r/TheMotte • • May 14 '22

Religion is Pragmatic and Atheists are Irrational

0 Upvotes

Edit: My title should be more accurately "Religion is Pragmatic and Atheism is Irrational" rather than "Atheists."

Edit#2: I realized I am mistaken about my definition of 'irrational', I took it to mean 'not in accordance with reality'

I'm going to attempt to be as succinct as possible and expand my reasoning as people inquire. I garner significant inspiration from the likes of Jordan Peterson. I think this [13 minute] clip from a debate between him and Sam Harris touches on the core argument but is not necessary to watch (https://youtu.be/F4wDobqp4Y0).

Essentially, religious texts are a collection of stories which elucidate human nature and metaphysics. Religious ritual is engaged in for a chiefly psychological purpose. Modern science exists within a religious framework; scientists operate under religious assumptions such as 'the truth will set you free.' Western science is a direct result of Christianity. The scientific method is analogous to human perception: start with hypothesis, experiment, and end with conclusion. The hypothesis and conclusion are both assumptions, acts of faith based on varying degrees of evidence (I use faith as synonymous to belief, and disagree with definitions which attribute total ignorance). Here's a quote from theoretical physicist Jim Al-Khalili "A scientist can never be certain that something is right... There are levels of confidence." In this sense I agree with the philosophy of Fideism (all knowledge is a result of faith), which I relate to Humeanism (reason is the slave of the passions; rationality is an instrument).

Atheists, when pressed, will often admit to being agnostic. This behavior demonstrates a tribal affiliation associated with 'being an atheist', and this is often projected onto religion by claiming it's merely a tribal instinct. Atheists usually don't understand religion, almost invariably straw-manning by characterizing it as archaic, while steel-manning their own position as supremely rational. Religious ideas are more sophisticated than they admit or understand. On the other hand, atheism is very simple: it's either a complete denial of religious belief, or a partial rejection which is more accurately agnosticism.

The essential danger for people of any belief system is becoming dogmatic and therefore irrational. I'm posting here after being perma-banned from r/sreetepistemology which is allegedly a forum for 'non-confrontational conversation; updated socratic method.' Unfortunately, the mods there are basically zealous atheist missionaries. I picked that subreddit, and am now posting here, because I like the stated doctrine of good faith conversation, and hope to reveal and elaborate my own beliefs by engaging in such conversation as well as spark some interesting discussion.


r/TheMotte • • Dec 26 '20

CMV: unless your work requires you to personally manipulate atoms, you should be allowed to work remotely.

0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Jul 09 '22

True or False? Setting aside the minority of bad players, all people are racist and will adamantly defend that they are not racist because they genuinely don't want to be. We have created blame, shame, and guilt toward being racist, so we are no longer willing to admit when we are being racist.

1 Upvotes

I admit that I am racist and suffer from intrinsic bias. I seek not to be. I've found that the key is to listen, discuss, and to move toward love rather than hate when the option is available.

What are your thoughts on being racist? If you're not racist, are you absolutely sure that you are not?


r/TheMotte • • May 05 '22

Ok, I'm back. AMA.

19 Upvotes

Probably a bad idea, but I want to argue about the current bullshit and the level of debate everywhere is just depressingly limited and boring. Judging by the latest quality contributions roundup, I still do not agree with the hivemind around here on most things and I'm sure I'll once again get people being angry at my defiance until a mod decides all the vitriol is solely my fault. But until then I'm back for fun.

My hope in making his post is that all the old-heads who somehow are still talking about me on here semi-regularly and still hold a grudge will do their trolling of me here instead of clogging up the main discussion thread with it. Open to all other conversion and questions as well.


r/TheMotte • • Dec 22 '21

"There are three main atrocities that people naively lump together when talking about the awfulness of the Stalin years"

Thumbnail
vacuouslyfalse.tumblr.com
3 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • May 01 '22

Am I mistaken in thinking the Ukraine-Russia conflict is morally grey?

13 Upvotes

Edit: deleting the contents of the thread since many people are telling me it parrots Russian propaganda and I don't want to reinforce that.

For what it's worth I took all of my points from reading Bloomberg, Scott, Ziv and a bit of reddit FP, so if I did end up arguing for a Russian propaganda side I think that's a rather curious thing.


r/TheMotte • • Nov 19 '21

More people died in the key clinical trial for Pfizer's Covid vaccine than the company publicly reported

Thumbnail
alexberenson.substack.com
24 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • May 15 '20

Stalin and the oil

0 Upvotes

“Stalin and the oil” by Tom Hart https://link.medium.com/vNQS0A6aw6


r/TheMotte • • Apr 17 '19

Yang Says the Hard Part is Already Behind Him, but is His Basic Premise True? Is Going From Anonymity to Legitimacy Harder Than From Legitimacy to Victory?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Mar 21 '22

Take this independent subreddit demographic and political survey!

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Mar 13 '19

Did the US cause the Venezuelan Blackout?

0 Upvotes

Venezuela is claiming thier blackout is the result of a US cyber attack.

I am more than willing to believe that, the USs record in South America is certainly vile enough. And we are clearly waging economic warfare on them.

But I saw this article referenced in the Guardian. A year ago the Venezuelan secret police arrested the head of the dam workers trade union because he went public with warning that they were skimping on maintenance so much they were putting the country at risk.

http://talcualdigital.com/index.php/2018/02/15/sebin-detiene-sindicalista-por-alertar-sobre-posible-colapso-electrico/


r/TheMotte • • May 31 '19

I don't understand why we don't see more whistle blowers (CMV)

2 Upvotes

With a sizable percentage of human resource workers being female and 75% of human resource managers being female, why don't we hear about more instances of whistle blowing with regards to inequality in pay due to gender?

This argument is specifically against folks who maintain the the gender pay gap is due to misogyny. Specifically, if there are men and women doing the same job and the women are getting paid less because they're women, why aren't women stepping forward to call out companies on this? I'm not saying they don't exist, but I would think we'd hear much more about them.

Yes. I am aware that human resources employees often do not determine compensation. However, HR employees traditionally have access to see how employees are compensated. They may not be able to set wages but they would be in a place to know how much those wages are.

So where are the whistle blowers? Are they out there in the news and just not being reported all that much? Do they not exist at all? If not, why not?


r/TheMotte • • Jun 23 '20

What "dark arts" are you interested in?

9 Upvotes

I got term "dark arts" from J.K. Rowling's fantasy book series Harry Potter. In the series, the protagonist goes to a school for wizards where he learns magic. One of the disciplines that we encounter in the wizarding world is "dark arts". This refers to things such as torture, soul-splitting, immortality, mind control, murder etc, things that are so dangerous that the students are only taught how to defend themselves against them, and the section of the school library with books about dark arts is sealed off for everyone but the seniormost students.

The reason why I began with this little reference to a children's book series is that I have been wondering about knowledge from our real world that might be referred to as the "dark arts". Knowledge that exists, but is either not put into writing for fear of circulation, or is not talked about outside specialized circles. For practical purposes I will exclude ultra specialized technology(liek cloning and gene editing) from this, instead chosing to focus on knowledge that does not require specialized equipment and education to work with.

For example.

Let us say I am a budding authoritarian leader in an extremist party. I am slowly rising up the party ranks, and I aim to one day become the chief executive of my country and restore to a status of glory and global hegemony.

I also happen to virulently hate a certain group of people 'X', and its is my wish to see them eradicated or expelled from my country. However, my problem is that most of my countrymen do not share the same level of hatred towards 'X'. Therefore, I am looking to perpetrate a propaganda campaign (using 21st century media) that normalizes hatred against them before they can actually be declared illegals and deported(or worse).

How do I go about doing this? What book do I read that will teach how to conduct a viral hate campaign, increase strife in society and engineer a power grab to take over a country? What book will teach me how to conduct a genocide? How to successfully demonize an entire group of people? How to control the media? How to brainwash my people into believing a twisted version of reality, much like the North Korens do?

Wouldn't it be interesting if there was a book out something like "How to take over a country as an authoritarian despot" or something like that? [The closest book I can think of is Luttwak's Coup d'État: A Practical Handbook. But that is specific to one situation.]

This is just one such example. What other "dark arts" exist that you're interested in?


r/TheMotte • • May 12 '22

A different way of approaching the abortion discussion (image and discussion)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Oct 11 '19

In seems that around 90% of the comments in this sub are concentrated in the culture war threads. Would it be time to rethink the handling of such topics?

8 Upvotes

I couldn't find a good way to tally the actual number of weekly comments on this sub, but I don't think that it's an unreasonable estimate that the CW-threads are easily 10 times bigger than the entire rest of the sub combined.

I understand that these threads were created to streamline moderation of contentious topics, but I find it hard to imagine that it still serves that purpose - the structure of long form discussions within a single thread is less intuitive to both read and moderate.

To illustrate this, here's /u/chaoslastorder's excellent write-up on a variety of thoughts on China and Hong Kong, which was even linked on /r/depthhub. Notice how he says there that it's going to be a long post, yet it seems fairly concise, by this sub's standards? Or how he has a point 1) without any following points? That's because the other 5 posts are strewn somewhere within the depths of this single comment subthread, which, in turn is only one of hundreds in that CW-topic. (I do recommend that you simply CTRL+F for "2)", "3)", etc. Those posts are well worth reading, if you have some time to spare!)

When a product's niche use case outgrows the popularity of the product itself, it may be time to rethink its purpose.

I'm not sure that I have elegant alternatives to propose.

More frequent topic-focussed CW-threads (like megathreads in other subs)?

Create a new sub for CW topics? (Wasn't that what themotte was for in the first place?)

Get rid of that restriction altogether and allow CW threads?

Even allowing for potential downsides of those options, I'm not sure that the current paradigm is conducive to constructive discussions.


r/TheMotte • • Jan 07 '21

Stacking analogies against each other is against the rules

4 Upvotes

I've adopted a simple system for discussions. If someone presents an argument by making an analogy, you're not allowed to present a more "correct" analogy. You can say it's a bad analogy, you can say why, or you can just ignore it and give a better argument—including any combination of those―but you can't say, "no, it's more like..." even if you also provide an argument of your own—e.g. you're not just presenting your analogy with no further comment. The idea is that it is simply forbidden to keep tweaking analogies or trying to swap one for another.

Here's an example. Someone who is pro-skub complains that that another pro-skubber is spending too much time criticizing the things other pro-skubbers do (because instead pro-skubbers should be putting energy into fighting people who are anti-skub, since they are responsible for doing the most harm in a big picture sense). So another pro-skubber chimes in to defend the criticism:

That's like if your spouse got upset with you for punishing your kid for doing something wrong, and they tell you that "the neighbor's kid is doing way more damage to the neighborhood". Yeah, well, this kid is yours. Of course you should do something to correct them. What, are you gonna go out and find that other kid and fix their behavior and ignore what your kid has done?

And here's the type of retort that wouldn't be allowed:

That analogy isn't very good. It's more like if half the teachers at the school are working together with the principal to bring down the entire education system, but you spend most of your time worrying about another kid in the class who is a bully. Clearly the first problem is much bigger, so it should get the most attention.

I don't have a concrete answer for why this rule is good, but it obviously doesn't asymmetrically favor any side of issues that I identify with more, because it's a general rule that has nothing to do with positions themselves. If I'm anti-pro-skub-criticism (read as: anti-((pro-skub)-criticism)) then it doesn't hurt or help my side any more than it hurts or helps someone who is pro-pro-skub-criticism. It might seem like it give first-mover advantage, but I don't think so. Besides, this isn't taking all further analogies of the table, you just can't use a "correct" one as a retort.

I've certainly felt compelled to respond to analogies with "better" ones in the past, but not much. I can say that I don't think they ever helped, and I've probably never seen any instance of this happening ever where I saw someone else doing it and thought, "yeah, that analogy is better, and I'm satisfied with where it took the discussion", even if I agree that the first analogy was bad, for example.


r/TheMotte • • Feb 25 '22

Charitable Geopolitics

9 Upvotes

Geopolitics is normally based on competition, tribalism and contempt. Here's my attempt at reformulating it based on charity.

One of the big reasons Russia is invading Ukraine is it feels lost. Their leaders see no perspective beyond a petrol state that may decline further in the near future due to carbon phase out. There is not much technological development going on or alternative sources, and the government's strong rule needs support from institutions and oligarchs.

The current (nationalistic, tribalistic) assumption is that we should restrict their power and protect their neighbors, and try to impose sanctions to curb their military and industrial or scientific capabilities.

I think we should do the opposite: Russia is going this way because they have nothing to lose. Give them something to lose. Make promises of development and help them economically, of course linked to some mutual (and verified) disarmament goals. Lift them up to Ukraine, don't push them down into the gutters.

The same plays in China. The common wisdom regarding Taiwan is that it should develop TSMC and use its virtual monopoly on advanced semiconductors to protect itself. I say we should let China develop its own advanced semiconductor manufacturing and not be so desperate about Taiwan. China could develop its own economy and values instead of relying on taking a foreign country.

Of course the world as a whole gains with this approach. More science, more culture, and better yet better lives (I care about every existing entity).

This of course extends to all sorts of conflicts. We rarely think win-win.


r/TheMotte • • May 21 '19

Why So Many Women Choose Abortion Over Adoption

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Dec 03 '20

A Cultural Delusion - Personal Essay

Thumbnail
likeclockworkorange.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Apr 23 '19

While the US is significantly reducing CO2 emissions, Europe as a whole is increasing them. As the US stops consuming coal, Europe is buying it and burning it.

Thumbnail
economist.com
3 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • May 07 '19

The Steelwool Scrub – A Fallacy

Thumbnail
crookedtimber.org
2 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Jun 03 '19

I made some public domain #YangGang meme designs

Thumbnail
sonyaellenmann.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Nov 06 '21

A Secured Zone in Haiti

0 Upvotes

Hello. I heard about TheMotte at ACX.

I would like feedback on this 8000 word plan to help Haiti. Positive or negative. More specific is better. My goal is to improve the plan.

If this is not appropriate for this community, please ignore it.

Peter

A Secured Zone in Haiti

The ZSS plan for Haiti in brief

Haiti has been much in the news in recent years, and for all the wrong reasons. Faced with a never-ending series of disasters, both natural and man-made, Haitians are desperately trying to flee their country and enter the US and other countries. Far better if they could live safely and productively in their own country.

We believe that Haiti is failing because of long-standing inequality, government corruption, and unrestrained gangs. In this plan we propose to eliminate corruption and gangs in the most distant Department (Sud) which has 5% of the population of Haiti. A functioning government in Sud could begin to address inequality. Success in Sud would provide a model for the other nine Departments.

The funding would come from the United States. Five year cost: $3.2 billion. About  one-thousandth of the cost of the Afghan War.

The US would provide a small military force which would back up the Haitian police in Sud.

Eliminating civilian guns in the Sud is key to eliminating the gangs. (Have you ever heard of a gang with no guns?)

We propose to empower government employees (including the police) while eliminating corruption by pairing each employee with a Haitian (Creole-speaking) auxiliary. Government pay would be matched for those employees with auxiliaries. Auxiliaries would be hired and paid by the US.

By guaranteeing security throughout Sud, tourism would be greatly enhanced. The entire Department, not just tourist enclaves.

We propose to decentralize government funding and authority so that Sud can succeed even if the central government is failing. Value-added tax revenue would stay in Sud and would be used to fund basic services: security, roads, water, sanitation, electricity, and trash collection.

We propose to fund the project (announced in 2013) to expand the Les Cayes airport to international status. This would enable tourists to reach Sud without passing through gang-controlled areas in Port-au-Prince or taking a prop plane.

The offer to fund the airport expansion also serves as a bargaining chip to encourage adoption of the plan.

Why would this plan succeed?

Nation building is hard and usually fails. Why would this plan succeed when so many others have not? 

  • In the Zone Sécurisée de Sud (ZSS) plan we have limited goals: eliminate corruption, gangs, and private guns in five percent of Haiti. This plan covers only one Department with a population of about 560,000, the size of Albuquerque, New Mexico.

  • Sud is the Department that is farthest from the corruption and gangs, thus the easiest to fix.

  • Building an international airport would be  both a huge bargaining chip and the key to economic success in Sud.

  • 98% or more of the personnel hired by the ZSS would be Haitian. The only exception to this would be a small military force and hopefully some of those would be Haitian-Americans.

  • US military forces would be used only as needed to back up the Haitian/ZSS police force and rarely be seen by the public.

  • By pairing Haitian government personnel with Haitian ZSS personnel (auxiliaries), we both support the government and eliminate corruption.

  • Because we start in one distant Department, it would be easier for corrupt officials and gang members to move to other parts of Haiti than stay and fight (and lose).

  • A well-funded gun buyback would do most of the work of eliminating private guns.

  • Success in one of the ten departments would lay the groundwork for success in the next.

Why do this?

So that Haitians can go home to their own revitalized country and not be resented and persecuted in others. The three and a half million Haitians in the diaspora are both the motivation and the means to success for this plan.

The plan: TinyURL.com/HaitiZSS


r/TheMotte • • May 03 '19

Capitalism Does Not Exist

Thumbnail
minds.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Feb 18 '20

Coronavirus conspiracy theory: accident with weaponized virus in China

7 Upvotes

My wife, an immigrant from China, is fairly convinced that this whole thing is China's fault - not just for handling it badly, but because they actually created it as part of a biological weapon program, which suffered some kind of accident. As with any conspiracy theory, she points to a number of possibly true items that might hang together circumstantially to support the idea. For example, apparently there's new regulations in the works to cover how biological agents must be transported; supposedly this shows that they're trying to avoid future instances of the accident that already happened, rather than simple recognition of the fact that they're going to be working with viruses because of this, and need to be careful.

Anyway, can anybody point to anything more than supposition that would tend to confirm, or more likely disprove, these theories?