r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jul 07 '26

What if we get “everything” we ever want?

22 Upvotes

Always wanted to ask this, so please answer whatever comes to your mind.

What if a human has everything he ever needs?

Infinite money -> can buy everything!
Infinite knowledge -> knows everything!
Infinite love -> has everyone!
Teleportation power -> can travel anywhere instantly!

He never has to work to earn money, never has to find love, never has anything to lose, never has to miss an experience.

What will a man do then? And why?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 31 '26

Has anyone ever heard of the "Lucky Rock" thought experiment?

22 Upvotes

Two men are walking through a forest scattered with thousands of identical rocks. One man pauses. His eye falls on a particular rock — unremarkable, indistinguishable from the rest. Then a thought arises in him, seemingly from nowhere: if he keeps this rock, it might bring him some kind of fortune.

Here's the catch: the concept of luck does not exist in this world. Neither man has ever encountered it. There is no word for it, no stories about it, no cultural tradition, no personal experience that could have introduced the idea.

The thought appears fully formed despite having no obvious source in memory, association, or learning.

Where did the thought come from?

A friend sent me this and claimed it's a known thought experiment, but I've never seen it before. Does anybody recognize it? Is it from a book, paper, or philosophical tradition, or is it just an internet thought experiment?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 16 '26

why can't we use ai to delete money and just route what everyone wants? a thought experiment... hear me out

14 Upvotes

i’ve been thinking about how completely broken our society is. at our baseline, almost everything we do is just glorified survival. animals hunt for food, we work 9 to 5 to pay a mortgage. the only unique thing humans have ever actually created is the arts, sciences, and pure creativity. but we waste our lives just grinding to survive.

what if we deleted money from our zeitgeist completely and let an ai handle the logistics? here is my blueprint:

say we make land completely equal among everyone on earth to start on a level playing field. then, everyone lists 3 options of what they can give (skills, items, labor) and 3 things they want to receive. with ai’s rapid processing speed, it could calculate a massive route of direct barters across 8 billion people. if i want a laptop, i build a table, it goes to person b, their item goes to person c, and i get my laptop. no money needed.

to stop it from being a dystopian machine that forces you into a job, the ai looks at your dna, interests, and talents, and gives you your top 10 results in alternative areas, along with your percentage of success based on what the world needs right now. you have total freedom of choice. if you want to take a gamble on a 12% success rate to be a musician, you can.

plus, all education is 100% free and open to everyone. if you want a path but your success rate is low because you lack a skill, you just download the free training modules to build yourself up and boost your percentage.

if the ai automates the "glorified survival" part, humans can finally focus entirely on utilizing their interests and creating things.

i know humans are greedy and prideful, but that actually makes the system self-correct. if someone offers minor but wants major (like offering 2 rotten potatoes for a tesla), they won't get anything. eventually their own greed forces them to offer things of actual value until they build themselves up.

but i see a few flaws:

  1. if the ai tells you you only have a 1% success rate at something, it might stop people from taking the risks that lead to actual genius or art.

  2. if survival is guaranteed, the people working 12 hours a day on medical research might get resentful of people who just want to lie on their land and look at clouds.

  3. humans favor friends, so what stops people from trading favors off the grid and accidentally reinventing money?

obviously it will never come to be, which is depressing, but mathematically, couldn't a predictive resource network like this work? i want to know all its potential flaws and how humans would actually respond to it.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Sep 26 '26

Why "Looking into the Past" in Space is a Myth: The Late Party Theory 🌌🎈

13 Upvotes

Body:

People always say that because light takes time to travel, looking at distant stars means we are "looking into the past." But honestly, that's just a misleading way to describe what's actually happening.

The universe only exists in one single moment: The Present (Now).

Think of it like this: If a star 100 light-years away explodes right now, that event happened in its actual present. The past isn't a physical place or a movie tape floating in space that we can visit. There is no backup drive for the year 1990.

If you developed a ship that could travel faster than light and flew straight to that star to see the explosion up close:

You won’t land in the past, and you won’t land in the future. You will simply arrive at the star's actual present. But guess what? By the time you travel that massive distance, years would have passed, the star would have already changed, and you'd find nothing.

It’s literally like traveling to a party, only to arrive after it's already over because the commute took too long!

We aren't looking at "the past." We are looking at one shared present, but with a massive cosmic lag (ping). The only real past we can actually see and visit is the one saved as a photo inside your phone.

Change my mind.

💡


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 01 '26

Imagine for a moment that Trump was a radical leftist

9 Upvotes

This is a bit of a thought experiment aimed at those who are currently Trump supporters, but anyone can comment!

I know that this is going to be very hard but, imagine for a moment that Trump was a radical leftist. He still has the same personality--egotistical, narcissistic, brash, & power hungry but he strongly believes in everything that MAGA is vehemently against. He still uses the same strong arm tactics, but instead of using ICE to go after immigrants, he is using the ATF to go after right wing militias and neo nazi groups, non stop. All of a sudden, they are everywhere in your small town, harassing your neighbors at grocery stores because they look like they might be part of one of those groups. Now he is mandating that all cars must be electric by 2027 because he has large amounts of money invested in that industry. All schools must teach critical race theory, including private schools.

I could go further with this, but I think that this is a good place to start. The strong arm tactics are what really bother me because they go against every principle our country was founded on. We can't have checks and balances if every branch is corrupted or beaten into submission.

Why does it seem so easy to ignore the corruption and erosion of values in our society?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 05 '26

“What if the universe doesn’t expand forever… but loops back to you?”

7 Upvotes

Everyone says the universe is expanding.

Bigger. Wider. Endless.

But what if that’s not the full story?

What if going far enough doesn’t take you away…
but brings you right back?

Think about this:

Start with a single dot.

Now draw a circle around it.
Then a bigger one.
Then another. And another.

Each one expanding outward.

It feels like it just keeps going forever, right?

But that only works if space is flat.

What if it’s not?

What if space isn’t something simple like a straight line or a flat surface…

…but something deeper, something we can’t fully visualize?

Then “moving outward” might not mean escaping at all.

It might mean looping.

In a universe like that:

  • There is no true edge

  • There may be no real beginning

  • Distance might not mean what we think it means

And here’s the weird part:

If light can travel like this…

Then looking far into space might not just show distant galaxies.

It might show versions of where we already are.

The “dot and expanding circles” idea isn’t perfect.

In normal geometry, it doesn’t loop back.

But maybe the problem isn’t the idea…

Maybe it’s that we’re trying to explain something beyond our understanding using simple shapes.

Science today says the universe looks mostly flat.

So this isn’t proven.

But it’s not completely impossible either.

So here’s the question:

Are we exploring something infinite…

Or something that quietly curves back into itself?

What do you think?

BTW-This is just a thought experiment I had, not claiming this is real physics


r/ThoughtExperiment • • 13d ago

I'm 21, and I Can't Make Peace With the Idea of Death

6 Upvotes

I'm 21, and lately I've been thinking more and more about death and how quickly time passes. I genuinely want to know how others deal with this.

I've had three ex-girlfriends. All three relationships ended after arguments and breakups. What haunts me is that two people who were once incredibly close can see each other or speak for the last time without even realizing it.

Last month, I went to The Weeknd's concert in Hong Kong and met a really energetic girl. But I was too shy to ask for her contact information. I'll probably never see her again, and I still regret it.

One day, my parents will be gone too. The people I trust most and can always talk to will no longer be there. I wonder how lonely that will feel.

And now 2026 is almost over. I'm in my final year of university, and next year I'll graduate and enter the working world. Everything keeps reminding me that time only moves forward.

Personally, I don't believe in heaven, hell, reincarnation, or a soul that survives death. To me, death means the complete disappearance of consciousness. No memories, no thoughts, not even the ability to realize I'm gone.

Sometimes I imagine it as being trapped in the endless void of the Backrooms. But that's not even accurate, because being trapped would still require someone to experience it.

My mind simply can't comprehend its own nonexistence, and the more I think about it, the worse I feel.

I try comforting myself with familiar ideas: life is about the journey, enjoy every day, contribute something meaningful to society. I understand them, but emotionally, they don't really convince me.

I've even thought about dedicating more of my life to studying AI, contributing to open source, and advancing technology, hoping that one day we might find a way to preserve human consciousness indefinitely. Or perhaps medical progress could outpace aging within my lifetime.

I know neither is guaranteed, and copying someone's memories wouldn't necessarily preserve their actual consciousness. But I desperately want there to be a possibility.

Maybe that's selfish. I just can't accept the thought of my consciousness disappearing forever.

I know living indefinitely could bring suffering and countless problems. I don't think everyone should live forever.

I just wish we had the choice of how long to live.

Right now, I can't honestly say I'm at peace with death.

Feel free to judge me however you like, whether you agree with me or not. I'd also genuinely love to hear your honest thoughts and personal experiences.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jul 28 '26

The Self Centred Simulation Experiment

5 Upvotes

Hope this is clearly written and conveys my message:

Assume a simulation exists that is primarily designed around a single conscious observer. In such a simulation, entities and events unrelated to the observer may only be fully simulated when information about them becomes necessary. And to maintain the observer's experience and to assume that the simulation optimises computational time by only simulating the necessary observations.

The observer attempts to test this by observing an event happening in a room indirectly through a camera. If the observer is not physically viewing a room but the (live) camera is recording it, then the event should still occur consistently if the simulation treats the camera as an extension of observation.

However, if certain events only occur when the observer is viewing this room then the outcome changes based on whether or not the observer's observation was extended into the room (for example: with a camera).

Thus these are the outcomes:

Outcome 1: The simulation generates an outcome that is only constrained by information available after the observer opens the door.

Outcome 2: The outcome is determined by events that genuinely occurred before the observer opened the door.

Can observation force the simulation to commit to a causal history that would otherwise remain undecided?

If an observer had no independent log of events, could they ever distinguish between a simulation and an independently existing reality? If not, would the observer be unable to tell whether they are actually in a simulation or merely believing they are?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Feb 21 '26

The 50/50 Paradox: Why humanity always fails the ultimate trust test.

5 Upvotes

Trust is a beautiful thing until it's worth a hundred million dollars.

I created a simulation for a thought experiment I call the "50/50 Paradox." It puts two people in a room where greed, logic, and survival instinct eventually collide.

In the animation, things get complicated when an

"emergency" occurs and the oxygen levels start dropping. It raises a disturbing question: Is it betrayal, or is it just survival?

I'd love to hear your logical takes on this scenario.

Watch the simulation: https://youtu.be/6BfHeOdJDCc?si=aNbrJQ-8qydLGo-N


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Nov 09 '24

The Human’s Advocate: Thought Experiment

5 Upvotes

If God is all-good and perfectly just, would such a God allow humanity to have a defense at the final judgment? If so, this advocate would need to be someone competent in both human experience and the supernatural realm.

Imagine, then, that a divine "lawyer" is assigned to defend humanity’s moral failings in rejecting God’s will, as expressed in our actions and ethics today. This advocate would have access to all of humanity’s collective knowledge as well as spiritual insights beyond our understanding.

Consider six possible advocates, each with unique knowledge and motives:

An angel, one of Jesus's disciples, Jesus himself, Lucifer, a servant of Lucifer, or even God as self-advocate.

The Central Question:

How might each of these spiritual beings defend humanity’s moral decisions? Would they argue that human limitations, ignorance, or circumstances justify our shortcomings? Or would they suggest humanity’s failings reveal an inherent flaw?

The Follow-up:

How might God respond to these defenses, balancing perfect justice with mercy? Would divine justice be swayed, or does God's perfect knowledge already encompass all possible arguments?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Nov 04 '24

Roko's basilisk

5 Upvotes

This is the world’s most “dangerous” thought experiment. You will never worry about being harmed if you do not know what this thought experiment is. If you know what this is, you put yourself at potential risk. Research it if you dare!


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 10 '24

The Cryogenic Paradox

5 Upvotes

I was writing a scenario for a Science Fiction/Fantasy RPG the other day which involves a character from Our Time being cryogenically frozen and awakening in a Post Apocalyptic Earth which is so alien that its functionally a Fantasy World.

When this thought experiment occurred to me.

Consider Oetzi the Iceman. Based on his preserved remains, we know a lot about him. We know he was of quite advanced age, and had numerous health problems. Let's say for the sake of the thought experiment the Oetzi was not just a well preserved mummy. Through some unimaginable confluence of circumstances, Oetzi had been put in a kind of natural Cryogenic stasis. Just so that it was possible to revive him.

Is it ethical or moral to do so?

Consider for a moment the quality of life he would have. He would a stranger in a strange land, surrounded by people he can't even communicate with and machines he barely understands. His health problems would mean his quality of life would be quite poor. We could teach him modern language, but to tell him what, exactly? "Hello. Welcome to the future. Everyone and everything you have ever known or loved is dead and gone. You are too old to re-learn how to function in an entire new society. All that will remain for you is to live out your twilight years as a scientific curiosity."

Would it be ethical to wake him up? Or would it be better to let him pass quietly in his sleep?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 30 '23

What would the implications be of a universe that operated solely along the lines of classical mechanics? What unexpected results would we see?

5 Upvotes

I am a computer programmer.

One thing I wanted to do to test my understanding of classical mechanics and physics more broadly is write a simulation of a small portion of the universe operating entirely along classical lines (i.e. pre-quantum pre-einstein).

Obviously, this is going to be computationally intensive, so I wanted to only do a very small portion of the universe.

But that got me thinking about the broader implications of a purely classical universe. What would that be like and how would it differ from our own?

I know that a purely classical universe couldn't have the atoms that we have today, as electrons would radiate energy and spiral into the nucleus. This entirely changes the rules and laws of chemistry, and thus rendering life probably impossible. Time dilation and length contraction, as well as a constant speed of light. I suspect that means that the night sky would be very bright and very hot because light from all stars would be reaching it as they don't have a fixed speed. I suspect that without length contraction and time dilation, our entire understanding of electromagnetism must change because current in wires will no longer produce a magnet field.

What are some other interesting effects of a purely classical universe? What would we expect to see that we don't today? What are the broader implications of a purely classical universe?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 17 '26

A Time-Travel Paradox: Would you need words to speak to your future self? (The Materialism vs. Panpsychism choice)

4 Upvotes

Imagine you are walking down the street and suddenly encounter your future self, exactly 10 years older. You look into each other's eyes. Here is the question: Would the two of you need words to communicate?

Depending on your intuition, there are only two paths, and your choice places you into one of two fundamental philosophical camps:

  1. If you answered "NO" (The Panpsychism / Idealism Camp)You instinctively feel that because you are the exact same conscious entity, words are completely redundant. Your connection is immediate, holistic, and multidimensional. A single gaze allows a direct, non-material transfer of 10 years of experiences, emotions, and memories. You see consciousness as a fundamental fabric of reality that transcends physical space and time constraints.

  2. If you answered "YES" (The Materialism / Physicalism Camp)You realize that over those 10 years, your future self’s brain has physically changed. Billions of new neural pathways were formed, and the biochemistry is different. Physically, you are now two separate biological objects trapped inside isolated skulls. Since there is no physical wire connecting your brains, the only way to bridge the gap is through a material medium — sound waves (spoken words), facial expressions, or gestures.

I’m curious to know which camp your mind instantly chose. What do you think?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 29 '26

Does Shakespeare always write Hamlet?

4 Upvotes

So suppose a minor apocalypse happens, and all existing copies of "Hamlet" are destroyed, existing only in the minds of those who survive.

Now fast forward a few years and the last person who had ever read or heard a first person account of a retelling of the play Hamlet has died without recounting it to anyone. obviously since humanity was just brought to the brink of extinction, they had more important things to do.

Now fast forward a few hundred or perhaps even thousands of years, and society has bounced back, people are fine, and the arts are thriving again, and somebody just so happens to be inspired to write a play that follows the exact narrative structure and plot of Hamlet, and then let's even say for the sake of argument that he even names the play Hamlet, after the main character.

now keep in mind, this new writer has never heard the story of Hamlet, and doesn't even know who William Shakespeare was, as all the records were lost in the apocalypse.

But now Hamlet exists again.

Is Shakespeare still the author of Hamlet?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Feb 02 '25

Nuclear Reactor Speedrun

4 Upvotes

Imagine, if you would, a world without humans. A world where there are no houses or farms, and animals roam freely. One man is placed at a random location in this world, this man is immortal, cannot be injured or feel pain, doesn't need to eat, sleep, or drink, and in any meaningful way is immutable. He has one goal in life "Build a fully functional Nuclear Reactor." He know exactly how to do it, and exactly where every material is, but the issue is that he has to traverse continents in order to bring all the materials to a central location and assemble them. How long do you think it would take him?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jun 02 '24

If you could ask only one question and get the absolute truth, what question would you ask?

4 Upvotes

r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 24 '24

Just another thought like "if you replace every single part of a ship is it the same ship"

4 Upvotes

Lets say you have a band called orange or somth. The drummer of your band quits so you get a new drummer. Later the bass guitarist quits so you get a new one. As time goes on every single member gets replaced but at that point is it even the same band? Like they are still orange but their music wouldnt even sound the same. Its prob not an original thought but its rly similar to the one thats like if you replace every part of the ship is it still the same ship.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 22 '23

the boy with the red ball

4 Upvotes

did a thought experiment with my mate a bit ago. if you have a baby and raise it in a white room dress it in white clothes and have only black and white things, the only colours it ever sees are black and white. one day you take in a black bag with a white ball and a red ball and take out the white ball to show him. you tell him the other ball is not white, hes gonna assume the other ball is black. question is. is he wrong? bare in mind things in this world are considered true in the face of information we dont know about. your thought process may be flawlessly logical but if you do not account for every single factor you may still be wrong.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jul 01 '23

Why do the politically-motivated confuse *equal-human-validity* with *identicality*? .. A thought-experiment shows the difference ( :

4 Upvotes

( I'm an autistic hard-line empiricist: contradiction between Universe & theory means the theory is wrong.

That also means it doesn't matter which phenomena/person/whatever it is, that puts a lesson in one's sight: it is inhenently ones obligation to evolve.

Lessons are put in our sight by both left & right, for people who see what Universe is saying.

: )


Late last century, Rush Limbaugh, on his TV show, said:

"Men & women are different: how can they be equal?"

When one is mistaking "equal" for meaning identical, that kind of mistake can happen:

Lets try switching some pairs-of-terms, to see how well this stands up...

  • Men & Women are different: how can they be identical?

  • that-color-skin-people & this-color-skin-people are different: how can they be identical?

  • this language's people & that language's people are different: how can they be identical?

  • that culture's people & this culture's people are different: how can they be identical?

  • tall-bodied-adults & short-bodied-adults are different: how can they be identical?

  • old-people-with-much-experience & children-with-little-experience are different: how can they be identical?

So, we all see, within ourselves, that this is right: different means not-identical, right?


Now let's try it with equal-validity and see how well the statement holds up, this way:

  • Men & Women are different: how can they be equally-valid?

  • that-color-skin-people & this-color-skin-people are different: how can they be equally-valid?

  • this language's people & that language's people are different: how can they be equally-valid?

  • that culture's people & this culture's people are different: how can they be equally-valid?

  • tall-bodied-adults & short-bodied-adults are different: how can they be equally-valid?

  • old-people-with-much-experience & children-with-little-experience are different: how can they be equally-valid?


This shows, in many of us, that confusing these 2 concepts is bad, and that when using the word "equality", one needs to differentiate between which meaning is in the word.

No-one sane would insist that men & women are identical.

Only a machiavellian would insist that men & women aren't equally-valid, right?

This has, obviously, been remaining wrong, in the mainstream dialog, both left and right for decades.


Apparently no non-autistics thought of it in all this time??

The SCOTUS getting-this-wrong, too: how could so many people with so much domain-specific experience all blunder the meaning of "equality"?

Muddled-discussion is costing lives, and adding the constraint of integrity would help our discussions, it seems.

Salut, Namaste, & Kaizen.

( :


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Aug 30 '17

If we brought populations from all over the world together what would happen?

4 Upvotes

Lets say we take a random 1000 people from every different country in the entire world and put them on one island. That is 195 different countries and 195 000 different people. Each person that is taken will be an infant and will grow up in a segregated environment that consists of 194 other infants from from every different country. Let's say that they all grow up learning the same stuff. Each of these individuals has no predisposed opinions and views before the experiment begins.

And now where it gets cool! The island is some magical island that makes it so all the residents that live on the island are physically incapable of harming each other physically or mentally. Bad stuff can still happen, as in human mistakes or actions can still cause manifested distress, but whenever an individual in the group of 195 is distressed the group makes it their mission to help the person in need. Each group will stay together until the age 18 and then that is when the barriers will be lifted and the magic of the island disappears. This is not going to be a shock for everyone because throughout their life they were taught of their situation on the island and they were made aware of what will happen when they turn 18. They were taught principles of empathy, understanding and tolerance.

From this point on do you suppose that with time tensions will grow within the population? Directly after the lifting of barriers will there be peace or chaos? If we look back at each group of 1000 individuals from each country will there be the same number of bad people as good people when compared to other countries? Will everyone be good because everyone was raised in such a manner to foster good intentions? Would the ensuing society be perfect?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 08 '26

The One Soul

3 Upvotes

Imagine that there has only ever been one human soul.

Every person who has ever lived, every person alive today, and every person who will ever live is the same soul experiencing existence through a different body.

When you die, the soul doesn't necessarily move forward in time. Your next life could be 500 years in the past, 200 years in the future, or even another point in history that has already been experienced.

As an infant, you may still have access to memories from your previous life. But as your brain develops, those memories become inaccessible — a natural "reset." Perhaps the occasional person who claims to remember a past life simply retained fragments.

Now imagine that one day, someone remembers being a person who hasn't been born yet.

They remember a technology humanity will invent 200 years from now. They tell scientists about it. Humanity cannot simply copy it, because the physics and materials don't exist yet. Instead, the information helps scientists rearrange the pieces they already have, eventually leading humanity toward the technology.

Two hundred years later, that future person learns the technology.

The information has gone in a circle.

Nobody invented it first.

And when humanity eventually discovers time travel, they find that history cannot actually be changed. Every attempt to prevent a historical event somehow becomes part of the chain of events that causes it.

Then researchers reconstruct the lives of the soul.

They discover that the person who caused an event, the person who tried to prevent it, the person who remembered it, and the person who eventually studied it...

were all the same soul.

So perhaps history isn't a straight line.

Perhaps the soul moves through it in ways we cannot perceive.

And perhaps the question isn't:

"What happened first?"

but:

"What if there was never a first?"


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Sep 17 '26

Could heat death actually be a recurring process for the universe to seed itself and shed entropy for a cyclical universe?

3 Upvotes

One of the biggest killers in the cyclic universe hypothesis is entropy building up over time. To picture a way around this, imagine a glass of water poured onto a slightly tilted table so it forms a stream.

Think of that water as the universe, and the stream itself as dark matter holding the whole thing together. The tilt and gravity act like dark energy pushing the expansion forward. As the stream flows, it stretches thinner and thinner until a small droplet or piece finally snaps off from the main stream.

That smaller piece becomes the seed for a new Big Bang (a bounce). Since the total entropy is stretched across the entire length of the main stream, only a "Goldilocks" amount of entropy goes with that breaking-off droplet—just enough to trigger the next bounce, but low enough to keep it from getting stagnant.

I call this idea the Organic Sovereign Inception Model (OSIM). I would like to hear other hypothesis of how a cyclical universe may shed entropy and trigger the next bounce if anyone has a (outside the box) hypothesis for how the mechanics may work.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Aug 14 '26

A car drives down your street announcing the world ends in 15 minutes. The interesting question isn't whether you believe it.

3 Upvotes

The car cannot be calculated. That it hasn't reached you yet is not something I know An unmarked car with tinted windows rolls slowly down your street. A PA system on the roof announces that the world will end in exactly fifteen minutes. Then, before it turns the corner and is gone: This is the final message to humanity. God save Consciousness. You don't believe it, and you shouldn't. An unmarked car is the wrong channel for a message like that. Real notification of anything at that scale arrives through everything at once, and the fact that it's coming from a single source is itself evidence against it. Look outside. No sirens, no alarms, nobody running. Fifteen minutes out, the world would not look like this. Your credence is maybe a thousandth, and that's generous. So you go back inside. And then, because it costs you almost nothing to be wrong about this, you pick up your phone to call your mother. Nothing. No signal. Sit with what just happened, because this is where the experiment actually starts. Dead phones fit two hypotheses equally well. Either something is interfering with the signal, or the network has collapsed because a million people are calling their mothers at the same time, which is precisely what you would expect if the announcement were true. It's the first piece of evidence you've encountered that's consistent with the claim, and it arrives at the exact moment you can no longer act on it. Your credence moves. Not to certainty, but off the floor. And notice what moved it: not any fact about the world ending, but an artifact of your own situation that you cannot diagnose from where you're standing. You also just lost your corroboration. The reason you disbelieved was that nobody else seemed alarmed, and now you can't check whether anyone else's phone is going off, because yours isn't. Your entire evidence base has collapsed to what you can see from your own doorstep in the next fourteen minutes. Which leaves you with the words. They're all you have now, and you'll spend some of your remaining time turning them over, because there's nothing else to examine. God save Consciousness. That's a sign-off, not a warning. It's the shape of a state formula, the thing said at the end of a proclamation by someone with the standing to make one, and cranks don't usually close that way. But it also isn't save us, or save the world. Whoever wrote it thought the thing at stake was the fact of experience itself, not the people having it, and that's either a category of seriousness you've never encountered or a tell that you're dealing with someone whose framework has nothing to do with reality. You cannot tell which. That's the point. It's the only datum you were given about the announcer, and it points both directions at full strength. The cheap option is gone too. The call was going to cost you nothing, which is exactly why the decision was easy. Now the only expressive acts left have a body in them. Get in the car. Run. Find someone, physically, before the window closes. That's expensive and uncertain, and you will not do it at a thousandth. So credence, which had gone inert, is suddenly load-bearing again. You have to decide what you believe, using an evidence base that the announcement itself may have severed, and you cannot tell whether it did. This is Descartes' demon in miniature. You aren't deceived about the claim. You're deceived about the reliability of your only means of testing it, and the deception is invisible from the inside. Hawaii, 2018, is the closest thing to a live run: false missile alert, thirty-eight minutes, a million people. Many of them described doing exactly the right things while reporting afterward that they never quite believed it, that some part of them was watching themselves say goodbye and finding it unreal. The goodbyes happened anyway. But their phones worked, and that made a difference nobody has fully accounted for. Here's the part that took me a while to see. The car doesn't tell you anything you didn't already know. You were always going to die, and you never knew when. All it does is replace indefinite uncertainty with a number. And if the reason to make the call was that it's cheap rather than that the end is certain, then that reason was in force yesterday too. The deadline was never what unlocked it. Which is where this stops being hypothetical. You've been reading for four minutes. Somewhere in there you thought of a specific person. Not a general category of loved ones, an actual name, and probably a specific unsaid thing attached to it. That happened at a credence of zero, with no car, no window, and a phone in your hand that works perfectly. You didn't call. That isn't an accusation, and I'm not going to pretend the decision is closed. You can still call in ten minutes and you know it. But you just watched yourself defer in real time, with full information, under no pressure, at no cost, which is precisely the pattern the fifteen minutes was invented to interrupt. The experiment turns out to be its own control condition, and the result came back before you finished reading it. The honest complication is that "not today" isn't only weakness. Ordinary life supplies real reasons, and any argument that converts your entire practical situation into a moral failure is cheating. Sometimes deferral is correct. The trouble is that it's correct one day at a time, indefinitely, and nothing announces when the last day was. The experiment ends before resolution. Fifteen minutes, and you never find out whether the phones were jammed or the network was drowning, whether the car was a crank or a courier, whether that last line was a proclamation or a symptom. What you're left examining isn't whether you were right. It's what you did under a condition you couldn't diagnose. Your phone works. The car hasn't come. God save Consciousness.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jun 05 '26

UPDATE FROM THE OLD MENTAL EXPERIMENT!!!!

3 Upvotes

​Ayo guys, I wanted to share a thought experiment I’ve been developing. It’s a conceptual model that tries to bridge the gap between Quantum Mechanics (Planck scale) and Macroscopic Cosmology using a mix of thermodynamics and... a high school metaphor. Ok? ​Since Reddit doesn't natively support LaTeX, here is the core equation of the experiment, heavily inspired by the bounce dynamics found in Loop Quantum Cosmology (LQC): ​H² = (8 * pi * G / 3) * rho * (1 - (rho / rho_max)) ​The Variables: ​H² = The square of the Hubble parameter (The actual expansion/contraction rate of the universe). ​G = Newton's gravitational constant. ​rho = The actual energy density of Jonny Jonny's stress (the report card mass). ​rho_max = The absolute maximum density threshold (The Planck Density / the physical limit of his pocket). ​The Thought Experiment: "Jonny Jonny and the Quantum Zero" ​Imagine the Universe is not a cold void, but a stressed teenager named Jonny Jonny. Jonny Jonny has committed the ultimate quantum crime: he compressed a massive amount of energy into an impossibly small space (he got a "zero" on his report card and stuffed it into his pocket, which is exactly the Planck Volume). ​Let’s test the boundaries of this experiment using this proper loop density cutoff: ​Boundary 1: The Quantum Bounce (The Shockwave) At instant zero, Jonny Jonny is in the living room trying to squeeze that massive bad grade into an impossibly small space. The density of his stress (\rho) reaches the absolute maximum physical limit (\rho_{\text{max}}). In our equation, the fraction (rho / rho_max) becomes exactly 1. ​The Result: The term (1 - 1) becomes 0. The contraction rate (H^2) stops dead in its tracks. Because quantum geometry cannot be compressed any further, gravity flips and becomes a massive repulsive force. Jonny Jonny doesn't just stop; he ricochets violently into Cosmic Inflation, launching the Big Bang from the sheer quantum pressure of the vacuum. Matter is created purely out of the shockwave of this rebound. ​Boundary 2: The Big Freeze (The Redemption) Trillions of simulated years pass. Jonny Jonny has run so far that his universe expands toward infinity (the density \rho approaches zero as matter dilutes). Mathematically, (0 / rho_max) becomes 0. ​The Result: Jonny Jonny grew up, studied, and finally got an A (the universe dissolved completely into pure, balanced radiation). The equation returns exactly to standard Einsteinian General Relativity because (1 - 0) = 1. ​However, as the universe keeps expanding and loses all mass, it also loses its sense of scale. Without mass to define time or distance, a massive, infinitely cold universe becomes mathematically and geometrically identical to a microscopic point. The psychological pressure vanishes, resetting the cosmic balloon for the next cycle. ​I know the metaphor is funny, but structurally it mirrors some aspects of Roger Penrose’s Conformal Cyclic Cosmology (CCC), where the universe loses its sense of scale at the very end, triggering a new Big Bang via a quantum bounce mechanism. ​But there is a difference: Jonny Jonny maybe didn't have his A+, actually, his mother was Asian...