r/TheoryOfReddit • u/ArchangelleDworkin • Aug 11 '12
The Shitlord Cycle: How reddit's site design and assholes are teaming up to make redditors bigots
Reddit, by design, is going to destroy itself. This has to do with several factors, some with the design of the site itself and others with general human behavior. In the end, reddit is going to create a cultural hegemony of unoriginality and awful users because negative behavior is being reinforced and rewarded.
The defining feature of Reddit is the karma system. Upvotes and downvotes are basically "like" and "don't like" buttons. Users upvote posts and comments they agree with, and downvote things with which they disagree. Posts and comments that the community likes will float to the top while those it dislikes will be automatically removed after being downvoted enough.
Officially reddit has a policy that voting should be different for Posts than it is for comments, but in practice it is not followed. Users use the same mentality of upvote means "like" and downvote is "dislike".
Karma is a mini reward system and is similar to achievements in video games. Both are meaningless in terms of actual gain, but people pursue them because of the tangential rewards. This is otherwise known as Gamification. An upvote on a post is like a little gold star from another person because it means another person "liked" your submission.
It's healthy to seek out attention and approval from others, and upvoting combines both into a form that requires the least amount of social interaction possible. And it feels good to get an upvote.
Problems arise when people get addicted to that feeling, even slightly. Gamification often creates users that will shortcut their way to getting the reward as quickly as possible. On reddit, these users aren't good submitters, but really good at collecting internet points.
One problem is unoriginal content.
From reddit's about page on voting it says:
"As a general rule, vote up what you liked (and want to see more of) and vote down what you disliked (and don't want to see similar things in the future)"
Written into the about page is why new content is not favored. Old, already seen content is prefered over new innovating or challenging submissions.
Adding to this problem is what is called the "Fluff Principle". New or difficult concepts take time to process. They might get upvotes, but not at the same pace as short, easy to digest, regurgitated bullshit. Fluff gets upvoted rapidly, and in depth comments don't get voted on at all, and due to Reddit's voting algorithm, it effectively hides them.
Users notice these trends, and will submit similar or the same exact content just to get points and attention. This applies both to submissions and comments.
Amplifying this effect of unoriginality is downvotes. If a downvote means "dislike", then it means another real person disliked your content. Most people will actively avoid disapproval. If their content is downvoted actively enough, most people will change how they post to gain approval.
But some users won't. And that's all that was needed to lead reddit into a spiral of shittiness.
People who hold white supremacist, misogynistic, homophobic, and generally terrible beliefs are less deterred by downvotes. They care less about other people or what they think, and they'll continue posting their shitty opinions with or without approval from others.
When a woman or minority comes across a comment or submission by these hateful assholes, there are three possible outcomes:
You leave the site entirely. This is the easiest option, and given the demographics of the site it's also the one most chosen. Women and minorities have other shit to do than listen to people tell them how horrible they are, so fuck it. They'll find a place that doesn't have content that directly attacks them.
You stay, and due to downvotes or hostile feedback, change how you post. Or you merely tolerate/ignore it by not saying anything.
You stay, trying to argue against the hate when you see it, but due to the general lack of caring by bigots about other people, your efforts will most likely go to waste. This eventually leads to burnout, and you leave reddit.
Hateful comments and submissions actively drive away those that they're aimed at from the site completely, making the population of reddit just a tiny fraction more hateful due to the bigots staying.
Non-minority men have the luxury of being able to ignore the comments because the hate is rarely, if ever, aimed at their demographic. Mostly these men fall into category 2, and is the reason why they dominate the site. Some will also fall into category 3.
Eventually the bigot to non-bigot ratio is so high that terrible comments actually start receiving upvotes, instead of being hidden. This attracts more assholes who like their content, making it more visible, so more women and minorities can be driven away.
Users that are addicted to karma will see that terrible comments mean internet points, so they will repeat it for approval.
Users who want to fit in will either accept what's being written as true and begin to repeat it as well, or stay silent for fear of downvotes.
Reddit then turns into a shithole that reposts terrible unorginal garbage over and over.
The only way to combat this is through active moderation; however, this is prevented by reddit’s mythos of being a free speech website and it's inadequate moderation tools. Any type of moderation is bemoaned and pitchforked, making moderators less enthusiastic about putting in any effort to use their limited and hard-to-use tools. So reddit is doomed.