r/TheMotte • u/SpeakTruthPlease • May 14 '22
Religion is Pragmatic and Atheists are Irrational
Edit: My title should be more accurately "Religion is Pragmatic and Atheism is Irrational" rather than "Atheists."
Edit#2: I realized I am mistaken about my definition of 'irrational', I took it to mean 'not in accordance with reality'
I'm going to attempt to be as succinct as possible and expand my reasoning as people inquire. I garner significant inspiration from the likes of Jordan Peterson. I think this [13 minute] clip from a debate between him and Sam Harris touches on the core argument but is not necessary to watch (https://youtu.be/F4wDobqp4Y0).
Essentially, religious texts are a collection of stories which elucidate human nature and metaphysics. Religious ritual is engaged in for a chiefly psychological purpose. Modern science exists within a religious framework; scientists operate under religious assumptions such as 'the truth will set you free.' Western science is a direct result of Christianity. The scientific method is analogous to human perception: start with hypothesis, experiment, and end with conclusion. The hypothesis and conclusion are both assumptions, acts of faith based on varying degrees of evidence (I use faith as synonymous to belief, and disagree with definitions which attribute total ignorance). Here's a quote from theoretical physicist Jim Al-Khalili "A scientist can never be certain that something is right... There are levels of confidence." In this sense I agree with the philosophy of Fideism (all knowledge is a result of faith), which I relate to Humeanism (reason is the slave of the passions; rationality is an instrument).
Atheists, when pressed, will often admit to being agnostic. This behavior demonstrates a tribal affiliation associated with 'being an atheist', and this is often projected onto religion by claiming it's merely a tribal instinct. Atheists usually don't understand religion, almost invariably straw-manning by characterizing it as archaic, while steel-manning their own position as supremely rational. Religious ideas are more sophisticated than they admit or understand. On the other hand, atheism is very simple: it's either a complete denial of religious belief, or a partial rejection which is more accurately agnosticism.
The essential danger for people of any belief system is becoming dogmatic and therefore irrational. I'm posting here after being perma-banned from r/sreetepistemology which is allegedly a forum for 'non-confrontational conversation; updated socratic method.' Unfortunately, the mods there are basically zealous atheist missionaries. I picked that subreddit, and am now posting here, because I like the stated doctrine of good faith conversation, and hope to reveal and elaborate my own beliefs by engaging in such conversation as well as spark some interesting discussion.