r/TheMotte • • Jun 23 '20

Star Slate Codex deleted because of NYT article.

Thumbnail
slatestarcodex.com
512 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Mar 17 '21

Death of a Client

450 Upvotes

I just found out one of my clients died.

He stopped answering my calls and got a warrant for not showing up to court. As is expected practice, I filed a notice of withdrawal from his case after not hearing from him for a while. Unbeknownst to me until many months later, the prosecutor filed a motion to dismiss the charges the day before I withdrew from the case, citing his death. My notice to withdraw must've been seen as especially pointless and petty given those circumstances. I didn't know about any of this until today.

My job requires me to watch hours and hours of bodycam footage, and over time I've gained an appreciation for the kind of work that police officers have to undertake. I think perhaps the general public has a severe under-appreciation for how much a cop's job resembles a janitor's. They're both summoned to handle extremely unpleasant situations by people who would rather just not deal with any of it, and often with the aim and purpose of cleaning up the trash (figuratively and literally). This person just bled all over my front door/is sleeping in my parking garage/set fire to all their belongings; please come here and fix it right now.

In the course of these duties, they encounter people like my client.

He was an elderly man with a heavy accent. He was homeless and perpetually unemployed. He loved meth.

He was arrested numerous times for simple drug possession and the petty mischief typically associated. In one instance, he was told by police that he either lets them search his RV or they'll tow it. He resisted at first, then relented and allowed the search, then he was arrested for meth possession, and then his RV was towed anyway.

Months later, he was exchanging messages with an attractive young woman who seemed to be particularly drawn to his purportedly unique ability to acquire methamphetamine. She was promising sex in exchange for meth, and he couldn't contain himself from describing how amazing sex feels when you're obliterated on stimulants. After weeks of build-up and logistics wrangling, he showed up giddy to her apartment and was promptly arrested by a squad of cops literally waiting in the bushes. The hot nymphomaniac meth head was a catfish. I had the privilege of seeing the disappointment on his face through the bodycam video.

The number of police officers involved in his arrest implicated an ungodly amount of overtime compensation and other resources sacrificed towards the task. My client brought along a friend higher up the chain in drug dealing to the meth sex party too, and the dealer friend decided taking his chances was better than risking a possession with intent felony, so he swallowed the entirety of his drug inventory in one fell swoop. I got to see his agony as he writhed while handcuffed on the precinct cell floor through the bodycam video.

If I was to highlight a strength of mine, it would be my empathy. It's profoundly advantageous to have this ability when navigating social situations. I can sense when people are nervous, anxious, confused, etc. and I can act accordingly. I believe this has been a tremendous boon when considering friends and romantic partners as the currency, but it has collateral positive effects in allowing me to connect with my clients. It's also, no questions, the most physically painful part of my job.

Maybe it's myopia saying this, but it's difficult for me to imagine a profession similarly as consequential as a public defender. Or at least, a public defender who cares. What I mean by this is that I've literally been in situations where the 11 words that came out of my mouth changed a client's sentence from 6 months in jail, to two days in jail. Most of my job is rote and I'm more or less a fungible gear in the machine but anytime I have a consequential hearing coming up all I can think about is the sinking feeling in my stomach. The reminder to make sure not to fuck up, or else a human being might spend weeks/months/years in a cage. No big deal.

By necessity, I have to put up artificial reefs and intentionally handicap my ability to feel empathy. Still, a lot of this already happens without any effort. Despite my marinated involvement in the field, there are still concepts that I remain completely unable to wrap my mind around. For example, I often have to talk about prison sentences in terms of months. "If we do X, then you're only looking at 63 months in prison" is a sentence that I had to speak out loud. What in fucking tarnation does that shit even mean to anyone? I can whip out a calculator and divide 63 by 12 and I have a bit over 5 years. Ok, what does that mean? Well I can try and think back to 2016, and then embark on a mental exercise where I erase every kiss I had since then, every piece of chocolate I ate, every bike ride I went on, every hug I gave to my mom, every hot bath I took, every fucking stupid tweet I laughed at. Et cetera. It won't come close to simulating the effect, but at least it's a start. So my defense mechanism is to read weeks/months/years as merely ink stains arranged in a peculiar fashion on a piece of paper, rather than the evocative concepts they embody. My mind can't handle the weight of their meaning beyond that.

There's also an unstated and unsavory principle at play. No matter how much I tell myself otherwise, deep down I know that my client's lives don't matter as much as "real" people. Especially the frequent flyers. I assume, maybe for my own sake and sanity more than anything else, that being in jail gets progressively easier the more times you do it. I need a few months to work on your case. What's the big deal with waiting that long in jail? I mean, you've already spent 6 years in prison not too long ago. Besides, what would you be doing out of jail anyways?

I admit to operating under the rubric of Main Character Syndrome at times. If past performance is any indication, I can expect to continue along a predictable and ever-improving life trajectory, while continuing to accumulate achievements and upgrading skills along the way. My client, and the large swathes of people just like him, are afforded nothing close to this luxury. Like I said before, my empathy can only go so far, and I have no idea how existentially agonizing such a reality must be. This realization was put into stark and horrifying focus when I read 'Two Arms and a Head', a 200 page suicide note written by a paraplegic thoroughly tortured by the concept of his continued survival. It's the most disturbing piece of writing I ever have experienced, and likely ever will. Set aside about 4-5 hours if you want to experience it, as there is a chance it will happen in one sitting.

The author expresses pure bewilderment when contemplating the fact that there are people currently serving lifetime imprisonment sentences and for whatever reason they have not killed themselves. I share this bewilderment, and more, with registered sex offenders being a prime example. My job obliterates my curated and manicured bubble. In my personal life, I walk away from unpleasant individuals without thinking, and I can barely name any friends who have a criminal record of any kind.

But I'm afforded no such allowance at work. Obviously. If we're being somewhat uncharitable, I am functionally and essentially a social worker on any given day, but one who is highly-paid and highly-respected by the powers that be. A life coach infinitely more than a legal scholar. Clients tell me all sorts of deeply personal shit, and they get me embroiled in a breathtaking array of random issues they're facing. It's a startlingly intimate relationship. But even then it has its limits, as I outlined above.

Today I found out my client died unceremoniously. His life mostly sucked as far as I can tell, but he loved sex and methamphetamine, especially when combined. I made him laugh once. I wish I had more than that to say about him.


r/TheMotte • • Jul 02 '20

History Welcome to Gettysburg (Day One)

406 Upvotes

Day Two Here

Day Three Here

Gettysburg is by far my favorite battle of all time.

First, it is an all-American battle in an all-American war, and myself being an old school nationalist it carries significance that other battles simply don’t; I may find Austerlitz or Stalingrad nifty, but nobody there was my people.

More, it was an extraordinarily clean fight. At any point, a soldier on either side could hurl down their rifle and grab some sky and be reasonably assured of having their surrender accepted without reservation, and for that matter their captor could rely on their new POWs to trudge back to the rear under light guard in good faith. Even though much of the fighting took place in an urban environment with embedded civilians, only one civilian died in the fighting. Let me tell you, the more military history you read up on, the clearer it is that massacring civilians before, during, and after a rough fight is par for the course. One might even say that butchering unarmed men, women and children of the enemy tribe is the de facto military objective more than half the time; it might be some weird, half instinctual, proto-game theory going on: “We told them to surrender or else. They didn’t surrender, we won anyway, and now there’s gotta be an ‘or else’ to persuade the next batch of holdouts that we mean business.” In the long run, butchering the first village usually made it morelikely the next three villages would get the message and surrender without a fight, saving the invaders men, materiel, and time. Or perhaps it’s that killing civilians has always been pure bloody-mindedness. But not at Gettysburg. Gettysburg is where the American platonic ideal of soldiers fighting soldiers and leaving the civilians be actually happened.

Another aspect to the battle that fascinates me is how utterly unplanned it was. Neither army had intended to fight there, and between the scale of the brawl, the rapidity of developments, the intransigence of their subordinates, and the communications lag, neither the Confederate general Lee nor the Union general Meade had a grip on the situation at all until the second day of the battle, and neither could enact their ideal plans until the third day. It was something of a clusterfuck for both sides, and the course of the battle depended on the initiative and guts of small unit commanders with little idea of what the big picture was.

Gettysburg tends to be remembered as the turning point in the war, when it stopped being a gallant passage at arms between roughly equal powers and started being a slow, painful inevitable grind towards Union victory. This is not exactly accurate; only with years of hindsight could anybody construct a narrative that framed this fight as the turning point, for at the time Gettysburg was seen as just another grisly slaughter yard in a long series of them. Still, between this fight and the conquest of Vicksburg out west, this does appear in hindsight to be the high watermark in terms of Confederate progress towards successful seccession. Certainly it was the last time any Confederate army went on the strategic offensive. For diehard secessionists (both during the war and in the years after), this was the last hurrah before the war started being truly hopeless.

It is also, I should mention, a place of spiritual significance for me. Myself being secular humanist with a vaccination against Protestantism from my younger days, I don’t have much in the way of codified religion. But when I was a youngin’ visiting relatives out east, I got to visit the battlefield. I found myself standing in front of a monument on the field on the north end of Herbst Wood (where the right flank of Iron Brigade stood and charged on the first day of the battle). It described how a Michigan regiment of about a thousand men stood on that spot and suffered two thirds casualties over the course of the day. I read the details on the monument, and stared up at the mustachioed rifleman staring defiantly to the west.

Looking left and right, I saw more monuments every fifty yards or so in a straightish line, spreading out to mark where a human line had once stood and bled. And I turned my back on the monuments to face away, and behold, I saw an opposing line of Confederate monuments stretched out horizon to horizon about a hundred yards away. Two lines, violently opposed but unmoving; courage and horror frozen into place forever. And the world there seemed very big, and very grand, and I felt very small and unworthy. The air was at once colder and hotter than any air I’d ever felt. The wind cut through my clothing and reminded me that flesh was mortal but spirit was eternal. This was holy ground, soil consecrated by blood. Shi’ite Muslims have Karbala. Catholics have the Road to Calvary. Australian aboriginals have Uluru. I have Gettysburg.

————————————————————————

BACKGROUND

A brief note- I will be including maps periodically to show the progression of the fighting. These maps must be taken with a grain or three of salt. They are intended to show relations between the armies and the terrain, not to mark the exact positions or dispositions of the units, nor to show an exact proportion of numbers involved. This is because I am not an expert mapmaker, and I thank you in advance for your understanding. First, a map of the northern part of the battlefield. Note how many roads lead there, and note the high ground of Cemetery Hill and Culp's Hill to the south of the town.

The Battle of Gettysburg happened because Lee needed to go on the offensive, and Lee needed to go on the offensive because of the big picture. I shall cover the broad outline just so the significance doesn’t pass anybody by.

The Confederacy in the Spring of 1863 was in a terrible dilemma. The leadership had two urgent problems, either one of which could (if unaddressed) destroy their enterprise, and to make things worse they didn’t have the resources to solve either of them alone without a miracle.

One, the Union was fixing to shove yet another army down Richmond’s throat. Two years of failed invasions into Virginia had been brutal to both sides, but the North had immense reserves of cash, food, industrial output, and manpower with which to replenish themselves, and the South simply didn’t. The Army of Northern Virginia on which every invasion thus far had broken was underarmed, underfed, and undermanned, and if these issues were not fixed then they’d be seeing Union soldiers in the Confederate capitol before Autumn. There had already been a push that year, which Lee had staved off at Chancellorsville. There was plenty of time left before winter for a second attack.

And two, Vicksburg, the railway hub that sat on the Mississippi River, was under dire threat. The Union had already grabbed New Orleans at the south end and pushed north up the river, and had been pushing south down the river since day one of the war, but Vicksburg prevented the whole river from falling in to Union hands. Vicksburg alone let the South shift resources and information from its Western half to its Eastern half. Losing it could be a death blow. The garrison of Vicksburg was also underarmed, underfed, and undermanned.

The fresh crops taken off the farm and the fresh host of new recruits also taken off the farm were middling at best. Even throwing all the resources they had at either problem and letting the other develop as it would might mean losing on both fronts. Splitting the resources in half to prop up both didn’t seem promising either. Lee, being something of a strategist, developed a third option. There was no point (he reasoned) in trying to prop up Vicksburg at this point- it would take weeks to shift reinforcements that far west, and by then it would be midsummer. If the siege lasted that long, either the garrison would fold or disease would rip through the Yankee army and drive it back home, as it had the last two years running. In either scenario, further support would affect nothing. Therefore, he proposed a bold plan- don’t sit around waiting to get hit in the face. Invade north. Take the fight onto their turf.

The more the Confederate leadership considered it, the better it sounded. Northern land hadn’t been ravaged like Virginia had- it would be easy to live off of the enemy’s food for once, thus lessening the headache of their constant supply problems. It was also an election year, and the anti-war Democrats were raging at the ocean of blood and gold being wasted on bringing States back into the fold who very clearly wanted to go their own way. One good, solid victory on Northern soil could tip the balance, drive home the point that that war was unwinnable. Get the Black Republican warmonger Lincoln kicked out of the White House, get a reasonable Democrat in, and next year they just might get a negotiated peace that would lead in time to true and recognized independence.

To which end-

Lee snaked his newly reinforced army of about 75,000 men up through the Shenandoah Valley, using the mountain range to mask his movements instead of using to well-worn direct route that the Union was camped on. He would end up north of the bulk of the Army of the Potomac, simultaneously threatening Washington D.C., Pittsburgh, Baltimore, and Philadelphia, which for a guy trying to score a symbolic victory to discourage the enemy voters put him in a pretty nice spot.

Lincoln freaked out, told Hooker and his Army of the Potomac to go out and beat Lee, to utterly destroy his army, and also not leave any weak point undefended, which are just the kind of orders one enjoys receiving. Hooker, having a bit of an ego and a poor history of getting his ass kicked by Lee, got into a feud with Lincoln’s advisors and impulsively offered his resignation as Commander of the Army of the Potomac following some stupid spat with the bean counters back in Washington. Lincoln called his bluff and fired him three days before the battle, putting General Meade in charge of the whole damn army with almost no prep time.

I should cut the narrative here to cast moral aspersions right quick. The Union were the good guys, and the Confederates were the villains. That said, the North made for really terrible heroes, and the South had more than its fair share of virtues. This was not a grand crusade of freedom-loving Yankees tearing down the moral abomination of human bondage. This was a brutal, no holds barred death struggle between the efficient new urban Industrial Revolution and the rural Cavalier latifundias. Only a smallish segment of New England Puritans and bleeding heart Quakers hated slavery on moral grounds- the rest of the North either hated it on financial grounds, didn’t give a fuck one way or another, or were actively supporting racial slavery. And on the flip side, most Southerners who fought in the war perceived quite accurately that outsiders were coming into their world to demand submission, and had decided to give these invaders the William Wallace treatment. This is a normal and admirable response that every healthy society should have in its toolbox, and in my not-even-slightly humble opinion it is a damn shame that so many people endured so much agony in support of so un-American a cause.

For you see, when Lee’s army reached Pennsylvania, they kidnapped every black person they could find, free or not, and sent them all south in chains. There was no attempt to ascertain their status by some legal due process, no splitting of hairs. The bare skeleton of Confederate ideology, the great Truth that would have snuffed out by continued political loyalty to the Union, had been that all men were not created equal. To be more precise, men had white skin, and anyone with black skin was not a man and did not have the rights of man. As such, anyone with black skin was to be sold into slavery and threatened with torture and death if they refused to labor in the cotton fields. The army that invaded the North was, in practice, the biggest slave-hunting gang that had ever set foot on American soil.

The side wearing grey were staunch defenders of a country based on the Ideal of Ethnic Supremacy, and the side wearing blue were fighting for a country based on the Ideal of Equality. There were a million nagging features of material reality in the South and the North that challenged both of these Ideals, but there were no Ideals to challenge these Ideals, save only for each other. We know that this is true, because as the war shifted away from a Federal attempt to rein in wayward states to an all out assault on the institution of slavery, more and more Northerners balked at the idea of dying to set niggers free; men who had fought for years to bring the rebels into the fold again threw down their rifles and went home in disgust after they heard of the Emancipation Proclamation. And as it became clearer that poor whites who never owned slaves were expected to die for plantation owners’ right to stay rich, fewer and fewer Southerners were willing to jump into the meat grinder feet first; many of them deserted to go home and form Unionist bushwhacker gangs instead. Speaking of the draft, a higher percentage of southerners dodged the Confederate draft than in Vietnam, yet Vietnam is remembered as a deeply unpopular war while the Lost Cause has painted the South as a unified bloc striving as one against the Yankee oppressor.

Also, the Confederacy had a draft imposed upon the states by its federal government. So, yeah, State's Rights. Tell me how that worked out.

To reiterate. Both sides are not the same. We are rooting for the Union. Slavery. Etc.

Pushing on-

The two armies surged northward, on parallel tracks with Lee on the west side of the Appalachians and Meade on the east side. Being critically low on recon drones and spy satellites, the only ways to find the enemy army was to send guys out on horseback to physically look at them before riding back, and to talk to locals whether they’d seen anyone wearing the other team’s uniform recently. Clouds of skirmishers, cavalrymen, and small detachments of infantrymen from either side scattered themselves in all directions, straining to catch a glimpse of the other army. The first side to locate the enemy, amass sufficient force, and maneuver against them would probably win, without regard for right or wrong.

————————————————————————

JULY 1st, 1863

Early Morning

General John Buford had a 2,500 strong brigade of cavalrymen patrolling southern Pennsylvania, being one of dozens of detachments sent out to find the enemy army. Using human intelligence from locals in Gettysburg, he learned that there was a column of rebel infantry marching down the Chambersburg Pike.

And indeed there was. Advance scouts from Buford’s brigade made visual contact with a column marching south towards Gettysburg. The ball was now rolling.

The story goes that the Confederates were looking for new shoes and heard that there was a stockpile in Gettysburg. As far as I can tell, this is a baseless legend- inspired by the true fact that the rebel army didn’t have enough shoes, but baseless nonetheless. The three Confederate commanders marching towards Gettysburg (Archer and Davis with a brigade apiece and Heth as division commander coordinating them), were simply doing what their counterpart was doing- reconnaissance in force, hoping to develop a lead for the rest of the army to follow. 7,000 infantry under Archer and Davis were about to pick a fight with 2,500 cavalrymen under Buford. The currents of this morning fight would provide the grooves for the next three days to follow.

Buford’s men fought as dragoons; the horse let you scoot around to where you need to go, but you got off it and fought on foot. They Union cavalry broke into tiny little four man teams to bloody the approaching Confederates’ noses. The terrain was a bushwhacker’s paradise- plenty of rocks and trees to hide behind, and plenty of low, rolling hills to speed off behind to break line of sight. One man would hold the horses while the other three crouch-ran forward under cover to pop off rounds into the enemy column from the sides of the road. When the enemy infantry redeployed from a fast moving but harmless column formation into a slow moving but dangerous line, the three shooters would run back to their buddy to mount up and retreat to a new position.

The cavalrymen were outnumbered nearly three to one, and their carbines had less range and power than the rebel rifles; then again, the terrain was working for them and their breechloading carbines could shoot much faster than the enemy’s muzzleloading long rifles. It was very close to being an fair fight, as long as the cavalry could stay mobile and keep their distance. Buford and Heth both had unclear, contradictory orders- “Push forward aggressively to locate the enemy, but do not enter into a general engagement until we know what we’re up against.” It was an order that must have made sense in the tent when Lee and Meade sent their own versions off. You wouldn’t want to force a battle until you knew the enemy’s location and disposition and the terrain you were going to be standing on, any more than you’d want bet it all on a poker hand before looking at your cards. But to the guys on the front line, it meant “charge forward, but do not charge forward. Attack, but do not engage. Show some initiative, but don’t pick a real fight.” Heth decided they were up against a skeleton crew of skirmishers, and he had orders to check out Gettysburg. He send riders back with a quick report and a request for reinforcements. Buford decided that if the whole damn rebel army was heading his way, he needed to delay their advance for as many hours as he could to give the rest of the Union army time to get to Gettysburg- the high ground south of the town looked like ideal terrain to fight from and he wanted his buddies to get there before the rebels. He too sent riders back with calls for help.

And meanwhile, the murderous, hazardous stalking of the rebel column continued as it trudged towards Gettysburg.

Meanwhile, in the Rear with the Gear

Imagine running a marathon- 26 miles and a bit from start to finish. That’s how spread out a Civil War army is, from vanguard to rear guard. You can’t really concentrate 75,000-100,000 people together that closely. Disease starts killing people off really fast, feeding everyone is a headache, and if you have to march out, the lead element will march all day before stopping for the night, while the rear element hasn’t even left camp yet. It’s unwieldy. So they all spread out to grab some real estate and forage easier and not choke on each others’ dust and crap.

The riders from the Chambersburg Pike were spreading the word through the marathon length of the armies. Units were halting, turning around. Captains and colonels and generals were consulting maps to figure out what roads to take to get south or north to Gettysburg from where they were now. Regiments were putting their heads to together to figure out whose company oughtta go in what order.

The movements were slow and and ungainly and awkward, but they were starting up.

Mid Morning to Noon

The rolling hills on either side of the Chambersburg Pike stopped at McPherson’s Ridge, a grand place to make a stand- plenty of cover, steep incline. In any case, there wasn’t much further to retreat to. Archer and David pushed the cavalrymen, Archer on the south side of the road and Davis on the north. Thoroughly annoyed infantrymen backed up on the Pike behind them, eager to get at the enemy but without frontage to occupy.

Buford dug in on McPherson’s Ridge, and the full force of Heth’s division slammed into him. Denied their mobility by the necessity of holding territory, the fair fight turned into a meat grinder for the dismounted cavalrymen. When Confederate artillery set up on Herr’s Ridge, it turned into a bloodbath.

Buford, at last, got in contact with somebody who outranked him. General John Reynolds, second in command of the whole Union army, rode ahead of his division to get eyes on the situation.

The two struck a deal in the middle of a firefight. Buford promised to hold to the last man, and Reynolds promised to reinforce him. It was an exercise in trust; if Buford’s men held firm and Reynolds let them down, they’d be swamped and slaughtered to a man, and if Buford’s detachment broke and scattered, Reynolds’ reinforcements would march directly into a line of hills held by an entrenched enemy force of equal size. Failure on either side would be fatal. Reynolds rode south again, leaving Buford and his dwindling cavalrymen to fend off 10% of the Confederate army all alone.

Meanwhile, Buford’s thin line was cracking. Outnumbered, outgunned, and unable to advance or retreat... That which was inevitable to start with was happening now. Davis’ brigade was pressing against Oak Ridge on the Union right, and Archer's was taking Herbst Woods tree by tree. Buford’s men were giving ground they couldn’t afford to lose. Confederate artillery was blasting giant holes in the ranks of the defenders.

That’s when the relief came- two fresh brigades of infantry coming up the Emmitsburg road, under generals Cutler and Meredith. Cutler got there first, taking up positions on Oak Ridge and straddling either side of the Pike with cannons. Their massive volleys disrupted Confederate momentum and silenced some of the rebels’ big guns as everyone scrambled for cover. Grateful and exhausted cavalrymen sidled off to the flanks to safety. Meredith’s brigade is still lagging behind- that’s the problem with columns, only the guys in front can do anything.

If Buford and Reynolds expected everything to be right in the world once reinforcements arrived, they were very much mistaken. Those men out there attacking up Oak Ridge were some of the finest infantrymen in the world- dedicated, disciplined, contemptuous of death. They did not stop being efficient killers just because they now fought peers instead of the hornet-like cavalry skirmishers. Cutler’s brigade was facing a small tidal wave of battle-maddened Southern veterans, and had no time to dig in and situate themselves before the moment of impact. Davis’ men ripped into them like a pack of starving wolves. Cutler’s men fell back to safety on the top of Oak Ridge. In pieces.

Meanwhile, Meredith’s brigade was finally in position to retake Herbst Woods on the south side of the road.

Now, Meredith’s brigade were the absolute elite of the Union army. They were the grizzled veterans, the old crew, the best drilled, the most experienced, the hardest of the hard. They were nicknamed the Iron Brigade, and the Black Hat Brigade, because they were authorized to wear dashing black foraging caps to signify their status as the best of the best. With their comrades north of the road falling back, it was imperative that the Black Hat Brigade protect their left flank. To which end, Reynolds frantically snapped orders for them to line up and charge Archer’s men who were occupying Herbst Wood.

Their charge was met by a storm of musket fire that churned the Iron ranks into blood and guts. But this was the Black Hat Brigade. For them, taking ten percent casualties in a single minute was just another Tuesday. They got in close to the rebel line to return the volleys with a vengeance, and then charged with the bayonet. Archer’s men saw the distinctive black hats come for them through the musket-smoke. For the first time, they realized that these were no mere cavalry skirmishers, no half-assed militia company facing them. The best of the best of the Army of the Potomac was coming at them at terrifyingly close range. Archer’s men cracked and scattered. The ones who stood firm, died. The ones who threw down their rifles and grabbed sky were allowed to live as prisoners. The ones who ran, lived, but found the Iron Brigade hot on their heels. Meredith’s elites carved through Archer’s brigade like it wasn’t even there.

Reynolds was a good leader. A great one, in fact. He was decisive, experienced, competent. Many thought he should have gotten command instead of Meade. As his men retook Herbst Wood, he turned behind him to check on how close reinforcements were, some rebel rifleman did his cause a world of good, and shot Reynolds in the back of the head.

Now the situation got pretty weird- Davis’ brigade had kicked the shit out of Cutler’s brigade and was pursuing them on the north side of the road, and the Iron Brigade had kicked the shit out of Archer’s brigade and was pursuing them on the south side of the road. Neither victor was aware of what had happened across from them, and soon enough they would pass each other by almost touching the edges of their lines. The first one to figure out what was happening would get to win.

As it so happened, General Doubleday (in command now that Reynolds was dead) saw the danger and the opportunity first. He broke off an Iron regiment from his reserve to swoop in and protect the flank just in time, setting them up in a defensive stance facing the road. That regiment was joined by another broken off from the Iron assault, and yet another from Cutler’s brigade, who had seen the maneuvering and joined in on its own initiative. It was like a ballet, all three regiments coalescing into a single front facing north across the road, as though they’d spent the last week rehearsing. Under their protection, the rest of the Black Hats gave chase to their prey.

When Davis finally turned and attacked, they were chopped down by a mass of highly accurate fire from the newly entrenched men. Confederates died by the dozens and were maimed by the score. As they reloaded, the Black Hats were astonished to find that the whole Confederate brigade vanish into thin air, like magic. The firing stopped; no more targets. It was bizarre.

The three regiments advanced cautiously. And were gutted by a close range surprise volley by the hidden Confederates as they tried to scale the fences on either side of the Pike.

It turns out that there was a cut in the side of road, deep enough for a man to jump down into with only his head able to peek out. Davis’ men had leapt into it as a source cover when the firefight started and found it was a grand place to shoot out of. But it was also a death trap. Once the Union regiments figured it out, they got in close enough to fire blindly down at point blank range into the milling mass of men.

Davis’ men surrendered, thousands of them all at once. Unable to move, unable shoot back, it was really the only choice. And with that, the first round of Gettysburg was over. Oak Ridge and Herbst Wood had held, and about 150,000 odd soldiers were converging on Gettysburg to shift the tide of war this way and that.

AFTERNOON

The rest of the first day was not free of drama, and heroics, and mass suffering. But it was free of surprises. The iron laws of physics had decreed that more Confederate units would be on hand for the fighting in the afternoon, and so it was. Fresh rebel troops swept down from the north and from the west, relieving their exhausted comrades and preparing themselves to assault Oak Ridge and Herbst Woods. Fresh Union troops arrived from the south to reinforce what they had and to extend their line out east, protecting their right flank and screening off the town itself.

Hours passed without a shot being fired. Everybody was reorganizing themselves, resupplying, carting the wounded to the rear to let the surgeons saw their shattered limbs off. Two small things happened that delivered a Confederate victory on day one, and a Union victory on day three. Union General Barlow pushed his brigade out to occupy Blocher's hill, and Union General Steinwehr plopped two of his brigades on top of Cemetery Hill. The first created a huge gap in the Union right, and the second secured the invaluable high ground for the rest of the battle.

Meanwhile, three Confederate divisions set themselves up for a concerted attack- Heth would press into Herbst Wood on the Union left, Rodes would assault Oak Ridge at the center, and Early would swoop down the Harrisburg road to threaten the Union right. When the big push came at around 2 p.m., it was badly organized and mismanaged. Southern commanders couldn't get it together and attack at the same time. Individual units charged at Oak Ridge alone, like a mob of Hollywood henchmen attacking the hero only to be smacked around one by one. Cutler's men didn't just fight them off; it was closer to mass murder. General O'Neal's brigade swooped down off of Oak Hill only to be cut down by musketry and cannon fire, and they did it without O'Neal, because O'Neal stayed in the rear while his men died. When O'Neal's brigade fell back having suffered heavy losses, Cutler shifted his men to greet the new threat from Iverson's brigade, who also charged without their commander. Iverson's men marched in parade perfect order across open ground, without so much as a molehill for cover. The story goes that during the assault, Iverson looked out from safety and saw half his men lying down on the ground. Iverson was pissed off because he thought his men were surrendering. In fact, he was watching his brigade die in droves.

The issue wasn't morale. The Confederate troops were eager to get at the enemy. The problem was purely organizational in nature. The men in charge of telling people what to do were simply too confused and disoriented to work out the solution in real time. While O’Neal and Iverson were getting bloodied, Barlow’s men on Blocher Hill were getting slaughtered. Barlow’s desire to hold the high ground on the defense was understandable- high ground being a grand place to fight from- but he was about one mile ahead of any friendly units. This meant that it was trivially easy to flank and destroy his brigades.

Georgia men under generals Early and Rodes linked up to flank and destroy Barlow’s isolated brigades. A thick stream of filthy, bloody, and terrified Union men flowed back to the town of Gettysburg, leaving a gaping hole in the Union line and spreading their panic like the plague. Victorious Confederates whooped and hollered. As the men to the north of town trade massacres- the failed assault on Oak Ridge being roughly balanced by the disastrous dissolution of Barlow’s brigades- Heth finally attacked the Iron Brigade still occupying Herbst Wood in the west. He’d been delaying it all afternoon, stymied by the contradictory orders from Lee. Lee, who was several miles away and not at all in touch with the situation, still wanted to avoid a general engagement. But now, Heth has been let off the chain to avenge Archer’s brigade.

Heth’s full division attacked Herbst Wood. It was a slow, hot, gory fight. The attacking rebels are aggressive, but also methodical and well-organized. The Black Hats made them pay for every tree they seized. But there’s only one outcome for a fight like this.

The Iron Brigade has the ghastly honor of having the highest casualty ratio of any Civil War brigade, North or South. Out of the 1,885 men in their ranks that morning, 1,153 (61%) were be dead or maimed by nightfall on the first day. The fates of individual units from within the brigade are even more gruesome- in the 2nd Wisconsin regiment, 397 out of 496 (80%) were killed or wounded. But despite the horrific losses, they didn’t break. They gave ground slowly and in good order, but they gave ground nonetheless. Iron does not break, but it does bend.

By late afternoon, the dominoes fell as they were always going to. With the debacle at Blocher’s Knoll, any hope the Union had to hold the right was lost. The Black Hats were being ground into sawdust on the left. And Rodes has finally gotten his brigades to charge at the same time, overwhelming Cutler’s defense.

Every Union man was running now, some in a blind panic, some withdrawing in good order like professionals.

The open field battle turned into urban warfare as the Confederates chased the Union army through the streets of Gettysburg. Companies blocked the streets to hold off the enemy advance long enough for the comrades to scamper. Marksmen played sniper games in the windows, either shooting men in the back as they ran away or ambushing overly aggressive platoons, depending on the color of their uniform.

The Union men were desperate to reach Cemetery Hill, south of the town. High ground and the reinforcements already stationed there promised safety. The Confederates were just as desperate to catch them first and seize that invaluable terrain for themselves.

Nightfall

A great deal of “woulda coulda shoulda” ink has been spilled over the orders that Lee gave to General Ewell, the man in charge of Rodes and Early: “Take Cemetery Hill if practical”. But Ewell saw two brigades with a lot of artillery standing on top of what appeared to be a natural fortress designed by God to repel infantry, and his men were exhausted to boot. Ewell decided it was not practical, and so did not try. Just one of those things, I expect.

In any case, the day was a Confederate victory. Every spot on the map the Confederate troops wanted to go, they had went. They had crushed all resistance, had even gone toe to toe with the cream of the Army of the Potomac and won. Their enemies were in flight before them.

There was, possibly, a certain amount of disquiet because the enemy had merely been driven from one ridge into another ridge, one even steeper and with more cover than the last. And rumor had it the rest of the Army of the Potomac was coming at them.

But that was a problem for the next day.


r/TheMotte • • Feb 10 '21

Gratitude Walking Through Walmart

372 Upvotes

Yesterday, I cried of gratitude while walking through Walmart.

My parents grew up in communist Romania, for my mom eating bananas was something rare and special, she was ecstatic every time her family was able to buy some. As a young boy, my dad would spend hours waiting in line (and defending his position against other young boys) for the privilege of being allowed to exchange money for food. Some people were luckier and happened to be friends with the food store clerks (or used bribes): they got advance notice when new items were in stock. Money wasn't the problem (the Party, in their infinite benevolence, understood that the people needed to be able to afford bread, and so kept the prices low), everyone had money, the problem was finding food to exchange against that money. If your family had a car, it was the same state-manufactured car , in the same gray color as everyone else's, my grandparents spent 3 years on a wait-list (having already paid, of course) before the State deigned deliver it to them. When my grandfather came to a Canadian suburb to see the house his engineer son had just bought, he asked how many other families we were sharing it with. When he saw the sapphire-blue pool in our backyard, he started crying.

I've also recently started reading The Gulag Archipelago, detailing the forced labour camp system in the Soviet Union. This book is making me feel the most intense emotions I've ever felt reading a book: blood-boiling rage, bone-deep indignation and strongest of all an overwhelming sense of duty to value the freedom that I have. I can feel the 60 million people who would have liked nothing more in life than to have the chance to experience what I would consider abject failure. What I fear happening to me in life, they would have hailed as a miracle from god. What I would consider a mediocre outcome isn't even in the set of possibilities for them, they would have hoped for it if only they knew it was possible, but they didn't. I suspect that they would have passed out from sheer disbelieving joy walking through Walmart. Most of all, I can feel them crying out "Don't you fucking dare waste your freedom out of fear!"

So I'm walking through Walmart, seeing the 30 different choices of chocolate bars, wall-to-wall offerings of chips, perpetually-filled bread-racks and meat counters, all the eggs, milk and butter that I could ever want, giant multinational corporations fiercely fighting for the right to sell me the tastiest food from every part of the world at the best price possible. I start to smile and this great sense of gratitude radiates from my upper-back. Suddenly my problems don't seem so large anymore, and I know that everything is going to be alright.

Discussions of the culture war here can get quite depressive and hopeless, and its good to sometimes remember just what the stakes are, just how bad things can get, and how good they are right now.


r/TheMotte • • Jan 22 '21

Most Media Is Porn

369 Upvotes

Porn has two major advantages over sex. First, it’s easy: The Hub is never more than a keystroke away, whereas even for the Chad Thundercocks of the world, convincing someone to have sex with you takes more effort than that. Second, it’s idealized: The actors in most porn are probably more attractive than both you and the people who are willing to have sex with you; They often find themselves in highly unlikely but arousing situations; And there are never any consequences of whatever they do.

Given these advantages, why does anyone still have sex? It’s a silly question: Porn isn’t real. I am not here to tell you not to watch porn; do whatever you want. But anyone who would chose porn over sex would deny themselves a rich human experience in favor of a cheap, shallow substitute. Porn is best viewed the same was as fast food: An occasional indulgence for someone with an otherwise healthy diet. If your relationship with fast food or porn is more substantial than that, you would probably be happier if you took action to reduce it, and based on personal experience, it’s possible the easiest way is to cut it out entirely for a while.

I think most people know this intuitively. But they may not see how much other media they consume is essentially similar. Fast food is catered to our hunger instinct. Porn is catered to our sexual instinct. A lot of popular media is catered in the same way to other instincts.

Romantic movies are essentially emotional porn. As an example, the hit 2016 anime movie Your Name is a story about a high school boy and girl who inexplicably begin swapping bodies and in the process form a deep connection with one another. This is an idealized romance: In the real world, nobody will ever know you as well or be as connected as deeply to you as those characters are to each other because body swapping isn’t real and nobody will ever literally inhabit your body. In the real world, you will have to make do with telling someone what it’s like to be you and having them tell you they understand. Like porn, watching Your Name or other romantic movies is much easier and more idealized than building a real connection with someone but ultimately less rewarding because it isn’t real. And like porn, someone who is unhappy with their emotional life would do better in the long term to control their consumption of material like this.

The way many people engage with Twitch streamers, YouTubers, Instagram influencers, and other “celebrities” is by forming one-sided parasocial relationships, or what I call friendship porn. Twitch is particularly susceptible to this because many Twitch streamers stream several hours a day every day, and in doing so make themselves more accessible than most people’s actual friends. Once again, friendship porn is far easer to access than real friendship, and it’s idealized (you will never get into a fight with your fake parasocial friends because they don’t actually know or care about you).

The way most people engage with political news and commentary is what I would call political porn. The kinds of things that have a substantive impact on the direction of political developments are voting, donating, volunteering, and protesting. Writing thoughtful essays can occasionally help too. Tweets and Reddit comments from otherwise un-noteworthy people occasionally might have an impact, but when they do it’s because they made some kind of unique insight and not because they repeated uncharitable partisan talking point #49 again but even angrier this time, which is the way most people tweet about politics. Paying attention to developments is important so you know how to vote, but let’s be honest: If you had gone into a coma on November 9, 2016 and woke up on November 3, 2020, how long would you need to spend catching up on news to know whether to vote Republican or Democrat? A month? A week? I reckon most people would need less than an hour. When you seek out news and commentary, really consider whether your actions come entirely out of a civic duty to stay informed or an instinctive urge to follow developments of power and drama which may be more interesting than anything that happens in your day-to-day life. Remember that while political news may give you the ability to feel power by siding and identifying with powerful people, seizing control of your own life will give you actual power. And just as porn can distract you from opportunities to have real sex, political media can distract you from opportunities to exercise real power.

It goes on and on. Spectator sports can provide the excitement, competition, and thrill of playing sports in an easy-to-access and idealized way, but you’re just sitting on your ass. Action movies can provide the feeling of going on an adventure more exciting than anything you’ll ever do from the comfort of your couch. Even the pop songs we absent-mindedly put on as background music contain potent doses of emotional expression, usually in context of a romantic relationship.

I’m not saying any of this is necessarily bad, I think it’s totally fine to consume porn or “porn” in controlled moderation. I’m not even saying it’s bad in excess — It’s not my place to tell you how to life your life. If you want to watch porn all day, then whatever, go ahead. But I think a lot of people can benefit from framing their media consumption this way, because they may not realize what they’re doing. Just as an hour spent watching porn is an hour spent not having sex or doing anything to make sex more likely, an hour spent watching movies, reading news, or watching Twitch is an hour spent not experiencing life yourself, exercising real influence, or making real friends. And because media is so idealized and easy to access, it can be easy to fill up more of your life with it than you realize or intended. I just think it’s useful to evaluate how you spend your time and whether the things you are doing with it are really the most fulfilling things you could do with it.

(I mostly wrote this for myself, because I definitely spend more time than I would like passively consuming media. I shared it because I suspect many others feel the same and may benefit from this framing.)


r/TheMotte • • Dec 03 '19

The Barbarian and the 7-11 Clerk

325 Upvotes

It was at the tail end of a long shift at 7-11, getting close to midnight. Business had been brisk all day but now there was only the customers going on beer runs and the night shift grabbing coffee and donuts. I manned my till, smiled at people by reflex, and swept every so often.

A man with a hoodie, glasses, and a dark green jacket approached the counter. As I started my spiel, he shocked me out of my autopilot by pulling a black handgun from his coat pocket, leveling it at my chest, and then stating his intention to rob the place.

“I see,” I said. “This is highly irregular.”

“It is,” he agreed. “Yet here we are.”

“I suppose you’ve given no thought to the long term viability of your chosen profession? Armed robbery is a notoriously unstable field. The cash in this register looks like a lot, if you grew up with little, but a simple cost benefit analysis will show clearly that the money here is almost comically small compared to the risks one must take to, well, take it. The possibility of arrest, being tackled by a bystander, the small but worrying possibility that I too have a concealed firearm about my person... sure, each individual robbery seems like a slam dunk, but in aggregate the risks are appalling and the payoff is almost the same as a 9 to 5 job. Imagine, if you will, a game of chance at a casino. You must place $200 on the table to play. The dealer takes a deck of cards and draws one at random. If it is any card other than the Ace of Spades, you the gambler earn $1. But if the Ace of Spades is drawn, you lose your $200 stake.

“Obviously,” I continued, “on any given draw you are likely to win a dollar. But in the long run, the house always wins- 1 in 52 draws will ruin you, so for every $51 you win, you have to pay $200. It is a fool’s game you are playing.”

“We are of an accord,” he said. “I am no mere thug who draws a weapon without thought. I am a man of action, but action must include forethought.

“The risks that armed robbers assume are high, as you say. But risks can be compensated for. I have cased this shop for a week- I am familiar with every route in and out. My car is parked the ideal distance away- close enough that I can get to it rapidly, far enough away that no camera can see or witness tie me to it. The camera will not show much with this hoodie and fake glasses. I specifically targeted you here because I live several towns over, so investigating cops will not patrol my own streets. And as long as I do not kill you, this remains a robbery, not a murder. Police budget is tight this fiscal year- criminal investigations must be prioritized.

“A gamble I am taking, to be sure,” said the gunman. “But a calculated one. The odds are much more favorable than your posited 52 to 200. I have adjusted them in my favor, and so roll the dice gladly.”

I nodded. “Impressive.”

“Thank you.”

“If appeals to practical costs avail nothing, let me try a new line of attack. Many people think their thievery is directed at some faceless corporation, and therefore bypasses the standard morality of ‘Thou shalt not steal.’ On the surface, perhaps; the store has an insurance policy that covers shoplifting and vandals and robbers. The money stolen from the till will indeed be replaced by a faceless insurance company a day or two after my boss fills out the paperwork. But the simple fact is that the insurance company charges a premium for its services- that cost to doing business is passed on to the consumer by way of pricing. Those bags of candy and the energy drinks in the cooler and the peanuts and the muffins and the ice cream and the beer and the chips and the sodas and the apples and the Advil and the coffee and the Mac ‘n’ Cheese bowls are all expensive as fuck. The mark ups around here are staggering. They have to be. Individuals like yourself force the high pricing to compensate for the premium; just as you have proactively adjusted the odds in your favor, so too do the insurance men. You are not stealing from me, you are not stealing from my boss, and you are not stealing from the 7-11 company, or the insurance agency for that. You are stealing from your fellow citizens. Would you not rather point that gun at an old lady as she walks down the street? Would you be willing to rob a hardworking family man who needs food stamps to get by? Would it not be easier to threaten a child of eight for his pocket change?”

“In a word, yes,” said the gunman. “I am aware that I am exploiting society as a whole, and not merely one tiny little subsection of it. But you have not considered carefully enough the structure of the world.

“Remember the great Libertarian doctrine that taxation is theft. Therefore, in mathematical certainty, theft is also taxation. Now, you apparently acknowledge the right of the government to steal your money- I suspect you are not plotting anarchist revolution in your spare time. So what line can you draw in the sand between me and the IRS?

“That question is rhetorical and easily countered, of course. I am not the government. But the line is drawn because of scale, not of type. Refusal to pay taxes will, eventually and with enough lines crossed, result in armed men visiting your home to take you to prison. I at least am upfront about my coercion. That upfrontness costs me badly, for I have no ‘legitimacy’ per se. The closest historical parallel may be this. Under the Byzantine empire, serfs- which is the closest label the situation has to wageslaves such as yourself, no offense- paid taxes to the Augustus, and considered it to be approximately dead center of the Overton Window. The Byzantines had royal pomp, army after army of soldiers to collect the taxes, centuries of tradition and shared culture bolstering them, and most importantly of all, an obligation to organize and fund large scale civic projects to the benefits of the taxed peasants.”

“I was about to say,” I interjected. “You beat me to it. ‘No taxation without representation’ was going to be how I would have phrased it, for the government spends the money to the communal good, in theory, and I get a small say in how and where.”

“I could easily challenge that,” said the gunman with a sardonic smile. “If representative democracy indeed dead in the water, what responsibilities have we to preserve the interests of the government?”

“A recognition that the government and society are distinct, and that wanton crime harms the second even worse than the first? Honestly. This seems like self-justifying sophistry on your part.”

The gunman shrugged. “It is what it is. To get back to the Byzantine metaphor. The peasant, i.e. you, does not do more than grumble when the tax collector comes, for the tax collect has that mystical property of legitimacy. But there is another faction in the world- the Mongol, the Goth, the Vandal, the barbarian from outside the known world who deals in raw violence. The barbarian holds a sword in his hand-“ and here the gunman wiggled his handgun suggestively- “and demands gold. The barbarian lacks legitimacy, to be sure, but one can hardly argue that his position is without merit.”

“At least one of us is deeply confused,” I said. “You seem to be justifying yourself by the savage and inhuman doctrine of Might Makes Right. Yet you claim to be in the right by equating your barbarism (your word, not mine) with a legitimate system of government whose very cornerstone is that Might Does Not Make Right.”

“You miss a vital piece of the puzzle, which is this: society is not on my side. That ‘legitimate system of government’ representing me and my community does not work to my prosperity. I have sworn no metaphorical oaths of allegiance to the Augustus, and I have sworn no literal oaths of allegiance to the system of government in the here and now. I deny the very concept that the Law is holy and must be obeyed for the common good, for the common good is none of mine. Imagine, if you will, standing before the Heavenly throne as a fresh soul that has never touched flesh before. God says to you, ‘Look, I’m going to send you on down there for a lifetime until you come back to me. You get a choice- you can either be a peasant who works 14 hour days and lives in a mud hut and will be abused and exploited every day of his life, or you can be a one of the Mongol horse archers who lives and dies by the sword. What’s your poison?’ I happen to find myself (quite inadvertently, for I did not as a child dream of a career as an armed robber) in such a position. Who could blame such a soul for choosing the sword instead of the plow?”

“Me,” I said. “I can blame you. I hate working for a living too. But I’m behind this counter trading time and energy for cash, and the society that gave birth to me, raised me, protected me, and will one day bury me is slightly better for it. Every impulse towards civilization starts with people like me plugging away at it and contributing to the present and the future, in a spirit of thankfulness for the past.”

“Admirable,” said the gunman. “I for one would rather cut off my right hand than to gainsay a man such as you in your lifelong devotion to civic virtue. But I won’t. You shall go your way, and me mine, and we shall both be content.”

“Shall we? Shall we truly both be content? Should a cancer patient try to live and let live with the tumor inside him? Shall a lifeboat of marooned sailors agree to disagree with the man who steals the rationed food and water while the others endure with little? Can there truly be anything but war between us- war in the abstract and at a remove, to be sure, but war nonetheless? Those Mongols and Vandals you invoked were met by force of arms, if you’ll recall.”

“Society is specialized and stratified- I’m sure you know the old rhyme. ‘Tinker, tailor, soldier, sailor, rich man, poor man, beggar man-‘ “

“ ‘Thief.’ Yes, I’m familiar with it. You’re saying that society can tolerate bad actors to a degree.”

“You have a pretty firm alliance with the bacteria in your stomach, I will say that. That alliance would be imposed by the little wrigglers even if they didn’t contribute to the body as a whole. It seems to work out for everyone. And we’ve already covered how and why I’m willing to try my luck against the specialized profession that is designed to counter me. Society through the government has imposed its prohibitions and laid out its enforcement mechanism; it has done its job. If I can successfully navigate my way to profit through the tangled web of both the rule and the enforcers, well, more power to me. If you think otherwise, then may I ask why you do not descend upon the lawless life-stealers of Wall Street with fire and sword? One white collar guy playing jump rope with the law can wipe out the life savings of hundreds and thousands of families with a click of a mouse.”

I considered this thoughtfully. “I assume there is no point in pitching you the idea of meaningful education and gainful employment as surer paths to success than armed robbery.”

“I already weighed such options. The problem is that I’m good at plotting methods to attack people and places, and I’m good with guns. Hence why I’m here. Like my old man would say, do what you love and you’ll never work a day in your life.”

The gunman sighed. “Earlier, you accused me of sophistry. I’m afraid that is basically accurate. All the rhetoric followed after the impulse. And the impulse is as simple as any other great truth around which a life can revolve. That truth is this- I am a man. I was designed by God or by nature to stand tall, to own a permanent and invulnerable home, to set my life as I see fit, and to enjoy the fruit of my own labor. I was meant to join with likeminded folk in a spirit of camaraderie and community and to take no abuse from anyone. I am a man. I was supposed to build, to fix what was passed down to me, to fight in defense of everything that is valuable and irreplaceable.

“And I can’t. It just isn’t an option anymore. My work is done for the profit of others. The egalitarian spirit that all men are created equal- not in ability, but in worth- has been denied and sneered at for too long. The sanctity of my home has been violated; can not the police shatter my door and shoot my dog as they see fit? Even the simple assertion that a man must fight a bully has been barred by law, for honest fights in defense of self-worth and self-esteem have been banned, even as the law had banned the perverse aristocratic imitation of dueling. Were a man to spit on me and call me a faggot or a nigger or a dumb fucking chink or a retard or a sister-fucker, and I was to break his nose for the insult, the police would crackdown on me and ruin my life with an assault charge. It is too late to fight for that which is valuable and irreplaceable; that fight is over and my side lost. How can a free man with pride exist under such conditions? How can a tree grow from salted soil?

“I am a man, and I will not be a slave. I am undoubtedly better off than a slave in chains, but a slave to circumstance is still not free. Well, I will live as a warrior before kneeling as a serf. The savage liberty of the barbarian at the gates is a pale imitation of the free man in a just and democratic society, but I will take the imitation since it’s all that is left for me. If I seize not the gun, I will live for decades as a servant to ‘better’ men; and I shall not.

“If I fall into foolish logic puzzles and contradictions trying to turn this impulse into words, so be it. The impulse remains nonetheless.”

I nodded. “Tell you what-“

I grabbed a receipt someone had left behind before the gunman showed up at my store and scribbled some numbers on it, hiding my writing from him. I stuffed the number in my pocket.

“The register doesn’t open without this number. I absolutely refuse to open the till for you, but if you gun me down, you can grab that note and open it yourself.”

“I could beat you up and just take the note without killing you, perhaps? If I shoot you, well, that impacts my odds of capture.”

“Yes,” I said, “but I have a box cutter here that I use to break down cardboard in the back. I don’t know if I can win, but I can make you kill me to avoid getting slashed up. I assume you would not want drops of your blood at the crime scene.”

“Very true. And I appreciate the sporting gesture of writing the number down.”

“So here we are. You want the money, which I estimate to be about $1,200 between the two registers, you need to shed blood.”

The silence hung heavy over everything else. My chest was tight and my breathing was shallow. The gunman held his gun at a forty five degree angle aimed at the counter between us, and it wavered up and down slightly, as though he was trying to decide whether or not to kill me.

“I’m honestly not clear what your angle here is,” he said. “This is contrary to store policy, surely; you’re supposed to just give me the money.”

“My angle is the same as yours, really. I too am a man, and I too chafe under the modern destruction of liberty. And I too yearn to fight in a holy crusade in defense of all that is valuable and irreplaceable. Today, that means I’m going to make you kill me. That’s what civilized men do when the barbarians are at the gate. You aren’t an idiot, you know damn well that if you carry that gun into enough shoppettes eventually you’ll have to kill someone. You appear to have accepted the possibility. Well, it’s no mere possibility now. You want the money, kill me. Smell the gunpowder in the air, feel the gunshot ring your ears, see the dark blood pool under me spread and spread and spread. Feel your hands shake as the enormity of what you’ve done sinks in. Motherfucker, I am a man, and you don’t get to rob my store without paying the price for it.”

The gunman stared hard into my eyes, and myself not being a poker player at all I could not read the intent. “I don’t really have to, do I? There are other stores. Hell, I can come back tomorrow and see if whoever is on shift then has less spine. My plan is still basically sound.”

“Pure cowardice. If you aren’t willing to be a proper Mongol and commit to barbarism, you have no business pretending you are a barbarian. If you refuse to kill me tonight, what do you intend to do in a month when someone tries to tackle you from behind mid-robbery? Stop being a little bitch and either open fire or get the fuck out of my store.”

He raised the gun in one smooth motion, leveling it in my face just far enough away that I could not lunge forward to try to grab it. He said something, but I didn’t hear it. I was staring at the muzzle too hard.

When he left, I don’t think he was truly any happier than he was before.


r/TheMotte • • Jun 13 '20

For Fuck's Sake, Stop Abusing The Red/Blue Tribe Terminology

311 Upvotes

"Red tribe" does not mean Republican or Conservative and "Blue tribe" does not mean Democrat or Progressive. Scott Alexander specifically coined those terms to be distinct from (if related to) those concepts.

Harvard might skew 80-20 in terms of Democrats vs. Republicans, 90-10 in terms of liberals vs. conservatives, but maybe 99-1 in terms of Blues vs. Reds.

If (for example) someone never attends church, lives in a city, tries to be vegetarian, doesn't watch football, doesn't own any guns, uses cannabis, listens to "everything but country", has a master's degree, and works in academia or technology, they are not part of the Red tribe, no matter how many times they vote for Republicans or write Reddit comments critical of progressives.

I'm not saying that nobody who posts to /r/TheMotte could possibly be part of the Red tribe, but most of the time when someone claims to be, I don't believe them. Because of its origins, this community skews towards Blue tribe conservatives and libertarians, and I think some people get confused about the terminology. Most of the time when someone here refers to the Red tribe or Blue tribe it's clear they're really talking about Conservatives or Progressives and they would be better off just using those terms. The tribes concept is interesting and important but only relevant in narrow contexts.

(Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.)


r/TheMotte • • Sep 04 '22

[META] The Motte Is Dead, Long Live The Motte

268 Upvotes

This has been a really weird ride.

I got the lead position here sort of by accident; we were talking about how to split The Motte off from the Slate Star Codex Discord, and somehow I ended up in the lead on that even though I was the newest mod. I have no idea how that happened. But it did. I was half expecting this community would die overnight, and most of the credit on avoiding that goes to the posters. We started with a blank canvas and you all filled it in.

We're going through a similar process now. Reddit has become increasingly hostile - we just had a comment removed for discussing the meaning of various types of parenthesis, I'm not making that up, I'm not exaggerating, that's a thing that happened - and if the community is to survive, we need to disengage from Reddit.

So that's what we're doing. We have our own site, we have our own servers, we are no longer under the immediate thumb of anyone with less power than an actual government.

I'd like to pre-emptively thank the people who have put serious time and effort into development on this site. I was hoping to have time I could devote to it, and, well, my life's been absolutely crazy, and I haven't had nearly as much time as I wanted, and despite that we still have a working site. That's thanks to our volunteers. They're great. I want to put up a credits page for them and I haven't because the site itself has been more important.

But the next step is critical. We have, once again, a blank canvas; once again, we need you to fill it in. The first week or two is vital to getting this thing off the ground. Visit, register, post in the Culture War thread, post non-Culture-War stuff elsewhere; you know the drill by now, and we haven't made any major changes to the basic concept of this community.

This has been a really weird ride, and with luck, it will keep being a weird ride for at least a few more years.

Re-join The Motte.


r/TheMotte • • Dec 28 '20

Trans People Don't Exist (?)

264 Upvotes

It's a provocative title, but this is more of a work in progress stance for me.

I'm starting to think that trans people do not exist. What I mean by this is that I'm finding myself drawn towards an alternative theory that when someone identifies as trans, they've fallen prey to a gender conformity system that is too rigid. I'd like some feedback on this position.

I've posted before about how inscrutable concepts like "gender identity" are to me. To start however, here are some mental models I do understand:

  1. There are two sexes, each with divergent ramifications beyond just what gametes you have (e.g. upper body strength, hip width, etc.).

  2. Society/culture has over time codified certain traits which either tend to correlate with, or are expected to correlate with to code along a gender spectrum. For instance, physical aggression is coded as "masculine" because generally males either engage in or are expected to engage in it much more frequently than females. Or, nurture is coded as "feminine" because generally females either engage in or are expected to engage in child-rearing much more frequently than males. Some things are ambiguous, and obviously things shift over time and across cultures. Sometimes these changes appear arbitrary, sometimes they're "rational" given the circumstances. But generally, you get a fairly strong consensus on what is masculine and what is feminine within a given culture.

  3. In modern liberal cosmopolitan societies, our adherence to expectations is significantly loosened. We're much more ok with weirdos running around doing their own thing compared to more traditionally rigid societies (I think this is largely a good thing from the standpoint of individual autonomy and liberty). Sometimes, people of a certain sex have a strong preference towards expression or activities that are coded as contrary to their expected gender role. Sometimes it's relatively mild and uncontroversial, like a female wanting to be a police officer, or a male wanting to be a nurse. Sometimes it's much more dramatic, like someone extremely distressed by the fact that they have a male sexual organ. (side note: I see a near-identical parallel with Body Integrity Dysphoria, individuals who are distressed at not being amputees). Generally, the trend for society is to be more accepting of what otherwise would have been previously disdained as "aberrant" behavior for changing lanes.

  4. In general, individual gender expression tends to strongly (but not perfectly) correlate with someone's sex. It's likely a combination of innate preferences (having a greater capacity to build muscles will naturally lead to a greater interest in weightlifting for example) and some of it is culturally programmed/imposed.

As far as I can tell I don't think there is any significant disagreement with anything I said above (outside of certain fringe groups).

Now to reiterate the parts that I don't understand.

Supposedly, gender identity and gender expression are completely separate concepts. This gets asserted multiple times but I genuinely have no idea what it means. I can understand "gender expression" as a manifestation of your appearance, affect, presentation, etc and where along the masculine/feminine spectrum it falls on. Ostensibly, "gender identity" is defined as "personal sense of one's own gender" but this doesn't explain anything. How does it "feel" to have a specific gender identity? Every explanation I've come across tends to morph into a rewording of "gender expression", often with very regressive stereotyping. For instance, to highlight just one example, Andrea Long Chu (a transwoman) wrote a book called 'Females' in which she defines female identity as "any psychic operation in which the self is sacrificed to make room for the desires of another." This strikes me as an inherently misogynistic position and I wasn't the only one to point this out. Other attempts I've come across largely fall under some variant of "I was assigned male at birth, but I always preferred wearing dresses" or something similarly essentialistic.

If it's true that everyone has an "innate sense" of what their gender identity is, then I would warrant that someone has been successful in explaining what feeling like a particular gender is. The only explanations I find usually boil down to "I have a deep and innate preference for expressing myself and being perceived in a particular way" with for example "feeling like a man" typically meaning "wanting to express myself in a masculine way or play a masculine role". Which, again, does no good at distinguishing identity from expression. The other thing I've come across is an infinite recursion. Why do you say you're a woman? I am a woman because I feel like a woman. What is a woman? A woman is someone who feels like a woman? And so forth.

With all that out of the way, this is the mental model I use when interacting with trans people. I take their distress as legitimate and real, because I have no reason to believe otherwise. But why they're in distress is another question.

The Trans Rights Activists (TRA), as best as I can tell, generally talk about trans identity as a mismatch between your sexed body (I don't have a better word for this) and your "innate" gender identity. In a widely-cited study, researchers found that individuals experiencing gender dysphoria tend to have brain structure similar to what you'd see in individuals of the opposite sex. So is trans identity a neurological disorder? That position would get you in trouble among TRAs. The idea that trans identity is necessarily tied to diagnosed dysphoria is dismissed as "transmedicalism" or "truscum". But then, if trans identity doesn't show up in brain scans, where and what is it exactly? Further, if "gender identity" is unmoored both from sex and gender expression, where does it "exist"? I had this question a few months back, trying to determine exactly what the difference between a transman and a masculine female is. If there is in fact no difference, then what purpose does the concept serve?

Why even bother with this question? As Katie Herzog has pointed out, there is a drastic increase in the number of people (especially females) identifying either as non-binary or trans. This on its own should not necessarily be a cause for concern, but it's very important to find out why. One theory is that as trans acceptance grows, then individuals who would otherwise just put up with severe distress now have the support zeitgeist to come out. I think this is a good thing. But we don't have compelling evidence that this is explaining the entire phenomenon.

Consider then, my "alternate theory". I'm starting to believe that anyone who identifies as trans is most likely a victim of adopting a strict gender binary framework, but in the "opposite" direction. One of the biggest reasons to adopt this alternative theory is that we know that gender paradigms exist and they can indeed be extremely stifling. "Individual grappling with uncomfortable societal expectations" is basically every coming-of-age story out there, and there is no shortage of examples of individuals trying to break into a role and facing repercussions for disrupting the norm.

The other compelling piece of evidence is TRAs themselves. One of the best ways to find out what a stereotypical woman is is to ask a transwoman why she "feels" like a woman. There is a high likelihood that long hair, high-pitched voice, make-up, dresses, breasts, etc. will be features that make the list. In other words, a stereotype. Therefore, trans identity appears to rely extensively on accepting the gender binary as a given. I.e. "I like boy stuff, therefore I'm not really a girl, therefore I'm really a boy, therefore I should like other boy stuff I don't already." If anyone can describe "gender identity" without relying on societal gender stereotypes, I've never seen it and would be appreciative if you can point me in that direction.

So going back to the rise of the genderqueer identity, it's certainly possible that this is primarily driven by increased acceptance of trans individuals. Again, if this is true, this is a good thing. But I outlined why I don't believe that's plausible compared to the alternate theory that trans individuals are still mired in a stifling gender conformity framework. The problem we're currently facing is that there is no socially acceptable method of distinguishing between these two scenarios. In fact, even entertaining the latter is deemed as heretical.

Even though I am writing explicitly what many dismiss as a strawman (I am denying that trans individuals exist), the vociferous reaction doesn't really make sense. Because if my alternate theory is accepted, then males who prefer wearing dresses can continue to do so, females who feel distress at having breasts can cut them off, and anyone with preferred pronouns can make that request. Nothing fundamentally would change; our march towards greater individual autonomy and acceptance is not likely to be abated.

What will change is that everyone will experience far less distress anytime they find themselves in a gender non-conforming role. The female who has affinity for "male" sports does not need to have an existential crisis to do what they want to do. People can carry on as they wish, and continue to fuck up the gender expectation game (which, again, I think is an unequivocal good). I also can't help but think that without 'trans' as a framework identity, expression is far more likely to be "genuine". It's impossible for anyone to legitimately claim "my expression is unaffected by societal expectations", I think we're all subject to some influence to some extent. But this influence is especially prominent when the entire basis of someone's identity is defined as "opposite of my birth sex" (trans, after all, is a Latin term used in biology). Because qualitatively, is there a difference between a transman who sees driving a big truck as part of their gender identity, and a cis male that thinks the same way for the same reason? I can't think of one.

P.S. This is an aspect that I think the non-binary and agender folks have a point. Sort of. Like I said above, I've never heard a definition of gender identity that isn't a rewording of preferred gender expression, so I'm inclined to think that gender identity doesn't exist either. Therefore, it's unremarkable for someone to lack an innate sense of gender and by that definition the overwhelming majority of the population would likely fit the definition. On this point, I'm of the same mindset as Aella. While I'm technically a cis male who presents masculine, I'm apparently agender because I lack this undefined "innate sense" of my supposed gender. If everyone fits the definition of a term, the term starts to become useless.

(This ended up being too long to post in the CW thread as a comment)


r/TheMotte • • Apr 13 '20

The don'ts of dating: romantic advice for contrarians

253 Upvotes

Databrokers? nope. Social networks? Also nope. This post was deleted using Redact.

head attraction fuzzy pot teeny quiet flag shy money growth


r/TheMotte • • Jul 03 '20

History Welcome to Gettysburg (Day Two)

235 Upvotes

Day One Here

Day Three Here

JULY 2nd, 1863

LATE, LATE AT NIGHT AND EARLY, EARLY MORNING

Lee and Meade had only just gotten to the scene of the action in the middle of the night. Until then, they had directed the battle from afar with nothing more than vague orders and knew nothing more than vague reports, which were largely obsolete by the time the rider had reached them. But they were present now.

Meade gathered a war council of all his generals to a) figure out what the hell had happened the day before, b) figure out what's facing them out there in the dark, and c) figure out what to do now. Because of his direct orders from President Lincoln, Meade had a diffident mindset at first. As he approached the war council on Cemetery Hill, he was trying to work out how to withdraw back closer to Washington D.C., being paranoid that Lee might slip around him and threaten the Capitol. But after meeting with his generals and reading the room, Meade switched gears; he decided that if all his men were eager to plant the flag on the high ground and fight here and now, then that's what they were gonna do.

Meade was a methodical man. His style of generalship is all about details, details, details, like an old engineer who knows his craft inside and out. There would be no reinventing of the wheel under him, no flashy strategies, no innovative maneuvers. He simply took the units he had available and planned out how much frontage they can occupy, what terrain they could exploit. He set up fields of fire, emplaced cannons, designated reserves and supply points. He shaped the piece of the Army of the Potomac that he had into until it resembled a fishhook. The sharp tip of the hook was just south of Culp's Hill. The curve of the hook passed through Culp's Hill and Cemetery Hill. And the hook straightened out into a line down Cemetery Ridge, ending at the natural fortress of Little Round Top. It was a hell of a tough nut to crack. No matter how you approached them, it would be a literal uphill battle across wide open fields of fire. Since they were packed in so tightly together, if any piece of the fishhook that started to bend under pressure, Meade could break off units from a peaceful section to reinforce them rapidly. Having issued his directions to his subordinate officers, and satisfied that he'd done all he could, Meade then waited patiently for morning.

Lee was angry. He'd given explicit orders to avoid a full on engagement, and now here he was, stuck in a full on engagement. Worse, the enemy held the high ground. Worse, he had next to no idea of the disposition of the Union army. J.E.B. Stuart, the legendary Confederate cavalry commander, was supposed to be Lee's eyes and ears. But Stuart was MIA, off joy-riding behind enemy lines, having fun taking prisoners and zapping supply trains like a raider instead of being the scout that Lee needed.

In the night of July 1st/morning of July 2nd, Lee took two actions to suss out how the enemy is positioned. He ordered a probe towards Culp's Hill, hoping to catch it unoccupied. It'd be way easier to take Cemetery Hill if they could grab the high ground across from it as a base of fire. But that probe bumped into the survivors of the Iron Brigade, who had set up shop on the invaluable terrain. After a short and skittish firefight, the probe backed off to return to friendly lines.

At dawn, Lee sent a Captain Johnston (an experienced recon man) to find the Union left flank. Johnston took the long way around, cutting across the Emmitsburg Road far to the south and clambering up Big Round Top to scope out the miniature valley below him (including Little Round Top). Nothing. Not a soul. Johnston scooted back quick to report his findings. Lee, reasoning that the Union left flank must be on the Emmitsburg Road which Johnston had avoided by necessity, decided that there was a good opportunity to crack the enemy line open. If Meade was dumb enough to leave his left flank open and unanchored by favorable terrain, Lee would be happy to take advantage.

Lee spent the rest of the morning developing a cunning plan. He mapped out an attack in echelon, meaning that he would stagger his attack all along the line, so that each element of his army would slam into the Union line at a different moment in time; the hope was that the never-ending series of stabs would overwhelm the Union response system and hopelessly confuse Meade as to where to send his reinforcements. Then, while the Union army was run ragged trying to respond to the myriad of attacks, Lee would send Longstreet straight north up the Emmitsburg Road and turn their unanchored left flank.

Let me be clear. Meade had given orders to occupy Little Round Top. There should have been bluebellies crawling all over that hill when Johnston laid eyes on it. The fact that there wasn't is sort of bizarre, and it was the root cause for the sheer insanity that was about to cook off that day. So let’s rewind a little. Meade gave out his orders and then settled in to wait patiently till morning. The problem was the man he gave the orders to- General Dan Sickles.

Sickles had been a big time politician in peace time, a Democrat Senator who drew his base of support from the immigrant enclaves of NYC. Despite his political differences with President Lincoln, and despite the cool attitudes that the Democrat base had about this suspect war to free the slaves (free them to compete with white workers, that is), Sickles consistently carried water for the Executive Branch in the rough patches at the start of the war. In the manner of the time, Lincoln had paid him back with a generalship, because that's how the game is played.

Things were loose back then. You could literally just be a General one day if you had the money or the right friends (and Sickles had both). That's seriously how one dumb political power broker ended up in charge of a freaking corps, one third of the Union Army on the field that day. Fun fact about Sickles, by the by- he once shot the son of Francis Scott Key in broad daylight for sleeping with his wife, and invented the "not guilty by reason of temporary insanity" plea out of whole cloth to get acquitted, because all kind of stuff is possible if you're a New York senator in the 1800's.

Anyway, Sickles received his orders- set up on Cemetery Ridge, and plant a strong force on Little Round Top. But Sickles was lazy and tired and took hours to get going that morning- that's why the hill was empty during Captain Johnston's recon mission. But as Johnston and his scouts rode back, Sickles marched forward, and upon reaching Cemetery Ridge he decided that Meade was screwing this whole thing up.

Cemetery Ridge was elevated terrain, but other than some fencing it was exposed. Right in front of him and across the shallow valley was higher ground with better cover. Sickles eyed positions whose names would soon echo through history, associated forever with blood and terror - the Peach Orchard, Rose Woods, the Wheatfield, Devil's Den.

Sickles unilaterally pushed his whole corps forward to occupy those deliciously strong positions. If there's one thing he knew for sure, it's that the higher the ground, the better. He also neglected to mention this decision to Meade.

So, let's recap. Meade believed his fishhook formation extends south along Cemetery Ridge, anchored on Little Round Top. He is wrong. A third of his army is in fact jutting out a mile in front of Cemetery Ridge, stretched dangerously thin and exposed from multiple angles. Lee, for his part, believed that the Union left was straddled on the Emmitsburg Road and thought he was about send a division rolling up their flank without significant resistance. He is also wrong- the attack was in fact about to charge face first into fortified positions on high terrain.

Literally nobody is in the driver's seat for this second day at Gettysburg.

————————————————————————

LATE MORNING

General Longstreet had been Lee’s right hand man ever since “Stonewall” Jackson had gotten killed two months back. Longstreet had intuited by observation what later strategists would conclude by analysis; direct frontal assaults are now as obsolete as stone axes in warfare. People were still using Napoleonic tactics to close distance with infantry and force the enemy to run with the bayonet. With shoddy cannons and inaccurate musketry, it was perfectly plausible to expect a brigade to endure a few volleys and get in close. But cannons, by this time, were works of art and science, and muskets were rifled. Charging in across open ground was now suicidal, as Iverson’s and O‘Neal’s brigades had relearned the day before.

Longstreet didn’t want to fight here. Not at all. With the enemy on the high ground? No. Longstreet argued for a wide flanking maneuver to bypass the Army of the Potomac entirely- slip all the boys south past Big Round Top and make for Washington DC. If they could get in between Meade and Lincoln (Longstreet figured), they could force Meade to attack them instead. But Lee demurred. Bad for morale, with the enemy in their sights and not engaging. Plus, spending a day shuffling tens of thousands of men the long way around the Union defenses would be dicey. There was nothing saying that Meade mightn't see them moving and attack while everybody was out of position. No, Lee was going to play the hand he was dealt, and ordered Longstreet's corps to attack the vulnerable Union Left.

Longstreet was slow to get started, and his attack was half-hearted. Neo-Confederates have damned his memory for it ever since; between his head-butting against Saint Lee and his participation in Reconstruction two years later, Longstreet has played the scapegoat for defeat in popular memory.

The Confederate movement to get into position took hours too long, and second-guessed their approach due to fear of being spotted too early. Poetically, it somewhat resembled a kid trying to work up the guts to show up behind the bleachers to finally fight the bully like he promised.

————————————————————————

MID DAY

Lee finally, finally, made contact with his scout element. J.E.B. Stuart had finally showed up.

If Stuart was expecting kudos for his antics- causing havoc behind enemy lines, taking prisoners and raiding supply trains and such- he is badly mistaken. Lee was smack dab in the middle of a clash of armies and he had only the barest idea of how many of the enemy were over on those hills, let alone their disposition. Lee was blind because Stuart dropped the ball.

Stung as he was by Lee’s rebuke, and ashamed to have let the side down, Stuart offered his resignation. Lee refused- he still needed the best damn cavalry commander the Eastern Front has yet produced. Like a good manager, Lee put a valuable tool back in the toolbox so it’ll be there when he needs it. The day’s fight would have little need for cavalry, but tomorrow...

————————————————————————

Early Afternoon

Meade finally found out how fucked they were, that Sickles was a full mile out of position. He metaphorically grabbed Sickles by the collar and dragged him out to the new front lines to inspect how bad the damage was going to be. Meade's temper spiked up into a towering rage as he let Sickles have it. As he's berating Sickles for ruining everything, the forward elements of Longstreet's corps touched Sickles' men in the Peach Orchard. Gunfire broke out as the Confederates got cut down by infantry and artillery that the plan had said weren't there.

Meade shifted gears fast. He told Sickles to stand fast and hold out, that help was on the way. There was no point to marching back to Cemetery Ridge if the fight was on. As horrible as this problem was, fighting with your back to the enemy would be even worse. The fish hook formation, tight as it was, allowed for some slack in terms of how fast reinforcements could be shifted.

On the Confederate side, the plan was already shot to hell. They had orders to drive on up the Emmitsburg Road, but the Emmitsburg Road was a pitiless kill zone with Union troops entrenched in the Peach Orchard with flanking fire menacing them from the Wheat Field and Devil's Den. Lee's orders were a no-go, obsolete on contact with the enemy. McLaws and Hood, under Longstreet, wanted to adjust the plan on the fly and attack more intelligently. But Longstreet had already fought Lee on this attack, and Lee had made it clear he wants them to roll up the Emmitsburg. While they hashed it out, the Confederate assault froze in place. Confederate and Union artillerymen had fun trading salvos at each other's positions, while the infantrymen hugged dirt and hated their commanders for doing this to them.

McLaws on the left almost charged across the road at the Union men entrenched in the Peach Orchard, but at the last moment Longstreet called it off so Hood can get into position. Hood hated Longstreet's orders to charge on the right of the Emmitsburg road in support of McLaws (which was the "expose your right flank to withering fire" option), and instead attacked Devil's Den directly- whether this was deliberate disobedience or an inevitable shifting in response to terrain, I'm honestly not sure. Either way, it meant that McLaws was left hanging. It also meant that the unengaged Union artillery in the Peach Orchard was free to deliver withering flanking fire into Hood's left flank instead. One such screaming shell burst overhead and ruined Hood's left arm, knocking him out of the fight. Hood's underling Law took over for him.

Devil's Den was a scattering of boulders on elevated terrain, occupied by Union artillery and snipers. They rained precision death upon the advancing Confederates from relative safety. But there were so many targets... Law's troops streamed down the path of least resistance, south of Devil's Den, bypassing Sickles' incompetently laid defenses entirely and charging up to Little Round Top to complete the flanking maneuver.

Meade, meanwhile, had just realized that Sickles hadn't put anybody on Little Round Top, which was the one patch of dirt that Meade had specifically told him to fortify. He shot a order out to his reserves to get a brigade up there and dig in fast, fast, fast fast fast. The courier, however, could not find the assigned unit; it's chaotic out there. The messenger bumped into Vincent's Maine brigade in reserve behind the Wheat Field and, under pressure, revealed the contents of the order. Vincent risked a court martial by taking the initiative and abandoning his post to go off and occupy Little Round Top himself. Vincent got there just in time to fight Law's assault from the high ground.

The little valley in between Devil's Den and Little Round Top, carved out by the Plum Run stream, earned two new nicknames that day: the Slaughter Pen, and the Valley of Death.

LATE AFTERNOON

Lee's timetable was ruined. His complex plan to attack in echelon was dead on arrival, wrecked by friction and faulty assumptions. Longstreet's attack had kicked off hours behind schedule, and the planned diversionary assaults on Cemetery and Culp's Hill fell victim to the same confusion and delay that had afflicted Rodes' assault on Cutler at Oak Ridge the day before. The moving pieces just weren't moving in concert. Meade was able to bring up reinforcements to hold the line as fast as Longstreet was able to kill them off.

The attacks, retreats and counterattacks across the Peach Orchard, the Wheat Field, Rose Woods, and Devil's Den are intricate and confusing to us today. It was confusing to them too. I'm not going to get lost in the details.

Each side brought in reinforcements as they arrived piecemeal from outside of Gettysburg, and hurled them into the fray as soon as they arrived. The pattern was that a successful assault was soon followed by a successful counterattack by fresh infantry, who paid for their victory in blood and were shortly afterwards attacked and slaughtered in turn. By such means did the strongholds change hands multiple times throughout the afternoon and evening.

In lieu of beat by beat replays, I will instead focus on two small narratives within the chaos.

————————————————————————

The Irish Brigade

If you're an Irish-American nerd, you already know about this.

The Irish Brigade had been formed at the very start of the war, drawn from the Irish immigrant enclaves of New York City. Their officer corps was drawn in part from the Fenian Brotherhood, a militant Irish Republican secret society devoted to overthrowing the British. Their commander at Gettysburg, Thomas Francis Meagher, had been a leader of failed (and pathetically inept) Young Irelander Rebellion of 1848, and was in fact a convicted felon in Great Britain who had escaped Van Dieman's Land to live in exile in New York.

The war had treated the Irish Brigade rough. Between Bull Run in 1861 and Chancellorsville earlier that year, they had been reduced to just 530 men: a regiment-sized brigade.

At the Wheat Field, Meagher saw a massive hole in the Union line about to be stormed by a Confederate brigade. The Irish Brigade didn't have the numbers to stop them, but they could slow them down for long enough for other men to plug that gap.

The Catholic chaplain gathered the Irish Brigade around them and granted mass absolution of sins, as there was not enough to time to hear each man's confession individually. This was common enough in European armies, but this was the first time it had happened in Protestant America. After that, they charged.

The Irish Brigade used smooth bore muskets instead of the newfangled rifled muskets that everyone else used. But this let them fire buck-and-ball shot, a .69 ball with four tinier balls in tandem. It was like a long range shot gun. They might not be able to snipe, but at close range their volleys were deadly. The Wheat Field was very close range indeed. The Confederates stopped in their tracks and bled. But their return volleys slashed the Irish Brigade into pieces. 320 men out of the 530 Irishmen were killed or wounded in minutes. They take second place to the Iron Brigade in terms of percentage of casualties at Gettysburg, and third place overall throughout the war.

The gap had held long enough.

————————————————————————

The Mainers, the Alabamans, and the Texans at Little Round Top

Law threw together an ad hoc, expanded brigade by combining his own Alabaman regiments with two Texan regiments, to make a strong enough force to take Little Round Top and push through to flank the whole Union line.

The significance of Little Round Top is actually not entirely clear. Historians as far back as the 1870's considered it to be the lynchpin of the whole battle. Control of it gave Meade an artillery firing point able to cover half the Union line, and had Lee taken it and set up his own artillery on the summit, he might have been able to deliver flanking fire across that same line. That said, Lee himself did not appear to have thought this way; he would later describe Longstreet as being "delayed" by the necessity of clearing out that hill, not of it being an objective in its own right. There's also been some question about how useful Lee would have found it anyway as the cannons might not have been able to have been stacked up properly to even fire at the Union line along Cemetery Ridge.

Still, though.

Law peeled off one Alabaman regiment to attack Devil's Den to the north of the Slaughter Pen, and the rest drove on to Little Round Top.

The Alabamans and the Texans were hard men. That whole morning, they'd been marching, struggling to get to Gettysburg in time to be useful. In the 87 degree summer heat and with only one canteen of water per man, they'd quick marched twenty miles that day, losing men as heat casualties as they went. Scarcely had they arrived before Hood threw them into battle.

As they crossed Plum Creek, the exhausted and heat-struck Confederates tried to stop to refill their canteens. Their officers beat the shit out of the enlisted men with the flats of their swords to keep them going; they were at that stage where they were going on pure adrenaline, and if they stopped for a water break, they were probably going to stay stopped.

They charged uphill to Little Round Top through the rough terrain, and ran into blistering fire from the Maine regiments up the hill that knocked them back. The Southerners reformed, caught their breath, and charged uphill again. And again. And again.

After another few hours of desultory failed charges, the Mainers on Little Round Top ran out of ammo. So they bayonet charged downhill instead.

The Alabamans and the Texans surrendered en masse, worn out beyond endurance. Little Round Top stayed in Union hands even as all else gave way.

————————————————————————

STILL LATE AFTERNOON

But, long story short, the Confederates won again on the Union left. By sunset, they owned Peach Orchard, the Wheat Field, Rose Woods, and Devil's Den, having shoved Sickles' corps back to Cemetery Ridge. But Little Round Top had held.

The Confederate line, bloodied and exhausted as it was, got their shit right and attacked up Cemetery Ridge as one. But fresh reinforcements drawn off of unengaged Culp’s Hill arrived to stiffen the Union line. Furious fire ripped the weary Confederates apart and drove them back.

The apocalyptic killing spree that would happen the next day sprang in part from one small Confederate success at this time. An under strength brigade had crossed the field and smacked into Cemetery Ridge, and on contact had driven the blue bellies off with the bayonet. Being all by themselves, and with Union reinforcements closing in on them, they’d withdrawn back to friendly lines with the rest of their limping, bleeding, worn out comrades.

But clearly, even a small unit could close distance on Cemetery Ridge. A larger attack might have worked...

EVENING

As the echoes died away from the killing fields of Peach Orchard, Rose Woods, the Wheat Field, Devil's Den, and Little Round Top, the diversionary attacks meant to support them finally kicked off. Confederates used the dying light to charge up the impregnable natural fortresses of Cemetery Hill and Culp's Hill. As can be imagined, they failed, and the Confederates suffered massive casualties for nothing. The fighting lasted well past nightfall- we’ll get into more detail tomorrow, because midnight is an arbitrary line to draw between the skirmishing and small pushes that stopped and started periodically all night long. The only part of these attacks that can be called a success is that the Confederates established a foothold at the base of Culp's Hill in the small sections that Meade had deemed nonessential and had already pulled out from so as to reinforce the idiot Sickles, who had gotten a leg blown off and had been carted away from the field. Sickles would later get the Medal of Honor for his bullshit that day, because all kind of stuff is possible for a New York Senator in the 1800’s.

Of all the men, Union and Confederate, who had fired in anger that day, approximately 1/3rd of them had been killed or wounded. This shakes out to roughly 15,000 men- 6,000 Confederates and 9,000 Union troops- cut down, a little less than 10% of each army. Now, the single bloodiest day in American military history was the battle of Antietam less than a year before, where 23,000 total had been killed or wounded. But- and I note this to drive home just how insanely intense the fighting had been that day- Antietam had last twelve hours. The fighting on the second day of Gettysburg had lasted only six. I did the math, so you don’t have to- at Antietam, about 32 men on average were killed and maimed every minute. At Gettysburg, on the 2nd day, it was about 42 men every minute.

It was a terrible day to be a soldier.


r/TheMotte • • Jan 21 '21

Still Alive (Slate Star Codex is reborn as Astral Codex Ten on Substack)

Thumbnail
astralcodexten.substack.com
233 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Oct 21 '19

The Three Utopias of Mass Effect

227 Upvotes

The Problem

I love Star Trek. Almost more than I love whatever this is. But something I've always noticed is that on the show the Federation's philosophy is treated with a triumphant inevitability, and every character displays a deep self-assurance that it is only a matter of time before Starfleet’s unique brand of fully automated luxury gay space communism wins over the forces of chaos and evil. Not even DS9 escapes this flaw, as for all its criticism of Federation idealism ("it's easy to be a saint in paradise") it still shows the bubbly gay communism of our heroes as still eventually conquering the galaxy (just on a slightly longer time frame). "It's insidious" remark Quark and Garak at one point.

But the reason for this sense of victory is entirely because the Federation has no philosophical rivals. All other societies are inevitably revealed to be barbaric (klingons), greedy (Ferengi), evil (Dominion), authoritarian (Romulan), misogynistic (Ferengi), diseased (Vidiians), chaotic (Kazon), don't know the meaning of the term 'informed consent' (Borg), cowardly (Ferengi)...the Federation basically just wins by default. The show doesn't try to actually challenge itself philosophically, and only presents the characters with alternative societies that they're able to easily dismiss out of hand. It's always like "This world is a utopia....except they eat babies". "This world is a utopia...except they practice human sacrifice". etc. etc.

The folks at /r/DaystromInstitute/ (the 'serious discussions' Trek subreddit) have long wished to see the Federation square off against the culture from the Ian Banks books, to finally have an enemy that can challenge them on a deeper level than merely military. Having two utopias standing side by side competing with each other is an interesting concept I don’t think I’ve ever seen explored before.

But recently it occurred to me that I have seen that idea explored, and in an extremely popular sci-fi franchise to boot. Although most of the details are buried so far in the various game’s codex entries most players probably missed it, this franchise does actually feature 3 distinct utopias all sharing borders with each other and interacting constantly. The franchise I’m talking about is, of course, Mass Effect.

The Three Utopias of Mass Effect

Mass Effect is a science fiction CRPG created by Bioware in 2008. In the series, humanity discovers the existence of large structures called 'mass relays' that are powered by a wonder substance called 'element zero'. More than being just another video game setting, the Mass Effect universe is one of the most realized sci-fi settings in popular media today. The logical implications of the existence of 'element zero' are explored to their natural conclusions, and the game's codex delves deeply into the unique lore and character of every major race you encounter. The sheer depth and sense of immersion is undoubtedly a large part of why the series has retained such a loyal fanbase even after the disappointing ending of the third game and the disappointing....entire thing of Mass Effect Andromeda.

I'd like to focus on an often under-appreciated part of the ME universe, and that is the politics. Specifically how Bioware managed to treat three different (and oft mutually exclusive) political ideologies fairly, and crafted for each one a representative race who are living in that ideology's utopia. In absolutely stark contrast with Star Trek, none of the societies are presented as either perfect or eating babies - instead each has a core philosophy they adhere to that works the best for them. Each ideology is treated as just as reasonable and valid as any other philosophy in the galaxy. And by allowing free movement between each version of heaven, the galactic society in the story ensures people of different temperaments are able to flow to the society they're most comfortable in without much hassle.

So let's delve into this by starting with the first, and probably most inexplicably fair-handed given Bioware's own political leanings, alien utopia:

Turians

The Turian ideology is one built on militarism, honor, and factional loyalty. Service in the armed forces is mandatory for all Turians, starting at the age of 15. Indoctrination into the state begins even earlier, as all Turian media is centered around the glorification of service to the state. There is no civilian government, instead the Turian political system is an unelected military hierarchy. The entire population is divided up into 27 different 'citizen tiers' functionally equivalent to military rank, from which citizens may be promoted or demoted based on their actions over the course of their life. Almost all Turians maintain guns in their homes, and it is expected that should a Turian colony fall to the enemy Turian civilians will take up arms against the invaders and form militias. To fail to perform one's duty to the military and to the state (which are usually the same thing) is considered the highest form of betrayal a Turian citizen is capable of, regardless of the form that failure to perform takes: Drug abuse, laziness, cowardice, incompetence. Turian religion is simple and all pervasive, with Turians believing in the existence of 'spirits' who guide their actions and reward honoring the hierarchy. Turian culture is profoundly parochial, with a great deal of emphasis on one's own personal community and local customs over more cosmopolitan concerns. Given the importance of one's "home town" to Turian culture, it is unsurprising that face tattoos celebrating one's colony or planet of origin are near ubiquitous among all levels of Turian society. To lack facial tattoos is to be 'barefaced', and is a mark of shame.

Yet the Turians, despite sounding like a fascist dystopia, are shown as enjoying their highly regimented, military-oriented life. To be 'demoted' a citizenship tier bears no shame on the person who lost rank. Instead the failure is considered to have been with the person who promoted them beyond their level of ability. The un-elected military hierarchy is extremely meritocratic, and the Turians you meet over the course of the series and in novels occasionally express confusion as to why anyone would tolerate the chaos and inefficiency of other government systems. What if you elect a President who is a terrible strategist, and he loses you a war? Indeed we even meet a Turian commander in the 3rd game who is ashamed at having tried to employ infiltration tactics, and laments his failure to charge straight forward in a disciplined fashion as Turian culture dictates he should. Further the Turians are not predatory or especially expansionist, they are content to live in their militarized society and enjoy its sense of profound order and safety without feeling the need to force others to join them at gunpoint. If the rest of the galaxy wants to live in absurd madcap anarchism, that's their problem. Further, the Turian commitment to militarism has saved the galaxy twice - first during the Krogan rebellions, and then later during the Reaper war when they held the line long enough for Commander Shepard to complete the crucible. The Salarians may not be using Turian technology, and the Asari may not be consuming Turian media, but no one can doubt the valuable contributions Turian society has made to the overall prosperity of the Council races.

The Turians, being a pro-military, pro-gun, law'n'order loving, small town focused culture represent a conservative, or right wing, or red tribe utopia.

Salarians

Salarian society is built on advanced technology, constant innovation, and prizing creative thinking or lateral solutions over brute force. Salarians are perhaps the race that best embodies the term "too clever by half", and would likely even regard it as a compliment - cleverness is simply that highly valued to the Salarians. Their society lacks concepts like "love" or "family", and instead reproduction is handled through negotiation and dealmaking on a clan level. Salarian 'romance' looks more like corporate merger negotiations than anything humans would recognize as courtship. To compensate for their physical inferiority and lack of biotic power, the Salarians have made themselves the masters of information warfare. Salarians make it a point to know every detail about every member of every species that might ever threaten them, and if it should come to it the Salarian miltiary has no compunctions against pre-emptive attacks. What other species would decry as a "cowardly sucker punch", the Salarians regard as simple logic: If in a fair fight you will lose, do not fight fair. Their utilitarian perspective on such matters marks them as distinct from the emotive Asari and the honorable Turians. Salarian armed forces are also unique in the advanced state of their technology, being the most cutting edge of all citadel forces. As an example Salarian dreadnoughts rely on near-ultraviolet wavelength point defense lasers - which offer longer range over conventional infrared designs, but at the cost of greater mechanical complexity and expense. Salarian society is ostensibly structured along feudal lines, but more realistically is best described as a massive free for all - where clans (basically similar to human corporations) compete against each other all the time in everything, and the winner is rewarded by the “market” for their clever thinking and innovative designs. To do something because tradition demanded it is anathema to the Salarian view of things. Finally the Salarians are the race most willing to disrupt the status quo, whether by introducing new technology or uplifting a new race to galactic prominence - indeed their society even takes pride in this habit of radical innovation and constant boundary pushing.

As with the Turians, the Salarians could easily be treated as evil. Their society is like a cross between 1980s wall street and every negative stereotype about Silicon Valley. But their society is still treated as perfectly happy, for as unpleasant as a liberal human would find the clan-based corporatocracy of Salarian life - to a Salarian it is home. A Salarian would look at human society with a sad eye, and ask how the bulk of mankind can tolerate living under puritanical busybodies who stick their noses in everything. How they can handle allowing vast, inefficient bureaucracies to manage their societies when it could all be handed over to sleek, efficient private entities. Salarian society values efficiency and utilitarianism as the utmost virtues, and to give such things up - for something as trivial as "safety" or "security" - is an utterly foreign concept to their society. Stagnation, to the Salarian Union, is death. And what are regulations except the harbingers of stagnation?

The Salarian habit of trying to improve everything all the time, even if it doesn't actually need improving, sometimes produces terrible results: Salarian forces are responsible for uplifting the krogan, Salarian explorers are responsible for unleashing the rachni, Salarian STG operatives are responsible for countless acts of terrorism, assassination and sabotage across thousands of years - tens of billions of sentient beings have died as a direct result of the Salarian inability to leave well enough alone. But those are the exceptions to the general rule, which is that Salarians are the primary innovators in galactic society. The Asari and Turians are too stuck in their ways, and without the constant pressure to improve (or more realistically, adopt Salarian improvements) they would be nowhere near the powerhouses they are in the modern day. As one example the entire concept of 'spectres' is the direct result of a Salarian idea - a 'spectre' is basically a Salarian STG operative given the authority of all three council races rather than just the Salarian Union. Ultimately you can't be angry at a Salarian for pushing the envelope any more than you can be angry at a bird flying - it's just what it was born to do.

Salarian society, being a tech-obsessed, efficiency-minded, competitive, innovative and utilitarian, is a libertarian, or grey tribe, or Silicon center utopia. Of the three, they are definitely treated the least kindly by the Bioware writers although still sympathetically (also they're right about the genophage, don't @ me)

Asari

The Asari are basically the Federation, except dial down the communism and dial up the gay. Also they’re blue women. Well the Federation has blue women (Andorians, Bolians), but the Asari are all blue women. Also they're all magical girls. Okay, let's back up here for a bit.

The Asari are an all-female race of long-lived sapients known for their compassion, diplomacy, and belief in tolerance and cooperation over conflict. They have an average lifespan of 1,000 years, which inclines them to take a long view on galactic politics. They are also near-uniformly blessed with biotic power (space magic), to such an extent that only those with biotics are allowed to join the Asari military. The Asari live in a patchwork of states loosely bound together in a democratic system, which doesn't have politicians or elections. Asari democracy is a free for all affair where any citizen can propose anything at any time, and everyone else votes on it - so-called "electronic democracy". The one exception is the Asari's citadel representative, who is elected in a more traditional manner with specific candidates being voted on. The Asari military is composed of volunteer warrior bands from each individual commune and city, organized similar to human militias. Mass conscription and traditional military style organization simply aren't how the Asari mind works, such things are too forceful and restrictive in their view. Asari militia-soldiers (called Huntresses) are given wide option in how they pursue their objectives, although given their lack of heavy weapons and small numbers their preferred approach is inevitably guerrilla warfare. The Asari are almost completely incapable of fighting a conventional war, which suits them perfectly fine - they prefer diplomacy and consensus-building over conflict.

The Asari are also known for their attitudes toward sex and love - the Asari's biology allows them to reproduce with any species in the galaxy of any gender, and so Asari relationships are the most diverse of any species. Some Asari marry krogans, others Salarians, others Turians, and all such relationships are treated as wonderful from the Asari viewpoint. The Asari believe reproducing with alien species allows them to gain some of the benefits of each alien 'father', and incorporate them into each new generation of Asari. The lone exceptions are the children born of two Asari parents, who are called 'pure bloods', and regarded as a gross waste of potential.

The Asari also form the ‘intellectual elite’ of the galaxy, due to both their cultural reverence for scholarship/science and their extensive lifespans. If you work as a physicist for 1,000 years, you’ll probably get pretty good at it. Although the Salarians are the most tech-y over-all, the Asari are still able to remain somewhat competitive due to their culture of intellectualism. They even enjoy superior biotic technology, as the Salarians have much less impetus to improve in that venue than the Asari do (Salarian biotics are very rare). Still, for all their mental prowess, Asari inventions tend to be iterative rather than truly novel – improving what already exists little by little rather than inventing something truly game-changing.

In many ways the Asari function as the conscience of the three races, and their compassionate belief in universal inclusion and fairness serves to temper the sometimes over-eager militarism of the Turians and poorly thought out experimentation of the Salarians. The only reason mankind wasn't exterminated in a protracted interstellar war with the Turians during First Contact is the Asari brokered a peace treaty before the Turian counter attack could reach us.

Yet at the same time, the Asari are not presented as completely perfect. The Asari's long life inclines them toward a frivolous attitude in their younger years. Which one of Liara's moms mentions leads most Asari to wasting the first 300 years of their lives stripping and partying. Further, unlike the Salarians who have a deep drive to innovative and improve, the Asari are deeply stuck in their ways. From the same conversation with Liara's mom mentioned above, Mama Liara describes how she proposed to the Asari leadership the idea of building new mass effect relays (space highways) themselves to expand the network the protheans left behind. The Asari Republics had the economy to support such a project, and their technology had advanced to the point where it was a feasible idea, so why not?

The response to her proposal was basically her getting laughed out of the room. Such radical disruption of the way the galaxy works is simply not how things are done in Asari culture. Instead the proposal should be debated for 500 years while consensus is built and everyone's consulted, and then maybe hand the idea over to the Salarians to do the nitty gritty detail work. Then allow a thousand years for more discussion and accommodation, and we should begin construction around....oh the year 4,000 (the games take place in the 2180s).

Asari society, being a free-loving, inclusive democracy of compassionate diplomats and scholars who place extreme importance on cooperation and consensus are a liberal, or blue tribe, or leftist utopia.

Conclusion

What I find so great about Mass Effect's three societies is not only are they all presented as mostly good places to live, but that they all serve to bring out the best in each other and support one another. Without the Asari, the Turains and the Salarians would grow cold and cruel. Without the Salarians, the Asari and the Turians stagnate and fade. Without the Turians, the Salarians and Asari are basically defenceless against the dangers of the galaxy. Remove one of them and the other two suffer. It's delightfully diverse without being preformative, and makes me think perhaps the culture war in our time isn't so bad after all. Perhaps it brings out the best parts of each of us, and sharpens them - would America be as strong as it is in 2019 if not for the contributions of liberals, conservatives and libertarians/techies all together?

Going back to Star Trek after enjoying Mass Effect's more nuanced position on politics always feels so....deflating and primitive. Hopefully more sci-fi settings can learn from ME's example.


r/TheMotte • • Jun 02 '21

Review of "I was born in Slavery" AKA, The past is a foreign country

225 Upvotes

A few weeks ago, in a museum gift shop in Georgia, I spotted a book titled "I was Born in Slavery." I thumbed through it and found it was a series of 28 personal narratives from ex-slaves in my home state of Texas, and immediately bought it.

In the New Deal era, the federal government sent unemployed writers out on various projects, one of which interviewing old people. The narratives from ex-slaves were eventually compiled, sorted by state, and sold. The book was fascinating, and I have some interesting takeaways and anecdotes below but I want to start out with the most shocking revelation: the vast majority of the former slaves either remembered slavery fondly, or had mixed feelings about it. According to the books introduction, 7% of those interviewed by whites remembered it harshly, compared with 25% interviewed by blacks. At times, the book felt like a piece of southern propaganda, even though if quite clearly was not. After I finished it, I decided to read the equivalent book from a notoriously brutal state (Mississippi) and while it the accounts do seem marginally worse, it is still more of the same.

Some other interesting takeaways:

-One of the points in southern apologia I heard growing up was often that while slavery was bad, the system enriched the wealthy whites at the expense of poor whites, and on the backs of enslaved blacks. While this might be true, the ex-slaves didn't seem to see it that way. They rarely had a kind word to say about poor whites, who made up the bulk of the overseers and slave patrollers, and later (presumably) formed the backbone of the KKK. More than a few of the ex slaves longed for the former aristocratic white class to put the other whites in their place.

-I know life was much harsher back then, but despite the ex slaves frequently extolling the kindness of their masters, they didn't come off as that kind to me. Most of the "kindnesses" were things like giving them enough to eat, letting them get married, not selling families apart, or not beating them too hard.

-Far more slaves than I would've expected said their parents had come from Africa. Even though the slave trade nominally ended a half century before the civil war, a black market clearly existed for quite a while.

-Lots of male slaves reported serving in the confederate army. Although they mostly didn't see combat, they served in various logistical roles that would be considered part of the military today.

-The ex slaves regularly said things that would get a white person automatically cancelled today, such as stating that black people were better off during slavery, or that Lincoln should have minded his own business and that they supported Jefferson Davis. The gentleman who made the latter statement was a former head house slave, which hilariously conforms to stereotypes.

-The KKK was ubiquitous in the post-civil war south. I assume the interviewers asked about it because it was in so many narratives, but pretty much everyone had something to say about them and it was all negative. Stories of black people (and whites who wouldn't fall in line) being intimidated, having their property destroyed, or even being violently assaulted were common. Our friend the house slave claims that he had "ridden with them many a time. It was the only way in them days to keep order."

-A huge chunk, probably the outright majority, stayed on the plantations even though they had been freed. They just didn't really know what else to do. Based on the narratives it seems that the plantation system died out about a decade later but I'm not sure exactly why. At least one ex slave said he refused to be paid for the first year after freedom because it "didnt seem right."

-The "n word" (dont want to get banned from reddit) was the only way any of the ex slaves referred to themselves or other black people. The word must not have been stigmatized at all by the mid-30s, at least not among the older generation.

-People in those days were incredibly tough. They would just casually talk about being beaten, having family members sold and never seeing them again, etc. An extremely stark contrast to the way modern people talk about "trauma"

My big takeaway was that the antebellum south was a bizarre, fucked up, and incredibly alien society, that I don't really know what to make of. I do find it funny that, if these narratives are at all representative (and it seems that they are, based on the statistics) the ex-slaves themselves would probably have sided with the red tribe on culture war issues like confederate monuments.

I found that personal interviews of ordinary people, 3 to 4 pages in length, from the distant past to be a very fascinating type of literature for me. If anyone has any recommendations of similar works, please let me know


r/TheMotte • • Jul 04 '20

History Welcome to Gettysburg (Day Three)

224 Upvotes

Day One Here

Day Two Here

JULY 3RD

A FEW HOURS AFTER MIDNIGHT

The night fighting on Culp’s Hill was slow and torturous. The Confederate assault from Johnson’s division had to cross rough terrain and a river before it even started going uphill, which at night was an incredibly miserable task even without Union troops firing at them. Union skirmishers played hell with their progress, and after brushing them aside, Johnson bumped into a defensive line that his Union counterpart Geary had spent all day perfecting.

As mentioned yesterday, their only success was to grab tiny footholds on the Union side of Rock Creek, which ran between the two hills.

As the fighting died away and the bone weary soldiers on both sides crashed asleep hard, Lee plotted. He smelled blood; on July 1st, they’d carved up the Union men good and drove them from the field. Yesterday, on the Union left, they’d wrecked a Union corps under Sickles, smashed into the Union center and almost broke it (damn those blue belly reinforcements showing up in the knick of time), and even gained a toehold on the Union right. The men’s morale was high. Lee decided to repeat yesterday’s plan, but better executed. Simultaneous attacks on both flanks should overwhelm them, and J.E.B. Stuart could make it up to all of them by chasing down the shattered Army of the Potomac to scoop up all the heavy guns and supplies and wounded that could not retreat rapidly. To which end, Lee sent Stuart on a super wide flanking attack around the Union right so as to be in position to strike at the right moment. Lee generated the orders in written form and sent them off by messenger to his corps commanders.

Meanwhile, Meade had another war council face to face with his generals. They decided to stand pat, to neither attack the Confederate positions nor retreat back towards Washington. The terrain massively favored them and Lee would (more likely than not) walk into their gunsights again.

A defensive stance, however, doesn’t mean pure passivity. A few hours after the Confederate assault petered out and Lee’s decision was made, the Union started a counterattack on a small scale.

————————————————————————

DAWN

At dawn, the Union right flared up. Fresh troops had marched in overnight and Meade wanted his damn hill back. The extreme end of the Confederate left flank (which is of course opposite the Union right) found itself getting hammered in front of Culp’s Hill by artillery from the Baltimore Pike. Clearly, such a bombardment was meant to be followed up with an assault to retake the bridgehead.

Johnson, having received his orders from Lee and being under the impression that Longstreet was attacking in tandem a mile and a half away on the other side of the hills, attacked Culp’s Hill again before the Union could attack him first. The plan was what the plan was; pressure here, successful or not, was needed for someone to break through somewhere. But Longstreet wasn’t attacking. Later on, Longstreet would claim to have never received the order to advance, but the sources I have assert this is untrue- he received the order, he just didn’t do anything about it. Instead of spending the night getting his troops on line to attack Little Round Top and the southern chunk of Cemetery Ridge, he just sat tight and did nothing. Oceans of ink have been spilled over the years speculating as to why. The Lost Cause narrative asserts that Longstreet was a Yankee-loving turncoat who deliberately sabotaged Lee’s plan and lost the battle on purpose. Others think that Longstreet's conviction that attacking here was insane and that they should fall back and look for battle somewhere else on more favorable terms had been strengthened by the results of July 2nd, and as such was dragging his heels trying to not attack again. Or maybe it was just the general haze of Civil War era incompetence taking its toll again.

————————————————————————

MORNING

As Johnson’s men gamely attacked the untakeable Culp’s Hill and were cut down by accurate rifle fire and close range cannon fire, Lee hunted down Longstreet to demand an explanation for his borderline insubordinate refusal to attack.

Longstreet pitched his idea again. He’d spent all night scouting the Union line. The enemy line was unbreakable. They shouldn’t try to attack them here. They should slip around the Union left, south of Big Round Top, to threaten the Union supply lines. Do that, they would make the Union respond to them, fight them on more equal terms. That’s the plan Longstreet had been preparing for all night, not a suicidal-

Lee cut him off with a raised fist. There would be no tricky maneuver around the flank. They would assault the Union line under the present conditions.

To the north, Johnson was still getting his teeth kicked in. Lee sent orders to call off the assault, but it would take a while for the messenger to get there and for Johnson to get word to his brigades to stand down and fall back. Meanwhile, across the way on Cemetery Ridge, Meade stalked his line, double checking all the positions for any confusions or errors to correct, emitting confidence and good cheer.

Lee scoped out the Union center personally, being in the area anyway. His complex double flanking maneuver wasn't working. A new plan was needed.

Lee figured that Meade had reinforced Little Round Top and the surrounding area yesterday, and that those troops hadn’t gone anywhere since. The Union defense at Culp’s Hill has been similarly fierce that morning, fierce enough to threaten Johnson with an offensive. If both flanks were strong... the center must be weak. Yesterday, a small Confederate brigade had crossed the Emmitsburg road under fire and smashed into the Union line on Cemetery Ridge, just south of Cemetery Hill. They had straight up routed the enemy- had there been more men available to back them up and follow through, that small brigade might have won the battle outright instead of being pushed back as they’d been.

Lee was satisfied. The Union center was brittle, undermanned, and the best point to hit it was at that same place.

Meanwhile, J.E.B. Stuart was stepping off on his flanking ride.

————————————————————————

LATE MORNING

Johnson’s last big push up Culp’s Hill was heroic. By that time, all of them knew how strong the Union position was. They surely walked into this with their eyes open.

A three brigade front set up for a shock attack, backed up by four more to exploit the hoped-for opening. Among them was the famous Stonewall Brigade, Jackson's old unit that he’d raised up and trained personally before being tapped for higher command. The Stonewall Brigade was, arguably, the elite of the Confederate army. The year before, they’d outmaneuvered and outfought a Union stab at Richmond coming through the Shenandoah valley.

The charge was cut down and butchered like all the others, and Johnson fell back.

Williams, whose batteries on the Baltimore Pike had kicked things off that morning, got a little overexcited and counterattacked without orders. His orders to attack the Confederate flank left his subordinates sickened with dread, but were obeyed nonetheless. Once the Union counterattack was butchered in retaliation by the entrenched Confederates, combat on the Union right ceased after six straight hours of gory, hopeless combat.

Meanwhile, Confederate artillery under the command of Colonel Alexander set itself up on a mile wide front, all carefully sited and positioned both for protection and for good lines of sight on the Union center. A brief but fierce artillery duel kicked off as each side tried to knock out the other’s firing points before the big moment, but was soon cut off to preserve ammo.

Lee mustered his available forces, bringing in troops that were only now straggling in and combining them with some units that had fought the day before. It was a haphazard and frankly half-assed piece of staff work- veteran units who hadn’t fought at all in the last two days were left in reserve, while exhausted troops who’d already suffered 50% casualties were included. Many of the brigades who were to charge Cemetery Ridge had green colonels in charge because their generals had been killed or wounded the day before. The gap between the northern half of the assaulting force and the southern half was four football fields long, and nobody seemed to notice or care. The division commander to lead the north side of the assault, General Pettigrew, was selected not for any rational consideration or advantage, but because he happened to be standing nearby when the decision was being made. Longstreet, who by this point wanted nothing to do with any of it, was placed in overall command. It took a few hours to organize this clusterfuck into something resembling a coherent unit- three divisions spread over a mile wide front, with Pickett on the left, Pettigrew on the right, and Trimble behind them to provide some depth to the big push.

There is no particularly good reason why the upcoming Pickett’s Charge is known as “Pickett’s Charge”. Pickett was not actually in charge of it, or even in charge of most of it. He was a division commander who had never seen proper combat before- in every battle since 1861, his unit had been held in reserve or absent. This was to be his first chance to get in this war. I suspect it’s known as Pickett’s Charge because he and his men were Virginians, and it was fellow Virginians who would pour over the battle to find out why the wrong side won. Accordingly, they conceived of it as being a Virginian affair, overshadowing the Tennesseans, Alabamans, North Carolinians, and Mississippians who formed the other two-thirds of the attack.

I was surprised to learn that we have a hard time figuring out how many men were actually involved in Pickett’s Charge (this being a basic narrative history, I am sticking with the common name for it despite the inaccuracy); I attribute this to the confusion involved in organizing it. I’ve heard as low as 12,500 men and as high as 15,000. I’m going with 14,000 men because it’s a nice even number that is approximately midway between the upper and lower limit, so don’t mistake my choice as being accurate or even evidence-based per se. Regardless, the agreed upon number of Union defenders is 6,500. The Confederates would outnumber the Union by about 2-1 or greater at the point of contact.

These days, a lot of people show up at the battlefield and stare out from Cemetery Ridge at Spangler Woods where Pettigrew would have emerged from (or stand in Spangler’s Woods and stare out at Cemetery Ridge, same difference) and wonder what the hell was going through Lee’s head. The ground there is now flat and devoid of cover, the exact kind of terrain that time and time again had proven to be a death sentence for infantry assaults. The answer is that the ground changed between 1863 and today. Just before World War One ended in 1918, the field over which Pickett charged was artificially flattened for tank training. Before that, it was the kind of rolling terrain that Buford’s skirmishers had exploited on day one- an observer from a distance would see the troops disappear and reappear as they went over and down each gentle slope. The 14,000 attackers would have some cover as they advanced- not perfect terrain to keep immune from artillery and bullets, but not explicit suicide either.

————————————————————————

EARLY AFTERNOON

By 1 PM, Alexander had his guns set up the way he liked them. What followed at his command was the single largest coordinated artillery mission that the Western Hemisphere had ever seen.

In the south, cannons at the Peach Orchard suppressed the Union firing point on Little Round Top. All along Seminary Ridge from whence the charge would spring, cannons lined up practically wheel to wheel for a mile, aimed at wrecking Cemetery Ridge.

Longstreet was in what you might call a high stress kind of mood. He was having second, third, fourth, and fifth thoughts about attacking, but orders were orders and he was in charge of this damned charge. As the guns began their bombardment, Longstreet did something that frankly goes beyond the pale of any command decision I’ve ever heard of. The film Gettysburg and the novel it’s based on cast Longstreet in a very sympathetic light, as a kind of deliberate pushback against the reductive myth that Longstreet was personally responsible for losing the battle and by extension the war, leaving Lee off the hook to stay firmly in the saintly canon of the Lost Cause. But here, Longstreet indisputably abdicates any pretense of the responsibility of command.

He fired an order off to Colonel Alexander, telling him:

If the artillery fire does not have the effect to drive off the enemy, or greatly demoralize him, so as to make our effort pretty certain, I would prefer that you should not advise General Pickett to make the charge. I shall . . . expect you to let General Pickett know when the moment offers.

Allow me to reiterate in case you were reading this on autopilot. Longstreet, the man in charge of the whole offensive, was telling a lowly artillery colonel that the decision when and if to attack was on him and no one else.

Alexander was a subject matter expert on artillery and not infantry for a reason. This order hit him from out of left field. He wrote back for clarification, and the professional in him mentioned that since the plan is to use every single artillery shell they can spare, if there is any alternative plan to charging Cemetery Hill at the end of the bombardment then they’d better tell him before he runs out of ammo.

And Longstreet reiterated his first order. He told Alexander to advise General Pickett whether or not to attack. And with that on his shoulders, Alexander gave the order to open fire.

All told, somewhere between 150 and 170 guns opened up at the same moment. The 75 Union cannons they had on hand briefly engaged in counter-battery fire, before being ordered to go quiet and save ammunition for the infantry assault to come. For about an hour, the Union troops just had to sit still and take what the Rebel had to give them.

What Lee was doing was classic Napoleonic tactics. Massing artillery against the weakest point on the enemy line was literally by the book soldiering. The problem, as was noted here before, was that technology had changed. Napoleonic could bring his cannon close to the frontline with the reasonable expectation that they wouldn’t be shot, since smoothbore muskets are basically harmless from 200 yards away. But that was no longer the case. The long stand off distance that the enemy rifles dictated meant that the cannonfire was proportionally less accurate and devastating. The smoke covering the field concealed the truth from the Confederates- their artillery fire was off. Most of the shells flew high overhead and exploded behind Cemetery Ridge. Some shells hit the target area- Union men did die screaming by the score. But the positions on Cemetery Hill were only lightly damaged, and the units manning them were intact and cohesive. Most of the damage done was to the rear echelon types- surgeons, supply wagoneers, staff officers, that kind of thing. Such men were massacred as the shells aimed at men a quarter mile away arced over and found marks elsewhere. Meade, of course, was on hand, showing a brave face and cracking some jokes about a similar moment in the Mexican-American War 15 years back.

Throughout the hour, as his line endured the steel hailstorm, Meade’s engineer mind was working. He’d already suspected that Lee was about to hit his center- he’d predicted as much the night before- and now the shot placements confirmed it. He was already ordering troops into position, getting ready to reinforce the line on Cemetery Ridge if needed. He hedged his bets, putting them in a position to relieve Cemetery Hill as well, just in case. Little Round Top became somewhat less defended as men marched out, using the high ground to mask their redeployment.

Irresponsible and insubordinate though Longstreet was at that moment, he was right. Lee’s improvised plan had already failed, though it hadn’t happened yet. Pickett’s Charge wasn’t going to slam into a fragmented and demoralized Union line. It was heading into a mile long, mile wide kill zone backed up by a defence in depth.

————————————————————————

Pickett’s Charge

Confederates were getting mangled before the charge even started. Union artillery fire reached out and touched out them in Spangler’s Woods, rolling solid iron shot and explosive shells into their huddled ranks.

Longstreet rode the line, exposing himself to the artillery fire to set an example of courage. The men didn’t need such an example- or rather, they’ve seen such examples in a dozen battles over the last two years and have already learned valor as a second language- but there’s something to be said for showing the groundpounders that their boss is in the wrong end of the shooting gallery the same way that they are.

Just before 2 p.m., Alexander decided if it’s gonna happen, it’d have to be now. He needed at least a small reserve of shells to function after the battle and he’s running out fast. He dashed off a note to Pickett telling him to step off. In keeping with the standard of Confederate comms thus far, Pickett then took Alexander’s note to Longstreet in person for confirmation, because nobody had told him that Longstreet was trying to dodge the responsibility of command.

Longstreet was desperate for an out, and in one crazed leap of illogic he thought he found one. Alexander was low on shells, with only a tiny reserve of ammunition left over for self-defense! Longstreet issued orders to halt in place and delay some more, so that they could replenish their ammo chests from their strategic reserves.

I really feel for Alexander, man. I've had bosses like that too. Alexander had to break the news to Longstreet that there was no strategic reserve, he already told him, they were shooting every round they got. Longstreet was shocked- apparently nobody on Lee's staff had been paying attention to how fast they'd been burning through their artillery rounds. (Meade's staff paid attention to such banal details- that's why they now had tons of ammunition standing by their guns on Cemetery Ridge, patiently waiting for something valuable to shoot at). Even then, Longstreet couldn’t bring himself to actually say the words to order the attack. He just nodded, mute and numb.

At 2 p.m., the attack started. 14,000 men rose up and walked forward, a giant line of infantry one mile across. In lieu of specific instructions about where they were going and how to get there, the order was to aim for a copse of trees on the objective- an easy visual marker that was easy to remember. As long as you kept the trees in sight and kept moving forward, you were right.

(Miles and miles away, J.E.B. Stuart’s flanking maneuver was being countered by an equal force of Union cavalry. Their clash had one of the few cavalry-on-cavalry battles of the Civil War; fun fact, this was one of the fights that put Custer’s career on the map, until getting killed off by the Cheyenne at Little Big Horn 13 years later. The battle was intense, but a draw; Stuart couldn’t break through. Even if Pickett’s Charge worked, there’d have been no way to follow up and finish Meade off for good. Lee’s plan was well and truly fucked.)

Things immediately stopped being clean and neat, as per the usual. The center of Pickett’s Charge sprang up and walked before the flanks did, but the brigades on the south and the north of them set off late, leading to a kind of droopy effect where the center bulged out unsupported.

When the Union soldiers manning Cemetery Ridge saw the Confederate advance begin, they began to chant “Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg!” Just a little “fuck you” from one set of veterans to another; at Fredericksburg eight months before, Union General Burnside had ordered several such suicidal attacks on prepared defenses which the Confederates had gleefully blasted into chunky salsa.

70 odd guns opened up on them all. To give a sense of the skill involved, the artilleryman in charge of the Union guns, Colonel Hunt, had written the book on artillery- literally, because his work Instructions for Field Artillery was the go-to manual for the US Army- and at West Point had personally taught most of the Confederate artillery officers across the way everything they knew about the big guns. One must not mistake this as just plopping down the cannons and pointing them in the right direction. Hunt was an artist with his weapon systems, and the pattern of explosions that snaked into the advancing infantry had been painstakingly designed by a master craftsman.

At the distance of a mile, it was iron shot and shell that carved bloody little holes into the line. The Confederates took the beating, closed ranks, and pushed on. On the south, the cannons on Little Round Top delivered particularly hideous effects from the flank, driving their line into disorder; some brigades cut in front of other brigades, and what should have been a line became a muddled column. On the north, a brigade under General Brockenbrough bumped into a small detachment of 160 Union men who were jutting out north of the road. The Union men fired a small but devastating volley that raked them from the side and broke their nerves. Brockenbrough’s men ran- the first to break, but not the last.

Similar small detachments of skirmishers dotted No Man’s Land between the armies. Between their vicious little ambushes and the massive shock of massed artillery, Pickett’s Charge slowed down. Slowing down just left them in the kill zone for that much longer.

When Pickett’s Charge reached the Emmitsburg Road, they were further delayed by the stiff fencing that lined it. As they clambered over it, Union infantry opened fire at long range. The casualties skyrocketed as the Confederate line absorbed the fire. If you want to know what it was like under fire, picture the start of a rainstorm. The water droplets go taptaptap tap taptaptap taptaptaptaptap taptaptaptaptap taptap taptaptaptaptaptap taptaptaptaptaptaptaptaptap... that's how the survivors described the musketry that pelted the fence they were trying to climb over. One small contingent of Davis’ brigade (you recall how roughly they were manhandled on July the 1st) accidentally got ahead of everybody else and found itself standing right in front of the Union line all alone. The guys closest to the Union defenses surrendered as one; the rest got shot up bad and ran for their lives.

Pickett’s Charge was pure chaos by then- their mile wide front that had surged forth from Spangler’s Wood had shrunk down to about a half mile, partly from taking casualties, partly from brigades running away after the shock of massed fire, and partly from bridges shifting north away from flanking fire from their right side.

From the fence line on the Emmitsburg to the stone wall that protected the Union defense was about two hundred yards. This is a long shot for a rifle, especially under pressure- that’s the whole point to volley fire, so that everybody shooting at once will create a sort of probability cloud of danger even at long range. Some Confederates, desperate to hit back after enduring hell, shot anyway. Their fire was ineffective. It is a very, very short shot for an artillery piece, even under pressure. A battery of cannons placed just behind the Union line switched to canister and blasted massive bloody holes in the bunched up Confederates.

A lot of Confederates huddled up behind the fencing and stayed put. It is marginally safer than moving two feet forward past the wooden railings, and the spirit had been knocked out of them by the mile long charge and the mile long shooting gallery they’d been subjected to. The left side of the attack had been stopped dead and turned back; the right side pushed on, disregarding any thought but closing distance. 1,500 men blitzed those last 200 yards to the stone wall

Scores of them died from rifle fire as the cannons reloaded.

The surviving Confederates, running on pure adrenaline, reached the stone wall at a place called the Bloody Angle. The Union line was disjointed, with the Northern section slightly back from the southern section. The Angle was the little joint that connected the two walls; it was also right by the copse of trees that everybody was racing towards.

A fierce firefight broke out once the Confederates reached the wall. Most of them stayed behind the wall; like their buddies to the west still behind the fence on the Emmitsburg pike, they’d finally found a few square feet that was sorta kinda safe, and every instinct they had in their brains screamed at them to stay there. The Union troops were outnumbered at the point of impact, and backed off in good order.

Reserve regiments were already marching up to plug the gap that didn’t exist yet. Units north and south of the Bloody Angle shifted in place to fire at the beachhead. Behind the Confederates on the Angle, there was a small ocean of blood on the ground and a mile long procession of silent, mangled dead and writhing, screaming wounded... but no follow on reinforcements to help exploit the breakthrough.

General Armistead, the only Confederate General there still on his feet, still believed in all that chivalrous Walter Scott romantic nonsense, still thought that raw valor and heart could somehow beat a superior enemy. He stuck his hat on his sword as a makeshift battle flag and rallied his men to leave the safety of the Bloody Angle and close distance.

Just as the pitifully few Confederates got on the east side of the wall, the cannons shot canister again and puked metal death all over them. After shooting, the artillerymen ran back to safety before the rebels could stagger up to them.

Hundreds of men surged forward by inertia; hundreds out of the 14,000 that they’d started with. They drove off the understrength Union regiments with the bayonet and capture those hated big guns, turning them around to use against the inevitable counterattack. This failed; there was no more ammo left for the guns. Colonel Hunt had measured out the number of rounds needed for the job at hand with the utmost precision.

The counterattack was messy and bloody for everybody involved, for the brawl saw everything available used as a weapon- bullets, bayonets, rifle butts, pistols, knives, rocks, boot heels, bare hands. But the Confederates all just dissolved after a short while. Nobody ordered a retreat; nobody was alive and of sufficient rank to order a retreat. Thousands just plopped down where they stood and waited for Union men to come out and collect them. They were too numb and exhausted to walk anymore. Others streamed back to safety in ones and twos.

For every Confederate who died, four more were maimed and crippled. For every wounded man, another was taken prisoner. It was an unmitigated disaster for the Confederate cause, and correspondingly it was a triumph of humanity as the stalwart defenders of the slave plantations died in droves. Remember, like I said, we’re rooting for the Union.

The battle wasn’t over, not really. Not was the campaign. But it certainly was decided.

————————————————————————

RIGHT SO

Interestingly, at first it was kind of ambiguous who won.

Meade got fired from the job after Lee got the Army of Northern Virginia home intact. Lincoln was seething that Meade hadn’t shown some aggression and had failed to destroy Lee’s army as he had been ordered. Meade, however, didn’t have much of an army at that point, just a diverse collection of units that had suffered 50% casualties and were in no condition to do anything. Moreover, there had been no way to bring the retreating Lee to battle without taking a lot of risks that might see all the good done at Gettysburg undone. Still though. Meade was out, and Grant, riding high after his conquest of Vicksburg, was in. Lee initially claimed victory in the Richmond papers, and it was hard to gainsay him at first. He had indisputably invaded north and thrashed the living shit out of the Army of the Potomac so bad that they could not invade again in 1863, which was indeed partly the point of the strategy.

But soon the facts of life made themselves clear. Lee had holes in his ranks that simply could not be filled anymore. Southerners didn’t want to die in a losing war, and coercing in them into the ranks through State violence only gave him shitty recruits who would desert the second they were put on guard duty. In contrast, tens of thousands of men poured into training depots across the nation, all armed and clothed and fed by the grandest industrial base in the world. Thousands of experienced veterans re-upped their contracts in Gettysberg’s wake to become these new recruits’ NCOs and commanding officers. Lee has gone north to break the will of the Union to continue the fight. Gettysburg had, if anything, demoralized the Confederacy and reinvigorated the Union instead. I do not believe that Gettysburg started this trend, but I do think it sped it up significantly. Patterns that might have taken a year to come to fruition instead took months.

Gettysburg, in my opinion, is significant not because of any great gains or losses on the material level, but because of its effects on the minds of voters and soldiers and politicians in the North and the South. To crib C. S. Lewis really quick, what matters was not whether a given action would take a specific hill, or seize a certain road; what matters is whether a given action pushes people to either dig their heels in and seek victory at any personal cost, or whether it pushes them to back down and seek a safer compromise. Gettysburg pushed all of the American people in the directions they were already heading down, that’s all. Any conclusion beyond that is on shaky ground, I feel.

Having said that, I shall now irrationally contradict myself; Gettysburg can also act as a Rorschach test with symbols and images and stories in lieu of the ink blots. Like I said, it’s a place of religious significance to me to an extent far beyond appreciation for its historic value.

I just don’t think it’s possible for that many people to die in such a short period of time, in so compact an area, and with such blunt contempt for the foreseen probability of violent death, and not leave an indelible and ineffable mark on the land itself. Like, if humanity went extinct and Earth got colonized by Betelgeusians a hundred years after, I am certain that the aliens would somehow feel a chill in their exoskeletons when they walk over the soft leaves and through the bare trees of Herbst Wood, or tromp around the south side of Little Round Top, or poke about on the steep slope of Culp's Hill, or splash across the Plum River in the Valley of Death.

I’m not saying I’m right, of course. But I am saying how I feel.


r/TheMotte • • Dec 13 '19

Even Space Marines Need Artillery Support: Why I like Warhammer 40k, but dislike Star Wars

222 Upvotes

Nineteenth platoon were about five hundred metres from Old Hive’s north entrance when they saw the gates close.

Skerral stopped in his tracks, and pulled the men up. Half his unit were dead. He ejected a cell from his lasrifle and slammed in a new one.

“Come on,” he said, turning back to face down the slope at the waves of assault sweeping in. “Let’s see how many we can kill.”

The remnants of nineteenth lasted seventeen minutes from the time the gates closed. They accounted for one hundred and eighty-nine enemy casualties. No one witnessed their heroism.

-Sabbat Martyr

No greater love hath a man than he lay down his life for his brother. Not for millions. Not for glory, not for fame.... For one person. In the dark. Where no one will ever know...

-Sebastian, Babylon 5

I quite like Warhammer 40k, and don't like Star Wars. In this post I'm going to attempt to delve down into why.

Before anything else, I want to tackle fascism element in the room. It's easy to look at Star Wars and 40k and conclude because one has the heroes be fascists, and the other has the heroes fight fascists, we can clearly divide up the two franchises as 40k = pro-Hitler and Star Wars = anti-Hitler. But I think this fails to appreciate the fact that 40k depicts fascism in all its hideousness. While Star Wars showcases fascism as it imagined itself to be, which is a far more dangerous meme.

Fascism in 40k is unbelievably dumb. Monstrously, painfully, mind-bendingly stupid. The Imperium of Man is going to die largely because it has been ruled by generations of fascists of various colors who should never been been put in charge of a potluck let alone a galaxy spanning empire. Some of the first words spoken by Roboute Guilliman upon his resurrection are:

Why do I still live? What more do you want from me? I gave everything I had to you, to them. Look what they've made of our dream. This bloated, rotting carcass of an empire is driven not by reason and hope but by fear, hate and ignorance. Better that we had all burned in the fires of Horus' ambition than live to see this.

Being a Nazi actively hurts the Imperium, and goodness only knows how many people have died in pursuit of xenophobia, ignorance, or blind hatred. Guilliman's attempts to drag the Imperium back into the light of reason and hope are the only realistic shot humanity has in the 41st millenium for survival. This mirrors our reality, where the Nazis - contrary to popular imagination - were kind of dysfunctional boobs who slowly ruined nearly every element of the country they inherited and actively undermined their own war efforts just to be evil. Albert Speer describes Hitler thusly, as one example:

Whenever I explained my organizational plans to Hitler, he showed a striking lack of interest. I had the impression that he did not like to deal with these questions; indeed, in certain realms he was altogether incapable of distinguishing the important from the unimportant. He also did not like establishing clear lines of jurisdiction. Sometimes he deliberately assigned bureaus or individuals the same or similar tasks. "That way," he used to say, "the stronger one does the job."

By contrast, fascism in Star Wars is hyper-competent. It's sleek, it's sexy, it makes the space-trains run on time. There is even a subreddit, the empire did nothing wrong, dedicated to empire apologism. The Empire in Star Wars is what real life Nazis probably imagined themselves as, unstoppable all powerful juggernauts who not only exterminate the lesser races but look dapper AF while doing it. I think this is a much more insidious concept, as it falsely paints fascism as a functional (or even superior) ideology that was only undermined via external effort - rather than a fundamentally toxic and broken system that would've killed itself in time even without outside intervention.

But with that out of the way, I'd like to get into specifics.

First, 40k feels much more realistic. Compare and contrast these two shorts:

Mace Windu vs. a bunch of clone troopers

A section of Space Marines assault a rebel ship

This dedication to at least superficial realism gives the action of 40k much more weight. Mace Windu is wearing a bathrobe and carries a sword, and is constantly getting himself surrounded to no meaningful effect. Meanwhile the Space Marines are armed with actual sensible equipment and frequently employ good tactics to overcome their problems. Flanking a heavy gun emplacement, smoking out an entrenched position, using suppressing fire to pin the enemy while other members of the team maneuver into position to take them down. Of course none of this actually is realistic - Space Marines are still 8 foot tall super soldiers wearing a literal ton of armor who fight with chainsaw swords - but the verisimilitude of 40k makes the outlandish elements feel all the more engaging as a contrast.

Of course 40k used to be a lot sillier and more Star Wars like. Early editions of the setting had the Imperial Guard behaving like boobs, Space Marines being space monks, etc. etc. But over time Games Workshop has learned that the setting is more fun when you make sure to maintain a veneer of competence around everyone. Space Marines should not be fanatical brutes, instead they should be highly trained professionals. The Imperial Guard shouldn't behave like dumb dumbs (that's the PDF's job), but instead like well drilled soldiers. This makes these characters so much more fun and gives the writers so much more room to get the audience invested.

A book that depicts the imperial guard as a competent, disciplined fighting force can get so much more impact out of their trials and tribulations than a book that depicts them as an army of irrelevant redshirts. I care what happens to General Strauss' army, because by giving them intelligence and courage they also make them "worthy" of my emotional investment. In a way I will never care about stormtroopers, with their dumb tactics and awful aim and general idiocy.

Second, 40k is a universe built on teamwork and cooperation to overcome insurmountable obstacles - while Star Wars celebrates individuals to the expense of everyone else.

The average human in the 41st millennium is a pathetic nothing. An Ork could easily crush a person up into a little ball and drop kick them a hundred yards. Space Marines, despite being super soldiers hundreds of years old each more valuable than a dozen main battle tanks, are not actually that much better off. One Ork boy is a fairly reasonable match against one tactical marine in melee, and there are billions and billions of Orks - many of whom are able to casually snip a marine in two with one snap of their snip snapper

Instead humanity survives via teamwork. One human is a pathetic nothing, but 10,000 humans all working together as one unit is something else entirely. And then add in well coordinated artillery support, and suddenly the orks - despite being so much stronger on an individual level - aren't doing so great. The common man and woman of the Imperium standing together as one, against all the horrors the galaxy can throw at them, are a true force to be reckoned with. Space Marines are similar - for all their speed and strength and armor, in 40k they must rely on cooperation to have any realistic hope of survival against the monsters that prowl the battlefield. Against a Bloodthrister of Khorne, even a space marine is tiny and pathetic and only stands a chance if his battle brothers have his back.

The enemies of the Imperium tend to be bigger, tougher, stronger on an individual level, but none of them have the Imperium's coordination and team work and that is what continually allows humanity to eek out victories.

40k, despite its grimdark exterior, is fundamentally a universe where people coming together and believing in each other and fighting for one another is the only way to survive. It's a setting where the individual common man or woman truly matters, and helps decide the fate of battles and wars and empires. Though courage and intelligence and loyalty any random citizen of the Imperium can make a difference.

....it all brings a smile to my egalitarian heart.

On the other side of things, Star Wars is a galaxy full of a small number of super elite special people who are simply more important than everyone else combined. The fate of the entire galaxy is decided when Luke Skywalker, alone, goes off to confront the Empire. The Republic was doomed when one person, Anakin, fell to the dark side. The deathstar was destroyed when the well-coordinated Rebel assau - hahaha no that's not how things work in this universe. The Death star was blown up because one of the super special awesome people happened to be sitting among the horde of ineffectual nobodies who got sent on the mission. Star Wars, at its core, is one of the most elitist settings in science fiction. Wars are won, politics are changed, empires are toppled almost exclusively through the actions of a tiny number of super people and every other person in the galaxy may as well sit and spin for all it matters.

Mace Windu, from the above clip, single-handedly taking on hordes of droids alone is typical of the setting. He is a super special awesome person, and the droids are not, therefore he is invulnerable to them. Another example is this comci page, which I admit is cool but does fundamentally underline the profoundly elitist character of Star Wars. If you're not special, you absolutely do not matter at all - even if you have the special person utterly surrounded and have every gun in the world pointed at them. They're special, you're not, so they win and you lose. End of story.

This idea even extends to the weapons and equipment. In 40k, Imperial forces rely on grenades, bullets, laser power packs, missiles, body armor. All things other people need to manufacture and ship to them. Without a vast support network enabling them, the average Imperial soldier (be they guardsmen, marine or even grey knight) is pretty much dead as a dodo. Again emphasizing the core theme of the setting that cooperation drives strength, as much as individual ability.

By contrast the warriors of Star Wars fight with laser swords and wear robes - meaning they don't need to rely on anyone but themselves to be effective. They need no logistics, they need no support network. In many cases they don't even need transport, as all Jedi also happen to be expert fighter pilots for whatever reason. Which similarly emphasizes the Star Wars theme of individual superiority and the irrelevancy of groups.

Third, the nature of heroism.

My favorite moment in any video game is from an indie title called "Bastion", from the company Super Giant Games. The moment comes near the end of the game, so spoilers!

The world has ended in an apocalypse, and you and a small band of survivors are trying to put back the pieces. You find Zulf among the wreckage, and take him into your group as one of your own despite the fact that he comes from an enemy tribe (the Ura). Later, it's revealed the apocalypse was caused by your people's attempt to build a super weapon to commit genocide against Zulf's people. Zulf, in a rage, smashes the little community you've managed to put back together and runs off to join his own. You seek him out, fixing the damage he's caused along the way, on a mission of revenge. Finally you find him, nearly dead, as his own tribe has turned on him in desperation as he brought you down on their heads. You're offered the chance to leave him to his well-deserved fate, or throw down your weapons and drag his unconscious body to safety through unknown miles of enemy territory.

The world of the Bastion is hard and cruel, and what everyone (probably even your character) expects is that trying to save Zulf would kill you both. The Ura are deadly warriors, and your people tried to commit genocide against them - you personally are drenched in the blood of countless Ura sons and daughters. Trying to drag Zulf through their territory unarmed is then almost certainly a death sentence - you cannot hide and you will find certainly find no mercy. The key here, what makes what ultimately happens so meaningful, is this expectation of failure and the player's choice to do it anyway. You have two paths diverging, one letting you continue down the road of war and justified revenge - and the other lets you cast aside a hundred years of atrocities and hate and death just to try and save one single person. Not someone important or powerful or special, but someone who betrayed you. Someone who shattered your only hope of building back what was lost. Someone who probably will still loathe you after this is all over, no matter what you do.

If you do decide to rescue him anyway this is what happens. In the end, after everything that happened, after all the terrible things you've done to each other, you throw Zulf on your back and try to save his life. Not for glory, not for power, not even as a bargaining chip - but purely because Zulf was your friend. And you have decided that friendship means more than hate. The world is miserable and people are traitorous bastards, but none of this will ever get any better if no one is willing to sacrifice for a higher ideal. Someone has to be better than the world they were born into. Someone has to teach the world to be better than it is.

What makes this moment so meaningful is the expectation of failure. You expected being a good person would hurt you, and yet you did it anyway. You had nothing to gain, everything to lose, and still decided to be the better man. That makes it so much more powerful, I think, than if you knew before hand the Ura would throw down their weapons and everything would turn out alright and there would be cake at the end. To be a hero in a world that rewards heroism, to be brave on a world that celebrates bravery, is I think not so impressive. You risked little being a good person, and so it counts for little. It is easy to be a saint in paradise. But to be a saint in hell, and remain saintly, is so much greater an accomplishment.

Star Wars is very much unlike Bastion. Star Wars heroes fall backwards into easy victories, just need to "believe in themselves" and gold medals and hot chocolate will be theirs. There is an expectation of fame and glory and success in being a hero in Star Wars, a casual assurance everything will turn out all right in the end. You may lose a hand, your moisture farmer care takers may be reduced to skeletons, but there's never any real doubt the force will prevail and goodness will reign and at the 11th hour the cavalry will show up and spare you from making any truly difficult sacrifices.

In 40k, by contrast, you will not be rewarded in any way if you stand up and try to do the right thing. Indeed the galaxy will almost certainly punish you for it. Your heroism will see you eaten by alien locusts. Your bravery will have your soul sucked out by murderous elves. You will suffer and die alone and forgotten on some distant world if you act with courage.

This makes 40k's good guys shine so much brighter to me, similar to the protagonist of the Bastion above. They see an army of demons, and a hab complex containing 12,000 innocent people, and they stand in between the two despite knowing they will die horribly. And not just die - die alone and afraid and with no one ever seeing their courage. All the civilians will know is the demonic advance was slowed for a handful of minutes, and that it bought time for perhaps a few hundred more to escape. But they do it anyway, because even in the grimdarkness of the 41st millennium...there are still heroes.

This ties back into the fascism discussion at the start as well. Because 40k protagonists do tend to be such incandescently heroic people, the fact that the overarching society they live in is fascistic is somewhat countered by their example. Our protagonists are solely motivated to help innocent people, and usually react with a mix of horror and rage that - as an example - their senior commander is wasting desperately needed munitions "purifying" a population center. Not only are you killing innocent people, you're making it harder for us to defend this other group of innocent people. You unbelievably massive jerk!

Finally, let's talk about Rogue One. Oh Rogue One, how I love you. It's the one Star Wars movie I've ever seen that abandons nearly every problem I have with the Star Wars universe and tells a story truly worthy of being a 40k novel. Our heroes aren't Jedi, or emperors, or darth anythings, they're just a bunch of random nobodies. Who come together and support each other and strike a blow against evil, despite evil having super elite special people on their side. Their strength and courage enables the rebellion to take down the death star, although they never live to see it. It's noble and beautiful and the fact that most Star Wars fans despise it strikes me as both completely understandable (it's a betrayal of the core principles of the franchise) and desperately unfortunate (I want more stuff like Rogue One!). "Your father would be proud of you" best line any Star Wars movie ever, 100%.

So that is why, in vastly too many words, I prefer 40k to Star Wars. This isn't a super serious post or anything, I'm just kind of bored and felt like typing something up to give my fingers some exercise. Star Wars fans feel free to fire back, btw.


r/TheMotte • • Jun 22 '20

Mormons and Voluntary Organization: Much More Than You Wanted To Know

216 Upvotes

By my estimate, throughout my life before leaving Mormonism, I spent somewhere around 15,000 hours on activities directly related to the religion. That translates to something around two hours of time daily on religious activity. Granted, this includes a two-year mission, but the estimate still only includes the time directly spent working during that time, not eating or sleeping. Take that out of the equation, and you're still left with around an hour a day through the rest of my life.

For something around 3% of that time, 500 hours of religious courses I got the dubious honor of attending in lieu of a regular elective high school course, I was around someone who was being paid for their work. Every other moment, it was volunteers all the way down.

That's my normal, the water I swam in. It occurs to me, though, that the intricacies of Mormon organizational structure might not be quite so legible to people who didn't swim through them for their entire life.

It's fascinating stuff, though, or at least it's been clattering around my mind enough that I need to inflict it on someone else. Either way, it's yours to enjoy now.


I.

Think of a famous Mormon.

Yeah, Mitt Romney will do just fine. Well done if you picked out some random like Clayton Christensen or Stephen Covey instead, though. I'll get to them too as I roll through a list of Mormon leadership roles. No women, I'm afraid: Mormon women, as a song an army of six-year-olds sang to me once reminds us, are to care and nurture, not to preside1, except over women and children. Explaining their role will have to wait.

1 (This isn't the time and place for this discussion, but some Mormon children's songs are something else. Take this one. Instructed young, indeed. Brainwashed, my fellow exmos would grumble, not really inaccurately. Catchy tune, though.)

The fascinating thing about being a visible, high-achieving, capable Mormon man is that you're really just playing Russian Roulette with your free time. No matter what you're doing or how busy you are, there's always a good chance that one day you'll pick up the phone and be saddled with an extra twenty to thirty hours of unpaid labor a week for half a decade or so. Going back to Romney, his experience is about typical for a successful Mormon businessman. Most notably, he spent five years as a bishop and another eight as a stake president.

A bishop is something akin to a pastor: leader of a local church group (ward) of some 100-500 people. He doesn't preach directly much more than anyone else, but he organizes weekly church meetings, assigns local members to a dizzying array of positions and responsibilities, and regularly counsels members who are struggling or interviews the ones who are due for their intermittent checkups. Still paying your 10%? Still not smoking, drinking, or sexing? Still believe in all this? That sort of thing.

Stake presidents are the middle managers of Mormonism, keeping tabs on a dozen or so wards, assigning new bishops and similar positions, making a bunch of sometimes-inspirational speeches, and handling problems that escalate beyond the level of bishops.

Neither position requires advance training. Well, a correction: Almost no unpaid positions in Mormonism require or provide advance training. They're just loaded up onto busy professionals with full-time work and usually a squad of kids2, who can sink or swim at their leisure from there. In Romney's case, it meant managing Bain Capital during worktime and a bunch of Mormons during his personal time. And so, you know, he just shrugged and did it. Why not, right?

2 (Think you can get out of marrying by snagging a leadership position like in Catholicism? Not a chance. Pretty much every position at the level of bishop or above is only open to married men.)

Clayton Christensen, while teaching at Harvard and presenting his case for disruptive innovation, got thrown into more-or-less the next level of Mormon leadership as an 'Area Seventy', in charge of administrative work and preaching over a large region, like Asia or Utah. In his case, it was northeast North America. He also spent a few years as a bishop, of course.

That's still a bit less demanding than one of Stephen Covey's roles, though. Before sliding into the public eye as a self-help writer, he was assigned as a mission president. In other words, he was asked to move to Ireland to spend three years babysitting some 150 young missionaries, inspiring, instructing, directing them around, and generally keeping the whole project from falling apart. I'm not sure the standard at the time he went, but at least recently, mission presidents do get a four-day seminar before being sent out to keep things running.

Finally, we get to global leadership, the general authorities of the church, and the first full-time, compensated positions. With a few exceptions, these have historically been too wrapped up in their Mormon-specific roles to be particularly visible to the world at large. You've got the seventies, who do the same thing as the area seventies discussed above but on a global scale. There are currently around 105 of them, as you'd expect from the name. At the very top, you've got the quorum of the twelve apostles, a group comprised of fifteen men if you include the first presidency and the president (or prophet) of the church.

Probably the most historically relevant apostle from a non-Mormon angle was Ezra Taft Benson, who served as Eisenhower's secretary of agriculture while leading the church. If you're looking for some light reading on obscure Mormon political drama (and who isn't!), I recommend this treatise describing the quiet wrestling match over the apostolic narrative throughout his tenure thanks to his increasingly extreme right-wing views and eagerness to use his platform to raise political topics in church meetings. He even almost made it onto a presidential ticket, first with Strom Thurmond and then with George Wallace, but the prophet at the time nixed it.

Anyway, most of the seventies and all the apostles hold their positions full-time until the day they die, traveling around the world, holding [mandatory biannual ten-hour meetings](https://www.wikiwand.com/en/General_Conference_(LDS_Church)) (General Conference) for all church members, speaking for God, and so forth. When one president dies, the longest-serving apostle takes his place. For their trouble, they get an annual stipend of around $120000 each and the reverent awe of Mormons everywhere.

The great majority of the global leaders are men, with the exception of the Relief Society presidency (leaders of the women's organization) and the Primary presidency (in charge of kids 0-12). In 2013, a woman prayed in General Conference for the first time, so that's something.

To summarize: The prophet and apostles appoint new apostles and seventies, the general seventies and apostles appoint area seventies and mission presidents, the area seventies appoint stake presidents, the stake presidents appoint bishops, and the bishops appoint every local member to all the roles needed to keep everything running. Nobody can volunteer for any position, and while technically they can say no if asked, it's considered bad form. Nobody gets paid except the mostly very old men who are in charge of the whole affair.

Aside from restrictions like being a man and having a wife, there aren't many limits on who can be appointed to which position when. Often someone will spend a while as a bishop or something, then be placed into a quietly useful minor role somewhere in the ward. In practice, getting noticed tends to breed more getting noticed, and someone successful at one level will drift upwards for a while and then rotate through assorted high-level administrative roles.


II.

Most of all that is quite distant from your everyday member, of course. You see your bishop weekly, your stake president a couple times a year, and watch the general authorities on TV while forlornly playing bingo and trying not to fall asleep too obviously. What does life look like if you're not a member of Mormon royalty?

Much the same, really. There's always stuff to do. You're assigned to a ward strictly geographically. No choice in the matter. You're with whoever you're around. Sometimes, the boundaries will be redrawn, and people you saw every week for years disappear from your life without ever physically moving. Growing up, I knew almost everyone in my ward, and almost nobody outside of it. During my time in the church, I spent time as a councillor in the various Mormon youth groups, a pianist and organist, (briefly) a teacher, an assistant clerk (in charge of the ever-thrilling task of keeping membership records up to date and processing some payments), and of course a full-time missionary. Missionairies do a little of almost everything in the church and have their own involved internal leadership structure, with more experienced missionairies getting put in as 'district leaders', 'zone leaders', and the universally adored Assistants to the President.

Back in my day, church meetings were three hours long, which have since been shortened to two hours for active members and zero hours for me. The first hour or so involves a few group songs, a bunch of the youth passing sacrament (communion) around, and speeches (always 'talks' in Mormon parlance) prepared by whichever lay members were unlucky enough to get a call from the bishop that week, usually starting with the dictionary definition of whatever they were supposed to talk about and an anecdote about how they hardly had time to prepare after getting a call from the bishop that week. The second hour (and third, he mutters) sees everyone divide up into small groups and alternates between a lesson on whichever of the Old Testament, New Testament, Mormon Testament Book of Mormon, and modern scripture is being covered that year and sex-divided meetings where they talk about whatever.

Oh, and it's the exact same format everywhere in the world, but sometimes meetings get out of sync by a week or so. It was always funny to go on vacation and sit there slowly realizing you'd studiously avoided hearing the same lesson a week before.

Don't think Mormons get out of it with just the Sunday meetings, either. Teenage boys and girls meet in sex-segregated groups one evening a week for whatever activities or instruction their leadership has come up with. Sometimes you get lucky and go on cool campouts or run around in the woods throwing flour bombs at each other. Other times, you get what's basically a fourth hour of church. Every Monday night, meanwhile, families are expected to meet together and have a church-focused activity night. Again, hit or miss depending on how much initiative everyone's feeling. Daily family scripture study and prayer is standard, and feeling guilty because you can never quite get in the habit of individual scripture study or prayer is its accompanying long-time tradition.

Nope, still not the end. I already mentioned religion classes for high school students. Utah students (that is, me) get them carved into their school days, and typically have a 'seminary building' just off school property so they can go study while maintaining official separation of church and state. Every other poor sap gets to wake up early every day to yawn through a bunch of church instruction before school. Thankfully, it's since been changed, but back in my day Mormons also had "home (or visiting, if you're a woman) teaching", where they were assigned a few local families to visit, chat with, and share a short spiritual message with. Much of the time, this just meant feeling guilty because you didn't actually get it done.

Members are also in charge of building upkeep and cleaning on a rotating schedule. They get very, very good at setting up chairs and coming up with excuses to avoid Saturday morning church cleaning. Finally, on no set schedule beyond "as often as possible", they're encouraged to go to the temple to perform tasks like the much-maligned baptism for the dead, or watching the same video again and again on behalf of those same dead people. ...It's complicated.

There's more. There's always more. I didn't even cover things like helping out the missionaries, ward activities, or reaching out to your less-active brothers and sisters to bring them back into the fold. But that's the overview of what you can expect the structure of life for an average Mormon to look like. Everyone has an assignment (sorry, 'calling'), or is supposed to have one. Everyone has a bunch of extra-assignment tasks. There is always, always something more a good, obedient Mormon can do in the church.


III.

Right, so now I've dragged you through more detail on the bureaucracy of Mormonism than you were ever planning to know. Congratulations. But why am I bothering to lay it all out like this? What am I hoping to prove?

Well, I'm not aiming specifically either to praise or condemn it in broad strokes. A lot of it is weird from an outside view, and a lot feels dated, to say the least. Plenty of important and true criticisms can be levied. What I'll say is that this was my childhood. It had a lot of good, a lot of bad, and a lot that was simply mundane. It felt perfectly normal at the time, for better or worse, and now that I'm out I'm mostly just fascinated that the whole thing exists and functions just about as well as any other organization. And I think other people should be, too.

There are a few things to highlight here:

1. The active, training-oriented structure.

A great deal of time in Mormonism is spent listening to untrained and often unskilled volunteers deliver messages straight from a manual. That's the downside. The upside is that, even though there's only a limited formal training structure, members are constantly put in positions to practice and perhaps even improve at various group-focused skills. I miss opportunities to give speeches, honestly. It was a lot of fun to practice public speaking in a low-threat venue of a few hundred people. Everything, more or less, is like that. It all ends up building on itself one way or another. Kids get sent out on missions, maybe convert a few people, maybe stay converted themselves, and return with solid doctrinal understanding, leadership experience, and exposure to thousands of randoms to train their social skills and persuasion on. Leaders get a chance to demonstrate their efficacy and get siphoned wherever they're needed. At every level, Mormons have a startlingly extensive pool of reasonably experienced talent ready to handle whatever the religion needs.

2. The sheer absurdity of it all.

I'm not talking about the origin story or anything like that here. I'm talking about the extent to which people are willing to spend their spare time and energy on all this stuff. I met a professional athlete during my mission. Know what he was doing at church? Helping out with the youth program he'd been assigned to. Another time, my bishop was a construction worker. Since the whole thing exists as a parallel structure only loosely connected to the rest of life, you just get tossed in with a group of randoms and make do with whatever you have. Sometimes it works great, other times it feels like it's constantly being held together by shoestrings and if you blink the whole thing will fly apart, but everywhere you go, it all comes together into something functional.

3. Some uses and limitations.

One of the features of a structure like this is that, when something needs to get done in the community, disaster response or helping a member in rough times, you know exactly who can get things done, how to organize, where to find a bunch of sometimes-eager, sometimes-grudging voluntolds to take care of things. When you already have a group used to coming together all the time for any reason or no reason at all, things that actively require that sort of community become a lot smoother. The extensive repetition of the same messages and constant contact with the same people is the structure culture is built of. Everyone gets enmeshed in it, everyone finds a role and a responsibility,

Of course, the church also has a tendency to be inward-focused, getting members to spend so much time working on church-related things that their time for outward-directed, non-church activities is sharply reduced. Not only that, by nature of its religious mission and origins, a lot of the activities tend to be a bit quixotic, where even as members feel or convince themselves of benefits and positive impacts, from a secular perspective they're mostly just spinning their wheels. Temple activities like baptism for the dead are an obvious example here. So much time and energy, spent on basically nothing from a secular standpoint.

That it works is remarkable. That it even excels in some areas, more remarkable still. But I'm convinced it's far from optimal. There's so much more that could be done.


IV.

Can another organization emulate this sort of structure exactly? Should it? In particular, is it possible to encourage that sheer level of commitment without the infinite carrot and stick of commands from an omnipotent deity? Should that level of commitment be encouraged?

I don't know that I can really answer yes to all, or any, of those questions. Stepping out of Mormonism into the rest of US culture, though, it feels like two different but quietly parallel worlds. I think people underestimate just how different things are for Mormons. It's night and day. And right now, while we avoid many of the problems that creep into the structure of Mormonism, my own feeling is that we develop an opposite and parallel set of problems: too little organization, too little structure, too few people willing to call for involved activities outside of settings where we're buying and selling our time. In a world full of Mormons, I'd say—hey, might be worth loosening up a little. In the world we have? There are worse things to notice than the Mormons.

The structure of Mormonism isn't a panacea for the world's problems, but I'm convinced that there are lessons to draw from it nonetheless.

Thanks for reading.

Until next time.


r/TheMotte • • Nov 27 '19

The Ins and Outs of the Kilmichael Ambush

215 Upvotes

“They discussed the Irish Question; but they never seriously contemplated the Irish Answer.”

-G. K. Chesterton, Irish Impressions 1919

99 years ago, on November 28, 1920, 36 IRA men under the command of Tom Barry laid an ambush just south of Kilmichael in West Cork for an 18 man British patrol and slaughtered them. 16 of the paramilitary policemen were killed outright. One was wounded, stumbled away from the carnage to seek shelter, and was summarily executed with his own weapon by two IRA men (not involved with the ambush) who were hiding nearby. The last one so severely injured that the IRA shooters thought he was dead; 24 hours later, he was scooped up by his comrades from the ambush site and nursed back to health to give the only British recollection of the fight.

It was the largest and bloodiest IRA action of the Anglo-Irish war. It was thought that the British superiority of numbers, logistics, and equipment made any stand up fight hopeless and so dictated that the IRA must skulk about sniping at tower guards and hitting isolated individuals and teams. 18 veteran soldiers being gunned down in the blink of an eye by some backwoods bushwhacker gang seemed to change everything.

—————————————————————

The Military and Political Situation in Ireland

I am going to attempt to give the background to the Anglo-Irish War of 1919-1921 in as broad of strokes as possible. My intent is to maintain focus on the ambush itself, which precludes delving too deeply into politics. However, military actions are welded firmly to political goals, and any discussion of fighting that does not give political context to them is inherently incomplete. Let them this extremely brief description suffice to satisfy both purposes.

As it stood at the end of the nineteenth century, Ireland was part of the UK the same as Wales, Scotland, and England, and was therefore represented within the British Parliament. For various reasons that convinced a decent sized majority of Irishmen (and a fair number of other ethnicities within the UK), people became convinced that Ireland needed its own Parliament to pass its own laws in order to prosper, which would give it a measure of self-sovereignty within the British Empire on par with Canada or Australia. Accordingly, Ireland had been demanding more and more insistently for Home Rule. For a variety of reasons which would needlessly elongate this section, Britain alternatively refused point blank to grant it and made false promises that Home Rule was just around the corner.

On Easter 1916, a coalition of Nationalists and Socialists joined forces in a rebellion centered in Dublin city to shove the envelope as far as it could go, asserting that mere Home Rule was insufficient. They declared the birth of a new Irish Republic, as distinct from Britain as France or Germany was.

The Easter Uprising in 1916 was utterly crushed by the superior British infantry and artillery within a few short weeks, but when the Nationalist leadership who had dared to declare independence right in the middle of the Great War were executed, their martyrdom sparked mass sympathy among the populace of Ireland. In 1918, the separatist party Sinn Fein ("Ourselves Alone") campaigned for Parliament seats on the promise they would secede from the UK if elected. They won the vote and, true to their word, they seceded to form their own Irish Parliament. The British naturally disagreed that such an action was legal or indeed possible and so declared Sinn Fein an outlaw political party. They sent troops over again to dismantle the nascent government and to keep order in the face of the simmering, belligerent rebellion, which in turn led the provisional government of the Irish Republic to organize resistance in 1919. Local militia units across the country, who swore allegiance to the Irish Republic as proclaimed on Easter Sunday 1916, formed a loose and decentralized guerrilla movement; the armed wing of the Republican movement was named, fittingly, the Irish Republican Army. The decentralization was necessary, for the leaders of IRA had no reliable and secure lines of communication and supply to their soldiers spread throughout the country. Every population center self-generated its own cadre of leaders and fighters and conducted the fighting as it saw fit- the West Cork IRA was for all intents and purposes on its own. The violence bubbled up sporadically in fits and starts as the various police, paramilitary, and military units loyal to the Crown feuded with the various “flying columns” of the IRA. The same population that had voted for Sinn Fein mostly supported the Republican cause, and this conviction only deepened when naked violence was employed against them to root out the insurgent forces.

On November 21st 1920, the de facto Commander-in-Chief of the IRA Michael Collins upped the ante of violence. Acting at last on two years' worth of carefully collected and organized information of enemy identities and movements, he sent assassins to murder every British intelligence agent and informant he could find, which turned out to be about 21 men all killed on the same morning, mostly at their own doorstep without warning. This stroke of violence not only shocked the British, it would also leave them blinded and almost incapable of detecting IRA members and helpers for the rest of the war. The British backlash was clumsy, emotional, and undisciplined. That same afternoon after Collins’ gunmen did their bloody work, the Dublin Auxiliary branch of the Royal Irish Constabulary surrounded a Gaelic football match with the apparent intent to mass search all 5,000 of them for weapons. Someone starting shooting, so all his mates started shooting, machine guns opened up on the crowd, and it was all in all about a minute and a half of pure craziness. 14 civilians died and about 65 were injured. ”Bloody Sunday” marked a significant uptick in the level of violence in Ireland.

Tom Barry of the West Cork IRA Brigade would match it just one week later at Kilmichael.

—————————————————————

So Who Are These People, Anyway?

The Auxiliary Division of the Royal Irish Constabulary were recruited and formed in 1920 to add firepower and spine to the Royal Irish Constabulary, who were trying to suppress the insurgents. Demographically, the Auxiliaries had a type. They were all former Army officers, mostly jumped up from the enlisted ranks in the First World War for valor and to fill dead men's shoes- not many blue blooded noblemen among them. They averaged about three years in the trenches each. They sprang primarily from the lower and upper middle class, the sons of merchants and shopkeepers. Ethnically, they were almost a perfect cross section of the UK with Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and England being proportionately represented. Barring one or two individuals, none of them had criminal records. The average age was around 30 years old. They simply couldn't find work after the war ended and so jumped at chance to serve in Ireland.

The men of the IRA also had a type. They were mostly young men from a working class or laborer background. Most had avoided the First World War, unwilling to die for a country that denied them Home Rule, though Tom Barry himself was an exception that tested this rule; he had served in the British Army in Iraq before his exposure to Republican politics following the 1916 Easter Uprising, and had been initially distrusted in the IRA for flying the British flag over his home when he returned home. They were overwhelmingly Catholic, though interestingly there were a couple of Protestant members scattered here and there.

In the face of the experienced and well-equipped British war machine, the IRA’s primary task was to survive, for as long as they could produce “flying columns” of guerrilla fighters to harass the British forces, assassinate British civil servants, and intimidate loyalist informers, the cost of the war to the government would act as a powerful inducement to recognize Irish sovereignty. They therefore rarely took any immense risks that might lead their units to being cornered and wiped out; they could afford to have individual volunteers snatched up, arrested, and often killed, but the apparatus that recruited, organized, and directed them was fragile and almost irreplaceable.

—————————————————————

The Ambush Itself

To set the stage for the Kilmichael Ambush, the West Cork Auxiliaries based in Macroom were out raiding after Bloody Sunday. They hopped in their lorries every day and rode out to burn homes, terrorize women and children, assault men with rifle butts and pistol grips for speaking Irish, and murder suspected members of Sinn Fein in cold blood. That's the folk memory of how the Auxiliaries conducted counter-insurgency, and it is relatively accurate in spite of frequent exceptions. Much has been said about their brutality and lawlessness, framing them as a bunch of psychotic, sadistic hooligans. Like many stereotypes, this is based on reality, but there are many reasons to cast some doubt on the folk memory of the Auxiliaries. Many of their barn burnings and raids and killings were said to be official British policy, and this was a solid 25 years before army men found out that "just following orders" was a not a proper excuse. According to one IRA spy named who had embedded in their ranks as a sleeper agent, they were mostly good guys, but about 10% were "bad eggs"; obviously, the actions of a "bad egg" wearing a distinct uniform will be attributed to everyone wearing the uniform. Counter-insurgency too has the tendency to bring out the worst in people, as the frustration of dealing with a hostile population and not being able to separate the guerrillas from the civilians takes its toll. Finally, they are often conflated and confused with their sister unit of the Royal Irish Constabulary Special Reserve (known slangily as the Black and Tans, because their uniform was an irregular mix of army khaki and police black), who were also paramilitaries recruited from the army to bolster the police presence, but who were a) recruited from the enlisted ranks, not the officers; b) far more deserving off their reputation for brutality and lawlessness; and c) far more numerous than the Auxiliaries. These distinctions and mitigating traits were, of course, blurred a bit for the population who suffered under state sanctioned violence.

Tom Barry paints this specific ambush as an absolute necessity for the war effort. As long as the Auxiliaries can roam at will and terrorize entire counties with impunity, the population that the IRA depends on for sustainment (food, clothing, shelter, intelligence, volunteers, etc) will start to waver in their support. After all, if the IRA can’t fight back, why allow our houses to burn and our children to be threatened by armed men? What’s the point of declaring independence if we lack the strength to defend ourselves? From there, it’s but a short skip and a jump to “Why am I giving up the last of the food in our larder to provide dinner to a group of raggedy insurgents?” and “It’ll go easier on all of us if we give the police the names and home addresses of the guys in the flying column,” at which point the war is basically lost. As such, a dramatic counter strike was desperately needed.

Through intelligence given by sympathetic locals, Tom Barry noticed that the Auxiliaries were committing the cardinal sin of counter-insurgency work; they fell into a predictable pattern, taking the same route home every night. There were two stretches of their route where they were vulnerable, but one was far too close to a British outpost filled with reinforcements for comfort. The other was a country road just south of Kilmichael.

I have made an effort to recreate the ambush that Tom Barry planned: an improvised L-shaped ambush. For those who never lovingly leafed through FM 7-85 “Ranger Unit Operations”, chapter 6 of it describes it succinctly: [“The L-shaped ambush is formed with the base (bottom) of the L perpendicular to the expected enemy direction of advance. This is a good ambush for a road, jungle trail, or an area where the enemy is canalized and his approach route is known.”] (https://i.imgur.com/Ae4u2bu.gif) Indeed, this matches the situation to a tee. I have no idea if Tom Barry instinctively sussed out how to set up a decent ambush from first principles or if he picked up the concept during his stint in the British Army. I suppose it hardly matters.

He divided up his force of 36 fighters into three distinct sections with some minor detachments. They were armed with captured rifles, shotguns, revolvers, bayonets, and a couple of grenades.

His three man “Command Post” (helpfully and expertly marked on my screenshot of Google Maps) adopted concealment behind a stone wall to the east of the ambuscade, staring west down the headlights of the advancing lorries. This CP would form the little leg of the L of the L-shaped ambush. Their task was to instigate the firing, for to preserve the element of surprise nobody would occupy their fighting positions until after the CP opened fire.

Section 1 with ten men was positioned mere yards away on the reverse slope of a big boulder, unable to see anything until they stood up and inched forward to peer over the top. They would function as the lower part of the long leg of the L of the L-shaped ambush, tasked with pouring flanking fire into the lorry once it was stopped. They would also be the assaulting element once the ambush was sprung.

Section 2 with ten men was strung out along the military crest of the hillside, hidden and protected by the rocky terrain. They would be the upper part of the long leg of the L. Once the patrol was fixed in place, they were to engage the second lorry in the convoy. I have no clear idea where exactly they were ensconced in, hence the question marks.

Section 3 was divided up into two groups, which I have arbitrarily labeled group A and B. Group A with six men was stationed behind some rocks to the south of the road in case the Auxiliaries dismounted and sprinted into cover on that side- trying to solve a problem before it developed, you see. Google maps shows no rocks that they could plausibly hide behind as Tom Barry said they did, so I’m not clear on where exactly they were either. I’m assuming that the field to the south has been cleared in the decades since the ambush, because this contemporaneous photo shows that the terrain south of the road was far rockier than it is today. Group B, also six men, were held in reserve somewhere north of the ambush site- they were expecting two trucks, but if there was a third or a fourth then Section 3B was tasked with maneuvering against them to prevent them from interfering with the ambush.

The remaining men were spread as scouts in all directions to provide security and advance warning of enemy movement. Tom Barry himself would take center stage, standing openly in the road in between the CP and Section 1; he's the green dot on the linked map. We’ll get to his role shortly.

This ambush was notable in two ways. First, it would be conducted at excruciatingly close range. The disparity of training between the IRA and the Auxiliaries was considerable. Due to ammunition shortages, there had only been enough bullets to allow each IRA man four live bullets to practice their aim before sending him into action, in contrast to the hundreds and thousands of rounds shot to hone marksmanship in the British army. Since there really aren’t any sharpshooters at a distance of five to ten yards- you either line up your sights onto the target or you don’t- the chosen tactics and starting positions neutralized the British advantage in arms.

Second, and very much related to the first, Tom Barry deliberately violated the cardinal rule of guerrilla warfare by selecting an ambush site with no easy exit. Every other premeditated skirmish they had ever staged had had an escape route to take if things went wrong. This time, however, neither the Auxiliaries nor the IRA would have any plausible opportunity to break contact after the first shot was fired. It was going to be (as Tom Barry gravely informed his men as they set up the ambush) a fight to the death- either the Auxiliary patrol gets wiped out, or the flying column perishes. To raise the stakes even higher, the West Cork Brigade were neither numerous nor well-stocked with weapons. At no point in the war did Tom Barry and his men have access to more than 116 rifles, and those 36 men were the cream of the crop of the whole county. If killed, and their weapons seized, they could not easily be replaced. Every egg they had was to be placed in the same basket for this fight.

The 36 IRA men got their battle plan from their captain that morning, then trudged off to take up their positions and wait. They’d marched on foot all night to reach the killing field to set up first. The owners of the house just to the south were sympathetic to the cause, but had no food for themselves, let alone a gaggle of frozen and weary riflemen. They sent a bucket of tea around instead to give the guerrillas something hot to drink. That’s how Tom Barry’s men passed the daylight hours of November 28th: soaked through from the dew and frozen in the Winter winds, empty stomachs gnawing at them, and with plenty of hours to sit still and think about what might go wrong.

—————————————————————

The Jaws Snap Shut

Francis Crake had been a clerk at an insurance firm, and he married his sweetheart in the same month the war broke out. On September 3rd, 1914, Private Crake enlisted with the 1st Hampshires and went to war in France.

Three years later, he was Lt. Crake.

A year later, in 1918, he was being mentioned in dispatches for conspicuous gallantry and leadership under fire.

February of 1920, he was discharged from the army.

October 3rd, 1920, seven years to the day since he joined the army as a private, Captain Crake joined the Auxiliary Division.

Two months after that, he was leading the 18 man Auxiliary patrol through West Cork. He sat in the lead vehicle, riding shotgun, heading home to Macroom after a day of raiding.

At approximately 4:05 pm, just after sunset, his convoy took the curve of the road around the darkened, rocky hillside at about 40 mph. Even without the headlights, the moon was almost full, so visibility was pretty good. He saw a man standing in the middle of the road wearing a military uniform, waving his hands as though to ask for help. Cpt. Crake ordered his driver to slow down to see what the problem was.

That man in the road was indeed wearing a military uniform, but not a British one. It was the official tunic of the IRA, though Tom Barry knew perfectly well that no British soldier would recognize it on sight. The man in the uniform with the military webbing and equipment over it was easily mistaken for a fellow Auxiliary.

Once Crake’s convoy had slowed down, the ambush was sprung. A grenade was flung into the cab, killing and mangling the driver and Crake alike. Rifle fire from the front and the left raked the men in the lead vehicle in a murderous crossfire. Behind them, the second lorry was being riddled with bullets by Section 2. Men shot rifles (designed to be accurate and deadly at a thousand yards) at men so close they could have spit on them just as easily.

The men of the lead vehicle (helpfully marked as a red square in the accompanying map) tried to dismount under fire. The survivors who did manage to get solid ground under their feet were hit by a charge as ferocious as any they’d seen in the trenches of France. They were alternately shot with pistols at close range, ran through with bayonets, clubbed down with rifle butts, and blasted with shotguns.

At some point, Temporary Cadet Cecil Guthrie escaped from the mayhem, crawling away from the rear vehicle with presumably non-fatal wounds. Guthrie was a Royal Air Force veteran, a pilot who spent the war all over the Middle East- in fact, it’s not impossible that he and Tom Barry were posted to the same base at some point, for although Tom Barry was an enlisted artilleryman and therefore unlikely to mix with the pilots, they were on the same front in roughly the same battle space and fighting the same Ottomans.

Guthrie was mentioned in dispatches in 1919 for his service in the Afghan war, where he met and fell in love with a nurse named Irene Peach. They had married earlier that year and the Mrs. Guthrie already had a child on the way; indeed, she was mere miles north of him at his base in Macroom, waiting patiently for his patrol to return. He scrambled into the dark, away from the Kilmichael ambush. He would make his way on foot four miles across the countryside towards safety, but two miles short of Macroom, Guthrie would try to get help at a civilian house. Unfortunately for Guthrie, two IRA men were hiding there, and they recognized the ragged, wounded man by face.

You see, a month before, an unarmed man named James Lehane has been snatched up by Guthrie’s unit in a raid and murdered without trial on suspicion of being an IRA volunteer. Witnesses had fingered Guthrie as the man who had emptied his revolver into Lehane at point blank range and in cold blood. It’s like I told you, counter-insurgency brings out the worst in people. Guthrie was executed with his own gun and his body was tossed into a nearby bog. Years later, after the Treaty, the Irish government had his remains dragged out and given a proper burial in deference to his widow and daughter, though there is no real way to know if the body they buried was in fact his or not.

As you can see from this updated map, the Auxiliaries of the lead truck were all killed. Those in the rear truck were at a lethal disadvantage. Tom Barry organized his CP and Section 1 and led them west down the road to fire into the enemy rear. The survivors of the second truck now were under fire from the hill to the north, the rocks from the south, and the road to the east. They had no cover at all save for the broken down lorry, which was not even bullet proof to start with. The next day, when a sister company from the Auxiliaries mapped out the battlefield and marked where the dead had dropped. The lead truck’s dead were bunched up in a tight clump, and the rear truck’s detachment were scattered across the fields. This indicates that the dismounted survivors of the rear truck scattered and were hunted down as individuals.

Here, presumably, Temporary Cadet Frederick Forde was dropped by a gunshot wound to the head. Forde was born to be a soldier; he grew up as a military brat in India and applied to the Royal Military Academy before the Great War even broke out. He commissioned in 1915 and served as an artilleryman in the Balkans, Egypt, and Palestine; at some point, just like Guthrie, Forde might well have bumped into the very man who had organized the ambush he’d been driven into.

By both Forde’s and Tom Barry’s account, the IRA finished off the wounded and stripped the bodies of ammunition, grabbed the dropped rifles, and searched the bodies for papers that might bear valuable intelligence.

Two of the Irishmen- Michael McCarthy, the leader of Section 2, and Jim O’Sullivan- were stretched out dead in the damp grass. They had died from Auxiliary shots from the rear truck. Sullivan in particular died under highly controversial circumstances that I will get to in a minute. Patrick Deasy, aged 16, was also hit, and hit bad. Pat Deasy was the little brother of 22 year old Liam Deasy. The two brothers had served in the West Cork IRA together, and when the Treaty came into effect the following year Liam would bitterly reject it. Both Liam Deasy and Tom Barry alike would end up on the Anti-Treaty side in the coming Irish Civil War, dodging policemen and soldiers of the Irish Free State instead of British policemen and soldiers, ambushing their former IRA comrades in arms instead of the Auxiliaries. Tom Barry would be cooling his heels in a Free State prison cell when his friend Liam Deasy set a long range ambush that would see Michael Collins shot to death in 1922.

However, all of that is in their future. That evening of the 28th of November, Liam’s little brother Pat was begging his commander for a drink of water. Tom Barry knew that giving water to a man with such a stomach wound would be lethal, so he promised him a cup of tea when they got to safety. Pat Deasy didn’t survive long enough to drink it.

Many of the IRA men were physically sick to their stomachs by what they had seen and done- by Tom Barry’s account, one IRA man had been standing so close to his victim that he had had blood splashed into his mouth when he shot the Auxiliary in the neck. The men of the West Cork brigade had learned the same lesson that the dead had learned in the Great War- violent death at close quarters was an intense and emotional experience. Noting that they had been shaken badly by the sheer violence of their own attack, Tom Barry found it necessary to spend valuable time parading them around the ambuscade site in close order drill- left, left, left right, about face, present arms, forward march, left face, right face, shoulder arms, left, left, left right- purely to settle their nerves and restore discipline. The drill was concluded by saluting their three slain comrades who were laid out before them.

The whole business took about a half hour from the initial shots until the flying column was marching off into the dark with their newly captured arms and ammunition, using their head-start to avoid the inevitable counterattack that would come once the results of the ambush were discovered.

The rains poured down heavy that night; black clouds blocked out the bright moonlight. When Forde’s comrades saw that Crake’s patrol had failed to return on time, they sent out a search party but in the dark and stormy night had found nothing. They tried again in the morning and found the site of the massacre easily this time. It is nothing short of miraculous that Forde survived until morning, and then survived the trip to the Battalion surgeon. He would end up with a medical discharge at the highest pension rate available at the time, which was only fair, for he would be paralyzed for life.

—————————————————————

The Controversies and Mysteries That We Are Never Going to Solve

The real problem here is that there are two primary sources for the Kilmichael ambush- Tom Barry’s memoir Guerrilla Days in Ireland and similar recollections from surviving volunteers given years or decades later, and the British account based on Forde’s recollection and on physical evidence collected the following day. I am happy to assume the truth when they are in agreement with each other, and even reasonably on board with details given by one account but not the other. However, when they assert conflicting facts, we are forced to play the part of the courtroom lawyer and the armchair psychologist by questioning sources and applying logic and unraveling unlikely alibis.

For instance, just after the ambush, a local coroner conducted a “superficial examination” and concluded that some of the bodies had been mutilated post-mortem with “an axe or some kind of similar heavy, sharp tool.” Forde’s personal account seems to confirm it- a fellow Auxiliary speaking of Forde’s private recollection claimed that “[t]he leader appeared to be an enormous red headed Irishman who personally inspected each body for signs of life. He was armed with a pistil [sic] and a small axe. The last thing Forde remembers was lying on the road with the red headed giant bending over him taking a swing at his head with the axe.”

Whereas Tom Barry stoutly denies any axe swinging or mutilation whatsoever, labeling it a vicious piece of British propaganda.

So just what are we to make of this?

Well, one, Forde was confused about a lot of things. He thought that there was about 100 IRA dressed as British soldiers, when there was only about 30 shooting in total and only one had a a uniform on. He thought that they had a machine gun and a mess of Tommy guns, when they absolutely didn’t. The guy walked into a maelstrom of chaotic violence and then got shot in the head, so how good could his memory possibly be? Not to mention that he described Tom Barry as an enormous, red-headed giant, while in real life he looked like he might go into a food coma if you fed him half of a ham and cheese sandwich. And it’s not like the British Empire held itself to a high moral standard when it comes to propaganda and spreading lies; the story that the West Cork IRA had mutilated the bodies hit the newspaper the day after the ambush, long before Forde was able to be properly debriefed. Come to that, Forde’s medical discharge stated that his head wound came from a gunshot with no mention of any other cause.

Then again, Tom Barry’s account may also be unreliable. He denied the allegation, sure, but he was also completely unaware at the time of his memoir in 1949 that Forde had survived at all. He was under the impression that 17 men had died by their trucks, and the 18th has escaped only to be hunted down and tossed into the bog the day after. So his account was made under the impression that no British eye-witness could possibly gain-say him. One might ask, what’s the point of desecrating the dead to make a point only to deny it later? The obvious answer is that the axe chopping was a spur of the moment, adrenaline-pumping-through-his-veins kind of thing. That is the exact kind of thing that an insurgent commander would need to stringently deny and cover up if he wanted to win the propaganda war.

If I had to make a call, which I really don’t want to do because I’d be standing on very shaky ground, I’d say that any post-mortem mutilation was a natural result of close quarters violence and not a deliberate attempt to subject the fallen to dishonorable degradation. I can kind of construct a timeline of it- the coroner takes a peek at a series of badly damaged corpses, ravaged as they were by grenades and bayonets and shotguns, and comments, “Jeez, it almost looks like someone took an axe to this guy.” Some savvy British spook then spreads the story far and wide that the savage Irish chopped up the dead like wild Injuns, Forde’s memory is influenced by the official story, and Tom Barry has to try to ignore all damage he ordered done to the enemy after they hit the dirt to counter the accusation. A nice, neat, clean interpretation of events, which is as plausible as any other fictional story because we simply don’t know.

We’ve already covered the controversial use of a uniform in an act of deceit. The British were convinced that the IRA used stolen uniforms to deceive Crake’s patrol, which infuriated them to no end. Tom Barry’s stance was that it was not only a practical strategy, but also perfectly above board because the IRA was a proper army under the leadership of a legitimate government, and the fact that the British couldn’t recognize the tunic on sight the way they could recognize a German or Italian uniform was their problem, not his. Deciding how foul and dishonorable a trick it was probably depends on your politics.

But the pinnacle of the controversy revolves around the narrative of “the false surrender”. Just as the British accused the IRA of mutilation, so to did the IRA accuse the British of faking a surrender to kill their attackers.

Tom Barry’s account is a clean cut narrative- once the ambush was sprung and Section 1 pushed west down the road to engage the rear truck, the British called out to surrender and threw down their rifles. The firing stopped, the Irishmen exposed themselves by walking forward to collect the prisoners, and the Auxiliaries opened fire with their pistols, killing Sullivan and mortally wounding Deasy (McCarthy had been shot and killed in the initial outbreak of gunfire). Tom Barry, in a fury, ordered them “annihilated” for their dishonorable fake out and had his men keep firing into the dead bodies for a minute or two to make sure of them.

There are reasons to doubt such a story.

One, Forde contradicts it. He claims the IRA did capture individuals after the fighting stopped and then executed them all one by one. Two, other volunteers who had taken part in the ambush being interviewed years after the fact offer a slightly different story- that they enemy tried to surrender and then drew pistols, sure, but not all of them. One volunteer, Jack O'Sullivan, testified that he disarmed a wounded Auxiliary but “[h]e was walking him up the road as a prisoner when a shot dropped him at his feet". Another volunteer recalled that Jim Sullivan had been shot before the surrender, not during. And three, frankly, Tom Barry’s story of the false surrender simply makes no sense.

How on earth could an ambushed squad, squirming about desperately under fire, possibly have concocted a plot to fake a surrender solely to get a confirmed kill or two? Why the hell would they? The West Cork Brigade had an established pattern of taking prisoners and letting them go again- it was broadly understood that if the IRA caught you flat-footed they’d take your rifle and ammo and send you off- so why commit suicide by opening fire after the shooting stopped? What kind of fast paced discussion among the dismounted and scattered men of the rear truck led them to think that faking a surrender would work out?

The ugliest explanation I’ve heard is that Tom Barry intended from the start to give no quarter- after all, if you’ll recall, the whole point to the ambush was to make a dramatic counter attack and prove that you’d couldn’t raid West Cork without paying for it. What makes the point clearer, jumping a couple of guys and disarming them, or slaughtering them all to a man? By this theory, after the initial volleys, the surviving Auxiliaries had tossed their rifles and given up only to be massacred as prisoners.

Tom Barry wrote his account in 1949, almost thirty years after the fact. His story is neat and clear cut and flows logically from point to point: the exact kind of clarity of vision that is deeply implausible during the rapid clash of arms that was the Kilmichael Ambush. I just don’t believe it. Based on the volunteers’ testimony, I can believe that in the confusion, some Auxiliaries tried to surrender at the same moment when others tried to keep fighting, and that the IRA vengefully slew them all in the heat of the moment, and that Tom Barry had decades to mull it over and decide that since those Auxies had sneakily murdered Jim Sullivan and young Pat Deasy with their false surrender, they had deserved what they got.

But I really don’t know. All the witnesses are dead and nobody involved had any great interest in the Truth for Truth’s sake.

—————————————————————

Reflections

The question naturally arises about why I bothered to do this write up. After all, not only did the Kilmichael Ambush happen before my grandparents were even born, but it’s not even my heritage. I’m neither Irish nor British; I lack a dog in this fight. The honest but surface answer is that I’m a nerd and I like reading up about wars. Even so, as an American, I have plenty of material to geek out over- Saratoga, Gettysburg, Iwo Jima, the retreat from the Chosin Reservoir. Why this time and place?

An answer that cuts a little deeper into the issue is that I was once involved at the ground level with a counter-insurgency myself, though my role in the proceedings was not terribly dramatic. The ethnic and cultural differences between us and the insurgents were considerable, and it takes an immense amount of effort for me to even try and step into the other guys’ shoes and see the world from their point of view. It is fascinating for me to study another insurgency from not too long ago with an entirely different cast of characters, both of whose cultural backgrounds are present in my own society. The patterns of the Anglo-Irish war are similar enough to Afghanistan that I find them achingly familiar, and yet altered enough to startle me at the same time.

As well, I was deeply impressed by how small of a scale this ambush was on. Twenty men killed and one wounded was considered a major event. Compare that to the Somme, or to Austerlitz, or God save us all to the charnel house of frozen hell that was Stalingrad. Twenty deaths wouldn’t even show up as a blip on the radar in a big war. It is easy to reduce humans to mere numbers when the scale is big enough. 20,000 marching there, 5,000 dead and twice that wounded, a small detachment of 200 sent to hold that bridge, a big push of 60,000 attacking the left.... the human mind can’t handle the amount of empathy it takes to process that many people suffering and dying. But with so few people involved, you can put names and histories onto corpses and get a proper perspective on how God-awful and cruel the whole business of war really is.

A few weeks back, I got into an argument with someone who suggested half-seriously- purely as a hypothetical- that we ought to send troops to Mexico to stamp down on the cartels to help reassert the Mexican government’s control. I pointed out that such an action would be pretty pointless, since the starting conditions that created the cartels would remain after we came, killed, and left. He responded that the number of the cartels’ potential recruits would run out sooner or later. In effect, he argued that if we killed off enough military age males, potentially tens of millions of people, the cartel crackdown would be permanent.

And I thought to myself, “I would bet money that this guy has never so much as been in a fistfight before. If he had ever hurt somebody bad, or seen them hurt bad before his very eyes, or gotten hurt bad himself, he’d know just how criminally insane his suggestion was.”

It worries me that people whose only exposure to war is video games, movies, and gushing reports of steely-eyed elite commandos taking the fight to the jihadis are so instinctively enthusiastic about it. It bothers me that people without skin in the game will happily vote their way towards armed conflict without bothering to think through whether people truly need to suffer and die en masse over the issue at hand. I’m no pacifist myself, you must understand. It just seems to me that people who are disassociated from the reality of war have a tendency to ruin things for everyone else.

However, all such moralizing is ultimately secondary to my purpose. The impulse to tell the tale of the Kilmichael Ambush is an old one, for the telling of war stories is an ancient tradition. As far back as Homer's Iliad, people have been huddling around campfires to gush about this hero's courage, to scorn that villain's cruelty, to mourn the death and agony inflicted upon the innocent, and to retread in the footsteps of the dead and buried soldiers of yesteryear. Undoubtedly there is some clever sociological explanation for why humans of all cultural backgrounds do this, but I need no justification for it. The campfire is replaced by a computer screen and the audience is full of strangers instead of kin and allies, but the form is the same, and in my opinion that is what matters.


r/TheMotte • • Oct 09 '19

As Hong Kong goes, so will our future

209 Upvotes

Posting this here because I don't know where else to--if it seems idiosyncratic or inappropriate, mod as appropriate.


I’m going tell you a story of how I turned down two of the three job offers that were extended to me a few years ago, how a funny thing about regret is that it’s better to regret something you have done than to regret something that you haven’t done, and what the ideal sound for pedestrian road-crossing signs might be.

I’ll then try to convince you that as Hong Kong goes, so will our future.


The year is 2012.

I’m (more) sheltered, young(er,) stupid(er), at the edge of swapping one corporate retail gig that taught me Hanlon’s Razor is fraudulently optimistic with another one, which will turn out to be a marginally improved but quintessentially similar affair.

A woman who heroically put up with my earliest twenties had just formally written off our four-year stint as unsalvageable. Let’s add listless and sad to the list of adjectives that I now know applied to me then [1].

In Anno Domini 2012, I do what relatively sheltered, stupid, listless and unconsciously sad young people stereotypically do: travel. Get Away From It All. Unplug, recharge, re-align my spine. The vacation time I hadn’t spent at soul-grinding job #1 (actual company value: “learn from challenge and change”) is about to get used.

Where to, then? A place far away and exotic enough to fulfil escapist illusions, but first world and English-speaking enough not to present any actual difficulties. So… New York? Not foreign enough. London? Insufficiently exotic. Mumbai? Maybe, but the head-shaking thing....

Hong Kong ticks all the right boxes. Added bonus: circa then, I fancied myself an avid poker player, and Macau is right there. Added bonus: so is Taiwan, origin of my Former Significant Other. I formulate ambiguous plans to hop right over and shoot her a deeply poetic postcard that will definitely, absolutely not be maudlin or laced with self-indulgent reprobation, and generally mega-cringe on an industrial scale, not at all.

Time off: secured. Airfare: booked. AirBNB: in my inbox.

I get my cell carrier to unlock my phone, a mostly US-centric indignity that used to be even more obnoxious. I overpack, under-prepare and buy a comically touristic 18-270mm lens with shit image quality that ends up getting carried everywhere but barely being used. I marvel at the layers of make up caked on briskly competent Singapore Girls. It dawns on me that crossing world in fourteen hours is a wonder, and something merely a few generous ago would’ve been thought magical, but that leg cramps and crying infants beat out meditations on gratitude.


I did say yes to one job offer extended to me in Hong Kong.

Friends-of-friend favor, but a job nonetheless. A Vancouver couple—let’s call them Jessica & Paul—had attended university, started their careers and lived in Canada for almost a decade before being pressured by their tremendously well-off families to head back for the kind of dog & pony show wedding customary with tremendously well-off families.

J&P were sanguine about elders taking complete charge, as the event was largely for their benefit. They self-exempted from plan-drafting, letting others coordinate for maximum pomp & circumstance. But they got sketched out upon meeting the media crew hired to document everything—as the saying goes: spouses might be temporary, but wedding photography follows you to the grave. Unwilling to dispute parental fiat and lacking a significant local social network, they put out an APB with NA West Coast homies for anybody in HK who had at least skill and equipment to be, or at least impersonate some fractional facsimile of a back-up photographer.

Here’s why J&P felt insurance policy was necessary:

The person facing away is the director of the five-man pro team: him(zir?)self, a lights guy, two DSLR-wielders and the muscle who loaded and unloaded traveling musician style hard suitcases that were never opened or used out of the kind of van you’d call cops about if you happened to see parked in the neighborhood. The faces made by everybody in that candid shot were the faces everybody involved with the wedding process made when interacting with the media crew, a number well into four-digit territory when accounting for service personnel manning various venues.

By no means a full itemized receipt of this motley crew’s antics:

  • The director spoke in Ruby Rhod falsetto and analogous affectations. He interrupted while people were giving speeches with demands about placement & posture—something crowd rumblings seemed to find especially egregious because older people were essentially being heckled.

  • While groomsmen and bridesmaids (11 of each) were engaging in traditional games, dances & assorted tomfoolery at the house of bride’s parents, the lights guy fell on and through a whole sucking pig parked on the living room table. I realize that sounds implausibly Rush Hour 3-ish, but it happened, & I mourn the loss of veritable hectares of crispy-brown pigskin to this day.

  • At the luxury sky-high apartment belonging to the parents of the groom, the crew installed two CIA investigation-style lamps and used flashes. Lest you believe this to have been a bold stylistic choice: after working up some courage, I asked for the thick curtains covering the full pane windows to be drawn. The hosts genially agreed, and the director immediately asked to redo previous shots.

I never learned how the hiring decision was made, although curiosity abounded in light of how well all other proceedings were managed. The topic seemed to be a sour one, not with J&P themselves, but with their respective sets of parents, who I ended up spending time with in subsequent informal settings.

Long before any of the above went down, I was contacted through social media intermediaries and after introductions over noodles, contracted to provide additional documentation of the grand union in exchange for a day’s worth of traditional HK wedding wiggeries among complete strangers, elaborate brunch, tea ceremony and eleven course dinner all included. Both parties got good value from the barter—J told me, charitably or otherwise, that this ended up being her favorite shot for the day.

Having discharged of my duties honorably, J&P became my local patron saints. We hung out, a lot. Maybe they cherished short-lived escapes from the intense marital churn foisted on then by families and old friends. They graciously disabused me of my harest-brained touristic ideas, were generally helpful and acted as guides.

At a Tuesday breakfast, P’s guttural dad, a whiskey and cigar old-schooler, propositioned me with the first job I turned down.


He was gruffly cordial but buried his face in a newspaper until my literature degree from Berkeley surfaced during random conversation, where upon I turned into the sole locus of his attention span for the remainder of the meal. After preliminaries to minimize the possibility that was a total imbecile or fraud, he extended an offer for teaching at an exclusive English-speaking private academy he was alumni of, along with member and/or chairman of assorted boards.

I walked away from that morning flattered but discounting the matter as the kind of idle chatter rich people engage in. Three phone calls from his secretary later, it was clear that I was mistaken. Job details and compensation benefits were discussed[2]—or rather, recited at me—in great detail. Point blank yes/no questions were re-iterated through calls made at my local HK number and a Skype session by two different representatives of the institution.

P himself shared in hushed but explicit terms that it was a Big Deal for his father to take that much interest, and that he was hoping my no would stay a no, because if it happened to be a yes and I’d turn out to be a fuck up (P phrased it more elegantly, and in an endearingly apologetic manner) his dad would invariably insist that it was all P’s fault.

To P’s relief, the no stayed a no. I did my best to convey that I had deliberated at length—true—that I was impossibly humbled by the insane way the proposition materialized and escalated—also true—and that the “lock in” stipulations did not freak me out, but I had other plans in North America—bald-faced lies.

In the event of an infinitely quantum-branching universe, this fork is in the top three I’d like to revisit.


The second job I turned down was offered by an out-of-breath stranger.

I mean that literally: I never learned his name, and he was panting during the couple of minutes we chatted.

It happened on the streets of the Hong Kong island, en route to Causeway Bay. I was looking for Goldfinch Restaurant, featured in for War Kai Wong’s In the Mood Lor Love[3], a movie that looks like art but feels like sex, while dragging my ridiculous 3 pound lens along. Nose buried in smart phone navigation, I ignored the yelling until a hand descended on my shoulder.

Young guy. Close to thirty, maybe? Sharp dress shirt, tailored slacks. He huffed and puffed, hands on his waist as if he had sprinted for a while. In curiously halting English—because he seemed to have escaped an office from the nearby financial district, where people tend to be hyper-functionally bi-lingual—he expressed his desire to hire me for a party.

A party? Yes, a large, loud club—he made “untz untz” mouth sounds and made the universal, vaguely piston-like fist motions associated with dance music. Where? Nearby warehouse, he said. Happens all the time. Every month, he added while I was attempting to process the surreal aspects of what was happening. He smiled broadly, no signs of embarrassment or discomfort other than the hard breathing.

I eventually regrouped and asked why.

Because of my look—he pointed at my shaved head and moved a splayed hand from top to bottom, as if presenting an especially entrancing offer on a late-night informercial, or an oversized catch while out fishing with buddies—and said: white. His winning smile grew galactically incandescent. Look here, I said for lack of anything meaningful, doing what? Photos? I pointed at my camera bag but he shook his head emphatically. Drinks. Doing, aah, making drinks. Bartender, he exclaimed, looking happy to have remembered the precise term.

I excused myself: I don’t know how to do or make drinks. He once again denied me, forcefully, and said it doesn’t matter. Great look. People really like white guys doing drinks. I got the sense that he was clinically, absolutely, incontrovertibly correct in the assessment, a rock-ribbed certainty born of out personal experience combined with knowledge of an entire field of expertise—hospitality, underground raves, techno, some mash-up thereof. I considered what was happening for a few seconds, wary of an elaborate scam that might be in process of being perpetrated, but mostly just confused. Mental images began congealing along my brain stem—flipping bottles in a dim, sauna-like hall, splashing whiskey into dirty glasses while rhythmic throbs ripple across a neon-frenzied background. A drunken, heavily tattooed wiry guy reaching ominously into a pocket because I gaped in the direction of his date too long. White powder residue mixing on a sticky counter-top with cigarette ash and squeezed-out lemon slices.

I’m good, I said, and started to turn.

Wait, wait, he exclaimed while settling a hand on my shoulder again. The transformation from smiling to crestfallen was shockingly abrupt. Please, it’s fun. He fumbled at his shirt’s chest pocket for a pen, realized something else he was looking for wasn’t there and reached for his wallet[4]. An old receipt emerged. He scribbled down his phone number and said, great look, smiling again before waving and running away.

I found Goldfinch Restaurant half an hour later and never called the top HK authority on hospitality, underground raves, techno back.


Plink, plink, plink.

The sound is instantly recognizable, insistent, close to alarming but not quite, just at the edge thereof.

It’s the ideal sound for pedestrian road-crossing signs, attention grabbing without escalating into inducing anxiety.

I don’t have anything else to say about that, but I don’t think I need to.


Time spent across the Pacific, as cliched and silly as it may have been in conception, was what I needed to snap me out of lingering shards of infantility.

For the first time, the urgency necessary to live with agency manifested itself unexpectedly. I was called to pay attention and to listen. To say yes. To say no.

Approaching the back half of my life, I dwell on these thoughts.

For the record, I did do well enough playing no-limit hold’em in Macau, and mercifully spared my ex, and my own conscience, of any histrionic correspondence.

It was also the beginning of a life-long love with Hong Kong, its people and what it represents.


William Gibson’s second trilogy concerns itself with many fun things like being a hair-raisingly good read, for example, but many serious ones too, like the concept of interstitial spaces.

The term is of medical origin but has been recast to describe the porous, amalgamated, adaptable in-betweens that formulate versions of the future before they become evenly distributed, spots where people innovate, hybridize or exploit loopholes to escape the pressure of social expectations and historical circumstance.

These spaces can be geographical or conceptual—often, they overlap.

In Virtual Light, the Bridge is a real place. The Bay Bridge links San Francisco and Oakland. In the novel, the bridge is earthquake-damaged and abandoned but gets appropriated by poor and marginalized people as an autonomous refuge, outside regular laws and customs. It starts organically, out of need for shelter and relief from oppressive oversight. Skinner, a Bridge veteran, describes the beginning:

This one woman, she kept saying plant the whole thing with ivy, Virginia creeper… Somebody else, they said tear it down before another quake did it for ’em. But there it was. In the cities, lot of people, no place to go.

The novel describes how one night, people climbed fences surrounding the defunct bridge and ran across, clinging to towers. The officials of the surrounding city decided, rather than risking the bad publicity of using force, to allow the collection of society’s unwanted to set up new homes, an alliance of outcasts, a functional but unplanned community of people who have created their own habitat, their own space, constructing eclectic dwellings and markets out of everything imaginable and available.

The Bridge is also an idea. Skinner again:

Shit happens. Happened that night. No signals, no leader, no architects. You think it was politics. That particular dance, boy, that’s over. (…) No agenda… no underlying structure.

The Bridge represents people figuring things out by themselves, out of sheer necessity. Neither attractive nor easy, it allows for a kind of liberty from norms that’s impossible in established, formal spaces. In the interstitial in-between, freedom or agency are not ideals, they’re pre-conditions.

Gibson’s Bridge was inspired by a specific place.


Hong Kong, in-between imperial Chinese main-land and imperial United Kingdom.

Hong Kong, in-between opium wars.

Hong Kong, in-between water and sky, in-between trade routes, crossroad of the world.

Hong Kong, in-between Cantonese, English and Mandarin.

Hong Kong, in-between the highest ranking on the index of economic freedom and increasing economic inequality.

Hong Kong, in-between concrete, steel and glass.

Hong Kong, in-between cars, airplanes and the MTR.

In-between, a flower blossoms.


The year is 2019.

The room for interstitial in-betweens narrows.

Political and cultural pathologies of today have various flavors of dysfunction, but a strong unifying thread is present: less agency.

Less privacy: you don’t own the data you generate, nor should you expect that online information you generate is protected from commoditization. Nation-states and their tentacular investigative agencies constantly probe—such is and has been a simple fact of life for decades—but cultural norms themselves are eroding into perpetual, low-intensity fear of being unmasked and un-personed, often over setting off ambiguous trip-wires. We’re slowly sliding toward a state of Stasi paranoia—whether by governmental fiat, corporatist kowtowing or online zealotry, the operative part of white terror is terror.

Less freedom of assembly and transaction, off or on-line. Security and prosecution of hate speech, real or imagined, or arbitrarily defined toxicity, are named as reasons (or excuses) to curtail activity that might be deemed undesirable by sufficiently powerful parties. Through a mix of surveillance, capricious enforcement and lack of accountability for abuse, the space to figure things out, to insist on rights and self-determination, shrinks.

Less flow of information. “Fake News” is now a pungently familiar lament, but it doesn’t capture the degree to which online channels have been weaponized for elaborate manipulation. Content is scrubbed, blocked, shadow-banned, gated, filtered, algorithmically de-ranked, de-prioritized, de-monetized. Machine learning is strategically deployed to herd attention toward the anodyne and the profitable, with the messy back and forth of figuring things out relegated to illegitimacy.

Nothing in the last three paragraphs is specific to Hong Kong protests, although a barrage of links would’ve been easy to assemble. This was on purpose: you should recognize how the paragraphs apply to you, whatever your own political convictions are, wherever you happen to live.

As Hong Kong goes, whoever you are, so will your future.

As Hong Kong goes, wherever you are, so will your future.

As Hong Kong goes, so will our future.

In 2000, while answering questions submitted online, Gibson dared to hope:

QUESTION: Do you think the internet will be entirely consumed by dot com commercialism, or will there still be a place for information sharing and community?

WILLIAM GIBSON: Always room for interstitial activity.

He didn't say anything about it being easy.


Elsewhere, u/chaoslastorder posted a tremendous series of meditations on mainland attitudes and the foreseeable future of China and its prospective chart through 21st century.

I recommend all of it, since it’s better writing than anything you’ve fought through to arrive here, & it cements my contention that what’s happening in Hong Kong right now is prelude to and weather-wane for the sharp edge of tomorrow.


I don’t have an agenda to conclude on a triumphal note with, a call to arms, not even a blog to plug.

But for the record: I love Hong Kong. I love its people. I love what they stand for and what they’re doing.

From afar, and with whatever menial ways my everyday life allows for, I love them and wish them godspeed, for they are fighting my fight, and yours, and all of ours.

Beyond everything else, I’m certain of the following: this is the best sound for pedestrian road-crossing signs.

光復香港 時代革命 五大訴求 缺一不可


[1] Acronymized to ATIM-KATMT, just shy of being catchy. But there’s something to the concept, no? Some self-deprecating wistfulness, a slightly up-tuned version of “Things I’d Tell Myself Of 10 Years Ago.”

[2] Hold on to your butts; this is a WILD ride: it was supposed to be a five year contract minimum, starting with year one wage in the neighborhood of $20,000-ish. Each year, compensation would go up by another $20,000—e.g., second year would amount to $40K total, then $60K, you know, arithmetic & shit. Two fully paid round trips to NA per annum would be fully sponsored. The nuttiest part: room and board was also covered up to a max of $2.5K/month, except that if the contract wasn’t fulfilled, I’d owe all of it back. It was explained that this style of contract was trial-and-errored as the best way to “lock in” instructors and provide a stable cadre of educators at the institution, since it was considered key to both academic achievement as well “compatible values,” a term which was uttered at me over and over again to the point where I briefly considered it as the best possible name for a punk band, ever. Any attempts to wiggle out of the “lock-in” provisions were summarily ignored and additional money was put on the table—by the final turn down, it was up to $30,000-ish for the first year followed by cumulative $25K each new year.

[3] I couldn’t remember the name of the restaurant. Looking it up, it turns out it was forced to move. I find to be heart rending beyond anything I'm capable of expressing and am not ashamed of tearing up while writing this. If you find that to silly or weird, you’re well within your rights to, but please consider (re)-watching In The Mood For Love.

[4] I remember it with hallucinatory clarity: light brown inside, darker exterior due to discoloration from the dye of his jeans.


r/TheMotte • • Dec 21 '20

Navalny trolls his own FSB assassin into revealing poison plot details

Thumbnail
bellingcat.com
203 Upvotes

r/TheMotte • • Jul 17 '19

Book Review Book Review: From Third World to First, by Lee Kuan Yew [PART ONE]

203 Upvotes

Intro

We believed in socialism, in fair shares for all. Later, we learned that personal motivation and personal rewards were essential for a productive economy. However, because people are unequal in their abilities, if performance and rewards are determined by the marketplace, there will be a few big winners, many medium winners, and a considerable number of losers. That would make for social tensions because a society's sense of fairness is offended. ...Our difficulty was to strike the right balance. (95) (Page numbers listed throughout for reference)

What happens when you give an honest, capable person absolute power?

In From Third World to First, Lee Kuan Yew, in characteristically blunt style, does his best to answer that question.

Lee Kuan Yew's politics--and by extension Singapore's, because he really did define the country--are often, I feel, mischaracterized. In We Sail Tonight For Singapore, for example, Scott Alexander characterizes it as reactionary. This is agreeable to the American left, because it's run so differently to Western liberal ideals, and agreeable to reactionaries, because Singapore is preternaturally successful by almost any metric you care to use.

The only problem is that the claim reflects almost nothing about how Lee Kuan Yew actually ran the country or who he was.

I get the impression it's a mistake to frame Singapore alongside a partisan political axis at all, because the second you do, half of what the country does will seem bizarre. Lee, personally, is open about his party's aim to claim the middle ground, opposed by "only the extreme left and right." (111) With that in mind, what works best to predict Lee's choices? In his telling, he is guided continually by a sort of ruthless pragmatism. Will a policy increase the standard of living in the country? Will it make the citizens more self-sufficient, more capable, or safer? Ultimately, does it work? Oh, and does it make everybody furious?

Great, do that.

From Third World to First is the single most compelling political work I've read, and I'd like to capture as much of Lee's style and ideology as possible. He divides the book (or at least the half I'm reviewing; I'll leave his thoughts on world affairs alone because there's so much to cover as is) into sections based on specific policy problems and how he approached them. I'll focus my attention on a few:

  • Citizen welfare & development

  • Free speech & free press

  • Approach to political opposition

  • Handling of racial & cultural tensions

The first section, in my estimation, deserves more space than a joint review would permit, so I will split it off and post it before the others.

At the end, I will link to my notes in full, and those who are interested are welcome to ask for more details. Depending on interest level, I may write a follow-up review of topics I don't have space to cover here. Note especially that LKY spends huge chunks of the book praising the politicians working alongside him and emphasizing their role. Ultimately, though, the decisions for the country flowed through him and so I am comfortable approaching all these as his policies.

LKY's writing is thoroughly readable and often hilarious, so I will quote it extensively throughout.

Citizen welfare & development

I.

To even out the extreme results of free-market competition, we had to redistribute the national income through subsidies on things that improved the earning power of citizens, such as education. Housing and public health were also obviously desirable. But finding the correct solutions... was not easy. We decided each matter in a pragmatic way, always mindful of possible abuse and waste. If we over-re-distributed by higher taxation, the high performers would cease to strive. (95)

There are two major questions LKY had to answer when it came to developing Singapore. First, how could the country develop a strong economy? Having achieved that, how could they ensure the welfare of all citizens? Or, as he put it, he wanted to leapfrog the region and then create a "First World oasis" (58).

LKY's strategy for the first was simple: provide goods and services "cheaper and better than anyone else, or perish." (56) He was proudly adamant about his country's refusal to beg, describing on every other page how he would go to his citizens and say things like "The world does not owe us a living." (53) or "If we were a soft society then we would already have perished. A soft people will vote for those who promised a soft way out, when in truth there is none. There is nothing Singapore gets for free." (53)

This is one of many areas where he was adamant about rejecting conventional wisdom. In his telling, development economists and other third world leaders of the 60s described multinational corporations as "[neocolonialist] exploiters of cheap land, labor, and raw materials... but... we had a real-life problem to solve and could not afford to be conscribed by any theory or dogma." (58)

So, instead, he threw his country's arms open and said, "Exploit us!" Image was everything. To attract tourism, they invented the merlion symbol and scattered it through the country. Places were renamed. My favorite--"Blakang Mati" (behind death), an island formerly used by a British battalion, was reinvented as "Sentosa" (tranquillity), a tourist resort. (54) To inspire confidence and demonstrate his country's discipline and reliability, LKY focused on planting trees and developing parkland in the center of the city and between the airport, his office, and hotels. For one Hewlett-Packard visit, when an elevator wasn't yet powered to take them to the sixth floor of their planned headquarters, Singaporean officials extended a cable from a nearby building to power it day-of. (62)

In the 70s, as the country's economy stabilized, that confidence manifested in other ways, as with this interaction:

When our... officer asked how much longer we had to maintain protective tariffs for the car assembly plant owned by a local company, the finance director of Mercedes-Benz said brusquely, "Forever," because our workers were not as efficient as Germans. We did not hesitate to remove the tariffs and allow the plant to close down. Soon afterward we also phased out [other protections]. (63)

The whole thing, at least from a distance, follows a pattern of initial tight control, caution, and centralized planning, followed by a slow move towards a freer economy as long as everything seemed to be working. Worried about government starting industries and running them at a loss, LKY insisted that state-run corporations stay in the black or shut down. As they succeeded, they privatized--telecommunications, the port, and public utilities all started within the government and became independent profitable companies over time. (67)

II.

From a Labour Party meeting in June 1966: "Lee Kuan Yew [is] as good a left-wing and democratic socialist as any in this room." (34)

I could go on for a while longer outlining Singapore's growth, and part of me wants to, because the story is fascinating. It's hardly unique, though, just the story of a well-managed economy. Everyone already knows about the growth of Singapore's economy. The work it took is worth noting, but much more compelling for me is what they did with all that new wealth. The United States had a hundred years or more to manage a jump Singapore went through in a couple decades. Growth brings all sorts of questions: How do you shift people to a new way of life? How do you get people invested in their country's success? How do you handle welfare, health care, transport? This is where Singapore excels.

Not without controversy, though, aided and abetted by Lee Kuan Yew himself. As much as I tend to appreciate his approach, his bluntness sometimes gives me pause. Here's a sampling of his thoughts on welfare:

We noted by the 1970s that when governments undertook primary responsibility for the basic duties of the head of a family, the drive in people weakened. Welfare undermined self-reliance. People did not have to work for their families' well-being. The handout became a way of life. The downward spiral was relentless as motivation and productivity went down. People lost the drive to achieve because they paid too much in taxes. They became dependent on the state for their basic needs. (104)

And:

There will always be the irresponsible or the incapable, some 5 percent of our population. They will run through any asset, whether a house or shares. We try hard to make them as independent as possible and not end up in welfare homes. More important, we try to rescue their children from repeating the feckless ways of their parents. We have arranged help but in such a way that only those who have no other choice will seek it. This is the opposite of attitudes in the West, where liberals actively encourage people to demand their entitlements with no sense of shame, causing an explosion of welfare costs. (106)

So--welfare bad. Got it. What's his alternative?

Funding Prosperity

The foundation for his strategy was laid before Singapore left colonial rule: an compulsory 5% pension fund (the CPF) with employers matching 5%. This fund became a major tool to support LKY's value of self-sufficiency. As he says, he "was determined to avoid placing the burden of the present generation's welfare costs onto the next generation" (97). So how did he fund welfare plans?

As Singapore's economy grew year by year, workers' wages went up. As wages rose, knowing that people would "resist any increase in their CPF contribution that would reduce their spendable money", he increased mandatory CPF contribution rates with part, but never all, of that increase. At its peak in 1984, mandatory contribution increased to 25% with full matching. Every working citizen was automatically saving at a 50% rate. This decreased to 40% over time. (97)

Every aspect of citizen welfare becomes easier when every worker has that large a guaranteed savings account.

Following the pattern of initial strictness, followed by expanding rights, the government expanded CPF investment options over time. One illustrative example: when they privatized bus services, they allowed citizens to spend up to S$5,000 to buy initial shares in the new transport company so "profits would go back to the workers, the regular users of public transport" ...and, as LKY adds in the same tone a moment later, to reduce incentive to demand cheap fares and government subsidies. (103)

This strategy repeated when they privatized Singapore Telecom, as they sold shares at half price to all adult citizens, with bonus shares every few years provided people held onto initial shares. Again, LKY describes this desire to redistribute surpluses and provide people a tangible stake in their country's success. He reports that 90% of the workforce owned Singapore Telecom shares. (103)

Neither the CPF fund nor HDB housing, incidentally, can be taken by creditors.

Sense of Ownership

Aside from pensions, LKY's initial major vision for the fund was a way to allow citizens to buy their own houses. He talks a lot about the value of people having a stake in their country, how a "sense of ownership [is] vital for [a] society [with] no deep roots in a common historical experience," (96) the ways home ownership increases civic pride and a sense of belonging. So the government constantly bought land up, built high-rise public "HDB" housing (up to 50 stories!), and then sold apartments to citizens. At its peak, 87% of Singaporeans lived in this public housing.

Some design decisions of HDB housing are worth examining. In some, LKY asked developers "to set aside land... for clean industries which could then tap the large pool of young women and housewives whose children were already schooling" (98). When older housing started decaying, the government created a program to upgrade and refurbish older apartments at the cost of S$58,000 per home, charging owners S$4,500 of that cost (100).

It's easy to get lost in policy details: decisions, reasoning, numbers. What about the humanity behind those policies, though? What was life like on the ground for the farmers and market vendors who abruptly found themselves moving from wooden huts to modern high-rises in the middle of a rapidly developing city? There was exciting progress, yes, but much of the time it was tragic, hilarious, and absurd.

LKY highlights some of these moments. Pig farmers, nudging their pigs up staircases to raise them in high-rise apartments. A family, gating off their kitchen for a dozen chickens and ducks. People walking up long flights of stairs because they were afraid of using elevators, using kerosene instead of electric bulbs, selling miscellaneous goods from ground-floor flats. (99) He grows somber as he talks about resettling older farmers, how even generous compensation money didn't matter next to losing "their pigs, ducks, chickens, fruit trees, and vegetable plots," and how many of the older farmers never really stopped resenting the change. (180)

He's quick to point out other changes, though: In riots in the 1950s and early 60s, he recalls, people joined in, breaking cars, lighting fires, reveling in chaos. Later in the decade, after home ownership started to spread, he mentions seeing people carrying scooters to safety into their HDB apartments. In his words, "I was strengthened in my resolve to give every family solid assets which I was confident they would protect and defend, especially their home."

"I was not wrong." (103)

I laughed when I got to that line, because I'm pretty sure this picture holds pride of place in LKY's mind. He presents this blithe sense of self-assurance throughout the book, with every controversial policy and scornful dismissal.

Health care

Speaking of blithe self-assurance and scornful dismissal, he dismisses the British National Health Service as idealistic but impractical and destined to cause ballooning costs, then takes a shot at the American system with its "wasteful and extravagant diagnostic tests paid for out of insurance." He reports that at least in Singapore, the ideal of free health care clashes with human behavior. Doctors prescribe free antibiotics, patients take them for a few days, don't feel better, and toss them out. Then they go to private doctors, pay, and take the medicine properly. (100)

The first solution was a token 50-cent fee to attend outpatient dispensaries. The full solution, and part of the reason Singapore's per capita health care costs are half the UK's and less than a quarter of the US's, once again went through the CPF pensions: 1% set aside into "Medisave" for health care costs at first, gradually increasing to 6%, capped at S$15,000. "To reinforce family solidarity and responsibility", LKY reports, accounts could be used for immediate family members as well. (101)

That's not to say he wanted no subsidies. At government hospitals, patients chose wards subsidized up to 80%, moving to more comfortable and less subsidized wards as they desire. Medisave funds could be used for private hospital fees in order to compete with government hospitals and pressure them to improve, but not for outpatient clinics or private general practitioners. Why? LKY didn't want to encourage people to see doctors unnecessarily for minor ailments. (102) This constant tinkering and fine-tuning around incentive systems is core to LKY's planning.

From there, Singapore added optional insurance for catastrophic cases, then added a fund from government revenue to provide total waivers for those who lacked Medisave, insurance, and immediate family. Per LKY's reporting, "no one is deprived of essential medical care, we do not have a massive drain on resources, nor long queues waiting for operations." (102)

Pragmatism.

Taxes

So how does this welfare structure reflect in taxes?

Every few pages in The Singapore Story, Lee Kuan Yew makes some grandiose statement about Singapore's successes, and so every few pages I would rush online to see what was exaggerated or cherry-picked and what has faded in the years since LKY's time. The tax structure was the point where this yielded the most fruit--not because of any cherry-picking, but because almost everything has gotten better in the 19 years since LKY wrote his book.

Here are some details on Singapore's tax structure, both as LKY reported and at present, in pursuit of an overall goal to shift from taxing income to taxing consumption:

  • Top marginal income tax rate decreased from 55 percent in 1965 to 28 percent in 1996 (now 22 percent).

  • Corporate tax rate of 40 percent reduced to 26 percent (now 17 percent)

  • No capital gains tax

  • 3% GST (goods and services tax, equivalent to VAT (now 7%)

  • 0.4% import tariff (now duty-free)

  • Inheritance/estate tax was cut from 60 percent to 5-10 percent in 1984, leading to increased revenue "as the wealthy no longer found it worthwhile to avoid estate duty" (now abolished)

In addition, they collect nontax revenue from a range of charges, aiming for "partial or total cost recovery for goods and services provided by the state" to "check over-consumption of subsidized public services and reduce distortions in the allocation of resources." (107)

How has this reflected on overall government expenditures?

At the time of LKY's book in 2000, annual budget surpluses had been recorded every year but the 1985-1987 recession. Since then, 2002-2004, 2009, 2015 also recorded deficits, but the government is still running at a comfortable surplus overall.

Here's what the budget looked like in 2016.

Ultimately, as LKY points out, his strategy relied heavily on a unique set of circumstances leading to steady growth, but they capitalized on that growth, made long-term decisions early, and set themselves up well for the foreseeable future as a result. I don't share a ton of his skepticism towards Nordic-style welfare states, particularly since they remain comfortable and successful twenty years later, but I'll admit to more than a twinge of envy when I compare Singapore's approach to welfare with that of the US.

Interlude

Having made the claim that Singapore really isn't reactionary, I'm left to defend it after a string of quotes and choices that, if not reactionary, at least seem tailor-made to pick fights with leftist thought. This is one reason I quoted the British Labour Party members at the start of section II. Lee Kuan Yew started the PAP as a socialist party, driven by trade unions, opposed to British colonialism, aligned with British progressives. Again and again throughout the book, you see LKY pause to note potential unintended consequences of a choice, to approach major decisions with caution, and to change his approach when presented with sufficient evidence, but threads of progressive ideals are persistent throughout and essential to his decision-making.

Those threads should become more apparent as I progress through more of the review, fitting naturally with Lee's overall bluntly pragmatic approach. No other section will likely be as long as this one, but I felt it would be doing Singapore's welfare structure a disservice if I didn't go in depth. Singapore is unlike any other country in the world, and while nothing done there can copy 1:1 over to different settings, there's a lot worth noticing.

Until next time.

Part two: You are free to agree

Part three: Race, language, and uncomfortable questions

Part four: The pathway to power


r/TheMotte • • Sep 24 '19

The Effectiveness of Rifle Fire Across Cultures

200 Upvotes

Image at the top: The Fallen Four Memorial in Mayerthorpe, Alberta

.

Disclaimer: I apologize if the below is Macabre but many different discussions both within and without the culture war revolve around these questions, and I think they merit discussion. I don’t see these discussion happening around the details that seem striking to me or much awareness for how strange a-lot of the facts on the ground are.

I will ask that all culture war discussion be confined to the associated culture-war thread LINKED HERE , and the comments to this post be reserved for either technical, factual or non-Cultures War items under discussion

.

Part 1:The “Snipers” of Afghanistan

I’ve been reading alot of The Wikileaks Afghan War Diary lately.

The “Diary” contains the leak of most all action reports from the Afghan war from 2004-2009 with the link above also granting access to the Iraq war diary covering the same period.

The reports, despite being brief and almost certainly selective on description (the average officer viewing them as paperwork which, best case scenario, no one mentions to them again) are none the less full of hinting details of what was actually going on. For example: why are their so many friendly actions with 50+ enemy dead, but no civilian casualties? Presumably we’d expect one or two to get mixed in as insurgent are famed for mixing with the civilian population, and yet there are very few labelled 50+ enemy dead, 1-5 civilian casualties. Were officers incentivized to just roll any civilian casualties into the enemy dead?

.

But one detail really stood out to me, and seems really relevant to a-lot of domestic discussions. The subcategory “Sniper Ops” is divided into two groups “Friendly Action” and “Enemy Action”. The Friendly action is pretty much what you’d expect: a two man team of highly trained upstanding marines fires one shot, maybe two, and then there are one or two Enemy KIA, sometimes they simply wound the target, and sometime they merely preform an overwatch: motorcycle rides up observes an FOB, then drives away, but it follows the pattern you’d expect from the movies: lots of sitting around observing and then (mostly) one perfect shot. The enemy action section could not be more different.

The Taliban it seems are really bad shots. Of the 93 enemy sniper ops included in the Afghanistan data set 67 resulted in no Casualties at all, the insurgents orTaliban simply rode up to some range, fired 1 or 2 shots that missed, and rode away. Of the remaining 26, 6 resulted in only enemy casualties, with the remaining 20 being something of a mess of friendly wounded and enemy casualties, in only one incident is a coalition fighter, a member of the 1st Royal Anglian, killed by sniper fire, and in two incidents are Friendly host nation forces killed, only one of which looks like a traditional sniper attack (the other is a messy assault that really stretches the definition).

Though this data set only covers 2004 to 2009, and 2010 famously saw the taliban hire “Mercenary Snipers” from outside Afghanistan, and the Sangin Sniper stirred up some news, this is still striking.

Between 2004 and 2009 as few as 1 member of the coalition in Afghanistan might have been killed by sniper fire, this seems ridiculous, maybe its a categorization error in the data set, and yet when we look at the Iraq War there are 84 incidents of enemy sniper ops resulting in 1 or more coalition fatalities, though if you believe the propaganda of Iraqi Insurgents 37 of those fatalities where the result of the mythical Juba who was the partial basis for the excellent John Cena movie The Wall.

Furthermore this seems to fit with the analysis I’ve seen that Iraqi insurgent snipers (many of whom were former members of Sadam’s Republican Guard) were vastly more effective than their Afghan counterparts many of whom seemed not to even aim, and according to at-least one (seemingly slanderous) take I’ve heard multiple times, trusted Allah to guide the bullet if he wanted it to hit. There’s also the interpretation that these untrained marksmen, afraid of Coalition Forces, stayed back as far as possible and tried not to hit, so they could say they completed the mission to their bosses back home while maximizing their distance and safety from the more numerous and vastly better trained forces they were going up against. And beyond this, despite reports many of the reports detailing “effective fire” (a military misnomer denoting fire being shot from within a weapons effective range, ie. fire that plausibly “could” hit someone (whether it “might” hit being another question)) most of the weapons used were either old turn of the 19th century to ww2 bolt action Russian Mosin Nagants and English Lee Enfeilds, weapons that despite their large calibers and effective ranges of 500+ meters were actual made to be fired as a volley by a squad, ie. not precision rifles, and relatively more difficult to use for Sniper fire than their modern large caliber equivalents.

.

.

Part 2: Why concern ourselves with sniper fire specifically?

There is a consistent discussion in relation to gun control and the potential of a civil war or insurgency in America, namely to what extent an American insurgency could ever hope to resist the combined force of the US military and law enforcement. While some responses are cringy with either poser “tacticool” right wingers posting about their planned rebellion (in many instances only to reveal their utter lack of knowledge about the equipment they own or even how to camp (hint it helps to pack food)) or Left wing commentators or even Congressmen gleefully pointing out the US government would obviously win since it can resort to nukes, or even Foreign Political Candidates suggesting predator drones give the federal government an indomitable edge over any gun-owners or insurgents.

But there is a serious discussion buried under the Pure Toxoplasma of the culture war: To what extent do the proliferation of small arms affect the balance between the central government and dissident factions? How much can the government do without provoking a backlash it can’t handle?

Note Again: please keep all “culture war” discussions in the attendant Culture War thread for this post, and reserve the below comments for non-culture war discussion

.

So Again why focus on sniper fire specifically?

Because sniper fire, or some equivalent ambushing at closer ranges, is pretty much the only thing an insurgency on the American continent would ever want to do with their guns (at-least for the first decade of any conflict).

The movie Black Hawk Down was criticized on its release for its supposed jingoism and unrealistic depiction of US troop seemingly effortlessly mowing down endless hordes of Somalis, the problem is, that was pretty much a realistic depiction. The casualty figures from The Battle of Mogadishu are really telling about the disparity between trained professional military, and amateur militias. Including The Casualties from the Pakistani and Malaysian rescue forces America and her Allies suffered 21 KIA, 82 wounded and 1 captured, whereas the Somali National Alliance suffered 200-500 killed and 500-812 wounded. And that was widely regarded as a complete US tactical screwup. Looking again at war diaries there are 23 incidents in that 5 year period in Afghanistan where the Coalition killed 40 or more enemy forces without suffering even a single wound.

The simple fact is gun fights are dominated by the principles of Fire and Movement. Two or more allied units achieve fire superiority (read: suppressing fire) and then alternate fire so one element can safely close in with an already suppressed enemy, and finish them from a superior position. Essentially the movement kills the enemy, even if the enemy executes a perfect ambush, if the allies can achieve fire superiority, then they can safely move, while the enemy can’t, until the positions have completely reversed and its the enemy forces encircled.

This requires tremendous teamwork and training, the type only a professional army can consistently instill, but once established it allows dramatic dominance over most untrained forces.

Sniper fire by contrast, through stealth and range, allows smaller and less trained forces to effectively take on larger better trained forces and survive. Sniper fire (in theory) allows a Corporal or two, unaccompanied, to take out a General surround by an entire company, and safely get away. If it is imaginable for an insurgency or rebellion to appear on American soil they would have to be using Sniper Fire, if they use guns at all. It is simply unimaginable that Amateur American’s would be willing to go on suicide missions and suffer 40+ casualties only to not even wound their enemy.

Simply put, looking at the Afghanistan data, if Sniper Fire doesn’t change anything for a hypothetical insurgency then guns in general don’t change anything, aside from maybe helping insurgents in-fight with each other.

.

.

Part 3: The Mad Men of the West

The data from Afghanistan and even Iraq suggests the proliferation of small arms changes very little. While I haven’t been able to find a breakdown of KIAs for the US and UK, the break down for the Canadian Fatalities in Afghanistan by cause is illustrative. Of the 159 Canadian Soldiers who died in Afghanistan between 2002 and 2014 (the year Canadian forces withdrew) 27 were caused by “Non-Enemy Action” (Friendly Fire, Vehicle Accidents, Negligent Weapon Discharge, Suicide, ect.), of the remaining: 97 were caused by “explosives”, 22 were caused by “Direct Fire”, and 13 were caused by “Suicide attacks”. While slightly unclear ( is an Rocket Propelled Grenade (RPG) an explosive or direct fire? (further research leads me to believe “direct fire”)Presumably all suicide attacks were also explosive attacks?) this gives us an interesting breakdown, 22 fatalities out of 159 were caused by enemy ”direct fire”, and at least one list suggests a majority of those were RPG fire, if any of those were sniper attacks it would be just one or two, and Some lists show fewer than 5 actually dying from enemy gun fire.

But something else happened between 2002 and 2014, two of the worst crimes in Canadian history took place in that timespan, the Mayerthorpe Tragedy and the Moncton Shooting which killed 4 RCMP officers and 3 RCMP officers respectively. Let me repeat Two armed men, each acting alone, on two separate days may have gunned down more armed representatives of the Canadian Federal Government, than the entire Afghan insurgency may have managed to shoot dead in more than a decade war.

.

These were not isolated incidents. The 2016 Dallas Sniper Attack killed 5 police officers, while the Baton Rouge Shooting ten days later killed 3 police officers, The 2015 Chattanooga Shooting killed 4 marines and 1 navy Sailor, and the 2014 Killings of NYPD officers killed 2 police officers, and that isn’t getting into the veritable abattoir of plain old mass shootings and attacks not targeted at police, which none-the-less ended in police or military dead or injured. If your interested you can look at the full list of all terrorist or terrorist adjacent attacks in the US: Here.

Simply put even more shocking than the ineffectiveness of the veteran Afghan Insurgency’s attacks with gunfire, is the terrifying effectiveness amateur and deranged North Americans seem to muster consistently against both the public and the police forces who have spent decades training and preparing for such events.

This demands explanation.

1st possible Explanation: Coalition forces played it very safe.

They stayed inside the wire, and only ventured out armoured, armed and in force. Whereas police have to intermix with the public in ways that make them vulnerable.

Problem: While this may explain some shooters getting the drop on police, it doesn’t explain a-lot more, both the Baton Rouge and Dallas shootings occurred during protests when police were already on alert and in most cases were responding to what they knew was either an armed man or an active shooter. Furthermore members of swat teams regularly get wounded or killed in action, even though they receive much the same if not better training and gear than most soldiers.

.

2nd possible explanation: The Afghan Insurgents were operating with uniquely bad training and equipment.

This has already been viewed in the equipment the Afghan insurgents were operating with, often old world war era bolt actions and old and poorly maintained Kalashnikovs. But beyond this the average Afghan Insurgent might very well be illiterate and, even if they can read in their native language, would probably not have access to the educational resources most english speakers take for granted. An American amateur can teach themselves marksmanship with youtube and a few thousand rounds of ammo, but an Afghan insurgent wouldn’t be able to access that media and probably wouldn’t have the ammo budget.

Problem: Afghan insurgencies are able to successfully manage bomb construction, emplacement and detonation, a task considerably more dangerous and knowledge intensive than learning marksmanship. This may be explained by a different distribution of knowledge: the insurgents only need one bomb maker in the mountains to supply an entire campaigns worth of bombs but marksmanship has to be taught to everybody on the front, but still you’d think this would be something they could overcome.

.

.

Part 4: Explanation 3: The Psychological Explanation

The question of how to get people shoot each-other more effectively and lethally is one thats been given a shocking amount of attention.

In his book “On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society”, retired lieutenant colonel Dave Grossman takes us through the history of the US military’s struggles to get soldiers to shoot effectively in combat.

Grossman goes through S. L. A. Marshall’s Ratio of Fire data from WWII. Marshall claimed from his interviews with combatants immediately after firefights that only 15-25% of men in combat would fire their weapons, blaming the other 75%’s failure to fire on an “...inner unrealized resistance towards killing their fellow man”. The military took this theory to heart and redesigned much of their training around attempting to increase that willingness to fire. I’ve seen it claimed that realistically human shaped targets were introduced around this time and a focus on combat simulation was added as part of this process with firing blank rounds in simulated combat and even sim-munitions (chalky paintball like rounds that are fired by real gun powder out of real rifles at the real members of your rival training team) entering the the training regimen and still in use today.

The result was dramatic by Korea some 55% of soldiers were supposedly firing and by by the Falklands that number had reached 95%.

Grossman has built an entire philosophy and Psychological speciality around this psychological quirk and Both On Killing and his followup On Combat are mandatory reading for most military and law enforcement officers. Beyond this Grossman and his theory of the unnaturalness of killing and the military’s conditioning of soldiers to overcome their natural instinct has become a core part of how the military and law enforcement deals with, and prepares their soldiers to deal with, PTSD., with Grossman’s philosophy of “Killology” and its destinction between “sheep” (normal non violent people) “wolves” (natural or unnatural psychopaths who perpetuate violence) and “sheepdogs” (those who take on aspects of the wolf to fight the wolves) taking a hallowed place, to this day, in the imaginations of law enforcement and military professionals.

Beyond this Grossman has Argued that violent pop-culture and video games in particular replicate military conditioning and psychologically train kids to kill.

There was only one problem:

it was complete bullshit.

In his review of Grossman’s work * KILLING FOR THEIR COUNTRY: A NEW LOOK AT “KILLOLOGY”* Robert Engen revisited SLA Marshall’s research and made 2 discoveries.

First SLA Marshall kept pretty much zero record of his interviews. As far as we know he made everything up, and there is certainly not the extraordinary evidence required to justify the extraordinary claim that 75% of infantrymen failed to fire in combat.

Second, Engen actual found questionnaires from the Canadian Military filled out by WW2 infantry officers about about their troops performance in combat:

The issue of Marshall’s ratio of fire was one that I have always found to be very interesting, and when I decided to pursue graduate studies in history, I began researching the subject to see what corroborating evidence might exist in the primary source documentation. In mid-2007, I began examining a series of battle experience questionnaires filled out by Canadian infantry officers during the Second World War, addressing as they did a wide array of tactical questions, and giving the soldiers the opportunity to provide feedback and personal comments with respect to combat. Several hundred questionnaires were filled out by Canadians from rifle companies in 1944 and 1945 shortly after they had returned from combat, giving them the same immediacy attributed to Marshall’s group interviews. Given the similar timeframe to Marshall, as well as the similar content, I believe they are at least as credible a source as Men Against Fire, and likely more so, since the original questionnaires can still be found and verified at the Library and Archives Canada (LAC) in Ottawa. These battle experience questionnaires are quite candid, and they explore the tactical realities facing Allied soldiers in the Second World War, both in the Mediterranean theatre and in northwest Europe. I perused over 150 of the infantry surveys stored at LAC over the course of several months, compiling statistics from the formal survey questions and transcribing all the informal personal comments that had been attached. The evidence I collected became the basis for my Master’s thesis, which, as this article goes to press, is being revised as a manuscript.

There is a wealth of varied information contained in these questionnaires, but what they can tell us about Marshall’s ratio of fire is pivotal. Not a single one of the questionnaires – filled out by infantry officers who fought at close quarters and commanded rifle companies, platoons, and sections in combat – mentions anything about soldiers not firing their weapons. Indeed, the exact opposite appeared to be the major problem – that is, Canadian troops firing too much, wasting ammunition, and giving away their positions.42 Most officers, however, were generally satisfied with the rate of small-arms fire, and they regarded it as being very effective in battle, particularly for defeating the inevitable German counterattacks that followed every offensive action.43 A failure on the part of some of their troops to actively participate in battle was only highlighted by a few respondents during discussions of combat fatigue and ‘green’ replacement soldiers, and even those cases constituted a small minority. If over 75 percent of the riflemen under their command would not fight, as Marshall and Grossman claim, then the officers filling out the questionnaires would have noticed. Given their candid responses and genuine desire to help the Canadian Army train and fight better – the stated purpose of the questionnaires was to provide feedback with respect to combat training and experience while the war was still going on – it is extremely implausible that they would have overlooked, concealed, or covered up such alarmingly relevant information.

The questionnaires demonstrate that infantry combat is too complex, fluid, and terrifying an experience to be reduced to simple numbers. Today’s hero could easily be tomorrow’s coward (a point Marshall tried to make), and soldiers could not easily be reduced to the labels of killer/non-killer, or shooter/non-shooter.

This pretty much jives with my own expectations and beyond this Engen does a very good job of taking apart Grossman’s unscientific and faulty views of human nature and the evolution of higher mamimal. Contrary to Grossman: Cats, Canines, and Primates rape and murder each other all the time and our closest relatives, chimps, even commit genocide against their rival tribes in a way that pretty much accords with anything readers of the Old testament or ancient history will recognize. The idea that human nature somehow precludes murderous violence is beyond fantastical, indeed even fantasy writers struggle to depict a human that is not innately capable of violence

.

While eventually I do want to do a full takedown of Grossman, there’s just to much to deal with. Read the Engen piece and know thats not half of whats wrong with Grossman.

.

But then what causes the difference between the taliban and western insurgency attacks? Well i have a theory.

.

.

part 5 (Final): My Theory

Now I’ve never been in combat, but I’ve read a fair bit, gone paint-balling, and played alot of MilSim (ARMA) video games. So I’m pretty much a Navy Seal ;b

And if I’ve concluded anything from my experience its that gunfights are really Counter Intuitive.

For the vast majority of human history the range of engagement had been spear distance maybe stretching out to throwing or arrow distance if your a specialist, and if you watch a-lot of hollywood movies you’d think this is the range fights still happen at. Watch an 80s action movie and that ranges fights happen at are not different from the ranges depicted in robin hood movies or even the more chaotic sword fights in movies, which often become painfully clear the second Arnold or Rambo runs out of rounds and starts throwing their Knives. Take a look at This Fight in Commando and notice how Arnold doesn’t even have to feign aiming, his targets are so close, with even the longest shot he takes maxing out at maybe 40-50 meters (a good range for a thrown weapon like a javelin) and even though Hollywood has supposedly embraced realism since the 80s this is still the range at which fights happen in movies with even the supposedly realistic fights in John Wick happening at ranges where a knife often proves the most effective weapon. Even movies about long range snipers such as Enemy at the Gates often have panoramic shoots which reveal the sniping is often happening at under 100 meters.

Now this makes sense for hollywood, they need the shooter and the target to be clearly legible to the viewer and if the two actually were several hundred meters apart they simply wouldn’t be able to convey that information with pretty much any tricks of cinematography, but its really telling that the trick of shrinking the ranges down to throwing distance works, with audiences seemingly experiencing no cognitive dissonance when watching a gritty war movie were the battle-hardened elite soldiers seemingly can’t shoot more than 80 meters.

That engagements at 5 meters feels intuitively right to most audiences, i think, speaks to the fact that our natural instincts are still tuned for melee combat with the occasional throwing of stuff and why most modern fighting happening at modern ranges feels so demoralizing and horrifying even in theory (Peter Pan and the Lost Boys sword fighting with pirates fill us with whimsy, whereas the idea of them sighting in mortar fire fills us with disillusioned ennui).

.

If you have never been paint-balling, I highly recommend it. Unless you live in the middle of nowhere there is almost certainly a location near you where you can drop in and for 20ish dollars get a big lesson in humility. While relatively quiet and peaceful compared to even a day at the range with a .22. Paint-balling (assuming you haven’t ruined the surprise by researching it to death) does seem to give an approximation of just why modern battle is widely considered a confusing horror (bonus points if you select a dark indoor location).

Simply put: you can’t see shit. Enemy rounds land near you and you take cover behind something, and now you have your mask (probably fogging from your panicked breathing (or your ballistic eyewear)), your cover, maybe 50-100meters of dense terrain and flying balls, and your opponents cover between your eyeballs and any information that might possibly be useful. Beyond this you are rightfully terrified to poke your head out and get a better look, and Oh god are they coming round your flank!?

As you can imagine this is incredibly demoralizing and disempowering and yet you have a magical empowerment device right there in your hands.... so of course you start firing wildly and pretty much blindly. You hose down a bunch of rounds and maybe even get the guys down range to duck down a little as you shout some (hopefully mild) profanity back at the twerps who were just cursing you out.

Now this is worse than useless tactically: your wasting scarce ammunition (an even worse offence when your carrying heavy ammunition instead of light plastic balls), you’ve given away your position (which is, again, vastly worse when your rounds explode loudly and let everyone within several kilometres know exactly where you are, and can visually verify it from your muzzle flash), and you’ve wasted time on a dominance display when you could have been moving and actually contributing to the fight.

And yet we see the exact same behaviour all the time in footage from conflicts around the world whether it be the various militias in Afghanistan or Iraq, or panicked conflicts in Vietnam or indeed the momentary breakdowns of discipline described by those Canadian Infantry Officers.

What you want to do, and what you eventually learn in subsequent rounds of paintball or whatever game your playing, is to note what you’ve seen, visualize the space, and then move under cover or covering fire to get to another position where you can then see more, process that info, and eventually close in on where you’ve narrowed down the enemy to be. It takes alot of teamwork to maintain that cover, a fair amount of metal work to narrow down where your opponent is and get the drop on them instead of getting dropped on, and a-lot of mental discipline to continue being small, and quiet, and moving.

Simply put there is a reason paintball and comparable training has been used by militaries everywhere, and why video games are increasingly used by militaries for training (Often with amusing results).

.

Grossman blamed the rise of mass shootings on Video Games, saying that they psychologically trains kids to kill, but while this is almost certainly wrong, mass killers and serial killers have been with us since the 30s and before (with famous serial killers and killers from the 70s-90s and travelling spree killers and robbers before that), but the phenomena of the modern effective North America gunman needs explanation and I think the spread of Video Games, gun culture and the associated knowledge does explain a great deal.

Now, this isn’t an argument against Gun Culture and video games, unlike the psychological conditioning Grossman envisions, knowledge is neutral. Indeed to the extent you think a gun culture should check the power of the state you might consider this a indicator that it does.But it points to something that should be concerning for us.

.

Our experience in Afghanistan or even Iraq is not representative of how we should expect small arms fights to play out elsewhere. Just as Iraq was vastly different from Afghanistan due to the number of former Iraqi army fighters who could employ sniper tactics, so should we expect any insurgency or combat in Europe or North America to employ vastly different and effective tactics.

It has been pretty much forgotten that America had its own spree of sniper attacks in the US in the mid 2000s with the “DC sniper” being only the most famous. And just as a cube van driving around with a shooter in the back would be entirely impossible in Afghanistan, so would it be entirely unlikely for any unrest in America to resemble our experience in the middle-east. We’re flying far more blind than we can imagine.


r/TheMotte • • Jul 22 '22

Eleven Magic Words

199 Upvotes

[Originally published as my first contribution to Singal-Minded back in February, and now unlocked for everyone.]

I am a public defender.

I am the vanguard of justice. I am the bulwark against tyranny. I am a hoot at dinner parties. I am this author’s Tinder bio. I am venerated by the new progressive zeitgeist.

I am the corporeal manifestation of professional burnout.

I am useless. So fucking useless.

There’s a dull reality to my job, which is that my clients have almost always done the thing they’re accused of doing. And usually the evidence against them is overwhelming — not even a close call. Yet I am duty-bound to poke, prod, and bluff my way into exaggerating a weakness with the government’s case. This usually doesn’t work.

For example, one time a client was picked up for his sixth drunk-driving incident. He had been prohibited from driving eons ago, but that hadn’t stopped him before. In addition to DUI No. 6, he was charged with fleeing the scene after crashing into another car. The fleeing was ineffectual, if only for the fact that he literally imprinted his license plate number onto the other car1. I saw the picture of the imprint, with a mirrored alphanumeric sequence perfectly legible on the metal body. Cops found his car billowing thick, black smoke in a parking lot in front of a nearby AutoZone. My client hadn’t gotten far from the scene: He was in the driver’s seat, having already passed out and pissed his pants.

So yeah, when I meet with clients I shrug a lot and give the “what-do-you-want-me-to-do?” look. I try to shift delicately into the gentle social worker persona and talk about damage control, which invariably means telling them that accepting a plea deal is the least bad option. This is one reason why almost everyone chooses to plead guilty. Ninety-four percent of state cases and 97% of federal cases are resolved by a plea deal, to be exact.

All this means I inhabit a different role than you may think based on TV shows or the occasional op-ed about the noble role of public defenders. I’m not a special agent who parachutes into the enemy hideout to orchestrate and negotiate an elaborate hostage release; I’m just the widget inspector. I’m there to sit at the assembly line with a checklist on a clipboard and make sure that my client’s rights are not violated too much throughout the process. And we literally used a checklist for DUI cases — six pages of potential rakes we could only pray a cop stepped on: Yes, yes, you have video of the guy swerving all over the road, his speech is as slurred as mud, and he has a small cargo ship’s worth of empty beer bottles in the back. BUT was the temperature of the liquid simulator solution utilized as the external standard for the breath sample machine measured by a thermometer which was properly certified by the state at the time? Hmmm?

It doesn’t happen often, but occasionally the cops do fuck up. Sometimes they don’t notice the thermometer certification lapsed two days prior, and of course you pounce on that. But this almost never happens, and it also underscores how fungible my own contributions are. Anyone plausibly qualified could replace me and it would not make a difference for the most part.

I’m borderline useless, in other words.

But there are terrifying exceptions to this rote monotony that forever haunt me. Like the one time I cast a spell in court with eleven magic words.


This happened early, when I was still a baby public defender. My client (different from License Plate Man above) was an illegal immigrant2 from Mexico. He was already on probation for one DUI when he was caught driving drunk a second time, seven years after the first. A judge released him from jail provided that his family fork over a small ransom for bail and that he agree to having his whereabouts monitored by an ankle bracelet. He would have to come back to address his probation issues in two weeks.

The ankle bracelet company sends me an update a few days later. My client had visited their office, informed them that he intended to flee the country because he was scared of jail, then underscored his statement with a flourish by taking out a knife and cutting off the ankle bracelet in front of them. In terms of the ratio between effort and impact, this was easily one of the simplest ways he could have irredeemably fucked himself over. But I did not have time to dwell on this. His actions meant I had one less client to worry about, since clearly he had decided to take his chances on the lam rather than in court.

Two weeks pass and I’m in court. Just a normal day: I review the sign-in sheet to see which defendants, of the cases I had prepped, did me the courtesy of showing up. Our caseloads aren’t always as bad as advertised because many of our clients don’t come to court, for reasons ranging from malicious (they’re reenacting a certain 1993 thriller starring Harrison Ford) to banal (the notice was lost in the mail).

Then I see his name — Bracelet Cutter. I turn and scan the row of benches in the gallery and he’s quietly sitting in the back, apparently oblivious to the shitstorm of his own creation he has walked into.

I motion for him to step out in the hallway and my first question is “What the FUCK are you doing here?” He looks down, ashamed, and explains he realized that if he had fled, his family would have remained liable for the bond they put up to get him released. “I am here to take responsibility,” he says.

There was no need for me to pillory him any further. He panicked and fucked up, but that was done. Unfortunately, I was completely ill-prepared to handle his case, as I had reasonably assumed he had successfully peaced out of the country (and out of the justice system’s grasp) by now. We went in front of the judge and I announced that my client was turning himself in to jail so that I could better prepare for his case. We’d be back in court in another two weeks.


In part because of those aforementioned stats on the frequency of guilty pleas, public defenders have garnered a reputation for being trial-averse, for pressuring clients to cop a plea just to keep the machine humming along. I think this reputation is ill-deserved. It’s completely counter to my own experience, at least, as few things are talked about with as much awed respect among one’s public-defender peers as the number of trials you have accumulated. It’s the functional equivalent of an attorney’s XP level.

Jury trials are sexy and cool and exciting, even despite the abysmal prospects for acquittal. But the understandable focus on dramatic moments can cause people to lose sight of potentially far more consequential proceedings that lack the luster and allure. Like probation hearings.

I hate probation hearings so much.

The gravitational center of the criminal justice system is not the judge, but the prosecutor. Prosecutors can summon criminal charges from the aether or dispel them into nothingness, if they so choose. The Trial Tax is real, so if you want to avoid getting resolutely fucked at sentencing, your best bet is to play nice from the start. This is what makes accepting a plea deal so irresistible to so many clients. Judges say they ultimately decide — sure, whatever — but in practice, a prosecutor’s offer recommendation is virtually guaranteed to be adopted. Judges are busy, and the vast majority used to be prosecutors themselves. A current prosecutor’s blessing on a deal is generally all the oversight a judge cares to invest. If the deal recommends no jail time, you’ll get no jail time. This is what I told all my clients, and it was always true.

But there’s a caveat, in that many little- or no-jail deals are paired with a laundry list of legal obligations that are monitored by the courts for many years. In addition to not committing new crimes, the obligations can be as simple as attending a class about how drugs are bad. Courts enforce this scheme by imposing the statutory maximum amount of jail time (a year for most misdemeanors), but simultaneously suspending nearly all of it. Think of it as setting aside a bucket of jail days that can be doled out as needed if a client didn’t adhere to the agreement.

Doling from the bucket was what the probation calendar was for. Clients who had already pled guilty were summoned back to court because they had fucked up somehow and needed to explain themselves to the judge.

During these probation hearings, the prosecutor would recite the list of violations and recommend a sanction. My job was to come up with a plausible-sounding justification and make a counteroffer for sanction, and the judge would probably just split it down the middle. Sometimes it’s 30 days of house arrest. Sometimes 90 days of jail. If jail, sometimes clients had a week to turn themselves in. Sometimes the court marshals were summoned to take them to jail immediately. All this in the span of 5-10 minutes per person, one after the other. Assembly line humming.


Generally, we had no way of knowing when someone would be summoned back to court for a probation hearing until it was scheduled. Our paralegals scanned the calendars and dove into our archives to retrieve a client’s file. I tried to call my clients prior to court appearances, but this was often a lost cause as numbers were frequently disconnected, out of service, or linked to full voicemail boxes. The best that you could eventually hope for was for the client to actually show up to court so that you could confer for the requisite five minutes in the adjoining hallways and stairwells before the proceedings.

But as much as Bracelet Cutter fucked up his prospects in other ways, at least there wasn’t any question as to whether he’d show up for his hearing — he was in jail, after all. I swung by with an interpreter (his English was passable, but not great) to fill him in on the details and answer his questions. I felt ready for the hearing.

The day came. Bracelet Cutter’s mother, wife, and children were in attendance in the gallery. The court churned through its list of cases until it was our turn.

Recall how plea deals are structured, and how the entire purpose of a suspended jail sentence is to dangle the anvil over someone’s head to “encourage” them to do the things they’re supposed to do. The bargain means you avoid jail time so long as you meet your obligations. But what if, perhaps through your repeated and extended frittering away of your opportunities to stay out of jail, there is no realistic expectation you’ll ever meet your obligations to the court? Rather than continue burning up the court’s resources, judges could instead impose a hefty jail sentence now and just close the file. This is affectionately known as “Impose & Close.”

On this day, luckily, the prosecutor was not feeling particularly bloodthirsty. He was going to recommend the mandatory minimum sanction of 48 hours in jail, which my client had more than already served by now, and leave the rest of the jail time suspended, meaning he wouldn’t have to serve it as long as he behaved himself. I was more than happy to cosign on that recommendation, excited to see the judge rubber-stamp our joint agreement.

Despite the good sign, though, I was still cautious — I had not walked into the hearing with much confidence. I knew that my client’s decision to cut off an ankle bracelet and threaten to flee to Mexico was going to be on the judge’s mind, and I knew that the worst approach with her would have been to ignore the issue completely. After effusively agreeing with the prosecutor’s recommendation, I got ahead of the issue. I started by acknowledging what happened, framing it from the standpoint of a poor guy panicking in a stressful situation, and highlighted the extended meeting I had with him while he was in jail. His family members in the gallery served as helpful props in my argument. After all, why would he flee the country when *gesturing widely* his family is right here?

This did not work. The judge said that she had no confidence that my client would be able to meet his legal obligations. She then turned to the prosecutor and asked what the recommended jail sentence was to close the file out. Which meant Impose & Close was happening.

This was a full-blown red alert moment, and by far the worst possible outcome. Now that a probation period appeared to be off the table, the prosecutor was no longer tied to asking for just two days in jail. The price to close the file would be 180 days. I stood up and did my best to slide in and emphasize that neither party requested to close out the file, and repeated my spiel.

The judge politely listened and then imposed 180 days in jail. The reactions came in waves — my client’s mom yelled out in anguish first because she could understand the judge, and then her son followed after the court interpreter delivered the bad news in Spanish. My client was handcuffed and slumped in his chair, disconsolate. This didn’t just mean six months in jail; ICE kept watch over the local jail rosters, so the sentence was not only long but virtually assured his deportation.

I tried to focus, to ignore the sudden cacophony reverberating around me. I remained standing and stared at nothing in particular. Fifteen seconds passed. What now? Was there anything I could do? Was there anything I should do?

Thirty seconds passed, and the only audible sound was the shuffling of paper and murmurs across the gallery. I figured it wouldn’t hurt to try, so I strung together a hastily improvised request to the judge — hereafter known as the Eleven Magic Words:

“Is there anything the court would like to review to reconsider?”

There are words recognized within legal circles to have near magical properties. The Supreme Court will tell you that all you need to immediately and forcefully end a police interrogation is to unambiguously ask for a lawyer. Declarations etched in steel by a dying man have the power to move trillions in assets. Even the lowly comma, or the absence thereof, can overturn entire industries. But the eleven words I uttered that day are not valorized or dissected by any scholars. They shoulder no inherent legal significance. And yet, they earned their title for what happened next.

Nothing but silence now. The judge peered directly at me over her glasses. She then asked for the file back from the clerk and barely even opened it before announcing, “All right. Mr. Meskhout, I’ll go ahead and give him an opportunity. Since you have asked.”

The judge then imposed two days in jail. Two days instead of one hundred and eighty.

The cacophony started up again — outcries of joy (and some confusion) this time rather than anguish. I gathered that neither my client nor his mom quite understood what the fuck had just happened. I certainly didn’t.

“Since you have asked.”

My heart rate skyrocketed and my eyes twitched. I remained standing and did my best to maintain composure.

“Since you have asked.”

I kept replaying that sentence over and over in my head. This wasn’t how it was supposed to work. I was not supposed to have this much power. I’m supposed to be useless, remember? A widget inspector. There was something thoroughly unconscionable about what had just transpired. I uttered eleven magic words in the right combination and this man’s life trajectory shifted radically, likely from near-assured deportation to continued freedom in the United States. I am not supposed to have this much power.

To say that I felt fear is an understatement. But I kept all of this to myself. This was my last hearing for the morning and I could go back to my office now and process at my pace.

I hastily scrawled my signature on the court order and walked out of the courtroom. My client was escorted out by the jail guard right behind me. Normally, inmates get their hands and feet shackled together before they step out. My client was completely unshackled. And normally, the jail guards waste no time heading to the security elevator they have exclusive access to, but my client was headed in the opposite direction.

I saw where he was going. His children had been sitting on a bench in the hallway. My client ran forward and bent down to embrace them both, and all I remember him exclaiming was “¡Niños!” The jail guard was calmly walking right behind this unfolding security breach beaming and carrying the shackled chain in his hands. My client finished hugging his children then promptly stood up and placed his hands behind his back to be shackled again. The guard and my client continued taking the long way to the security elevator.

I was awestruck by the unexpected display of humanity by the guard. I have no idea when they negotiated this, but he broke all kinds of protocol just to let my client have this brief embrace with his children.

I walked into the main elevators by myself, watched the doors close, and waited for the cab to start moving. Once I knew I was alone and safely insulated by several layers of steel and concrete, I finally let out the primal scream I had been holding in this whole time.

Once the heart palpitations calmed, I reflected on what transpired. I certainly would love to believe it was the Eleven Magic Words that did the trick that day — that would reflect well on my legal acumen and provide me a modicum of agency within this chaos. But that is a self-serving delusion that would also imbue the criminal justice system with a patina of legitimacy it has no rightful claim on.

In all likelihood, the judge changed her mind because fuck you — that’s why. They’re human after all, subject to the same tempestuous emotional storms as the rest of us, including the same impulses that might prompt you to idly fantasize about a horrific vehicular rending of the guy who just cut you off on the road. Despite that human fallibility, they’re nevertheless endowed with a terrific amount of real power over other people’s lives. Maybe if they’re addressed as “Your Honor” enough times per minute, they’ll believe it and act accordingly.

Or maybe I should jettison the fake humility and just take credit. Based purely on the sequence of events (I said something, a thing happened), I have a legitimate basis to exploit this story to flatter myself and impress attractive individuals. Yet this too has horrifying implications.

Either way, every day since, I wonder whether I will clock out at the end of the day as the mild-mannered widget inspector I normally am. Every morning I wonder whether that day has Eleven Magic Words and, if it does, whether I’ll be able to figure them out. And every day that potential scares the shit out of me.

And yet, I still do the work. I’m still a public defender.


1 I have told this story to many fellow attorneys, and more than once they’ve had to double-check to make sure I wasn’t talking about their own client, because apparently imprinting your own license plate number on the other car is a relatively common occurrence among the nation’s habitual drunk drivers.

2 Here’s why I still use this term.


r/TheMotte • • Feb 19 '21

Maginot syndrome: Bullish for Han hegemony

182 Upvotes

There’s a fairly common contrarian narrative circulating around the internet:

Sure China looks big and strong but they really have all kinds of problems. The shadow banking sector, inefficient SOEs, corruption, horrendous environmental degradation, middle-income trap, command economy, expensive internal security apparatus, low birth rates and so on will prevent them from overtaking the US. Meanwhile, while the US looks like an empire in rapid decline, American capitalism and republican institutions have often rebounded in the past. The US still has a technological edge in semiconductors, enduring power of democracy and freedom, world’s largest navy by tonnage etc, dozens of allies…

I believe this is cherry-picking and that China looks big and strong because it is big and strong. They have problems but have the willpower and intellect to fix them, to expand and improve. Meanwhile, it is the US that is experiencing a precipitous decline. They’re far weaker than they look on nearly every front. There’s a critical weakness in elite willpower that has rendered the US passive and incapable of effectively wielding what remains of its strength.

This imbalance happened once before. France in the 1930s and those few weeks in May is the archetypal example of this failure mode. They experienced more than a decade of decay (military and political) before a stunning defeat, yet it was largely unnoticed outside a few niche commentators. Nearly everyone thought they’d wipe the floor with the Germans. I think the same thing is happening with the US and China today. Note that I’m not focused on advocating a normative argument ‘this is how things should be’, I’m trying to describe a phenomenon within a zero-sum strategic worldview: 'This is how things should be if you want to win'.

Background to WW2: Losing the unlosable war

France had recently won the greatest war in human history. On a strategic level, they’d managed to encircle Germany pre-war, securing an alliance with Russia and eventually Britain. They’d developed a plan to actively reshape Europe in their favour: force Germany into a two-front war they lacked the resources to win. Then retake Alsace-Lorraine and neuter Germany forever more. In 1912, the French told the Russians they’d be willing to fight for their Balkan interests, essentially ensuring a war at some point. But despite propping up Russia with loans and strategic investment for decades, the Russians didn’t do nearly as well as expected on the battlefield. (Obviously all kinds of other factors were involved but I’m just interested in what the French were doing. Their strategy was simple and worked, on the whole.)

France performed very well on the military front, fighting against a powerful foe with some of their richest provinces under enemy occupation. While the British lost 20,000 men on Day 1 of the Somme, the French took their objectives at a minimum of fatalities (something like 200, excellent even considering it was a primarily British operation). Ferdinand Foch was the Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in WW1. He was their Eisenhower and rightly so: the French made the greatest contribution to the Western Front and thus the war. The French showed extraordinary resolve to fight on through heavy casualties (the highest proportionately of any major power) and mastered the new doctrine of trench warfare.

Anyway, one would think that Germany would have no chance for round 3. They’d lost 10% of their European territory, their entire colonial empire, their navy was all but deleted, the army was vastly reduced, airforce prohibited and their allies had been dismembered. France now had alliances with Czechoslovakia and Poland and of course they had the British Empire on their side, along with limited support from all the other democracies. Even Fascist Italy was friendly towards the Allies: they joined in the 1935 Stresa Front which promised to defend Austria from Hitler. After all, who would you prefer to ally with as a second-rate wannabe power? The triumphant victors of the Great War or the bitter loser? Furthermore, France developed a powerful defensive strategy: fortify the Franco-German border to the point of impregnability (the infamous Maginot line) and prepare mobile forces to move into Belgium to dig in there. Then, use the vastly superior Allied navies to blockade the Germans into submission like in the last war. All the while, the Allies would be mobilizing the vast resources of the world’s greatest empires plus whatever could be bought on world markets. Germany had no oil, no rubber, no tungsten, little iron ore, not much of anything but coal. In the long run they’d have to lose. France would merely have to defend from prepared positions for a few years, then strike with overwhelming force. It would be a very cost-effective way to win the war, saving money and lives.

(There’s a myth that the French didn’t expect the Germans to go around the line: that’s totally untrue. They remembered WW1. Even the Ardennes-being-impenetrable part isn’t really true. Once you get out of the Ardennes you still have to break through several rivers to get anywhere. River crossings against prepared opponents are some of the most difficult things you can possibly do.)

From the Outside View, sending the best part of your army deep into enemy territory in a rapid armoured thrust is a recipe for disaster, especially against a numerically superior force who has spent 20 years preparing to defend against your invasion. It was a hail-Mary move because the strategic situation for Germany was so bleak: they were totally outmatched by Allied resources. But it worked. I posit Maginot syndrome as an explanation for why France performed so poorly, why they failed to beat an opponent they should’ve had every advantage over. There are a number of causes, all stemming down to a failure of focused willpower by elites to implement a strategy:

  1. Political division. France was divided between communists and rightists to a crippling extent. Cabinet was unable to make a meaningful response to the great crisis of the time: the Great Depression. Corruption was rife. Mass strikes shut down industry and hasty, overgenerous labour reforms hurt the economy. When one’s government can’t manage internal affairs, it won’t have the energy to deal with foreign relations properly: attention is a scarce resource after all. Things got to the point where the French government was afraid of the military: one argument for why De Gaulle’s armoured division proposal was ignored is because it would represent a danger for the military to have too much autonomy and independence. France was internally divided, incapable of focusing on a strategy to advance their interests.

  2. Appease when they’re weak, challenge when strong (the worst possible grand strategy). French foreign policy in the later interwar period was largely dominated by what the British wanted: the French rightly knew they needed British help to beat Germany (though they should’ve been able to hold alone), so they don’t bear all the blame for this one. Even so, the French enjoyed overwhelming military superiority up until 1937. They could’ve kicked down the door when Hitler remilitarized the Rhineland and the whole structure would’ve come crumbling down. But they didn’t, because they were apathetic. French generals deliberately overestimated the number of German troops entering the Rhineland, including SS paramilitaries in the count. Inaction was the goal, not any kind of realistic strategy. The same goes for Czechoslovakia: the British persuaded themselves the Germans had the firepower to obliterate London on Day 1 because they used WW1 trench warfare deaths/tonne of TNT statistics and vastly overestimated the Luftwaffe’s range and payload capacity. It was a stupid and inappropriate thing to do then and didn’t even make much sense: surely they would invest in a much larger air force if the damage was so great OR move to take out Germany before the Luftwaffe developed? But the phoney numbers justified inaction, which is what Chamberlain and the rest of the appeasers desired. Certainly, Chamberlain lost his son in WW1 and fully understood the gravity of war – but that isn’t an excuse for bad strategy even if it makes his decisions more understandable. The Allies frittered away their hard-won spoils of WW1: they bungled the Stresa Front and pushed Italy towards Hitler by mishandling the invasion of Ethiopia. Misguided virtue-signalling and adherence to the League of Nations spirit of countering aggression cost them an important ally (and the Ethiopians were no better off btw). They handed Czechoslovakia (a well fortified country in a great meatshield position) to Hitler on a silver platter. They failed to secure Soviet support, making an extremely worthless treaty with the Soviets in 1935 rather than anything binding and effective. This naturally led to the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. Stalin couldn’t comprehend just how stupid Allied foreign policy was, he assumed the Allies were working with Hitler to turn him against the Soviets, so he pre-empted them. Essentially, Allied foreign policy from 1933 onwards was a complete debacle: they were blindly, passively pacifistic rather than actively, strategically advancing their interests.

  3. Obsolescence and inadequacy in the places that mattered, abundance in the irrelevant. The French army had plenty of artillery and tanks – more than Germany. Their tanks were often better armed and armoured than early-war German armour. The combined Allied forces (who had months and months to actively prepare for the invasion) outnumbered their German counterparts. The BEF was very well motorized, proportionately more motorized than the German army as a whole. However, they lacked radios, anti-aircraft guns, anti-tank guns and aircraft, the critical things they needed. Their doctrine was also obsolete: they were well-prepared for lengthy, well-planned Great War style battles not fast-paced armoured thrusts and counter-thrusts. They expected time to plan, not to need radios because nothing would be happening on the scale of hours. There were a few reformers who urged change but nothing was done. Nobody had the will to push into the unknown, to try out unproven new tactics.

  4. General military ineptitude. The infamous German push through the Ardennes did not go unnoticed. French recon planes spotted the buildup and should’ve alerted command. Perhaps command was alerted and chose to ignore it. Perhaps they were counting on the Germans to have to bring up heavy artillery if they wanted to break river defences: instead the Luftwaffe did that. In any event, French High Command was passive when the situation was in their favour and defeatist when things got bad. They ignored a months-long opportunity when the bulk of the German army was demolishing Poland, sitting still on the vulnerable French-German border. They somehow managed to let Germany invade Norway, by sea, despite having a huge advantage in naval power. They threw in the towel when the Germans did something unprecedented, like Rommel’s tanks and Stukas blitzing through the French at the Meuse. The rank and file were quickly demoralized, retreating en masse. While it’s true that after the initial encirclement the French fought fairly well, after you lose 61 divisions in an encirclement it’s very hard to come back without Soviet levels of space and manpower.

The Modern Day

Looking at the US in the present day, I’m concerned by the similarities. The US is at least as politically divided as France was. The government is dysfunctional and incapable of efficiently executing basic tasks like the Chinese can: see infrastructure, housing, highspeed rail, COVID vaccines, COVID lockdowns and shambolic foreign policy see-sawing (Iran deal, operations in Syria). This ineptitude naturally extends into the military: warships crash repeatedly. I don’t have any egregious combat errors because the US hasn’t fought a naval war since WW2 – but avoiding collision in open waters in peacetime is surely a prerequisite to winning a naval war! If you can see cracks and broken windows outside the house, things are probably worse inside where you can’t see.

The US is being consistently outbuilt by China as well, which is alarming considering the supposed gulf in defense budgets. The greatest military threat to the US is China, so how is America being outpaced when they have around twice the money? US dockyards are in a sorry state, contractors are incompetent and there’s new ships are expensive and ineffective like the Zumwalt. Alternately, the Chinese might be pumping a lot more money into their military than they say. At any rate, they can afford to do so. If they truly are spending about 1.2% of GDP on the military as they say, they can triple it. Russia can afford 3% of GDP despite crippling sanctions and rampant corruption in an already weak economy. A strong dictatorship with a colossal industrial base should be capable of more.

Furthermore, just like France, there’s a danger of the US being behind in the areas that matter. China is ahead in hypersonics. While the US does have an advantage in supercarriers and 5th gen aircraft, it may be that hypersonic glide vehicles are simply superior. They are faster, longer range and possibly cheaper once you account for pilot training costs and the other miscellaneous expenses of aerial warfare. If carriers can’t get close enough to Taiwan because of the missiles and the airbases themselves get obliterated, what good can the F35 do? Of course, the US and allies are developing anti-missile systems and hypersonics of their own but these technologies aren’t really mature yet. Besides, it’s always been very difficult to shoot down missiles in a cost-effective way, let alone missiles that can alter their ballistic trajectories. And there's an innate advantage to the aggressor if hypersonic missiles become the primary weapon of war: he who launches first wins. Even if both sides lose their airfields, C4I, radar… the side that can launch a few sorties and is marginally more prepared will have an advantage. This will favour China, since the US is never going to strike first.

Yes, even if the US loses its nearby airbases, they can use strategic bombers with standoff weapons to counterattack. There are weaknesses in this though: the US doesn’t have many strategic bombers, they are more temperamental to maintain for long-term operations and even the B2 would need in-air refuelling, complicating the logistical situation. They are also quite old and are unable to contest for air superiority. There’s danger in deploying last-generation stealth tech against a foe who has had 20 years to prepare and counter them. Modernity matters: updating avionics and weapons has diminishing returns.

The Chinese fleet is also in many respects more modern than the American fleet. The new Type 55’s seem quite capable. The Chinese 052Ds are young, along with most of the other frigates and destroyers. Looking at their fleet, I was surprised by how many frigates and destroyers they can pump out in a single year.

They’ll be facing off against US Ticonderegas (the youngest of which was commissioned in 1994), a couple of disastrously mismanaged but contemporary Zumwalts, a lot of Arleigh Burkes (mostly made in 1990s and 2000s but with updated production continuing), Los Angeles subs from the 80’s and 90’s, a couple of 2000’s Seawolfs and 2000’s and 2010’s Virginia subs. The new Gerald R Ford carrier is modern but the Nimitz’s are old and their powerplants will make it difficult to install new systems like missile-defence lasers. So as we continue into the 2020s, the aging USN will face a modern, readily upgradeable and rapidly growing fleet that’s totally concentrated in the West Pacific theatre. Its older ships will require more lengthy and expensive maintenance, limiting how many can actually be deployed in time along with potential obsolescence.

Now, one might argue that China is 10 years behind the US in everything, so age doesn’t matter so much. I think this is a pretty arrogant assumption, reminiscent of how the Allies derided Japanese aircraft as garbage pre-WW2. Certainly, the Japanese struggled with high performance engines – but that didn’t prevent the Zero from being effective early in the war. The Chinese still struggle with modern high-performance engines for their fighters as well as semiconductors – this doesn’t mean they can’t be capable in combat, that they can't offset that weakness with doctrinal, tactical or strategic adaptation. They are making better indigenous engines and microchips and have stolen a great deal from the US. Trends are more important than raw inequalities.

The US is very weak in cyberspace. Newspapers abound with stories of the Pentagon being hacked. A US general was impersonated and lost his passwords, which I believe compromised the White House too at one point. The marvellously named Shadow Brokers ran off with (or some disaffected staffer gave them) some stolen US cyberweapons and sold them for bitcoin! And of course, we know the Chinese have stolen secrets from the F35.

The only time I’ve heard of China getting hacked is when it recently emerged that millions of Communist Party members had infiltrated businesses and countries around the world. Now perhaps the US hears everything that happens across Eurasia but keeps quiet about it. Perhaps the CIA stole all the amazingly competent and discreet spies from the Snowden/Manning-ridden NSA. It’s possible – but it seems unlikely to the point of Q-tier secret wars. I believe there are more and higher placed Chinese spies in America (Fang and all those bribed scientists) than American spies in China. If things are decided by tech-stealing, grid-sabotaging, bioweapon-planting, software-backdooring shadow warfare, I think China holds all the cards. Cyberwarfare and hypersonic missiles may be the new radios and aircraft, it may be that we look back in 50 years and think ‘how stupid could you be to spend trillions on the most sophisticated network-centric weapons systems the world has ever seen but let the Chinese steal the designs and install a backdoor somewhere in the terabytes of all-important software’. This is the US’s entire force strategy in a nutshell: ask any expert about the F35 and they’ll say network integration is its greatest strength, its raison d'être. On land, sea and air it’s all network-centric warfare, the most vulnerable to cyber.

There are gaping vulnerabilities for the US in this most opaque field of warfare. The US has been hit before by Chinese electronic subversion. Slackness in defence computing is a recipe for disaster. France only lacked a few pieces of novel and largely unproven technology for its apparently world-class military to be torn apart. The US is probably in the same situation.

Perhaps more important is a lack of strategic vision. For about 25 years since the Tiananmen massacre, the US persuaded itself that they should assist China’s rise. They didn’t just appease China, they advanced her. Nobody should ever make fun of Chaimberlain again. Since 2014-2016, America realised that things won’t be so easy and that China is in fact a rival. But what strategy is there now to defeat China? Truman came up with Containment and made alliances with Greece and Turkey, bribing them into NATO. Trump launched the trade war – but that clearly isn’t enough to defeat China. It simply isn’t enough to rely on watered down Containment style policies – especially when you can’t get your allies to follow suit and slap on tariffs, nor bribe new partners into the fold. If your opponent is less populous and severely hampered (the Soviet Union lost 20M out of 180M in WW2 and had its homeland devastated) then containment is logical. It’s difficult to lose if you keep a weaker opponent from expanding.

But this time the rival isn’t less populous, nor is it less developed. We’re not talking about slight gaps like Japan producing 20% more steel than the US in 1990. China produces more steel than the rest of the world combined. They’re world No.1 on the number of TOP500 supercomputers. They’re not slouching on high speed rail either, with something like 60% of the world’s total installed in China. They are the biggest exporter in the world. They produce the most electric cars of any country. Of course, the Economist will say that it’s all fine because the US still has a lead on some other high-tech capital goods, semiconductors, robots and so on. This ignores the trend we’ve seen in Japan, Korea… First they make cheaper textiles than you, then more cars/steel, then consumer electronics, then high-tech capital goods. The US did the same thing to Britain. I see no reason why China should flounder in high technology: they do not lack high-IQ scientists or government support for advanced technology. There are no ethical qualms preventing them from stealing everyone else’s technology, human experimentation or genetic augmentation. They couldn’t care less about the privacy implications of intrusive AI surveillance needed to train world-leading neural networks. They have a gargantuan internal market too – they have every ingredient for success in high technology.

Yes, in terms of labour force, China exceeds the US, EU and Japan combined – by 300 million. Again, the Economist will say that it’s fine because China is aging faster than the US. This is true but it’s unclear how significant the trend is. My suspicion is that the CCP can reverse this by altering anti-natalist regulations that keeps many migrant workers from settling down in the cities. Centralized control over social media may also be very helpful in pushing a natalist message. More cynically, Chinese air pollution and tobacco use could be their saving grace in shortening expensive retirement periods. In any case, China is going to have a huge manpower advantage over almost any combination of powers that excludes India. Manpower is their card, not ours. And as we have seen in the recent COVID extravaganza, China’s manpower is very well organized. They can leverage tight Party control to make things happen quickly. Have you seen how quickly they can build an office building when they try? What about an arms factory?

If the US cares about winning, it ought to do more than circulate buzzwords like strategic competition, the ball is in their court. The ball has been in their court for the last 30 years and they have refused to take any pre-emptive action to suppress China. It was not as though nothing could’ve been justified: Tienanmen square, forced abortions in the One Child Policy, genocide and organ harvesting of the Falun Gong, support for crazy North Korea, Uyghurs etc… all could be used to justify action. Even if you don’t agree on the importance or accuracy of any of these issues, surely the media that justified the Iraq War could muster up support for sanctions on China? Forget morality and hypocrisy, what about strategy? Without oil imports, US capital and foreign technology, it would’ve taken China a very long time to get as strong as they are. Anyway, that opportunity is lost now. It was squandered by misguided, overconfident and sclerotic leadership. There was a brief attempt to develop some kind of strategy: at least the Project for the New American Century had a plan for American dominance even if it was incredibly stupid, wasteful and couldn’t be executed.

But now there is no plan. The US has been executing an energy-focused foreign policy while it exports oil. Saudi Arabia’s biggest customer is China. The US is butting heads with Russia, pushing them into the Chinese camp. The Trump administration seemed determined to push Iran into China’s arms and really bring that Eurasian world-island concept to life. Instead of a single global strategy, the US has numerous conflicting priorities. Fighting climate change, promoting liberal democracy, maintaining a vast network of vassal-states, adhering to UN multilateralism and non-aggression while suppressing two great powers is too much to ask for a country that's struggling with its domestic issues. It's as though the US has a mental model of itself as the righteous protagonist in one of its unbelievably syrupy TV shows (looking at you, Designated Survivor). You can't wrap everything up at the end of the episode. Sometimes you just have to ruthlessly prioritize, discard the luxuries and fight just to stay in the game.

The impression I get is that the US is a hollow force, overdue for a catastrophic humiliation. Perhaps they’ll wake up and get their act together like the British did in WW2: the US has General Geography on their side more than Russia ever had Winter. Certainly, China doesn’t have much hope of getting far into the Pacific right now, let alone threatening the US’s West Coast ports. It's logistically impossible. The US certainly has time and space on their side if things go poorly on the West Pacific Front. They can regroup and form a new defensive line in the Straits of Malacca, blockading Chinese oil imports. But the Chinese aren't idiots. They know this and will plan around it.

They also have an advantage in allies (Pakistan and NK are weak), though there are risks there too. Japan can be relied upon to be loyal (they hate China) but I have fears about their staying power. Japan really is too old, bringing its cost in debt and a lack of dynamism. South Korea is less reliable, given their distrust of Japan and relatively warm feelings about China. Taiwan is apathetic, with a weak military. They don’t like the Communist Party but their will to fight hard is dubious. Vietnam and the Philippines don’t like China but aren’t strong: the Philippines might be useful as a naval base but can’t really contribute much more than that. And there’s also the prospect of China buying/bullying them into submission. The Philippines and Vietnam are not strong democracies; their political systems are opaque and potentially vulnerable. As with Europe in the 1930s, there may be defectors like Italy or Romania or opportunists like Hungary and Bulgaria. Just as they were economically dependent on Germany, so too are many Asian countries economically tied to China.

As for the Great Powers, Russia is leaning towards China. They’re aligned ideologically, leading the anti-liberal democracy camp. There are a great many commentators in the West who think they should join us vs China but I can’t understand why. How can China hurt Russia in the face of thousands of nuclear warheads and a relatively self-reliant economy? They can’t blockade Russia for geographical reasons. They don’t care if Russia kills journalists, annexes Ukraine, is undemocratic… What does the West have to offer Russia? China can offer them a free hand at home and in Europe plus the world’s biggest market for resources. They can provide world-leading surveillance and repression AI. Our leadership class can’t even spell realpolitik; such is their obsession with bullying non-democracies. No lessons were learnt from hectoring Mussolini over Ethiopia: either go hard or go home. Sanctions don’t work.

The Europeans lean towards the US but can’t be relied upon to help much. They’re very far from the frontline in the Pacific and have quite weak militaries. Britain and France might be able to contribute a carrier group each – but I doubt that the marginal carrier will be of major significance. Either the US supercarriers in the Pacific Fleet will defeat China or they will be destroyed/neutered. Inferior European carrier groups will not be the decisive factor. Germany has also been flirting with Russia for some time and EU hesitance on banning Huawei doesn’t bode well for the US. India could be a useful ally for the US, opening up another front for China and acting as a potential balance to China’s huge size. There’ve been motions towards building up the Quad: Australia, Japan, India & US as an alliance. But there’s no actual treaty which is the all-important part.

Germany didn’t have much military experience. The German army had been rapidly built up over six years from the Versailles 100K limit. Some airmen had experience from Spain but the rest of the army had only been recently trained.

However, France hadn’t had any military experience either. They hadn’t fought a major war and thought things would look similar to WW1. Today, nobody has had any experience with modern naval warfare since the Falklands - two generations ago in defence terms. On the air front, the US showed it’s mettle with convincing victories against the Iraqi and Serbian air defence systems. But that was still one generation ago – and the Chinese air force is a much tougher, much larger beast with major geographic advantages (not being near a huge number of NATO/allied airbases for one). They have studied the lessons of those wars and gambled on hypersonic missiles being the key to unravelling the US’s airbase-centric forward-deployment doctrine. There is every chance for a first-of-its-kind move from China. They might do a helicopter airlift instead of a traditional beach landing. They might mass-activate sleeper cells to disrupt Taiwanese mobilization. They might launch a massive cyberwarfare attack and cripple the F-35 fleet, radar, communications and power. They might perform some strategic-level masterstroke like Molotov-Ribbentrop or launch a massive synthetic oil program to circumvent resource shortages. They are the rising, dynamic power: sudden change is their prerogative. Overall, unless there is major change, I expect a major humiliation for the US military by 2030: the annexation of Taiwan by China and corresponding rise of China to No. 1 great power. With Taiwan, they’d occupy a strategic position in world trade and an entire world-class semiconductor industry. The prestige of victory would smooth out nearly every other difficulty they face around the world. They’d be in a good position to dominate Asia, high technology and thus the entire 21st century.

Examples of a major change would be a binding, NATO-style mutual defence treaty between at least India, Japan, Taiwan and the US. Massive nuclear proliferation would also do the trick as it would solve the problem of Taiwanese willpower and self-defence capacity in a single stroke. Any leader tough enough to deploy nuclear weapons won’t let their country be annexed without a fight. Of course, the US might pull something big out of its sleeve: UFOs, orbital weapons or whatever wizardry the black budgets pay for. I just don’t think that’s likely, given all trends thus far. I think the black budgets go towards the same kind of overpriced, corruptly managed, cyberfragile tech the conventional budgets buy. The visible trends are that China wins and keeps winning. They keep militarizing new islands, keep taking ground with their salami tactics, keep making more and more ships, stealing more and more IP. The US spasms all over the place with its Cultural Revolution, inability to halt COVID, inability to maintain stable politics and total unwillingness to have a coherent global strategy. There is a comprehensive gulf in elite willpower that can make up for any Chinese shortcoming and negate every US advantage.


r/TheMotte • • Apr 06 '20

Translated: The Chinese internet reacts to the epidemic in Europe and America

176 Upvotes

In the comments below, I will shortly post a few translated posts from Zhihu, a mainland Chinese Q&A site similar to Quora in both format and annoying writing style.

The essays, all posted in the past few days, are ostensibly answers to questions like

  • "On April 3, confirmed cases in the U.S. surpassed 270,000, an increase of 35,000 in a single day. Has the growth rate peaked?"

  • "What’s your take on the U.S. having 210000 confirmed cases as of April 1? What will be the effect on the U.S. and the world?"

but mostly take them as excuses to rant at length about much else besides.

Disclaimers:

  • I am still learning Chinese. There are no doubt errors in these translations. Any corrections are welcome. My notes are in square brackets []. Italics are for phrases that appear in English in the original.

  • I am presenting these essays solely as primary source material for understanding the Chinese zeitgeist.

  • I do not know how representative these posts are. On the one hand, these are all highly upvoted posts on the one topic that matters right now. On the other hand, imagine if I took the top comments from /r/politics and presented them as representative of the United States. Maybe someone more in touch with the Chinese internet can comment on whether Zhihu has any particularly biases.

  • I hope the mods will tolerate this not being in the coronavirus thread, given the length of these posts and their wide scope.

See also my previous post last year on the NBA / Hong Kong situation.