r/Thief • u/JEhcmier • 1h ago
Policy Changes AI, creativity, and the community
A Word from the Keepers: AI, creativity, and the community
Or: Thou shalt not bring unexamined Mechanist contraptions through the City gates.
Taffers,
Our community has always been home to artists, writers, musicians, programmers, modders, and other creative people who have kept the series alive, and we want that to continue.
Artificial intelligence has introduced new creative possibilities, but also legitimate concerns about artists' livelihoods, consent, authenticity, and security. We have members who reject generative AI entirely, members who enthusiastically embrace it, and plenty who fall somewhere between.
Everyone is welcome here. Not every use of AI, however, is welcome as a submission.
These guidelines aren’t intended to settle the larger AI debate. Rather, they’re meant to establish what we will and will not permit in the subreddit.
The human comes first
We value human imagination, craftsmanship, and the creative contributions that have sustained this fandom.
AI is a tool. It’s not an artist that’s owed an audience, and it’s not a substitute for the talented taffers whose work has helped shape this community.
Using AI privately is your business. Whether something belongs in our community is ours. To that end, our purpose is to amplify human creativity, not provide a distribution platform for automated output.
AI-Generated art is not permitted
AI-generated or altered illustrations, concept art, textures, music, videos, and similar creative material may not be submitted as original fan content.
This restriction reflects legitimate concerns about consent, specifically the use of artists' work in training datasets, imitation of recognizable artistic styles, displacement of commissioned projects, and the promotion of generated work at the expense of human creators.
We recognize that not every AI model, dataset, or application operates identically, and we are not declaring every use of the technology equally harmful.
That said, the moderation team cannot investigate the origins, consent, or licensing behind every generated submission.
For this community, human-created fan content takes priority.
Digital editing, drawing tablets, and other forms of computer-assisted craftsmanship are not automatically prohibited. The distinction is between tools that assist a creator and systems that generate substantial creative content on the creator's behalf. When in doubt, ask the moderators before posting.
AI-assisted software and games require vetted distribution
This is our most immediate security concern.
AI-assisted coding, often called vibe-coding, has made it possible for people with limited programming experience to create new VR enhancements, mods, textures, utilities, and even entire games.
Experimentation can be rewarding, but it can also introduce serious security vulnerabilities. Generated code can contain dangerous operations, insecure dependencies, credential exposure, compromised packages, or other issues its creator may not recognize.
Until we have a reliable means of independent review, r/Thief will not allow the distribution of software containing substantially AI-generated code that has not been vetted.
This includes:
Direct download links, executables, installers, and archives
GitHub or other repository links meant to distribute prohibited content
Links to download pages, mirrors, or other indirect acquisition methods
Requests for members to install, execute, or test unvetted builds.
A creator's personal assurance, an AI-generated security report, or an anti-virus scan are not sufficient independent verification. This isn’t an accusation against creators. It’s an acknowledgment that even well-intentioned people can unknowingly distribute dangerous software.
No independent security review, no distribution through our community. We will provide additional updates on the vetting process as we develop it.
Discussion is not distribution
To be clear, we’re not banning discussions of AI, programming, or experimentation. Members are free to discuss AI-assisted workflows, ask questions, debate technical approaches, and describe personal experiments provided those discussions are relevant to Thief and otherwise follow our community rules.
However, discussions can’t become veiled advertisements or directions for obtaining software prohibited under these guidelines.
Screenshots may be allowed at moderator discretion when their purpose is genuine technical discussion rather than promotion.
The line is simple:
Discuss the technology if it contributes something worthwhile, but don’t invite the City to adopt it.
Transparency, attribution, and respect for creators
Don’t misrepresent AI-generated material as wholly human-created.
Don’t falsely claim another person's artwork, code, writing, voice, or other creative contribution as your own.
Credit human contributors and disclose generative-AI involvement when it’s relevant to a permitted discussion. However, a disclosure does not automatically make otherwise prohibited content acceptable.
We also ask members to respect creators who have objected to their work being replicated or imitated through AI.
Disagreement is welcome; harassment isn’t
We know this subject inspires strong opinions.
You’re free to criticize AI technologies, business practices, training methods, environmental costs, or security risks. Conversely, you’re free to defend AI's potential as a creative and technical tool.
What you may not do is harass, insult, threaten, or personally attack other members over their views on AI.
We’ll never require members to endorse AI, and we won’t ask them to condemn it. Debate the technology and its consequences but leave personal hostility out of it.
No Loopholes, no commercial end-runs
Prohibited content does not become permissible because it is free, labeled experimental, hosted elsewhere, offered for donations, or accompanied by a disclaimer.
This includes advertisements, promotions, referrals, donation solicitations, and attempts to steer members toward prohibited AI-generated content or unvetted software.
Enforcement and appeals
Moderators may remove submissions or comments that violate these guidelines, request clarification about how content was created, or restrict accounts that repeatedly or deliberately circumvent these policies.
First-time mistakes may receive an explanation and an opportunity to correct the submission, but deliberate deception, harassment, or attempts to bypass moderation may warrant stronger action.
Members may contact us through Modmail to request clarification or appeal a decision. These guidelines will be revisited as technology changes and as reliable, practical ways of assessing software security become available.
A final word
The Thief community has survived because the fans care enough to create, restore, document, and share their work and we want to protect that tradition.
We’re not here to police your imagination, your private projects, or your opinions. We are here to maintain a community where human creativity can flourish without exposing its members to unnecessary risk.
The tools belong in the workshop. The responsibility belongs to the person using them.
— The r/Thief Moderation Team