r/TheExpanse • • Oct 15 '23

All Show Spoilers (No Book Discussion) I can’t justify Belter behavior… Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I love the expanse and I am the middle of Season 6, and planning to buy the books after this lol.

But I just can’t get how horrifying behavior by the Belters is constantly justified or ignored. During the stay on Ilus the Belters kill an entire ship of the RCE and then are shown as poor oppressed victims when the survivors aren’t too kind with them.

During the Ceres occupation the Belters on Ceres who openly call for Earth Genocide are given food and provisions instead of the billions of Earthers that are starving because of them. And that’s treated as a good thing?

Same as trying to humanize the free navy goons when the only thing they deserve is a bullet through the skull.

This goes on and on across the show. I get that Belters have been treated horribly by the Inner Planets and that this isn’t exactly a good vs bad guys good guys win show. But goddamnit I just can’t feel sympathy for them after murdering innocents and the only thing they show is being a little sad for it.


r/TheExpanse • • Nov 29 '23

Cibola Burn I don't see how RCE are supposed to be the bad guys? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

More or less the title.

I am currently reading Cibola Burn and I can see that they are trying to make the RCE people the bad guys in a way. But at least for now, the only one I agree with is Murtry (as Amos said, he definetly is a killer). But the people on Illus/New Terra started the bloodshed with the shuttle explosion and did continue it when attacking the RCE security, so I am not sure how I am supposed to feel for them. Sure, one could argue that they didn't want to blow up the shuttle itself, but they knew it was to close and willingly risked the death of the persons on board.

Am I just wrong here? I am really curious for other perspectives.

Edit: I do enjoy the discussion going on, although I am not sure how downvoting everything does much for it


r/TheExpanse • • Nov 04 '24

Spoilers Through Season ONE, Books Through LEVIATHAN WAKES In book version of Leviathan Wakes James Holden is an insufferably BORING character. Am I the only one who feels this way? (sorry if this is a repeat topic) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In book version of Leviathan Wakes James Holden is an insufferably BORING character. Yet, in the TV show he is far far more interesting and likeable. I think this is mainly due to 3 factors: (1) in the books he is some type of do-gooder moral crusader and has very little depth or complexity. (2) His character, even if a bit boring or dry, is not very well developed,,,, he doesn't do much, say much, or think much. (3) Miller, on the other hand, is a complex character and we have access to Millers inner dialogue.

(In the TV show the actor playing Holden is a very good actor so the above problems are not as relevant)

I do not want to start an argument/debate with anyone who loves the books. My point is I LOVED the TV show. I think the TV show is - amazing - truly, I do. But I am about 90% done with reading Leviathan Wakes and to be quite honest I goan with disamy every time I have to read a Holden chapter because it is so plain/ordinary/boring.

Does anyone else feel this way and does this trend continue for all of the novels?


r/TheExpanse • • Mar 24 '24

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Am I the only one who has trouble caring about Naomi's family drama? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Obviously, I think this is a fantastic series. I've only seen the show, so I don't know how things are in the (first 6) books, but I feel like so much screen time is dedicated to Naomi reuniting with Filip, and the drama between Naomi and Marco Inaros. And it's hard for me to care about any of it.

So many people have died in the series, so many have lost family members. Why should I care about Naomi reuniting with her son that it's worth so much screen time? When Holden decides against blowing up Marco because Filip is on board... I lose it.

Compare Naomi's son with Amos's friend Prax and his daughter. It's heartwarming. It's enjoyable. Mostly because we don't spend multiple seasons on reuniting them.

Am I alone in this? Or should I have more appreciation for all the time spent on Naomi's family drama? If it's the latter, explain why. Thank you.


r/TheExpanse • • Jan 05 '23

General Discussion (All Show & Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) Please. Stop. Drinking. Whiskey. As. Shots. NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know it's how it's done in the USA. I know Ty and Franck are big Whiskey fans (presuming, given the inordinate amount of time it pops up in the text).

But whiskey does not, should not, cannot be consumed as shots.

The mere idea of consuming whiskey as shots, without a nice glass, one or two ice cubes (three is too much, waters it down), is blasphemy. The concept of consuming room temperature whiskey gives me an aneurism. I literally lie awake at night thinking about it.

How can you savour or enjoy a drink when it's chopped as a shot? You can't. It's a sipping drink, not a shots drink. Shots are done because you can't hack the taste for protracted periods.

This is not the point of whiskey. My countrymen have not laboured to make these drinks for generations for them to be flitted away down a gullet.

So, James Holden, you have paid a figure large enough to eclipse a gdp of a modern undeveloped nation for genuine scotch imported from earth to ceres, and you drink it in an instant.

I do not say these things out of fears that my own whiskey consumption is being threatened by the unenlightened Americans, but rather I mourn that people so clearly fond of whiskey consume them in such a wrong way.

If they love it that much as shots, imagine how much they'd love it if consumed properly?

They are on the cusp of heaven, but they don't have the confidence to step through the pearlescent gates.

Literally shaking rn.


r/TheExpanse • • Jan 11 '23

General Discussion (All Show & Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) Naomi ruins the show

22 Upvotes

So the title might be overstating it a little bit.. but she definitely ruins episodes. I struggle to think of a character in any other show that I dislike as much as her.

Maybe that's what the show writers were going for, but she has no real redemption arc and even when it feels like you should be rooting for her I hoped she failed.

I haven't read the books in a long while, but I don't recall her being bad in them. So maybe because it was a show they felt the need to add that one super annoying person to the crew.

Overall just feel like the show would have benefited from focusing on the other characters rather than letting her have these long monologues that all sound the same.


r/TheExpanse • • Dec 08 '23

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Why isn’t there AI in the Expanse? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Something I’ve always been a bit puzzled about is why there is a complete absence of any sort of artificial intelligence in the series (not counting whatever Proto-Miller was, I’m just talking about in terms of human technology). It seems like a really weird technological omission.


r/TheExpanse • • Dec 15 '23

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Anyone else on Team Errinwright? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm rewatching the early seasons (for like the 5th time but hey who's counting), and one detail that I'd sort of forgotten is that the first time we meet Errinwright, he's angrily giving Avasarala a direct order to stop torturing a Belter. "If you want to talk to that Belter, put him in the tank!"

It made me think about his story arc. Obviously he committed serious crimes and nearly got the Earth destroyed by Eros, but everything he did was out of a genuine fear for his homeworld. He knew that he was taking enormous personal risks, and there was no financial reward in it for him, but he did it anyway. He didn't trust his "bobblehead" boss to adequately protect the planet, so he did what he felt he was morally obligated to do once he learned about the protomolecule.

Pretty damn heroic if you ask me.

Edit: I'm assuming here that he didn't know about the plan to use Eros as history's most fucked-up science experiment. If he knew about that, then obviously that changes my assessment of him completely.


r/TheExpanse • • Jul 09 '24

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Is it just me or is season 6 average Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I’ve watched all seasons in 8 days so maybe I’m just fully expansed out but season 6 was kinda disappointing, what are your thoughts. Season 3,4&5 were gold & I’m going to rewatch again and again💗


r/TheExpanse • • Jan 16 '22

Season 6, Episode 6 (Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) About the series finale Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Are we really pretending this was a satisfying ending? To me this was on the same level as Lost, GoT and Dexter. It was just awful. The first four seasons were so focused on the protomolecule and than the whole storyline gets just abandoned. The series gets hijacked by Inaros and his boring family drama. Why? They had something good going there. The show started as a mix of Mass Effect and the good parts of GoT, but then turned it into some generic bullshit. I dont even know what it was.

They just left ALL the questions about the protomolecule unanswered and even though they knew this was going to be the end, they had the audacity to start another protomolecule subplot with new questions they dont answer as well? What is wrong with them? They knew the mystery about the protomolecule is big reason to watch this for many, they knew how people reacted to the end of Lost, but still they pull this shit?

Also, what kind of battle was this supposed to be in the finale? Is Amazon strapped for cash? Supposedly three different battlefields with hundreds of ships, but all we ever see is Camina firing at Inaros. And Inaros firing back one time. Thats it. Time for Plan B. What even was the advantage of disguising Inaros ship as another ship? This was space D-Day. Did they not expect anyone to fire back or why did one salve end the whole thing?

I used to love this show so much and now it has become another show I will never rewatch. You can downvote me now.


r/TheExpanse • • May 11 '21

Caliban's War Some thoughts on 'The Expanse,' from a skeptic. (Spoilers up to Caliban's War.) Spoiler

33 Upvotes

I've tried to watch, "The Expanse" twice. Both times, I wound up quitting after only a few episodes. I didn't really care for it. But those wonderfully passionate people over in r/Babylon5 consistently recommend it as one of the (very) few shows to be of comparable quality--an exceptionally high bar if ever there was one--so I decided to give The Expanse another shot.

But not the TV show: I decided to save time and read the book.In the past week, I've read through both Leviathan Wakes and Caliban's War.

This is not an essay. I don't have an argument to make. I'm simply sharing some disorganized thoughts after reading through the first two novels without really expecting very much. So here they are:

  • The comparisons to Babylon 5 are entirely unwarranted (at this point). This story is much more in the vein of Firefly, minus (most) of the problematic bits. It's kinda astonishing how similar the premise and structure of the two are. I think I probably would have given The Expanse another shot sooner, had it been billed to me simply as, "Firefly, but better."

  • I cannot possibly overstate how much I abhor Corey's assertion that aesthetics and efficiency are mutually exclusive. This is a very backwards attitude that handicaps the art design of this universe from the point of inception.

  • I have some thoughts on James Holden that I'll refrain from sharing, but suffice it to say I do not find him to be an interesting or compelling or engaging character. Honestly, he seems kinda like a self-insert protagonist loosely modeled on Kirk or Mal with little understanding of why those characters worked (or, when applicable, why they didn't). The frustrating thing is that Corey is pretty good at writing interesting, compelling and engaging characters. Miller was a lot of fun; Prax was fantastic; Avasarala was incredible. Why can't the series' lead be as dynamic? It's especially annoying when the Rocinante's crew discuss why Holden should be captain--there is no real reason, he's simply not good at anything else. The best justification anyone has is that, "he's a good man," or, "he's honest," and... what?

  • It's just so weird to me that the actual text of these books acknowledges that Holden is kind of a crap character, yet he's still to protagonist.

  • And even if he were a more interesting character, there's also the total lack of emotional, psychological or legal consequences for Holden initiating the most destructive war in human history. You'd think that'd affect him somehow, but nope, he totally "Not My Problems" it--like a sociopath.

  • Speaking of weird things, kinda odd how the second book's plot is basically the same as the first: broken old man teaming up with a space cowboy to rescue a little girl kidnapped by evil corporate scientists to be engineered into an alien bio weapon. Really hoping the next book(s) is/are more imaginative.

  • I will keep reading, btw, if that wasn't clear. These thoughts I've shared so far may be negative, but that's just because they're so annoying--this novels are pretty good and more than sufficiently engaging for me to enjoy them on the whole and keep going.

  • Oh, yeah. I forgot to include her, but Bobbie was also pretty great. It's definitely kinda disappointing to crack open the next book and scan the table of contents and see a whole host of new POV characters, with the only familiar name being Holden's.

  • I'll just have to assume Praxiatel is too busy with the minutiae of rebuilding Ganymede, but I'd still love to check in on the rest.

  • I don't want to talk too much about the TV show, as I don't remember much about it. But I do remember a scene where a character, who I think was supposed to be Avasarala (introduced far too early) brutally tortures a Belter on Earth. It was, I think, one of the things that turned me off the show (in addition to the pacing). After seeing Avasarala in print, the TV version kinda pisses me off. There's a very key moment near the end of Caliban's War where she explicitly states that her brusque and profane personality is a deliberate affectation to fool people into thinking she's a "hard ass" despite being (as demonstrated through her very consistent actions) a very moral individual. She's absolutely not the kind of person who would order prisoners tortured, let alone attend to the violence personally. That whole scene reeks of (TV) writers who saw her profanity in the text, and thought, "she must be a hard-ass." What nonsense.

  • I am definitely ready for an Avasarala-centric West Wing-Style spin-off series.

So... that's basically my reaction to the first couple books. I may or may not give the TV show another shot (in retrospect much of the casting feels wrong, somehow; though ironically Shohreh Aghdashloo is the best fit for Avasarala). I definitely wouldn't compare it to Babylon 5 or Star Trek, but maybe later novels make those comparisons feel more earned. It definitely doesn't have the thematic or ideological depth I find in "the best" science fiction stories, but it's still very enjoyable. If I were writing a review on Amazon (ugh) it's a solid 4/5 stars from me. Engaging, well-paced popcorn adventure. I just wish the protagonist weren't the least interesting character in the series.

Such are my thoughts. I'm curious whether or not y'all think it'd be worth it for me to revisit the TV show, or just stick to the novels. I'm likewise curious if you think any of my opinions will shift as I keep reading. The only one that's set in stone, I'm fairly confident, is the 2nd one: I feel cheated out of sext starship designs!

EDIT: Wow, this took off. And is apparently very controversial? This sub may not be for me. I really like The Expanse so far, but that doesn't mean I think it's perfect. I haven't read through everything yet (I will, promise) but I know many of you are engaging in good faith here, and I really appreciate that.

EDIT2: 'Kay, I've read everything now and responded to much of it. Some interesting discussion to be had here, but also a disheartening amount of defensiveness. I'm sorry I didn't find the novels to be universally perfect, and only "pretty good" instead. I had no idea this would be perceived as an offensive hit-take. Oh well.


r/TheExpanse • • May 24 '24

Abaddon's Gate Is it just me, or are all the ‘Anna’ chapters in Abaddon’s gate just torturous to read through? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’ve watched the show, and always tuned out during her scenes, but reading the book, I am just so overwhelmingly bored with all of her chapters, and can’t understand why there’s just so many of them?


r/TheExpanse • • Jun 20 '18

Meta Please tell me I'm not the only one who finds her character completely uninteresting, her role illogical to the point it breaks immersion, and her scenes generally a waste of valuable screen time

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheExpanse • • Mar 13 '21

Spoilers Through Season [2] A Singularly Awful Character: Bobbie Spoiler

12 Upvotes

She is, on paper, an "exemplary soldier". We hear this multiple times in the show. This exemplary soldier continually badmouths her superiors, questions their orders, and exudes insolence in every pore of her body. She is soft and unfit (looks nothing like a soldier). To the surprise of no one really, her first combat experience leads to her trembling like a child. She loses her cool while being interviewed at the peace conference between Earth and Mars, and is so perturbed that she breaks out of her room and goes on an escapade toward the ocean.

I have never in my life met even a bad soldier who is half as insolent and childish as this one, nor have I encountered a character in fiction so replete with contradictions.

A reminder to writers: you cannot have your cake, and eat it too. She is a laughably poor soldier, and you should have embraced that, or tried to write an authentically good soldier.


r/TheExpanse • • Jul 06 '24

Cibola Burn Murtry isn't wrong - OPA settlers Spoiler

67 Upvotes

I've seen all of the TV series and love it. So I know the general direction of the story. It also makes me really impressed with both the Author(s) of the book and the Writers of the show.

That being said, I'm about 15 percent done with Cibola Burn and it is hard not to be sympathetic a LITTLE with Murtry. I mean, the trip to Ilus / New Terra literally ended with a bang for the initial RCE team. His ostensibly peaceful security force was ambushed and murdered (and not as prepared as they should have been when dealing with hostile forces). Coop made a very clear indirect threat to him and his team, challenging his authority in front of the majority of the settlers, while being aware of martial law and Murtry's orders to preemptively eliminate threats.

Yes Amos was right, he's a killer, and likely not just on the colony. I get the impression he was always the kind of character that was just itching to put the boot down if given a reason: and he was given plenty of reasons.

But one thing I don't understand, I hope someone can explain. The RCE charter was granted by Earth. Was there anything remotely similar given to the OPA settlers by Fred Johnson others in the OPA? I don't remember that and it doesn't seem like that was the sort of thing Belters would do. And if that was the case, it would seem to me the RCE should have expected a more hostile force from the beginning..

Still waiting to see how Mars might play into this planet: the book opens up with Bobby Draper.


r/TheExpanse • • Jun 20 '22

Spoilers Through Season 4 (Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) Oh god Cara Gee's voice is so annoying. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Even following her plotline in S4 is boring.

Edit 1 - oh wow. I'm clearly on the lone side with this considering the strongly worded responses. 'Tis what it is. My opinion is limited to midway of season 4, I'm yet to finish the remaining.

Her character displays such a limited range of emotion. It's always that vocal cord strutted monotonous drag in her voice as well as response in any scene. As though, one's never had any zeal towards anything. The plotline development around her is lethargic, as in a writers had a lack of intent or just had to add some fillers. I accept it's unfair to comment mid season, but meh could have done without this.


r/TheExpanse • • Aug 10 '25

Absolutely No Spoilers In Post or Comments Why Ice-Freighters instead of Water?

0 Upvotes

First of all i mean the question on a very basic level: Why ice? Water has the same weight, needs the same space and all, correct? Oil freighters (im not so knownledgable about water freighters on earth ;) dont freeze the oil So i guess they did it to make it sound cool?

Then there could be questions like probably because they get it from ice-sources (that would be a mildy okay spoiler) but still the question stays... Why not make it into Water? Like whats easier? Water you just pump and need to complex system? Also... Even under the Earth/Whatever Planet Water isnt ice. Not so sure about ice planets, but even there im pretty sure they would get watery at some point because of the degrees in the core?

What am im missing?


r/TheExpanse • • Oct 11 '26

All Show & Book Spoilers Discussed Freely Book reader, first time watching the show: I do not like how they handled Alex. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm sure this has been said a million times, but I want to rant about it.
I get why they had to make a quick dramatic change with Alex, I just don't like what they did. My complaints are 3.

  1. There were better ways to write him off.
    Forgive my dumb little heart but I can't help but think it was an opportunity to give the character his happy ending. Let him finish rescuing Naomi, and then Bobby can explain to Holden later that he went back to Mars to try to be a father or something. It's also not perfect. I know Alex's TRUE happy ending is being a pilot forever. But...

  2. It would have been so easy to recast. Either immediately for season 6, OR if you let him go back home to be a family man for a bit, the door is open for him to get pulled back into the action after his kid is off on his own in a potential season 7. Everyone would be older so it's SUCH a natural moment to recast him. He just misses season 6! Then you've got the character achieving that sweet balance between the two halves of his soul that writers love: He tried his best for his family. He still gets to be a fuckboy pilot. Perfection.

  3. If they had to pick this way, the execution was also bad. He was like, the least likely to die that way. When Fred died that way in the books, it actually felt like "Yeah there was always a risk of that." He was old, he was injured, etc. But when the guy MOST ABLE to do high G dies that way, with next-to-zero lead-up, it makes High G just seem like there's not any skill that can save you, you can't train for it, it's just a roll of the dice. Rather than a difficult thing that could kill you eventually but you can train for and mitigate the risk of. Also the actual moment was just a "wtf" and not in a good way.

Anyways, thanks for reading. Mostly loving the show so far. Most of the other changes make good sense to me considering the change in format. I'm also pretty forgiving of adaptational changes. I'm sure I'll get over this one.


r/TheExpanse • • Sep 02 '26

Osiris Reborn Game | All Show Spoilers (Tag Any Book Spoilers) AI in Osiris Reborn

0 Upvotes

I know that this is not a new topic, but I actually didn't find any posts about this in this sub. I just wanted to ask about your opinions on the fact that owlcat uses AI while making this game. I would also be very curious to know what Dan and Ty think about it... At first I was VERY excited about the game, but then this information came to light, and I have been battling with my thoughts ever since. because at one hand much more work is being put into this game, it's not pure ai slop, but at the other hand I don't want to support a studio who thinks that this is OK, you know? even if it's just for concept art and such. I am still torn tho... what do y'all think?

edit: since many people are not familiar with this, here is an article that gives a good overview of what type of usage we're talking about.


r/TheExpanse • • Mar 29 '24

All Show Spoilers (Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) Does anyone else get tired of the infighting at any point? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm re-watching the series and just into season 4, I forgot how consistent the faction wars between Earth, Mars, and the Belt are. Given everything about coming together in season 3 and overcoming the Protomolecule and now living in the era of The Ring, it's exhausting that there is still so much fighting amongst humans.

I get that it's a major theme of the series. And very, very likely how things would go with our own species after tenuously coming together to defeat an external force. But damn it seems so petty given all the wonder The Ring provides.

Also, it's a bit hard to suspend my disbelief that there wouldn't be more security and prevention over all the mischief people get into at various points, given that the human race has evolved enough to colonize another planet and live on rocks in our solar system.

Does any of this, or anything similar to it, grate you about the series (in general or in certain moments)?


r/TheExpanse • • Nov 01 '25

Leviathan Falls Cultural shifts between PR and LF Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I know this is a relatively minor quibble, but I find it strange how the Laconia of Persepolis Rising ("We are honourable and ordering collective punishment against people in our domain is against our laws and punishable by death,") became Laconia of Leviathan Falls ("Surrender your flagship or be collectively punished!") Same goes for Tanaka being dismissed for being level-headed to very much not (even prior to the Lighthouse event).

I know there's some sort of commentary on the nature of autocratic dictatorships, particularly when a power vacuum forms and the granting of unlimited power, but still comes off as rather jarring for an organisation a few decades old at that point, even if they started out rogue.

EDIT Holy cow, this sub can't take even the mildest form of criticism from someone saying it's a minor criticism without getting defensive. Seriously, some of your guys need to lighten up.


r/TheExpanse • • Jan 06 '25

Spoilers Through Season 3 (Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) I'm at the end of season 3, am I supposed to find Anna absolutely insufferable? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

It doesn't seem like the show wants to portray her that way so I'm bit sure if it's just my personal bias for her personality type.

I don't know even how to put it in words so maybe someone can do it for me. She seems perfectly genuine so it's not that. Smug seems like the wrong word but somewhere along those lines.

Her smile like she has all the answers just rubs me the wrong way, comes off as high and mighty like she self assuredly thinks she's better than everyone on an intrinsic level. I can't remember if I felt thr same way when she was on Lost so idk if it's the actress or not.

Anyone else have some opinions on this they can put into better words?


r/TheExpanse • • Aug 29 '23

General Discussion (Any Show & Book Spoilers Must Be Tagged) Can I get a basic almost-no-spoiler summary of the entire book series? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’ve always wanted to invest some time into reading more Sci-fi, since it’s never been a genre I’ve seriously tried, and The Expanse seems like one of the best Sci-fi books out there, and I’d like a rough overview of the series itself than one book to see how interesting I might find it.

Like, are there Aliens or is it mainly about normal people on Spaceships? If there are aliens, is it a fight against them, or is it against each other? Is the story Character-driven or story-driven? Is there treasure hunting on newly-discovered planets? Does it incorporate the whole universe or does it focus on a important planets?

Naturally, you don’t need to answer all those questions, but those are the kind of things that I’d like to find out before buying the series. Thank you in advance!


r/TheExpanse • • Dec 30 '21

Persepolis Rising Book Drummer is boring Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know show Drummer is a mix of characters but I was not ready for the dread that creeps up on me every time I see the next chapter is a Drummer POV. Same boring her being unsure of herself, missing her husband, EMC brass being incompetent.

I’m already not digging this book so much but her chapters really drag it down. Reminds me of those random Medina worker boring chapters from Babylons Ashes. I almost miss Anna and Prax chapters!