I've posted a theory that The Terminator shows at least Kyle Reese's second trip to the past, not his first:(https://www.reddit.com/r/Terminator/comments/1xq8rv2/)
In that post I argued that there had to be a first time, and that what we see in the film is already Kyle's second trip. What I didn't explain was how the later trips affect the first version of history.
I know that in Cameron's film the story is a closed loop: Kyle is John's father, and John sends Kyle back. One creates the other. It's a beautiful paradox, and that's how the story was designed. This theory is just my own reflection, based only on the first film and leaving aside what the author intended. I tried to step outside the paradox and imagine how this could actually work.
Many comments read "original timeline" as if I meant parallel timelines or a multiverse. That's my fault, I didn't explain it well.
The whole premise of the films is that changing the past changes the present. John sends Kyle because if Sarah dies in 1984, he dies too. That only works if there is ONE timeline. If time travel created a parallel one, John's present would never be touched, and sending Kyle would make no sense.
So by "original timeline" I meant the first pass of events: the first version of history, before anyone traveled back. When someone goes back, a new version is written on top of the old one, on the same timeline.
In the other post I argued three things. The first time history happened, nobody had traveled through time, and John's father was another man. When that John sent Kyle back, Kyle became the father of a new John. And the Kyle we see in the film is already coming for the second time, because he knows things he could only know if all of this had happened before. The arguments are in the other post.
What's missing is how the new version replaces the old one. I see two possibilities.
First possibility
When Kyle steps into the time machine, the present up ahead ends. It's as if all of humanity stepped into the machine with him: the future they built stops existing, and history starts again in 1984. The film itself is told a bit like this. It starts in 1984. We know there is a present, John's present, where Kyle is sent back. But we never see what happens to that present after Kyle leaves it and enters the time machine. It's as if the next frame after Kyle leaves for the past is the frame of their landing in 1984.
In this version, John's present ends there, and John may know it. By sending Kyle, he isn't saving the John he is now, but protecting the John who will exist again in the past. It's a new chance for himself.
Is this a new timeline? No. It's rewriting the timeline. It's a new version of time, a new iteration.
It's practically the closed loop. The difference here is that we have a first time (the one with an original John Connor).
Second possibility, my favorite
There's another way to picture it, where John's present doesn't end the moment Kyle leaves.
When Kyle lands in 1984, history starts being rewritten from there. But up ahead, in 2029, the old John keeps living his present, at around 44 years old.
If the rewriting moved at the normal speed of time, it would always stay 45 years behind him. By the time the new John reached 2029, the old one would already be in 2074. They'd always be in different years and would never meet. The old John would live his whole life and die of old age before the changes ever reached him. There would be two presents at once, which means two timelines. And that's exactly what the premise rules out. Changing the past changes the present.
So for the past to reach the present, the rewriting has to move faster than time. And it can move faster, because the future is already written. It doesn't need to write it from scratch, only to adjust it.
We can picture this as a reel of film. Kyle's arrival in 1984 is like a jolt to the film. From there, a wave runs along it, rewriting every frame it passes. Behind it is the new story: another father, another John. Ahead of it, the old John keeps living, not knowing the wave is coming.
The film behaves like a whip: the wave speeds up as it travels. When it reaches the tip, the present, the film cracks. In that instant, the old present is replaced by the new one. Not two worlds side by side. One film, rewritten all the way to the tip.
In this theory, the future already exists, because it's the past of the first pass. So it arrives already shaped, like a material we're handed. But, as the saying goes, the future is what you make of it.
In other words, something is already predestined, but there's still some free will. A bit like in our own lives: we have déjà vus, coincidences, the feeling that there's a destiny, but we can still step in and change the course of things.
Either way, this looks like the closed loop people talk about, but with two differences. It has a beginning: a first pass with another father, no photo, no warning. And it has an exit: if in one pass John manages to stop Skynet from using the time machine, nobody needs to send Kyle, and history moves forward for the first time. The loop isn't eternal. It repeats until someone breaks it.
The wave caused by the time travel rewrites the story. Connor has no idea of the wave that is coming to hit him. The film makes a whip movement and cracks up ahead. And when it cracks, Connor's reality is replaced.
What do you think?