r/TrueWalkingDead • u/[deleted] • Feb 14 '13
TV Show Is Daryl becoming too popular?
I love Daryl like the rest of you, but I'm concerned about something. You see there's a problem when a character on a show becomes the breakout character. This happened with Cartman on South Park, Steve Urkel on Family Matters ect...what happens is that the character eventually takes over the show. Steve Urkel became so popular that Family Matters felt like it was The Steve Urkel show. People forget that Family Matters use to be more about Carl and his family.
When a supporting character becomes too popular, they eventually end up becoming caricatures of their former selves. They feel less real, and the writing feels less natural. I don't want this to turn into a show where Daryl is constantly given these "Daryl" moments, just to appease his fans. This is already happening actually. Daryl is starting to feel like more of a fan fiction-esque character. Luckily his Merle story is keeping me emotionally invested in him. He's not a full caricture yet, but these "Daryl moments" might become more and more frequent, until Daryl eventually becomes a "Chuck Norris" type character, where it's apparent the writers are writing in a way to appease the Daryl fans, and not writing what should be happening. I don't want every Daryl line to be some badass remark. I don't want everything Daryl does to be some badass move that can be turned into a gif. I want Daryl to be a real character, with flaws, character development. He's that right now, but that could change.
If Daryl Dies, I won't riot. I will be sad. Extremely sad, but I will applaud the show for showing that no one is safe in The Walking Dead world.
I don't want Dary to die, but he should be able to die. I don't want Dary becoming a Steve Urkel type breakout character. And that's the last time I'll ever compare Daryl to Steve Urkel.
A show that has done a really good job of dealing with a breakout character is Boardwalk Empire. Richard Harrow is essentially the Daryl Dixon of that show, but the difference is that the writers of Boardwalk Empire do not circlejerk Richard constantly. They always focus on developing him as a character. He has badass moments, but it happens at the perfect time, and it happens after a lot of emotionally interesting stuff has happened to him. He feels real. He doesn't feel like an internet meme action hero. I hope the writers of The Walking Dead give Daryl this treatment. They've done well so far.
tl,dr: Darly becoming too popular could be bad for the show.