r/ThoughtExperiment • • 29d ago

I can survive black hole

1 Upvotes
I am special; as a black hole pulls me in, I will accelerate so much that I’ll pass right through it—causing it to explode—and emerge in an entirely different universe. Why haven’t scientists discovered this yet?

r/ThoughtExperiment • • Aug 08 '26

If you don’t buy something they’re paying you not to buy it

0 Upvotes

Weird but I just had this thought , for example if you want to buy a pizza but then decide not to that store has basically payed you to not eat there as you haven’t given them money


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 01 '26

Imagine for a moment that Trump was a radical leftist

9 Upvotes

This is a bit of a thought experiment aimed at those who are currently Trump supporters, but anyone can comment!

I know that this is going to be very hard but, imagine for a moment that Trump was a radical leftist. He still has the same personality--egotistical, narcissistic, brash, & power hungry but he strongly believes in everything that MAGA is vehemently against. He still uses the same strong arm tactics, but instead of using ICE to go after immigrants, he is using the ATF to go after right wing militias and neo nazi groups, non stop. All of a sudden, they are everywhere in your small town, harassing your neighbors at grocery stores because they look like they might be part of one of those groups. Now he is mandating that all cars must be electric by 2027 because he has large amounts of money invested in that industry. All schools must teach critical race theory, including private schools.

I could go further with this, but I think that this is a good place to start. The strong arm tactics are what really bother me because they go against every principle our country was founded on. We can't have checks and balances if every branch is corrupted or beaten into submission.

Why does it seem so easy to ignore the corruption and erosion of values in our society?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 05 '26

One plus one equals two; can God make it equal three?

0 Upvotes

As humans, it is completely impossible for us to comprehend or execute such a problem. This is because it directly contradicts the most basic rules of the logic of this universe in which we live, as well as the logic of our minds through which we understand this universe. But does this mean it is equally impossible for God?
First, logic as a creation, not a backdrop: Logic is not a backdrop that has existed since eternity, because this contradicts one of the fundamental tenets of monotheism—namely, that the only eternal entity is God. There can be no other eternal thing alongside God alone. Therefore, logic is one of God's creations. Just as God was capable of creating our human logic—the logic our minds comprehend and by which our universe operates—God is equally capable of creating another logic, by virtue of His unlimited power.
Second, the unstudied critique of this idea: We cannot use the very same tool—human logic—to criticize an idea asserting that human logic is not the only logic. Thus, most ideas and attempts aimed at criticizing the notion of another logic's existence—specifically, the idea of God's ability to do inherently impossible things—are flawed. They simply rely on logic itself, human logic, assuming that our human logic is the sole baseline and foundation upon which everything must be constructed. The idea that another baseline or foundation could exist is deemed impossible by them. Building upon such premises is what renders these criticisms fundamentally incorrect at their core.
Third, when we discuss logic and propose the example of 'one plus one equals three,' we are not talking about mere terms and labels; we are speaking about essence, existence, structure, and perception.
Fourth, this idea is not built on our own logic: Our human logic states that 'one plus one equals three' is impossible, with no room for debate. Therefore, when we entertain the possibility of another logic, we are effectively no longer relying on human logic in our thinking.
We are trapped inside this logic and cannot apply or comprehend any other logic, including mathematical logic, which branches from it. This is simply because our minds are constructed and programmed around this logic—it is what we require to exist in our universe, which is likewise built upon this exact logic that we, as humans, understand. If you were to ask someone: 'Is there another logic? And if so, what does another logic look like, or how would another mathematical logic operate?' it would be akin to asking a person sitting inside a room with opaque walls and locked doors: 'Is there another room outside? And if yes, what is inside that room?'
In our scenario, the walls represent the human mind, which blocks our comprehension of another logic just as those walls block the view of another room. The locked door represents our universe, which prevents us from applying any other logic just as that lock prevents the person from exiting the room. Ultimately, even this metaphor and analogy are built upon our human logic itself. In another logic, perhaps people can see through opaque walls and pass through locked doors. This is not a flaw in the analogy itself, because the analogy was crafted by a human who is also trapped inside this very same human logic.
As the creator of this idea, I do not claim to be absolute about this information, because I am human. However, I looked through the keyhole designated for the key in our previous analogy. Even if I couldn't see anything—because the key is inserted in the lock, blocking the view—I still gained a little insight. I haven't left the prison, but I realized that I am imprisoned.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 02 '25

Not a moderator, but ..

1 Upvotes

I see a lot of these posts are fictional and in no way relevant to real world scenarios. Thought experiment should be theoretical and hypothetical testing ideas and to be relevant to a otherwise not currently possible scenario instead of imaginative never possible dream. Just saying... Alan Watts did thought experimentation and that's the true way to follow it.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jul 14 '25

What would it be like to be a pillow?

1 Upvotes

r/ThoughtExperiment • • 7d ago

The Unobserved Light Hypothesis — Can Something Exist Without Being Perceived?

0 Upvotes

The Unobserved Light Hypothesis (ULH)

A thought experiment on the relationship between existence and human perception

Proposed by: [Absurd phycologist]

  1. Introduction

Human beings generally understand the world through observation. We see objects, hear sounds, feel physical sensations and use these experiences to understand our surroundings.

But an interesting question arises:

Does something need to be perceived in order to exist?

The Unobserved Light Hypothesis explores this question through a simple optical thought experiment. It examines the difference between physical existence and human perception, challenging the intuitive assumption that what cannot be observed is somehow absent.

2. The Experimental Setup

Imagine a completely dark room containing two perfectly smooth, parallel mirrors.

A narrow beam of ordinary visible light is introduced between the mirrors. The light repeatedly reflects from one mirror to the other.

An observer is positioned inside the room.

The beam travels through the room, but its trajectory never intersects the observer's eyes. Furthermore, assume that no scattered light reaches the observer.

Consequently, the observer cannot see the beam.

However, the light continues to exist and reflect between the mirrors.

3. The Central Observation

The experiment presents two simultaneous conditions:

- The light physically exists within the room.

- The observer cannot perceive its existence through vision.

Neither condition cancels out the other.

The light does not cease to exist simply because the observer cannot see it.

This illustrates a distinction between physical reality and perceived reality.

4. The Psychological Paradox

Consider someone entering this room without knowing about the mirrors or the light.

From their perspective, the room appears completely dark.

They have no visual evidence of the beam.

Yet the beam is physically present.

This creates an interesting psychological question:

How confidently can we describe our surroundings when our perception provides only incomplete information?

The observer's experience of the room is not necessarily an accurate representation of everything physically occurring inside it.

5. Philosophical Implications

The thought experiment explores three ideas:

A. Existence independent of observation

Something can exist regardless of whether an observer is aware of it.

B. Limitations of perception

Human senses provide information about reality, but they do not necessarily reveal all of it.

C. The distinction between absence and invisibility

Not observing something is different from establishing that it does not exist.

6. Scientific Foundation and Limitations

The optical principles involved are already established in physics.

Light travels along paths determined by optical conditions, and reflection follows established laws. A beam travelling through an ideal dark environment may remain invisible from the side if no light scatters into an observer's eyes.

This thought experiment does not propose a new form of electromagnetic radiation or a new law of optics.

Its originality lies in its framing as a demonstration of the psychological and philosophical difference between existence and observation.

7. Conclusion

The Unobserved Light Hypothesis does not attempt to prove that invisible phenomena must exist.

Instead, it asks us to reconsider the relationship between what exists and what we perceive.

A room can appear empty of light while a beam travels through it. The observer's inability to see the beam does not alter its physical existence.

Perhaps the most important lesson is this:

Not everything that exists must be observed, and not everything that remains unobserved is necessarily absent.

The boundary of perception is not necessarily the boundary of reality.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Sep 26 '26

Why "Looking into the Past" in Space is a Myth: The Late Party Theory 🌌🎈

13 Upvotes

Body:

People always say that because light takes time to travel, looking at distant stars means we are "looking into the past." But honestly, that's just a misleading way to describe what's actually happening.

The universe only exists in one single moment: The Present (Now).

Think of it like this: If a star 100 light-years away explodes right now, that event happened in its actual present. The past isn't a physical place or a movie tape floating in space that we can visit. There is no backup drive for the year 1990.

If you developed a ship that could travel faster than light and flew straight to that star to see the explosion up close:

You won’t land in the past, and you won’t land in the future. You will simply arrive at the star's actual present. But guess what? By the time you travel that massive distance, years would have passed, the star would have already changed, and you'd find nothing.

It’s literally like traveling to a party, only to arrive after it's already over because the commute took too long!

We aren't looking at "the past." We are looking at one shared present, but with a massive cosmic lag (ping). The only real past we can actually see and visit is the one saved as a photo inside your phone.

Change my mind.

💡


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jul 08 '25

Which would make more money

0 Upvotes

A medical breakthrough that lets people live forever but still physically at 100 years old, or a medical breakthrough that lets men be as naturally well endowed as they want


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Aug 15 '26

You get offered a hefty sum to be in front of the camera of a news program to talk about a topic of interest. You get the make-up and get dressed up properly. On live TV you note they gave you make-up so you looked like a clown! What would you do?

0 Upvotes

Now you understand why there were no mirrors in the make-up room.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 06 '26

What happens when the rich can literally pay the poor to feel their physical pain?

0 Upvotes

I've been developing a thought experiment on pain transfer:

Imagine a reality where neural pain signals can be transferred wirelessly between two people. You suffer an injury or illness, but instead of painkillers, you offload that physical sensation onto someone else in real time.

  1. Economic Underclass: People in extreme poverty renting their nervous systems to absorb the agony of the wealthy.

  2. Professional Sponges: A black-market workforce trained specifically to endure high trauma for money.

  3. The Psychological Rift: Experiencing excruciating pain while knowing your physical body is intact.

How do you think laws or society would regulate this? Would it become a legal commodity, or strictly an underground black market?

(Visual exploration of this dilemma:https://youtu.be/P8uCDSOUG-M)


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 31 '25

Infinity, Balance, and the Dynamics of Numbers: A Purely Conceptual Model

0 Upvotes

This is a mathematical visualization thought experiment. Imagine the universe as a kind of press machine — a simple, mechanical system in which numbers move, interact, and transform. The press machine is just a tool to simplify the idea; it does not represent infinity itself. It helps us visualize how numbers behave, while the true overarching process — infinity — contains and governs all numbers, no matter which ones appear or are “feared.”

People sometimes assign meaning or emotion to numbers based on superstition — for example, 13 is often considered unlucky, while 2 or 6 may feel troubling in certain contexts. Within this system, these superstitious associations are insignificant, because numbers themselves carry no intrinsic authority. Whether it’s 2, 6, or 13, infinity always has the final say in how the system unfolds.

For example, in this system:

1 represents the origin point — where everything begins.

2 might indicate a split or branching pathway.

3 mediates or balances two pathways.

5 adjusts flow or motion, correcting imbalances.

6 can represent a stress point — a place where the system requires reflection or adjustment.

Infinity is the overarching process — vast, continuous, and boundless — within which all numbers exist and interact. At any number, including commonly feared ones like 13, infinity observes, absorbs, and guides the outcome.

Think of it like a mechanical simulation: when “trouble” occurs at any number, the system responds — smaller numbers like 5 or 3 adjust local flows — but infinity always governs the entire process, ensuring balance and continuity. Nothing magical happens; these are just the rules of the system at work.

Even repeated patterns, clusters, or coincidences of numbers carry no inherent meaning — they are simply part of the system’s dynamics. The mind may perceive patterns and attach emotional weight, but within this framework, numbers are neutral, and infinity is the ultimate authority.

Ultimately, this is a way to conceptually visualize processes, balance, and iteration, not a guide to superstition. Every step, imbalance, or “error” in the system is just part of the rhythm of the press machine — a tool to understand dynamics — while infinity represents the overarching, boundless process that observes and governs all numbers, rendering any superstitious fear irrelevant.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 13 '26

Interesting thought experiment

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ThoughtExperiment • • Nov 27 '23

Paladin's Puppet Theory (Idk if this fits here)

0 Upvotes

I'd like to make a Roko's Basilisk-esk theory, and I would like to name it after myself by calling it Paladin's Puppet Theory.

Now, let's assume that I am going to put a puppet show for you. Let's say it's about a dog and a rat talking about the weather. So I have my stage, and I'm behind the stage with my hands up, and I have some sock puppets on my hands. Maybe I get a brown sock and put ears on it with a black nose and some googly eyes for the dog, and for the rat I might get some round ears with some whiskers, a pink nose and some googly eyes. And I have these puppets talk about the weather. Now no matter what, your brain, through contextual clues from the script and the puppets' designs, will interpretate a dog and a rat talking about the weather. And that is what you see. If my skills in puppeteering increase, I can make the dog and rat look more realistic, and the dialogue might be more like how a dog and rat would talk, given that they could. And it would look more and more like a dog and rat talking about the weather. But even if I had a trained dog and a trained rat and professional voice actors that discuss the weather, you would know that it's not real. This is because a dog and a cat cannot actually talk about the weather, let alone intelligently communicate, let alone the dog not wanting to eat the rat. But despite this surreal and absurd scenario not being real, you would still see it as such. Your mind would automatically interpretate it as whatever it is posing to be because that is how your brain works. It takes shapes and objects and attempts to recognize them and relate them to something you can comprehend. This is why apophenia (the tendency to perceive patterns) and pareidolia (the tendency to perceive faces) are part of normal human experience.

Now, let's look at an unfortunately vulgar issue, and that is the topic of loli. Please note, the following is an argument against it, as I think it is deplorable and disgusting in every regard. If we apply the Paladin's Puppet Theory, we can see that the excuse of it just being a drawing or animation is not effective, and one can still internally perceive it and its concepts all too realistically. If it is just a drawing or animations and one can detach themselves from all implications or tendencies of that, then why are offensive animations a concept? Besides, anyone who believes that such content is in any way acceptable should be given a whack upside their head.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Nov 03 '23

If you had a dudget of 100.000.000 Dollars and had to eliminate humanity (or at least come as close as possible) how would you proceed.(Alternative with diffrent budget)

0 Upvotes

r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 29 '23

A Diarist is guilty of a Crime

0 Upvotes

Everything in the Diarist's life has been recorded in his journal. One day, he finds himself in a pickle - he's murdered someone in a crime of passion. Is the requirement of his eliminating evidence compelling enough to corrupt his moral dedication to his craft? He can transgress the laws that humans are all bound by, but can he transgress the laws by which he binds himself?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 19 '25

H.A.T.E.

0 Upvotes

I hate. … I love. … I don’t. … But I do. … Why do we? … I don’t get it. … It doesn’t makes sense…

Ņ.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Sep 21 '25

100 Men vs. 10000 Gorillas

0 Upvotes

Thought experiment: You and 99 other people receive one million euros. You have two years to buy whatever you want with the money. When the two years are up or you have spent your million, you will be taken to the mansion of the rich guy who organized the event. There you can chat with the other participants. You have to stay in the mansion for at least two days, after which you can leave. When all the participants are there, you will be taken to a jungle. Everything you have bought will be set up there. The jungle is 50 by 50 kilometers in size. Your task is to find and kill 10,000 gorillas scattered throughout the jungle. When all the gorillas are dead, everyone gets 10 million. You can leave the area at any time, but then you won't get any money. You cant Spend the Money on changing the jungle or on services from other people and you can't invest into stocks or bring the money to the bank.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jun 29 '25

Clone fight

0 Upvotes

If I were to clone someone. Put the both of them inside a clean room where the environment is perfectly homogeneous, where both are placed and seemingly have the exact same angle in the room. In short, the environment is exactly the same for the both of them.

And then I ask them to fight. How would that fight turn out ? I said they would cancel their attack and eventually KO each other, a friend of mine argued one would come on top, but why would they if they are exactly the same in the same environment experiencing the same things ?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Jan 25 '26

Letter For My Father

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ThoughtExperiment • • Nov 03 '25

Character AI

0 Upvotes

🇬🇧🇺🇸 Hi, I want to create a space to share experiences and opinions about Charecter AI and other softwares/apps with fictional charrcter generated by AI. These apps are often used by people to "socialise" with charecters and create fake connections and project friendships and romantic relationships, and it may not sound harmful at first, but there are awful cases involving teens (for example) that got into this deep hole. I'm doing a cinematic project about AI that involves Charecter AI, and I want to know real people's thoughts and stories to make my project as realistic as possible. Please help a artist out! 🫶

🇵🇹 Alô, quero ter um espaço de partilha de experiências e opiniões sobre Charecter AI e outros softwares/aplicações com personagens ficcionais generados por IA. Estas aplicações costumam ser usadas para "socializar" com personagens e criar relações falsas (platónicas e românticas). Isto pode parecer cagativo, mas já existem casos com desfechos tristes envolvendo adolescentes que se envolveram com estes personagens. Estou a desenvolver um projecto cinematográfico sobre a IA que envolve a Charecter AI, e queria saber as opiniões e histórias vindas de pessoas reais para que o projecto fique o mais realista possível. Por favor, ajudem a artista!🫶


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 04 '26

Shower thought

0 Upvotes

What if in an endless or infinite system The beginning is the end itself.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • May 16 '26

why can't we use ai to delete money and just route what everyone wants? a thought experiment... hear me out

14 Upvotes

i’ve been thinking about how completely broken our society is. at our baseline, almost everything we do is just glorified survival. animals hunt for food, we work 9 to 5 to pay a mortgage. the only unique thing humans have ever actually created is the arts, sciences, and pure creativity. but we waste our lives just grinding to survive.

what if we deleted money from our zeitgeist completely and let an ai handle the logistics? here is my blueprint:

say we make land completely equal among everyone on earth to start on a level playing field. then, everyone lists 3 options of what they can give (skills, items, labor) and 3 things they want to receive. with ai’s rapid processing speed, it could calculate a massive route of direct barters across 8 billion people. if i want a laptop, i build a table, it goes to person b, their item goes to person c, and i get my laptop. no money needed.

to stop it from being a dystopian machine that forces you into a job, the ai looks at your dna, interests, and talents, and gives you your top 10 results in alternative areas, along with your percentage of success based on what the world needs right now. you have total freedom of choice. if you want to take a gamble on a 12% success rate to be a musician, you can.

plus, all education is 100% free and open to everyone. if you want a path but your success rate is low because you lack a skill, you just download the free training modules to build yourself up and boost your percentage.

if the ai automates the "glorified survival" part, humans can finally focus entirely on utilizing their interests and creating things.

i know humans are greedy and prideful, but that actually makes the system self-correct. if someone offers minor but wants major (like offering 2 rotten potatoes for a tesla), they won't get anything. eventually their own greed forces them to offer things of actual value until they build themselves up.

but i see a few flaws:

  1. if the ai tells you you only have a 1% success rate at something, it might stop people from taking the risks that lead to actual genius or art.

  2. if survival is guaranteed, the people working 12 hours a day on medical research might get resentful of people who just want to lie on their land and look at clouds.

  3. humans favor friends, so what stops people from trading favors off the grid and accidentally reinventing money?

obviously it will never come to be, which is depressing, but mathematically, couldn't a predictive resource network like this work? i want to know all its potential flaws and how humans would actually respond to it.


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Oct 13 '25

I need as MANY people to respond to this as possible, please and thank you!

0 Upvotes

If you were given access to an infinite space, and this infinite space is contained somewhere. It has nothing in it ,not even nothing, call it "absolute-nothing". it is s programmable space and there are no limits as to what can happen inside of it. If you were given the sole goal to program as little things into this infinite space starting from nothing to simulate all of existence perfectly what would you program and why?


r/ThoughtExperiment • • Apr 13 '25

Just a Question.

0 Upvotes

Why do God created only Man and Woman in this World?