r/rum • • Jun 30 '22

Plantation is racist and cringe

http://fuckplantation.com
0 Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

14

u/breadley91 Jun 30 '22

They claimed they were going to change the name a while back and haven’t given any updates since.

2

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Yeah it’s been two years since then I think. Which is great since now they acknowledge it’s racist and they’re still sticking with it

11

u/fuzzyalchemist Jun 30 '22

This guy! To anyone in the comments who is saying, “how is this racist”, this is how. The company publicly has admitted that it is racist and they are going to change….but that was a couple years ago. Nothing has changed. Since then they are just plugging along and collecting your money until you forget they admitted it was racist and everyone on the other side gets exhausted hitting you over the head with facts and gives up. Typical corporate strategy.

Even if they change the name, they still suck. Their strategy of deception and adulteration is the core of the problem with the company. The name is just a reflection of how shitty they are.

-8

u/SoggySet3096 Jun 30 '22

How is another word for farm racist

3

u/ClairvoyantArmadillo Jul 01 '22

I’m going to assume your comment is in good faith, if it isn’t at least maybe someone else will be informed.

The transatlantic slave trade didn’t start in North America. Once the native population of the Carribean had been worked to death mining for precious metals and growing food for the Spanish crown and its enterprises, enslaved people was imported from Portuguese forts on the West coast of Africa. From there, French and British interests began occupying more of the region and required more labor. Sugar Cane became the number one cash crop in the world. The conditions for these enslaved people are as bad, or worse, than anything you’ve read about the tobacco and cotton operations in the US.

So, it’s racist because you’re naming a rum after a critical piece of the multi-century transatlantic slave trade.

4

u/SoggySet3096 Jul 01 '22

I realize thats bad and everything. But nothing you've said shows that the word is actually tied to racism. Yes i realize there may have been slaves on most plantations, but this does not mean the word is racist. This can only be the case if someone uses it in a racist manner. Words can't be racist. However the people that say and use them can be. Just hits home because I grew up on what you would call a plantation and there were no slaves nor did my family own any way back. They were against owning people and unpaid labor. Or so I've been told and some documents my grandparents have support this. And if you look up what the original definitions of plantation, in the 1500s it was defined as the action of planting seeds, in the 1600s it was another word for colonization, in 1706 it was defined as a large farm growing tobacco or cotton, and 1895 defines it as a farm, estate, or large tract of land usually in tropical or semi tropical areas. Doesn't really seem racist to me but I'm open to be swung the other way with facts tying it to racism.

1

u/SoggySet3096 Jul 01 '22

Sorry let me correct myself before you do. Some words obviously are racist which I won't list for obvious reasons. But they were created specifically for that. And at the same time some racist asshole had to come up with it. The word can't speak itself. Much like a gun can't pull its own trigger

10

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22

A rep of theirs was doing a tasting at our store recently and chalked it up to legal battles for 2-3 names they had in mind. Haha yeah, okay.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

One thing that I haven't seen mentioned in these comments and OP seems to be ignoring, is that in the article written in June 2020 Maison Ferrand anticipates the rebrand to take over two years. Everyone is acting like they've been ignoring this, but by their own estimates they aren't behind schedule.

And I know everyone likes to hate on the rum for being "boring", but it's honestly a great workhorse rum. Sure you may not want to sip it, but it works well in just about any tiki drink calling for a dark rum.

I am not nearly as offended by the dosing either. They may not put it on the bottle, but the info is readily available online and it's not an extreme amount either like Bumbu or something like that. The only bottle of their's I really think has an issue with its claims is the XO. All the rest seem pretty straight forward and I don't think it's a huge issue if the origin claim is less then accurate.

2

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Let’s suppose it is a great workhorse rum. Is it any better than the other great workhorse rums that don’t have a racist name or colonialist trade practices?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Oh cut the shit and fake crusade.

Let me ask you this: If tomorrow they roll out a new name and branding and properly label their bottles with dosage and region information, would you forgive them? If they supported the GI bill and respected it, would you turn the page and support them?

I'd put a bottle of OD on the line that you wouldn't.

Why don't you take this one step further while you're at it? Why aren't you crusading against Martin Cate and Smuggler's Cove for working with Plantation to make O.F.T.D. as well as serving it in his bar? What about Beachbum Berry for serving it in Latitude 29? If you're going to take up the pitch fork, go all the way in!

3

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

what is a bottle of OD?

idk why you think any of this is "crusading." I do not buy ferrand products, and I advise others don't either. I think they're bad news!

I do not live near those bars, and I've never been. not sure what else to tell you on that one.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Now you're just being pedantic. You don't live near Maison Ferrand I presume, but you're willing to boycott and post against them. So why's it matter if you don't live near those bars? Martin Cate and Berry are two of the biggest names in the rum world.

OD is Plantation Original Dark. Clearly you missed the snark in my comment.

3

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

I can buy ferrand products. I choose not to.

I don't know how I could possibly buy a martin cate or berry product? I would probably choose not to if I could.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Not just pedantic I see, but obstinate too.

9

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

lmao

7

u/anax44 Jun 30 '22

Plantation might be racist, but a lot of the people on that list gaslit anyone who brought up Luca Gargano's obsession with far right conspiracy theories, and are still actively involved with brands that use colonial nostalgia in their marketing.

5

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

I'd love to know more about this if you have some info. Definitely did not mean to imply other rum brands are good or perfect or whatever.

8

u/anax44 Jun 30 '22

I'll share a post with some info soon!

10

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

if you have a gif of him smashing an ipad, thatd be cherry

34

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

/r/rum is back babyyyy

5

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

In light of how much plantation posting goes on here I just wanted to share this helpful link to consider why you might want to purchase rum from someone else.

3

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

So where’s the racism? Not following quality specs isn’t racism

5

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

not for you, but for other people genuinely interested who may not know - a lot of plantations attitude in the past has been the "we're french we elevate everything by taking boring rum (ie poor distillate for cheap) and finish it in cognac casks", and in the past they used good old fashioned deceptive packaging and marketing language to try to mask the original rum and pass it off as french/plantations doing.

go and watch some talks by alexander gabriel, and you'll see some awesome mental flips of how shipping rum from the caribbean to france effectively ages it longer.

no ones problem with plantation is weird finishes or experimentation, those are good things. its how they use it to justify a weird colonialist mindset of doing business that should have died off in the late 1800s. but every time you bring this up with them directly, gabriel and his henchmen love to double down and try and gas light. its wild.

1

u/ManNamedDonaldBlake Jun 30 '22

I’m unfamiliar with Gabriel’s claims that shipping rum from the Caribbean to France “effectively ages it longer”. However, I am aware that many of their bottles specify how long a specific expression was aged topically and continentally, for which there is some logic to aging in different climates which other spirits have adopted (take Jefferson’s Bourbon Ocean expression for example). If I’m understanding your post correctly though, it sounds like Plantation’s position has been that the act of aging it in France alone (continentally as their labels would say) is what makes their rum superior? I would be interested if you could point me in the direction of any interviews or panels where Gabriel has “doubled down” though.

3

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

I'm very curious what part of jefferson aged at sea bourbon is logical.

1

u/ManNamedDonaldBlake Jun 30 '22

To clarify, I said there is some logic to the idea of aging in different climate. Jefferson Ocean was simply an example of a spirit, other than rum, that has attempted to apply that idea to their product.

1

u/AdditionalPuddings Jun 30 '22

Allegedly can be in a climate that has more climate swings which is what the bourbon folks want out of their aging. As many hot days and cool nights as possible. That being said unsure if putting barrels on a ship actual DOES that. Basically they want as much expansion and contraction as possible. Probably better to just use smaller barrels…

5

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

oh also, plantation calls it Dynamic Aging™. they bought a fucking peaky blinders ass barge for it.

7

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

i mean, plantation employees stopped replying in ministry of rum because they were getting dunked on so much.

its funny since like a lot of other craft producers over the past 20 years, gabriel was in the right spot at the right time, riding the wave of increased interest in transparency and information with demand for a superior product. so he starts following other peoples trends, mainly luca, to put more stats on labels to help educate his consumers.

except, putting more information on his bottles reveals what plantation is really doing, and he's effectively taught his customers to be wise to his lies. LOL.

cant have it both ways, trying to be deceptive while also trying to play off like youre transparent and honest and honoring the real rum producers with integrity. one will catch up to the other.

1

u/anax44 Jun 30 '22

i mean, plantation employees stopped replying in ministry of rum because they were getting dunked on so much.

I think that a lot of people in the MOR fb group see this as a victory, when it isn't.

A co-author of the document that OP posted gaslit people when they brought up Gargano's far right conspiracy theories and then locked the entire forum for a month until the issue died down.

But then the document says;

We hope Maison Ferrand is attentive to the conversations that are ongoing on social media, particularly in rum-related groups on Facebook. The tone of the conversations is not even slightly approving or accepting of your position.

Maison Ferrand could easily claim that MOR has a vested interest against their brand and that their employees were harassed there.

6

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

sure i think theres a lot of weird favoritism and power at play, particularly as some in that fb group are also part of veliers own special market development taste maker group, and dont want to spoil their relationship with gargano.

i dont really care either way. i dont think luca is better than gabriel by any means.

plantation choosing to just cover their ears and ignore the whole thing just shows how dumb they really are, and shows their real intentions which is just to milk other dumb consumers for as much money as possible, and not cater to actual rum fans. velier pulling all products out of american market just because luca got called out in some facebook comments is just as if not more dumb.

1

u/anax44 Jun 30 '22

plantation choosing to just cover their ears and ignore the whole thing just shows how dumb they really are

Idk, I think they realized they can't win over enthusiasts and are trying to focus elsewhere

velier pulling all products out of american market just because luca got called out in some facebook comments is just as if not more dumb.

Wait, they really did that?

Also, I don't really have a problem with Gargano. I expect a rich, old, white man to be out of touch.

My problem is that the entirety of the "woke" rum community tried to cover it up behind the scenes and suppress discussion of it.

People who profited significantly from 2016 until now by pushing progressive issues while being funded by some of the only rum brands that support far-right politicians.

-4

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

In the name that they refuse to change.

9

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

What name do they use that’s racist?

-5

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Plantation. I believe if you ask a black friend if he wants to visit your farm/plantation you will get wildly different responses based on which word you choose.

6

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Ok, That’s not racism… the word plantation doesn’t have anything to with race or forced labor by definition, and an “electrical plant” is a “plantation”. This post is a bunch of just trying to find things to complain about. Mods should remove.

9

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

I’m just explaining why I don’t buy plantation products and why I think others should consider doing the same. I’d love to hear more about the slave-free rum plantations of the Caribbean if you have time.

8

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Ok if you presented as such that would’ve been fine, but in the title you say they’re racist and cringe for using a synonym for ‘large farm’ that we typically and evidently incorrectly, associate with slavery or forced labor because of it’s use in the new world. Just because you associate something incorrectly doesn’t not make it reality.

I will repeat again this post should be removed because it’s just finding something to complain about, you care strongly and you research poorly. the name’s already being changed.

11

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

That was announced two years ago and we have heard no update since. I invite you to open a plantation to table restaurant and see what sort of clientele you get.

0

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Still a more recent article than yours. I’d assume they’re going for a strong rebrand and that takes time and money, something which was not really available in the middle of the pandemic, they could have already rebranded and just not been able to ship those bottles because of back stock and pandemic shipping.

8

u/Rachel_Underspoon Goddess of White Overproofs Jun 30 '22

ah yes, nobody could ever possibly mistake this French brand named 'plantation,' centered around an industry infamous for its sordid history of slavery and brutality perpetrated against native and Black people by, among others, French colonialists, for anything racist. after all, the word 'plantation' could also refer to an electrical plant!

I am very smart, you see, and definitely not deliberately blinding myself to incredibly obvious context.

-5

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

The founder named it this because he grew up on a “large farm”. People are so into conspiracy. Don’t try so hard.

9

u/Rachel_Underspoon Goddess of White Overproofs Jun 30 '22

oh, you mean like the people in the american south who grew up in neighborhoods with the word 'plantation' in their name and then dismissed any complaints as conspiracy-mongering- oh wait

-9

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Big french farm. Moo moo. Oink oink.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

Mods should remove.

lol

6

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Yes because the name is already being changed and OP’s article is almost 3 years old.

5

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

Yes because the name is already being changed

it is cute that you believe this, yet have insinuated that mount gay may be adding sugar to their rum. you don't trust those big corporations! well...except ferrand

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

It’s funny how words aren’t racist until someone in a power trip decides it’s racist.

-7

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jun 30 '22

Dont know any of my friends or family who have EVER been offended by this. You wanna Ban the word "whip" too? This is at a point where it aint even funny no more. This has to stop asap and white people should let black people decide If they are offended by it or not

2

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22

This dude tried comparing the name of a clothing accessory to the name of a company known for buying up ownerships of distilleries around the world, taking those distilleries’ product and shipping it to France for “elevage” and “blending” and who had previously taken credit for these products, labeling a Jamaican rum or a Bajan rum “products of France”. Too funny.

17

u/LIFOanAccountant Hampden Estate Jun 30 '22

Plus their rum is really Boring and samey tasting. Fernand cask finish and added sugar for all. Taste the "terrior"

3

u/memphis_rum_club 7/10 Jul 03 '22

I just spent a crapload of money on a nice vacay to Barbados.

Specifically did not visit WIRD lol

Visited the other distilleries that actually care about the island and are carbon neutral if not negative, plus making amazing, additive-free rum.

30

u/tscottf that guy with the video reviews Jun 30 '22 edited Jul 01 '22

I honestly don't think the most damning thing one can say about Plantation, from a consumer perspective, is that they've got a Bad Look name, or that the fact they announced a name change over two years ago and still haven't showed any signs of rebranding shows them to be either deeply dysfunctional or bad liars, or that they insist on marking things as "made in Barbados" when they often mostly aren't, or that the founders got their start by shaking down an old Cognac family until they could legally take their name and then invented a total myth about how they came into the brand (so, okay, liars). Set all that aside, if you will.

No, the most damning thing is that even if one looks past all that, the rum just isn't competitive. In the bad old days when rum topped out at Zacapa and the main "integrity" alternative was Appleton 12, maybe you could view the Five Star as a value, but the rum world has now moved on. Nothing Plantation makes that I've tried is at the top of its class right now; name something they put out and I can name something of similar kind down the shelf, usually cheaper. Most of what they make is light, sugared-up, laboratory rum where they justify their middleman role as sourcers via questionable cask engineering, and it's just not particularly good; and then when they release something less tampered with, they actually charge you more for the "extreme" privilege.

So one wraps oneself into knots trying to defend them for... well, what, exactly?

7

u/justinrcasey Jun 30 '22

I didn’t know about their history. That’s really crappy

10

u/cobranathan Jul 01 '22

name something they put out and I can name something of similar kind down the shelf, usually cheaper

OFTD

8

u/tscottf that guy with the video reviews Jul 01 '22

Hamilton 151. Or, less available, Pussers 151.

9

u/cobranathan Jul 01 '22

I like Hamilton 151 a lot, but I would not consider it a substitute for OFTD. Maybe making some sort of house blend, combining the Hamilton with a Jamaican and a Bajan would be similar. Rather than playing around with that, I prefer to buy the bottle that's already been optimized.

8

u/tscottf that guy with the video reviews Jul 01 '22

You know what, I'll give you that one. If you don't just need an aged overproof rum, but specifically a Bajan-leaning overproof rum (yes yes I know there's tinctures of Port Mourant and Long Pond in there), then OFTD is currently the only game in town. Until Mount Gay brings back their 154-proof Eclipse or we get an aged version of Cockspur 130 or Foursquare does a Doorly's 151 or something, sure, OFTD wins its class. I'll even give you Stiggins while we're at it, at least until Doctor Bird rolls out its Pineapple bottling sometime in the next year. ("Optimized" is pretty strong, though, as I've made the kind of home blends you're talking about and they end up significantly better.)

1

u/DASboat C<>H Rules Everything Around Me Jul 01 '22

I wouldn’t say it’s necessarily optimized. You could easily make a better blend with smith and cross, Hamilton 151, and doorlys, and it’ll average out to the same price and be better neat and in cocktails

2

u/cobranathan Jul 01 '22

I think the "easily" part is relative. I'm not interested in spending time playing with ratios to develop a proper blend of three rums. It's far easier for me to drive down the street and buy a bottle of OFTD, which I already know is delicious. As an added bonus, I don't have to drive out of state to buy a bottle of Doorly's.

2

u/DASboat C<>H Rules Everything Around Me Jul 01 '22

I just would disagree on the delicious part I guess

3

u/cobranathan Jul 01 '22

More evidence that taste preferences are subjective!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22

That’s like equating Appleton 8 and Hampden HLCF. Both will serve, but the difference will be noticeable.

5

u/tastycakeman Jun 30 '22

In the bad old days when rum topped out at Zacapa and the main "integrity" alternative was Appleton 12, maybe you could view the Five Star as a value, but the rum world has now moved on.

yes, now do velier

6

u/tscottf that guy with the video reviews Jul 01 '22

Oh Velier's got issues too, but different ones! Another day, another day...

0

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Anyone else feel this way

3

u/Tasumi11 Jun 30 '22

I might have misunderstood this but this link has following title: An Open Appeal to Maison Ferrand to change its position on Barbados Geographical Indication I agree that you shouldn't take advantage of Barbados Rum label if your rum doesn't have legal requirements for that. But where's the racism?

7

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

The name of the brand is Plantation.

-8

u/Tasumi11 Jun 30 '22

Ok I understand that it's problematic but do you know there is country called Montenegro. Do you want that country to change name? Are they called Plantation to insult people if yes please share link that covers that.

9

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Montenegro literally means black mountain in Italian. To my knowledge, there were not many slaves living or dying on this mountain.

Plantation refers to the sugar plantations of the Caribbean. Many slaves worked and died at these plantations.

0

u/Tasumi11 Jun 30 '22

Thanks for clarification. Agree that Montenegro was bad example. I didn't know that it literally means farm with slaves that's why link that talks about this would be helpful instead of Barbados Rum label

2

u/Melonskal Jun 30 '22

I didn't know that it literally means farm with slaves

It doesn't though. The word is much older than Carribean slavery.

7

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

montenegro means black mountain

what bizarre point are you trying to make? do you understand how language works?

-4

u/Tasumi11 Jun 30 '22

That words doesn't have only one meaning. So I just now googled definition of the word plantation and found out it can mean colonization or settlement witch i didn't know (English is not my first language witch doesn't excuse me ). I thought it only means farm.

But my main point was that the link was confusing because it wasn't about racisms.

10

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

yeah sorry for the confusing title. was trying to discuss two matters at once.

to be clear plantation generally connotes a large farm that relies on slave labor.

-5

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jun 30 '22

Again, white people tryna tell black people when to be offended. Brilliant

10

u/G-List Jun 30 '22

Colonialism and racism are pretty inextricably linked, I'd say.

27

u/LIFOanAccountant Hampden Estate Jun 30 '22

Thats it.

I'm tired of the deceit, i'm tired of the lies, i'm tired of the humiliation. They come in the mail, through my inbox, in the street, I can't escape it. They all say the same two things, the same two fucking words.

“Plantation sucks”

I was on my way to work yesterday when someone shouted this at me through their window, I could barely hold back my tears of rage

NO MORE

I won't accept this anymore, this is one of the best smelling and tasting rums out there. Alexander Gabriel was right, it's so beautiful. IMO it's freaking delicious and excellent neat.

I tried Plantation for the first time last month and holy smokes, I immediately fell in love with this one upon trying it. Even several hours after leaving the bar, I was still thinking about it. I got into Rum a little over a month ago, so it was my first serious sip of cane spirits and I wasn't sure if I would like it.....but wow. This rum was so insane I have no idea what to think. When the bartender poured a glass, I watched the smoothest-looking liquor (viscosity-wise) leave the bottle. I already knew I was in for a treat. I spent, no kidding, at least 2 minutes just smelling it. I would smell my shirt to refresh my nose then I tried breathing in the smell.

Now onto the pallette: reading that a rum is complex is one thing. Experiencing your entire mouth burst with all sorts of flavours is a whole other. If there ever was a moment of pure bliss in one's life, this is it. It was like drinking a literal sugar cookie in the tropics after building a hammock and having unprotected sex with your wife. It's like a Sunday evening grill with friends when you steal grandma's special nutty spice rub and make an amazing piece of juicy grilled pineapple. And start questioning yourself. What have I been eating for so long?

So smooth, rich and sweet. I think I found a lifelong staple in my collection.

Rum isn’t just a Product of France of exceptional quality. It’s an intense, roaring bonfire of a Cane Spirit passionately crafted and perfected on the shores of a faraway remote island. Like a sugary smooth drink at dusk, its sweetness envelopes you, banishing the wet and the cold with tropical notes, vanill, and an unexpected delicacy reminiscent of raw sugar. Not for nothing is this regarded as the Classic Product of France and, for me, the definitive Rum

Legends take time, 3 years in Ferrand Casks in France to be exact.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22

this reads like copypasta

3

u/LIFOanAccountant Hampden Estate Jul 01 '22

Who's to say

7

u/sequoiarabbit Jun 30 '22

Fill your shot glass with sugar before pouring — will taste even better!

23

u/LIFOanAccountant Hampden Estate Jun 30 '22

Man these Plantation bots sure showed up quick.

14

u/justinrcasey Jun 30 '22

I’m newish to rum and rum companies. How is this proposal racist and cringe? It seems like Plantation is being strong armed into only being only able to produce rum a certain way. Barbados rum is region specific and not a sub type like Agricole or bourbon. I don’t have a shoe in this game, so I don’t see how this is problematic.

I am also well aware that their name is very problematic and that they are working on changing names. A successful rebrand takes time from a corporate and legal standpoint. I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s a few more years before we see a name change. Not defending the name or brand, but it’s understandable why it’s taking time.

11

u/bigkinggorilla Jun 30 '22

That’s kind of the point of geographic indicators. You can’t call sparkling wine champagne unless it’s produced in the champagne region of France, and a spirit made from 100% agave is only tequila if it’s made in the tequila region of Mexico. But just because something is champagne or tequila doesn’t mean it’s going to taste the exact same as any other champagne or tequila.

The Barbados GI designation was intended to make it so Barbados rum meant the rum was distilled and aged in Barbados.

3

u/justinrcasey Jun 30 '22

So, if I get it correctly, it’s a thing so if you buy a Barbados rum, you know generally what it’s going to taste like? I get that. I’m not real familiar with champagne, but tequila can be aged in different kinds of barrels and it can also have additives. I guess I just like distilleries to be able to experiment with different flavors and techniques. That all being said, I want all the liquors information on the bottle do I can make an informed decision ie. how much sugar as been dosed, where it’s been aged, type of cask, any coloring added ect. But even then, I’m going to look online for at least some reviews or descriptions. But I also tend to research most purchases I make that I’m not real familiar.

It also seems to me that they don’t like the way Plantation does things and the market share they are growing. From what I’ve been reading, there seems to be a Good Old Boys Club there.

I also know this is probably me just being naïve and new to rum. I just don’t really get why it’s a big deal outside of those Barbados distilleries.

6

u/bigkinggorilla Jun 30 '22

Strictly speaking tequila must be aged in 100% oak to carry any of the official designations you commonly see (respodo and anejo). I’m not sure if other woods are allowed too at some point too, but a specified time in pure oak is required to earn those designations.

It’s really less about guaranteeing a consistent taste and more about making it so barbados rum has more meaning to it. Brands would still be allowed to produce whatever rums they want, however they want, they just wouldn’t get to call certain products barbados rum anymore.

7

u/justinrcasey Jun 30 '22

Ok. That I can understand. The way I was understanding it is they weren’t going to allow any manufacturer of rum in Barbados to produce something different. I’m totally fine with Barbados rum meaning one thing, but still being produce rums that’s doesn’t follow guidelines. Plantation Barbados 5 Year would just have to drop the Barbados name which I wouldn’t think would be too detrimental to markets, especially if they live up to their promise of changing their name.

Also I think Reddit is dumb for down voting my question.

1

u/overproofmonk Dec 08 '22

I'll upvote your comment here then, to balance it out! ;-0

13

u/doctom8175 Jun 30 '22

How is the word plantation any less problematic than the drink itself? Rum was part and parcel of the triangular trade that included slavery. If it is correct to reject the name should not also reject rum itself ? Myself, I’ll keep both and move on.

11

u/bigkinggorilla Jun 30 '22

Probably because you can make rum through non-slavery means while the name Plantation is inextricably linked to slavery.

Cotton was also part of the slave trade, and it’s ok to buy cotton products while not wanting to buy cotton from a company called 3/5 compromise.

9

u/doctom8175 Jun 30 '22

It’s only inextricably connected because we say it is. You can have a plantation with paid labor instead of slaves. My argument is that if you didn’t speak English and this was your favorite rum there is no connection to slavery. Words do not have inherent meanings they have expressed meanings. Slang is an important demonstration of this principle. I think there are better ways to improve relations rather than be distracted by manufactured outrage. Share some rum with a stranger you might not otherwise hang out with. Share this rum if you like it. I do.

5

u/bigkinggorilla Jul 01 '22

Theoretically you could have a plantation with paid labor, yes.

But in practice the sugar plantations which produced the product that became rum were overwhelmingly worked by slaves. And the word plantation is the same in English and French and carries the same history. France dominated the sugar industry on the back of horrific slave labor in its Caribbean colonies.

And that’s a history the French company who started the brand in 1997 would have known about. They didn’t just choose the name at random.

It’s not manufactured outrage to call out a brand for a bad name.

And let’s be honest, you’re not going around with a bottle of rum walking up to strangers and sharing a drink and discovering new and meaningful connections. So, your argument about the drink improving relations between people and having more value than the name has problems rings a bit false.

1

u/doctom8175 Jul 01 '22

I get you are trying to make a solid argument but perhaps your straw man at the end undercuts you. I was not imagining anyone walking around handing out drinks and I suspect you know that as well. There are many times I have been in public say at a bar and you can choose whether to offer to engage a stranger or not.
As for your point, you made my argument for the rum as well. The history of rum is just as entwined with slavery as was the history of plantation. Not only is the outrage manufactured but your solution to capitulate and change a brand that you do not own. If your problem is with the brand then don’t drink it. My solution would be to help broaden our circles to help broaden our experience and perspective. Your need to reject that with a straw argument so that you can enlist people to follow your banner of outrage does more to divide than unite.

4

u/bigkinggorilla Jul 01 '22

How many times have you approached a stranger at a bar and bought them a glass of Plantation in an effort to broaden your experiences and perspectives? Or are you saying in general going out to a bar you have the opportunity to meet people and broaden your experiences? If it’s the latter, of course that’s true; but what does that have to do with this specific brand’s name?

People are capable of sharing a drink with someone and asking a company to change a problematic name at the same time. It’s not like those 2 things are mutually exclusive.

And again it’s hardly manufactured outrage. Maison Ferrand (the parent company of Plantation) has said the name will change because it’s problematic. People are just wanting them to follow through on that.

So, if some number of people think the name is problematic, and the company who has to spend a bunch of money rebranding also agrees the name is problematic, why are you arguing against the change? How does this change personally impact you more than seeing the name Plantation impacts people who see it as trivializing a horrific moment in American/Caribbean history?

And no, the product isn’t equally problematic as the name is. I get why you’re saying it is - so you can accuse people of being hypocrites - but that requires a gravity-defying leap in logic to actually reach that conclusion.

7

u/AdmiralAkbar1 Jul 01 '22

I don't know enough about Plantation/MF's business practices to weigh in on that, but I do love debating semantics, so I'll throw in my two cents on the debate as to whether the name's racist.

The crux of the arguments from the "yes it's racist" camp that I've seen is that using a word linked to the history of chattel slavery for a brand either cheapens and commodifies its seriousness, or whitewashes it by using the term in a positive context. It's true that the history of cash crops in the Americas is inexorably linked with chattel slavery for the first several centuries of their history. However, it's a term generally used to describe a cash crop farm in general, with or without slavery. If I described a sugarcane farm as a "sugarcane plantation," the average person wouldn't assume that it has anything to do with slavery. It's not like the brand is trying to strip all connotations of slavery from the definition, because there's already a definition that lacks those connotations.

There's also the question of whether knowledge of this brand would actually affect people's perceptions of chattel slavery. Would the average person see this rum and infer that it's making a value judgement about slavery? If they did, would it make racists more inclined to buy it? Would it cause people who already like this rum to less harshly oppose slavery? I can't see any of those questions realistically be answered with "yes."

Now, I'm not denying that it's impossible for a brand to use the word "plantation" in a context evoking slavery. If there was a modern American textile brand called "Plantation Cotton," the only debate we'd be having is whether the company's marketing department is racist or just extremely moronic. It's also possible for rum to be marketed in a racist way (see: the Rhum Negrita name & logo). But France is not America, and plantation slavery does not play a central role in their national history the same way that it does in America. So I find it a bit silly to fault a French company for using a French word (it's a cognate with English) for an international marketing brand because one of the word's definitions can have an unpleasant historical connotation in America.

3

u/bigkinggorilla Jul 01 '22

French colonies in the Caribbean dominated sugar production through at least 1802 on the back of horrific slave labor on sugar *plantations.” They lost control of Saint Domingue (now Haiti) after the slaves completed the only successful slave revolt in history, but continued using chattel slavery in other colonies.

The word plantation has close ties to chattel slavery in France too.

I strongly suspect the name was chosen for its connection to such historic practices to make people associate it with a rich heritage that didn’t exist (brand founded in 1997 I believe).

-6

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jul 01 '22

THIS! But since Americans think they the center of the universe THIS is the result. Than they wonder why one of their stereotypes is being dumb

9

u/fuzzyalchemist Jun 30 '22

Fuck Plantation and fuck Maison Ferrand. Fuck you if, “well, Stiggins Fancy is so good”. The fucking Applebees of rum.

4

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22

Goated comment.

4

u/affordable_firepower Jun 30 '22

Agree entirely with the letter.

Can't say I've ever had Plantation rum either

3

u/cobranathan Jun 30 '22

Honest question for anyone who doesn't buy Plantation products because of the name. If they changed their name tomorrow to something you don't find offensive, would you start buying their products (once stock with new labels was available to you) or would you continue to avoid the products because they're made/sold by the same company that called themselves Plantation for years?

5

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22

https://www.reddit.com/r/rum/comments/voca00/plantation_is_racist_and_cringe/ied4jsh/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

This comment pretty much sums up why I personally do not like Maison Ferrand nor will buy their products. Name change really won’t change much. The story of how they stole the Ferrand name for their cognac production also can be lumped up in this.

2

u/cobranathan Jun 30 '22

Makes sense. I know there are a number of reasons that people don't like/purchase Plantation products. I phrased my question the way I did to try and parse out two things:

First, I'm curious how many people actually make purchasing decisions based on a name that bothers them (as opposed to people who just like to tell the internet that it bothers them).

Second, I'm curious if changing the name would actually change those purchasing decisions.

0

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jul 01 '22

Egh, let’s be honest, no one buys a product based on its name or stops buying it because of its name and same will apply here whenever they change their name. People were buying a rum called Ron Esclavo ffs lol literally translates to Slave Rum.

1

u/cobranathan Jul 01 '22

That was what I was thinking. If the name doesn't affect what people purchase, what's the point of all the complaining? Also, from MF's perspective, why bother spending all the time and money to change it?

4

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jul 01 '22 edited Jul 01 '22

Because plantation, in the context of the business they are in along with their business practices and the ethos they very much paraded around with (thinking that French men taking distillate from other countries and taking it to France for blending and elevage turns it into a premium product, that they then labeled as products of France previously), is pretty bad/controversial to have as a name. The name is a gripe of mine, but it’s compounded on by all the other things. The name change was inevitable as they have been hounded for all their practices and a name change is easier than changing their entire ethos (they won’t change the way they create their products anyways) that will allow them to “save face”

0

u/bigkinggorilla Jun 30 '22

Most people would probably start buying it if the name changed. Just like most people were ok with buying Fanta and Hugo Boss after WW2 ended.

1

u/cobranathan Jun 30 '22

Were there boycotts of those brands during the war? I was under the impression that the Hugo Boss link only became widely known decades later.

1

u/bigkinggorilla Jun 30 '22

They are both products with ties to Nazi Germany that people started purchasing once that relationship was severed and the products were available for consumption.

Past sins tend to be easily forgiven when it comes to consumer behavior.

-1

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Oof I can't imagine giving any money to a place that'd name itself after a style of forced labor camp, even as an edgy teen.

3

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Says the edgy teen. You should probably look up the definition of plantation because it actually has nothing inherently to do with slaves or forced labor.

5

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Sorry your dictionary didn't come with a history lesson.

6

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

A history lesson like plantations existed before new world was found? Using resident labor? As explained in the definition of the word? You’re dense.

13

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Okay look because I'm a goddamn saint I'm gonna treat you like you're not a jackass.

Sometimes in language, words are ruined because they were used for awful things. Perfectly good words! Useful words! Words that you don't think should be ruined. Unfortunately cultural context doesn't care about any of those things. I'm mad about it too! Being mad about it doesn't change the fact that those words now contain those meanings. Being mad about it on the internet only makes strangers wonder if you don't understand how language and culture works, it certainly doesn't change anything. The correct people to be mad are are the worst people in history who decided that human bondage was okay. Peeing on their graves also isn't going to change anything, but at least the people who see you do it aren't gonna think you're a dumbass.

-11

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Definition of the word hasn’t changed. You simply thought it was something it wasn’t. Definitions of words don’t change unless the definition is… changed…

10

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Do you call your boss your master? Connotations matter too.

-4

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

I call him Chef or his name, both valid definitions, I’m not calling him something I made up or thought was his name though and that’s the point here.

-4

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

You do know a Wind Farm and a Hydro Electric Plantation are the same thing right? Look up what a synonym is.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Umm...

I have a thesaurus if you'd like to borrow it, because you're clearly using some other kind of reference book.

14

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Incorrect on all three counts, go check with a linguist.

-5

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

plan·ta·tion /planˈtāSH(ə)n/ Learn to pronounce noun an estate on which crops such as coffee, sugar, and tobacco are cultivated by resident labor.

an area in which trees have been planted, especially for commercial purposes. HISTORICAL a colony.

Example: That Hydro Electric Plantation produces energy for 10,000 people in the Pacific Northwest!

Since you don’t know how to click on links calling you dense, probably because you’re dense.

13

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

Definitions of words don’t change unless the definition is… changed

this might be the dumbest thing i've read in a long time

how do you think a definition gets "changed"? an official proclamation from merriam webster? no, they change when usage changes. when was the last time you heard someone refer to a farm as a plantation?

-7

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

I play Port Royale don’t ask me stupid questions, you got the definition wrong accept it and move on.

→ More replies (3)

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

How about instead of giving words evil power over you, you move forward, remove the evil power, and take them back

11

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

wait a sec, are you telling me that the meaning of words is dynamic and changes over time? wow, i had no clue

really makes u think!

2

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

It never changed, some people on here just think it-by definition-included slaves or forced labor when it simply does not. If you wanna argue that they named it after slave owning plantations on Barbados you can, hard to prove, but the word plantation is not inherently slave related in anyway.

10

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Look friend, wife just means woman, not married person. I don't know how everyone but me somehow got this wrong.

-3

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Idk what you thought you were doing with this comment but you have to be a married woman to be a wife. Can’t even get the definition right to that homie.

Edit: Oh I got you, you thinking this helps your argument is hilarious. You chose definition 1: which is just female human. But definition 2: is female; spouse.

Plantations definitions still don’t fit yours 🤷🏼‍♂️ ie large farm or colony.

7

u/LlammaLawn Jul 01 '22

Looooool yeah you get it words change meaning well done you got it sorry you had to feel like a dope to get there

-1

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jul 01 '22

You should reread that, the example you used is defined in the dictionary, the thing you’re trying to do with plantation is not.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

[deleted]

-1

u/Quetzalcoatle19 Jun 30 '22

Considering it’s a french guy born in France in the 20th century, not Jamaicans.

6

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jul 01 '22

lol

-6

u/SoggySet3096 Jun 30 '22

Actually it was just another word for farm from the beginning. To be specific in 1706 it was recorded as a farm, estate, or tract of land in a tropical or semi tropical area. In the 1600s it was another word for colonization. As for your argument that meanings of words change over time you're correct. Seeing that at some point western culture did have it tied to slave labor. But I'll use the same argument. Who says we can't change it again?

12

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

are...are you arguing that we "take back" the word "plantation" and use it to refer to farms?

is this satire?

-3

u/SoggySet3096 Jun 30 '22

Or use the original term. Whatever. It's pointless to talk to people like you. Either way. There's no way for a word to be racist. It's the people that use them that are racist. Except of course words created specifically for those purposes. Just like its impossible for a gun to shoot someone. Someone has to pull the trigger. Also we should be more worried about other things going on in the world. Such as economies, hunger, clean water, etc.

5

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

There's no way for a word to be racist.

smoothbrain moment

-2

u/SoggySet3096 Jun 30 '22

The smooth brain is you not reading the sentence after lmao. And technically the word can't create or say itself. We're the ones that create words and say them.

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jul 01 '22

IS you dumb? Where's the petition for name change, where's the Twitter outrage by black folks? We both know there is none. Same as the redskins being re-named and 9 Out of 10 natives not giving a fuck. Yall some snowflakes who love being outraged. Stay inyour fucking place and let black people decide wether WE actually give a fuck or not

6

u/baldurthebeautiful Jul 01 '22

Black folks are quite capable of speaking up for themselves on this.

https://www.southernfoodways.org/distilled-identity-2/

3

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jul 01 '22

Lmfao Baldurthebeautiful dunking on you too now with ease. Just stop speaking for Black People you don’t know.

PS: Love all the N word comments you left me this morning. :)

2

u/LlammaLawn Jul 01 '22

Baby doll, OP says it's racist and cringe. I'm saying it's racist and edgelordy. It may or may not be outrageous but it's definitely fucking embarrassing. Aren't you ashamed to be buying that shit where people can see it?
When you buy it and you're not wearing black does the liquor store clerk ask you if it's laundry day? When you're walking it out to.the car does anyone finding a Marilyn Manson CD in the lot assume it's yours?
When you get to your car do folks ask you if your hearse is in the shop? Do you find that people complement your eyebrow piercing without ever seeing your face? Buddy if you ever want to "rap" about how your parents just don't understand you and everybody in the world is stupid but you, you just put it here in the comments. You can accompany that post with a picture of your skull shaped novelty lighter.

-8

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jun 30 '22

There's not one black person out there offended by this. Let black people decide wether they feel offended or not and sit your ass down

9

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Damn you speaking for a large population that you certainly don’t know the entirety of. I don’t speak for all Hispanics. Speak for yourself.

7

u/Big_d00m Jun 30 '22

Speak for yourself. I doubt you even have African ancestry.

8

u/Rachel_Underspoon Goddess of White Overproofs Jun 30 '22

I can't presume to speak for the Black community, though I would certainly question whether one single person is entitled to speak for that community (hint: they're not).

I can say for sure, though, how I'd feel as a Jew if someone released "Concentration Camp Rum," or as a transfemme lesbian if someone released "Conversion Therapy Rum." (that is, offended as fuck.) So, take that how you will.

-9

u/Melonskal Jun 30 '22

I can say for sure, though, how I'd feel as a Jew if someone released "Concentration Camp Rum,"

This might just be the dumbest comparison I have ever seen in my almost a decade on reddit. Congratulations.

-15

u/Kamwind Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

A plantation is just the word given to a farm with a large house. So your comment is more against farmers then anything else or just ignorance of history and how the word has been used around the world.

12

u/LlammaLawn Jun 30 '22

Since you can speak English you should know better than to write this stupid, incorrect, ahistorical thing.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

A farm with a large house and if you knew anything about history the laborers were slaves on Barbados. Don’t be so thick.

-10

u/Kamwind Jun 30 '22

In that case you better be against the word 'house' and 'estate' since in barbados they used those terms with plantation not that common.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

You’re annoying.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/LlammaLawn Jul 01 '22

Bajans don't speak standard English.

1

u/ThRrEEsTacKz Jun 30 '22

White people telling us that we should feel offended. Can't make this shit up

0

u/Striking_Rutabaga824 Jun 30 '22

Fantastic rum

9

u/popeeyes30 Jun 30 '22

I concur. Plantation absolutely OWNS the rum game, it REIGNS SUPREME. I love how PURE it is. Spiced plantation rum is SO MUCH BETTER than other DARK rums that are polluting this earth. Yuck!

0

u/flat19 Jul 01 '22

I drink to relax, not to play politics or social justice warrior. You enjoy yours. I’ll enjoy mine.

8

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jul 01 '22

thanks for letting us know

1

u/flat19 Jul 02 '22

You’re welcome. Glad to help.

2

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jul 01 '22

So cool, straight edge.

1

u/flat19 Jul 02 '22

You bet, Spicy!

-10

u/jmlbm Jun 30 '22

here's the real problem though: there's no other rum that comes anywhere near being as good for the price point, we need decent competition if you want to replace plantation.

2

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

So theres about 7 gajillion rum brands out there. Personally I’m gonna choose to give my money to the guys who aren’t racist and shitty.

Is there a particular plantation product you’re struggling to find a similar/superior replacement for at a comparable price?

-5

u/CityBarman Jun 30 '22

It's not about which rum or company is better or worse. It's about availability. It's that Plantation gets much of its line on shelves and the others do not. It's about what bottles consumers can relatively easily put their hands on. I'm referring to the NYC metro area. Those who live in smaller regions are sure to have a worse struggle.

8

u/SidSpirits Jun 30 '22

yeah sure, just accept the bottles that are given to ya, probably because of cozy arrangements with distributors and the power of marketing money. Also, NY area has some of the best access to a variety of rums. one can choose other offerings, even if it takes a couple clicks on the interwebs

7

u/G-List Jun 30 '22

The ethics and business practices of the producers don't matter as long as the product is cheap and widely available? Isn't that the attitude that created this problem in the first place?

0

u/CityBarman Jun 30 '22

I don't like the ethics and business practices of many companies, including the multinationals that own Mount Gay, Appleton, Havana Club, Ron Zacapa, Bundaberg, etc, along with many other good liquors sold today. If we boycotted all the nasty multinationals, we'd have slim pickings to choose from, especially since smaller producers can't seem to keep up with demand or deal effectively with distribution.

6

u/G-List Jun 30 '22

At least you're honest about caring about a luxury product more than the people who are harmed by it, I guess?

-1

u/CityBarman Jun 30 '22

We're just not going to agree on this issue. I see all of Plantation's sins as being blown far out of proportion.

9

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

here's the real problem though: there's no other rum that comes anywhere near being as good for the price point

lmao wait, what? you're being serious?

7

u/jmlbm Jun 30 '22

I’m in Dublin - captain Morgan? Kraken? Havana club? It’s grim out there

4

u/No-Entrepreneur575 Jun 30 '22

Malta here. Selection is wider, albeit limited. The non-plantation good stuff costs easily € 20/30 more...

Edit: just to say that I feel your pain...

6

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

do you have a link to a local store or a list of what is available to you?

4

u/jmlbm Jun 30 '22

https://www.obrienswine.ie/ thats the main one. Sure a Havana club 7 is good, so is the especial but they’re more expensive. Even finding plantation is hard

7

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

2

u/jmlbm Jun 30 '22

Those price points though…

6

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

what price point do you want? many of these are around the same as plantation 3 star

1

u/Pollitin Jun 30 '22

You can try Ron Pepon if you go to Puerto Rico

-17

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

Where was race mentioned in that?

So what happened with the GI since January 2020?

Consumers know that, unless specifically labeled as such (e.g., spiced rum), Barbados Rum from Foursquare, Mount Gay and Saint Nicholas Abbey (alphabetical) is not flavored/dosed in any way.

Do we know that? What prevents Mount Gay from adding sugar, and how do we know that none of their products do?

14

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Not sure what you’re getting at here. Mount gay wants the law that says you can’t dose. Don’t think it’s super likely they’d be excited about that one if they were dosing their rums.

And the racist bit is not described on that website, but it is in the name. Didn’t think I really needed to explain why the name “plantation” was racist.

-4

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

Mount gay wants the law that says you can’t dose. Don’t think it’s super likely they’d be excited about that one if they were dosing their rums.

Or they're willing to change their rums when the law passes. "Likely" or not is not "knowing".

And the racist bit is not described on that website, but it is in the name.

Sure, in which case linking to a website about a GI is irrelevant to a racist and cringey product name because the product name is racist and cringey anyway.

So there is a disconnect between the title of your post and the website you linked to, therefore I was wondering if I missed something because I didn't study everything on that website. I was just asking if there was something in particular you were referring to.

If all you want to talk about is their product name and racism, you could have done that with a text post. Or if you wanted to discuss the GI, I would have mentioned the GI as being relevant to your post instead of posting about just racism.

If you just want to rant, that's fine, but I was trying to make sense of your post.

7

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

These are two things yes. The name is the racist part. The GI bit is the other cringe part.

-1

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

The GI bit is the other cringe part.

Sure, but that was unclear. If a global corporation lobbying in its own interests, which conflicts with the interests of everyday consumers, is cringey, then at least 80% of the entire liquor and wine shelf is cringe, and so is just about every product at your grocery store.

Mount Gay is majority-owned by Remy Cointreau, and the cognac industry is no stranger to bad behavior, among which is also the Ferrand cognac company.

4

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

I also don't buy Ferrand products. Glad you agree Ferrand is also cringe generally.

I believe this is extra cringe and racist bc all the companies from Barbados want this GI and this one European company is opposing it. Not just against the consumers' desires but also against producers' desires.

I will work on the clarity of my titles in the future.

0

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

I agree. My only points were a) whether I missed something about race on that website; b) and I asked whether there has been any progress on the GI since 2.5+ years ago. And I said that if you want to highlight and spark a meaningful discussion on the GI, your title was counter-productive. But that's your prerogative. Your post isn't very upvoted (~40%), so it's not likely to change a lot of opinions here.

Cheers.

EDIT:

all the companies from Barbados want this GI and this one European company is opposing it.

And Mount Gay is a European company too. And Foursquare was founded by a European person. I haven't researched each and every company, though, but chances are they're all European. So it's really about two cognac companies in a competitor fight. Like Diageo taking on William Grant, or any other liquor industry fight.

10

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

Or they're willing to change their rums when the law passes

lol, are you seriously insinuating that mt gay adds sugar to their rum?

-9

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

I have no idea. I don't think they would to their most premium products, but I haven't lab-tested each bottle of theirs.

I asked how do we "know" and how is that "knowing" guaranteed over time? The reason scotch and bourbon laws are so strict is so that consumers can actually "know" with more certainty.

Do you have an actual argument for how you "know" Mount Gay never does, or is that just based on your blind trust of a corporation and its brand name? The entire point of creating a GI would be to truly enforce it so that we can all know. Otherwise if you already "know", what would a GI change?

11

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

The reason scotch and bourbon laws are so strict is so that consumers can actually "know" with more certainty.

my man, that's literally the entire point of the GI that MOUNT GAY is pushing for

-3

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

Exactly, and I agree with that. So until that GI passes, you cannot "know". And so how do we already "know" that Mount Gay does anything if that's based just on faith?

OP said we know because they are pushing for the GI, and I provided the logical alternative is that we don't know yet until the law is passed. I was not implying anything.

10

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

damn if only there were some way to test this sort of thing like by using hydrometers

sheesh

-4

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

Sure, so keep testing. Got a link to recent tests of all their bottles?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

How do we know that bottled-in-bond bourbon was distilled by the same distiller, at the same distillery, during the same season, aged at least four years, and bottled at 100°?

And certainly, nobody's ever subjected their product to hydrometer testing...

-3

u/quercus_robur Jun 30 '22

Yes, I'm familiar with old tests or tests of unknown dates, but I support that site testing regularly and dating their tests. More information is great. But it would be even better to have the protection of law and real consequences behind it instead of just the weight of a blog's reputation.

How do we know that bottled-in-bond bourbon was distilled by the same distiller, at the same distillery, during the same season, aged at least four years, and bottled at 100°?

As I said below, "know" with more certainty. If someone wants to risk breaking the law, losing their liquor license, and a class-action lawsuit, nothing can stop them, not even GI laws.

But when there is no law, there would currently be zero legal risk to Mount Gay adding sugar to their cheapest product, and the average liquor store consumer would have zero knowledge about it, even if the rum blogs revolted over the change.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

[deleted]

10

u/cagliostro9 Jun 30 '22

Not sure where I'm denigrating consumers of Plantation. I am saying 1) the name is racist, 2) it is very shitty to go against the proposed GI that all other Barbadian rum companies are in favor of (and colonialist), and 3) there are other rums that are of similar or greater quality (imo) if you don't want to support Plantation. Happy to discuss any of those matters with you if you'd like.

5

u/SpicVanDyke Independent Reviewer Jun 30 '22

Damn now he’s gone back to lurking :/

9

u/stormstatic PM Spirits Jun 30 '22

lmao