r/TheoryOfReddit • u/Fluid-Routine-8838 • 6h ago
Update on hidden profiles: hidden is AUTOMATICALLY TURNED ON BY DEFAULT - major implications on userbase trust and forum nature of Reddit.
I posted here earlier about my theory that Reddit has implemented hiding profiles as a way to hide LLMs/bots. Many of you said this isn't the case, I personally do not buy that.
Today I thought about it and realized I should check if my account is hidden. I did not know this....but to my shock and horror.....it WAS hidden. I use old reddit and I know for a fact that many new features do not reflect on old reddit, so I knew to switch visibility and check if this was on by deault, and it was. Yikes!
So hiding seems to be on by default on new profiles, unless this is specific to NSFW or 18+ accounts. Either way, it was turned on for me without my knowledge or taking that action.
I think this has major implications for trust and identity within the userbase. Beyond the major red flags with AI bot associations, the entire fundamental point of having usernames and profiles IS visibility. This is a core change in the nature of users relation to Reddit.
The entire forum nature of Reddit is hollowed out if people do not develop identity through user post history visibility. New users will not know to check this feature, and people will not be out here memorizing usernames in local subreddits.
Obviously, I do understand this is the way Reddit is going, as just a feed and 1:1 engagement, not actually developing communities. But communities were the core userbase that kept Reddit afloat behind the scenes all these years. So if Reddit is actively moving away from the community forum element, if all of the content is just tweets and tiktoks and links to well know websites, I strongly believe this will be an isolating and alienating force away from engagement to Reddit as a platform, unless it is trying to market itself as anonymous, which doesn't make sense because it's both wanting you to register with an email (as opposed to older throwaways) and not actually using the post history feature. That doesn't really help either userbase camp (people who want identity with the pseudonym or people who want anonymity).
This is a tangent off of the first post and since I shared my thoughts on that, I figured I would broaden the theory discussion in light of my discovery with this, and also share that this feature is turned on for awareness.


