Following my previous post, "The logo is a map" (https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOA/comments/1v5cs7y/the_logo_is_a_map/), I've been thinking further about how the original five-part story of The OA could be completed. I believe there may be another piece to the puzzle.
What if, during the filming of Parts I and II, Brit Marling and Zal Batmanglij also recorded additional scenes intended for the later parts?
We know the creators had planned the entire five-part story from the beginning. Jason Isaacs also revealed that some scenes in Part II were directly connected to the story arc originally intended for Part V.
My theory is that Parts III, IV and V could reveal events we've already seen from a completely different perspective, uncovering details and meanings that were hidden from us. Previously filmed footage could be combined with new scenes to complete the story.
I find this possibility particularly fascinating because it would be a brilliant creative solution: the long wait since the cancellation could become part of the experience itself, while previously filmed material could help preserve the original vision without being constrained by real-world issues such as the actors ageing or the difficulty of reuniting the original cast years later.
It also brings to mind T. S. Eliot's Little Gidding, quoted in the Nob Hill house in Part II:
"And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time."
Perhaps the creators could still complete the story exactly as they originally envisioned it, using time itself as part of the narrative.
I have no evidence that such footage exists, but given how carefully the five-part story was planned, I find this possibility fascinating.
I am eagerly awaiting November 16th and/or December 16th :-)