r/TheoryOfReddit • • Aug 11 '12

The Shitlord Cycle: How reddit's site design and assholes are teaming up to make redditors bigots

0 Upvotes

This is a response to the other ToR post that blamed SRS and children for the current state of reddit.


Reddit, by design, is going to destroy itself. This has to do with several factors, some with the design of the site itself and others with general human behavior. In the end, reddit is going to create a cultural hegemony of unoriginality and awful users because negative behavior is being reinforced and rewarded.

The defining feature of Reddit is the karma system. Upvotes and downvotes are basically "like" and "don't like" buttons. Users upvote posts and comments they agree with, and downvote things with which they disagree. Posts and comments that the community likes will float to the top while those it dislikes will be automatically removed after being downvoted enough.

Officially reddit has a policy that voting should be different for Posts than it is for comments, but in practice it is not followed. Users use the same mentality of upvote means "like" and downvote is "dislike".

Karma is a mini reward system and is similar to achievements in video games. Both are meaningless in terms of actual gain, but people pursue them because of the tangential rewards. This is otherwise known as Gamification. An upvote on a post is like a little gold star from another person because it means another person "liked" your submission.

It's healthy to seek out attention and approval from others, and upvoting combines both into a form that requires the least amount of social interaction possible. And it feels good to get an upvote.

Problems arise when people get addicted to that feeling, even slightly. Gamification often creates users that will shortcut their way to getting the reward as quickly as possible. On reddit, these users aren't good submitters, but really good at collecting internet points.

One problem is unoriginal content.

From reddit's about page on voting it says:

"As a general rule, vote up what you liked (and want to see more of) and vote down what you disliked (and don't want to see similar things in the future)"

Written into the about page is why new content is not favored. Old, already seen content is prefered over new innovating or challenging submissions.

Adding to this problem is what is called the "Fluff Principle". New or difficult concepts take time to process. They might get upvotes, but not at the same pace as short, easy to digest, regurgitated bullshit. Fluff gets upvoted rapidly, and in depth comments don't get voted on at all, and due to Reddit's voting algorithm, it effectively hides them.

Users notice these trends, and will submit similar or the same exact content just to get points and attention. This applies both to submissions and comments.

Amplifying this effect of unoriginality is downvotes. If a downvote means "dislike", then it means another real person disliked your content. Most people will actively avoid disapproval. If their content is downvoted actively enough, most people will change how they post to gain approval.

But some users won't. And that's all that was needed to lead reddit into a spiral of shittiness.

People who hold white supremacist, misogynistic, homophobic, and generally terrible beliefs are less deterred by downvotes. They care less about other people or what they think, and they'll continue posting their shitty opinions with or without approval from others.

When a woman or minority comes across a comment or submission by these hateful assholes, there are three possible outcomes:

  1. You leave the site entirely. This is the easiest option, and given the demographics of the site it's also the one most chosen. Women and minorities have other shit to do than listen to people tell them how horrible they are, so fuck it. They'll find a place that doesn't have content that directly attacks them.

  2. You stay, and due to downvotes or hostile feedback, change how you post. Or you merely tolerate/ignore it by not saying anything.  

  3. You stay, trying to argue against the hate when you see it, but due to the general lack of caring by bigots about other people, your efforts will most likely go to waste. This eventually leads to burnout, and you leave reddit.

Hateful comments and submissions actively drive away those that they're aimed at from the site completely, making the population of reddit just a tiny fraction more hateful due to the bigots staying.

Non-minority men have the luxury of being able to ignore the comments because the hate is rarely, if ever, aimed at their demographic. Mostly these men fall into category 2, and is the reason why they dominate the site. Some will also fall into category 3.

Eventually the bigot to non-bigot ratio is so high that terrible comments actually start receiving upvotes, instead of being hidden. This attracts more assholes who like their content, making it more visible, so more women and minorities can be driven away.

Users that are addicted to karma will see that terrible comments mean internet points, so they will repeat it for approval.

Users who want to fit in will either accept what's being written as true and begin to repeat it as well, or stay silent for fear of downvotes.

Reddit then turns into a shithole that reposts terrible unorginal garbage over and over.

The only way to combat this is through active moderation; however, this is prevented by reddit’s mythos of being a free speech website and it's inadequate moderation tools. Any type of moderation is bemoaned and pitchforked, making moderators less enthusiastic about putting in any effort to use their limited and hard-to-use tools. So reddit is doomed.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Nov 08 '15

When did anyone ever get the idea that Reddit was liberal?

0 Upvotes

Why is "liberal" or "left-wing" or whatever an adjective that gets thrown in when someone talks about this website?

In what universe did anyone ever get the idea that Reddit is liberal?

One glance at the front page on any given day and it's pretty easy to see how it's an upper-middle class white-boys club. Subtle and obvious racism, sexism, etc. make it to the front page with thousands of upvotes on a DAILY basis.

Under the guise of "humor" or, "it's just a joke bro", is the most sexist and racist shit I've seen on any website that I regularly read.

EDIT:

I've gotta say, before this thread I had never heard the term "brogressive", but now from everything I've read that it is defined as, I completely agree.

Reddit is "liberal" on anything that effects "me, myself, and I". Weed, guns, taxes, student debt, etc. etc. threads are all voted to the top on a daily basis... and right below it will be a disparaging joke about rape, race, transgendered people, or feminism. Yeah, jokes are jokes, but they come from a very real place, and whether people want to admit it or not, they can and do normalize offensive acts and behavior.

To the person below saying this is all anecdotal evidence of a vocal minority, I don't think it's that absurd to say you can make a fairly broad generalization about the beliefs of a majority of people on a website with millions of viewers based on the thousands of people that participate by upvoting or downvoting, or commenting in threads.

Also, maybe "liberal" was too politically-charged of a word to use in the title. Politics comes in to it definitely, but I more meant to comment on social issues, but feared (correctly) that I would be pegged a "SJW".


r/TheoryOfReddit • • May 19 '17

Why does everyone complain about t_d saturation when the anti trump subreddits have a much larger dominance on /r/all?

0 Upvotes

To be clear, I'm not a fan of Trump at all. However, I always see everyone complain about the_donald, when it seems the anti-trump users are much more pervasive and have multiple subreddits which all dominate /r/all. For example, this is what /r/all looks like now. It's the same exact article, with basically the same title.

To me, that is much more obnoxious. What are your thoughts?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Dec 18 '23

Unpopular opinion: Reddit is more far-right than far left

0 Upvotes

With the US election coming up next year, I've been noticing a noticable trend that Reddit is veering to the far right and amplifying the most extremist voices. Often there are some consequences for the hate-subreddits but too often it's too little too late & only done as a sort of damage control so that advertiser's aren't fightened off. So unless it affect's the bottom line then nobody steps in. This in and of itself raises questions about the platform's ability to effectively combat and contain the spread of far-right extremist and other hate community's.

To be fair there is a proliferation of far-left aka "Tankie" subreddits probably due to the influence of the evil, racist, genocidal CCP. So at either end the extreme voices are being amplified probably through outside influence campane's to try and divide the American electorate. But out side of this contrary to popular belief that Reddit's core political supporters lean left the right wing is more operative in the Redditsphere due to there connections with foreign troll farms. Also it should be noted that there is a worrying alliance between the far right and the far left in that they both see Western-style "politically correct liberalism" as a common enemy but this perhaps is a story for another day.

On a personal level my posts criticizing trump or ruzzia have routinely been removed from prominent subreddit's without explanation or with a snarky and false explanation. This signals at least an effort on the part of rogue mod's to delete trump-critical information from the public eye.

So the next time people tell you "reddit is "far-right" you should scrutinize why they are telling you this. They are trying to pull the wool over you're eyes and distract from real bigger problem's at hand in order for you to be outraged at nothing.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • May 24 '13

reddiquette Hate groups on Reddit and the problem of 'leakage.'

0 Upvotes

Ever since users first were able to register their own subs, the presence of racists, misogynists, fascists and other hate groups attempting to use reddit for their own social organization was an inevitability. A decision was (apparently) made that, in the name of free speech, these groups would be allowed to continue, and anyone who didn't like the content could simply not subscribe to those subs. The issue then becomes, if people with those beliefs are being invited in to form their own communities, how much do they interact with the rest of reddit, and what consequences does that have for other subs and other users?

Today, r/niggers has 7000+ subscribers, r/whiterights has 2000+, r/mensrights (designated as a "hate-hub" by the Southern Poverty Law Center, America's foremost experts on monitoring hate groups) is one of the largest political subs with over 70,000 (!) subscribers, and r/theredpill (a newer, even more radical and misogynistic offshoot of mensrights) has 6 and a half thousand. Compared to total reddit users or the millions that subscribe to the largest default subs, these numbers might seem like small potatoes, and any cross-subscriptions those attracted to the site for these ideologies have with other boards would be negligible. However, I do not believe that all 'leak' is incidental. These ideologies have grown and festered on the internet in recent years, and it has been partially due to active policies of and tactics for recruiting new believers over sites such as reddit.

I think the first question that needs to be addressed on this issue is whether or not this is a problem. Personally, I strongly believe it is. Smaller subs can be permanently poisoned by an invasion of hate group subscribers, and propaganda they spread in the larger subs can take those most vulnerable to it down a dark, terrible path that harms themselves and the world. However, as the only solutions are rather drastic in the context of what reddit has been willing to do as a site so far, whether or not 'free speech' is more important than these issues is an issue for the community to decide, not myself. If it is decided that these subs are a problem that needs to be addressed, what solutions are available to us? If entire subs should be banned (as happened to r/creepshots and r/jailbait), which ones qualify and which ones are worth at least attempting to save? Is there a possibility for moderators from outside the community to improve content and ban individual users to a point where the subs are no longer truly hate groups, or are they all beyond repair? If subs are banned, will their users abandon reddit, or flood into new communities, and will this aggravate the problem?

I don't claim to have the answers to all these questions. But we need to at least be discussing this issue. Tolerating these groups is a moral decision and statement we are making just as much as banning them would be, and it is important for use to be critically examining it before we continue to make it.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Nov 17 '16

Alt-right subs. Should they be allowed?

24 Upvotes

Twitter has now taken a stand against alt-right content. Should Reddit?

Censorship? So what? This is a privately owned and operated site and the owners are under no obligation to host hate speech. There is a huge difference between offensive material, such as racist jokes one can find at subs like /r/ImGoingToHellForThis and providing a platform for fascism.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Feb 24 '24

Reddit will be the next major social platform to die

0 Upvotes

We all know how how Reddit has been on the verge of death many times these past couple years. Now it's really showing considering the amount of users this website has compared ot Facebook, twitter, Instagram, etc. Even Quora is starting to become more active and considered better than reddit.

Reddit will 100% be the next major platform to die. I can't believe quora and snapchat will outlive reddit.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Dec 25 '18

When did reactionaries co-opt r/unpopularopinion?

8 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/unpopularopinion/

This is something that I've only noticed a few weeks ago when someone on a discord I'm in started linking some of that sub's most upvoted posts that day, and I've been checking it pretty regularly and you can always second guess what they're going to upvote to the frontpage, this is a new account that I created but I've been on reddit for almost 5 years and I definitely recall a time when this sub wasn't filled with these types of reactionaries with some rather thinly veiled racism/sexism/transphobia content.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Apr 19 '24

You’re on Reddit, but you hate Reddit. Why?

0 Upvotes

Why?

Do you remember when you first “found” Reddit?

I first found Reddit in 2008. Scumbag Steve memes were the thing.

And where have we come?

We’ve come to the point where, I don’t know if this post will be approved.

We’ve come to the point where, I’m scared to share my opinion.

We’ve come to the point where… we’re prisoners.

Yes. We’re prisoners.

I hate Reddit. No…I… DESPISE Reddit.

When I think of the average Redditor, I want to punch them in the face.

But… who is the average Redditor?

When I got to thinking about this question, I had an EPIPHANY.

Yes, an epiphany.

Because the average Redditor is not who you think.

The average Redditor is site:reddit.com.

They might know what site:reddit.com means, and you might not either, but that’s who they really are. Because the fact is…

The average Redditor isn’t on Reddit. They’re on Google.

They’re looking for answers…and the only place to find them is the prison of Reddit.

We’ve been imprisoned. “Oh, the small hobby groups are OK.” Yes, the prisoners are allowed to walk around outside once in a while. That’s you. You’re a prisoner.

Why?

Because you open Reddit every day, even though you hate it.

Don’t deny it.

But that’s the thing…

The average Redditor hates Reddit. So why doesn’t it change?

It follows the principles of power structures. You THINK it’s a democratic system of upvotes. Well, maybe you think that. But maybe you already know the truth. Reddit is not just a prison. Reddit is mind control. Reddit is CIA’s accidental MKUltra.

You think you’re immune? Sorry. You’re reading this post right now. Welcome to the show. You’re the guest star. And we’re all going to cater to your every whim. After all, you’ re a celebrity? But what show, exactly, are you starring in?

The show of your own mind rotting into oblivion.

~~~

0Big0Brother0Remix0 


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Nov 23 '23

Why is Reddit so left wing?

59 Upvotes

Saying anything about Trump or Republicans are good would get you downvoted to hell and banned form a subreddit you said that on, Saying you support Israel would get you compared to Hitler and called a Nazi. And don’t get me started on Reddit during Covid 19, free speech did not exist.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Jan 14 '20

Sexism in subreddits

0 Upvotes

What can be done to combat sexist mods? I am dealing with some mods from r/sex that are claiming misandry is a form of sexism and gender oppression that I am guilty of (even though I never once claimed I hated men, I criticized some men for reacting defensively, immaturely and obtusely to a women sharing the truth about our life experiences) .

in making their argument, they are essentially saying that if and when someone says they hate men (which I did not even do), the results are just as serious and wrong as misogyny - apparently this leads to men facing violence and discrimination from women at all levels of society - sexual violence, domestic violence, being paid less, being politically underrepresented, being expected to rear children and preform unpaid work - they are claiming that when someone expresses hatred of men, suddenly men are oppressed by it - and this is why it must be stopped - except of course we know none of this is true.

these guys are punishing women from being vocal about the oppression we face in our sexual culture. they are allowing men to belittle and doubt us when we express our personal experiences with gender inequality in sex, and then when we defend ourselves and express frustration, we are punished for it, silenced, and accused of hating men. then we are excluded from online public culture and forums where values and standards around sexual culture, as well as having the freedom to tell the truth, are created - meaning these guys are looking to systemically exclude women who look at the larger picture of men's overall behaviour towards us in sexual culture.

they want to exclude women who connect dots between our own lives and the lives of other women, because they think this makes men looks bad and encourages hatred of men.

this is classic sexist modding.

what can be done about this?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Aug 08 '21

Reddit is seemingly full of degree collectors

0 Upvotes

Many people on this website will ask you if you have a degree and tell you to go to college/university to get jobs, as well as entry-level ones. Also, you will get yourself downvoted to hell for saying that you don't have a degree. I feel like those people act like earning piece of paper will give you "freedom." Like r/jobs and r/personalfinance, for example.

People in-person will tell you not to go to college because it's expensive and you need to climb up the ladder. Lots of people I've met in-person also do not have a degree (both the cinema and retail store). Even people thought about having a degree doesn't earn anyone freedom and we all have freedom in the USA.

Huge difference between reality and Reddit.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Dec 26 '17

Reddit is Suffering from Mean-World Syndrome. The site serves millions of users that can post what they want all at once, fueling a climate of paranoia in the name of viewership.

25 Upvotes

Because of the increasing number of reddit users, it is getting harder to upvote moderate content, and extremes are growing ever more popular.

One of the most famous hated subs was the incels subreddit. Despite only having 40,000 subscribers, compared to the 20 million members of reddit, it received far more negative attention than was warranted. It is not clear how many people were truly threats out of this relatively small population, especially when the views on women still had significant variation. Other possible threats in the world received much less attention. Some only joined because they thought ForeverAlone was too passive and counterproductive (even though Incels wasn't much better).

Personally, I would see multiple posts about it on askreddit, the frontpage, and many other communities on a daily basis.

The other, more prominent example is the Donald Trump presidency. About 50% of posts on the frontpage are against him. While Trump is one of the worst presidents, it is unclear how big of a threat he actually is, and how useful filling the frontpage with posts against him is in stopping him.

Of course, there are many subs focused on attacking a group of people, and the upvoted posts on those subs are getting more extreme by the day.

If Trump were to suddenly resign, and after reddit celebrated, what would be their most hated topic?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Feb 13 '18

Hypothesis: Redditors will often side with marginalized and stereotyped groups of people, perceiving them to be unfairly treated, even if there is evidence to support these groups and individuals are behaving according to the perceived stereotype.

26 Upvotes

I have found that posts of people that are part of marginalized subcultures are seemingly viewed as underdogs to many on Reddit, and will be fervently defended, even when it does not make sense in the context of a post showing these people doing and saying things that are disreputable.

Edit: When I say subcultures I do not mean races. I mean ideas of Punks, Skaters, Metal heads, Rappers, and essentially any other culture that has had negative connotations associated with their perceived lifestyles. My experience is that it is seen as unfair and untrue that these subcultures behave in negative ways, that they have been inaccurately represented by our media and in fact they are healthy, constructive environments for kids to be brought up around.

For example, today on the front page there is a post about a mother who took her daughter to a skate park and was initially deterred when she arrived and found the park filled with nothing but teenage boys who were smoking and swearing. She was surprised when one of them took an hour out to show her daughter how to skate properly. The thread quickly filled up with people stating how skaters like to help people and the community is really inclusive. However I grew up around many skaters and bikers in the New England area. I went to the skate park a lot as a teenager and found the experience to be, ultimately, nonconstructive and lacking a healthy environment, personally. I pointed this out to someone who commented on the post stating the mother was an asshole for presuming and stereotyping the skaters. From my perspective however, this was the exactly the kind of stereotype I witness on a daily basis. Many of the people at my local skate parks did very little with their lives and committed too much time to skating and biking. I pointed out in the post that the mother was correct in being worried as when she arrived to a park where she wanted her daughter to experience a healthy activity they encountered an unhealthy environment: smoking, being physically unhealthy, and swearing being unsportsmanlike. I was quickly attacked by people saying I was wrong and that skaters mainly want to help and are a supportive community that embraces people... but it all depends on your own experience and in my experience I saw more negativity in my life with this community and wanted to be objective in my analysis of what information the post itself contained.

Skaters in this instance became the marginalized subculture that was unfairly being stereotyped. Upon me pointing out that these people were in fact embodying certain stereotypes and that this person was, in my opinion, an aberration I was attacked by people who were offended at my comment.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Apr 30 '14

What exactly is wrong with ELI5?

22 Upvotes

/r/explainlikeimfive is in a kind of horrible limbo. Although its mods don't censor dissenting opinions, and thankfully are not Neo-Nazis, when compared to a subreddit like /r/AskHistorians the moderation just seems... lazy. Sources are not expected for answers, sarcastic shit comments often go to the top, many responses show an obvious bias, and petty fighting between commentors is common. The mods seem oddly obsessed with asking that you search first, even though on a sub like /r/askhistorians or /r/askscience duplicate questions are a non-issue. An active mod team usually allows people to answer, but simply posts a link to the last time the question has been asked.

Recently, I asked "Why do many exams have a page that is intentionally left blank?" Although it fit the form and style of most other questions on the subreddit, it was deleted by a Moderator who said it didn't fit the nature of the sub. When I asked him to elaborate, he said he was "too busy".

Has ELI5 always been like this? What steps could be taken to improve the sub?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • May 03 '18

Where did the "old internet" go to? Did it just grow up? Is it on a site I don't know about?

10 Upvotes

By old internet, I wil speak broadly so as to not devolve this into a debate over whats new/old. I will simply say that there seemed to be a turning point where, very quickly, the internet started becoming less and less "soulless" and less and less a place where the only overarching principle was refutation of all that was normal and mainstream.

Now, for some reason, we have to make the Internet less "problematic" and less "toxic." Which is really fucking retarded. There was a distinct band of internet (4chan/SomethingAwful) that thrived on the novel and crazy. I don't think something like ChrisChan would have started in this era of the internet.

I also feel like there's no way these people actually grew up and totally left the internet. I just feel they're somewhere different or have dug themselves deeper underground to really let themselves fly with their opinion with no fear of backlash.

Maybe I sound completely crazy, but hopefully you guys understand what I'm talking about. Where did this go to?! Is it gone forever?

edit: the source of policing "problematic" stuff is usually twitter and instagram and facebook. Not saying reddit does that much.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Feb 10 '16

Is the Sanders circlejerk is reducing the popularity of reddit outside the USA?

0 Upvotes

Not saying that Americans are necessarily happy with it either, but to me a non-American it is both asinine and irrelevant.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Sep 03 '23

Why is r/Russia quarantined and why every sub that tries to be pro-Russian gets removed?

0 Upvotes

While r/Ukraine is functional despite their aggressive and often psychotic rhetoric and comments towards Russian people. Why is there is so strong bias for one side over the other?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Jul 27 '15

Do harm-inciting subreddits make a wiser, stronger internet society?

17 Upvotes

The question I want to present is: did the presence of the harm-inciting subreddits /r/rapingwomen and /r/gasthekikes make for an overall wiser, stronger, more robust internet society? [1]

A while ago I said /r/rapingwomen was a breath of fresh air, and if I had known /r/gasthekikes was going to be banned as well, I would have protested the plans of /u/spez to ban the evil masterminds planning genocide there.

b-b-but they're inciting harm! We must stamp out evil!

What do you think is better: people doing evil in secret or people doing evil in public?

People here seem to think that if speech is suppressed, then things won't go horribly wrong in society. It's completely mixed up. It's deluded. What you want in a civil society is people who understand all sides of history from different angles. People who have the capacity to step outside their native world-view for a moment. People who understand the language of evil.

One of those angles is seeing history through the eyes of evil people. How are you going to do that? By interacting with and having conversations with evil people.

You want to understand what it is about people that makes them hate each other. And you want to let the scientists of hatred ask questions. You want to give them access to data, the thoughts, feelings, and behavior of those who hate.

This idea of the ideal society as a perfectly regulated democratic system (there are many examples, but Zardoz comes to mind) of well-behaved individuals is just plain nuts. People aren't well-behaved, and trying to fit them into a rigid system that fails if it can't control the behavior of individuals is doomed.

The Reddit admins in general and /u/spez in particular should be delighted that people use the platform to express racial hatred and advocate sexual violence. The fact that people seem to think this will lead to negative IRL outcomes speaks to the complete unwillingness of the society we live in to take the inner lives of individuals seriously and take action accordingly. People are crazy, they're deranged, they're dangerous. This is naturally how they are, and they resist external control. This incuriosity can lead to disastrous consequences.

Maybe if we don't know how people think, and don't ask questions, then we can pretend our world is neat and clean and well-ordered and everything will be fine.

This is skating on thin ice. The impulse to ban harm-inciting subreddits reflects incuriosity, the fear that life might entail things we don't like, things we don't want. It reflects the desire that Reddit should be a lovely thing, something beautiful that reflects only the good, positive qualities of being human. We want Reddit to tell us that we are the best of all. We want the fact that we are Redditors to be something we are proud of. What pride is there in being a Redditor? What pride is there in being alive? We go on Reddit and we reflect in words the way we are in life. Taking pride means we get caught up in ego games of our own devising, which will lead to grief when the truth finally comes out. These are not my ideas.

Reddit Reddit on the Internet

Reddit tells us who we truly are, and of course we are largely powerless to change who we are. We cling to this idea that we are powerful, but clearly the queen in Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is powerless to change her own physical appearance.

Ursula K Le Guin said it much better than I could ever hope to, but she had an entire book: A Wizard of Earthsea.

Part of maturity is accepting your dark side. By rejecting its own dark side, Reddit persists in immaturity. And the society we live in is weaker and more vulnerable as a result.

[1] By "internet society" I mean: the English-speaking, internet-connected, Reddit-browsing world and those who interact with this world, which is a large chunk of modern civilization.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Mar 16 '24

Reddit downvotes are keeping readers in the dark about the most important facts: A concrete example from r/Politics

12 Upvotes

Over the past few months I've had a lot of success posting on r/Politics. It's no secret that r/Politics is very liberal and very anti-Trump. Thus, it probably comes as no surprise that these were some of my best-performing posts:

"Judge starts countdown clock in Donald Trump's E. Jean Carroll case – Trump must pay the full $83.3 million he owes Carroll or post a bond." - 21,000 net upvotes https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1an07jq/judge_starts_countdown_clock_in_donald_trumps_e/

"Biden just delivered a State of the Union unlike anything we've seen before" - 18,000 net upvotes https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1ba3wpt/biden_just_delivered_a_state_of_the_union_unlike/

"Trump Might Be Convicted in D.C. Just Days Before the Election" - 16,900 net upvotes https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1amwn3r/trump_might_be_convicted_in_dc_just_days_before/

In general, my posts to r/Politics almost always generate hundreds or thousands of upvotes.

However, this changed dramatically when I posted what was arguably my most important post: A New York Times article on the fact that a significant portion of the funding for MAGA and Trumpism is coming from wealthy Democratic donors and even the Democratic party itself, because they believe MAGA candidates are easier to beat in elections, even if MAGA endangers democracy:

"Democrats Meddle in Ohio G.O.P. Senate Primary, Pushing Trump’s Choice – A Democratic group is spending nearly $900,000 on a television ad promoting Bernie Moreno, who was endorsed by Donald Trump, just ahead of next week’s Republican primary." - 0 net upvotes https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1beacsr/democrats_meddle_in_ohio_gop_senate_primary/

Now, I can completely understand the psychology of why someone might dislike this revelation from the New York Times. For those of us who believe Trump really does threaten democracy, the fact that a significant amount of the funding for Trumpism is coming from Democrats can cause a bit of sadness and anger, as it did for me when I first read it.

It's also an absolutely vital fact for Democrats to understand, and a crucial eye-opener about our particular historical and political period. And the exposé comes from the New York Times, a left-leaning publication and arguably one of the most credible publications in the world.

But because this fact from the New York Times caused many readers psychological distress, as all the most important facts do—and because 99.9% of Reddit downvotes are actually given to posts that users dislike, rather than to posts that are off-topic as Reddit's TOS says is technically intended—this crucial revelation from the New York Times was downvoted very heavily, so 99% of readers were kept in the dark about this very important disclosure from the New York Times.

Not to mention that given this is a crucial political exposé from one of the world's most credible publications, every single one of these hundreds of downvotes was technically an abuse of the downvote button, per Reddit's TOS.

This is a serious problem, and while I really like Reddit and feel it often has a lot of good stuff, it can't be taken seriously as a source of information when readers are kept in the dark about the most important facts simply because people don't want to hear them, and thus downvote them.

I believe a very simple way to address this issue, without in any way removing the benefits of having a downvote option, would be to include a simple prompt when someone goes to downvote something saying:

"Please note: You are about to downvote a post/comment. Downvotes should only be given for posts/comments that are off-topic or which otherwise violates Reddit's TOS. Extreme and excessive downvoting can even result in action being taken on your account. Are you sure you want to downvote this post/comment?"

This simple prompt would in no way impact the use of the downvote button for posts that are off-topic as Reddit's TOS says is intended, while helping to inform the majority of Reddit users as to what the downvote button is actually for and preventing abuse of the downvote button, allowing for the most important facts and information to reach readers.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Nov 21 '23

Reddit Admins Objectively Aid Misinformation

2 Upvotes

Misinfo is incredibly damaging. For more than a decade, reddit has been one of the most damaging social media platforms with regard to the propagation of misinfo.

Since Oct 7th, reddit admin staff have allowed mods from subs like r/palestine carte blanche with regard to targeting actions against members who correct blatantly doctored, or misrepresented media.

Here's the latest instance. A doctored video of Israeli children singing about genocide. Look how much hate it generated in the comments. Simply posting the original lyrics was enough to qualify for instant permaban, and appealing that decision was enough to qualify for a sitewide ban.

Why do reddit users have to walk on eggshells just to point out falsehoods in posts meant to incite hate? Even 4chan moderation is leaps and bounds better than the crooked leadership of today's reddit.

e: Adding the message that I sent them. Thought I didn't have access to it, but there you go. Utterly vicious.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Feb 06 '15

The reddit experience as a whole has been slowly declining since the beginning of its creation, and the ever increasing amount of community members isn't helping.

22 Upvotes

Here's why:

  • Since reddit was founded on June 23, 2005; I believe that over time, is has slowly been declining in quality.

  • A high influx of users has caused all the default subreddits to be bogged down with new, clueless users, as well as; trolls, mock accounts, novelty accounts, and others of that sort. These are problematic because it causes clutter, and chaos. While legit new users should be held back from commenting and posting for, let's say, one week. That will give them more time get to understand reddit, and how it functions. I also think that those new users should be asked(suggested, not forced) to watch a quick video demonstrating the aspects of reddit as a whole.

    • I say all of that to say this: There are so many people on here who create a new account on a whim, and use those accounts to fudge numbers -ie. Upvoting their own content, upvoting their own comments, etc. etc..

  • A lot of the problem is caused by the community itself. Most users seem to lack tact, and can be somewhat rude to new/confused redditors, thus causing them to be reluctant to share their true thoughts, and just 'go with the flow'. I can count numerous times where I have stated an honest opinion, and had users butter me up like a roll, and devour me, before I could even finish my side of the story. Reddit should be a safe Haven for members all across the world to feel welcome, and not to feel worried whether or not they will gain precious, yet meaningless, karma.


How can this be addressed and fixed on a mod/community level?

  • Granted, it would take a reddit-wide community effort, to change the on-goings of which are aforementioned. However, I believe that it can be done!

  • First off, there is a grey area throughout reddit. Certain communities strive on the harassment, trolling, mocking, etc., however, I am not talking about those subreddits during this post. I am only referring to the default/most popular subreddits.

  • Drastic measures are always looked upon as something that is a last resort. I don't see that to be the case. I think that if we, as a community, all stood together to eliminate the allowance of such trolls, mock accounts, novelty accounts, etc., we could finally move past all that nonsense that has seemed to take over reddit.

  • Everyday that we stand by and do nothing, is another day that is wasted. I think this is a legit concern for /r/TheoryOfReddit, and I have spent a lot of time debating whether of not to post my concerns here. However, I feel that this is the best community to help address this matter, and help me/us/reddit come up with bigger and better solutions! I have eliminated some of the text to cut down on some of the read time, but feel free to add anything to this down below in the comments.


Thanks for reading, and I look forward to hearing some of your comments/suggestions/solutions to better improve the quality of a community that we all hold so dear, www.reddit.com: -The Front Page of the Internet.


r/TheoryOfReddit • • May 06 '12

Why do so many people choose to start the title of their posts with "So..." when it is not needed grammatically?

0 Upvotes

You've seen them: "So Reddit..."; "So, this happened to me today..."; etc.

I notice this mainly in posts that are trying to be funny and I can only assume people think it makes them sound more humorous. In real life, you rarely hear people prefacing a funny statement with "so" when it is not needed grammatically. Why has it become common on reddit?


r/TheoryOfReddit • • Jun 19 '26

After years of using reddit this is what i found/understood

0 Upvotes

SOOOOO Ive been using reddit for the last 4 years in multiple accounts, with each having an entirely different main page/feed idk what to call it and this is what i found about reddit and its people

First of all i found that reddit isn’t like the other social media. The other social media doesn’t reaaally have main audiance, it basically has every type of people there in the same amount while reddit isn’t like that. Reddit has main group that uses it

\-Reddit is used mainly by introverts

Want a proof? Look at the introvert vs extrovert sub, the introvert sub has more than 10x the amount of weekly visitors. Or Even normally, did you notice than on most posts there’s a lot of people that dont really have a social life ?

\-Another thing, this will sound harsh but… a surprising amount of redditors are actually very negative in all the ways

In every social media i use i found reddit to be the most negative. About everything

On EVERY post there’s going to be people complaining and being negative. Look at all the posts complaining about something. Or Even normal posts there are a lot of redditors being assholes for nothing

Even on the most happy post there’s going to have people being negative and talk shit

People are very pessimist here

\-a good amount of redditors think they are they smarter or better than everyone

No seriously, did you realize that a huge amount of redditors think they are better than everyone ?

They love laughing about someone and acting like they are stupid and they are smarter than them. And dont Forget that redditors are always like “oh how can’t this person know this? Everyone know this. Hes a stupid fuck” why do so many people act superior if they know something the other doesn’t?

Redditors LOVE putting others down, they love making others misérable because they are “superior” like oh this Guy doesn’t know how to that (specific) thing on a computer, lets make him misérable because of that

\-redditors are in the minority

Idk what to put here since this basically says everything. But every take that i see on reddit and things that seem like everyone agree on is actually the minority. Everyone in real Life has a different opinion that majority here. Want an exemple? Ai, most redditors hate ai while in real life basically everyone uses it and like it

\- a bunch of people here are weird

No seriously. Idk how many times i found the weirdest accounts ever. And here you will see the weirdest subs ever. There’s fucking subs about people shitting themselves brother

\-most redditors dont really have a social life

I dont have proof about that but its more of a feeling i have based on everything ive seen.

Exemple, on dating subs you Will see people giving the worst advices EVER, really, NEVER listen to them. Most people there dont have a social life so they hate everything and make a big deal out of small things. And they will tell everyone to break up over the tiniest thing. Idk how many of them survive on their relationship

I for exemple tried searching about people that talk a lot but i basically didn’t found posts about that but there’s a great amount of posts saying that they hate talking to people, they hate people that talk a lot and etc etc

There’s a great amount of posts where people say that they hate people and that they hate everyone

\-The downvote system doesn’t make sense

Really, it always Goes like this redditor one says something and get downvoted to hell, redditor 2 says that they agree with redditor 1 and they get upvoted a lot, like what??!! Y’all Said the same thing and one got downvoted to hell while the other upvoted. And theres also the hivemind that downvote things simply because it has one downvote. And idk why but for exemple a comment can have 50 downvotes but no one responded saying why they disagree. Like whyyyyy, if everyone is going to downvote Atleast say why to the guy

\-echo Chambers

Here you will se a BUNCH of echo chambers
And some of them are The wildest opinions ever

\-redditors love being unhelpful and making snarky comments

Just search for any post wanting help about something. 80% of the comments are redditors joking about op and treating him like hes stupid and never actually just responding the guy. Why comment at all if you aren’t going to help?

So to conclude:

Never take an advice from reddit, seriously, dont do that

Anyway

Im not talking about everyone, there are normal people here and great human beings. Im just talking about the other people

If you’re coming here just to hate. Then know that My posts is about you

Everyone, feel free to talk about redditors and what you found/understood

I will happily read and respond most of the comments