r/ThreePedals • • Oct 20 '16

Carjackers leave man's car behind after discovering it has a manual transmission

Thumbnail
kmov.com
25 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Jul 25 '16

So...I've been driving stick for a little over a month and here are my findings...

24 Upvotes
  • I get much much much more annoyed with the people who want to stop half a foot away from my bumper while I'm on an incline.

  • I am far more observant than I used to be.

  • My brain has to do a little rewiring when I get an automatic, for a couple seconds anyways.

What things did you notice initially?


r/ThreePedals • • Dec 29 '16

Visible clutch engagement

Thumbnail
youtube.com
23 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Jul 30 '17

Badass Woman Escapes Kidnappers Using A Manual Transmission And Nerves Of Steel

Thumbnail
jalopnik.com
19 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Sep 04 '17

How do people move off as fast as an auto?

18 Upvotes

When the light turns green a car beside me would be usually be in the intersection as soon as get my car to start moving. I typically find the grab point then accelerate. Any tips? I tried to practicing today to get faster but I either stall or my revs rise too fast. I recently watched a you tube video where the guy said to practice accelerating and holding 1500 rpms then release the clutch slowly but its a little difficult because it takes almost no force to hit 1500rpms.


r/ThreePedals • • Mar 13 '17

Police: Driver shot, killed by frustrated carjackers who couldn't figure out manual transmission

Thumbnail
jalopnik.com
17 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Dec 20 '16

How a Clutch System Works - This YouTube mechanic deserves more views.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Jun 07 '19

Tip for smoother shifts

16 Upvotes

tl;dr: Instead of pulling the clutch slowly through the end of the biting range, pull the clutch quickly into the middle of the biting range and hold it for a second.

Hey all,

Just wanted to share a helpful tip that should smooth out your shifts. First, let's clarify a few terms since lots of people use different meanings for different things. If you use them differently, that's perfectly fine. These aren't absolute definitions - they're just how I'm using them in this post:

  • Biting range: I'll be using "biting range" to refer to any point in the travel of your clutch pedal where the clutch is touching the flywheel, including when pedal is completely let out.

  • Biting point: I'll be using "biting point" to refer a very specific point towards the bottom of the travel of your clutch where it first touches the flywheel. It marks the beginning of the "biting range" - once you move your pedal past the biting point, you are in the biting range.

  • Engage: I'll be using "engage" to refer to when the speed of your clutch disc and the speed of your flywheel match up, the friction material of the clutch is no longer slipping against the surface of the flywheel, and all the power from your engine is going into your transmission. At this point your clutch is completely connected to your flywheel as if they were a single piece. When your clutch engages, you no longer need your foot on the clutch pedal.

  • Engagement point: This is a specific point in the travel of your clutch pedal, thought to be towards the top at the at the end of the biting range. When this point is crossed, the transmission fully engages with the engine. This does not exist, and trying to cross this imaginary point in your clutch travel will lead to jerky, inconsistent shifts.

Now, the biggest misconception I see from people learning to drive a manual vehicle is thinking that there is a specific point in the travel of the clutch pedal - not unlike the biting point - where the clutch fully engages with the engine once crossed. It is thought that if they start at the biting point and, while adding gas, smoothly travel the length of the biting range, the clutch will engage once they cross a consistent and predictable point at the other end of that range.

Your clutch pedal is not what engages the clutch. Friction is what makes the clutch engage. The more friction you add, the less time it takes. The clutch pedal gives you direct control over time, but only indirect control over friction (via pressure). Try this the next time you drive:

  • Instead of slowly pulling through the entire length of the biting range, quickly (but smoothly) pull the clutch halfway into the biting range and hold it there while you give it gas.

    • Pull deep into the biting range - far enough to guarantee eventual clutch engagement.

    • Your gas pedal should not increase the speed of the engine, but rather keep it from slowing down too quickly. You should be far enough into the biting range that if you were not adding gas, your engine would choke or stall from a dead stop or jerk if in-between gears.

    • If shifting between gears, match your revs to the next gear as closely as you can before your clutch bites to reduce the time it takes to slip into engagement. Engagement when shifting between gears should take no more than a second, but can be almost instantaneous if your RPMs are in the right place.

    • Ease into this, and don't take it too far. Start by letting your clutch out just a little more than you're used to and giving just a little more gas than you're used to. As you get comfortable, you'll be able to gradually increase both. Biting too softly or giving too much gas will make your clutch will slip. Biting too hard or not giving enough gas will make your clutch shudder and your car jerk.

  • Without moving your left leg at all, manipulate the accelerator until your clutch is fully engaged.

    • If starting from a dead stop, get your RPMs just above idle before you bite, and use the gas pedal to keep your engine as close to idle as you can until your clutch engages. You'll be surprised how quickly you can engage your clutch from a dead stop this way. If you are far enough in the biting range, this should only take a second or two.

    • If shifting between gears, you will immediately begin to accelerate as soon as your clutch bites. Be aware that this is slipping your clutch, and there is an amount that is appropriate and an amount that is not. Regularly catching your needle as it's falling and quickly locking it in place will not take miles off your clutch. Sloooowly pulling your needle down or revving your needle up while your clutch is biting will. You can minimize or completely eliminate this wear by letting your RMPs drop (or blipping your throttle during downshifts) before your clutch bites.

    • The signs of full clutch engagement are the same, whether starting from a dead stop a dead stop or shifting between gears. You will stop feeling the vibration from the clutch slipping, you will see your tachometer's needle lock in place and quickly rise as you accelerate, and you will feel your engine's power being completely delivered to your wheels.

    • Clutch engagement feels different than hitting the biting point - there is no tap or thunk, and you feel a vibration stopping instead of a vibration starting. Both have a feeling of power suddenly going to the wheels, but power from full clutch engagement feels complete and even. Almost like all the power moves to your gas pedal, and your clutch pedal feels "done".

  • Once you feel your clutch engage, release the clutch pedal smoothly and completely.

    • Or don't. A big point that I want to make is that once you're clutch is engaged, the rest of the clutch pedal's travel is sort of irrelevant. Keeping the pedal pressed in won't cause the clutch to slip because it's already engaged. Releasing the pedal slowly won't smooth out the engagement because it's already engaged. Make sense?

    • Your clutch can be both slipping and fully engaged at the same point of travel in your clutch pedal. There is a specific, predictable point where your clutch bites, but the only point it engages is wherever you're holding the pedal when friction finally causes it to engage.

    • There's no rush to get off the pedal, and when you do there's no nuance or finesse to it. Once your clutch engages, just take your foot off. When you're shifting, the goal isn't to let the clutch pedal all the way out, it's to let it out enough for your clutch engage. Just be easy on your throwout bearing and don't keep your foot on the pedal - you can cause your clutch to slip if you suddenly deliver a lot of power to the engine since the pressure plate isn't entirely engaged.

Once you get a sense of what it feels like for your clutch to engage, you can then begin pulling the clutch through the biting range instead of holding it to make the engagement happen even faster and dialing in your rev-matches to make engagement instantaneous. This isn't THE way to shift, it's a starting point to teach you what clutch engagement is and how to smooth it out. The point is that clutch engagement is a matter of friction and time, not a point in the travel of your clutch pedal. The nuance doesn't happen in the clutch pedal, it happens in the gas pedal.

------------------

Edit: I wanted to add a point of clarification based on an exchange I had with someone on /r/cartalk. While this tip is fundamentally a way to slip your clutch, it is meant to be used along with rev-matching and not in place of it. Please do not use this to slip your clutch outside of it's normal operating range. In fact, once you learn what true, full clutch engagement feels like and what makes that happen, you should work towards minimizing the time spent in the biting range by letting your revs drop between shifts. Unless you are an absolute beginner you should not spend more than a second or two slipping your clutch. This does not include time spent letting your revs fall or holding your foot on the pedal.

If you perfectly rev-match, you will feel your clutch engage the instant you touch the biting point and you will not need to hold your pedal in the biting range. However, there is also no rush to get out of the biting range because at that point your clutch is fully engaged. You're not slipping the clutch by keeping the pedal pressed in. Perfect rev-matching is difficult, and if you get in the habit of pausing while you release your pedal you'll always have a little padding in case your clutch doesn't engage right at the biting point. Ultimately the goal is to learn what clutch engagement feels like - it isn't what hitting the biting point feels like, and it isn't another point in the travel of your clutch pedal. Match revs as close as you can, bite your clutch until it engages, then let off the pedal.

Having said that, there are a few schools of thought on if, when, how much, and how often you should slip your clutch. My personal opinion is that the clutch is a wear-part. It should be replaced at a certain maintenance interval before it wears out, typically once over the life of the car, to protect the rest of your drive-train. It is designed to slip within a normal operating range before that maintenance interval, and trying to stretch the life of the clutch past that maintenance interval is dangerous. The purpose of slipping the clutch is to minimize shock to the drive-train and provide partial power to your wheels when full power would cause you to go too fast or too slow. Furthermore, the drive-train is not a wear-part, and reducing or eliminating clutch-wear should always come secondarily to reducing or eliminating drive-train wear. Likewise, reducing wear-and-tear to your car should always come secondarily to driving safely in traffic. I would literally rather smell burnt clutch material in my cabin than experience a hard jolt from my engine stalling and my drive-train locking up, and if I need to power-shift to get safely through a busy intersection I'm going to. A perfect driver making perfect shifts in perfect traffic will never slip the clutch, but perfect drivers and perfect traffic don't exist. There's a way to slip your clutch, and a way not to do it.


r/ThreePedals • • May 06 '20

New car is jerky/bumpy in lower gears

15 Upvotes

Hello all. Just got a new Civic Si. I am also new to manual transmissions. I've noticed that when cruising around a parking lot/garage at lower speeds (< 10 mph), the car is very jerky (in both 1stand 2nd gear). Almost like it's sputtering, but the RPMS are in the 1000-2000 range. This also happens when driving in my neighborhood in 2nd gear < 20 mph.

It worries me because this is a brand new car (300ish miles). I've tried looking it up, and there aren’t many results (that I could find) regarding new cars having this issues. Do I need to patient and let the car "break in?" I haven't been aggressive accelerating. I rarely go above 3500 rpm (I shift around 3000ish). I'm attempting to rev match while down shifting. It goes well for gears 4-6, but the lower gears are harder.

Thanks!


r/ThreePedals • • Nov 17 '21

Why do you drive a vehicle with a manual transmission?

14 Upvotes

I am giving a persuasive speech in my COMM101 class next week about why everyone should drive a manual. I thought it would be fun to directly quote some Redditors for my conclusion! What would you like to tell a handful of students about why they should drive a vehicle with a manual transmission?


r/ThreePedals • • May 18 '19

How much gear grinding does it take to destroy a transmission?

14 Upvotes

I am a new manual driver, i own a 2012 Mazda2. I have grinded the gears by accident, it seems to happen whenever i am too careful with the shifter and don't apply enough left pressure when putting it in second. However when i am firm with the shifter and push it to the left a bit it feels fine, the question is, is this normal? a friend told me that's normal to feel if you don't use the shifter properly and slide it into gear the right way, i think i was pushing the shifter right against the "gate" and it did that. I have grinded the gears maybe 4 times in the 2 months i've owned it lol. But i haven't noticed any damage and when i am firm with the shifter it feels buttery smooth, and the more careful i am and the more tense i get the more i grind, so the question is, how tough are the gears/synchros? Are they pretty tough and able to withstand a bit of abuse? I won't make a habit of it of course but when i did grind i went to corrected it at once before too much time passed, maybe a split second. And the clutch on the car is fine, so that's not an issue.


r/ThreePedals • • May 04 '16

How do you change gears without "slipping the clutch"?

14 Upvotes

I was always taught that to change from any gear, press the clutch in, change gears (eg., 1st to 2nd), and then release the clutch. I just read in this thread that this is called "slipping the clutch" and that's a poor practice.

Did I read wrong or am I doing this wrong? I'm a brand new manual driver.


r/ThreePedals • • Nov 18 '13

I'll just leave this here. [Gear Shift Porn]

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • May 22 '20

I figured out the secret to heel toe downshifts.

13 Upvotes

After almost 5 years of driving stick, I FINALLY figured out what I was doing wrong.

Heel toe downshifts were inconsistent for me until today.

Put some muscle into that clutch. Really step on it hard and anchor your lower body into the seat.

Your right leg and foot won't be swaying around like mine were doing. I'm hitting crisp, clean heel toe downshifts 80% of the time now.

Late braking also helps because you're getting deeper into the pedal travel.

This might not be the answer for everyone but I hope this helps someone.


r/ThreePedals • • Mar 02 '21

tips for stopping on a hill

12 Upvotes

i’m fairly new to the manual game and my dad said the hardest part of learning to drive a manual are the hill’s because people will ride your butt and if your not quick enough from clutch to gas ratio then you will hit the other person. is there any effective better quicker way to do this?


r/ThreePedals • • Mar 18 '20

Manual in a drive thru?

12 Upvotes

Is there a right way to do this? I feel like I’m just riding the clutch and I don’t want to break anything.


r/ThreePedals • • Mar 02 '20

To anyone struggling right now.

12 Upvotes

If I could learn, a pretty stupid 15 year old, anyone can, just practice a lot, and keep learning, Conquer Driving is a spectacular channel with great videos. I have probably watched all of them already.

Once you know how everything works, and what each thing does, everything becomes way simpler.


r/ThreePedals • • Mar 27 '19

From a complete stop, is it A MUST to switch from neutral to 1st gear before switching to 2nd gear (instead of neutral to 2nd gear) if I want to accelerate again?

12 Upvotes

I'm thinking of gear 1 (for manual transmission car) as equal to the Smallest Chainring (for mountain bikes).

I have drive a mountain bike, and while in flat/straight road, I don't switch may chainring to the smallest one at all... ONLY when I'm in UPHILL.

I'm usually in 2nd-4th Chainring all the time in flat/straight surface.

Now for manual transmission car, in a flat/straight surface (not uphill):

  1. Can I switch my gear to 2nd gear all the time?

  • Let's say I'm approaching in an intersection (while I'm in gear 2) and I need to stop completely,

  1. Now I'm in an intersection, so I'll make a complete stop.

  2. let's say I only need a complete stop for 15 seconds, so I switch my gear to neutral and wait for the GO signal.

  3. Now, the GO signal turns on,

...If I came from a complete stop, is it A MUST to switch from neutral to 1st gear before switching to 2nd gear (instead of neutral to 2nd gear and skip 1st gear) if I want to accelerate again?

I'm thinking that... for manual transmission, gear 1 is only for uphill.

If I can accelerate in a Mountain bike from complete stop to 2nd chainring  (second one after the smallest) and skip 1st chainring then why not with manual transmission (neutral to gear 2) and skip 1st gear?


r/ThreePedals • • Feb 07 '17

5 easy ways to shift quicker

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Nov 18 '13

Heel Toe Driving Technique

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/ThreePedals • • Feb 23 '21

Question about daily driving

11 Upvotes

Hi guys! I’ve been driving stick for about 3 months now. I’m pretty decent, not as smooth as automatic but I’m not jerky either. I have had a burning question about neutral though. So let’s say you’re slowing down for a red light. You down shift through the gears, then go into neutral. But right as you get into neutral the light turns green and you haven’t stopped. There’s cars coming behind you, and you need to get into gear again. What do you do?


r/ThreePedals • • Dec 09 '20

Come off throttle completely during downshift?

11 Upvotes

I recently bought a 2017 Mazda 3 coming from a 2004 Acura RSX. The throttle response of the Mazda is much slower than the Acura was, and quickly blipping the throttle like I’m used to doing doesn’t get the engine speed up enough to rev match properly when downshifting quickly.

To work around this, I’ve been letting off the throttle just enough while I disengage the clutch, downshift and re-engage the clutch. With some practice I’ve been getting smooth rev matches without overshooting, but I am curious if this technique is unnecessarily wearing any components. Is there any reason I should let off the throttle completely before disengaging the clutch?

Thanks in advance for any insights!


r/ThreePedals • • Nov 21 '20

Clutch

11 Upvotes

I recently started to drive a manual and I been enjoying it. The only thing that sets me off is how hard the clutch is, it has given me knee discomfort. Is this normal or am I doing something wrong?


r/ThreePedals • • Jun 16 '16

Tips for shifting smoothly.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes