r/Thief • • Apr 02 '26

Thief 2014 is an underrated masterpiece of a game, I'm surprised it didn't get more love! (No Spoilers Please)

2 Upvotes

As a person who's played and seen the original games, I understand that everyone has opinions. But this is one of those creations that i really don't understand the hate for it, I've seen bad games especially nowadays with the amount of slop being made daily. So recently i actually wasn't thinking of playing this game, i actually got dishonored first and lets just say i really didn't like it. The plot is generic, the gameplay isn't my favorite, and i just don't like the cartoony graphics and the world i guess its cool... but it just isn't for me.

Anyway when i finally was able to play thief, I was actually surprised on how intense and dark and cinematic it was. Especially during certain moments, i love the gameplay, graphics, and plot. Sure the whole entire thing with the magical church or whatever made no sense but i loved the atmosphere, the world building, and the way the combat and things were made. I also loved the voice acting, sure it was pretty corny at times but i really liked how they made it sometimes especially with Garret's.

Now i do understand some of the hate, Thief was never a game like elder scrolls for example with tons of lore and such. But i feel like they should have added more stuff for example, maybe more weapons or areas to explore. Because with the original games, their was always some kind of exploration despite it being a game about levels. I also understand how many fans didn't like the modernization, but at least compared to dishonered. I really liked this game and it was really fun and unique, I've heard theirs a VR game called Legacy of Shadows. But i haven't played that one yet, also I'm a huge fan of Square Enix (Especially their Final Fantasy games) so that also may be why i love the game so much.

But what do you think, do you think I'm over exaggerating the game too much or am i right in some way?


r/Thief • • Jan 09 '25

Replaying Thief 4...

3 Upvotes

...forget being the worst in the series. It's one of the worst games I've ever played and I remember when TDP came out. That even includes board games and sports. Everything about it is just bad, except for maybe that it doesn't have many bugs.

I thought I'd revisit it to see if some nugget of unique vision was overlooked, but it very evidently looks like the entire development was one of utter torture.


r/Thief • • Aug 01 '26

I'm still waiting for Thief 5 or... THI5F

3 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Feb 23 '23

Ay, is Garrett gay?

0 Upvotes

Don't take this too seriously just a funny vibe I got from him ever since I was shown his personality, I weirdly always thought he was bi or a bit fruity at least.


r/Thief • • Feb 28 '14

Let me get immersed, damn you!

1 Upvotes

All I want to do is get immersed in the atmosphere and sneak around but every 10 seconds something wrenches control away from me or some cheesy cutscene starts. Even picking up loot wrenches control away from you as a redundant and stupid animation takes place before you can move on again. Then there are the QTEs. WHY?!?!?! I'm supposed to be a master thief but now I'm reduced to spazzing out at my fucking keyboard like an epileptic seal on an electric beach just to open a god damned window.

Sometimes I think games companies are deliberately trolling people who know what games used to be like. Back before games were trying so fucking hard to be movies and shoving any stereotypical shit that console gamers are used to into every fucking game instead of just making an interactive story that you get immersed in and feel a part of. I want to BE the story, not fucking witness it in loads of z-grade cutscenes that only a fucking moron whose sole experience of culture is Transformers the movie would be impressed by.

This game is literally Hackers but without the fucking rollerblades. It's a prime example of what is wrong with modern gaming.


r/Thief • • Jul 12 '24

I am a bit afraid of playing Thief 2 after finishing Thief Gold

4 Upvotes

I finished 4 missions of the second game, I have reached Ambush! But I can't bring myself to play it even though lots of people love both games. I've watched videos and read people's rating the missions and it often goes like this... This mission sucks, this one is okay... this one was a pain, this is a REALLY good mission! This one was meh... this mission might be one of my favorite from the series! Oh... this one I HATE IT with passion, just... skip it"

It's either very good or very bad, and most of the time the mission aren't that good, and even a chore to do, so why should I even bring myself to play if there's maybe 3 or 4 good missions and the rest is just... alright? If I think of games like Return to Castle Wolfenstein or Star Wars Jedi Knight Dark Forces II, there's rarely any levels that I hate, some are a bit annoying like the stealth missions, but overall I like pretty much all the levels, but for thief, it's something else. Does that make sense?

Thief Gold comes with three extra missions, they weren't that great but I guess playable, even the Thief's guild if you learn the map. The only missions that I remember being fun was Lord Bafford's Manor, Break from Cragscleft Prison, Down in the Bonehoard, Assassins after you're done stalking the two guys, then The Sword. That's 5 missions that were fun, and 10 missions that were just okay...

Honestly I don't see myself ever finishing the second game, unless I'd be bored of my mind and I got nothing else to do or ran out of games to play.


r/Thief • • Nov 29 '25

The Cradle is not THAT scary

2 Upvotes

Hi Idk how to start this but...Robbing the Cradle is not the most scary Video Game Level ever. Everyone praises it as the pinnacle of scary Missions in Thief, hell even Video Games in general. But i dont see why

So finished my first play through the Cradle yesterday and i was a bit underwhelmed. Sure, it was a bit scary because of the theme and the enemies...but at some point in the mission i figured out the Enemy AI, so it became relatively easy to just run past them. Also i just blasted some of them with explosive Mines. I really dont think this mission deserves all the glory it gets. The Objectives were pretty linear for a Thief game, get Item A here, put it at place B etc. Also the "small" Level Areas in Thief 3 makes everything feel less at stake somehow

I can think of instances that were far more scary than the Cradle like Hammer Haunts in Thief1-2 or FMs like Into the Odd or those Fucking Stone Sculptures in that Mage Tower FM

What do you especially like in "Robbing the Cradle" and what makes it the best Mission?


r/Thief • • Nov 26 '25

Thief 4 is a good stealth game

12 Upvotes

I've played through entire Thief franchise this year and started playing Thief 4 recently. Just finished chapter 2 and I'd say that it's not nearly as bad as I expected. Story while feeling very different from the trilogy is decent. Gameplay reminds me a bit of Dishonored which I've grown to really enjoy over past decade. And here's probably a wildtake: I'd say that I prefer 4 over 3. So just wanted to know why do people usually dislike Thief reboot?


r/Thief • • Oct 08 '26

Thief (2014) thief 4 hate is overplayed

0 Upvotes

i completley get why its hated though, its a massive departure and is the obligatory DmC treatment thief got out of some other games in that era, but it was a ver sloppy production and pushed out the door, im sure it wouldve been great had it been given just more time. i hope it starts becoming more liked like max payne 3 is being liked currently after being shat on for a decade. and honestly its a pretty solid game, with its glaring flaws but its not unplayable or an abomination against the franchise


r/Thief • • May 13 '24

Why so much thief 4 hate?

6 Upvotes

Granted I hadn't played 1-3. But I didn't really have a good pc when they were popular. Looking back at videos and screenshots, they look a little rough to revisit.

I've played 4 and it was fun, running and vaulting over rooftops and window sills felt smooth and responsive, the story was interesting, it looked pretty good as I remember. Ultimately I enjoyed it.


r/Thief • • Apr 15 '25

Does the 2014 game really need a separate wiki from the original trilogy?

0 Upvotes

I know it's a highly divisive title, but it seems so unnecessary to keep it seperate from the first three games. It's still canon.


r/Thief • • Jul 08 '25

Why blackjack?

1 Upvotes

Why is Garrett's baseball bat called blackjack?


r/Thief • • Sep 09 '25

Despite the reviews and the tedious atmosphere, I think this game is still good enough for a remaster?

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Aug 04 '24

First playthrough of Thief Gold, my mission rankings

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Feb 24 '14

Thief review from AusGamers. 5/10

Thumbnail
ausgamers.com
0 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Sep 19 '26

Canon or not?

0 Upvotes

I’m jealous of Basso’s sister because she actually got to sleep with my thief hahaha😂

I know there are several interpretations, and none of them are 100% confirmed. Even so, just thinking that it might have been part of the story makes me ridiculously jealous lol

At the same time, I understand that Garrett, as a fictional man, would naturally have a sex life or maybe some encounters. I mean, all protagonists have one, right? After all, the characters are based on human archetypes

But I want to hear your theories, please hahaha. What do you guys think? 👀 I’m reading all your thoughts!


r/Thief • • Oct 10 '26

THIEF REMASTERED - NEW GAMEPLAY Analysis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Apr 05 '24

Are the old thief games worth playing?

5 Upvotes

I feel like this is the wrong place to ask cuz obviously everyone is biased, but i got the thief game (2014) on sale from steam today. But i'm reading random posts here and everyone says u should start from 1 to understand the story, and everyone says that the latest thief doesn't feel like thief to them??? But i have 203 games on my wishlist, i really don't have time for mediocre games, are the 3 ancient thief games worth playing? Considering their graphics prob suck ass and all the mechanics are outdated most likely compared to modern games, like are they worth playing for the average gamer or only if you're huge fan of the series?


r/Thief • • Oct 09 '26

Question If Garrett operated in modern-day Europe, what would his loadout look like? (for a comic-noir short story series)

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m writing a series of dark, comic-noir audio stories about a professional modern-day thief named Vance—a character heavily inspired by Garrett’s clinical pragmatism and shadow-dwelling tradecraft, mixed with the real-world methods of elite cat burglars like Blane David Nordahl (the Silver Cat Burglar).

​The stories are built on authentic lockpicking rather than Hollywood clichés like picking a high security lock with hair pins. The first episode is set in Vienna, Austria.

​Instead of a mechanical blackjack and water arrows, what kind of modern gadgets, specialized tools, and EDC arsenal would a present-day Garrett use to slip through a high-end European estate without leaving a trace?

​Curious what gear real Thief series enthusiasts or fans of the genre think a modern master thief would keep in his tactical bag.

​(If anyone is interested in the feel of the audiobook/comic-noir adaptation of these stories, you can find 'em on YouTube as "Thief Archives: Ghost without name")

https://youtu.be/POcx84NWNeQ?is=U6iMva8rAFsg3ZCU


r/Thief • • Aug 28 '25

The Black Parade is fun, but are all the missions just remakes of missions from the first two games?

4 Upvotes

The first mission feels pretty distinct, but since then...

The second mission is good, but it is just The Sword again. Starts as a standard mansion heist then there's a creepy magical pagan bit at the top. It's neat but completely predictable, as soon as I saw the map I thought it was going to do the same thing as The Sword, and it did.

The third mission feels a lot like Eavesdropping from Thief 2. With some elements from Undercover from TDP, and the Hammerite church from Deadly Shadows, and the many older fan missions that take place in Hammerite buildings. Again, not a bad mission, but didn't really do anything to surprise me.

The fourth mission is just Down in the Bonehoard again. And, hey, it's a good mission to recreate--I'm not a big fan of the more supernatural side of the Thief games, but Bonehoard is I think where that was done best, so i don't mind doing it again. But it did mostly feel like I could have played Bonehoard again and got a similar experience.

And I've only just started the fifth mission, but it seems like it's very similar to The Haunted Cathedral.

Is the rest of the game like this? Again, it's not that any of these are bad missions, I just feel like it's an odd choice to make a big new campaign only to have it consist of repeats of old missions. Is the second half of the game more unique?


r/Thief • • Sep 28 '24

I think kingdom come deliverance might be the modern day thief. Plus you get an open world and a deeper immersive sim / RPG experience. Anyone else loving this game and getting that thief itch scratched?

0 Upvotes

r/Thief • • Aug 20 '20

Imagine a Game in Thief Universe But We Aren't Playing As Garrett And the Whole Game Is About Slaying Beasts

3 Upvotes

I'm deadly serious, what if someone in Square Enix just thought of this idea? Like, sure, the series itself is over and they don't have people that can make stealth at the moment, but there are folks on board that know how to do slasher RPGs.

I got this from a headcanon of sorts. I saw this giant Burrick head in ||Little Big World|| and wondered, if it was real or a gigantic replica. Considering the fact that Constantine is ||Trickster|| and the whole mission revolves around obtaining a magical sword, it's a real possibility that the head is real and Constantine beheaded that beast with the said sword. It raises a question, though, if Burricks get so big. And this is where my headcanon comes into play.

Maybe, possibly, I don't insist, it's just a speculation, but maybe Burricks are descended of Wyverns. Like, they are lizards, and lizards grow almost throughout their entire life (I know it's much more complicated than that, but, come on, it's almost D&D stuff). So if a Burrick gets big enough and old enough, magic happens and it turns into a Wyvern. Bizarre, isn't it?

Now, imagine a game is partially based on this supposed myth, that once upon a time Trickster defeated a giant Wyvern and now its body lays in great woods outside of the City and to this day spreads poison and illness. Of course, such an ugly site upsets Builder's eyes, so we, let's say a Hammerite knight, are tasked to get rid of it. And nobody could do that before, because the woods are filled with tree nymphs, rat beasts and whatnot, and we are an absolute elite among all Hammerites. And so you come to the location, where thre corpse of the Wyvern should lie, and as soon as you start to get around it, it comes back to life. Boss fight

I'm terribly sorry for rushing it all on you, I don't usually do that. But, seriously, how would you welcome or unwelcome a game in Thief universe, that isn't based on stealth?


r/Thief • • 29d ago

Discussion A roadmap for decompiling thief

2 Upvotes

NewDark, openDarkEngine and the upcoming Nightdive remaster are all great, but for the sake of true preservation it'd be really good to have a full decompile of thief, similar to other games of its era. This would allow for a Linux port and is something I've been looking into, though I do not have anything to release yet. Perhaps more importantly, I think it'd be good to put out a general roadmap of what this process would could look like.

First, the various leaks of existing (but partial) source code are a great help, especially the Thief 2 one. It's fairly easy to find that with some googling and using the TTLG forums. There is a debug build of dromed (DBGDROM) in there as well as an external pdb with many symbols. In addition theres a release build of dromed with internal symbols.

You may choose to decompile either the OldDark or NewDark builds of Thief. As neither of those exes contain symbols or debug info, the next step is to identity and name as many functions as possible. Various version tracking tools can be useful to transfer symbols from DBGDROM, for example Ghidra and bindiff. This might be a bit easier with OldDark as it uses the same VC6 compiler as the dromed builds, but NewDark (VS2008) is also possible.

A compiler toolchain for the leaked source code can be setup and projects like decomp-toolkit and objdiff can be used to compare the source code against the binary and to iterate on it as required. From there its mostly a case of iterating until you have a matching decompilation.

Needless to say that you could do all of this by hand and that none of it requires the use of a LLM/AI at all, though it would likely provide a significant speedup.

Using an existing leak like this is probably a grayer zone than regular decompilation, though I think its unlikely that it'd be much of an issue for anyone. You could choose to simply use DBGDROM as a base and ignore the rest, or not even that and invent function names from scratch.


r/Thief • • Jun 03 '24

Really underwhelmed by Thief 2

12 Upvotes

I'm a massive fan of the og Thief, and so I decided to try out Thief 2, since everyone claims it's a refinement of the mechanics, with a better focus on stealth. I'm in the middle of the warehouse mission and so far it's been a massive letdown compared to my experiences with the Dark Project. Firstly, the game just feels different to play. Garrett is way less responsive - jumping is slower and I feel like there's a lot less control when moving. I've found myself moving too far forward and falling off ledges when I only pressed the movement keys a little. So maybe you're supposed to take it slower, hence the increased view of stealth? I would think so, but the level design also seems to have taken a fall off. In the original Thief, most rooms would have at least something useful to pick up - maybe water arrows in a basin or even just some small loot like a golden goblet. Instead, many rooms in Thief 2 have literally nothing in them. There seems to be more of a focus on secret hunting, and I don't know who at Looking Glass decided it made more sense to hide mission-critical loot behind obtuse levers and hidden panels, but I really want to know what the idea was.

The emergent gameplay Thief is praised for has also taken a hit. In most missions of the original game, you had all these options to change the way a mission played. Use water arrows to create shadows and hide, lay down moss and leap between soft surfaces. Don't want to find a key? Just lockpick the door. Instead, Thief 2 feels like it's on rails. So far I've picked up almost zero unique arrow types, and there's barely been a chance to use water arrows since there are fewer torches and more electric lighting. Rooms seem to switch between "so dark I can't find the loot" and "no shadows to hide in at all" far too frequently. Not to mention most doors can't be lockpicked, or so it seems. At the point I've reached in Shipping... and Receiving, I'm going up and down this maze of corridors, unlocking the shipping areas one at a time and inevitably finding them to be full of useless junk. Kilgor's hammer-making workshop had NOTHING valuable in it - it had some arrows, but no loot at all. Not even some sort of ornamental gold hammer loot. Going up and down between the offices and around the stockyards doesn't feel like robbing a warehouse, I feel like I'm working at a warehouse!

The first mission was also bad for this. Inevitably I knocked out all the guards and then found myself going back and forth trying to find 200 in gems. It's one of the only Thief levels where I've had to look up one of those Keeper's Chapel loot guides - another notable one was The Haunted Cathedral, to give you an idea of how long I spent looking for a tiny switch to open a compartment with a gem in it, instead of just picking up a ring or something. I also led Basso and his partner outside before completing the loot requirement; this made the game glitch and the Objective Complete chime sounded on repeat whenever I stood next to Basso.

I also think the game looks a lot worse. The textures seem washed-out and muddier compared to Thief 1, which makes sense if the Mechanists are polluting the City with smog, but I have to look at it while I'm playing. Water looks incredibly bad compared to the first game, notably. The lighting system has also taken a hit. In Thief 1, it was usually very clear where was a shadow to hide in - they were dark and dramatic, and very obvious too. In Thief 2, everything seems the same shade of half-dark, so I can barely tell what I can use as cover. The light looks even worse than the darkness - for reference, I haven't installed any kind of bloom patch, and the well-lit areas have this awful sickly light-radius around them. Also, despite everything looking like it's the turn of the century, the guards look even more medieval than they did in Thief 1. You have these goons guarding a Victorian-era warehouse and they're dressed like Templar Knights.

On the topic of enemies, I also think their AI is a lot worse than Thief 1. Guards have a habit of not noticing you even when your light gem is at middle brightness and you're standing in blackjack range. Equally, they can somehow notice the player when given no stimuli whatsoever - you don't even get a "I hear you there!" line, they just turn around and start swinging.

To compare this to the first two missions of Thief 1, Bafford's mansion has an open layout with lots of ways to get to the scepter, and every room has at least something of interest. The stealth system, guard patrols, etc is all conveyed very well in my opinion. Cragscleft is also good, with a layout that has multiple routes to completion, and level design that can work whether you knock out every Hammerite or avoid them. Your new mechanics (moss arrows, holy water, electronically sealed doors) are explained well and used in unique ways. I hate to say it but Thief 2 feels like a bad fan mission, like some forum taffer has replaced all the textures with their own and doesn't really understand level design and what made the first game great. And I know that Thief 2 only gets worse, with its filler missions and bad finale, so I really don't feel like it's worth completing.

(I am using T2fix by the way, for what it's worth. Don't know if it's different with some other patcher.)