r/Tiki • u/JLthephilosopher • Aug 22 '24
The Mai Tai Perfected? And What Should I Call it?
I couldn’t find mint today but this was better than no Mai Tai. I can only dream of a home tiki bar but this pic is in front of my home tiki bar cart.
This past year or so I’ve been working on a little book of tiki recipes I’ve developed—both originals and tributes to other cocktails, including some riffs on classics. I thought I could preview some for the tiki fans on here. I am new here. This is my first time sharing.
What better place to start than the Mai Tai? Not the quintessential tiki cocktail but perhaps the most iconic, and for me, one of the all-time greats. I would love it if anyone wants to try it (or any aspect of it) and share your thoughts/experience. The Mai Tai is one of the classics that, I feel, stands least in need of fixing, tweaking, or updating. It’s almost perfect. Almost. My tweaks are subtle and the result of “studying” (drinking) a lot of recipes for what is already an elegant and sublime masterpiece.
I will start with the recipe (with 2 variations) and for anyone interested I will follow up with a deeper dive into the basic ideas/principles underlying my approach to the Mai Tai.
My Ultimate Ultimate Mai Tai (not sure what to call it)
1 oz Fresh Lime Juice
5/8 oz Orgeat
1/3 oz Orange Liqueur
1/3 oz Maple Syrup (high quality)
2 oz Rum (See note on rum)
5 Drops Vanilla Extract (genuine high quality)
5 Drops Bittermens Elemakule Tiki Bitters
4 drops 20% Saline Solution
Variation-1 The Canadian Mai Tai
If you prefer something closer to a standard Mai Tai, these proportions also work perfectly if you just omit the vanilla and tiki bitters.
Variation-2
For those who prefer their Mai Tai less sweet I will drop the maple syrup and orange liqueur to ¼ and the Orgeat to ½ or 3/8—just under the ½.
Obviously, I have strong feeling about this cocktail (as many do) but I will preface this by saying that it is calibrated to my tase, however “balanced” can be different for everyone so at the end of the day, you do you, just take anything that works. Now I will say a little bit about each ingredient.
Rum
This recipe is not about the rum per se, it’s meant to be a template that can be used to riff-on using different combinations of rum. This is one of the great things about the Mai Tai. I have tried many rum combinations that work well with these specs.
I will offer a few recommendations for blends I enjoy.
First, a delicious and highly recommended blend of rums I have been enjoying most recently:
1 oz Chairman’s Reserve Legacy
½ oz Hamilton False Idol 151 Full Strength
½ oz El Dorado 12
Another go to for me is the blend developed by Kevin Crossman, the ultimate authority on the Mai Tai, for his famous “Ultimate Mai Tai.” I keep a bottle of this blend batched up because I use it in some other cocktails as well. Another advantage is that you can then easily split this ultimate blend with another rum to create some fun and complex variations. Ultimate blend:
½ oz Appleton 12 Rum
½ oz Smith & Cross Rum
½ oz Plantation OFTD Rum
½ oz Plantation Xaymaca Rum
If you are looking for a simpler and more affordable option, try this:
1 oz Chairman’s Reserve Original
1 oz Coruba
And to be honest, if you want to keep it super simple and economical, you could do a lot worse than just using Coruba.
Maple Syrup
This recipe is an iteration on my own earlier recipe I call the Canadian Mai Tai, which simply replaces the sugar syrup with maple syrup. The result of this tweak is subtle (perhaps surprisingly?) but I find it delicious.
Vanilla Extract and Tiki Bitters
The inspiration here is from one of the masters of modern tiki mixology, Jason Alexander, and his Officer’s Mai Tai. He uses allspice dram and vanilla syrup (AKA Don’s Spice # 2). I think the intention here is to add just a hint of classic tiki spice to up the complexity of this drink just a little. I love this idea but, in my cocktail, there is just not enough room in the specs to support this much extra sweetness, so instead I achieve the same basic flavor profile by using the tiki bitters and vanilla extract.
Orange Liqueur
For a tiki drink, the Mai Tai is extremely simple. With these relatively few ingredients, the precise ratios can make a huge difference. ½ oz orange liqueur is too much. The orange liqueur (in the most common specifications for this drink) tend to punch through and predominate too much. Just cutting back to 1/3 makes for a much more balance drink. I think this is more important than what brand you use. The usual suspects work well—Pierre Ferrand, Grand Marnier—but I particularly recommend trying a Mediterranean orange liqueur called Magdala, if you can get it. I think most people will find this very similar to and as good as Grand Marnier and it’s generally significantly less expensive.
Orgeat (pronounced or-zha**)**
This is the secret sauce. It’s the star of the show. It’s the most distinctive dimension of the drink. It’s what ties the whole thing together into a rich flavor-filled package. I know a lot of great mixologists still do it but, to me, using ¼ oz is insane. Just over 1/2 oz is what I find to be perfect, and if I am not using another syrup, I would go with ¾ if not 7/8 oz.
I generally keep two styles of orgeat on hand. For many cocktails I actually prefer the generally lighter colored, what I would call less rich, orgeat that works a bit more like an almond syrup. For a Mai Tai, however, I think you need the richer, more roasted notes of a generally darker brown colored orgeat. I use Liber and Co. It’s delicious in a Mai Tai but anything with a similar flavor profile, including home-made, would work.
Saline Solution
It intensifies the flavors a bit and also dials in the balance of the cocktail. I know it is common to drop the lime to 2/3 oz but this sacrifices a bit of the “juiciness” the cocktail needs and with the addition of a little salt, which cuts through the acidity ever-so-slightly, I think you will find this is not necessary.
