity and its REALLY simple to be a part!

First the good stuff!

I will be sending the winner an ORIGINAL piece of ARTWORK from The Walking Dead drawn by the artist Charlie Adlard!

How cool is that!??

All you have to do is enter by:

  1. Donating to a charity and submitting a picture link of the receipt/email from the donation- Every $1.00 donated = 1 entry. (ANY reputable charity of your choice will work!!)

The contest will end on January 27, 2013.

Any questions, feel free to PM either myself or Bagel and good luck!

As for the prize of the art - I will select a page from my gallery - which can be found here!

(More details on what page will come as the contest gets on!)

official edit - this contest has been extended to January 27, 2013 to include the sub-reddit /r/thewalkingdead!


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Nov 14 '12

Comic Official Discussion for The Walking Dead Issue #104

34 Upvotes

Release Date: November 14, 2012

"If you won't handle this...I will"

Tomorrow we will find out what Carl plans to do about the Negan situation following Rick's lack of action, and possibly see more of Jesus in pursuit of Negan's camp.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Apr 01 '14

[SPOILERS] S04E16 "A" Comic / TV Episode Comparison

Thumbnail
film-book.tumblr.com
33 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Oct 29 '13

TV Show AMC Renews The Walking Dead for a Fifth Season

Thumbnail
blogs.amctv.com
33 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 31 '13

TV Show S3E16/Finale "Welcome to the Tombs" Official Discussion

33 Upvotes

Episode Details

Written by: Glen Mazzara

Directed by: Ernest Dickerson

Rick and the group have to seriously consider if the prison is worth defending as the Governor's impending attack looms over their heads.


Promos and Sneak Peeks

Promo

Sneak Peek #1: Packing

Sneak Peek #2: Assault


Useful Links

Speculation Thread

Season 3 Spoiler Discussion

Read before PostingOfficial Discussion Rules and Hub


This finale isn't the end of our episode discussions until Season 4 premiers. More to be revealed later this week.

We will have a Season 3 Overview Discussion one week from today, to range from the narrative to the situation behind the scenes, so keep today's discussion focused on the episode itself and thoughts on Season 4.


Looks like quite a few new folks are posting outside our regulars, so welcome everyone! You are guests here, not prisoners, so make yourself at home!

Do be sure to read up on the rules of this sub though.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Feb 08 '13

Merchandise Season 3 DVD case. *drool*

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 10 '14

General Just want to say thanks

32 Upvotes

I love this sub! It is so nice to be able to read calm and thoughtful submissions about the recent television episodes and comic issues. I came from r/thewalkingdead - and 99% of posts and comments there are repeated memes, jokes, and general off topic nonsense. I was relieved to find this place for people who enjoy the show as well as the comics in a more respectable way.

So thanks to the mods for keeping everything grounded, and to the community for respecting the rules!


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Apr 01 '13

General ***Mod Announcement: After some unforseeable circumstances, we must close down /r/TrueWalkingDead***

32 Upvotes

It is with much sadness that we need to shut down /r/TrueWalkingDead due to legal and ownership issues.

This is completely out of my control and am extremely sad it has come to this. This community prospered in only 5 months and the people here have been nothing but exceptional.

We look to open something else you know this is an April fools joke in the meantime, and hope you all move over with us in the future whenever I decide to start something back up.

Thank you all for contributing and especially to cwazydiabetic for modding this with me.


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Mar 10 '13

TV Show S3E13 "Arrow on the Doorpost" Official Discussion

32 Upvotes

Episode Details

Written by: Ryan C. Coleman (Chupacabra; Nebraska; 18 Miles Out; Judge, Jury, Executioner; Better Angels; Beside the Dying Fire)

Directed by: David Boyd (Guts; Tell it to the Frogs; Vatos; Wildfire; TS-19; What Lies Ahead; Bloodletting; Save the Last One; Cherokee Rose; Secrets)

In an effort to prevent any more deaths, Rick and the Governor meet to come up with a peace treaty.


Promos and Sneak Peeks

Promo

Taiwan Promo

Australian Promo: Sorry about the poor quality.

Sneak Peek #1: Prepare

Sneak Peek #2: Meeting at Last

Sneak Peek #3: Making Things Clear

Sneak Peek #4: Change of Plan


The upcoming episode discussion postings, as well as the Official Episode Discussion SOP (rules), are located in the Official Episode Discussion Hub. That way we can get down to business and save some space up here instead of repeating the same 'ol speech.

I know that there's been a lot of work recently put into the AMC television series, arguably due to that being the main drive in traffic. There's only so much to be done at a time, so yes, the AMC series has been given a bit of priority.

That is starting to change.

Soon, you'll be seeing much of the work put into the show regarding discussions and features on this sub being put into the comics. We already have the Letter Hacks open discussion and our own Traveling Compendium. Hopefully starting this week, I will be posting a hub for the episode discussions (Issue #108 this Wednesday). I'll have the dates of each issue/volume/compendium release with their discussions, just like with the episodes. Yes, we will try to hold discussions on the full arcs just like we do with entire seasons. We'll also try and get some comic imagery up on the sidebar as well, though theming it to each issue may be problematic regarding spoilers for the uninitiated.

So if you're interested in the comics, we have not abandoned you! If you haven't joined in any of the comic discussions thus far but are into them, join the fun. There's plenty of room.

Have fun with tonight's episode everyone!


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Feb 17 '13

TV Show S3E10 "Home" Official Discussion

32 Upvotes

Written by: Nichole Beattie

Directed by: Seith Mann

As the group debates their next course of action, Rick wanders after a lost friend. Daryl and Merle question their choices. The Governor restores order in Woodbury and makes plans to punish those responsible.

Promo

Sneak Peek #1: Daryl and Merle

Sneak Peek #2: Glenn the Tactician and Michonne Speaks


This is going to be another character-building episode, so it will be interesting to see how the writing is presented and executed on screen this time around. Remember to spoiler tag anything about future episodes and comic content, even regarding rumors that may be common knowledge.

Edit: And thank you /u/dizzle22 for the banner!


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Oct 29 '13

[Spoilers] Regarding Carol this season

30 Upvotes

I tried posting this over at /r/thewalkingdead but they didn't seem that interested in discussing it. I found out about this sub and decided to post it here to find out what you all think!

I think Carol has plenty of motivation to act the she way did. Sofia died because of her inaction. If Season 4 Carol had been on that highway when the herd came through her daughter would still be alive. Now she's been given a second chance to keep her newly adopted family safe and it's clear she's going to do that at any cost.

.

I've seen a lot of people commenting about how they hate Carol because she's become just the worst character. How she's psychotic and unstable. I'd argue that her actions fit perfectly. This woman has been a pure renegade since Season 3. There was even a deleted scene where she threatened to slit Merle's throat if he kept messing with Daryl.

Carol took a preemptive strike against the disease to try and prevent exactly what is going down right now. It didn't work, but if she hadn't killed Karen and David she would have always wondered if it could have been prevented. Sure it was the wrong call and there needs to be a reckoning but there is a perfectly sane logic to her thinking.

.

Regarding what is next for her, as much as I love her character, Carol has to die. The setup is similar to Season 2 with Shane and Dale. She's the pure Renegade this season and as we've seen in the past that just isn't sustainable.

.

The good people, they always die. And the bad people do, too.

Everybody is being pushed to their breaking point this season. I think the tipping point for her is yet to come. I think she'll lose it after Daryl and Michonne hook up.

If this is the case, we may yet see [this scene from the comics.] (http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/Carole-Full-620x356.jpg)


r/TrueWalkingDead • • Jul 02 '13

Robert Kirkman announces new 12 issue story arc starting with October's issue 115

Thumbnail
newsarama.com
30 Upvotes

r/TrueWalkingDead • • Jan 14 '13

TV Show The Walking Dead 3x09 Promo #3 "The Suicide King"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
30 Upvotes