r/TheOA • • Jun 24 '25

Thoughts Does Karim have to smoke in EVERY scene??

1 Upvotes

Idk why but him lighting a cigarette every time he appears on the screen just irritated the hell outta me. and then he proceeds to smoke it throughout the WHOLE SCENE. I swear that’s the longest burning cigarette ever.

It kinda seems like they wanted to make that his whole personality (besides him not wanting kids).

That’s it, I just had to share my frustration lol


r/TheOA • • Apr 22 '22

Netflix | Cancellation Episode 1 is why the OA got cancelled

4 Upvotes

I am sure this will be seen as controversial, but I wanted to post it here to see what others thought, and if anyone could convince me I am wrong.

I believe episode 1 of the OA is weak and its why the show got cancelled. I hear people blame Netflix mishandling the shows advertising as the reason for the OA not getting good viewing numbers, but I disagree.

Episode 1 starts with Prarie jumping off a bridge, that creates some mystery but not enough. And then what follows is a full 60 minutes of very very slow very boring scenes, mostly centered on Steve, where almost nothing interesting is revealed. Finally after an hour the OA tells her story and it gets interesting. The last 20 minutes of the episode are beautiful but the first 60 are boring. I do like the first 60 minutes, but thats only because I know what comes later and how it is connected. And the scene where they go shopping for clothes should have been cut entirely in my opinion.

When I first found the OA it was through a netflix preview that showed Obama not becoming president or something, and so I decided to watch the show since I knew it would have some kind of timeline thing. I wish that the timelines could have been a surprise for me but the truth is without that prerequisite knowledge I would not have got through the first 60 minutes. I realized this when I introduced my family to the show a few months ago and only my dad sat through the whole thing and made it past 60 minutes. He admitted to me the last 20 minutes were pretty good but the first hour was so slow and he almost didn’t get through it. He never ended up watching episode 2 and I think it was because of that. I’ve only ever been able to get one person past episode 1. I believe if people knew what a gem the OAs other 15 episodes were it would be at least as popular as stranger things or squid game, but not many people can sit through episode 1. I hope that a different streaming service buys the OA from netflix and recuts episode 1 down to probably 40 minutes. I know alot of details in that hour connect to other things, but they ward off prospective viewers.

I kind of believe that Brit Marling and Zal intentionally made episode 1 like that because they only wanted viewers who believed in the story when they had no reason to. Then just like the crestwood 5, the viewers would have to have doubt there was magic in the OAs story, but still believe anyways in order to see it. If that metaphor was intention I think it was amazing, and it is my head canon. But I don’t think it was worth it since it killed the show as a commercial property and we never got to see the story that would occur after season 3 (the main plot points of season 3 are strongly implied by various scenes throughout season 2, especially in the octopus episode).


r/TheOA • • Dec 03 '23

Discussion/Themes Did the show get canceled because Brit and Zal were on to something?

5 Upvotes

First... Thank you so much Brit and Zal for all you've done. I've been a fan since day one, Another Earth!

My friend and I were talking about the awful experience of The OA getting canceled and we couldn't help but wonder, were they right about everything with the show and the people in power didn't want the information exposed? Not necessarily everything like the moves but the idea that there is more to this world and other worlds.

I think The OA was giving us truth in a world of lies.

I think about this show often.


r/TheOA • • Nov 24 '24

Screenshots & Clips endearing little brother. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

her brother is homer. he is of the age difference... when nancy and abel went to the russian baby factory, she said to them... "the pictures don't do him any justice".

when homer was on a date in season 2, his date said "wow you're look way better looking in person than in your online pictures"

this was to indicate a mirroring of the 2 scenes. remember it's an echo. HAP is aware which is why he doesn't want them touching. oa and homer even joke like brother and sister in the elevator. the kiss was to unlock his mind. we don't know Oa's mother so she could have hid out in america with OA's aunt. had another baby.. and dipped because the voyi followed her to america. where her now second child awaits the first.

OA is even seen as young nina tending to his crying in the same scene. the mom sent her to take care of him... and later he to take care of her.


r/TheOA • • Sep 21 '19

Review Guys, no offense but it's just a show

6 Upvotes

Look, I love the OA. I do, but it's also just a show. I felt it was genuinely a great show, but it's not perfect either. I applaud the efforts taken to try and bring it back, but please don't take it too far. The characters aren't real, they are fictional. It's fun to post about seeing messages and symbols, but don't treat it like some mystical creation that deserves everyone's love and attention. Treat it for what it is, because I've seen a lot of posts talking about how powerful and healing it is, and though I do agree, I don't agree that it's some kind of miracle show. It's still just a show about life and death.

All I'm saying is, don't hound companies obsessively to bring it back like they're evil for cancelling it. That makes the entire community look toxic and terrible to everyone who isn't apart of it. It can push people away from watching it. And not to mention, it's just a show. There's no need to be rude or offensive if it doesn't get brought back.


r/TheOA • • 6d ago

Thoughts The OA is boring. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Did I scare you with that title? Don’t worry, I don’t feel that way. But I just had another person tell me that they tried to watch it and thought it was boring. Anytime someone says that to me it takes all I have not to launch into a TED talk on why their perspective is not valid since they did not finish the show. But it’s OK because when I do find people in the real world who have watched all of the OA, we lock in in such a way that those two episode viewers will never understand lol


r/TheOA • • Dec 30 '18

To all those who have made it their life’s purpose in downvoting every single post/comment I make, at least Zal & Ian likes my video...lol (please feel free to downvote 🤪)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheOA • • Sep 19 '19

New Zal IG story. Too weird. Any thoughts?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/TheOA • • Oct 08 '21

Production Has anyone else seen this/know more?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/TheOA • • May 28 '21

Thoughts Sorry, but “You all did well” is just patronizing.

20 Upvotes

Zal purposely and consciously misled the most sincere fan base on the planet, and he manipulated and used us to create buzz when he could have been open.

We know Zal was perfectly aware of what was going on, and he could have defused all the speculation any time he wanted to. Instead he fed it. As I say, sure, I might be wrong, but all seems to point to him manipulating us to create buzz in the hope of pushing for a renewal or pick up. My issue is that rather than mislead and manipulate us and have us believe something is coming or happening, he could have played it straight and even said something as simple “Nothing solid yet, but the more buzz you guys make, the more likely it is to happen.”

We would’ve moved mountains.

I feel used, and I’m sure a lot of us do.


r/TheOA • • Sep 08 '19

Should we call out Brit and Zal?

2 Upvotes

Okay, so I’ve been giving this a lot of thought over the weekend / particularly in light of Zal’s posts and the QR code etc. I really do believe enough is enough now. Somebody made a really a good point on one of the other threads about vulnerable people and being careful not to mess with people and stuff and that’s exactly what’s happening now. So many of us are taking time out of own lives in pursuit of what might be nothing. Just a cancelled TV show. I myself am heading back to university this month and I do not need this hanging over me, you know!! The digging, the clues, the threads is potentially beckoning too much.

I’m not writing this as a negative post by any means, nor to cause aggression or distress I just think given the level this has now reached after a month with no clear response from anyone - it’s time we got some answers. Solid, real answers.

As we all know from the original announcement and continued posts in IG and social something has been amiss. The language used on almost all correspondence and interviews by cast and producers has been has never included the word ‘cancelled’ it’s almost always been ‘not continuing’ or ‘the story won’t continue’. Or vague language that’s open to interpretation. Netflix never used it, Brit and Zal have never used it. Not once. Netflix have gone quiet. And Brit and Zal just keep posting cryptic poetic bullshit.

I keep coming back to the other comment over the weekend about vulnerable people and this needs to stop.

We’ve got hunger strikes and people travelling to benches for co-incidental QR codes, and funding boards checking maps and flights and obsessing over every detail (myself included) and i think it’s now irresponsible of Brit and Zal to allow this continue. Peoples mental health is at stake.

I think it’s amazing what we’ve all done, I think the fandom and unity and stamina is incredible. I think what Brit and Zal created is incredible.

But this isn’t sustainable. We need a statement, we need something concrete. Something like a joint statement along the lines of ‘hey guys we want to thank you for all you support and belief but we think it’s important to clarify that The OA is 100% cancelled for real. This isn’t a game. This isn’t publicity. We’re doing all we can on our end but wanted to let you all know that for now the show is over. We will Update if and when as we know anything.’

No emojis, no quotes, no poetry or dancing around with creative intelligence and semantics. Just a solid answer. It wouldn’t be that difficult to put together at all.

I mean this cannot continue like this, it is damaging to some people in the long term surely?

I think they have a responsibility as artists and public figures to ensure that people aren’t driving themselves crazy over it. And I still fail to understand why NOBODY involved in the production has directly and succinctly clarified this at any point over the last month.

But the fav that HAVENT said anything just still makes me think it IS IRL.

But that’s exactly my point, it needs to end one way or the other.....

What are people’s thoughts??


r/TheOA • • Sep 11 '21

Thoughts Have hope, but don't let it run away with you.

1 Upvotes

It seems there's been a resurgence of interest. Brit and Zal have both been posting interesting things and several of the cast of The OA have apparently done similarly.

I think we need a little bit of a reality check.

People could just be emulating other people they respect and admire. They could also be playing, or even perhaps seeking attention, knowing that thousands of people are watching what they post solely because of their involvement in this story.

And why wouldn't they? The OA was a great success for a lot of young actors, they should be enjoying it and using this experience to build their careers.

I think it's also important to remember that this is their job. They are writers/actors who make a living telling stories. There's an element of self-promotion and it would be naive to ignore it.

Their connection to this story is not the same as the connection the viewer has. When an artist paints a portrait it's a lot of work, a lot of struggle and a lot of effort. The viewer only sees the finished creation and has a certain romantic notion about how it was made.

I love seeing other fans so passionate about this story, it's often fun to speculate and imagine what might come next.

Having said that, sometimes a photo is just a photo. Actors and writers are allowed to enjoy the appreciation their work receives. They should be able to post something without fearing that it's going to be analyzed by a thousand people reading something unintended in every pixel.

Brit and Zal have a certain aesthetic. They both appreciate a certain style of imagery, it appears in a lot of what they create. Instead of understanding that this might just be their style people link it to The OA, which was also made in their creative style, so of course if that's their general aesthetic there are going to be similarities even where no link was intended.

I actually feel quite bad for them all. It seems that no matter what they post, from a fun moment in their own lives to something intriguing about a new project they're excited about, it's often going to be twisted and reshaped to be forced into an OA box.

I think I just worry that a lot of people are going to be disappointed, and that this will ultimately turn sour when people don't get what they wanted and hoped for.

Thankfully I also know that a lot of people in this community will be excited for whatever Brit and Zal create, and whatever the cast of The OA go on to do.

I know I'm looking forward to seeing their new creations. Sure, it would be an incredible surprise if it was a continuation of the story we all love so much, but I hope expectations can be tempered so that there isn't a backlash if it doesn't lead to that.


r/TheOA • • Feb 09 '26

#SaveTheOA Signs..signs..and more signs..or is it just me overthinking it..?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Goin in my liked list hittin the shuffle button and getting this song rollin in..hearin it saying far away oa oa oa😭✨


r/TheOA • • Feb 09 '24

Thoughts Anyone else feel like this show villainizes mental health treatment? Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Not much of a spoiler, but I wanted to be cautious. I've only watched up to Part II Episode 2, so please no spoilers for me! Also please excuse the awkward formatting. Bullet points is the only way I know how to separate paragraphs on mobile.

  • We as the viewers get to see that she is having real premonitions and an elevated level of cognition, but I don't think the people I the real world thinking she's sick is irrational and malicious. She's angry at her parents for taking her to a doctor who decided to prescribe her medicine when she was pulling knives out of her suitcase while sleepwalking and having anxiety attacks. Those are very reasonable and rational things for her parents and doctor to have done but she's acting like they were bouncing her between looney bins with a Valium drip.

  • I understand why people thinking OA is just crazy fits the plot, but it has made me uncomfortable with how many times she has snapped at people and held a grudge against her parents for having her take medication, insisting she should see a therapist, and/or suggesting a stay in a hospital for a bit to get her bearings after disappearing for years and/or waking up with severe amnesia. Of course she's extra sensitive because she was just held captive for years so a lock down unit would be incredibly triggering, but she's also obsessed with traveling to another dimension while calling herself an angel, coming home with dog bites, and telling a social worker about how this Nina is not really her. In the real world probably 1 in 1,000 people who says they're being stalked and surveilled by the government is telling the truth, but feeding the delusion of the other 999 is causing harm to them.

  • I may be extra sensitive to this because my parents didn't believe in psychiatric treatment so I struggled and suffered immensely when I desperately needed therapy and medication. OA seems to be painting with a very broad brush on a topic that already gets a lot of criticism for being subjective and unfair and unfounded claims that taking medication is numbing and throwing a tarp over a person's true self. It's so prevalent in the show that it feels like they're fanning the flames of the stigma that haunts getting treatment for mental illness.


r/TheOA • • May 22 '18

More proof of multiple dimensions..?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/TheOA • • Sep 10 '17

Watch this show high

3 Upvotes

Me and my girlfriend watched the first episode one night before bed. It was slow but seemed really interesting. The. Ext day was her birthday and my friend gave her some LSD-25 to enjoy the night of. So we took our acid and turned on the OA, and I just want to say it was amazing. This show is just the right kind of rollercoaster and if anyone here messed with L I highly suggest this show.


r/TheOA • • Jul 04 '24

Question Canceled on Purpose?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this has been posted before, but I don't go on reddit very often. What if there were never meant to be more than 2 seasons, and all of this getting canceled stuff was actually part of the plan?


r/TheOA • • Jan 15 '26

OA Theories AM I READING TOO DEEP?😹 Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hey guys does this look familiar??? Funny poster to have in a book store.


r/TheOA • • Jan 16 '24

Question Worth watching S2 if I didn't enjoy S1?

0 Upvotes

I just finished watching S1, because a friend REALLY pleaded with me to watch it and that it would be an absolutely wonderful experience. So, even though I didn't really feel anything throughout the series, I made it through because of her. However, even after watching the finale, I just simply...didn't get it. No scene really spoke to me, no strong emotions were evoked, and I was left with only questions and a vague sense that I had wasted my time.

Now, I've done my due diligence and looked at a plethora of reviews online about how amazing this show is and how it gets even better in S2 and how many questions will be answered, but I was wondering, does S2 have a similar style and tone as S1? Will I enjoy it even if I wasn't impressed by S1? Maybe this series just isn't for me, but I want to at least ask for perspective on maybe why you liked S1 and what's so good about the show in it's entirety, before I give up on the series completely.


r/TheOA • • Jul 09 '24

Theories Brit is OA and we have to remind her(theory)

0 Upvotes

EDIT: PLEASE READ. There has been a miscommunication in my part, I’d like to clear it up. I do not believe the OA is real, it is a TV show, and i absolutely don’t believe Brit is anyone other than Brit. To people telling me to leave her alone, I was never going to harass her?? I was literally talking about fanmail, sending in my silly theory, hoping to maybe hear about any news because it was right before the show was cancelled. I’m sorry I wasn’t clearer, I didn’t think anyone would think I believe this is real. I do not condone contacting anyone against their will, I was talking about fanmail, because she had a fanmail address on her site(i think it was hers? I don’t remember.) I said I wanted to send two letters, one addressing Brit, and one addressing the OA, the one addressed to OA would have started with something like “hi Brit, I had this fun theory,I hope you’ll indulge me while I tell it to you.” I have absolutely no intention of contacting her, it was something that could have made for fun fanmail but I’d like to think that the fact it’s been years and I still haven’t done it should prove I respect her boundaries. I will never do it. Again, apologies for the misunderstanding I had no idea my post would be interpreted this way.

Title says is all really, my theory is that the real life Brit Marling is actually OA and we have to remind her of that, maybe in the form of an ARG or something.

I had this theory years ago before the show had been cancelled(so I thought this could be plausible at the time), and I was actually keeping it to myself because I was going to write a letter to Brit, two letters actually, one addressed to Brit and one addressed to OA, because I thought if I’m right, maybe she’ll reply and give me some juicy details no one else knows lol, but it’s been a very long time since I had this theory and holding onto it is dumb, time to share, I’m sure other people have thought of it by now too.

Highly doubt anything like this will happen now, but it would be so much fun.


r/TheOA • • Apr 21 '18

Does anyone else like The OA ironically?

2 Upvotes

I love The OA. Seen season 1 twice, check on fan theories, and regularly look for updates on season 2. I've got to ask however, is anyone else here because of how ridiculous the show is? Maybe loving the show ironically isn't the best way to phrase it but it definitely has a lot of so bad it's good stuff going on (to me at least). I just want to know if I'm in the minority or not.


r/TheOA • • Aug 12 '17

The characters have no reason to sit and listen to Praerie for hours

3 Upvotes

This show was strange to get through. Steve is an abhorrent character repeatedly displaying horrifying gauges of social cues of friend/foe and is deathly violent. He is rewarded for this.

The OA doesn't delve in to any conversation with the other people she possesses for her story telling time. Her story embellishments and details included add nothing for her audience. They extract nothing from the story and lose faith in her.

Khatun was drawing lifeforce and was a malicious entity disguised as someone 'helping' OA. She never appeared in the end because OA had already fallen so low by repeatedly being dunked under by the evil doctor, there was practically nothing left to siphon from her.

The ending is supposed to be the five people charging the attacker at once from different sides, enabling a takedown. The choreography breaks you, once again, from the only remotely natural, organic element that you longed for, to root you to the show as something teaching a real culmination of trust, unity, will, sacrifice.

I'm leaning towards the theory of the show being a metaphor for unbearably bad, long endured torture, torment, and worse - as she pleads with them to listen to her stories.


r/TheOA • • May 24 '21

Theories Mind blowing theory

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! It was very inspiring to read all the posts/theories yesterday (and always). However, something just came to my mind last night. Let me share with all the fans: I think The OA wasn’t cancelled, everything was planned before. When at the end of S2 - we jumped to our dimension everything become IRL. What if, all the chat yesterday in Reddit, all the comments/theories here and Twitter fan pages etc. are part of season 3? We will see actual footage when in Season 3 Zal and Britt are thinking to start filming the next season, so they ended up showing a message online (Instagram posts) about Season 3 (just as once Praire sent a message in Season 1 on Youtube. Who knows/ what are you guys think about this theory ?


r/TheOA • • Jun 26 '19

The goosebumps I get while watching this show

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/TheOA • • Jun 11 '18

Are Rachel and Prairie the same person?

Post image
5 Upvotes